Miriam, Aaron and Moses: Sibling Rivalry

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Miriam, Aaron and Moses: Sibling Rivalry CHAPTER 17 Miriam, Aaron and Moses: Sibling Rivalry According to Numbers 26: 57–59, Miriam and Aaron are the siblings of Moses. In the pericope studied here (Num 11:35–12:16) Moses is challenged by Miriam and Aaron both with regard to his marital choice and to his superior prophetic status. The present article attempts to explicate some of the philological and thematic difficulties in the text. In the light of the archaeological data currently available, which demonstrate that none of the narrative of the Torah is historical, the study suggests that Num 11:35–12:16 is addressed to a Jewish audience of the Achaemenid Persian period; a period in which a written Torah, an innovation, was in competi- tion with oral prophecy, an older traditional form of divine revelation. By compos- ing a tale in which YHWH himself affirmed the superiority of his communications to Moses over his communications to other prophets, the author of the pericope was, in fact, claiming that Scripture, which contained the divine word in its clear- est form, was far more reliable than prophecy orally delivered. The Pentateuch portrays Moses (and God) as regularly beset by opposi- tion. This is especially true with regard to the Book of Numbers chapters 11–21, 25.1 In the pericope studied in this paper Moses is challenged by Miriam and Aaron, who, according to the earliest level of the tradition (Micah 6:4) are his co-leaders in the exodus from Egypt, and his siblings according to Num 26:57–59. The present study attempts to explicate some of the philological and thematic difficulties present in the text, and to clarify some of the theological and ideological concerns of its author, and of the ancient audience. Before pro- ceeding further I wish to clarify the general approach to the narratives of the Torah that will be taken in this study.2 It is no exaggeration to say that the Arab-Israeli Six-Day War (1967), and later the peace treaty between Israel and Jordan, had a revolutionary effect on the direction of biblical studies. For the previous thirty to forty years much of 1 See G. Coats, Rebellion in the Wilderness (Nashville: Abingdon, 1968). Coats (261–264) deals with the pericope studied here in an appendix because he considers it not to be part of the murmuring tradition. 2 An earlier version of this article was presented on June 12, 2000 as a Hebrew lecture to a sym- posium sponsored by the Department of Bible at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. It is my pleasant duty to thank Dr. Israel Knohl and Professor Alexander Rofé for their invitation to the symposium, and the attendees for their extremely helpful comments. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���7 | doi ��.��63/9789004340879_0�8 Miriam, Aaron And Moses: Sibling Rivalry 211 biblical scholarship had been heavily influenced by the “biblical archaeology”3 school associated in the main with such American scholars as William Foxwell Albright,4 and his disciples G. Ernest Wright,5 John Bright,6 David Noel Freedman7 and Frank Cross.8 To a lesser extent we should include Ephraim Α. Speiser whose studies on the patriarchal period, and especially his commen- tary on Genesis,9 continue to influence contemporary scholarship.10 These scholars, to whose names we may add that of Benjamin Mazar11 (Maisler)12 3 For a more detailed treatment of the rise and subsequent decline of the “Biblical Archaeology” school see S. David Sperling, The Original Torah: The Political Intent of the Bible’s Writers (NewYork: New York University, 1998), 17–25 and the literature cited there. 4 For Albright’s vast bibliography see D. N. Freedman in The Bible and the Ancient Near East Essays in Honor of William Foxwell Albright, ed. G. E. Wright (Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor, 1965), 488–524; ErIsr 9 (1969) 1–5; D. N. Freedman, R. MacDonald and D. Matson, The Published Works of William Foxwell Albright: A Comprehensive Bibliography (Cambridge, Mass.: AASOR, 1975); See further, P. Machinist, “William Foxwell Albright: The Man and His Work,” in The Study of the Ancient Near East in the Twenty-First Century. The William Foxwell Albright Centennial Conference, eds. J. Cooper and G. M. Schwartz (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 1996), 385–403; B. Long, Planting and Reaping Albright: Politics, Ideology and Interpreting the Bible (University Park: Pennsylvania State University, 1997). 5 See especially G. Ernest Wright, Biblical Archaeology (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1957). 6 J. Bright, A History of Israel (1st ed.; Philadelphia: Westminster, 1958). Between the late 1950s and the late 1970s Bright’s History in its various editions was probably the most influential work of the school. The book was required reading in virtually any non- fundamentalist seminary or university course on the history of the biblical period. 