Binghamton Regional Freight Study, 2008
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Binghamton Regional Freight Study final report prepared for Binghamton Metropolitan Transportation Study prepared by Cambridge Systematics, Inc. with Eng Wong Taub & Associates RL Banks & Associates, Inc. Global Insight (USA), Inc. September 2008 www.camsys.com final report Binghamton Regional Freight Study prepared for Binghamton Metropolitan Transportation Study prepared by Cambridge Systematics, Inc. 33 East 33rd Street, Suite 804 New York, NY 10016 September 2008 Binghamton Metropolitan Transportation Study Table of Contents Executive Summary .............................................................................................................. ES-1 1.0 National and Global Trends: Setting the Stage..................................................... 1-1 1.1 Long-Term Trends................................................................................................ 1-2 1.2 Recent Trends........................................................................................................ 1-5 1.3 Long-Term Perspective........................................................................................ 1-12 2.0 Economic Profile........................................................................................................... 2-1 2.1 Demographic Profile............................................................................................. 2-2 2.2 Industry Analysis.................................................................................................. 2-8 2.3 Looking to the Future – Economic Prospects for the Binghamton Area....... 2-14 3.0 Freight Profile ............................................................................................................... 3-1 3.1 Overview of Regional Freight Network ............................................................ 3-1 3.2 Trade Patterns and Commodity Flows .............................................................. 3-39 3.3 Changing Freight Patterns................................................................................... 3-54 4.0 Carrier Profile and Stakeholder Feedback .............................................................. 4-1 4.1 Research and Field Observation ......................................................................... 4-1 4.2 Methodology.......................................................................................................... 4-1 4.3 Interviews Completed.......................................................................................... 4-2 5.0 Regional Freight Forecasts.......................................................................................... 5-1 5.1 Development of the Binghamton Regional Freight Forecasts ........................ 5-1 5.2 Freight Forecast Results ....................................................................................... 5-4 5.3 Opportunities and Implications of Forecast...................................................... 5-27 6.0 Freight Transportation Improvement Program ...................................................... 6-1 6.1 Transportation Project Identification ................................................................. 6-1 6.2 Recommended Projects and Strategies .............................................................. 6-7 6.3 Estimated Benefits and Benefit/Cost Ratios of Recommended Projects ...... 6-39 7.0 Conclusions and Recommendations......................................................................... 7-1 Appendix A Detailed Freight Forecast Methodology .................................................. A-1 Appendix B Benefit/Cost Methodology ......................................................................... B-1 Appendix C Stakeholder Outreach.................................................................................. C-1 Cambridge Systematics, Inc. i 7771.001 Binghamton Metropolitan Transportation Study List of Tables ES.1 Summary of Stakeholder Responses.......................................................................... ES-8 ES.2 Highway Project Cost Estimates................................................................................. ES-11 ES.3 Rail Project Cost Estimates .......................................................................................... ES-12 1.1 Long-Range Sector Shift in the U.S. Economy.......................................................... 1-3 3.1 Bridge Condition Data for BMTS Region .................................................................. 3-7 3.2 Bridges with Condition Ratings Below 4.000............................................................ 3-8 3.3 Low Overhead Bridge Clearances in BMTS Region ................................................ 3-9 3.4 Pavement Condition Rating Data for Interstate, Federal, and Major New York State Roadways within Broome and Tioga Counties .............................................. 3-10 3.5 Pavement Condition Rating Data for Nonstate Federal-Aid roads within the Greater Binghamton Metropolitan Area.................................................................... 3-12 3.6 Truck Percentage Summary for BMTS Region ......................................................... 3-18 3.7 Truck Volume Summary for BMTS Region .............................................................. 3-18 3.8 Freight Tonnage by Mode 2004 (in Millions of Tons) ................................................ 3-46 3.9 Value of Freight Moved by Truck and Rail 2004 (in Billions of Dollars) ................. 3-47 3.10 Binghamton Trading Patterns and Partners for Freight Shipped by Truck......... 3-48 3.11 Intraregional Truck Traffic .......................................................................................... 3-49 3.12 Binghamton Trading Patterns and Partners for Freight Shipped by Rail Rail Tons .......................................................................................................................... 3-52 4.1 Stakeholder Interview Count by Industry ................................................................ 4-2 5.1 Summary of Freight Forecasts for Binghamton Region .......................................... 5-4 5.2 Forecast of Freight Tonnage by Mode – 2004 versus 2030 in Millions of Tons ...... 5-6 5.3 Forecast of Value of Freight Moved by Mode – 2004 versus 2030 in Billions of 2004 Dollars .................................................................................................................... 5-6 ii Cambridge Systematics, Inc. Binghamton Metropolitan Transportation Study List of Tables (continued) 5.4 Binghamton Trading Patterns and Partners for Freight Shipped by Truck – 2004 versus 2030............................................................................................................ 5-8 5.5 Intraregional Truck Traffic in 2004 and 2030 ............................................................ 5-9 5.6 Binghamton Trading Patterns and Partners for Freight Shipped by Rail – 2004 versus 2030 in Tons ........................................................................................................ 5-22 5.7 Warehouse and Distribution Center Outbound Truck Tonnage (millions) Growth in BMTS and Regional Counties .................................................................. 5-27 6.1 Highway Project Cost Estimates................................................................................. 6-9 6.2 Rail Project Cost Estimates .......................................................................................... 6-17 6.3 Estimated Daily VHT/VMT Reduction in 2030 for Proposed Highway Projects 6-41 6.4 Estimated Private User Benefits in 2030 – Highway Project 1 in 2008 Dollars ..... 6-43 6.5 Estimated Public Economic Benefits in 2030 – Highway Project 1 in 2008 Dollars ............................................................................................................................. 6-44 6.6 Summary of Benefits and Estimated Benefit-Cost Ratio – Highway Project 1 in 2008 Dollars .................................................................................................................... 6-44 6.7 Estimated Private User Benefits in 2030 – Highway Project 2 in 2008 Dollars ..... 6-45 6.8 Estimated Public Economic Benefits in 2030 – Highway Project 2 in 2008 Dollars ............................................................................................................................. 6-46 6.9 Summary of Benefits and Estimated Benefit-Cost Ratio – Highway Project 2 in 2008 Dollars .................................................................................................................... 6-46 6.10 Estimated Private User Benefits in 2030 – Highway Project 3 in 2008 Dollars ..... 6-47 6.11 Estimated Public Economic Benefits in 2030 – Highway Project 3 in 2008 Dollars ............................................................................................................................. 6-48 6.12 Summary of Benefits and Estimated Benefit-Cost Ratio – Highway Project 3 in 2008 Dollars .................................................................................................................... 6-48 6.13 Travel Time Savings ..................................................................................................... 6-51 6.14 Rail Investments – Estimated Private Benefits in 2008 Dollars ............................... 6-51 6.15 Rail Investments – Estimated Public Benefits in 2008 Dollars ................................. 6-52 Cambridge Systematics, Inc. iii 7771.001 Binghamton Metropolitan Transportation