DOCSLIB.ORG

Review of Social Rent Setting in Northern Ireland

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Review of Social Rent Setting in Northern Ireland REVIEW OF SOCIAL RENT SETTING IN NORTHERN IRELAND Updating the 2007 research project Gillian Young1, Allison Orr2, Kenneth Gibb2 Steve W ilcox 3 and Declan Redmond4 Final Report date: 21 February 2013 1 Newhaven Research Limited 2 University of Glasgow 3 University of York 4 UCD Dublin Contents 1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................ 3 1.1 Aims and objectives ................................................................................................3 1.2 Overview of research methods ............................................................................... 3 1.3 Report structure ......................................................................................................4 2 RENT SETTING POLICIES IN CONTEXT ..................................................... 5 2.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................5 2.2 Rent setting in the social sector .............................................................................. 5 2.3 Housing Benefit and Universal Credit ..................................................................... 6 2.4 Rent policies in England ......................................................................................... 9 2.5 Wales ....................................................................................................................15 2.6 Scotland ................................................................................................................16 2.7 Republic of Ireland ................................................................................................18 2.8 Northern Ireland ....................................................................................................23 2.9 Concluding Observations ...................................................................................... 28 3 NORTHERN IRELAND'S SOCIAL HOUSING STOCK ................................ 30 3.1 Introduction ...........................................................................................................30 3.2 Overview of NIHE stock data ................................................................................ 30 3.3 Overview of housing association stock data ......................................................... 32 3.4 Social rented stock attributes ................................................................................ 35 3.5 A benchmark rent ..................................................................................................40 3.6 Concluding observations ....................................................................................... 41 4 ANALYSIS OF BASIC RENT LEVELS AND STRUCTURES ...................... 42 4.1 Introduction ...........................................................................................................42 4.2 National comparisons ...........................................................................................42 4.3 Northern Ireland Rents ..........................................................................................44 4.4 Further consideration of housing association rents .............................................. 54 4.5 Concluding observations ....................................................................................... 58 5 AFFORDABILITY OF SOCIAL RENTS IN NORTHERN IRELAND ............. 61 5.1 Introduction ...........................................................................................................61 5.2 The concept of affordability ................................................................................... 61 5.3 Affordability of social sector rents in Northern Ireland .......................................... 68 5.4 Affordability across the UK .................................................................................... 71 5.5 Welfare Reforms ...................................................................................................72 5.6 Northern Ireland rents under the Universal Credit regime .................................... 75 5.7 Concluding observations ....................................................................................... 77 1 6 POTENTIAL FOR RENT HARMONISATION ............................................... 79 6.1 Introduction ...........................................................................................................79 6.2 Rationale for greater rent harmonisation .............................................................. 79 6.3 Potential rent structure alternatives ...................................................................... 80 6.4 Overview of the illustrative rent harmonisation model .......................................... 81 6.5 Central scenario: main findings ............................................................................. 86 6.6 Concluding observations ....................................................................................... 96 7 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS ............................................................... 98 7.1 Introduction ...........................................................................................................98 7.2 Summary of Findings ............................................................................................98 7.3 Conclusions ........................................................................................................103 8 Appendices ............................................................................................... 