7 Freedman, not himself an archaeologist, has regularly employed the models and dis- coveries of archaeology in his own work. See especially D. N. Freedman,“Pottery, Poetry, and Prophecy,” JBL 96 (1977), 5–26. The essay is reprinted in D. N. Freedman, Pottery, Poetry and Prophecy (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 1980), 1–22; On Freedman’s method in general see the reviews of D. N. Freedman, Divine Commitment and Human Obligation. Selected Writings of David Noel Freedman (2 vols; [Eerdmans: Grand Rapids, 1997]) by R. E. Friedman in JQR 88 (1998), 259–261; S.David Sperling in HS 39 (1998), 7–13. 8 See e.g., F. M. Cross, Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic: Essays in the History of the Religion of Israel (Cambridge: Harvard University, 1973). For Cross’s bibliography see Erlsr 26 (1999), xiii–xxiv. 9 E. A. Speiser, Genesis, (AB; Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1964). 10 See e.g., G. Rendsburg, The Redaction of Genesis (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 1986); Ν. Sarna, Genesis (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1989); idem, Exodus (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1991). 11 See S. Ahituv, ed., Benjamin Mazar, Biblical Israel: State and People (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1982). 12 Mazar may be accounted a disciple of Albright..
Recommended publications
  • The Lost Women of Iraq: Family-Based Violence During Armed Conflict © Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights and Minority Rights Group International November 2015
    CEASEFIRE centre for civilian rights Miriam Puttick The Lost Women of Iraq: Family-based violence during armed conflict © Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights and Minority Rights Group International November 2015 Cover photo: This report has been produced as part of the Ceasefire project, a multi-year pro- Kurdish women and men protesting gramme supported by the European Union to implement a system of civilian-led against violence against women march in Sulaymaniyah, Iraq, monitoring of human rights abuses in Iraq, focusing in particular on the rights of November 2008. vulnerable civilians including vulnerable women, internally-displaced persons (IDPs), stateless persons, and ethnic or religious minorities, and to assess the feasibility of © Shwan Mohammed/AFP/Getty Images extending civilian-led monitoring to other country situations. This report has been produced with the financial assistance of the European Union. The contents of this report are the sole responsibility of the publishers and can un- der no circumstances be regarded as reflecting the position of the European Union. Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights The Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights is a new initiative to develop ‘civilian-led monitoring’ of violations of international humanitarian law or human rights, to pursue legal and political accountability for those responsible for such violations, and to develop the practice of civilian rights. The Ceasefire Centre for Civilian Rights is registered as a charity and a company limited by guarantee under English law; charity no: 1160083, company no: 9069133. Minority Rights Group International MRG is an NGO working to secure the rights of ethnic, religious and linguistic minorities and indigenous peoples worldwide, and to promote cooperation and understanding between communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Rede Record Brazil's 'Os Dez Mandamentos': You Still Haven't Seen It All
    Rede Record Brazil's 'Os Dez Mandamentos': You Still Haven't Seen It All 04.04.2016 Regarded as the great sensation of Brazilian television, the biblical telenovela Os Dez Mandamentos (The Ten Commandments), returns for a second season, with a warning: you still haven't seen it all. The series, penned by Vivian de Oliveira, will premiere Monday, April 4, at 8:30 p.m. on Rede Record Brazil. The channel - considered Brazil's second-largest producer of original content with a total of more than 90 hours per week - offers programming focused on the Brazilian family. The novela's first season was exported to Argentina, where it aired on Telefe in prime time, becoming the country's most-watched program in its debut, scoring a 14.9 household ratings average. Also, the production has been turned into a film, where it became the second biggest box-office hit in the history of Brazilian cinema. The launch campaign for the show's second season builds on this phenomenon. "The great secret behind the excellent results obtained by The Ten Commandments has been selling the product as a telenovela, and not as a biblical story," says Alexandre Barbosa Machado de Souza, on-air creative promos coordinator for Rede Record. This is why since season one the communication strategy has focused "more on the plot than the biblical aspects, including the romances, the conflicts, the betrayals and the drama that all major soap operas have," Souza says. As for the show's Biblical origins, Marcelo Caetano, programming director of Rede Record, says "we have been producing this type of content since 2010.
