Holiday 2020 NEW YORK CITY HAMPTONS GREENWICH, CT

1 CITARELLA FRESH FROM THE SOURCE SINCE 1912 Table of Contents

4...... Holiday Indulgences 6...... Joe's Feast of Seven Fish As a family run business, we’re driven by a passion for great food and the desire to help fill 8...... Stuffed Calamari Recipe your family table with traditional, handcrafted favorites. Led by owner Joe Gurrera — and his 11...... Holiday Feasts commitment to superior quality — we have grown from a respected NYC seafood shop into 13...... Hanukkah Specialties a gourmet hot-spot with locations across New York City, the Hamptons, and Greenwich, CT. 15...... Hanukkah Selections Each of our 7 gourmet markets offers thoughtfully sourced ingredients and hand crafted dishes. 16...... Christmas Favorites 18...... Christmas Selections Our selection includes an incredible variety of fresh seafood, prime dry-aged meats, fresh 20...... Butcher produce, chef-prepared foods and pastries, international cheeses, cured meats, smoked fish, 23...... Seafood a line of curated Citarella products; and more. Our wine shops in Hudson Yards and 24...... Greenwich, CT boast a dazzling display of fine vintages and artisanal spirits. 26...... Cheese 28...... Catering 30...... Gift Ideas 32...... Wines & Spirits 34...... Preparing Holiday Meals STAY SAFE. SHOP EARLY. AVOID THE LINES. 35...... Shopping List Enjoy our fastest shopping experience yet, pre-order from our curated list of Holiday favorites.

The holidays this year will be a unique time for all. To provide the safest shopping experience for our customers and team, we ask that you consider placing your order in advance from our list of Holiday favorites, noted with a “ ”. Only these items will be available for pre-order and fulfillment on Tuesday, 12/22, Wednesday, 12/23 and Thursday, 12/24.

To allow for social distancing, we will limit the number of shoppers in our markets. Your selections will be freshly packaged for delivery (where available) or waiting for you at the Citarella Curbside Concierge. Pre-orders will be charged the week before Christmas (Citarella.com orders will be charged immediately upon checkout). All other items will be available for in-store shopping during those days. We suggest shopping for grocery and produce items the weekend before the holiday. Please use the shopping list on page 35 to plan ahead.

TO ORDER NEW this year: Shop online at Citarella.com from a collection of our Holiday favorites, 2 email [email protected] with your name, phone number and order details and a team 3 member will get back to you within 48 hours, or call our customer service team at 212.874.0383. Holiday Indulgences

Make the holiday special with these exceptional delicacies.

CAVIAR - $MKT Celebrate with the food of kings! Pair these luxurious pearls with minced egg yolks, whites, and onions atop our delicate Citarella French blinis — then crown your canapé with a dollop of crème fraîche! Citarella Gold Imperial Osetra* • Citarella Osetra • Citarella Siberian Citarella White Sturgeon • Citarella American • Hybrid Beluga Caviar – Limited Exclusive

OYSTERS - $MKT Sweet, succulent, and briny; enjoy our ultra-fresh oysters on the half shell or in one of your favorite dishes. They’re also fantastic in a vodka shooter with a touch of hot sauce — our favorite! For the recipe, check out "Joe Knows Fish," Joe Gurrera's cookbook.

FRESH WHITE TRUFFLES - $MKT We wait all year to enjoy white truffles from Alba, Italy. In season now, they are decadently aromatic with a fantastic taste: truly incomparable. Shave over your favorite dish; a little goes a long way.

FRESH BLACK TRUFFLES - $MKT Savor the intoxicating aroma of these freshly foraged Italian gems. A true culinary prize, shaved black truffle will effortlessly elevate your favorite dish.

FRESH FOIE GRAS - $69 lb For a truly festive meal, sear grade A lobes of fresh duck foie gras, drizzle with Citarella Aged Balsamic Vinegar, and serve over our French blinis.

MOUSSES, PÂTÉS & TERRINES - $MKT Smooth Mousse de Truffe, dense Pâté de Champagne, or mild vegetable terrines — we have stunningly elegant appetizers for every palate!

CELEBRATION OF THE SEA - $MKT Create your own tempting array of seafood with sweet steamed lobsters, Alaskan King Crab Legs, and Stone Crab Claws. Enjoy one or enjoy them all!

SHRIMP COCKTAIL PLATTER - $95/$129** The freshest, large shrimp, steamed and served with tart lemons and tangy cocktail sauce.

MINI CRAB - $3.00 ea*** Generous chunks of crab meat make these individually sized appetizers utterly irresistible. Serve with our housemade tartar sauce for a true treat!

*Special order 4 **We recommend a small platter for 10 to 15 or a large platter for 15 to 20 guests. 5 SIBERIAN CAVIAR ***12 Piece Minimum = Holiday items available for pre-order. Joe's Feast of Seven Fish

"You don't need to be Italian, or even celebrate Christmas, to cook up this feast. You just need to love fish, and lots of it!" —Joe Gurrera

DINNER FOR FOUR − $359 ($90 per person) Gather together this Christmas Eve, or throughout the season, for a spectacular spread of seafood — and make fond memories that will be recalled for years to come!

STARTERS: Wellfleet Oysters with Mignonette Baked Clams Insalata di Mare with Arugula and Lemon

SOUP: Bouillabaisse

PASTA: Clam Sauce with Fresh Linguine (Cook pasta as directed)

ENTRÉE: Stuffed Calamari Steamed Lobsters with Butter Asparagus & Roasted Potatoes

DESSERT: Ricotta Rustica

Wine Pairing: Our Wine & Spirits Director Michael recommends coastal wines from the Mediterranean, particularly from Cassis, Liguria, and Sicily.

