PLANNING COMMITTEE Appendix A APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS FOR THE MONTH OF APRIL 2015

App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0656 Outline Clifton Outline application for residential development and LAND TO THE EAST OF TOWNEND The Lowther Estate APPROVED Application associated infrastructure. CROFT, CLIFTON, PENRITH Trust & North Associates Ltd - Mr A Ross

14/0795 Outline Bolton Outline application for residential development. LAND AT VIOLET BANK FARM, Mrs C Gollins APPROVED Application BOLTON, APPLEBY

14/1008 Full Application Brough Extension to rear of property to provide new entrance THE INN AT BROUGH, MAIN The Inn at Brough - Mrs APPROVED and reception, extended function site and refurbished STREET, BROUGH, KIRKBY S Coplowe toilet facilities. STEPHEN

14/1009 Listed Building Brough Listed building consent for the extension to rear of THE INN AT BROUGH, MAIN The Inn at Brough - Mrs APPROVED property to provide new entrance and STREET, BROUGH, KIRKBY S Coplowe reception, extended function suite and refurbished STEPHEN toilet facilities

14/1029 Full Application Sockbridge & Erection of 3 detached dwellings including re-use of LAND TO REAR OF THE COTTAGE, Mr & Mrs A. Morrison APPROVED Tirril stables as ancillary storage/amenity space. SOCKBRIDGE AND TIRRIL, PENRITH

15/0022 Full Application Kirkoswald Conversion of redundant workshop and garage to a 1-2 CROSS LANE, KIRKOSWALD, Mr & Mrs P Telford APPROVED dwelling. PENRITH

15/0090 Full Application Penrith Change of use from retail (class A1) to a tattoo 25A CORNMARKET, PENRITH Mr C Pearson APPROVED parlour (Sui Generis).

15/0095 Reserved Matters Penrith Approval of Reserved Matters comprising siting LAND AT BEACON FARM, Mr J Heath REFUSED design, external appearance, means of access KEMPLAY BANK, EAMONT BRIDGE, thereto and the landscaping relating to outline PENRITH planning permission 11/0446.

15/0096 Full Application Sockbridge & Proposed altered access. BARN ADJ. TO THWAITE Mr & Mrs P Greening APPROVED Tirril COTTAGE, TIRRIL, PENRITH

15/0097 Listed Building Sockbridge & Listed building consent for proposed altered access. BARN ADJ. TO THWAITE Mr & Mrs P Greening APPROVED Tirril COTTAGE, TIRRIL, PENRITH

15/0099 Full Application Change of use of first floor room from meeting room MARKET SQUARE, KIRKBY Mr S Harlow APPROVED (use Class B1) to cycle hire and repair service (use STEPHEN Class A1).

15 May 2015 Page 1 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0102 Full Application Temple Sowerby Proposed rear extension at first floor level and GREENFIELD HOUSE, TEMPLE Mr & Mrs C Rush APPROVED external alterations to front porch and adjacent panel SOWERBY, PENRITH of render.

15/0103 Listed Building Temple Sowerby Listed building consent for the proposed rear GREENFIELD HOUSE, TEMPLE Mr & Mrs C Rush APPROVED extension at first floor level and external alterations SOWERBY, PENRITH to front porch and adjacent panel of render.

15/0104 Full Application Penrith Erection of dwelling (retrospective). PLOT 1A KITCHEN GARDENS, Mr B Armstrong-Payne APPROVED BEACON EDGE, PENRITH

15/0105 Full Application Newbiggin Change of use of land and outbuildings from MOORLANDS HEAD FARM, Eden Animal Rescue APPROVED farmstead to animal rescue centre, extension to MILBURN ROAD, NEWBIGGIN, Centre - Mrs C Holland farmhouse for associated store and erection of TEMPLE SOWERBY cattery building.

