Journal of Stevenson Studies Volume 9
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of Stevenson Studies Volume 9 JSS9Book.indb 1 17/10/2012 23:06 ii Journal of Stevenson Studies JSS9Book.indb 2 17/10/2012 23:06 Journal of Stevenson Studies iii Editors Professor Linda Dryden Professor Emeritus Centre for Literature and Roderick Watson Writing English Studies School of Arts and Creative University of Stirling Industries Stirling Napier University FK9 4LA Craighouse Scotland Edinburgh Tel: 01786 467500 EH10 5LG Email: [email protected] Scotland Tel: 0131 455 6128 Email: [email protected] Contributions to volume 10 are warmly invited and should be sent to either of the editors listed above. The text should be submitted in MS WORD files in MHRA format. All contributions are subject to review by members of the Editorial Board. Published by The Centre for Scottish Studies University of Stirling © The contributors 2012 ISSN: 1744-3857 Printed and bound in the UK by Antony Rowe Ltd. Chippenhan, Wiltshire. JSS9Book.indb 3 17/10/2012 23:06 iv Journal of Stevenson Studies Editorial Board Professor Richard Ambrosini Professor Gordon Hirsch Universita’ di Roma Tre Department of English Rome University of Minnesota Professor Stephen Arata Professor Katherine Linehan School of English Department of English University of Virginia Oberlin College Dr Hilary Beattie Ohio Department of Psychiatry Professor Barry Menikoff Columbia University Department of English Professor Oliver Buckton University of Hawaii at Manoa School of English Professor Glenda Norquay Florida Atlantic University Department of English and Cultural History Dr Jenni Calder Liverpool John Moores National Museum of Scotland University Professor Linda Dryden School of Arts and Creative Professor Marshall Walker Industries Department of English Edinburgh Napier University The University of Waikato Professor Richard Dury Professor Roderick Watson University of Bergamo Department of English Studies University of Stirling (Consultant Editor) Dr Penny Fielding Department of English University of Edinburgh JSS9Book.indb 4 17/10/2012 23:06 Journal of Stevenson Studies v Contents Editorial.................................................................................. 1 Robert-Louis Abrahamson & Richard Dury Stevenson the essayist ..............................................................3 Robert-Louis Abrahamson ‘The Essays must fall from me’: an outline of Stevenson’s career as an essayist .................................................................9 Richard Dury Stevenson’s essays: language and style ..................................43 Richard J. Hill Stevenson in the Magazine of Art ..........................................93 Alex Thomson Familiar style in Memories and Portraits ............................119 Dewi Evans Stevenson in Scribner’s: ethics and romance in the literary marketplace ............................................................. 149 Neil Macara Brown Had their day: Robert Louis Stevenson’s ‘Popular Authors’ ...................................................................171 Marie Léger-St-Jean ‘Long for the penny number and weekly woodcut’: Stevenson on reading and writing popular romance ...........207 Jennifer Hayward ‘The Foreigner at Home’: the travel essays of Robert Louis Stevenson ........................................................233 Andrew Robson Stevenson as sympathetic essayist ....................................... 271 Timothy S. Hayes ‘Not so childish as it seems’: Stevenson’s interrogation of childishness in the South Seas ......................................... 291 JSS9Book.indb 5 17/10/2012 23:06 vi Journal of Stevenson Studies Lesley Graham The reception of Stevenson’s essays..................................... 313 Uncollected Stevenson (3) ‘Books and Reading. No 2. ...................................................343 Richard Dury, Notes on ‘Books and Reading. .....................346 Contributors ......................................................................355 Notes and Queries............................................................ 