= Holiday items available for pre-order. 6 Photo from “Joe Knows Fish,” Citarella’s owner and original fishmonger, 7 Joe Gurrera's debut cookbook. Book available in store and online. INSALATA DI MARE Stuffed Calamari

MAKE YOUR OWN FEAST OF SEVEN FISH RECIPE DIRECTIONS: Serves Four 1. Preheat the oven to 375° F. 2. Heat 1 teaspoon of the oil in a medium sauté pan over medium-high heat. Add the mushrooms and cook for about 3 minutes, or until slightly tender. Set aside in a medium bowl. 3.  Heat another teaspoon of the oil in the pan and sauté the calamari tentacles for 3 minutes. 4. Let the tentacles cool and chop them into 1/2 inch pieces. Add the tentacles to the bowl with the sautéed mushrooms, the breadcrumbs, the remaining 1/2 cup oil, and salt and pepper to taste. Stir to combine. The stuffing mixture should be moist. 5.  Using your fingers, stuff the body of each calamari with the mushroom mixture, being careful not to pack it too tightly. Thread a toothpick through the open end of each calamari to keep it closed. 6. Cover the bottom of an 8 by 10-inch baking dish with 1 cup of the marinara sauce and place the calamari in the dish. Top with the remaining marinara sauce and bake in the preheated oven for 40 minutes. 7. Remove the toothpicks before serving. Sprinkle with chopped chives for if desired.

JOE SAYS: MAKE AHEAD OF TIME This dish reheats well the next day: cover the baking dish with foil and heat the calamari in a 350° F preheated oven for 15 minutes.

INGREDIENTS • 2 teaspoons plus 1 cup extra-­virgin olive oil, divided • 8 small white mushrooms, trimmed, cut into 1/4-inch pieces • 8 (4 1/2 to 6-inch) whole calamari (bodies & tentacles), cleaned • 1 cup seasoned breadcrumbs • Sea Salt and freshly ground pepper to taste • 1 cups Citarella marinara sauce, divided • Chopped chives, for garnish NEW! JOE’S FEAST OF SEVEN FISH RECIPE SUGGESTIONS Crispy Calamari Shrimp Scampi Spaghetti with Crab Sauce JOE’S STUFFED Stuffed Calamari Steamed Lobsters Oven Roasted Little Neck Clams CALAMARI Oyster Shooters Portuguese Sardines Sautéed Nantucket Bay Scallops Fried Shrimp Available for purchase online and in our markets. Just heat and serve!

Watch videos of Joe Gurrera, Citarella’s owner and original 1 LB PACKAGE - $24.99 fishmonger, prepare recipes from “Joe Knows Fish,” his debut 8 cookbook. Book available in store and online. 9 Holiday Feasts

Welcome your friends and family to the table and share in the spirit of holiday warmth and generosity with a delicious, gourmet meal.

PRIME RIB FEAST FOR 4 - CHOOSE ROASTED OR RAW: Roasted Prime Rib Feast Raw Prime Rib Feast $359 ($90 per person) $299 ($75 per person)

PRIME RIB FEAST FOR 8 - CHOOSE ROASTED OR RAW: Roasted Prime Rib Feast Raw Prime Rib Feast $679 ($85 per person) $599 ($75 per person)

EACH INCLUDES: Wild Mushroom Soup Chestnut Stuffing Cornbread Sautéed String Beans Cranberry Conserve Chocolate Pecan Pie Roasted Root Vegetables Baked Stuffed Acorn Squash Apple Crumb (Dinner for 8 only) Potato Purée Demi-Glace

TURKEY DINNER FOR 4 - CHOOSE ROASTED OR RAW: Roasted Free-Range Turkey Breast Dinner Raw Free-Range Turkey Breast Dinner $179 ($45 per person) $159 ($40 per person)

TURKEY DINNER FOR 8 - CHOOSE ROASTED OR RAW: Roasted Free-Range Turkey Dinner Raw Free-Range Turkey Dinner $359 ($45 per person) $319 ($40 per person)

EACH INCLUDES: Pumpkin Bisque Chicken Stock Wild Rice Stuffing Lasagna Bolognese Turkey Gravy Corn Bread Sautéed Brussels Sprouts Glazed Sweet Potatoes Apple Pie Sautéed String Beans Chunky Mashed Potatoes Pumpkin Pie (Dinner for 8 only) Cranberry Conserve Sausage Stuffing (Dinner for 8 only)

THE PRIME RIB 10 ROAST FEAST = Holiday items available for pre-order. 11 Detailed warming and cooking information will be included and are available at Citarella.com/seasonalmenus Sorry, we are not able to accommodate substitutions. Hanukkah Specialties

MAKE YOUR OWN TRADITION Our expert fishmongers are happy to help you select from the freshest and widest variety of seafood around — and provide you with exactly what you need for your special holiday meal. We will happily grind fresh Whitefish, Pike, and Carp for your homemade Gefilte fish. We can even include the onions!

TRADITIONAL GEFILTE FISH - $12.99 lb New York’s Best Gefilte Fish — “just like your grandmother made.” Chef-prepared with freshly ground Whitefish, Pike, and onions. White Horseradish ($3.99 ea) is the perfect complement to this holiday favorite.

POTATO PANCAKES - $8.99 lb Made by hand from fresh potatoes, onions, and eggs, these pancakes are fried until they’re deliciously golden and crisp.

APPLESAUCE - $4.99 pt Homemade applesauce at its best: we carefully select and hand-peel our apples, setting a new standard for this classic. Try our fresh applesauce with our golden-fried potato pancakes!

MATZOH BALL SOUP - $12.99 quart (Extra Matzoh balls - $4.99 for 4) Traditional home-cooked flavor starts with the best ingredients — like our freshly made chicken stock and fluffy, hand-rolled Matzoh balls.

