Corsican Pine
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AN INVESTIGATION OF THE DURABILITY OF UK GROWN SOFTWOOD DISTRIBUTION POLES CCA-TREATED BY SAP-DISPLACEMENT. SANDRA D. HAINEY, B.Sc. (Hons.) This thesis is presented to the Council for National and Academic Awards in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Department of Molecular and Life Sciences. Dundee Institute of Technology August, 1992 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS. I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my supervisors Dr A. Bruce and Dr G.M. Smith for their supervision and guidance throughout the duration of this project. Thanks are also due to Prof. B. King and Dr. P.D. Evans for their helpful advice during the early stages of the project. I am grateful to the Electricity Council for the grant in support of this work, and to my external collaborators Mr J.J. Blair (North of Scotland Hydro Electric Board) and Dr S.F. Morgan (formerly of the Electricity Council Research Centre, Capenhurst) for their valuable advice during our many progress meetings. I would also like to thank Calders & Grandidge Ltd., Gloucester for supplying the treated poles, and to Mr I.M. Fowlie (formerly of Midlands Electricity Board) for his expert advice from an industrial viewpoint. I am very appreciative of the advice and encouragement given by my fellow research students, with special thanks to Mrs Anne Vigrow for her much valued practical help. I would also like to thank Mr H.J. Staines for his time and patience in the statistical analysis of my work. Finally, special thanks are reserved for my family for their financial and emotional support throughout the duration of this project, and to Bob for his continual encouragement and good humour which saw me through to the end. DUNDEE IN STITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY LIBRARY Reproduction of Project Report Author Sandra D. Hainey Title An Investigation of the Durability of UK Grown Softwood Distribution Poles CCA-Treated by Sap-Displacement. Qualification Doctor of Philosophy Year of submission 1992 I agree that a copy may be made of the whole or any part of the above mentioned project report by the Library of Dundee Institute of Technology at the request of any one of its readers without further reference to the undersigned on completion of a Copyright Declaration Form, and on payment of the fee currently in force. Signature Address 17th August, 1992. AN INVESTIGATION OF THE DURABILITY OF UK GROWN SOFTWOOD DISTRIBUTION POLES CCA-TREATED BY SAP-DISPLACEMENT. Sandra D. Hainey B.Sc. (Hons) ABSTRACT. The decay susceptibility of UK grown Corsican pine, Scots pine, Norway spruce and Sitka spruce poles treated with CCA by the high pressure sap-displacement process, was investigated using full size poles in a field site and representative pole sections in an accelerated decay system. Analysis of cores removed from the field poles showed a significant difference in the treatability of the four wood species. While satisfactory uptake and penetration of copper, chromium and arsenic were recorded for Corsican and Scots pine and Norway spruce, significantly lower levels of CCA penetration and retention were found in Sitka spruce poles. The narrow preservative penetration and extensive checking recorded in Sitka spruce poles contributed to the isolation of decay fungi after only four years field exposure. Radial distribution of the three preservative elements showed a gradient of chromium and arsenic which generally decreased from pole surface to centre, however, in all species except Sitka spruce an intermediate peak in copper concentration was recorded. Analysis of core samples removed annually from the groundline region of field poles indicated that migration of the CCA salts had occurred. This migration appeared to be complete after the first year of field exposure. Significant increase in copper and chromium levels in soil adjacent to poles of each species, indicated that leaching of the CCA components had occurred from the poles to surrounding soil. This small leaching effect is not expected to have a significant adverse effect on protection of the poles or to act as a soil pollution hazard. Exposure of pole sections to the natural soil microflora in the accelerated decay system resulted in untreated control sections suffering extensive soft rot decay of their curved and checked surfaces. Soft rot attack of CCA-treated sections was however, limited to small surface pockets at the untreated or poorly treated regions of their checked surfaces. Inoculation of the pole sections with basidiomycete fungi produced major differences in the type and location of decay development between the untreated and CCA-treated samples. Despite the presence of a heavy basidiomycete inoculum, decay of untreated control sections continued to be due to soft rot attack of curved and internal checked surfaces. Severity of decay was in the order of Corsican pine > Scots pine > Norway spruce > Sitka spruce. Decay of CCA-treated sections however, was produced principally by internal basidiomycete attack with large internal pockets of brown rot decay in the Sitka spruce sections. Severity of decay was the reverse of that for untreated pole sections i.e. Sitka spruce > Norway spruce > Scots pine > Corsican pine. The unexpected patterns of decay in CCA-treated pole sections was linked to the presence of CCA in the wood and soil, and the significantly lower moisture levels present in these sections. The validity of using the accelerated decay system to assess the performance of the four treated wood species is discussed. CONTENTS INTRODUCTION. 