A Lutheran Professor Educated at Westminster Theological Seminary Looks for Similarities and Dissimilarities Richard E

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Lutheran Professor Educated at Westminster Theological Seminary Looks for Similarities and Dissimilarities Richard E Volume 61:Numbers 1-2 January-April1997 Table of Contents The Porvoo Common Statement Prepared by the Fourth Plenary Meeting held at Jarvenpaii, Finland, 9-13 October 1992 .... 3 The Porvoo Declaration in Confessional Perspective The Departments of Systematic Theology: Concordia Theological Seminary, Fort Wayne, Indiana, and Concordia Seminary, Saint Louis, Missouri.. .................................. 35 The Holy Spirit in the Augsburg Confession: A Reformed Perspective Richard A. Muller ........................... 53 A Lutheran Professor Trained at Westminster Looks for Similarities and Dissimilarities Richard E. Muller ............................ 79 Cum Patre et Filio Adoratur: The Holy Spirit Understood Christologically David P. Scaer ............................... 93 Saint Polycarp of Smyrna: Johannine or Pauline Figure? D. RichardStuckwisch. ...................... 113 Books Received ................................... 126 Book Reviews ....................................127 Emanuel Hirsch und Paul Tillich: Theologie und Politik in einer Zeit der Krise. By A. James Reirner ..........Lowell C. Green The Descent of God: Divine Suffering in Histoy and Theology. By Joseph M. Hallman ........Jeffery A. Oschwald Adolf Schlatter: A Biography of Germany's Premier Biblical Theologian. By Werner Neuer .......... William C. Weinrich Martin Luther in Two Centuries: The Sixteenth and the Twentieth. By Helmar Junghans ...............Paul J. Grime A History of Christianity in the United States and Canada. By Mark A. Noll ..........................Robert E. Smith True Faith in the True God: An Introduction to Luther's Life and Thought. By Hans Schwarz .......... Martin Noland Baptized into God's Family: The Doctrine of Infant Baptism for Today. By A. Andrew Das ............ James W. Kalthoff Paul's Letter to the Romans: A Cornmentay. By Peter Stuhlmacher ..........................Jonathan F. Grothe Genesis 1-11: From Eden to Babel. By Donald Gowan .......................................Dean 0. Wenthe I Believe but I Have Questions. By Jane L. Fryar . James E. Butler Christian Moral Judgment. By J. Philip Wogaman .....................................Terrence Reynolds Giving Goliath His Due: New Archaeological Light on the Philistines. By Neal Bierling ..............Thomas H. Trapp Windows on the World of Jesus: Time Travel to Ancient Judea. By Bruce Malina ......................Charles A. Gieschen Islam: An Introduction for Christians. Edited by Paul Martinson; Leader's Guide by Irene Getz ............... Henry Rowold Canon and Theology: Overtures to an Old Testament Theology. By Rolf Rendtorff ......................... Henry Rowold Indices to Volume 60 (1996) Index of Authors and Editors ..................... 153 Index of Titles ................................... 154 Index of Book Reviews ........................... 156 A Lutheran Professor Educated at Westminster Theological Seminary Looks for Similarities and Dissimilarities Richard E. Muller This article opens with some comments on theological education at Westminster Theological Semianry, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania in the late 1960s. It then outlines the general Reformed or Calvinistic approach to the topic of the Holy Spirit: The Person of the Holy Spirit; The Work of the Holy Spirit; The Holy Spirit and Scripture; The Holy Spirit and Sanctification; and The Holy Spirit and Soteriology. Each section will consider briefly the similarities and dissimilarities between Reformed theology and Lutheran theology. Finally, the concluding portion of the article will consist of a few comments in response to Dr. Richard A. MuUer's fine article, "The Holy Spirit in the Augsburg Confession: a Reformed Definition."' Theological Education at Westminster Westminster in the 1960s espoused an authentic Calvinistic Reformed theology. It blended the British Puritan tradition with the Five Point Dutch T-U-L-I-P Calvinism and emphasized strongly the Sovereignty of God. In short, what it taught was consistent with how the Reformed have traditionally done theology - from the fixed point of the Sovereignty of God and the decrees of God, including the secret or hidden decrees. In contrast Lutherans do theology by focusing on the Crucified God, or the Cross of Christ and the revealed knowledge of God. This author 'At the Eighteenth Annual Symposium of the Lutheran Confessions in January 1995 I responded to Dr. Richard A. Muller's "The Holy Spirit in the Augsburg Confession: A Reformed Definition." I was chosen for this task because of the similarity of our names (to the best of our knowledge we are not related) and more importantly because I received my basic theological education at Westminster