DOCSLIB.ORG

Conceptions of Citizenship and Civic Education

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Conceptions of Citizenship and Civic Education Conceptions of Citizenship and Civic Education: Lessons from Three Israeli Civics Classrooms Aviv Cohen Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy under the Executive Committee of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 2013 © 2013 Aviv Cohen All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT CONCEPTIONS OF CITIZENSHIP AND CIVIC EDUCATION: LESSONS FROM THREE ISRAELI CIVICS CLASSROOMS Aviv Cohen Based on the notion that philosophical assumptions and educational aims are important factors that gear educational processes, this study focuses on the ways in which teachers’ assumptions and goals regarding citizenship influence their teaching of civics. The research of this topic is pursed based on a set of comparative analytic case studies that observe different ways in which conceptions of the notion of good citizenship manifest in three Israeli high school civics classrooms. This study draws from the research traditions of grounded theory, the use of ideal types, as well as the principles of the qualitative instrumental collective case study approach. This study’s main finding is the identification of a stark disparity between the conceptions of citizenship that are promoted in each of the three cases, despite the a-priori similarities between them. This disparity results in the enactment of very different types of civics lessons as well as influences the goals, the relation to the curriculum standards, and the pedagogies implemented in these three settings. As a result of these findings, three ideal types of citizenship and civic education (CCE) are presented, reflecting these different approaches: (1) disciplined CCE; (2) participatory CCE; and (3) critical CCE. The importance of these findings is in the illumination of a civic education gap, relating to these differences. Following the scholarly discourse surrounding this topic, this study contributes to the understanding that not only is there a gap regarding the civic experiences and opportunities to which the students are exposed, but that the fundamental meaning of the term good citizenship is interpreted and promoted in a varying fashion. This focus, on the ways in which these different conceptions influence and reinforce the reality of the civic education gap, forges the connections between these two fields of study, a connection that yet has to been acknowledged in the literature. In fact, this civic education gap implies to the contextual factor of social inequality as it reflects in the classroom settings, in relation to this specific subject matter. An explanation for this gap is the central role that the civics teachers hold, in relation to their students’ opinions, academic levels and socio-economic backgrounds. With the help of the theoretical concepts of civic abandonment and civic activity, which relate to the individual’s civic identity in relation to the country in which s/he lives, this study documents ways in which teachers frame their civics lessons in congruence to their own perception of their students’ civic orientations. In this manner this study points to the dangers of such a reality in which teachers choose to promote civic ideals that do not recognize the complexity and multiplicity of this topic. Based on these findings, a presentation of pedagogical strategies as well as a descriptive theoretical model of the civic education process will be brought forth, utilizing these different approaches to CCE. This presentation will potentially support teachers in designing holistic educational experiences that touch on a variety of CCE conceptions. This stands in contrast to the current reality in which such conceptions are dealt with as mutually exclusive. In this manner, this study promotes the belief that all students should have equitable access to the knowledge, values and dispositions that are crucial for any democratic citizen. CONTENTS CONTENTS ............................................................................................................................... i LIST OF TABLES .................................................................................................................. viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS....................................................................................................... ix INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................1 Theoretical Assumptions ............................................................................................. 7 Problem Statement and Research Questions .............................................................. 14 Citizenship in Israel ................................................................................................... 16 Significance of the Study ........................................................................................... 21 Limitations ................................................................................................................ 22 Chapter Summary...................................................................................................... 23 REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE AND THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK ............................. 24 Assumptions.............................................................................................................. 25 Key Debates .............................................................................................................. 30 Procedural Political Knowledge vs. Substantive Political Knowledge. ............................... 30 Individualistic Normative Values vs. Communal Normative Values. ................................. 32 Thin Civic Dispositions vs. Thick Civic Dispositions. ....................................................... 34 Typologies of Citizenship and Civic Education ......................................................... 36 i Citizenship. ....................................................................................................................... 37 Citizenship and Civic Education. ....................................................................................... 39 Citizenship and Civic Education – An International Perspective ................................ 43 The Civic Education Gap .......................................................................................... 