    [Show full text]
  • The Life of Moses #25 February 2, 2020
    The Life of Moses #25 February 2, 2020 “The 10 Plagues upon Egypt” Part 5 Exodus 7-12 Introduction: Tonight, we return to the first of the ten plagues which God brought upon Egypt. This plague consisted of the water being turned into blood. This beginning of plagues would have been devastating to the Egyptians. The Nile River was the lifeline which flowed through the land. Let me review the points which we looked at last week. 1. The Reproving before the Plague Notice Exodus 7:14-16 Pharaoh was given fair warning before the plague. We considered this thought before, but I will remind you again that God always brings a warning before His judgment falls. 2. The Revelation in the Plague Notice Exodus 7:17 One of the purposes of all the plagues would be to educate the people of Egypt and Israel about God. 3. The Ruin of the Plague. Notice Exodus 7:19-21 This plague was devasting to the Egyptians. The river waters and the ponds were all turned to blood. It would affect three areas of their lives: 1. Their food supplies. 2. Their environment. 3. Their economy. Egypt was desert country. They depended completely upon the Nile for irrigation as well as soil to put upon their fields. Most of Egypt’s trade and commerce depended upon the Nile River. This plague was a great blow to every area in Egypt. 4. The Reaping of the Plague. This plague of water to blood brought upon Egypt was the reaping of that which they were guilty of in the past.
    [Show full text]
  • 1. the Account of Korah and His Followers Numbers 16:1-40 We Read the Account in Our First Two Lenten Thoughts On… Rebellion Scripture Readings This Morning
    Holy Trinity Lutheran Church centuries ago. And then we will learn lessons Des Moines, WA for our faith and our Christian life as we worship God this Lent. March 3, 2013 1. The account of Korah and his followers Numbers 16:1-40 We read the account in our first two Lenten Thoughts on… Rebellion Scripture readings this morning. Background 1. The account of Korah and his information will be very helpful to us in followers understanding what exactly was happening in that power struggle. Looking back, the 2. Lenten lessons for our faith and life Israelites had left Egypt in a dramatic exodus. Moses had led them through the parted Red Sea and Pharaoh’s army had been dashed to Hymns: 385 – 302 – Distribution: 116, 124 – pieces behind them. Then the community of Closing: 114 (6-7) Israel had journeyed through the wilderness to Mt. Sinai, where they had paused for quite a All Scripture quotations from NIV 1984 while as Moses received the laws of God on the mountain. Then they had traveled northward all the way to the southern border of the Power struggles! They are common in our Promised Land. Spies had been sent to check world today: out Canaan and had returned with a negative • Nations struggle for power. We watch report: “We can’t take this land! The cities are on news channels as nations undergo too fortified and the people are too strong!” riots and depose their governmental Therefore, in Numbers 14 God declared that leaders. due to their lack of faith and their complaint • Our own Congress struggles for power.
