1920. CONGRESSIONAL Recbr~SENATE. 3885
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1920. CONGRESSIONAL RECbR~SENATE. 3885_ SENATE. MESSAGE FROM THE HOUSE. A message from the House of Representatives, by D. K. Hemp-! FRIDAY, March 5, 19130. stead, its enrolling clerk, announced that the House had passed 1 (Legislatit:e day of Wed,nesday, March 3, 1920.) a bill (H. R. 12610) making appropriations for the legislative;i executive, and judicial expenses of the Government for the fiscal l The Senate met in open executive session at 12 o'clock noon, year ending June 30, 1921, and for other purposes, in which lt' on the expiration of the recess. requested the concurrence of the Senate. Mr. CURTIS. 1\1r. President, I suggest the absence of a quorum. TREATY OF PEACE WITH GERMANY. The PRESIDENT pro tempore. The Secret.:'tr'Y will call the rolL The Senate, as in Committee of the Whole and in open execu- , The roll was called, and the following Senators answered to tive session, resumed the consideration of the treaty of peace their names: with Germany. Beckham G1ass Knox Sheppard Borah Gronna Lenroot Smith, Ga. Mr. KNOX. Mr. President, I send to the desk a reservation ; Brandegee Hale Lodge Smith, Md. which I propose to offer to the resolution of ratification of the 1 Calder Harris McCormick Smith, S.C. treaty with Germany. I ask that it may be printed and lie on Capper Henderson McLean Smoot Chamberlain Hitchcock McNary Spencer the table. Colt Johnson, S.Dak. New Sterling The PRESIDENT pro tempore. It will be so ordered. Culberson Jones, N.Mex. Norris Sutherland Mr. LODGE. I should like to have it read. Cummins Jones, Wasb. Nugent Townsend Curtis K-ellogg Overman Trammell The PRESIPENT pro tempore. The Secretary will read the Dillingham Kendrick Phipps Wadsworth proposed reservation. Edge Kenyon Pittman Watson The reading clerk read as follows: Fran<'e Keyes Poind~!A'ter Williams Feelinghuysen King Ransdell The credlt of the United States shall not be pledged by or through Gay KirlJy Reed any action of any representative of the United States or by any of the organs of government of the League of Nations without the prior af- Mr. KING. The Senator from Virginia [1\fr. SwANSON] is de firmativ-e authority of Congress. tained by illness in his family, and the Senator from Massa chusetts [Mr. "\V ALSH] is absent on account of the death of a The PRESIDENT pro tempore. The question is upon reserva member of his family. tion No. 8, re-ported from the Committee on Foreign Relations. j 1 The Senator from California [Mr. PHELAN], the Senator from Mr. LODGE. To that I offer no modification, and I ask that Rhode Island [Mr. GERRY], the Senator from Montana [Mr. we may have a vote upon it. WALsH], the Senator from Tennessee [1\Ir. SH.IELDs], and the Mr. KING. Let it be read. Senator from North Carolina [Mr. SIMMONS] are absent on The PRESIDENT pro tempore. The reservation will be read. official business. The Assistant Secretary read as follows : I wish to announce the absence of the Senator from Alabama 8. The United States understands that the reparation commission wffi [Mr. regulate or interfeTe with exports from the United States to Germany, [1\Ir. UNDERWOOD], the Senator from Minnesota NELSON], or from Germany to the Untted States, only when the United States by the Senator from Ohio [Mr. PoMERENE], the Senator from Dela act or joint resolution of Con.,o-ress approves such .regulation or inter ware [Mr. BALL], the Senator from Maine [Mr. FERNALD], the ference. Senator from Tennessee [Mr. McKELLAR], the Senator from Mr. REED. I do not desire to interfere with the Senator Mississippi [1\fr. HARRISON], the Senator from Arizona [Mr. from Massachusetts if he has the floor. · AsHURST], and the Senator from South Carolina [1\-lr. DIAL] in Mr. LODGE. I have the floor only to ask for a vote; that attendance at the funeral of the late Senator BANKHEAD. is all. The PRESIDENT pro tempore. Fifty-eight Senators have Mr. REED. Mr. President, I desire to make a correction. answ_ered to their names. There is a quorum present. I notice in two of the Washington papers the statement is ANNIE E. CARSON. rather broadly made that I voted against the Shantung amend.. 