109 APPENDIX 1: REFERENCES .................................................................................... 109 APPENDIX 2: PROCESSING NIHE AND HOUSING ASSOCIATION DATA ............. 113 APPENDIX 3: HOUSING ASSOCIATION RENTS - ADDITIONAL TABLES .............. 120 APPENDIX 4: NIHE and HA RENT REGRESSION - SUMMARY OUTPUTS ............ 136 APPENDIX 5: SERVICE CHARGES .......................................................................... 139 2 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Aims and objectives This report explores the pattern of rents in the social housing sector and considers the scope for the development and implementation of a harmonised rent-setting regime. The specific objectives of this study, which was commissioned by the Northern Ireland Housing Executive (NIHE), were to: • Compare the rent policy framework, rent-setting arrangements and pattern of rents in Northern Ireland with those in Britain and the Republic of Ireland. • Provide a reasonable like with like comparison of rents between social landlords across Northern Ireland in 2011 and explore the extent to which the pattern of housing association rents reflects the rent policies of social landlords. • Develop a definition of an affordable rent and review the affordability and effectiveness of arrangements to determine rent levels, taking into account the potential affordability implications of the welfare reforms legislated for by the UK Government Review. • Explore the influence of grant rates and rent controls on housing association rents and reserves, their ability to lever in private finance and any potential scope to reduce grant available to housing associations. • Develop a model to exemplify the profile of rents that might be generated from an alternative harmonised rent-setting regime and assess its potential implications, including plausible convergence strategies. The study builds on a previous review of social rents in Northern Ireland (Gibb et al, 2007), which highlighted inconsistencies between the rents of different social landlords and suggested a need to establish a new and consistent way of setting social rents. 1.2 Overview of research methods The main research method was the collation and analysis of data on rents in the social rented sector. All 29 housing associations and NIHE were asked to supply details of the weekly basic rent, service charges (split by HB eligible or not) bedroom size, address and the main attributes, such as dwelling type and size, for each of their properties. Some landlords were able to respond relatively promptly but others required repeated reminders and chasing in order to secure the required data. Considerable time was also required to verify and, where necessary, rectify incorrect or missing data. In total in took 10 months to secure the necessary data. 3 To accompany the data collection exercise, the study team undertook an analysis of the rent policy documents provided by social landlords. The study team also reviewed research and policy documents relating to rent setting in the social rented sector elsewhere in the UK and the Republic of Ireland and conducted interviews with key stakeholders and opinion formers in both countries. 1.3 Report structure Chapter 2 outlines the rent policy framework across the UK and the Republic of Ireland and the wider policy, regulatory and subsidy arrangements that shape social rents. It also reviews the rent policies and structures of social landlords in Northern Ireland and the role affordability plays in setting rents. Documents reviewed as part of this study are detailed in the references section (appendix 1). Chapter 3 provides an overview of the NIHE and housing association data used to inform the analysis presented in the rest of the report and why the basic rent for a 3 bedroom terraced property was selected as a benchmark rent. Appendix 2 provides further details on the research method and the work undertaken to collate and process
Load more

Recommended publications
  • List of House Types
    List of house types This is a list of house types. Houses can be built in a • Assam-type House: a house commonly found in large variety of configurations. A basic division is be- the northeastern states of India.[2] tween free-standing or Single-family houses and various types of attached or multi-user dwellings. Both may vary • Barraca: a traditional style of house originated in greatly in scale and amount of accommodation provided. Valencia, Spain. Is a historical farm house from the Although there appear to be many different types, many 12th century BC to the 19th century AD around said of the variations listed below are purely matters of style city. rather than spatial arrangement or scale. Some of the terms listed are only used in some parts of the English- • Barndominium: a type of house that includes liv- speaking world. ing space attached to either a workshop or a barn, typically for horses, or a large vehicle such as a recreational vehicle or a large recreational boat. 1 Detached single-unit housing • Bay-and-gable: a type of house typically found in the older areas of Toronto. Main article: Single-family detached home • Bungalow: any simple, single-storey house without any basement. • A-frame: so-called because of the appearance of • the structure, namely steep roofline. California Bungalow • Addison house: a type of low-cost house with metal • Cape Cod: a popular design that originated in the floors and cavity walls made of concrete blocks, coastal area of New England, especially in eastern mostly built in the United Kingdom and in Ireland Massachusetts.