    [Show full text]
  • Traditions About Miriam in the Qumran Scrolls
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department Classics and Religious Studies 2003 Traditions about Miriam in the Qumran Scrolls Sidnie White Crawford University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/classicsfacpub Part of the Classics Commons Crawford, Sidnie White, "Traditions about Miriam in the Qumran Scrolls" (2003). Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department. 97. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/classicsfacpub/97 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Classics and Religious Studies at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. Published in STUDIES IN JEWISH CIVILIZATION, VOLUME 14: WOMEN AND JUDAISM, ed. Leonard J. Greenspoon, Ronald A. Simkins, & Jean Axelrad Cahan (Omaha: Creighton University Press, 2003), pp. 33-44. Traditions about Miriam in the Qumran Scrolls Sidnie White Crawford The literature of Second Temple Judaism (late sixth century BCE to 70 CE) contains many compositions that focus on characters and events known from the biblical texts. The characters or events in these new compositions are developed in various ways: filling in gaps in the biblical account, offering explanations for difficult passages, or simply adding details to the lives of biblical personages to make them fuller and more interesting characters. For example, the work known as Joseph andAseneth focuses on the biblical character Aseneth, the Egyptian wife of Joseph, mentioned only briefly in Gen 41:45, 50.' This work attempts to explain, among other things, how Joseph, the righteous son of Jacob, contracted an exogamous marriage with the daughter of an Egyptian priest.
    [Show full text]
  • Moses and Miriam Praise God
    Moses and Miriam Praise God Bible Background • EXODUS 14:1–15:1-21 Printed Text • EXODUS 15:11–21 | Devotional Reading • PSALM 105:1–2, 37–45 Aim for Change By the end of this lesson, we will EXPLORE why and how Moses and Miriam praised God; REFLECT on the actions of God that are celebrated through music, dance, and words; and CELEBRATE God’s faithfulness with joy. In Focus “FIRE DEPARTMENT, CALL OUT!” “Over here!” Ramona cried, coughing. The smoke stung her eyes and was so thick that she couldn’t see where the voice was coming from. The disaster had been sudden. One moment, she was typing away at her desk. The next, there was a quick rumble from the ground that shook the floor and shattered the floor-to-ceiling windows. Part of the ceiling frame fell to the floor, dragging down tiles and light fixtures. Some of the sprinklers came on and drenched everything nearby, but others were broken. The way to the exit stairs was blocked with flaming debris. Ramona prayed, “Heavenly Father, please bring me to safety.” She could hear the firefighters crashing through the wreckage to get to her. “OVER HERE!” she shouted again. Ramona could see the shapes of the firefighters coming forward in the dark, knocking aside desks and chairs and filing cabinets. The water sprayed from their hoses sizzled and turned to steam as it hit the flames, adding to the chaotic scene. But after a moment, two of them emerged like ghosts and crouched next to her. “Praise God! I am so grateful to see you!” Ramona cried.
    [Show full text]
  • Opening the Door for Elijah
    THE OTHER SIDE OF THE SEA: A Haggadah on Fighting Modern-Day Slavery 4RUAH4HE2ABBINIC#ALLFOR(UMAN2IGHTSsWWWTRUAHORG Opening the Door for Elijah Miriam the prophetess is linked with water An early morning conversation in a number of ways. She watched over her with my daughter, Lila Rose, age 3 ½: baby brother Moses in the Nile and sang During my trip to Immokalee, I and danced at the shores of the Reed Sea. heard many stories from workers who described the conditions LR: Why has Elijah not come to Midrash teaches us that when Miriam died, our house, Mama? before and after the Fair Food the magical, portable well that had sustained Program. One in particular ֵאִלָיּהוּ ַהָנִּביא ,Eliyahu ha-navi our people dried up. stands out: “Rosalie” told of an אֵ לִ ָ יּ ה וּ הַ תִּ שְׁבִּי Me: Elijah is going to come when it is time for a new world to come. Eliahu ha-Tishbi, experience of sexual harassment According to tradition, Elijah will bring on a farm by a supervisor. !is ָוּהִיֵּלאְִָידִﬠלַגּה .Eliahu ha-Giladi person showed up at her home Messiah to us and the world will be ִבְּמֵהָרה ְבָיֵמינוּ LR: I think we should give Elijah Bim’hera veyameinu a present when Elijah comes. and threatened her in front of her .redeemed. In my lyrics (below), Miriam children and friends יָבֹא ֵאֵלינוּ ﬠִ ם yavo eleinu im brings us to the waters of redemption. It ָמשַׁיח ֶןבּ ָודִּד. .Me: What should that be? mashiach ben David will then be our task to enter the waters and Because she was working on a farm that participated in the LR: Juice.