CHOPPED CHICKEN LIVER (8 oz) - $4.99 1/2 pt We combine delicate liver morsels — from our all-natural, free-range chickens — with sautéed onions and seasonings for a classic flavor.

BRAISED PRIME FIRST-CUT BEEF BRISKET - $19.99 lb Our expert butchers carefully hand trim our prime beef to create our First-Cut Beef Brisket, which our Executive Chef then slowly braises for perfect flavor, juiciness, and tenderness. Be sure to order extra brisket gravy.

DECORATED WHOLE POACHED SALMON - 8 lb: $189 / 12 lb - $269 We do the work for you, lightly poaching the whole salmon, removing the skin and bones, but leaving the head and tail on (optional). Decorated with cucumber slices and paired with our creamy dill sauce.

FRESHLY BAKED CHALLAH - $5.99 ea 12 Rolled by hand and baked fresh everyday in our own kitchen, our Challah is a holiday table must-have. 13 Hanukkah Selections

MORE ENTRÉES SALADS Whole Filet Mignon Roast Beet Salad Braised Lamb Shank Cucumber Salad Roasted Turkey Tuna Salad Roasted Turkey Breast Egg Salad POTATO PANCAKES & APPLE SAUCE Stuffed Cornish Hens Chicken Salad Rotisserie Chicken Low-Fat Chicken Salad Baked Salmon Creamy Potato Salad Wild Rice Salad TRADITIONAL ADDITIONS Quinoa & Kale Salad Israeli Couscous Cole Slaw Barley & Mushrooms Noodle Kugel Potato Kugel SIDES Stuffed Cabbage SPECIALTIES Chestnut Stuffing Herring Wild Rice Stuffing (12-oz, in cream, dill or wine sauce) Roasted Potatoes Salmon Caviar Chunky Mashed Potatoes Assorted Smoked Fish Potato Purée (hand-sliced, 3-oz, 4-oz or 16-oz packages) Sweet Potato Purée Fresh Horseradish (white or red) Roasted Root Vegetable Baked Acorn Squash SPREADS & DIPS Grilled Mixed Vegetables Whitefish Spread Beets al Forno Smoked Salmon Spread Poached Asparagus Baked Salmon Spread Sautéed String Beans Artichoke Spread Sautéed Kale Roasted Eggplant Spread Sautéed Brussels Sprouts Roasted Carrot Spread Roasted Corn Sun-Dried Tomato Spread Spinach Dip Tzatziki Dip SOUPS & STOCKS Assorted Hummus Chicken Noodle Soup Mushroom Barley Soup SAUCES & GRAVY Cream of Wild Mushroom Soup Brisket Gravy Pumpkin Bisque Turkey Gravy Sweet Potato & Ginger Bisque Dill Sauce Chicken Stock Demi-Glace Beef Stock Cranberry Conserve with Pecans 14 15 Christmas Favorites

ENTRÉES CHEF-PREPARED WHOLE BEEF WELLINGTON − $225 ea (6-7 lb) Tender, aged prime filet mignon is wrapped with our flavorful Porcini mushroom pâté, ham, and puff pastry. Simply warm in the oven for a traditional favorite made easy.

CITARELLA ROASTED GOOSE − $145 ea ( 12 lb) A time-honored tradition at many Christmas dinners, goose pairs perfectly with our delicious, brandy-infused cranberry conserve with pecans.

CITARELLA ROASTED TURKEYS − $95 ea (12 lb) / $159 ea (18 lb) Let us do the cooking! Our cooked, free-range turkeys are simply seasoned and roasted for the best flavor. Just warm, carve and serve. 12-pound (serves 8) and 18-pound (serves 12) birds are available. Based on raw weight.

FESTIVE HAMS SMOKED BONELESS − $9.99 lb / SMOKED WHOLE − $8.99 lb / SMOKED HALF − $9.99 lb SMOKED SPIRAL CUT WHOLE − $7.99 lb / SMOKED SPIRAL CUT HALF − $8.99 lb / FRESH HAM − $4.99 lb Fill your kitchen with the mouthwatering aroma of savory, slow-roasted ham. Choose from a fine selection to warm and serve - smoked boneless (2-3 lb), smoked bone-in (whole 14-16 lb or half 7-8 lb), or spiral-cut (whole 14-16 lb or half 7-8 lb) with a sweet apricot glaze. If you’d prefer to cook your own we have fresh hams available (9-10 lb or 18-20 lb).

ROASTED WHOLE SUCKLING PIG − $19.99 lb A spectacular presentation for your holiday table! Crispy skin and tender meat — perfect with any of our festive side dishes.

WHOLE AGED PRIME FILET MIGNON − $199 / $299* Tastefully decorated for a beautiful display, our tender, sliced Filet Mignon is served with our own Crème Fraîche Horseradish Sauce.

WHOLE DECORATED POACHED SALMON − $189 (8 lb ) / $269* (12 lb) Perfect served cold or at room temperature, our poached salmon is silky and rich. Decorated with cucumber slices and served with our creamy dill sauce, it is as stunning as it is delicious.

CHEF-PREPARED ENTRÉES Boneless Roast Turkey Breast (3-4 lb − sliced or whole) − $65 ea Rotisserie Chicken (2 lb) − $4.49 lb Prime Beef Filet Roast (4 lb) − $179 ea Rotisserie Duck (2 − 3 lb) − $6.99 lb Roasted Capon (8 lb) − $89 ea Rotisserie Turkey Thighs (3/4 lb) − $6.99 lb Roasted Stuffed Cornish Hens (1 − 1 1/2 lb) − $7.99 lb Turkey Wellington (6 − 7 lb) − $15.99 lb Roasted Turkey Breast (5-7 lb, or 10-12 lb) − $59 / $119 Baked Salmon (approx. 8 oz portions) - $24.99 lb CITARELLA ROASTED TURKEY

16 = Holiday items available for pre-order. 17 *We recommend a small platter for 10 to 15 or a large platter for 15 to 20 guests. Reheating tips are available at citarella.com/reheat. Christmas Selections

STUFFINGS NEW! GLUTEN-FREE STUFFING WITH ORGANIC PORK SAUSAGE − $29.99 (32 oz.) Chef Fedele’s gluten-free take on his original classic stuffing, this holiday favorite is made from organic pork sausage seasoned with fennel seed, our own housemade chicken stock, fresh celery and onions, with artisanal gluten-free croutons.

