Holographic Effective Field Theories and the Ads4/CFT3 Correspondence
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Universit`adegli Studi di Padova DIPARTIMENTO DI FISICA E ASTRONOMIA “GALILEO GALILEI” Corso di Laurea Magistrale in Fisica Tesi di laurea magistrale Holographic effective field theories and the AdS4/CF T3 correspondence Candidato: Relatore: Davide Billo Prof. Luca Martucci Matricola 1132447 Anno Accademico 2016-2017 Abstract The identification of the low-energy effective field theory associated with a given microscopic strongly interacting theory constitutes a fundamental problem in theoretical physics, which is particularly hard when the theory is not sufficiently constrained by symmetries. Recently, a new approach has been proposed, which addresses this problem for a large class of four-dimensional superconformal field theories, admitting a dual weakly coupled holographic description in string theory. This approach provides a precise prescription for the holographic derivation of the associated effective field theories. The aim of the thesis is to explore the generalization of this approach to the three-dimensional superconformal field theories admitting a dual M-theory description, by focusing on a specific model whose effective field theory has not been investigated so far. ii Contents Introduction 1 1 SUSY, CFT and AdS 5 1.1 Basics of SUSY . 5 1.2 Rigid SUSY in d=3+1 . 6 1.2.1 Supersymmetric Lagrangians in d=3+1 . 9 1.3 Rigid SUSY in d=2+1 . 11 1.3.1 Supersymmetric Lagrangians in d=2+1 . 13 1.4 Conformal Field Theories . 13 1.4.1 The conformal group . 14 1.4.2 Local Field Representations . 16 1.4.3 The stress-energy tensor . 18 1.4.4 Superconformal algebra . 19 1.5 Anti de Sitter spacetime . 21 2 Complex geometry handbook 25 2.1 Basics of differential geometry . 25 2.2 Riemannian manifolds . 28 2.3 K¨ahlergeometry . 29 2.3.1 Ricci-flatness: the Calabi-Yau geometry . 32 2.4 Calabi-Yau cones . 33 3 M-Theory and brane solutions 37 3.1 Basics of M-Theory . 37 3.1.1 Field content and M-branes . 38 3.1.2 Supergravity action . 39 3.2 M-branes on conical backgrounds . 41 3.2.1 M2-brane solutions and the near-horizon limit . 41 3.2.2 Supersymmetric M2 solutions . 43 3.2.3 Warped CY4 backgrounds and deformations . 46 iii iv CONTENTS 3.3 The gauge/gravity correspondence . 48 3.3.1 Maldacena duality . 49 3.3.2 Generalizations of the conjecture . 51 4 Quiver Field Theories 53 4.1 The quiver structure . 54 4.2 Chern-Simons coupled to matter . 55 4.3 The Q111 quiver theory . 56 4.4 The moduli space of Q111 ............................... 58 4.4.1 The abelian branch for Q111 ......................... 60 4.4.2 The monopole method . 63 5 Holographic Effective Field Theory 67 5.1 Topology, K¨ahlermoduli and harmonic forms . 68 5.2 Chiral parametrization of moduli . 70 5.3 The Holographic Effective Lagrangian . 71 5.3.1 A dual description with linear multiplets . 73 5.3.2 The S-operation . 74 6 The Q111 HEFT 79 6.1 Toric geometry and the GLSM . 80 6.2 The internal M-Theory geometry . 82 6.2.1 The GLSM of C(Q111): M-Theory analysis . 83 6.2.2 The Ricci-flat K¨ahlermetric . 85 6.3 The HEFT ingredients . 89 6.3.1 Harmonic forms . 89 6.3.2 Asymptotic behaviors . 90 6.3.3 Potentials . 94 I 6.3.4 The Gab metric and the Aai connection . 95 6.4 Final consistency checks . 96 6.4.1 From M-Theory to type IIA . 96 6.4.2 Superconformal invariance . 102 7 Conclusions and closing remarks 107 Introduction Quantum Field Theories (QFTs) are currently the best way to describe fundamental interac- tions. However, they are affected by some formal illnesses: for instance, Haag's theorem put a strain on the perturbative approach, since it states the non-existence of the interaction pic- ture1. Even if we accept to work with perturbation theory there could be problems: indeed, QFTs have typically both weakly-coupled and strongly-coupled energy regimes. While we can use perturbative technologies for the former, the latter is quite challenging to deal with. A practical example is the theory of strong interactions: at low energies it is strongly coupled and hence one should invoke non-perturbative methods in order to get informations. By the way, it turns out that the low-energy behavior of this theory can be described by an Effec- tive Field Theory (EFT): namely, we can build an effective Lagrangian in order to perform calculations in the strongly-coupled regime2. It is important to stress that this Lagrangian contains informations about the degrees of freedom relevant at low energies, for example pions, and has the most general expression compatible with the symmetries of the problem. At this point, one could ask if the UV completion of this theory is actually Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), which is the current gauge theory of strong interactions, or alternatively if integrating out high-momentum degrees of freedom leads to the EFT we are talking