44 Education in Israel..................................................................................................... 48 Historical Development. .................................................................................................... 49 The Bagrut Matriculation Certification System. ................................................................. 54 Education in Israel Today. ................................................................................................. 57 The Teaching of Civics in Israel ................................................................................ 58 Historical Development. .................................................................................................... 60 The Contemporary Civics Curriculum. .............................................................................. 64 Population. .................................................................................................................... 64 Content. ......................................................................................................................... 64 Educational principles. .................................................................................................. 65 Goals. ............................................................................................................................ 65 Subjects. ........................................................................................................................ 66 The Official Ministry of Education Textbook. ................................................................... 67 The Civics Bagrut Exam. ................................................................................................... 68 A Review of the Academic Literature. ............................................................................... 70 ii Historical Studies........................................................................................................... 70 Empirical Studies........................................................................................................... 71 Diversity Studies. .......................................................................................................... 73 Opinion Surveys. ........................................................................................................... 73 Policy Papers. ................................................................................................................ 75 Chapter Summary...................................................................................................... 76 METHODOLOGY.................................................................................................................... 78 Rationale ................................................................................................................... 78 Role of the Researcher .............................................................................................. 82 Bounding the Study ................................................................................................... 85 Case Identification, Settings
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Future for Israeli-Palestinian Peacebuilding
    Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre A future for Israeli-Palestinian peacebuilding Ned Lazarus July 2017 The Israel-Palestine conflict is one of the most heavily researched in the world. Yet a shockingly small fraction of this research focuses on the millions of Israelis and Palestinians who share this land, their relations with one another, and how such relations could be improved so that a breakthrough might be possible. This report is both timely and necessary, and can hopefully provide a blueprint for greater international support of civil society efforts to foster conflict resolution. John Lyndon Executive Director of OneVoice Europe and Research Fellow at Kings College London BICOM, the Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre, is an independent British think tank producing research and analysis to increase understanding of Israel and the Middle East in the UK. Fathom: for a deeper understanding of Israel and the region is BICOM’s online research journal, publishing interviews, articles and reviews from a range of Israeli, Palestinian and international contributors. Front Cover Photo: EcoPeace’s Israeli, Jordanian and Palestinian directors and staff standing together in the Jordan River as part of their campaign to rehabilitate the river which is dwindling due to diversion of its source waters and pollution. Photograph used by permission of EcoPeace. The Author Ned Lazarus is Visiting Professor of International Affairs at the George Washington University’s Elliott School, and an Israel Institute Teaching Fellow. A conflict resolution scholar, practitioner and evaluator, Ned has conducted evaluative studies of Israeli-Palestinian peacebuilding initiatives on behalf of USAID, USIP and the European Union.
    [Show full text]
  • The Labor Party and the Peace Camp
    The Labor Party and the Peace Camp By Uzi Baram In contemporary Israeli public discourse, the preoccupation with ideology has died down markedly, to the point that even releasing a political platform as part of elections campaigns has become superfluous. Politicians from across the political spectrum are focused on distinguishing themselves from other contenders by labeling themselves and their rivals as right, left and center, while floating around in the air are slogans such as “political left,” social left,” “soft right,” “new right,” and “mainstream right.” Yet what do “left” and “right” mean in Israel, and to what extent do these slogans as well as the political division in today’s Israel correlate with the political traditions of the various parties? Is the Labor Party the obvious and natural heir of The Workers Party of the Land of Israel (Mapai)? Did the historical Mapai under the stewardship of Ben Gurion view itself as a left-wing party? Did Menachem Begin’s Herut Party see itself as a right-wing party? The Zionist Left and the Soviet Union As far-fetched as it may seem in the eyes of today’s onlooker, during the first years after the establishment of the state, the position vis-à-vis the Soviet Union was the litmus test of the left camp, which was then called “the workers’ camp.” This camp viewed the centrist liberal “General Zionists” party, which was identified with European liberal and middle-class beliefs in private property and capitalism, as its chief ideological rival (and with which the heads of major cities such as Tel Aviv and Ramat Gan were affiliated)­.