Theological Seminary in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, from which I graduated in 1967. Richard E. Muller is Associate Professor of Systematic Theology at Concordia Theological Seminary, Fort Wayne, Indiana. never felt at ease with, what Luther and his followers refer to as, "the theology of glory." The practical ramifications of this approach are enormous. Some professors at Westminster taught that one could not tell a group consisting of Christians and non-Christians that Christ died for their sins. One could only tell them that Christ died for their sins ifthey were of the elect. This was an application of the infamous "L" in the Calvinistic T-U-LI-P-the "limited atonement" theory. Such a theology changes the comfort the Gospel is designed to provide for the sinner into a spiritual problem of considerable magnitude which confronts the sinner. Under the "limited atonement" concept a basic shift takes place in doing theology. The Deus Reveibfus, the Eternal Word through whom the Father creates and reveals, and which culminates with the death and resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ, is exchanged for that of the Deus Abscondifus or the eternal and, therefore, hidden God of the "secret decrees." According to Deuteronomy 29:29 the "secret decrees" are God's secret possession and one therefore dare not do theology on the basis of them. Theologians ought not work in the area of archetypal theology, or God's knowledge of himself, but must be totally dependent upon ectypal theology, or God's revealed knowledge of himself. With this distinction in mind between the Revealed God and the Hidden God, or between the Word of God and the Will or Decrees of God, let us now consider specifically the place of the Holy Spirit in the Reformation perspective of Calvinism and of Lutheranism and search for similarities and dissimilarities. The Person of the Holy Spirit In considering the Third Person of the Holy Trinity, theologians distinguish between the person of the Holy Spirit and the work of the Holy Spirit. In regard to the person of the Holy Spirit there is more similarity than dissimilarity between confessional Calvinism and confessional Lutheranism. Both the Reformed and Lutheran traditions, coming as they do from the sixteenth century, hold to the full and unqualified deity of the Third Person. This similarity is based not only on agreement with the Lutherans and the Reformed 81 testimony of Holy Scripture, but also on the common acceptance of the ancient ecumenical creeds. While there is admittedly a significant dissimilarity in the Calvinistic and Lutheran understanding and confession of the person of Christ, especially the genus maiestaticum, this is not true of the confession of the person of the Holy Spirit.2The only point at issue in a confession of the person of the Holy Spirit is that of his full deity, and here the Calvinists and Lutherans agree. Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion, while not technically a confession, functions practically as the foundational document upon which all Reformed Confessions are set and judged. In the ~nstihttes,Calvin says the following in regard to the person of the Holy Spirit: Because he is circumscribed by no limits, he is excepted from the category of creatures; but in transfusing into all things his energy, and breathing into them essence, life, and movement, he is indeed plainly di~ine.~ In short, upon him, as upon the Son, are conferred functions that especially belong to divinity. Paul, therefore, very clearly attributes to the Spirit divine power, and shows that He resides hypostatically in ~od.~ Nor, indeed, does Scripture in speaking of him refrain from the designation, 'God.I5 Qf course, the confession of the person of the Spirit is far less complex and complicated than that of the Christ since only the Christ was incarnate. The whole issue of the mysterious relationship of the two natures to the one person, which received its classical formulation in Chalcedon in 451, does not apply to the Third Person. 'institutes, I.XIII.14,138. All references are to John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, edited by John T. McNeill, translated by Ford Lewis Battles, The Library of Christian Classics volumes 20-21 (Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1W). 'Institutes, LXIII.14,139. 51nstitutes, LMII.15,139. The same testimony is found also in the Westminster Larger Cate~hism.~ Question #9. How many persons are there in the Godhead? Answer - There be three persons in the Godhead, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost; and these three are one true, eternal God, the same in substance, equal in power and glory; although distinguished by their personal properties. So also the Westminster Confession, Chapter 11.111: In the unity of the Godhead there be three persons, of one substance, power, and eternity; God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Ghost. I John 5:7; Matt.