15/0108 Outline Alston Outline application for residential development with LAND WEST SIDE OF PARK VIEW Mr R Gold APPROVED Application all matters reserved. LANE, ALSTON

15/0110 Full Application Penrith Extension to dwelling. 8 BOWSCAR ROAD, BOWSCAR, Mr & Mrs S Gate APPROVED PENRITH

15/0114 Full Application Hesket Erection of roof over existing feed area. THACKWOOD FARM, Mrs M Wilson APPROVED MONKCASTLE, SOUTHWAITE,

15/0118 Tree Works Fell tree (Sequoia) due to damage to retaining wall, CHRISTOPHERS COTTAGE, Mr Tom Richardson REFUSED (TPO) potential risk to highway users, improve access for WARCOP, APPLEBY-IN- larger vehicles and damage to neighbouring properties from loss of branches during high wind; Tree Preservation Order No 162-01, Christopher Cottage, Warcop.

15/0122 Full Application Penrith Variation of condition 1 attached to planning approval LAND ADJ. TO WILDRIGGS, John Beaty Transport APPROVED 13/0645 comprising of a revised location for the PENRITH Ltd - Mr S Beaty vehicle wash (retrospective)

15/0123 Full Application Penrith Extension and alteration to frontage of dwelling. SPRING BANK, NICHOLSON LANE, Mr K Addison APPROVED PENRITH

15/0126 Full Application Penrith Extension to rear of dwelling. CAROLINE HOUSE, LOWTHER Mr K. Reed & Miss D APPROVED STREET, PENRITH Coates

15/0128 Householder Penrith Proposed single storey rear extension. 32 BRENTFIELD WAY, PENRITH Miss A Cooke APPROVED PD/PN

15/0129 Full Application Alston Permanent siting of two portable buildings BOND PRECISION CASTINGS LTD, Mr J Forsyth - Bonds APPROVED (retrospective). POTTERS LOANING, ALSTON Precision Castings Ltd

15 May 2015 Page 2 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0130 Full Application Penrith Extensions and alterations to existing dwelling and BEDFORD HOUSE, LOWTHER Mr P McDonald & Ms D APPROVED detached garage. STREET, PENRITH Hopley

15/0132 Full Application Asby Removal of condition no. 3 (requiring the GREAT KETTLE BARN, GREAT Mr M Clayton APPROVED accommodation to be used as an ancillary to the ASBY, APPLEBY main dwellinghouse) attached to planning approval 09/0351.

15/0134 Full Application Alston Change of use of storeroom (use class B8) to THE COACH HOUSE, KINGS ARMS Mr A Dumble APPROVED residential annexe (use class C3) including external LANE, ALSTON alterations

15/0137 Full Application Penrith Siting of 16 No storage containers within rear yard UNIT 63 GILWILLY ROAD, GILWILLY Trade Copiers Ltd - Mr APPROVED (retrospective) INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, PENRITH S Armistead

15/0139 Full Application Penrith Change of use to taxi office and erection of an aerial MOSTYN COTTAGE, FRIARGATE, Mrs R Wordsworth APPROVED to the rear wall (part retrospective) PENRITH

15/0140 Full Application Glassonby Change of use of lean to extension to a holiday let. BRIDGE FARM, GAMBLESBY, D Henderson APPROVED PENRITH

15/0141 Full Application Penrith Alterations and extensions. 2 TYNEFIELD DRIVE, PENRITH Police & Crime APPROVED Commissioner for - Mr R Rhodes

15/0144 Cert. of Lawful Glassonby Certificate of lawfulness for the mixed use of land as LAND AT BLENCATHRA VIEW, Mr P Dixon REFUSED agricultural and class D2 (assembly and leisure) to GAMBLESBY, PENRITH allow the schooling and exercising of horses.

15/0146 Full Application Appleby Proposed solar PV installation on the roof of the APPLEBY GRAMMAR SCHOOL, Mr J Rostron APPROVED sports hall. BATTLEBARROW, APPLEBY

15/0149 Full Application Appleby Proposal to demolish the existing rear extensions for 9 MARGARETS WAY, APPLEBY-IN- Mr C Nelson APPROVED new domestic extensions. WESTMORLAND

15/0154 Full Application Nateby Proposed installation of a ground mounted 22kW LOCKTHWAITE, NATEBY, KIRKBY Mr A Davis APPROVED Solar PV Panel facility. STEPHEN

15/0156 Full Application Tebay Removal of existing garage to accommodate a two ROSEBANK, ORTON ROAD, TEBAY, Mr G Capstick REFUSED storey side extension. Change of use of part of agricultural field to rear, to garden and erection of new garage.