SAUSAGE STUFFING − $19.99 (32 oz.) CHESTNUT STUFFING − $19.99 (32 oz.) Made from scratch with our freshly baked cornbread, We roast our own chestnuts and bake our own fresh pork sausage, and slowly simmered chicken stock. cornbread for this sweet and savory stuffing.

WILD RICE STUFFING − $19.99 (32 oz.) CORNBREAD − $4.99 (14 oz.) This cornbread stuffing has just the right amount of Our homemade cornbread is freshly baked texture thanks to the addition of hearty wild rice. with plump kernels of corn.

HORS D’OEUVRES SPREADS & DIPS VEGETABLES Crab Cakes (2 pack) Artichoke Spread Baked Stuffed Acorn Squash Fish Cakes Assorted Hummus Beets Al Forno Mushroom Puffs Baked Salmon Spread Butternut Squash with Cranberries Sausage Puffs Black Olive Spread Seafood Puffs Grilled Mixed Vegetables Roasted Carrot Spread Poached Asparagus HEARTY BITES Roasted Eggplant Spread Pomegranate Seeds Sun-Dried Tomato Spread Giuseppe’s Beef Meatballs Roasted Corn Giuseppe’s Chicken Meatballs Spinach Dip Tzatziki Dip Roasted Root Vegetables Turkey Meatballs Sautéed Brussels Sprouts Turkey Pot Pie Chicken Pot Pie SALADS Sautéed Collard Greens Beet Salad Sautéed Kale SOUPS & STOCKS Cucumber Salad Sautéed Onions Chicken Noodle Soup Lobster Salad Sautéed String Beans Cream of Wild Mushroom Soup Quinoa & Kale Salad Stuffed Artichokes Lobster Bisque Wild Rice Salad Mushroom Barley Soup PASTAS Pumpkin Bisque Sweet Potato & Ginger Bisque POTATOES Lasagna Bolognese Chicken Stock Chunky Mashed Potatoes Mac & Cheese Beef Stock Potato Purée Mushroom Ravioli* Roasted Potatoes Pumpkin Ravioli* Pumpkin Tortellini* SAUCES & GRAVY Sweet Potato Praline Risotto with Pumpkin & Mushroom Turkey Gravy Sweet Potato Purée Brisket Gravy Sweet Potato Ravioli* Demi-Glace Glazed Sweet Potatoes Pumpkin Gnocchi Cranberry Conserve with Pecans Dill Sauce

= Holiday items available for pre-order. BAKED STUFFED ACORN SQUASH, 18 See our catering section (page 28) for an assortment of our crowd-pleasing hors d’oeuvres. POACHED ASPARAGUS, CHESNUT STUFFING, 19 *Cook our fresh pasta in boiling water for 4 to 6 minutes or as noted on the package. CRANBERRY CONSERVE WITH PECANS Butcher PRIME RIB ROAST

TURKEY BEEF Citarella Free-Range, All-Natural Turkey (10 − 20 lb) Beef Wellington − Ready-to-Cook ~ Individual (3/4 − 1 lb) Citarella Turkey Breast (4 − 7 / 10 − 12 lb) Cowboy Rib Roast (2 − 7 ribs) Bell & Evans Turkey (10 − 20 lb) Prime Beef Filet Roast (4 lb) Kosher Turkey (10 − 16 / 16 − 20 lb) Standing Prime Beef Rib Roast (2 − 7 ribs) Organic Turkey (10 − 20 lb) Smoked Turkey (10 − 12 / 12 − 14 lb) Wild Turkey (6 − 8 lb) Heirloom Turkey – Limited Quantities Available SPECIAL FOR YOUR HANUKKAH TABLE Turducken First-Cut Prime Beef Brisket Flanken-Prime Beef Short Ribs (3/4 lb) Kosher Turkey (10 − 16 lb) Soup Chicken (5 − 6 lb) POULTRY & FOWL Citarella Natural Chicken Livers Citarella Natural Chicken Schmaltz (rendered chicken fat) Citarella Organic Chicken Cornish Hens (1 − 1 1/4 lb) Goose (10 − 16 lb) Long Island Duckling (5 − 6 lb) GAME: SPECIAL ORDER ONLY Magret Duck Breast Guinea Hen • Pheasant • Poussin • Rabbit • Quail Boneless Quail (4 pack) Squab • Rack of Venison • Venison Tenderloin Capons (8 − 10 lb)

LAMB & VEAL PORK Crown Roast of Lamb (16 ribs) Bershire Pork Center-Cut Roast (5 − 10 lb) Shoulder of Veal Roast (boneless 5 lb) Crown Roast of Pork (16 ribs) Fresh Ham (9 − 10 / 18 - 20 lb) Smoked Ham − Bone In (7 − 8 / 14 − 16 lb) Smoked Ham − Boneless (2 − 3 lb) FOR STUFFING Smoked Ham − Bone In − Spiral Cut (7 − 8 lb / 14 − 16 lb) Fresh Loose Country Sausage Fresh Loose Sweet Sausage

= Holiday items available for pre-order.