    [Show full text]
  • Profiles of Peace
    Profiles of Peace Forty short biographies of Israeli and Palestinian peace builders who have struggled to end the occupation and build a just future for both Palestinians and Israelis. Haidar Abdel Shafi Palestinian with a long history of working to improve the health and social conditions of Palestinians and the creation of a Palestinian state. Among his many accomplishments, Dr. Abdel Shafi has been the director of the Red Crescent Society of Gaza, was Chairman of the first Palestinian Council in Gaza, and took part in the Madrid Peace Talks in 1991. Dr. Haidar Abdel Shafi is one of the most revered persons in Palestine, whose long life has been devoted to the health and social conditions of his people and to their aspirations for a national state. Born in Gaza in 1919, he has spent most of his life there, except for study in Lebanon and the United States. He has been the director of the Red Crescent Society in Gaza and has served as Commissioner General of the Palestinian Independent Commission for Citizens Rights. His passion for an independent state of Palestine is matched by his dedication to achieve unity among all segments of the Palestinian community. Although Gaza is overwhelmingly religiously observant, he has won and kept the respect and loyalty of the people even though he himself is secular. Though nonparti- san he has often been associated with the Palestinian left, especially with the Palestinian Peoples Party (formerly the Palestinian Communist Party). A mark of his popularity is his service as Chairman of the first Palestinian Council in Gaza (1962-64) and his place on the Executive Committee of “There is no problem of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) (1964-65).
    [Show full text]
  • Taking the Initiative: Reflections on Ariel Sharon Parashat Bo January 4, 2014 Rabbi Carl M
    Taking the Initiative: Reflections on Ariel Sharon Parashat Bo January 4, 2014 Rabbi Carl M. Perkins Temple Aliyah, Needham In today’s parashah, we read of the increasingly tense standoff between Pharoah and Moses. Last week, and again this week, we read about plague after plague, as the struggle continues. And yet we know that this conflict will eventually come to an end, with the Israelites victorious as they depart Egypt defiantly, b’yad ramah. The Israelites will defeat their foes in a manner that is almost impossible to conceive of today: without lifting a finger to defend themselves; in fact, without at all fighting their enemies. They’ll be free because God is on their side. Throughout the Exodus story, the use of physical force by humans is disparaged. We do have that story of the Egyptian taskmaster beating the Israelite. Moses intervenes, but is then not fully appreciated, and is even condemned the next day. The bottom line is that the entire people is rescued in a cosmic, mythic, epic scene that is far different from the battlefields of modern warfare. For generations, this model worked very well. For two thousand years, in fact. But although the story inspired liberation struggles all over the world among the powerless against the powerful, although the story bought hope to millions, it had nothing to offer those who were actively fighting for their freedom. It was of limited value to those actually fighting for their freedom. In fact, it was ultimately rejected by those who believed that it was necessary to fight, and not only to pray, for freedom.