    [Show full text]
  • DESIGN GUIDELINES Form of Housing
    Form of Housing 1.3 Apartment Design BCA CLASS 2 CONSTRUCTION DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR SUSTAINABLE HOUSING & LIVEABLE NEIGHBOURHOODS on behalf of the South Australian Housing Trust Valid until December 2017 DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR SUSTAINABLE HOUSING & LIVEABLE NEIGHBOURHOODS 1.3 APARTMENT DESIGN CONTENTS Introduction 6 Background 6 This Design Guideline 7 Medium Rise Building Form 7 High Rise Building Form 7 Healthy Living and Community Connectivity 7 Scope 8 Complementary Design Guidelines 9 Building Code of Australia (BCA) 9 Background and History 10 Building Forms for Walk-Up Flats 10 Recent Developments 11 Future Occupation and Use 11 Refurbishment 12 Guiding Principles 13 Qualities of Well Designed Apartment Living 14 Diversity 14 Liveability 14 Context & Connecting with the Surroundings & Wider Community 15 Structure Plan 15 Continuity and Enclosure 16 Community By-Laws 16 Connecting Pathways and Entrances 17 Car Parking and Transport 17 Internal Circulation 17 Character and Sense of Place 18 Features 18 Consistency and Variety 18 Quality of Public Realm 18 Landscape 19 Safety and Security 20 Open Spaces and Meeting Places 20 Community Infrastructure 23 Community Activities/Cultural Infrastructure 23 Noise Attenuation 24 Environmental, Social and Economic Sustainability 24 Water Efficiency 25 Energy Efficiency 25 © Crown Copyright 2 Housing Design Guidelines Government of South Australia Valid until December 2017 DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR SUSTAINABLE HOUSING & LIVEABLE NEIGHBOURHOODS 1.3 APARTMENT DESIGN Building Forms for SAHT Apartments
    [Show full text]
  • ©2013 Tal Zalmanovich ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
    ©2013 Tal Zalmanovich ALL RIGHTS RESERVED SHARING A LAUGH: SITCOMS AND THE PRODUCTION OF POST-IMPERIAL BRITAIN, 1945-1980 by TAL ZALMANOVICH A dissertation submitted to the Graduate School-New Brunswick Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey In partial fulfillment of the requirements For the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Program in History Written under the direction of Prof. Bonnie Smith And Approved by ---------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------- New Brunswick, New Jersey May, 2013 ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Sharing a Laugh: Sitcoms and the Production of Post-Imperial Britain, 1945-1980 By Tal Zalmanovich Dissertation Director: Bonnie Smith Sharing a Laugh examines the social and cultural roles of television situation comedy in Britain between 1945 and 1980. It argues that an exploration of sitcoms reveals the mindset of postwar Britons and highlights how television developed both as an industry and as a public institution. This research demonstrates how Britain metamorphosed in this period from a welfare state with an implicit promise to establish a meritocratic and expert-based society, into a multiracial, consumer society ruled by the market. It illustrates how this turnabout of British society was formulated, debated, and shaped in British sitcoms. This dissertation argues that both democratization (resulting from the expansion of the franchise after World War I) and decolonization in the post-World War II era, established culture as a prominent political space in which interaction and interconnection between state and society took place. Therefore, this work focuses on culture and on previously less noticed parties to the negotiation over power in society such as, media institutions, media practitioners, and their audiences.
    [Show full text]
  • Apartment Living in Ireland 2019
    The Housing Agency National Study of Irish Housing Experiences, Attitudes and Aspirations in Ireland APARTMENT LIVING IN IRELAND 2019 Acknowledgements The Housing Agency would like to thank the Central Statistics Office’s Census Division, the Residential Tenancies Board, Dublin City Council, the Apartment Owners’ Network, and Eoin Corrigan and George Hussey in the Department of Housing, Planning and Local Government for the support received in the development of this study. The Housing Agency would like to thank Amárach Research for their continuing support and work on this project and acknowledge and thank all the focus group participants and survey participants who took part in this research. This research study has been led by Roslyn Molloy of the Housing Agency. Authors: Roslyn Molloy, Ursula McAnulty, Séin Healy and Anne Murphy Date: December 2019 For more information and publications in this series see: www.housingagency.ie ISBN: 978-1-903848-67-8 The Housing Agency, Research & Policy, 53 Mount Street Upper, Dublin, DO2 KT73 Apartment Living in Ireland 2019 Contents Foreword / 05 Executive Summary / 09 1 Introduction / 15 2 Research Methodology / 17 3 Context and Literature Review / 21 4 Nationally Representative Survey Results / 31 5 Focus Group Results /71 6 Conclusion and Summary of Key Findings / 82 7 Appendices / 87 – Appendix I: Sampling procedure / 87 – Appendix II: Sample profile / 89 – Appendix III: Additional tables / 93 – Appendix IV: Relevant policy, legislation / 102 and guidelines – Appendix V: Bibliography / 110 01 National Study of Irish Housing Experiences, Attitudes and Aspirations Abbreviations and Glossary AHB Approved Housing Body Also called housing associations or voluntary housing associations, they are (AHB) independent, not-for- profit organisations.