1 The UK Softwood Resource. 1 Softwood Structure. 3 Treatment of Poles and their Decay. 7 Treatment with Creosote. 7 Treatment with Copper, Chome, Arsenic (CCA). 9 Preservative Treatment of Refractory Species. 11 Sap-Displacement Processes. 13 Performance Testing of Treated Poles. 16 Field Testing. 16 Accelerated Testing. 17 Laboratory Tests. 17 Soil-Bed Test Systems. 18 Aims of Project. 19 EXPOSURE OF POLES TO FIELD CONDITIONS. 22 Introduction. 22 Methods. 27 The Field Site. 27 Determination of CCA Loading, Penetration, 29 Distribution and Permanence. Sampling of Poles. 29 CCA Extraction Procedure. 30 Analysis of Metals. 31 Statistical Analysis of Data. 33 Examination of Longitudinal Variation in CCA 34 Levels. 2.2.4 Measurement of Preservative Elements in Soil. 35 2.2.4.1 Soil Sampling. 35 2.2.4.2 Recovery of Metals from Soil. 37 2.2.4.3 Analysis of Metals from Soil. 38 2.2.4.4 Statistical Analysis of Soil CCA levels. 40 2.2.5 Measurement of the Acidity of Rainwater. 40 2.2.6 Determination of Moisture Profiles. 41 2.2.7 Comparison of Extent of Checking in the Four 42 Wood Species 2.2.8 Isolation and Identification of Fungal 42 Colonisers. 2.3 Results. 44 2.3.1 CCA Loading, Penetration, Distribution and 44 Permanence. 2.3.2 Preservative Permanence during Field Exposure. 56 2.3.2.1 Longitudinal Variations in Preservative 58 Levels. 2.3.2.2 Leaching of Preservative Components from Poles 66 to Soil. 2.3.3 Measurement of Acidity of Rainwater. 68 2.3.4 Moisture Distribution within the Poles. 69 2.3.5 Extent of Checking. 71 2.3.6 Identification of Fungal Colonisers. 72 2.4 Discussion. 75 2.4.1 Treatability of the Four Wood Species. 75 2.4.2 CCA Permanence. 81 2.4.3. Factors Affecting Fungal Colonisation 87 EXPOSURE OF POLE SECTIONS TO ACCELERATED DECAY 92 CONDITIONS. Introduction. 92 Methods. 98 The Accelerated Decay System. 98 Monitoring of Soil Decay Potential. 100 Preparation of Wood Sections. 101 Soft Rot Test System. 103 Basidiomycete Test System. 105 Dehydrogenase Assay of Soil. 108 Measurement of Surface Decay using Pilodyn. 110 Measurement of Soft Rot by Microscopic 111 Analysis. Measurement of Moisture Profiles. 113 Decay of Checked Surface and Internal 114 Cross-section. Isolation of Fungal Colonisers. 115 Identification of Fungal Colonisers. 117 SDS-PAGE Analysis of Basidiomycete Isolates. 118 Cross-reactivity Studies of Basidiomycetes 119 with Mould Isolates. CCA Analysis of Wood Sections. 120 Effect of Wetting Wood Sections Prior to Soil 120 Burial Effect of Soil Burial on CCA Levels and 121 Distribution. CCA Analysis of Decayed Regions. 122 CCA Analysis of Soil. 122 3.3 Results. 124 3.3.1 Soil Decay Potential. 124 3.3.2 Compatability of Basidiomycete Mixed Inoculum. 125 3.3.3 Dehydrogenase Assay of Soil. 127 3.3.4 Measurement of Surface Decay using Pilodyn. 132 3.3.5 Measurement of Soft Rot by Microscopic 138 Analysis. 3.3.6 Measurement of Moisture Profiles. 145 3.3.7 Decay of Checked Surface and Internal 152 Cross-section. 3.3.8 Isolation of Fungal Colonisers. 164 3.3.9 SDS-PAGE Analysis of Basidiomycete Isolates. 167 3.3.10 Cross-reactivity Studies of Basidiomycetes 171 with Mould Isolates. 3.3.11 CCA Analysis of Wood Sections. 173 3.3.11.1 Effect of Wetting Wood Sections Prior to Soil 173 Burial. 3.3.11.2 Effect of Soil Burial on CCA Levels and 178 Distribution. 3.3.11.3 CCA Analysis of Decayed Regions. 183 3.3.12 CCA Analysis of Soil. 183 3.4 Discussion. 188 3.4.1 Control of Accelerated Decay Conditions. 188 3.4.2 Permanence of CCA Components. 190 3.4.3 Soft Rot Decay. 192 3.4.4 Basidiomycete Decay. 201 3.4.5 Patterns of Decay. 207 CHAPTER 4 GENERAL DISCUSSION. 215 4.1 Suitability of UK Grown Softwood Poles 215 CCA-treated by Sap - displacement. 4.2 Development of the Accelerated Decay System. 221 4.3 Appraisal of the Accelerated Decay System 223 for Testing the Decay Susceptibility of Poles CCA-treated by Sap - displacement. REFERENCES 228 APPENDICES PUBLICATIONS ABBREVIATIONS. m metre nm nanometre mm millimetre ml millilitre g gramme ug microgramme mg milligramme kg kilogramme umol micromole M molar 0 degree 0 C degree centigrade % percent rpm revs per minute min minute ppm parts per million w/w weight to weight w/v weight to volume Cu copper Cr chromium As arsenic AAS atomic absorption spectrophotometry CCA copper chrome arsenic ESI Electricity Supply Industry GL groundline HPSD high pressure sap-displacement PAGE polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis PVC polyvinyl chloride SDS sodium dodecyl sulphate TTC triphenyltetrazolium chloride TTF triphenyltetrazolium formazan WHC water holding capacity UK United Kingdom ul microlitre C H A P T E R 1 INTRODUCTION 1.