    [Show full text]
  • Download 2019-2020 Annual Report
    Annual Report: Canadian Friends of Peace Now שלום) Canadian Friends of Peace Now (CFPN) is a sister organization of Peace Now Shalom Achshav), Israel's preeminent peace movement. We support the agenda of/עכשיו Peace Now in Israel, and raise awareness in Canada of the need for a viable and durable solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. CFPN is dedicated to promoting Israeli- Palestinian peace on the basis of the two-state solution. With branches in Ottawa, Toronto and Montreal, and supporters throughout Canada, CFPN sponsors public talks and webinars, engages in advocacy, publishes press releases and newsletters and partners with other progressive Zionist organizations on Israeli-Palestinian peace issues. A registered Canadian charity, CFPN raises funds to support its activities in Canada and Peace Now's educational programs in Israel. ( שלום עכשיו) Peace Now Peace Now became a dominant force in Israel’s political scene in 1978, when the peace talks between Israel and Egypt appeared to be on the verge of failure. In order to rescue the peace talks, 348 combat soldiers and officers signed the ‘Officers' Letter’ – an open letter to Prime Minister Menachem Begin, calling for him to seize the window of opportunity and ensure a lasting peace. Tens of thousands of Israelis supported the letter, and the Peace Now movement was born. Since 1978, Peace Now has been the leading Israeli organization calling for peace between Israel and its neighbours and particularly for a viable resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Its key message is: two states for two peoples – Israel and Palestine. Its activities include advocacy, public campaigns, education, and monitoring and protesting West Bank settlement expansion.
    [Show full text]
  • Collection Israeli Peace Movement (1965-) 1977-20101977-2010
    Collection Israeli Peace Movement (1965-) 1977-20101977-2010 International Institute of Social History Cruquiusweg 31 1019 AT Amsterdam The Netherlands hdl:10622/ARCH00672 © IISH Amsterdam 2021 Collection Israeli Peace Movement (1965-) 1977-20101977-2010 Table of contents Collection Israeli Peace Movement..................................................................................................5 Context............................................................................................................................................... 5 Content and Structure........................................................................................................................5 Access and Use.................................................................................................................................6 LIST...................................................................................................................................................7 Peace organizations....................................................................................................................7 Conscientious Objectors and Soldiers' Groups.......................................................................... 7 Demonstrations, protest- and solidarity actions..........................................................................7 Joint Jewish-Arab actions........................................................................................................... 8 Palestinian Organizations..........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Jewish Terrorists in Hebron: a Playwright’S Vision
    Jewish Terrorists in Hebron: a playwright’s vision I had a hard time initially with the Off-Off-Broadway New York production of “Martyrs Street,” which a few of us at PPI saw together late in April; but it was not nearly as hard for me as it was for a number of people who angrily walked out on the “talk back” panel after. Panelists included a variety of Jewish and Israeli activists (including PPI’s own Maya Haber) who reflected upon what has motivated them into their peace activism, including frustration at Israel for its continuing occupation of the West Bank and outrage at last summer’s invasion of the Gaza Strip. This obviously upset those in the audience who left most conspicuously — two of whom voiced their dissent as they exited. What disturbed me about the play was that the settlers were depicted as embarking on terrorism against Israelis, when in fact the worst of them have engaged in what we can call terrorism and hooliganism against Palestinian Arabs. (Yes, I know that this was meant to be fiction.) The political environment portrayed in “Martyrs Street” is completely different from Israel’s current reality, with the pro-settler movement basically being in the driver’s seat. The play described the radical settler community in Hebron under siege by the IDF and Shin Bet, with an Israel about to evacuate settler homes there. This is what should have happened in 1994 in the wake of Baruch Goldstein’s massacre of 29 Muslims at prayer in a mosque. Yitzhak Rabin’s failure to do what Meretz and other doves were suggesting, to forcibly remove settlers from this area (Hebron and/or nearby Kiryat Arba, where Goldstein had resided) fueled the Hamas and Islamic Jihad acts of terror against Israelis that ultimately undermined the Oslo peace process.