Recommended publications
  • Protestant Reformed Theological Journal
    PROTESTANT REFORMED ,. THEOLOGICAL JOURNAL APRIL, 1989 VOLUME XXII, NO. 2 THEOLOGICAL SCHOOL O'F THE PROTESTANT REFORMED CHURCHES ! Z GRANDVILLE, MICHIGAN 1 I I L :_ APRIL, 1989 Volume XXII, No.2 PROTESTANT REFORMED THEOLOGICAL JOURNAL Edited for the faculty of The Theological School of the Protestant Reformed Churches Robert D. Decker David J. Engclsma Herman C. Hanko Homer C. Hoeksema by Prof. Herman Hanko (editor-in-chief) Prof. Robert Decker (editor, book reviews) The Protestant Reformed Theological Journal is published semiannually, in April and November, and distributeo in limited quantities, at no char~e. by the Theological School of the Protestant Reformed Churches. Interested persons desiring to have their names on the mailing list should write the Editor, at the address below. Books for review should be sent to the book review editor, also at the address of the school. Protestant Reformed Seminary 4949 Ivanrest Avenue Grandville, MI 49418 -.;:J..----- - -- ---~--.... TABLE OF CONTENTS Editorial Notes ' 2' The Doctrine of Predestination in Calvin and Beza Prof. Herman C. Hanko 3 Martin Bucer - "Fanatic of Unity" Prof. David j. Engelsma : 18 The Elders of the Church Prof. Robert D. Decker. ...................••......... 35 . Book Reviews '.' '' .. ~ 48 . Editorial Notes In this issue of our jourual \"'C arc continuing two series \vhich were be­ gun in earlicr issues. Prof. Hanko continues his series on "Calvin, Beza. and the Doctrinc of Predestination," and Prof. Engelsma continues and concludes his series on Martin Bucer. As we wrote in an earlier issue when Prof. Engclsma's series was begun, these articles were first delivered in lecture form in Mid-America Seminary in Orange City.
    [Show full text]
  • John W. Welch, “'All Their Creeds Were an Abomination':A Brief Look at Creeds As Part of the Apostasy,”
    John W. Welch, “‘All Their Creeds Were an Abomination’:A Brief Look at Creeds as Part of the Apostasy,” in Prelude to the Restoration: From Apostasy to the Restored Church (Provo, UT and Salt Lake City: Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University and Deseret Book, 2004), 228–249. “All Their Creeds Were an Abomination”: A Brief Look at Creeds as Part of the Apostasy John W. Welch John W. Welch is a professor of law at Brigham Young University and editor-in-chief of BYU Studies. On October 15, 1843, the Prophet Joseph Smith commented, “I cannot believe in any of the creeds of the different denominations, because they all have some things in them I cannot subscribe to, though all of them have some truth. I want to come up into the presence of God, and learn all things: but the creeds set up stakes, and say, ‘Hitherto [1] shalt thou come, and no further’; which I cannot subscribe to.” While Latter-day Saints gladly and gratefully recognize that all religious creeds contain some truth, the problem is that those formulations of doctrine also contain errors or impose limits that are “incompatible with the gospel’s inclusive commitment to truth and continual [2] revelation.” Such mixing of truth and error is reminiscent of the parable of the wheat and the tares, the Lord’s most [3] salient teaching on the nature of the Apostasy (Matthew 13:24–30, 37–43; JST Matthew 13; D&C 86:1–11). Thus, the creeds themselves, as vessels of mixed qualities, become metaphors or manifestations of the Apostasy itself.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Groningen Word and Spirit in the Confessions of The
    University of Groningen Word and Spirit in the Confessions of the European Reformation van den Belt, Hendrik Published in: Religion and Theology IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite from it. Please check the document version below. Document Version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Publication date: 2016 Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database Citation for published version (APA): van den Belt, H. (2016). Word and Spirit in the Confessions of the European Reformation. Religion and Theology , 23(1-2), 95-110. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). The publication may also be distributed here under the terms of Article 25fa of the Dutch Copyright Act, indicated by the “Taverne” license. More information can be found on the University of Groningen website: https://www.rug.nl/library/open-access/self-archiving-pure/taverne- amendment. Take-down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum. Download date: 29-09-2021 Word and Spirit in the Confessions of the European Reformation Henk van den Belt University of Groningen, The Netherlands [email protected] Abstract Protestant spirituality is characterized by the mutual relationship between Word and Spirit.