15/0157 Full Application Asby Erection of three dwellings following the demolition of CROFT HOUSE FARM, ACCESS Mr B Park APPROVED existing farm buildings. ROAD IN GREAT ASBY, GREAT ASBY, APPLEBY

15/0159 Full Application Penrith Change of use from dental surgery to a ground floor THE SURGERY, ST ANDREWS Mrs K whitehead APPROVED residential flat. VIEW, PENRITH

15 May 2015 Page 3 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0160 Tree Works Penrith Remove Lime tree affected by decay fungus; Tree LAND BEHIND 1 MACADAM Council - APPROVED (TPO) Preservation Order No 60, 1994, Land adjacent to GARDENS, PENRITH Mr P Emmerson Macadam Way, Penrith.

15/0161 Full Application Kirkoswald Change of use of land to allow the siting of 14 THE MAINS, KIRKOSWALD, Mr & Mrs R.L. Pickthall APPROVED touring caravans, tents and the siting of 7 camping PENRITH

15/0162 Listed Building Ousby Listed building consent for the proposed alterations STAG COTTAGE, MELMERBY, Mr & Mrs Rowley APPROVED to dwellinghouse. PENRITH

15/0164 Listed Building Appleby Listed Building consent for alterations to the internal 15 CHAPEL STREET, APPLEBY-IN- Mr & Mrs G Lightburn APPROVED floor level, rear roof-scape and demolition of existing WESTMORLAND building fronting the highway and disused warehouse associated with the change of use of former builders merchants to a dwelling.

15/0165 Full Application Appleby Change of use and extension of former builders 15 CHAPEL STREET, APPLEBY-IN- Mr & Mrs G Lightburn APPROVED merchants to a dwelling, including demolition of an WESTMORLAND existing building fronting the highway and disused warehouse.

15/0167 Tree Works (CA) Penrith 1) Plum tree - Formatively prune to clear footpath PAVEMENT OPPOSITE PORTLAND John Banks - Cumbria APPROVED and remove epicormic growth; 2) Plum tree - PLACE, PENRITH County Council Remove lower branches to clear highway and remove epicormic growth; 3) Fell Plum tree and replace with new; 4) Fell Plum tree and replace with new; Penrith and Penrith New Streets Conservation Areas.

15/0172 Full Application Great Salkeld Erection of a conservatory to the side elevation. 3 SUMMER HILL, NORTH DYKES, M Horn APPROVED GREAT SALKELD, PENRITH

15/0173 Full Application Proposed change of use of existing barn to a single LANE FARM, WEASDALE, Mr A Davis APPROVED dwelling. NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE, KIRKBY STEPHEN

15/0174 Listed Building Ravenstonedale Proposed alterations required for the proposed LANE FARM, WEASDALE, Mr A Davis APPROVED change of use of existing barn to single dwelling. NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE, KIRKBY STEPHEN

15/0175 Tree Works (CA) Culgaith T1: Remove Ash tree (as it is starting to spoil shape THE OLD VICARAGE, SKIRWITH, Ms Sandra Field APPROVED of large specimen Holly); G1: Remove 4 Sycamores PENRITH (growing directly against base of side wall of The Coach House); Skirwith Conservation Area.

15/0176 Full Application Temple Sowerby Creation of a vehicular access to existing dwelling. MEADOWS END, TEMPLE Mr Andrew Burne APPROVED SOWERBY, PENRITH

15 May 2015 Page 4 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0177 Full Application Hesket Erection of a side extension to incorporate derelict VICARAGE FARM, ARMATHWAITE, Mrs F Armstrong APPROVED outbuilding. The creation of new door and window CARLISLE openings and the demolition and rebuild of former farm buildings.