THE FULL CITARELLA EXPERIENCE Don’t forget your cooking essentials — we have roasting pans, twine, thermometers, turkey basters, Cook a delicious Prime Rib Roast in a few simple steps. 20 and more! Season your roast to perfection! We carry a full line of Citarella-brand olive oils, vinegars, Visit www.citarella.com/tips-prime-rib-roast for details. 21 sea salts, and spice blends. Seafood

Access to the freshest seafood depends on trusted relationships — like those between our fishmongers and valued fishermen.

OYSTERS BY THE DOZEN FISH Available in shell or shucked. Baccala (Salted Cod) Belon Branzino Cape Cod Fishers Island Eel* Kumamoto Flounder Peconic Imported Sardines Prince Edward Island Octopus Wellfleet Norwegian Salmon Organic Salmon CLAMS Smelts* Cherrystones Squid Little Neck Tuna Manila New Zealand Cockles READY TO EAT Razor Cocktail Shrimp (lg & jumbo) Alaskan King Crab Legs MUSSELS Stone Crab Claws* New Zealand Jonah Crab Claws* Prince Edward Island Jumbo Lump Crab Meat Cooked Octopus SHELLFISH Steamed Lobsters (sm & lg) Cold Water Lobster Tails Cracked & split upon request. Live Lobsters (sm & lg) Langoustines SAUCES Madagascar Organic Shrimp Cocktail Sauce Raw Cleaned Shrimp (lg & jumbo) Dill Sauce Sea Scallops Mustard Sauce Nantucket Bay Scallops (seasonal) Tartar Sauce Mignonette Sauce SEA URCHIN East Coast Uni West Coast Uni = Holiday items available for pre-order.

MAKE YOUR OWN TRADITIONAL GEFILTE FISH Our expert fishmongers are happy to help you select from the freshest and widest variety of seafood around — and provide you with exactly what you need for your special holiday meal. We will happily grind fresh Whitefish, 22 Ring in the New Year with a stunning spread of fresh seafood. Pike, and Carp for your homemade Gefilte fish. We can even include the onions! 23 Order everything you need to create a raw bar at Citarella.com *Special order only. TARTS SMALL BITES Apple, Lemon, Mixed Berry, Decorated , Cannoli Dip, Desserts Pear Frangipane, Raspberry Lemon Chocolate-Dipped Strawberries, Assorted Cookie Boxes, Mini Tarts, ANY TIME TREATS Mini Brownies CHRISTMAS FAVORITES Pumpkin, Apple, Carrot, BÛCHE DE NOËL and Chocolate Tea Cakes, FRESH FRUIT (AVAILABLE FOR PICKUP ONLY) Pumpkin Muffins Seasonal Fruit Bowl A classic French and impressive holiday centerpiece, this rolled takes inspiration Cinnamon Puffs froma storybook forest featuring charming decorations and a sliceable log shape. FINE CHOCOLATES Choose from Vanilla and Chocolate or Chocolate and Hazelnut. PIES Citarella Assorted Truffles Apple Pie Citarella Assorted Pralines ASSORTED CHRISTMAS COOKIES Chocolate Pecan Pie Citarella Chocolate Bars We’re making our popular sugar cookies in fun, festive shapes for the holiday. Pumpkin Pie Each one is decorated by hand and full of holiday cheer! Apple Crumb Pie COFFEE Sour Cream Apple Pie Citarella House Blend DECORATED HOUSE Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Citarella Dark Blend Spiced eaves and frosted icicles: our freshly baked gingerbread houses are hand-decorated Cherry Pie Citarella Decaf House Blend by our world-class chefs — and guaranteed to fill your home with the fragrance of warm, aromatic baking spices. Blueberry Crumb Pie Assorted Whole Bean Coffees

EXTRA SWEETS Citarella Imported Panettone: Traditional, Chocolate, Almond, and BÛCHE DE NOËL Decorated Christmas Cupcakes

HANUKKAH FAVORITES

CHOCOLATE RAISIN CHALLAH BREAD PUDDING We layer our own Raisin Challah Bread with fresh, sweet custard and chocolate chips for this comforting, oven-baked favorite.

FLOURLESS This luxuriously rich and creamy chocolate ganache-style cake is finished with a dusting of dark cocoa powder for incredible decadence.

VANILLA CAKE Light and fluffy vanilla is layered with freshly made Chantilly cream and topped with flambéed meringue for a perfectly sweet treat.

EXTRA SWEETS Decorated Hanukkah Cupcakes • Chocolate • Honey Cake • Assorted Rugelach

CITARELLA CLASSICS CAKES Champs Élysées • Chocolate Fudge • Maracaibo • Walnut • Red Velvet • Ricotta Rustica Cheesecake • NY-Style Cheesecake

24 = Holiday items available for pre-order. 25 The grand finale to any holiday meal, complement our dessert selections with fresh fruit and ripe berries, whipped cream or ice cream. Cheese Selections

