Evaluation Report on ECHO Funded Humanitarian Mine Action Pilot Projects in North-West of Cambodia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
James Madison University JMU Scholarly Commons Center for International Stabilization and Global CWD Repository Recovery Fall 10-2003 Evaluation Report on ECHO Funded Humanitarian Mine Action Pilot Projects in North-West of Cambodia Marcel Durocher Agim Hoti Mok Tonh Keo Vut Follow this and additional works at: https://commons.lib.jmu.edu/cisr-globalcwd Part of the Defense and Security Studies Commons, Peace and Conflict Studies Commons, Public Policy Commons, and the Social Policy Commons Recommended Citation Durocher, Marcel; Hoti, Agim; Tonh, Mok; and Vut, Keo, "Evaluation Report on ECHO Funded Humanitarian Mine Action Pilot Projects in North-West of Cambodia" (2003). Global CWD Repository. 1132. https://commons.lib.jmu.edu/cisr-globalcwd/1132 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Center for International Stabilization and Recovery at JMU Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Global CWD Repository by an authorized administrator of JMU Scholarly Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. EVALUATION REPORT ON ECHO FUNDED HUMANITARIAN MINE ACTION PILOT PROJECTS IN NORTH-WEST OF CAMBODIA th October 6 2003 Marcel Durocher Agim Hoti Mok Tonh Keo Vuthy TABLE OF CONTENTS ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS.......................................................................................................... 5 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .............................................................................................................................. 6 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................................. 6 METHODOLOGY............................................................................................................................................ 7 MAP 1: MAP OF THE PROVINCES VISITED DURING EVALUATION ......................................... 8 TABLE 1: EVALUATION WORK PLAN ............................................................................................. 9 TABLE 2: ITINERARY OF EVALUATION FROM SEPTEMBER 02 – 17, 2003 ............................ 10 QUESTIONNAIRES.................................................................................................................................. 16 TABLE 3: THE LIST OF VILLAGES SELECTED FOR EVALUATION.......................................... 17 TABLE 4: THE LIST OF THE LOCATIONS AND THE NAMES OF INTERVIEWEES................. 18 MINES ADVISORY GROUP (MAG)............................................................................................................ 21 PROPOSED TARGETS............................................................................................................................. 21 RESULTS TO DATE................................................................................................................................. 22 EVALUATION TEAM OBSERVATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS/ RECOMMENDATIONS................... 22 GENERAL OBSERVATIONS .................................................................................................................. 22 MAP 2: MAP OF THE DISTRICTS OF PVR PROVINCE WITH MAG (RRT) INTERVENTIONS 24 MAP 3: MAP OF THE COMMUNES OF PVR & OMC PROVINCES WITH MAG (RRT) INTERVENTIONS................................................................................................................................ 25 TABLE 5: THE LIST OF VILLAGES WITH MAG (RRT) INTERVENTIONS ................................ 26 TABLE 6: THE SUMMARY OF RESULTS OF MAG (RRT) ACTIVITIES ..................................... 27 TABLE 7: THE MINE/UXO CASUALTIES IN YEAR 2003 IN PVR PROVINCE........................... 28 TABLE 8: SUMMARY ANSWERS OF MAG VILLAGE SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRES .............. 33 TABLE 9: SUMMARY ANSWERS OF MAG VILLAGE MRE QUESTIONNAIRES...................... 36 CASUALTY TRENDS AND DATABASE ISSUES ................................................................................ 41 FIGURE 1: PVR CASUALTY TRENDS.............................................................................................. 43 FIGURE 2: DISTRICTS OF PVR CASUALTY TRENDS .................................................................. 44 FIGURE 3: CHOAM KHSANT DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS BY 2002 ....................... 45 FIGURE 4: CHOAM KHSANT DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS BY 2003 ....................... 46 FIGURE 5: KULEAEN DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS.................................................... 47 FIGURE 6: ROVIENG DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS..................................................... 48 FIGURE 7: CHHAEB DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS ...................................................... 49 FIGURE 8: SANGKOM THMEI DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS ..................................... 