    [Show full text]
  • An Analysis of Muslim Women's Rights Based on the Works Of
    An Analysis of Muslim Women’s Rights Based on the Works of Amina Wadud, Fatima Mernissi, and Riffat Hassan The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Stack, Roohi. 2020. An Analysis of Muslim Women’s Rights Based on the Works of Amina Wadud, Fatima Mernissi, and Riffat Hassan. Master's thesis, Harvard Extension School. Citable link https://nrs.harvard.edu/URN-3:HUL.INSTREPOS:37365037 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA An Analysis of Muslim Women’s Rights Based on the Works of Amina Wadud, Fatima Mernissi, and Riffat Hassan Roohi Khan Stack A Thesis in the Field of Religion for the Degree of Master of Liberal Arts in Extension Studies Harvard University May 2020 Copyright 2020 Roohi Khan Stack Abstract This thesis will analyze the arguments, methods, results and contexts of Islamic feminist scholars Amina Wadud, Fatima Mernissi, and Riffat Hassan. These women have been at the forefront of writing about the equal rights of women in Islam. Although each looks at Islam from a different scholarly lens, their work involves trying to elucidate Muslim women’s equality as stated in Islamic religious texts such as the Qur’an and the ahadith, as well as looking at the actions of the Prophet Muhammad and Muslim women in the early Islamic period.
    [Show full text]
  • Participant List
    Participant List 10/20/2019 8:45:44 AM Category First Name Last Name Position Organization Nationality CSO Jillian Abballe UN Advocacy Officer and Anglican Communion United States Head of Office Ramil Abbasov Chariman of the Managing Spektr Socio-Economic Azerbaijan Board Researches and Development Public Union Babak Abbaszadeh President and Chief Toronto Centre for Global Canada Executive Officer Leadership in Financial Supervision Amr Abdallah Director, Gulf Programs Educaiton for Employment - United States EFE HAGAR ABDELRAHM African affairs & SDGs Unit Maat for Peace, Development Egypt AN Manager and Human Rights Abukar Abdi CEO Juba Foundation Kenya Nabil Abdo MENA Senior Policy Oxfam International Lebanon Advisor Mala Abdulaziz Executive director Swift Relief Foundation Nigeria Maryati Abdullah Director/National Publish What You Pay Indonesia Coordinator Indonesia Yussuf Abdullahi Regional Team Lead Pact Kenya Abdulahi Abdulraheem Executive Director Initiative for Sound Education Nigeria Relationship & Health Muttaqa Abdulra'uf Research Fellow International Trade Union Nigeria Confederation (ITUC) Kehinde Abdulsalam Interfaith Minister Strength in Diversity Nigeria Development Centre, Nigeria Kassim Abdulsalam Zonal Coordinator/Field Strength in Diversity Nigeria Executive Development Centre, Nigeria and Farmers Advocacy and Support Initiative in Nig Shahlo Abdunabizoda Director Jahon Tajikistan Shontaye Abegaz Executive Director International Insitute for Human United States Security Subhashini Abeysinghe Research Director Verite
    [Show full text]
  • Miriam and Moses
    TM ® MIRIAM AND MOSES MILY FA LEVEL OF BIBLICAL LEARNING SCRIPTURE: Exodus 1:8–2:10 God’s plan is for children to do WEEKLY VERSE: what their parents tell them to do. Children, obey your parents. Colossians 3:20 LIFE POINT: God wants children to do what their parents tell them to do. THE BIBLE MEETS LIFE Miriam’s family had a new baby boy. Miriam helped her mother take care Parents, today your child learned of the baby. about Miriam and Moses. Miriam helped her mother care for her The king of their country did not want baby boys to live. So Miriam baby brother. Miriam obeyed and her family hid the baby for three months. As the baby grew, Miriam’s when Pharaoh’s daughter told her family had to think of a way to keep the baby safe. to get someone to care for the Miriam’s mother covered a basket with sticky tar. The tar would keep baby. Parents, your duty is to help your children learn to obey. water out of the basket. Miriam’s mother laid the baby in the basket. She placed the basket in the tall grass near the edge of the river. Miriam stayed nearby to watch her baby brother. As the king’s daughter walked beside the river, she saw the basket and LIVE IT OUT Print on paper the word OBEY. the baby. Miriam went to the king’s daughter and asked, “Do you want Read the word and explain what me to get someone to take care of the baby for you?” it means.