TRUFFLE CHEESES RACLETTE Acidic, nutty, and sweet. Melt and serve MOLITERNO AL TARTUFO with charcuterie or winter vegetables. Injected with thick veins of rich black truffle, this show-stopping, fan-favorite cheese is GOAT LOGS fantastic with risottos. Locally sourced from a quaint dairy in upstate New York. Handcrafted, smooth & milky. Choose from: URBANI CACIOTTA CON TARTUFO Plain, Honey, Garlic, & Herb A high quality cheese where the taste of the 100% Italian Mountain milk combines perfectly with the PAIRINGS intense aromatics of black summer truffles. BRINS JANIS, MARMALADES & JAMS CITARELLA SPANISH CHEESES A Brooklyn-based, women-owned and operated company. Delicious, vibrant, and inventive, their products 3-MONTH MANCHEGO include Banana Jam, Cherry Chai Spread, Rosemary The youngest of the La Mancha region cheeses — Grapefruit Marmalade, Lemon Saffron Marmalade, and our most popular. Soft creaminess Strawberry Lemongrass Spread, and Chili Pepper CREATE YOUR OWN gives way to wonderfully grassy flavor. Spread. CHEESEBOARD 6-MONTH MANCHEGO NEW! MEMBRILLO, MEMBRILLO WITH NUTS Made using sheep’s milk from Spain’s La Mancha region, this cheese is richer and CITARELLA IMPORTED FRENCH HONEYS oilier than the 3-month variety. The additional Acacia, Lavender, Orange Blossom aging allows the cheese to develop a rich, grainy texture. CITARELLA IMPORTED FRENCH PRESERVES Apricot, Damson Plum, Cherry & Poppy, 9-MONTH MANCHEGO This unpasteurized gem is made by hand Seedless Raspberry on a small, family owned farm. It has a robust, sweet flavor that is truly extraordinary. CRISPS Aged Parmesan, Cheddar Parmesan, TRADITIONAL CHEESES Jalapeno Parmesan, Sour Cream Parmesan OUR CHEESEMONGER RECOMMENDS CREATING ONE OF THESE DELICIOUS CHEESE BOARDS FINE CHEESE COMPANY TOASTS COLSTON BASSET STILTON NYE CELEBRATION HOLIDAY FESTIVE Hand-ladled for a chilled butter texture, with Apricot Pistachio Sunflower, Cherry Almond Linseed, a luxurious almond opening and a bright, Date Hazelnut Pumpkin, Gluten-Free Cherry Almond Pierre Robert Taleggio Moliterno al Tartufo tangy finish. Delice de France Cambozola Blue Citarella 9-Month Manchego MITICA DATE CRANBERRY WALNUT CAKE St. Agur Le Châtelain Camembert La Petite Reine Camembert PONT L’ÉVÊQUE An Artisanal Spanish Cake featuring Deglet Noor dates Délice de Bourgogne Pitted 5-Type Olive Citarella Membrillo One of Normandy’s oldest cheeses. Washed in & cranberries for a balance of sweet & tart, finished Casatica di Buffalo Cantal Dalmatia V.S.O.C 3 yr Gouda brine and aged for eight weeks, it is wonderfully with walnuts for rounded texture & flavor. Enjoy Lavendar Honey Fig Spread Le Roulé Herb Log aromatic with a rich, nutty flavor that as a dessert or perfect with all Spanish cheeses. Fig Cake Queso de Cabra con Paprika Cashel Blue complements pastas, squash, and apples. Le Roulé Cranberry Log MITICA FIG CHOCOLATE CAKE CABOT CLOTH-BOUND CHEDDAR An Artisanal Spanish cake made with juicy, whole Buttery, with hints of toffee. Not too sharp. Pajerero Figs & rich chocolate. Snack by itself Dazzle guests this holiday season by creating your own gourmet Great with fruit and our freshly baked pies. or pair with a piece of your favorite blue. cheese board with perfectly paired accompaniments. DÉLICE DE BOURGOGNE MITICA DATE This sweet, buttery, triple cream (75% An Artisanal Spanish Cake made with soft, exquisite butterfat) from Burgundy has a thin, pungent whole Deglet Noor dates, ideally matched with fresh THE FULL CITARELLA EXPERIENCE 26 rind that offers woodsy, earthy aromas. flaked coconut. No additives or preservatives. A great Don’t forget the accompaniments — we have a fantastic selection of gourmet 27 energy boosting snack. olives, nuts, fresh and dried fruit, cured meats, and more! Catering Expertly prepared for effortless entertaining. TUSCAN APPETIZING − $149 SESAME CHICKEN FINGERS − ONE SIZE (SERVES 10 − 15) $129 - LG (SERVES 15 − 20) A country-style appetizer tray with marinated Sesame breaded chicken fingers made with only bocconcini, truffle mushrooms, dates stuffed white meat, served with sweet-and-tangy honey Hors d’Oeuvres Party Platters with blue cheese, sundried peppers, tapenade, mustard sauce. Best served warm. HEAT & SERVE SHRIMP COCKTAIL − artichoke hearts, Italian meats, cheeses, and $95 - SM (10-15) / $129 - LG (15-20) imported olives. A basket of our Crostini SANDWICH PLATTERS Frank ‘n Blanket Fresh large shrimp, steamed and served is included. A broad selection featuring our handmade Artichokes w/ Boursin Cheese with lemons and cocktail sauce. sandwiches, tramezzini, mini wrap bites and more. Brie, Pear & Almond Filo Pouch SEASONAL FRUIT − − $1.50 ea* PRIME FILET MIGNON − $59 - SM (10-15) / $79 - LG (15-20) SUSHI $199 - SM (10-15) / $299 - LG (15-20) A medley of juicy, in-season fruits such as Enjoy a dazzling display of sushi, made to order. Chicken Chao Tastefully decorated for a beautiful melons, fresh berries, pineapple, and grapes. (We recommend 3-4 pieces per person, per hour.) Chorizo Empanada display, our tender, sliced filet mignon is PASTRY PLATTERS Firecracker Chicken served with our own crème fraîche GARDEN CRUDITÉ − $59 - SM (10-15) Korean BBQ Spring Roll horseradish sauce. $79 - LG (15-20) / $149 - XL (25-35) CHOCOHOLIC’S DELIGHT − $49 / $89 Texas White Wings Crisp, colorful, and garden-fresh, this medley of ASSORTED SWEETS − $49 / $89 Mini Beef Wellington INTERNATIONAL CHEESE − vegetables is served with our flavorful dill sauce CHOCOLATE-DIPPED STRAWBERRIES − $119 Black Bean & Cheese Quesadilla $129 - SM (10-15) / $179 - LG (15-20) or roasted red pepper aioli. Caramelized Onions & Feta in Filo Cup A sophisticated spread of imported − $2.50 ea* and domestic cheeses served with juicy grapes, fig cake, and our Mini Crab Cakes rustic, house-made crostini. Tartar Sauce − $3.00 ea* MEDITERRANEAN PLATTER − $139 ONE SIZE (SERVES 10-15) Baked Clams (12 per tray) A vibrant platter of crisp, freshly cut and grilled − $29.99 vegetables, Citarella Gourmet Olives, Citarella Baked Escargot (8 per tray) Hummus, Citarella Sundried Tomato Spread, − $11.99 and stuffed grape leaves served with multigrain and sea salt pita chips. CANAPÉS (served room temperature) WHOLE DECORATED POACHED SALMON Beef Filet & Creamy Horseradish 8 lb − $189 / 12 lb − $269 Smoked Chicken w/ Papaya Perfect served cold or at room temperature, Ciliegine & Sundried Tomato our poached salmon is silky and rich. Hand- Smoked Duck & Cranberry decorated, it is as stunning as it is delicious. Prosciutto Bow Tie Accompanied with our creamy, fragrant, handcrafted dill sauce. − $3.50 ea* TUSCAN PLATTER