    [Show full text]
  • Thematic Entries List
    Thematic List of Entries Biographical Bonhoeffer, Dietrich Adams, Hannah Booth, Catherine Agricola, Michael Booth, Joseph Allen, Richard Booth, William Allen, Roland Bosch, David Jacobus Boucher, Jonathan Alline, Henry Boudinot, Elias Althusius, Johannes Bourne, Hugh Ames, William Boyle, Robert Amissah, Samuel Hanson Bradstreet, Anne Amsdorf, Nikolaus von Braght, Tieleman Jansz van Anderson, Rufus Brainerd, David Andrewes, Lancelot Bray, Thomas Andrews, Charles Freer Brent, Charles Arminius, Jacobus Brenz, Johannes Arndt, Johann Britten, Benjamin Arnold, Eberhard Brooks, Phillips Arnold, Thomas Browne, Robert Asbury, Francis Browning, Robert Attoh-Ahuma, Samuel Richard Brew Brownson, Orestes Azariah, V. S. Brunner, Emil Bach, Johann Sebastian Bryan, William Jennings Backus, Isaac Bucer, Martin Bacon, Francis Bugenhagen, Johannes Bae¨ta, Christian Goncalves Kwami Bullinger, Heinrich Baillie, John Bultmann, Rudolf Barnes, Robert Bunyan, John Barth, Heinrich Bushnell, Horace Barth, Karl Butler, Joseph Bauer, Bruno Butler, Josephine Baumgarten, Otto Butterfield, Herbert Baumgarten, Siegmund Jakob Buxtehude, Dietrich Baur, Ferdinand Christian Cadbury, George Baxter, Richard Calixt, George Bayle, Pierre Calvert Family Beecher, Henry Ward Calvin, John Beecher, Lyman Campbell Family Bell, George Campbell, John Bengel, Johann Albrecht Capito, Wolfgang Bennett, John Cappel, Louis Bentham, Jeremy Carey, William Bentley, Richard Carnell, Edward Berggrav, Eivind Cartwright, Peter Berkeley, George Cartwright, Thomas Berkhof, Hendrikus Cary, Lott Beza,
    [Show full text]
  • Confessing the Reformed Faith: Our Identity in Unity and Diversity by Richard A
    Confessing the Reformed Faith: Our Identity in Unity and Diversity by Richard A. Muller Richard Muller is the P. J. Zondervan Professor of Historical Theology at Calvin Theological Seminary, Grand Rapids, Michigan. This address was given by Professor Muller at a meeting of the North American Presbyterian and Reformed Council on November 9, 1993 and appeared originally in the March and April numbers (1994) of New Horizons, the publication of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. The essay is republished here with the permission of the publishers. I have selected as my topic this evening, “Confessing the Reformed Faith: Our Identity in Unity and Diversity.” The central issue that I will address is the issue of Reformed identity – specifically as indicated by the body of confessional documents that both unites us in faith and distinguishes us into branches and denominations. I would also argue that retention and maintenance of the integrity and stability of the Reformed faith in its confessions is one of the two greatest issues confronting our churches today. The other, I would venture, is the parallel and profoundly related issue of the retention and maintenance of our tradition of liturgy and hymnody in which the doctrinal stance of the confessions is put, as it were, into action and application in the corporate life of believers. In fact, the two issues are inseparable. I propose to address these issues with a view to: (1) our confessional diversity; (2) the nature of our unity in diversity; (3) pressures on confessional integrity in our times; and (4) ways of reaffirming and strengthening confessional integrity today.
    [Show full text]
  • Calvin and the Confessions of the Reformation
    Page 1 of 5 Original Research Calvin and the confessions of the Reformation Author: This article discusses the complicated question of the connection between Calvin and the 1,2 Alasdair I.C. Heron confessions of the Presbyterian Reformed tradition. Firstly, a contrast is drawn to the question Affiliations: of the connection between Luther and the Lutheran confessions. It is noted that here a closed 1Reformed Theology, canon of Lutheran confessions exists, and Luther himself wrote three of the documents. On University of Erlangen- the other hand, there is no closed canon of Reformed confessions. However, there is a broad Nuremberg, Germany consensus concerning which Reformed confessions from the 16th century are classical. In this 2Department of Systematic article a synopsis is provided of this list, and it is discovered that Calvin himself only wrote Theology and Christian one of the classical Reformed confessional documents, although he influenced some others. Ethics, University of Pretoria, South Africa The article then continues to discuss Calvin’s own contribution, his Catechism of 1542/1545. The historical context of writing in which this Catechism is sketched, its use in Geneva is Note: described, and the outline of the Catechism is mentioned. The article continues to discuss why Prof. Dr Alasdair Heron is Professor Emeritus at the Calvin thought there was a need for a catechism, and why he wrote it in Latin and sent it to University of Erlangen- East Friesland. In conclusion the author explains why he has discussed Calvin’s Catechism, Nuremberg, Germany. He instead of focusing on the English Confession of 1556.