    [Show full text]
  • Moses Calls Aaron to the Ministry
    Moses Calls Aaron to the Ministry Exodus 4:10, 14–16, 27; 5:1; 7:9; 8:6–17; 16:1–2; 24:9–10; 28:1; 40:12–16 Thou shalt put upon Aaron the holy garments, and anoint him, and sanctify him; that he may minister unto me in the priest’s office. Exodus 40:13 hen the Lord called Moses to go to Egypt (see Exodus 7:9) and brought plagues upon the Wto free the Israelites, Moses did not feel he Egyptians (see Exodus 8:6–17). could do it. He said he was slow of speech and Aaron was with Moses when he led the was afraid to talk to Pharaoh (see Exodus 4:10). Israelites out of Egypt and into the wilderness The Lord was angry with Moses. He told Moses (see Exodus 16:1–2). He was also with Moses he could take his brother, Aaron, with him to be and 72 other priesthood bearers when the Lord his spokesman. (See Exodus 4:14–16.) The Lord appeared to them (see Exodus 24:9–10). then spoke to Aaron: “Go into the wilderness to meet Moses” (Exodus 4:27). Aaron and Moses Once when Moses was on Mount Sinai, the were happy to be together again. Lord told him to anoint Aaron and Aaron’s sons to serve as priests in the tabernacle (see Exodus The two brothers traveled to Egypt and went 28:1). When the tabernacle was completed, before Pharaoh. Aaron spoke for Moses, try- Moses anointed Aaron and his sons to this call- ing to get Pharaoh to let the children of Israel ing.
    [Show full text]
  • Sarah Miriam Peale's Mary Leypold Griffith and the Staging Of
    Sarah Miriam Peale’s Mary Leypold Griffith and the Staging of Republican Motherhood Sarah Leary In 1841, Sarah Miriam Peale painted a portrait of a longings.1 Unfortunately, Peale’s death mask of Mary Griffith young Mary Leypold Griffith (Figure 1). Mary sits on the floor. doesn’t survive, but it would have looked somewhat like the Her left leg is gracefully crossed over the right. Her vibrant, life mask taken a few months prior to Lincoln’s assassination red dress stands out against the nondescript background. She (Figure 2). Such masks developed from the tradition of death holds a white ribbon that she cuts to form a jagged pattern, masks and offer insight into what Peale’s mask of Mary may and yet looks up from this activity to the viewers. But her have looked like. The Griffith family also lent Peale a minia- mature expression and poise seem incommensurate with her ture of Mary (also lost) to aid in her representation of their age. Without the benefit of the object label, a viewer would daughter. These aids were supposed to help Peale represent assume that Mary is four or five – old enough to wield scissors Mary as she appeared and lived in the days before she died, and to understand the educational materials that surround but Peale took several liberties with Mary’s appearance her. But in point of fact, Mary Griffith died of Scarlet Fever at that aged her beyond her years and introduced books and the age of two and a half in 1841 – the same year in which symbols that allude to the future role Mary never fulfilled.
    [Show full text]