= Holiday items available for pre-order. = Holiday items available for pre-order. JUST ASK: We also have sternos, chafing trays and stands, serving utensils, and flowers for your 28 holiday table. We recommend a small platter for 10-15 or a large platter for up to 15-20 guests. Prices are subject to change and may vary by location. All items are subject to availability. 29 *12 piece minimum per variety. Not responsible for typographical errors. Citarella Gift Ideas Our gift basket collections make an elegant host or hostess gift.

COFFEE TREATS − $39.99 The difference is in the details — that’s why we work with youto customize GOURMET COLLECTION − $49.99 Brooklyn Roasted coffee paired with freshly the perfect food gift! The snacks we’d want to share at our own movie night baked almond and chocolate biscotti – this or casual get-together, complete with a reusable green gift is truly a treat anytime of the day! bag to carry them in! CITARELLA GIFT CARDS TASTE OF ITALY − $49.99** Our gourmet markets are a food lover’s paradise. Give a Citarella gift card and let your IMPORTED CHEESE COLLECTION − $59.99** A thoughtful collection of some of our favorite epicurean choose something special from our shops. Available in store & online. Cheese lovers will savor this selection of cheeses favorite flavors imported from Italy. and perfectly paired accompaniments. TASTE OF SPAIN − $49.99** SWEET COLLECTION − $49.99 Savor the flavors of Spain with our GOURMET / CITARELLA’S FEAST − $315* Cookies, candy, and more: there’s nothing sweeter hand-curated selection of fine charcuterie. GRAND GOURMET − $119 / $159* From a family-style Italian dinner to after-dinner than sharing a tasty snack with friends! Give the gift of the gourmet pantry with these coffee and sweets — a true culinary feast. hand-selected antipasti essentials. Sweet and FRUIT COLLECTION − $49.99** savory favorites make appetizing easy. PANTRY ESSENTIALS / This basket of good-for-you treats will satisfy any ULTIMATE PANTRY - $99 / $159* sweet tooth with ripe, juicy fruit, tender dried THAT’S SO SWEET / A selection of Citarella pasta and sauce, extra-virgin pineapple, and crunchy cranberry trail mix. THAT’S EXTRA SWEET − $89 / $139* olive oil, coffee blends, jam, honey, seasonings, GRAND GOURMET Like a kid in a candy store! This collection and more. SWEET & SAVORY COLLECTION − $59.00 of delights will have the young — With gourmet cookies, chocolate, nuts, and young at heart grinning from ear to ear! SWEET AND SAVORY - $129* crackers, and more, this is the perfect gift From a variety of indulgent chocolates and for a range of occasions. NATURE’S HARVEST / treats to your favorite salty snacks, this gift is sure GRAND NATURE’S HARVEST− $69 / $119** to please a discerning palate. APPETIZER ESSENTIALS - $69.99** A bounty of natural goodness: sweet, succulent Great for a small gathering of friends, this cheese fruit sings when paired with rich artisanal choco- WARMEST WISHES - $109** and charcuterie snack tray makes gourmet entertaining late or our fresh, handmade pastries. A delicious way to let someone know you’re thinking easy – the perfect ‘thank you’ for a gracious host. of them, this collection includes sweet gourmet treats, coffee and tea. CITARELLA’S FINEST SELECTION − $359** WITH CAVIAR − $499** GOURMET CHEESE TRIO $99** NATIONWIDE SHIPPING DETAILS Exceptional luxury and an epicurean sensibility — Give the gift of a well-crafted cheese board. this generous gift overflows with rich, flavorful SHIP IN TIME FOR CHRISTMAS Complete with manchego, aged cheddar and treasures. Perfect for someone who has it all. Last shipping for non-perishable 12/15 a spread of perfectly paired accompaniments: Last shipping for perishable 12/21 honey, preserves, crisps, and more. SHIP IN TIME FOR NEW YEARS Last shipping for non-perishable 12/21 Last shipping for perishable 12/29 Visit Citarella.com/gifts for a complete listing of our gift collection. 30 Buying more than a few? Ask about special pricing. 31 *Free ground shipping & local delivery. **Perishable. Ships priority overnight. Holiday Wine Pairings

5 wines we’re drinking this holiday season. Get into the Spirit! Citarella Wines & Spirits is proud to offer a vast selection of cellar gems from our highly curated collection. With locations in Hudson Yards, Manhattan and Greenwich, CT, we’ve BUBBLES got the right wine for every occasion. Whether it’s Franciacorta, Champagne, or a Blanc de Noirs from California, sparkling wine is perfectly at home this time of year. Try Prosecco as an aperitivo, or pop something more serious with the main course. Blanc de Blancs are especially good with Christmas goose. 10% OFF FOR EARLY BIRD HOLIDAY ORDERS! Planning ahead has its rewards. As a thank you for placing SANGIOVESE your order ahead of time, we’re offering 10% off your first Nothing says “take me to Tuscany” like a glass of Sangiovese. Iconic wines can be online order for delivery placed before December 18th. found in Brunello di Montalcino and Chianti Classico, while upstarts make their mark Simply enter the promo code HOLIDAY during checkout at throughout the rest of the region. These wines age tremendously well and represent CitarellaWines.com. Offer excludes spirits and beer. Other some of the best values in the entire wine world. Brunello Riserva makes a wonderful exclusions may apply. See citarellawines.com for details. gift, while wines from Radda and Gaiole are versatile for your holiday table.