about. The answer should be positive and this is supported by numerical results and experimental observations, together with basic theoretical considerations (i.e. symmetry consistence). But what about other theories? Is it always like the QCD case? Does the EFT Lagrangian exist? How can we build it? A general answer has not been found yet, however in certain cases there are prescrip- tions that lead exactly to the effective Lagrangian. Within this context, supersymmetry is a useful implementation to furtherly constrain a theory. Since supersymmetric particles have not been discovered yet, we should try to introduce a minimal amount of supersymmetry in order to deal with pseudo-realistic theories. Recently, a novel approach for building EFT Lagrangians of minimally supersymmetric theories has been found in [1],[2]: it exploits the power of the so called gauge-gravity corre- spondence. This technology comes from a seemingly unrelated area of physics, i.e. String 1The original result from Rudolf Haag dates back to 1955 and can be found in \On quantum field theories", Matematisk-fysiske Meddelelser, 29, 12. 2See for example [4, 5]. 1 2 CONTENTS Theory, and the basic idea is to study the gravity dual of the gauge theory: indeed, the for- mer is typically weakly-coupled when the latter is strongly-coupled. In these cases we talk about Holographic Effective Field Theories (HEFT), \holography" being a key word when dealing with this particular kind of duality. Actually, this term perfectly describes the situ- ation: the \hologram" is the gravity theory, also called the \bulk" side of the duality, and leaves in one dimension higher than the gauge theory, also known as the \boundary" side. More precisely, the \bulk" side has also extra dimensions which can be compactified in order to have an AdSd+1=CF Td duality, where the AdS stands for anti-de Sitter while the CFT is a QFT having an additional conformal symmetry. But why have we invoked String Theory? The reason is that the dynamics of branes, which are the multi-dimensional generalization of point-particles, is described by a gauge theory supported on their worldvolumes. In a large class of models, this gauge theory flows under the renormalization group to a non-trivial CFT and its strongly-coupled regime can be studied switching to the holographic dual. One can place a stack of branes on different background geometries: this will give rise to a family of field theories. The typical spacetime splitting is Rd × X, where Rd is \parallel" to the branes (and it is identified with the gauge theory spacetime) while X is a transversal manifold, usually a cone, whose dimension sums with d to ten or eleven, depending on whether we are working in a superstring or a M-theory context respectively. At this point, the stack generates a seemingly black hole configuration: if we study the near-horizon geometry we will find an AdSd+1 × Y splitting, where Y is the (compact) base of the cone X. The most notorious example is the 5 Maldacena duality [3], which relates IIB superstring theory set on the AdS5 × S background with maximally supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory on R1;3. In this case we are dealing with 5 AdS5=CF T4 duality, where the extra-dimensions of S are compactified. Since this model is maximally supersymmetric it is quite constrained: one among possible generalizations consists 5 in replacing S with another five-dimensional compact manifold Y5. This would typically lead to theories with less supersymmetries, the amount of supersymmetry being encoded in the ge- ometrical structure of Y5. The purpose of this thesis is to investigate a further generalization, namely the correspondence between three-dimensional superconformal field theories and their holographic dual. In this case the gravity side is M-theory, which may be interpreted as the 1;2 strongly-coupled limit of IIA superstring theory. The spacetime splitting is R × X8, whose near-horizon limit becomes AdS4 × Y7. A natural question would be why are we interested in these kind of models, namely AdS4=CF T3? Firstly, toy-model three-dimensional theories have been important for the study of strong coupling features. For instance, in M-Theory context CFTs dual to gravity theories obtained by placing a stack of branes on a particular background lack an adjustable coupling constant and hence are necessarily strongly-coupled: so, hologra- phy could shed light on strong coupling phenomena. Secondly, there could exist untreatable condensed matter three-dimensional models which can be studied from the holographic point CONTENTS 3 of view3. Last but not least, three-dimensional theories with N = 2 supersymmetries are ob- tained from dimensional reduction of four-dimensional theories with N = 1 (because they have the same number of supercharges), which are actually the most realistic models since they are minimally supersymmetric and four-dimensional.