International Human Rights

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

International Human Rights HUMAN RIGHTS, LGBT MOVEMENTS AND IDENTITY: AN ANALYSIS OF INTERNATIONAL AND SOUTH AFRICAN LGBT WEBSITES A thesis presented to the faculty of the Center for International Studies of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Masters of International Affairs Laura Mack June 2005 This thesis entitled HUMAN RIGHTS, LGBT MOVEMENTS AND IDENTITY: AN ANALYSIS OF INTERNATIONAL AND SOUTH AFRICAN LGBT WEBSITES BY LAURA MACK has been approved for the Department of International Development Studies and the Center for International Studies by Ann Tickamyer Professor of Sociology and Director, International Development Studies Josep Rota Director, Center for International Studies MACK, LAURA. M.A. June 2005. International Development Studies Human Rights, LGBT Movements, and Identity: An Analysis of International and South African LGBT Websites (109 pp.) Thesis Director: Ann Tickamyer This thesis examines human rights, the international and South African lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) movements, and their organizations, exploring how they articulate human rights, sexuality and identity. The literature review includes the different perspectives on human rights philosophy and the LGBT movements, their influences and philosophical underpinnings. Issues of identity, continuity in the movements, and conceptualizations of rights are also explored. Organization’s websites, from both the international and South African movements, are analyzed using a post- structural textual analysis methodology to see how these organizations represent themselves and articulate human rights and homosexuality. Through this research, it is clear that both sets of organizations view human rights as universal and homosexuality as natural, but there are variations in the types of rights emphasized and the way homosexuality is represented and articulated. Though both groups of organizations collaborate and interact, they are distinct movements with unique approaches to LGBT rights. Approved: Ann Tickamyer Professor of Sociology and Director, International Development Studies 4 Table of Contents Abstract................................................................................................................................3 List of Tables .......................................................................................................................5 Acronyms.............................................................................................................................6 Chapter 1: International Human Rights ...............................................................................7 Universalism ............................................................................................................8 Cultural Relativism................................................................................................12 Socialist..................................................................................................................16 Imperialists ............................................................................................................18 The Paradigms and Sexual Orientation as a Human Right....................................20 Conclusion .............................................................................................................22 Chapter 2: International LGBT Movement........................................................................24 History of the International Movement..................................................................27 Analysis of the International Movement’s Focus and Assumptions .....................32 Critique of the International Gay and Lesbian Movement ....................................35 Conclusion .............................................................................................................41 Chapter 3: South African Gay and Lesbian Movement.....................................................43 History of the South African Movement ...............................................................46 Analysis of the Movement.....................................................................................55 Opposition and Critiques.......................................................................................58 Conclusion .............................................................................................................63 Chapter 4: Research Topic and Methodology ...................................................................65 Significance............................................................................................................67 Methodological Legitimacy...................................................................................68 The Sample ............................................................................................................70 Approaching the Quantitative Analysis..................................................................73 Approaching the Qualitative Analysis ..................................................................75 Chapter 5: Observations, Findings, and Conclusion .........................................................78 Quantitative Results...............................................................................................79 Qualitative Results.................................................................................................83 Similarities......................................................................................................83 Differences......................................................................................................89 Findings and Conclusion .......................................................................................98 Further Study.......................................................................................................104 Bibliography ....................................................................................................................105 5 List of Figures Figure 1: Content Analysis Table ......................................................................................80 Figure 2: Durban Lesbian and Gay Community and Health Center’s Logo ...................103 6 Acronyms African National Congress.................................................................... ANC Association of Bisexuals, Gays, and Lesbians.............................ABIGALE Azanian Peoples’ Organization........................................................ AZAPO British Broadcasting Corporation ..........................................................BBC Gay Association of South Africa ........................................................GASA Gay Identification Development and Enrichment ............................ GAIDE Gays and lesbians of the Witsatersrand .............................................GLOW Human Immunodeficiency Virus/ Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome......................................HIV/AIDS International Covenant of Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights..ICESCR International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission...........IGLHRC International Lesbian and Gay Association .........................................ILGA Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender ................................................. LGBT Lesbians and Gays Against Oppression ............................................ LAGO National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality............................ NCGLE Nongovernmental Organization............................................................NGO North American Man Boy Love Association .............................. NAMBLA Organization for Lesbian and Gay Action......................................... OLGA Organization of African Unity..............................................................OAU United Democratic Front .......................................................................UDF United Nations .........................................................................................UN United Nations Economic and Social Council...............................ECOSOC Universal Declaration of Human Rights ........................................... UDHR 7 Chapter 1 International Human Rights Although the concept of human rights is internationally known and debated, it is hardly an issue with a standard understanding or universally accepted definition. Even though under the United Nations there are many international treaties and declarations which define and describe human rights, and many nation-states throughout the world are signatories to these instruments, the topic of human rights is one with differing ideologies, debates, and disagreements. The first of these instruments, created in 1948, was the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), and although this instrument is only a declaration and not legally binding, it serves as a foundation for other subsequent human rights conventions, resolutions, etc. However, issues including whether human rights are universal, indivisible, individualistic, applicable to groups and not just individuals, of Western origin, compatible with non-Western values, culturally specific, or not applicable to all cultures are debated and hotly contested by both scholars and politicians alike. Human rights as a concept and as a discourse is internationally known, but different philosophical approaches to human rights have emerged. Through all of these differing understandings, sexual orientation and gender identity as human
Recommended publications
  • LGBT Terminology 2011
    LGBT Terminology & Cultural Information Orientation Related Terms Sexual Orientation - The internal experience that determines whether we are physically and emotionally attracted to men, to women, to both, or neither (asexual). Biphobia - Fear and intolerance of bisexual people. Bisexual/Bisexuality/Bi - A person who feels love, affection, and sexual attraction regardless of gender. Down-low - slang term that refers to men who have sex with men (MSM) but are either closeted or do not identify as gay. Most often associated with and has its origins in African American culture in the US Gay Man/Homosexual - A man who feels love, affection, and sexual attraction toward men. Heterosexism - Institutional policies and interpersonal actions that assume heterosexuality is normative and ignores other orientations. The belief that heterosexuality is superior to other orientations. Heterosexual/Heterosexuality/Straight - A person who feels love, affection, and sexual attraction to persons of a different gender. Homophobia - Fear and intolerance of homosexual people and/or of same sex attraction or behavior in the self or others. Lesbian/Homosexual - A woman who feels love, affection and sexual attraction toward women. Men who have Sex with Men (MSM) - or Males who have sex with Males (MSM) a clinical term that refers to men who engage in sexual activity with other men, whether they identify as gay, bisexual, or neither Omnisexual/pansexual: a person who feels love, affection and sexual attraction regardless of their gender identity or biological sex. Thus, pansexuality includes potential attraction to people (such as transgender individuals) who do not fit into the gender binary of male/female. Pomosexual: describe a person who avoids sexual orientation labels (not the same as asexual) Same gender loving (SGL) - coined for African American use by Cleo Manago in the early 1990s.