    [Show full text]
  • Come I Profeti Movimenti Religiosi Ebraici Per La Pace in Israele E Nei Territori Palestinesi Occupati (1975-2012)
    Corso di Laurea magistrale in Asia meridionale e occidentale: lingue, culture e istituzioni Tesi di Laurea Come i profeti Movimenti religiosi ebraici per la pace in Israele e nei Territori Palestinesi Occupati (1975-2012) Relatrice Ch.ma Prof.ssa Marcella Simoni Correlatrice Ch.ma Prof.ssa Emanuela Trevisan Semi Laureanda Cristiana Calabrese Matricola 815424 Anno Accademico 2011 / 2012 Al mio papà Alfredo, la mia guida INDICE Elenco delle immagini p. 4 p. 7 הקדמה Introduzione p. 11 1. Argomento e obiettivi della tesi p. 11 2. Collocazione della tesi in rapporto alla letteratura e alla storiografia esistenti p.12 3. Breve presentazione dei movimenti Oz Ve Shalom , Netivot Shalom , Rabbini per i Diritti Umani , Eretz Shalom p. 17 4. Fonti e metodologia di lavoro p. 26 5. Struttura della tesi p. 28 Capitolo 1: Il ruolo dei movimenti religiosi ebraici per la pace nel panorama politico, sociale e istituzionale israeliano 1.1 La collocazione politica dei movimenti religiosi ebraici israeliani per la pace e il loro rapporto con i movimenti laici p. 31 1.2 La visione del sionismo e dello Stato d’Israele nel pensiero dei movimenti religiosi ebraici israeliani per la pace p. 40 1 Capitolo 2: Le posizioni dei movimenti religiosi ebraici per la pace su alcune questioni politiche e ideologiche di rilievo 2.1 I Territori Palestinesi Occupati/Giudea e Samaria p. 60 2.2 La soluzione al conflitto: partizione, Stato bi-nazionale o Stato federale? p. 77 2.3 L’esercito, il servizio militare obbligatorio e la violenza p. 96 2.4 L’obiezione di coscienza, il
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Outline
    Peace, Politics and PostZionism: Contemporary Left-Wing Graphic Design in Israel Bareket Kezwer Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts in the History of the Decorative Arts and Design MA Program in the History of the Decorative Arts and Design Cooper-Hewitt, National Design Museum, Smithsonian Institution; and Parsons The New School for Design 2011 ©2011 Bareket Kezwer All Rights Reserved Table of contents Introduction 1 Chapter One: The Birth of a Nation: Visual Language and the Construction of the Zionist Narrative and Israeli Identity 5 Chapter Two: Breaking Out of the Narrative: the Birth of PostZionist Design 14 Chapter Three: Varied Voices: Expanding the Practice 53 Concluding Remarks 110 Bibliography 112 Appendix A: Timeline 115 i Acknowledgements This project would not be possible without the help of Jen Cohlman, Iris Dishon, Ronen Eidelman, David Grossman, Lahav Halevy, Ofer Kahana, Ruben Kohn, Jonathan Lax, Yossi Lemel, Ellen Lupton, Paula Markus, Ilan Molcho, Guy Saggee, Amitai Sandy, Adi Stern, Adlai Stock, David Tartakover, Alice Twemlow, Ziv Tzapati, Yarom Vardimon, Mushon Zer-Aviv, and Gil Zohar. Thank you תודה רבה ii 1 Introduction ―Israel is a country still searching for its principles and its identity.‖1 Pundits have quipped that Israel is a country with more history than geography. That surfeit could equally apply to the Israeli political system, which has been called a democracy on steroids. The number of political opinions, are jokingly said to outnumber the population. Israelis span a spectrum from the far left to the rabid right, and are rarely shy about making their opinions known.