15/0180 Full Application Extension to existing agricultural building. SPITTALS FARM, LOW MOOR, Mr J M Addison - JM & APPROVED KIRKBY THORE, PENRITH SM Addison

15/0181 Full Application Kirkoswald First floor extension over existing garage. 9A ROODS DRIVE, KIRKOSWALD, Mr Ostle & Miss APPROVED PENRITH Falconer

15/0183 Listed Building Kirkby Stephen Listed building consent for the redecoration of CROFT HOUSE, MARKET STREET, D Keener APPROVED building façade and change of colour, and KIRKBY STEPHEN replacement of existing entrance door.

15/0185 Tree Works (CA) Great Salkeld Removal of Cherry Blossom tree in rear garden; 4 MATTINSON CROFT, GREAT Barbara Holmes APPROVED Great Salkeld Conservation Area. SALKELD, PENRITH

15/0188 Full Application Asby Replacement of existing stained timber windows and FELLSIDE COTTAGE, LITTLE ASBY, C Foster APPROVED doors to cherry wood UPVC windows and doors APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND

15/0189 Full Application Change of use of existing storage building into BUILDINGS ADJ TO ROSE BARN, Mr D Mallinson APPROVED dwelling. SHAP, PENRITH

15/0190 Full Application Penrith Conversion of existing dwelling to 3 flats. 27 KING STREET, PENRITH Red New Ltd APPROVED

15/0191 Listed Building Penrith Listed building consent for works required in the 27 KING STREET, PENRITH Red New Ltd APPROVED conversion of existing dwelling into three flats.

15/0194 Listed Building Temple Sowerby Listed building consent for the construction of a ACORN BANK MILL, ACORN BANK, The National Trust APPROVED dismantled kiln. TEMPLE SOWERBY, PENRITH

15/0196 Full Application Musgrave Erection of a timber framed garden room part LOWGILL, FLITHOLME, WARCOP, Lady Middleton APPROVED replacing existing structure. APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND

15/0197 Full Application Hesket Proposed two storey extension to gable end 6 BYRNES CLOSE, PLUMPTON, Mr R J McNeil APPROVED elevation. PENRITH

15/0198 Full Application Appleby Creation of a dormer window and solar panels to 3 CHAPEL STREET, APPLEBY Mr & Mrs A Wells APPROVED front elevation and demolition of existing kitchen extension and the erection of a rear extension.

15/0199 Full Application Bolton Proposed cattle housing building extension and BRIGHAM BANK FARM, CLIBURN, Messers R & EA APPROVED erection of a new steel portal cattle housing building. PENRITH Thompson & Son

15/0200 Full Application Proposed silage clamp area and steel portal cattle ESPLAND HILL FARM, FRITH LANE, DI & AA Cannon APPROVED housing building infill. BRAMPTON, APPLEBY

15 May 2015 Page 5 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0203 Full Application Crosby Proposed single storey conservatory on rear PINFOLD COTTAGE, CROSBY Mr & Mrs J & Y Mullen REFUSED Ravensworth elevation. RAVENSWORTH, PENRITH

15/0204 Full Application Penrith Variation of condition No 2 (plans compliance) CRANSTONS, ULLSWATER ROAD, Cranstons Ltd APPROVED attached to planning application 14/0695 comprising PENRITH of revised changes to office layout and foyer.

15/0205 Full Application Hesket Variation to condition No 2 (plans compliance) LOW PLAINS LODGE, LOW PLAINS, M Jones APPROVED attached to planning approval 14/0767 comprising of CALTHWAITE, PENRITH minor amendments to part of roof covering and minor adjustments to elevations.

15/0206 Full Application Hartley Single-storey extension to front elevation. HOLLY BECK HOUSE, HARTLEY, Mr & Mrs G Wilson APPROVED KIRKBY STEPHEN

15/0207 Full Application Dacre Single storey extension to rear of dwelling. INVERCRAE, FAIRYBEAD LANE, Mr T Coleman APPROVED STAINTON, PENRITH

15/0208 Full Application Penrith Erection of an agricultural portal frame building CROSSFIELD FARM, BOWSCAR, Mr R Threlfell APPROVED (Phase 1). PENRITH