50 FIGURE 9: TBENG MEANCHEY DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS.................................. 51 FIGURE 10: CHEY SAEN DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS............................................... 52 FIGURE 11: TRAPEANG PRASAT DISTRICT - OMC CASUALTY TRENDS............................... 53 FIGURE 12: RIK REAY COMMUNE – ROVIENG – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS ......................... 54 FIGURE 13: ROMONIY COMMUNE – ROVIENG – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS ......................... 55 FIGURE 14: ROMTOM COMMUNE – ROVIENG – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS .......................... 56 FIGURE 15: RUMDAOH COMMUNE – ROVIENG – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS........................ 57 FIGURE 16: KULEAEN CHEUNG COMMUNE – KULEAEN – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS....... 58 FIGURE 17: KULEAEN TBONG COMMUNE – KULEAEN – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS.......... 59 FIGURE 18: THMEI COMMUNE – KULEAEN – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS............................... 60 FIGURE 19: CHOAM KHSANT COMMUNE – CHAOM KHSANT – PVR CASUALTY TREND 61 FIGURE 20: RUMDAOH SRAE COMMUNE – CHOAM KHSANT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS62 FIGURE 21: KANTOUT COMMUNE – CHOAM KHSANT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS........... 63 FIGURE 22: TUEK KRAHAM COMMUNE – CHOAM KHSANT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS. 64 FIGURE 23: YEANG COMMUNE – CHOAM KHSANT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS ................ 65 FIGURE 24: PREAH PRALAY COMMUNE – TRAPEANG PRASAT – OMC CASUALTY TRENDS................................................................................................................................................ 66 FIGURE 25: TUMNOB DACH COMMUNE – TRAPEANG PRASAT- OMC CASUALTY TRENDS ............................................................................................................................................................... 67 TABLE 10: THE MINE/UXO CASUALTIES IN YEAR 2003 IN PVR PROVINCE......................... 68 THE HALO TRUST ....................................................................................................................................... 69 PROPOSED PROJECT OBJECTIVES...................................................................................................... 70 RESULTS TO DATE................................................................................................................................. 70 Evaluation report of ECHO Funded – Humanitarian Mine Action pilot projects 2 EVALUATION TEAM OBSERVATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS.................... 70 GENERAL OBSERVATIONS .................................................................................................................. 70 MAP 4: MAP OF DISTRICTS OF OMC & PVR WITH HALO TRUST (ECHO) INTERVENTIONS ............................................................................................................................................................... 73 MAP 5: MAP OF COMMUNES OF OMC & PVR WITH HALO TRUST (ECHO) INTERVENTIONS................................................................................................................................ 74 TABLE 11: THE VILLAGES/AREAS AND THE NUMBE OF FAMILIES/PERSONS/BENEFICIARIES UNDER HALO TRUST (ECHO) INTERVENTIONS..... 75 TABLE 12: SUMMARY ANSWERS OF HALO TRUST ORGANIZATION QUESTIONNAIRES. 76 TABLE 13: SUMMARY ANSWERS OF HALO TRUST VILLAGE SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRES ............................................................................................................................................................... 81 TABLE 14: SUMMARY ANSWERS OF HALO TRUST VILLAGE MRE QUESTIONNAIRES .... 84 TABLE 15: SUMMARY ANSWERS OF HALO TRUST MINE/UXO QUESTIONNAIRES ........... 88 CASUALTY TRENDS AND DATABASE ISSUES ................................................................................ 91 FIGURE 26: OMC CASUALTY TRENDS .......................................................................................... 92 FIGURE 27: DISTRICTS OF OMC CASUALTY TRENDS ............................................................... 93 FIGURE 28: SAMRAONG DISTRICT – OMC CASUALTY TRENDS............................................. 94 FIGURE 29: BANTEAY AMPIL DISTRICT – OMC CASUALTY TRENDS ................................... 95 FIGURE 30: ANLONG VEAENG DISTRICT – OMC CASUALTY TRENDS ................................. 96 FIGURE 31: CHONG KAL DISTRICT – OMC CASUALTY TRENDS ............................................ 97 FIGURE 32: TRAPEANG PRASAT DISTRICT – OMC CASUALTY TRENDS.............................. 98 FIGURE 33: CHOAM KHSANT DISTRICT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS..................................... 99 FIGURE 34: KANTOUT COMMUNE – CHOAM KHSANT – PVR CASUALTY TRENDS......... 100 FIGURE 35: BAK ANLUNG COMMUNE – TRAPEANG PRASAT – OMC CASUALTY TRENDS ............................................................................................................................................................