    [Show full text]
  • Daniels__Oldfield__Deborah TF
    TRABAJO DE FIN DE MÁSTER EN ESTUDIOS LITERARIOS Y CULTURALES INGLESES Y SU PROYECCIÓN SOCIAL FROM EAST CHEAM TO CHINGFORD VIA PECKHAM: BRITAIN’S JOURNEY FROM THE 1950s TO THE PRESENT DAY, AS SEEN THROUGH HER SITCOMS. DEBORAH DANIELS OLDFIELD TUTORA: DRA. MARÍA LUZ ARROYO VÁZQUEZ FACULTAD DE FILOLOGÍA UNED CONVOCATORIA JUNIO – CURSO ACADÉMICO 2020-21 Trabajo de Fin de Máster en Estudios Literarios y Culturales Ingleses y Su Projección Social Título del Trabajo: From East Cheam To Chingford Via Peckham: Britain’s Journey From the 1950s To the Present Day, As Seen Through Her Sitcoms. Autora: Deborah Daniels Oldfield Tutora: Dra. María Luz Arroyo Vázquez Facultad de Filología UNED Convocatoria: Junio – Curso Académico 2020-21 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents………………………………………………………………………...…2 List of Television Sitcoms Featured………………………………………………………...3 1. Introduction………………………………………………………………………………6 2. Post-war Britain Gives Birth To the Television Sitcom.…………………..…………..12 2.1. Britain in the 1950s – Rebuilding the Nation……………………………………...12 2.2. Television Sitcoms in the 1950s – Class, Conscripts and Competition..………….15 3. The Swinging Sixties and the Striking Seventies Herald the “Golden Age” of the Sitcom…………………………………………………………………………………..21 3.1. Britain in the 1960s – They’d Never Had It So Good……..……………………... 21 3.2. Television Sitcoms in the 1960s – Clergy, Chaos and “Coons”….……....……….26 3.3. Britain in the 1970s – The Nation Crumbles…………………………...………….35 3.4. Television Sitcoms in the 1970s – Insults, Intolerance, and Ire……..…...………..41 4. The Exciting Eighties and Notorious Nineties Initiate the Age of Sitcom “Girl Power”…………………………………………………………………………….53 4.1. Britain in the 1980s – The Ladies Step Forward……………………....…………..53 4.2. Television Sitcoms in the 1980s – Wartime Witticisms, Wheeler-Dealers, and Women…………………………………………………………………………….59 4.3.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Housing Taskforce Report Final
    More than a Roof and Four Walls Social Housing Taskforce Final Report - 30 June 2009 Chair’s Foreword One of the fundamental needs of any human being is shelter. It rates up there with food and water! Unfortunately access to quality, affordable housing is not available to all Western Australians. After decades of inaction and lack of investment by successive governments, many indicators, such as the public housing waitlist and housing stress, have clearly been at unacceptable levels for far too long. The Social Housing Taskforce members were invited therefore to review all options for addressing these issues and to try and meet an aspirational target of 20,000 new social and affordable housing units by 2020. In the last six months we have consulted, analysed, deliberated and reviewed the data and the day-to-day realities of the Western Australian housing market. We believe that the aspirational target can be met, but only with a significant change in the way which housing is managed in this State. It will take a whole of government, whole of community commitment with a new way of looking at this crucial component of people’s lives. The Department of Housing will need to take a new leadership role within a comprehensive social and affordable housing continuum which supports individuals and families from homelessness to home ownership. It will also have to be led by continuing significant investment, by both Federal and State Governments, into the social and affordable housing continuum. The recent economic stimulus packages for example will create an additional 2,600 housing units in Western Australia.