15/0209 Full Application Penrith Erection of an agricultural portal frame building CROSSFIELD FARM, BOWSCAR, Mr R Threlfell APPROVED (Phase 2). PENRITH

15/0210 Full Application Penrith Erection of an agricultural portal frame building CROSSFIELD FARM, BOWSCAR, Mr R Threlfell APPROVED (Phase 3). PENRITH

15/0211 Full Application Penrith Erection of an agricultural portal frame building CROSSFIELD FARM, BOWSCAR, Mr R Threlfell APPROVED (Phase 4). PENRITH

15/0213 Full Application Penrith Construction of seven parking spaces from existing BUPA, COLD SPRINGS PARK BUPA Care Home APPROVED grassed area. RESIDENTIAL CARE HOME, COLD SPRINGS PARK, PENRITH

15/0224 Tree Works (CA) Ravenstonedale T1 Beech: Crown raise to 3m over road, minor 15% THE CHANTRY, Mrs Houston APPROVED crown reduction and 15% crown thin; RAVENSTONEDALE, KIRKBY Ravenstonedale Conservation Area. STEPHEN

15/0225 Full Application Lowther Replacement of existing chicken rearing shed. MELKINTHORPE POULTRY FARM, Performance Pullets Ltd APPROVED MELKINTHORPE, PENRITH

15/0226 Tree Works (CA) Alston T1 Remove Cherry tree; T2 Crown lift Cherry tree to GARDEN HOUSE, THE BUTTS, Mrs Susan Condon APPROVED 5.2m over road; Alston Conservation Area. ALSTON

15/0227 Tree Works Kirkby Stephen Remove Ash tree (due to condition of tree) from 41 BIRKBECK GARDENS, KIRKBY Mr Bainbridge REFUSED (TPO) Group 1 of Tree Preservation Order No 169, 2015, STEPHEN Birkbeck Gardens, Kirkby Stephen.

15 May 2015 Page 6 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0230 Full Application Skelton Erection of single storey bungalow. ESTHER CROFT, BRAISGATE, Mr & Mrs J Wilson APPROVED SKELTON, PENRITH

15/0233 Full Application Kaber Extension to dwelling. HEGGERSCALE FARM, Mr & Mrs M Slack APPROVED HEGGERSCALES LANE, KABER, KIRKBY STEPHEN

15/0236 Tree Works (CA) Langwathby T1 Lime - Crown raise to 3m by removal of two ORCHARD HOUSE, EDENHALL, Mrs Gowling APPROVED lowest branches, epicormic shoots and shortening PENRITH back descending branches; T2 Oak - Remove one side branch from large lowest branch towards house and also remove third branch up on the field side; Edenhall Conservation Area.

15/0237 Full Application Bolton Erection of a rear sun lounge extension. KIDSTY VIEW, BOLTON, APPLEBY- Mrs D Gainey APPROVED IN-WESTMORLAND

15/0239 Full Application Ravenstonedale Rebuilding of storage shed on same footprint. SHED ADJ TO HIGH LANE, Mr T A Law APPROVED NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE, KIRKBY STEPHEN

15/0241 Notice of Intention Kirkoswald Proposed erection of an agricultural building. SCALE RIGG COTTAGE, RENWICK, Mr J Kirkby APPROVED PENRITH

15/0244 Full Application Penrith Proposed side extension. 11 PARK CLOSE, PENRITH Mr M Whitfield APPROVED

15/0247 Householder Shap Single storey rear extension. 8 CHURCH STREET, SHAP, Miss E Carruthers APPROVED PD/PN PENRITH

15/0251 Full Application Crosby Proposed erection of a silage/straw building. WYEBOURNE, REAGILL, PENRITH Messrs TG & TA Harris APPROVED Ravensworth

15/0253 Tree Works (CA) Penrith Fell Silver Birch tree which is blocking the access 97 LOWTHER STREET, PENRITH Mr G Rae APPROVED footpath and has roots undermining the path; Penrith New Streets Conservation Area.