    [Show full text]
  • A Progressive Pivot
    A Progressive Pivot By Hillel Ben Sasson In his inaugural address to parliament in 1992, in the heyday of hope for peace in Israel, Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin said: “Speaker of the Knesset, members of the Knesset, in this decade, the last of the 20th century, atlases, history and geography books no longer present an updated picture. The walls of hostility have fallen. Borders have been erased, superpowers crumbled, ideologies collapsed, states have been born, states have died. The gates of immigration to Israel are now open. It is our duty, to ourselves and to our children, to see the new world as it is. To assess the dangers, examine the odds, and do everything we can to ensure that Israel is part of this changing world. We no longer have to be ‘a nation unto itself’. It is no longer true that the whole world is against us. We must overcome the sense of isolation that has held us in its thrall for almost half a century. We must join the peace train of reconciliation and cooperation that is thundering across the globe, otherwise we will remain alone at the station.” The Israeli Progressive Camp in 2020 Twenty-seven years later, the mainstream mood in Israel is a stark contrast to this sentiment. “There is no shame in wanting peace,” declared former chief-of-staff and candidate for prime minister, Benny Gantz, during his election campaign. “There is no shame in seeking peace,” he reaffirmed. After stressing that Israel will likely have to keep fighting for the next fifty years, he concluded: “I will not let an entire generation of Israelis live without hope that things can be different.” Gantz’s words captured the mood of Israeli progressives – a section of society that still believes in peace but is too embarrassed to say so, given the entrenched notion that there is no partner on the Palestinian side.
    [Show full text]
  • THE TRANSFORMATION of ISRAELI PEACE ACTIVISM SINCE the SECOND INTIFADA by LEONIE FLEISCHMANN a Dissertation Submitted for the De
    THE TRANSFORMATION OF ISRAELI PEACE ACTIVISM SINCE THE SECOND INTIFADA By LEONIE FLEISCHMANN A dissertation submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy City University London Department of International Politics December 2015 ©2015 Leonie Fleischmann All Rights Reserved i ii TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES ...........................................................................................................................................x LIST OF ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS .................................................................................................. xi ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .............................................................................................................................. xii DECLARATION ............................................................................................................................................ xiii COPYRIGHT DECLARATION ........................................................................................................................ xiii ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................................. xiv CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................. 1 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 1 2 Research Questions ..............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • DEMOKRATIEBILDUNG in ISRAEL Geschichte Und Aktuelle Ansätze
    DEMOKRATIEBILDUNG IN ISRAEL Geschichte und aktuelle Ansätze URIEL KASHI Impressum © Stiftung „Erinnerung, Verantwortung und Zukunft“, Berlin 2008 www.stiftung-evz.de Verantwortlich: Sonja Böhme, Sandra Anusiewicz-Baer (AJC) Diese Veröffentlichung stellt keine Meinungsäußerung der Stiftung „Erinnerung, Verantwortung und Zukunft“ dar. Für die inhaltlichen Aussagen trägt der Autor die Verantwortung. Die Studie wurde vom American Jewish Committee (AJC) Berlin Office in Auftrag gegeben und von der Stiftung „Erinnerung, Verantwortung und Zukunft“ gefördert. Alle Copyright-Rechte an den Photographien liegen bei den jeweiligen Institutionen. Gestaltung Deckblatt: Sonja Frank, graphik design, Berlin Eine Reproduktion ist nur mit Genehmigung der Stiftung „Erinnerung, Verantwortung und Zukunft“ möglich. Lektorat: Anke Zeitschel Satz: Stellwerk Grafic Concepte+marketing Druck: Druckerei Elsholz GmbH ISBN-10: 3-9810631-7-1 ISBN-13: 978-3-9810631-7-2 DEMOKRATIEBILDUNG IN ISRAEL DEMOKRATIEBILDUNG IN ISRAEL Geschichte und aktuelle Ansätze URIEL KASHI Inhaltsverzeichnis Vorwort 7 Vorwort des American Jewish Committee 9 I. Einleitung 11 II. Das israelische Bildungssystem im Überblick 13 2.1 Historische Entwicklung des israelischen Bildungssystems 13 2.2 Das israelische Bildungssystem seit der Staatsgründung 15 2.2.1 Schulautonomie als Lösungsansatz 16 2.3 Allgemeiner Aufbau des Bildungssystems 19 2.3.1 Elementarbereich 21 2.3.2 Primarschule 22 2.3.3 Sekundarbereich 23 III. Einführung zur Geschichte der Civic Education in Israel 25 3.1 Die Berichte Shenhar
    [Show full text]