    [Show full text]
  • 8.6. Community Housing Project and Funds: New Generation Boarding House
    8.6. Community Housing Project and Funds: New Generation Boarding House AUTHOR: Rebecca Aukim, Acting Director Community and Library Services ATTACHMENTS: 1. Link Housing Briefing Paper - Revised Project Costs and Investment Requirements [8.6.1 - 3 pages] 2. Link Housing Letter - Council Investment in Housing for Women Escaping Domestic Violence [8.6.2 - 11 pages] 3. Previous Report - 23 September 2019 - Affordable Housing Need in North Sydney 2016-2036 [8.6.3 - 31 pages] PURPOSE: Increase and modernise Council’s affordable Housing offering utilising available development contributions restricted for this specific purpose. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: In September 2019 Council considered a report on the then current affordable housing need in North Sydney and based on this, the best use of the remaining funds in the affordable housing reserve, which have been accumulated from developer levies. The amount available is $4,381,105. This amount is fixed and cannot be increased due to the 2009 Ministerial Directive which transfers to the State Government any amounts levied from that date. It is important the reserve be expended before the reserve too is called in by the State Government. Link Housing, Council’s Approved Provider, has a proposal to demolish 287 Miller Street, a jointly owned 5-bedroom boarding house, and construct on-site 11 modern self-contained studio apartments with specialist disability accommodation. Link currently owns 86.26% of the property with Council owning the remainder. The proposal has been advanced to DA stage and Link Housing lodged a pre-DA#2 submission in June 2020. Link Housing received feedback from Council’s planning staff and have subsequently revised the project design as well as project costs.
    [Show full text]
  • European February 2009 Housingreview
    EUROPEAN FEBRUARY 2009 HOUSINGREVIEW Research rics.org EUROPEAN HOUSING REVIEW INTRODUCTION The RICS European Housing Review 2009 is commissioned and published by RICS (Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors) which is the largest organisation for professionals in property, land, construction and related environmental issues worldwide. With 100 000 members, RICS is the leading source of property related knowledge, best practice and consumer protection. Policy makers, from local authorities to governments and global bodies, listen to and value RICS’ impartial advice on public affairs, economic analysis and policy research. From its Brussels office, RICS monitors, comments on and influences policy through its relationships with the European Union institutions. RICS also provides a comprehensive news, information and analysis service, including: • RICS Global Commercial Property Survey - a quarterly analysis of the world’s commercial real estate markets • Market surveys – independent market research on UK property, land and construction • Global Real Estate Weekly - a brief overview of key economic and property market indicators To subscribe to these publications, or to find out more about RICS, email [email protected] or call +44 (0)870 333 1600 RICS Europe RICS Europe, based in Brussels, is the regional head office of RICS in continental Europe and represents the 17 European National Associations (RICS Belux, RICSČeska Republika, RICS Cyprus, RICS Danmark, RICS Deutschland, RICS España, RICS France, RICS Hellas, RICS Italia, RICS Magyarország, RICS Malta, RICS Nederland, RICS Oesterreich, RICS Polska, RICS Portugal, RICS Rossia, RICS Switzerland). To find out more about membership in continental Europe, contact RICS Europe in Brussels on +32 2 733 1019 or email [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • Brexit and the Housing Market
    BREXIT AND THE HOUSING MARKET A report for The Northern Ireland Housing Executive by RSM Consulting July 2019 CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4 Key findings 4 Conclusions 7 INTRODUCTION 9 Methods 9 LITERATURE REVIEW 12 What kind of Brexit? 12 The drivers of the housing market 12 The impact of Brexit on the drivers of the housing market 13 The impact of Brexit on the social housing sector 19 MIGRATION AND CROSSING THE BORDER 22 The demography of Northern Ireland 22 Migration in and out of Northern Ireland 24 Migrants and the housing market 30 The experience and concerns of migrants currently living in Northern Ireland 37 Crossing the border 42 THE NORTHERN IRELAND HOUSING MARKET 45 Tenure patterns in Northern Ireland 45 Housebuilding rates 46 Recent trends in house prices and rents 47 The social rented sector 51 Views of estate and letting agents on the impact of Brexit 55 ANALYSIS OF SOCIAL HOUSNG STOCK WITHIN TEN MILES OF THE BORDER 60 Housing Executive tenants within ten miles of the border 60 Housing association tenants within ten miles of the border 64 CONCLUSIONS 65 2 The matters raised in this report are only those which came to our attention during the course of our review and are not necessarily a comprehensive statement of all the weaknesses that exist or all improvements that might be made. Recommendations for improvements should be assessed by you for their full impact before they are implemented. This report, or our work, should not be taken as a substitute for management’s responsibilities for the application of sound commercial practices.