RIESLING Speaking of versatile, there is perhaps no grape that displays as many iterations of HOW TO ORDER style as Riesling. Piercingly dry, luxuriously sweet, and every mode in between, Riesling In addition to in-store shopping, our entire inventory is available for is a true crowd pleaser. A powerful dry Riesling from Alsace is a great foil to any richer order online at CitarellaWines.com. Our friendly experts are more dishes, while an off dry Kabinett from Germany is a fun way to begin the evening. than happy to help you select the perfect bottle, so don’t hesitate to email us and we’ll get right back to you with a host of great options. CHARDONNAY Chardonnay comes in many styles from across the globe, and as the weather gets FREE LOCAL DELIVERY & PICKUP cooler we tend to prefer the richer, more luxurious versions. Look for something from Meursault in Burgundy, or a wine from your favorite New Modern producer in the cool- Both of our shops offer FREE same-day local delivery er climates of California. Sure to keep you warm on a chill winter night. for all orders over $50. In-store pickup is always free.

NATIONWIDE SHIPPING PINOT NOIR Pinot Noir is a noble varietal with many faces. Roasted poultry is great this time of year, Looking to send a gift outside our local delivery zone? and a stunning complement to something earthy from Burgundy. If salmon is on the We’ll help you select just the right thing, and we’re more than happy menu then Pinot from the Sonoma Coast or Santa Rita Hills is an inspired choice. Or to ship to almost every state in the union. Bottles are nicely wrapped expand your horizons and try something new, perhaps a Spätburgunder from Germany! and securely packed to ensure your wine arrives safely and in perfect condition. Please note this service is available from our Hudson Yards location only, and excludes spirits. A full list of states available for shipping can be found on our website. All varietals come in a range of price points. Order online at Citarellawines.com 32 or call us today to help put together your Holiday Wine Menu. 33 32 Hudson Yards: 917-993-6490 or Greenwich, CT: 203-862-8466 33 Preparing Holiday Meals Shopping List

Who is preparing your Holiday meal this year? We have provided expert STAY SAFE. SHOP EARLY. tips no matter how you are planning to celebrate the season. Enjoy our fastest shopping experience yet, pre-order from our curated list of Holiday favorites. See page 2 for more details.

HOME CHEF Crafting a stunning holiday spread is simple with our tried and true cooking To allow for social distancing, individual shopping times on the days techniques. Visit Citarella.com/Tips for culinary guidance from our experts, leading up to the holiday may be limited. Please plan ahead and create like creating the perfect cheese plate or roasting an impressive Prime Rib. your shopping list below for an efficient shopping experience. Popular item suggestions: Turkey, Prime Rib, Gravy, Stock, Stuffing, THE CITARELLA KITCHEN Sweet Potatoes, Potatoes, Garlic, Onion, Celery, Carrots, Cranberries, Tradition means something to us at Citarella and it can be found in all Lemon, Apples, Herbs, Spices, Butter, Desserts. of the chef-prepared dishes that grace your holiday table, from handcrafted potato pancakes to a holiday roast goose. Visit Citarella.com/SeasonalMenus for simple warming tips for many of our signature handmade dishes.

IN HOME CHEF SERVICE For the ultimate holiday experience, enjoy our signature fresh Citarella products with an inspired custom menu and in-home chef service provided by the Culinistas. From a spectacular New Year’s Eve soirée featuring seafood and caviar to a truffle-infused holiday menu or Feast of 7 Fish dinner with a unique spin, allow the talented Culinistas team to handle all of the details so you can savor the season. Our Sommelier Michael can take your custom menu to the next level, hand-selecting pairings based on your unique preferences. For more information reach out to our Concierge Steven at [email protected]. 34 35 34 Visit Citarella.com/seasonalmenus for more cooking and warming tips. 35 CITARELLA SERVICES Nationwide Seafood Shipping • Personal Shopping • Local Delivery • In-Store Pickup • Floral • Gift Baskets • Catering

@CITARELLAGOURMETMARKET

Place your order in-store, by phone, online or by e-mail: [email protected] by 4pm on the following dates*:

Sunday 12/20 for Tuesday 12/22 Sunday 12/20 for Wednesday 12/23 Sunday 12/20for Thursday 12/24 Tuesday 12/22 for Saturday 12/26 Saturday 12/26 for Wednesday 12/30 Tuesday 12/29 for Thursday 12/31

*Only our Holiday Favorites (noted with a snowflake) will be available for pre-order and fulfillment on Tuesday, 12/22, Wednesday, 12/23 and Thursday, 12/24. Please note, Citarella stores are closed on Christmas Day.

GOURMET MARKETS WINES & SPIRITS

NEW YORK CITY GREENWICH, CT HAMPTONS NEW YORK CITY GREENWICH, CT 212 - 874 - 0383 203 - 861 - 6900 631 - 283 - 6600 917-993-6490 203 - 862 - 8466

CITARELLA.COM CITARELLAWINES.COM

Orders will be available for pick-up or local delivery (where available). Response time is typically 48 hours 36 from e-mail. Prices are subject to change and may vary by location. All items are subject to change based on availability. Not responsible for typographical errors.