    [Show full text]
  • Martin Bucer and the Eucharistic Controversy in Bern
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Faculty Publications, Department of History History, Department of 2005 The Myth of the Swiss Lutherans: Martin Bucer and the Eucharistic Controversy in Bern Amy Nelson Burnett University of Nebraska - Lincoln, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/historyfacpub Part of the History Commons Burnett, Amy Nelson, "The Myth of the Swiss Lutherans: Martin Bucer and the Eucharistic Controversy in Bern" (2005). Faculty Publications, Department of History. 99. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/historyfacpub/99 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the History, Department of at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications, Department of History by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. The Myth of the Swiss Lutherans: Martin Bucer and the Eucharistic Controversy in Bern In 1842, Carl Hundeshagen published Die Conflicte des Zwinglianismus, Lu- thertums und Calvinismus in der Bernischen Landeskirche von 1532-1558.' The book describes the doctrinal strife within Bern and the effects of that strife on the relationship of the Bernese church with those of Geneva and Zu- rich. The conflicts centered on two issues: the Lord's Supper, and the inde- pendence of the church from state control. As the title implies, Hundeshagen identified the three positions in the controversy as Zwinglian (as represented by Zurich and one of the factions in Bern), Calvinist (Geneva and Vaud), and Lutheran (the dominant faction in Bern during the later 1530s and 1540s). It is difficult to overestimate the impact of Hundeshagen's book.
    [Show full text]
  • The Sacraments in the Confessions of 1536, 1549, and 1566
    Peter Stephens The Sacraments in the Confessions of 1536, 1549, and 1566 – The Sacraments in the ConfessionsBullinger’s of 1536, 1549, Understanding and 1566 – Bullinger’s Understanding in the The Sacraments in the Confessions of 1536, 1549, and 1566 – Bullinger’s Understanding in the Light of Zwingli’s by Peter Stephens The names of Zwingli and Bullinger are joined in such a way that it is natural to think of Bullinger not only as the successor of Zwingli but also as a con- tinuation of Zwingli. There is indeed continuity in their ministry and their theology, but Bullinger is also distinctive both as a reformer and as a theolo- gian. This is true for his view of the sacraments. As we look at Bullinger’s understanding of the sacraments in the confessions of 1536, 1549, and 1566, it is instructive to see similarities and differences between him and Zwingli, as well as the developments in his thought. 1 Zwingli’s Understanding of the Sacraments The writings of Zwingli 1 most obviously comparable with these confessions are the Sixty-Seven Articles (1523) and the Marburg Articles (1529). 2 However, these do not reflect Zwingli’s theology in his final years and it is this to which Bullinger naturally refers. Three of his works from 1530–31, to which Bullinger does refer, are: Account of the Faith presented to the Em- peror at the Diet of Augsburg in 1530, Letter to the Princes of Germany again for the Diet in August 1530, in reply to Eck’s attack on Account of the 1 Most of Zwingli’s works are published in Emil Egli et al.
    [Show full text]
  • 10390794.Pdf
    https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ Theses Digitisation: https://www.gla.ac.uk/myglasgow/research/enlighten/theses/digitisation/ This is a digitised version of the original print thesis. Copyright and moral rights for this work are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This work cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Enlighten: Theses https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] EUCHARISTIC SACRIFICE AND THE PATRISTIC TRADITION IN THE Th e o l o g y o f m a r t in b u c e r I534-I546. by Nicholas James Thompson Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Glasgow Appli^Qoo, © Nicholas Thompson 2ooo ProQuest Number: 10390794 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest ProQuest 10390794 Published by ProQuest LLO (2017). C o pyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author.
    [Show full text]
  • THE STORY of MARTIN LUTHER the Reformation and the Life of Martin Luther Part Two Pastor Charles R
    THE STORY OF MARTIN LUTHER The Reformation and the Life of Martin Luther Part Two Pastor Charles R. Biggs The Bible in German After Luther’s bold stand for the Word of God at Worms, he would continue to be influential in the translation of the Scriptures into the common German tongue. In 1521, Luther wore a coat of mail, disguising himself as a knight named “Knight George”, and lived peacefully and constructively as a professor at the Wartburg Castle in Eisenach Germany as part of the beautiful Thuringian forest. On Luther’s return to Saxony from Worms, he was suddenly and unexpectantly overwhelmed by a group of horsemen, who took Luther safely to the Castle Wartburg. Elector Frederick had sent his men to apprehend Luther and place him in hiding, fearing that the Pope would find him first and put him to death. Frederick did not want to lose the great Reformer and professor of Theology at his Wittenberg University. At Wartburg, Luther struggled with his own flesh, the very devil of hell, and through great anguish of spirit and weakness in ability translated the Bible into the common German tongue so that all could read it for themselves and find the hope of salvation in Christ. Luther’s reformation was not merely theoretically a stand for scripture alone, but he believed that the people needed the scriptures to read for themselves and so be saved. Later in his life, Luther remembered the year 1521 as the most useful year of his life. Dr. Luther, although weak intellectually and theologically in his own estimate and threatened by great fleshly and diabolical temptations and threats, succeeded by God’s grace in translating the first German New Testament.