15/0263 Full Application Ravenstonedale Proposed replacement windows, re-roofing and METHODIST CHURCH, MAIN Mr G Boustead APPROVED minor external alterations to Methodist Church. STREET, NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE, KIRKBY STEPHEN

15/0264 Full Application Skelton Proposed first floor extension to dwelling. 3 INGLEWOOD COURT, HUTTON Mr P Sorton APPROVED END, PENRITH

15/0283 Notice of Intention Newbiggin Prior notification for the erection of a steel frame BLACK LEASES FARM, KIRKBY Mr T Robinson-Messrs APPROVED building with fibre cement roof over an existing THORE, PENRITH J C Robinson concrete yard used for handling of livestock.

15 May 2015 Page 7 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

15/0284 Non-Material Ainstable Non material amendment for planning approval WYN SHIELS, AINSTABLE, Mr J P Hardon APPROVED Amend 13/0585 comprising insertion of door to side of CARLISLE garage, alteration to size of 2 no. porch windows, change of window colour from white to anthracite grey, addition of extended overface with gable ladder to the following front porch and rear sunroom, change of guttering & fascia colour from light grey to dark grey/black.

15/0289 Tree Works (CA) Appleby Fell Norway Spruce in Appleby Conservation Area. GRAPES INN, THE SANDS, Marstons Brewery APPROVED APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND

15/0291 Non-Material Ravenstonedale Non-material amendment to planning approval HWITH, RAVENSTONEDALE, Mr & Mrs Windle APPROVED Amend 13/0376 comprising of an amendment to increase KIRKBY STEPHEN the length of the two storey extension by 1.5 metres to the rear garden frontage gable elevation.

15/0292 Non-Material Sockbridge & Non material amendment to planning approval BLACK SHEEP BARN, TIRRIL, Brier Associates - D APPROVED Amend Tirril 14/0349 comprising the retrospective installation of a PENRITH Brier sewage treatment plant.

15/0306 Tree Works (CA) Penrith T3 Cypress - Crown raise to 1m above height of HAMELN HOUSE, LOWTHER Mr G Sowerby APPROVED street lamp; T4 Yew - Tidy up past pruning and STREET, PENRITH remove shoots from main stem; T5 Lime - Remove lowest branches that have been previously reduced to height shown by yellow line in photograph; Penrith New Streets Conservation Area.

15/0311 Tree Works (CA) Great Salkeld T1: Prune to clear overhead lines, clear epicormic WILLOW GARTH, GREEN LANE, Mr P Carrington APPROVED shoots from stem and crown raise to clear road; T2: GREAT SALKELD, PENRITH Shape Cypress around telegraph pole and to clear overhead line (garden of High Berries); Great Salkeld Conservation Area.

15/0313 Tree Works (CA) Appleby Fell 2 x Japanese Maples; Appleby Conservation FAIRHOLME, BONGATE, APPLEBY- Mrs Nicola Elliott APPROVED Area. IN-WESTMORLAND

15/0333 Non-Material Hesket Non material amendment to planning approval PLOT 15 COOPERS CLOSE, HIGH Mr R McManus APPROVED Amend 13/0725 comprising of addition of interal garage and HESKET, CARLISLE white spar dashed panels.

15/0334 Non-Material Shap Non material amendment to planning approval 9 BRACKENBER LODGE, SHAP, Miss L Evans APPROVED Amend 14/0872 comprising the replacement of non-original PENRITH bow window with 3 no. sliding sash windows and intermediate stone mullions.

15/0336 Tree Works (CA) Appleby Various tree pruning works as detailed in Schedule; APPLEBY CASTLE, Mrs Nightingale APPROVED Appleby Conservation Area. BOROUGHGATE, APPLEBY-IN- WESTMORLAND

15 May 2015 Page 8 of 9 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

In relation to each application it was considered whether the proposal was appropriate having regard to the Development Plan, the representations which were received including those from consultees and all other material considerations. In cases where the application was approved the proposal was considered to be acceptable in planning terms having regard to the material considerations. In cases where the application was refused the proposal was not considered to be acceptable having regard to the material and relevant considerations. In all cases it was considered whether the application should be approved or refused and what conditions, if any, should be imposed to secure an acceptable form of development.

15 May 2015 Page 9 of 9