    [Show full text]
  • Creating a Safe Environment (CASE) for LGBT Iowans Through Public Health Daniel Hoffman-Zinnel, MA, CHES Director of Education A
    Creating a Safe Environment (CASE) for LGBT Iowans through Public Health Daniel Hoffman-Zinnel, MA, CHES Director of Education and Outreach, Planned Parenthood of the Heartland Donna Red Wing, MA Executive Director, One Iowa Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) people face significant health challenges. Many healthcare workers, from receptionists to physicians, are not accepting of or trained to work with LGBT people. The lack of understanding or hostility faced by LGBT patients, contributes to a large disparity in health access. National data show that 29% of LGB adults and 48% of transgender adults delay or avoid medical care compared to 17% of heterosexual adults. LGBT people seeking healthcare encounter medical forms that don’t acknowledge their gender identity, concerns that their gender identity or sexual orientation will not be held in confidence, and no idea if the healthcare provider and staff will treat them with respect and dignity if they disclose their sexual orientation. This presentation will provide best practices in working LGBT Iowans and offer strategies to create a safe zone designation. Reexamining LGBT Healthcare WELCOMING LESBIAN, GAY, BISEXUAL AND TRANSGENDER (LGBT) INDIVIDUALS INTO HEALTHCARE Goals Define LGBT identities and issues Examine the particular hurdles and challenges that LGBT people face in accessing health care Provide simple steps you can take to remove barriers to care Answer questions, provoke discussion This material may be new or review for you Moving beyond “I treat all people the
    [Show full text]
  • LGBTQA by Mrfanrainbow Contents
    LGBTQA By Mrfanrainbow Contents 1 History 1 1.1 LGBT history ............................................. 1 1.1.1 Ancient history ........................................ 1 1.1.2 The Middle Ages ....................................... 5 1.1.3 The Renaissance ....................................... 6 1.1.4 Europe ............................................ 7 1.1.5 United States of America ................................... 8 1.1.6 Historical study of homosexuality ............................... 14 1.1.7 See also ............................................ 14 1.1.8 Notes ............................................. 15 1.1.9 References .......................................... 17 1.1.10 Further reading ........................................ 18 1.1.11 External links ......................................... 18 1.2 LGBT community ........................................... 18 1.2.1 Symbols ............................................ 19 1.2.2 Human and legal rights .................................... 19 1.2.3 Media ............................................. 20 1.2.4 Buying power ......................................... 20 1.2.5 Health ............................................. 22 1.2.6 LGBT multiculturalism .................................... 22 1.2.7 See also ............................................ 24 1.2.8 References .......................................... 24 1.2.9 Further reading ........................................ 25 2 Your Sexuality 26 2.1 Coming out .............................................. 26 2.1.1
    [Show full text]
  • PRIDE FLAG GUIDE a Resource Developed by the Edmonton Federation of Community Leagues
    PRIDE FLAG GUIDE A Resource Developed by the Edmonton Federation of Community Leagues Rainbow Pride Flag This flag has come to represent the whole of the LGBTQ+ community. However when it was first created it was only for gay men and lesbians and featured more stripes of different colors. As time went on and demand increased, the flag was altered to accommodate the production, leading to the current one. The flag now represents all those who are apart of the LGBTQ+ Community Bisexual Pride Flag This flag represents bisexual people. The creators explanation of the colors is that the pink represents sexual attraction to the same sex, the blue represents sexual attraction to the opposite sex and the resultant overlap color purple represents sexual attraction to both sexes, which is bisexual Lesbian Pride Flag This flag is different than others as there is no agreed upon design for the lesbian pride flag, Different flags have been designed for different subsets which has created issues. This flag was created in collaborative attempt with the lesbian community to create a flag that represents all lesbians, not just one single subset. Page 1 PRIDE FLAG GUIDE A Resource Developed by the Edmonton Federation of Community Leagues Transgender Pride Flag The creator of the flag, trans woman Monica Helms explains that the stripes at the top and bottom are light blue, representing the traditional color for boys. The stripes next are pink, the traditional color for girls. The stripe in the middle is white, for those who are transitioning or consider themselves having a neutral or undefined gender.