    [Show full text]
  • General Household Survey
    (jN 5170 Office of Population Censuses and Surveys GENERAL HOUSEHOLD SURVEY Coding and Editing Notes 1 993/94 Ss513 / 1 993/94 VB14J4 2s.4 777 GHS 1993/94 CODING AND EDITING NOTSS INTRODUCTION These notes cover the questionnaires used between April 1993 snd March 1994 inclusive. These notes are intended to provide a guide to those General Household Survey coding procedures which are not ael f -evident from the question wording and layout. They also include coding frames, extra codes and any points of definition. They are not an exhaustive description of all coding action. The working document used by coders takea the form of fuller ceding instructions which incorporate such items as codes for non-response snd checks and applicability at some questions. Some of the edit checks, denoted by EC in the notes, are incorporated in order to give a more detailed picture of editing at both the coding end computing stages. To facilitate the use of these notes the computing Master Schedule is interleaved so that, as far as possible, any relevant points are opposite the appropriate guestions. In the ccmputing edit ONA (does not apply) and NA (no answer) are treated as follows : all ONA codes are set to -9 all NA codes are set to -8, unless recoding haa taken place either into existing precedes or sp.scif ic NA codes. The treatment of NAs is indicated on the computing Master Schedule at each question as follows: ~- No answers are not allowed. Blanks are rejected and answers imputed. Scecific NA codes - eg NA = 99.
    [Show full text]
  • Addressing the Housing Needs of People Using Mental Health Services
    Addressing the Housing Needs of People using Mental Health Services A GUIDANCE PAPER Prepared by a multi-agency advisory group for the HSE National Vision for Change Working Group Addressing the Housing Needs of People Using Mental Health Services A GUIDANCE PAPEr Prepared by a multi-agency advisory group for the HSE National Vision for Change Working Group 2012 Uses: This is our master full colour logo which should appear on a white backround. A Vision for Change ADVANCING MENTAL HEALTH IN IRELAND 1 Contents Introduction …….................................................................................................................................................................…...........…….... 4 Part 1 Defining the Role of Mental Health Services in Housing of People with Mental Health Difficulties Introduction …….......................................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Conceptualising the Links Between Housing, Mental Health Difficulties and Social Exclusion ……...................................................................................................................... 8 Determining the Service User Perspective ........................................................................................................................................ 9 Housing of Individuals with Mental Health Difficulties – General Considerations ............................................................ 9 Long-Stay
    [Show full text]
  • National Report for Republic of IRELAND
    This project has received funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme for research, technological development and demonstration under grant agreement no. 290694. TENLAW: Tenancy Law and Housing Policy in Multi-level Europe National Report for Republic of IRELAND Author: Mark Jordan, University of Southampton Team Leader: Prof Peter Sparkes, University of Southampton National Supervisor: Dr Padraic Kenna, National University of Ireland Galway Peer reviewers: Dr Joris Hoekstra, Delft University of Technology (Netherlands) Prof Lena Magnusson Turner, University of Oslo Prof Jakob Juul-Sandberg, University of Southern Denmark Prof Iustin Armasu, Metropolitan Research Insitute (Hungary) 1 National Report for Republic of Ireland Table of Contents 1. Housing situation ......................................................................................................... 4 1.1 General Features ................................................................................................... 4 1.2 Historical evolution of the national housing situation and policies ...................... 4 1.3 Current situation ..................................................................................................... 8 1.4 Types of housing tenure in Ireland...................................................................... 19 1.5 Other general aspects ......................................................................................... 41 2 Economic Factors ......................................................................................................
    [Show full text]