    [Show full text]
  • The Lord's Supper in the Reformed Confessions
    THE LORD'S SUPPER IN THE REFORMED CONFESSIONS BY B. A. GERRISH "Schaff's judgment, that Calvin's eucharistie teach­ ing 'must be regarded as the orthodox Reformed doctrine/ oversimplifies the evidence. In actual fact, Zwingli's view continued to find its way into the confessions even after Calvin's emergence as foremost leader of the Reformed Church. More­ over, Bullinger's Second Helvetic Confession (1561/3) exhibits a third eucharistie type. There seem to be, then, three doctrines of the Eucharist in the Reformed confessions, which we may label 'symbolic memorialism/ 'symbolic parallelism/ and 'symbolic instrumentalism! " URRENT interest in the Reformed confessions raises afresh an old question: do the historic Reformed confessions, despite C their varied authorship, present a uniform "system of doc- trine"? As a step toward an answer, my purpose is to take a test case, the doctrine of the Lord's Supper and to inquire what the con­ fessions say about it. The Lord's Supper is a particularly appro­ priate choice at the present time, since the ecumenical dialogue has given special prominence to the doctrines of the ministry and the sacraments. The opening of conversations with the Lutherans (not to mention the Roman Catholics) obliges Presbyterians to reconsider their traditional eucharistie theology; and it becomes a matter of great importance to determine the "official" Reformed position, if there is one, as defined by the historic confessions. It would be no great surprise if the classical Reformed confessions of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries were found to contain a variety of eucharistie theologies. The confessions are both numer- 224 THE LORDS SUPPER 225 ous and in origin diverse,1 and it is common knowledge that the Re­ formed theologians of Switzerland were at first divided among them­ selves on the meaning of the Lord's Supper.
    [Show full text]
  • Reformed Confessions List: Vol. 1 Introduction 1. Huldrych Zwingli
    Reformed Confessions of the 16th and 17th Centuries in English Translation: 4 Vols. Set (1523-1693) James T. Dennison, Jr. Reformed Confessions List: Vol. 1 Introduction 1. Huldrych Zwingli, Sixty-Seven Articles (1523) 2. Huldrych Zwingli, Short and Christian Instruction (1523) 3. The Ten Theses of Bern (1528) 4. The Confession of the East Friesland Preachers (1528) 5. William Farel, Summary (1529) 6. Huldrych Zwingli, Fidei ratio (1530) 7. The Tetrapolitan Confession (1530) 8. Confession of the Vaudois (1530 or 1531) 9. Huldrych Zwingli, Exposition of Christian Faith (1531) 10. Articles of the Bern Synod (1532) 11. The Synod of Chanforan (1532) 12. The Confession of Angrogna (1532) 13. The (First) Basel Confession (1534) 14. The Bohemian Confession (1535) 15. The Lausanne Articles (1536) 16. The First Helvetic Confession (Second Basel Confession) (1536) 17. John Calvin’s Catechism (1537) 18. John Calvin, Geneva Confession of Faith (1536/37) 19. John Calvin, Catechism (1538) 20. Waldensian Confession of Merindol (1541) 21. The Confession of the Waldensians of Provence (1543) 22. The Confession of the Vaudois of Merindol (1543) 23. Walloon Confession of Wessel (1544/45) 24. John Calvin, Catechism (1545) 25. Juan Diaz, Suma de la Relijion Cristiana (1546) 26. Juan Valdes, Catechism (1549) 27. Consensus Tigurinus (1549) 28. Thomas Cranmer, Anglican Catechism (1549) 29. The London Confession of John à Lasco (1551) 30. The Large Emden Catechism; or Catechism of the Immigrant Church in London (1551) 31. The Confession of the Glastonbury Congregation (1551) 32. Confessio Rhaetiae (1552) 33. John Calvin, Consensus Genevensis (1552) Vol. 2 34. The Forty-Two Articles of the Church of England (1552/53) 35.
    [Show full text]