    [Show full text]
  • LGBT ABUSE in LATER LIFE with Kathy Flores Statewide LGBTQ Anti‐Violence Manager, Diverse & Resilient
    6/26/2018 LGBT ABUSE IN LATER LIFE with Kathy Flores Statewide LGBTQ Anti‐Violence Manager, Diverse & Resilient Hosted by: End Domestic Abuse Wisconsin In Partnership with: Department of Children and Families Sharon Lewandowski Domestic Abuse Program Coordinator Who is Diverse & Resilient? Our mission is to achieve health equity and improve the safety and well‐being of LGBTQ people and communities in Wisconsin. 1 6/26/2018 Our work • Centering our LGBTQ work on LGBTQ People of Color. • Addressing and acknowledging systems of oppression tied into race, poverty, disability. • “If you center LGBTQ work around People of Color, you will automatically serve all people well because we already know how to serve the white LGBTQ community. We figured that out long ago because everything has been centered on whiteness.” ‐Sebastian Margaret: Gender nonconforming queer, anti ‐ ableism/ disability community educator and capacity builder. What the Room to Be Safe Resource Line Provides: • LGBTQ Support via Phone • CONTACT INFORMATION: • Safety Planning • (414) 856‐LGBT (5428) • www.roomtobesafe.org • Co‐Advocacy with Programs • Resources • Referral 2 6/26/2018 Brief Reminder of Understanding Sexual Orientation A person’s physical, romantic, and/or emotional attraction to others Lesbian Gay People, typically men, Bisexual A woman whose whose primary A person whose primary attraction attraction is to attraction is to more is to other women. members of the same than one sex or gender. sex. Queer A term that can be used to Straight describe gender and sexual People whose primary identities, claim a unique attraction is to members of identity, or to describe the a different sex or gender.
    [Show full text]
  • Pride Flag Guide
    Pride Flag Guide Created by the Edmonton Federation of Community Leagues Lesbian Pride Flag This flag is different than others as there is no Intersex Pride Flag agreed upon design for the lesbian pride flag, Created in 2013 by Intersex Human Rights Australia, Different flags have been designed for the flag was designed intentionally not to be different subsets which has created issues. This derivative and to represent wholeness. To quote the flag was created in collaborative attempt with organization about the circle, it is meant to represent the lesbian community to create a flag that "unbroken and unornamented, symbolizing wholeness represents all lesbians, not just one single and completeness, and our potentialities". It also subset. represents the future and potential of the intersex community. Rainbow Pride Flag References: This flag has come to represent the "Community Lesbian Pride Flag.” Pride Nation, whole of the LGBTQ+ community. pridenation.lgbt/collections/lgbtq-pride- flag/products/community-lesbian-pride-flag. However when it was first created it was only for gay men and lesbians and “Intersex Flag.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 4 June 2019, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex_flag. featured more stripes of different colors. As time went on and demand “LGBT Symbols.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 11 July increased, the flag was altered to 2019, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_symbols. accommodate the production, leading Bisexual Pride Flag “Non-Binary Gender.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia to the current one. The flag now Foundation, 2 July This flag represents bisexual people. The 2019, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non- represents all those who are apart of creators explanation of the colors is that the binary_gender#Symbols_and_observances.
    [Show full text]
  • Download This Guide, Visit Lgbtagingcenter.Org
    Strengthen Your State and Local Aging Plan A Practical Guide for Expanding the Inclusion of LGBT Older Adults National Resource Center ON LGBT AGING CONTENTS Introduction 4 Framing the Issue 7 Including LGBT Stakeholders in Planning 10 Assessing Community Needs 12 LGBT-Inclusive Planning Goals and Objectives 16 Measuring Success of LGBT Inclusive Efforts 21 Best Practices Checklist 24 Conclusion 25 Glossary 26 The National Resource Center on LGBT Aging is the country’s first Services and Advocacy for GLBT Elders (SAGE) is the country’s and only technical assistance resource center aimed at improving the largest and oldest organization dedicated to improving the lives of quality of services and supports offered to lesbian, gay, bisexual and/ lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) older adults. Founded or transgender older adults. Established in 2010 through a federal in 1978 and headquartered in New York City, SAGE is a national grant from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, the organization that offers supportive services and consumer resources National Resource Center on LGBT Aging provides training, technical to LGBT older adults and their caregivers, advocates for public policy assistance and educational resources to aging providers, LGBT changes that address the needs of LGBT older people, provides organizations and LGBT older adults. The center is led by Services & education and technical assistance for aging providers and LGBT Advocacy for GLBT Elders (SAGE) in collaboration with 18 leading organizations through its National Resource Center on LGBT Aging organizations from around the country: the American Society on and cultural competence training through SAGECare.
