Proceedings, High Altitude Revegetation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PROCEEDINGS: Hiqh-Altitude Revegetation - Workshop no. 5 Edi ted by Robin L. Cuany and Julie Etra December 1982 ~~.---.,~ ~olorn~o Water ,.........- .-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.- ~esources ~esearc~ Institute Information Series No. 48 CoI~ University PROCEEDINGS HIGH ALTITUDE REVEGETATION WORKSHOP NO. 5 Colorado State University Fort Collins, Colorado March 8-9, 1982 Edited by ROBIN L. CUANY and JULIE ET~~ Department of Agronomy, Colorado State University WORKSHOP CO-SPONSORS THROUGH THE H.A.R. COMMITTEE Aspen Skiing Corporation Homestake Mining Company Climax Molybdenum Co. (AMAX) LTV-RDI-Steamboat Colony Shale Oil Project Mile High Seed Company Colorado Division of Wildlife Stoecker-Keammerer & Assoc. Colorado Mountain College USDA-Soil Conservation Service Colorado School of Mines USDI-National Park Service Colorado State University tHnter Park Recreational Assoc. Gibbs and Hill Inc. (Dravo) Copies available a. $6i~ @8e~ from: Water Resources Research Institute Bttiletiu Reem CSU Ayles\i'Qrt1:l Ball, CSlJ Fort Collins CO 80523 EGrt ColliQ5 cO 80523 PREFACE The Fifth High Altitude Revegetation Workshop is now history. The early history of the group is explained in one of the papers pre sented and the composition of the High Altitude Revegetation Committee is printed after the Table of Contents. The Committee started as an ad hoc group and has grown along with its sponsored activities such as the Workshops and the annual sunnner Field Tours. One of us has been Chairman since 1974, and prevailed on the Committee to hold an election during the March, 1982 workshop. As a result, Larry F. Brown (who had been Vice-Chairman) was elected to the Chairmanship and Wendell Hassell was elected to be Vice-Chairman. Most of the committee member ship continues, as an invaluable source of advice and strength, and the thanks of all who are interested in High Altitude Revegetabion are gratefully offered to these persons and to their parent agencies and companies, whose names are recognized on the title pages. The editors also realize, and wish to point out, that the Workshop could not have been as successful as it was (with 243 participants) without the valuable contributions of three groups: the participants who attend~d contributed their resources and knowledge in the discussions; the chairmen and panelists who likewise guided the thoughts and questions of the group; and the speakers who contributed their skills and time in the preparation and delivery of their papers. One paper, by Richard Hallman, was not given orally but the value of the text and photographs made it a worthy addition to the sequence. On short notice, William Mitchell volunteered a progress report from Alaska which we transcribed and have printed here at the end of the first afternoon session. Our efforts to record and transcribe the panel discussion were foiled by technical_problems, for which we tender apologies. We acknowledge the help and organizational abilities of Dean Bressler and the staff of the CSU Office of Conferences and Institutes. Our thanks also extend to Randall and Blake, Inc. for their generous sponsorship of the social hour. A special feature of the Banquet this year was the thought-provoking tape/slide show on the eruption of Mt. St. Helens. The magnitude of this disturbance and the scope of natural succession and revegetation efforts is humbling to those of us involved in this field. Robin L. Cuany Julie Etra iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface. ........................................................ iii The High Altitude Revegetation Committee.~..••••••••••.•.••••••• vii SESSION: AN INTRODUCTION TO HIGH ALTITUDE REVEGETATION (Chaired by Larry F. Brown, Climax MOlybdenum Company) The Principles of Ecology as a Framework for a Total Ecosystem Approach to High Altitude Revegetation Research (Keynote Address) I. Lehr Brisbin, Jr., Savannah River Ecology Laboratory and University of Georgia....................................... 1 The High Altitude Revegetation Committee - Who We Are and vlhat We Do. Robin L. Cuany (Chairman), Colorado State University....... 12 Management's Role in Developing Reclamation Programs. James J. Ludwig, Climax Molybdenum Company................. 29 Drastically Disturbed Lands Richard L. Brammer, Randall & Blake, Inc................... 36 SESS ION: EQUIPMENT - NEW IDEAS AND TECHNIQUES (Chaired by Jeffrey L. Pecka, Gibbs and Hill Inc.) Six Items of Equipment for Revegetating Surface Mined Lands. Richard G. Hal~man, Equipment Development Center, Missoula M'r •••••• ••• • •••• •• ••••• ••••• •••• • •• • •• •••• •• ••••••••••• ••• ••••• • 41 New Equipment Developments for Steep Slope/High Altitude Revegetation Raymond V. Adolphson, Phillip R. Schulz, and Kenneth K. Dykeman, USDA-Forest Service..................................... 