361 Journal Notes ....................................................................363 JSS9Book.indb 6 17/10/2012 23:06 Journal of Stevenson Studies 1 Editorial Our thanks go to Robert-Louis Abrahamson and Richard Dury who have been the guest editors of this special issue of the Journal of Stevenson Studies, which is entirely dedicated to Stevenson’s work as an essayist. As they say in their introduction they are both involved in editing volumes dealing with Stevenson’s essays for the New Edinburgh Edition of his works, and this project will undoubtedly bring much-needed attention to the essays along with new and rewarding critical insights. The present issue of the journal is already an example of just how much is to be gained by a renewed critical focus on the essays, and we are indebted to Dury and Abrahamson for this initiative. In fact, with this in mind, we would like to encourage Stevenson scholars to consider taking on, or proposing guest editorships in their turn, if there is a particular theme in Stevenson studies that they would wish to explore in any future dedicated issue. On the international front, professor Roslyn Jolly has posted an invitation for papers for the 7th biennial International Stevenson Conference, which will be held at the University of New South Wales from 8th to 10th July 2013. It seems likely that volume 11 of the Journal will contain papers from this event, continuing a tradition that goes back to the first such conference in Stirling in the year 2000. The topic for the 2013 conference will be ‘Stevenson, Time and History’. Readers should know that the Journal of Stevenson Studies is now available online through EBSCO, starting with volume 8. Previous numbers will still be available online (and current issues after two years) on the Stevenson website located at Napier University. Nevertheless, we would still like to encourage readers to place an order at their own institution for hard copy versions of the Journal. Finally, it is with great pleasure that we announce that Edinburgh Napier University has taken possession of the bulk of JSS9Book.indb 1 17/10/2012 23:06 2 Journal of Stevenson Studies the Ernest Mehew collection, with other items being lodged at the National Library of Scotland. For over sixty years Ernest Mehew collected a huge library of Stevensonia, some which may be very rare. This now amounts to around 2000 books and journals as well as copies of letters and other materials. In due course the collection will be housed in a special room, dedicated to Robert Louis Stevenson, within Edinburgh Napier’s Merchiston Library. Eventually a plaque for the room will acknowledge the tireless work of Ernest Mehew and his wife, Joyce, in preserving these items for posterity. It is anticipated that the Edinburgh Napier collection will be available to scholars in the autumn of 2013, once funding has been secured for the housing and curating of the bequest. Linda Dryden would especially like to thank Nick Rankin and the Ernest Mehew Estate for the enormous effort that went into ensuring that this collection was finally delivered in its entirety to Edinburgh. It is entirely fitting that Mehew’s bequest will now be permanently situated in the city of Stevenson’s birth. Roderick Watson and Linda Dryden JSS9Book.indb 2 17/10/2012 23:06 Journal of Stevenson Studies 3 Stevenson the essayist Robert-Louis Abrahamson Richard Dury The contributions to this issue of the Journal of Stevenson Studies all address some aspect of Stevenson’s essays. As guest editors, along with Lesley Graham and Alex Thomson, we are editing Stevenson’s essays in five volumes for the New Edinburgh Edition. The four of us have been working together on the pro- ject for the last few years, discussing the essays with others in the ‘ReadingRLS’ internet forum and speaking with each other often several times a week via Skype. Volume 1, prepared by Abrahamson, will present the 1881 text of Virginibus Puerisque; Volume 2, prepared by Abrahamson and Dury, will contain Familiar Studies of Men and Books; Volume 3, by Thomson, Memories and Portraits; Volume 4, by Dury, Uncollected Essays, 1871-80; Volume 5, Graham, Uncollected Essays 1881-94. In the context of this work, it made sense to propose a whole issue of the JSS to the essays, both to assess what aspects of Stevenson’s essays are currently engaging the attention of scholars and critics and to open up new areas of discussion. The call for papers brought forth a good crop of proposals, eleven of which survived to this publication. These gave us an immediate picture of current interests: no proposal concentrated on the 1870s essays (representing almost exactly half of Stevenson’s 100-odd published essays) and no fewer than three proposals focussed on one essay, ‘Popular Authors’ (one of the proposers was persuaded to widen his approach and the two others that remain are interestingly complementary). This gives us a hint of current interest in non-canonical ‘popular’ texts and suggests an uneasiness among literary critics as to how to approach the genre. Two of the pieces included in this issue, however, offer some clues as to how to talk about essays in their own right: Thomson JSS9Book.indb 3 17/10/2012 23:06 4 Journal of Stevenson Studies focusses on the interesting self-reflexivity of the familiar essayist and Dury looks at how to read the essay as performance. The relative blindness to the 1870s essays (which, however, are dealt with at length on the overview contributions of the