    [Show full text]
  • LGBT Terminology & Cultural Information
    LGBT Terminology & Cultural Information Orientation Related Terms Sexual Orientation - The internal experience that determines whether we are physically and emotionally attracted to men, to women, to both, or neither (asexual). Biphobia - Fear and intolerance of bisexual people. Bisexual/Bisexuality/Bi - A person who feels love, affection, and sexual attraction regardless of gender. Down-low - slang term that refers to men who have sex with men (MSM) but are either closeted or do not identify as gay. Most often associated with and has its origins in African American culture in the US Gay Man/Homosexual - A man who feels love, affection, and sexual attraction toward men. Heterosexism - Institutional policies and interpersonal actions that assume heterosexuality is normative and ignores other orientations. The belief that heterosexuality is superior to other orientations. Heterosexual/Heterosexuality/Straight - A person who feels love, affection, and sexual attraction to persons of a different gender. Homophobia - Fear and intolerance of homosexual people and/or of same sex attraction or behavior in the self or others. Lesbian/Homosexual - A woman who feels love, affection and sexual attraction toward women. Men who have Sex with Men (MSM) - or Males who have sex with Males (MSM) a clinical term that refers to men who engage in sexual activity with other men, whether they identify as gay, bisexual, or neither Omnisexual/pansexual: a person who feels love, affection and sexual attraction regardless of their gender identity or biological sex. Thus, pansexuality includes potential attraction to people (such as transgender individuals) who do not fit into the gender binary of male/female. Same gender loving (SGL) - coined for African American use by Cleo Manago in the early 1990s.
    [Show full text]
  • The Face of Hatred. Crimes and Incidents Motivated by Homophobia and Transphobia in Ukraine in 2014-2017
    LGBT Human Rights Nash Mir Center THE FACE OF HATRED Crimes and incidents motivated by homophobia and transphobia in Ukraine in 2014-2017 Kyiv 2018 УДК 343.4+316.647.82]-055.3(477) ББК 87.7(4Укр) О-17 The Face of Hatred. Crimes and incidents motivated by homophobia and transphobia in Ukraine in 2014-2017. The second edition, corrected and enlarged. / Nash Mir Center, Kyiv, 2018 – 64 pages. Editor Andrii Kravchuk. The report was prepared by: Andrii Kravchuk, Oleksandr Zinchenkov, Sofiya Lapina (Nash Mir Center); Ihor Koblikov, lawyer; and Serhii Kravtsov, PhD in Sociology. The authors express their gratitude to LGBT organizations and individual activists as well as all active participants of e-mail lists and Facebook groups who collect and exchange up-to-date information on various aspects of the LGBT situation in Ukraine. We also thank J. Stephen Hunt (Chicago, IL) for proofreading the English translation and making other contributions to this publication. This report was prepared according to results obtaining through monitoring and human rights defending activities by Nash Mir Center. In 2017 it was supported by the British Embassy in Ukraine, Tides Foundation (USA), the Human Rights Fund of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands, the State Department of the USA, and the Canada Fund for Local Initiatives (the Embassy of Canada in Ukraine). Opinions expressed by the report’s authors are solely theirs, and should not be considered as the official position of any of the donors to Nash Mir Center. Nash Mir Center thanks all those who participated in monitoring of discrimination and violence against LGBT people in Ukraine and in the drafting of this report.
    [Show full text]
  • Ukraine Sociological E
    Study on Homophobia, Transphobia and Discrimination on Grounds of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Sociological Report: Ukraine Disclaimer : This report was drafted by independent consultants and is published for information purposes only. Any views or opinions expressed in the report are those of the authors and do not represent or engage the Council of Europe or the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights. Table of Contents A. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3 B. DATA COLLECTION 3 C. FINDINGS 5 C.1. Public opinion and attitudes towards LGBT people 5 C.2. Freedom of assembly and association 7 C.3. Freedom of expression 11 C.4. Hate crime - hate speech 13 C.5. Family issues 17 C.6. Asylum and refugee issues 19 C.7. Social security, social care and insurance 20 C.8. Education 21 C.9. Employment 22 C.10. Housing 23 C.11. Health care 23 C.12. Access to goods and services 25 C.13. Media 25 C.14. Transgender issues 25 C.15. Other areas of concern 28 C.16. Data availability 28 A. Executive summary 1. The general attitudes towards LGBT persons in Ukraine are reported to be strongly negative. This negativity is often explained by the fact that being a homosexual is against Ukrainian moral standards and principles and therefore completely unacceptable. The church is also playing an important role, as the Ukrainian society is very religious and the views and opinions of the different churches are influential for a large segment of the population. 2. The cases of discrimination, reported by the Ukrainian LGBT NGOs, are mostly relating to the violations of the freedom as assembly, freedom of speech and discrimination at the workplace and in the education sphere.