50 Transplanting Techniques Used in the Establishment of Native Vegetation. Kent A. Crofts and Kenneth E. Carlson, Colorado Yampa Coal Company, Steamboat Springs CO ••••.•..•.•••.••.•••••••••••••• ;,... 58 SESSION: RECLAMATION CASE STUDIES (Chaired by Mark A. Schuster, Colony Project, EXXON Co., USA and TOSCO Corporation) iv An Update of Urad Mine Reclamation Charles L. Jackson, Climax Molybdenum Company.............. 79 Methods Used to Revegetate the Coeur d'Alene Mine District of Idaho. Ed Pommerening, Bunker Hill Mining Co., Kellogg ID .......•. 106 Soil Disturbance and Stabilization on High Altitude Ski Slopes. Duke Hall, Beaver Creek Associates, Inc.................... 110 Oil Shale Reclamation: Review and Observations Ed B. Baker, Cathedral Bluffs Shale Oil Co., Rifle CO 114 Revegetation Progress in Alaska William F. Mitchell, Alaska Agricultural Experiment Station, Palmer, AI<....................................................... 122 SESSION: THE ROLE OF SOIL SCIENCE IN HIGH ALTITUDE REVEGETATION (Chaired by Wendell Hassell, USDA Soil Conservation Service) Overview of Soils Considerations in High Altitude Revegetation J.J. Jurinak, Utah State University............. .. ••..•.••. 128 Erosion Control of Logging Roads Alfred Darrach, USDA Forest Service••••••...•••.•.••.•..... 136 New Developments in Soil Amendments -A Biologist's Point of View Cyrus M. McKell, Native Plants, Inc., Salt Lake City VT •..• 151 Soil Survey - Accommodating User Needs Richard Trenholme, Intermountain Soils, Inc, Denver CO ••••. 164 SESSION: PANEL DISCUSSION: TOPSOIL, REVEGETATION AND REGULATIONS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION OR DOGMA? (Moderated by Thomas A. Colbert, Gibbs and Hill, Inc.) Panelists: Marlene Berg, Office of Surface Mining Alfred Darrach, USDA Forest Service Cyrus McKell, Native Plants, Inc. Larry F. Brown, Climax Molybdenum Co. (No transcript was available for this panel discussion) SESSION: WHAT'S NEW AND AVAILABLE IN PLANT MATERIALS AND REVEGETATION TECHNIQUES (Chaired by John Ericson, Mile High Seed Co.) Erosion Control Revegetation on Land Damaged by the 1980 Mt. St. Helens Eruption. Jack R. Carlson, James R. Stroh, and John A. Oyler, USDA Soil Conservation Service........................................ 174 v Turfgrass Revegetation Projects. Jack D. Butler, Colorado State University ..•..•.••••..•.... 190 Alpine Revegetation Research and Techniques' at the Lake Louise Ski Area. David G. Walker, Walker and Assoc., Ltd., Edmonton, Alberta, Canada................................................. 195 New and Available Varieties of Plants John Ericson, Mile High Seed Co............................ 201 Plant Tissue Culture: An Overview of Applications and Procedures. Sarah K. Upham, Native Plants, Inc., Salt Lake City UT ..•... 202 List of Participants at the Fifth Workshop .•..•.....•.•........•• 206 List of Publieations Available.............................. ... .. 218 vi HIGH ALTITUDE REVEGETATION COMMITTEE (1980-82) Robin L. Cuany Associate Professor, Department of Agronomy Chai rman Colorado State University, Fort Collins CO 80523 Larry Brown Deputy Director, Environmental Control, Climax Vice-Chairman Molybdenum Company, 1707 Cole Blvd., Golden CO 80401 Julie Etra Research Assistant, Department of Agronomy Secretary Colorado State University, Fort Collins CO 80523 James Anderson Mile High Seed Company, P. O. Box 1988, Grand Junction CO 81501 Phil Barnes Homestake Mining Company, 320 N. Main Gunnison CO 81230 Cl ark, Rob Aspen Skiing Corporation, P. O. Box 1248 Aspen CO 81611 Colbert, Tom Gibbs and Hill, Inc., Dravo Bldg., 1250 14th St. Denver CO 80202 Dobbierstein, Dick Winter Park Rec. Association, P.O. Box 36, Winter Park'CO 80482 Ericson, John ~1i 1e Hi gh Seed Company, P.O. Box 1988, Grand Junction, CO 81501 Grand Pre, Charles J. Senior Wildlife Biologist, Colorado Division of Wildlife, 6360 Broadway, Denver CO 80216 Hassell, Wendell Plant Material ~pecialist, SCS, P.O. Box 17107 Denver CO 80217 Jackson, Charles Environmental Control, Climax Molybdenum Company, Henderson Mine, P. O. Box 68, Empire CO 80438 Keammerer, Warren Stoecker-Keammerer and Assoc., 5858 Woodbourne Hollow, Boulder CO 80301 Kline, Gary Steamboat Ski Corp., P. O. Box 1178, Steamboat Springs CO 80477 Moller, Peter Environmental Protection Techn., Colorado Mountain College, Leadville CO 80461 vii Pecka, Jeffrey Gibbs and Hill, Inc., Dravo Bldg., 1250 14th St. Denver CO 80202 Schuster, Mark Exxon Co., USA. Colony Shale Oil Project P.O. Box 440342, Aurora CO 80044 Snobble, James Aspen Skiing Corporation, P. O. Box 1248, Aspen CO 81611 Stevem, David National Parks SerVice, Rocky Mountain National Park, Estes Park CO 80517 Wilderman, Paul Steamboat Ski Corp., P. O. Box 1178, Steamboat Springs, CO 80477 Willard, Beatrice E.