1\Ir. OVERMAN. Mr. President, as in legislative session, I menton yesterday. I know that the statement was merely the ask unanimous consent to submit a -resolution to be .referred to result of inadvertence. I voted against an amendment the the Committee to Audit and Control the Contingent Expenses Senator from Massachusetts offered to his reservation, because of the Senate. I th9ught it did not add anything to the strength of his res- · There being no objection, the resolution ( S. Res. 321) was ervation, but I voted for the reservation. referred to the Committee to Audit and Control the Contingent I hope if the press report has carried the story to the country Expenses of the Senate, as follows: that I voted against the Shantung reservation the press will Resolt:ed, That the Secretary of the Senate be, and he hereby is, au be kind enough to correct it. thorized and directed to pay from the miscellaneons items of the con The PRESIDENT pro tempore. The question is on agreeing tingent fund of the Senate to Annie E. Carson, widow of Robert Carson, late an employee on the maintenance roll of the Senate Office Building, to reservation No.8. a sum equal to six months' salary at the rate he was receiving by law Mr. LODGE. On that I ask for the yeas and nays. at the time of his death, said sum to be considered as including funeral The yeas and nays were ordered. expenses and all other allowances. Mr. IDTCHCOCK. Mr. President, I suppose nothing that : liTSS JULIA I.A.THROF"S TRIP TO EUROPE. can be said is liable to make any change in the vote on this 1\fr. Sl\IOOT. Mr. President, I have a letter from an Ameri reservation, but I stili shall venture to call attention to the can mother who had two sons in the World War, calling atten impossibility of such a reservation as is proposed. tion to a clipping in the Washington Post of March 3, 192.0. The The treaty constitutes the reparation commission, and the clipping is as follows: reparation comuittee is placed in control practically of the MISS LA.THROP GOING ABROAD--W!LL STUDY CONDITIONS OF CHILDRES IN economic resources of Germany,' and to a -large extent it is CZECHOSLOVA.KU.. placed in control of the amount of reparation which Germany 1\Iiss Julia Lathrop, Chief of the Child Welfare Borenu, Department must pay. The United States has, if it enters into this treaty, of Labor, on Saturdny will sail from New York, aboard the Imperator, for Czechoslovakia, where she will study the conditions confronting the a member on that reparation commission. If so represented by children of the new Republic. a member of the commission, the United States will have a large While in Pragu-e, Miss Lathrop will be the guest of President voice in the orders of the commission. It will have a disin- . ~~~s~~~t!n~0~~~ dgfu~~~~o~l~v~~ Masaryk, at the castle of Hradcany, terested voice to a large extent, for the reason that the United States has little or no interest in the amount of reparation which The writer of the letter say~, am-ong other things: Germany shall pay. I want to call your attention to the above clipping. It seems strange to a taxpayer that this woman bas to go so many But when you stipulate in this reservation that it is a condi thousand miles to study. tion of our adherence to the treaty that the reparation com It is about time that such junkets were halted: mission shall make no order interfering with the exports 1\lr. President, I simply call attention to this because I be from Germany to the United States or the exports from the lieve that all such junketing trips should cease. I think there United States to Germany you make it impossible for the repa is plenty to do here in America, studying the conditions of ration commission to function. If the United States, through children and child labor, without going abroad. I have been its Congress, can control the reparation commission, any nation trying to find out from what appropriation moneys are spent whose representative sits on the reparation commission can do for this purpose, but so far I am uninformed. the same thing. Our influence on the reparation commission . Mr. OVERMAN. She is the head of the Children's Bureau? must necessarily be through the action of our member on the Mr. SMOOT. Yes; the head of it. commission, and that influence will be large, and, as I said, Mr. OVERMAN. That is the bureau which was to cost but disinterested. To stipulate that we will not ratify the treaty $25,000 per annum. except upon the condition that Congress shall control the 1 Mr. SMOOT. Yes; that was the promise made when the reparation commission in its control of German commerce is to 1 bureau was created. take an impossible position. 3886 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD- SENATE. }iAROII 5, Mr. KING. Will· the Senator permit an inquiry? on and tra.de? In other words, does the Senator think we have 1\Ir. HITCHCOCK. Certanly. already got to the point where the only way we can trade with a Mr. KING. As I understand, the contention of those who country is by and through an agency of the league? support this reservation is that unless there is a reservation of Mr.