    [Show full text]
  • Shelter Response to Intimate Partner Violence in the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Community
    St. Catherine University SOPHIA Master of Social Work Clinical Research Papers School of Social Work 5-2016 Shelter Response to Intimate Partner Violence in the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Community Raelene Carlson St. Catherine University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://sophia.stkate.edu/msw_papers Part of the Social Work Commons Recommended Citation Carlson, Raelene. (2016). Shelter Response to Intimate Partner Violence in the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Community. Retrieved from Sophia, the St. Catherine University repository website: https://sophia.stkate.edu/msw_papers/563 This Clinical research paper is brought to you for free and open access by the School of Social Work at SOPHIA. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master of Social Work Clinical Research Papers by an authorized administrator of SOPHIA. For more information, please contact [email protected]. RUNNING HEAD: Intimate Partner Violence Shelter Response i Shelter Response to Intimate Partner Violence in the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Community by Raelene D. Carlson, B.A. MSW Clinical Research Paper Presented to the Faculty of the School of Social Work St. Catherine University and the University of St. Thomas St. Paul, Minnesota In Partial fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Social Work Committee Members Mike Chovanec Ph.D., LICSW (Chair) Kacie Ervasti, MSW, LGSW Eva Wood, J.D., Anti-Violence Program Director The Clinical Research Project is a graduation requirement for MSW students at the University of St. Thomas/St. Catherine University in St. Paul, Minnesota and is conducted within a nine-month time frame to demonstrate facility with basic social work research methods.
    [Show full text]
  • Supporting Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, & Transgender
    Supporting Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, & Transgender Inclusivity in Long-Term Care Homes: A Canadian Perspective Tamara Sussman,1 Shari Brotman,1 Heather MacIntosh,1 Line Chamberland,2 Judith MacDonnell,3 Andrea Daley,4 Jean Dumas,5 and Molly Churchill1 RÉSUMÉ Il est indispensable que les foyers de soins de longue durée (FSLD) soient sensibilisés aux besoins des aîné(e)s lesbiennes, gays, bisexuels et transgenres. Considérant que le degré d’intégration de stratégies recommandées en ce sens dans le secteur des FSLD est inconnu, cette étude qualitative canadienne vise à présenter les résultats de deux initiatives principales ciblant cette lacune : des entrevues semi-structurées téléphoniques ont ainsi été menées avec des administrateurs de FSLD au Canada concernant les stratégies adoptées pour appuyer l’inclusion des personnes LGBT (n=32) et une rencontre de deux jours organisée sur la thématique de l’inclusivité des personnes LGBT dans les FSLD (n=25) a été organisée, le contenu des discussions de cette rencontre ayant été analysé dans la présente étude. Nos résultats révèlent que la formation concernant l’inclusivité LGBT était la stratégie la plus fréquemment adoptée dans les FSLD participant à l’étude. Ils montrent aussi que les pratiques plus visibles pour les résidents et les familles, telles que les programmations thématiques, l’utilisation d’un vocabulaire ou de symboles LGBT ou les initiatives conjointes avec les communautés LGBT étaient moins fréquentes, étant donné l’anticipation de réactions négatives de la part des résidents ou de leur famille. L’importance et les avantages de stratégies intégrées incluant le personnel, les résidents et les familles sont discutés.
    [Show full text]