Montreal Says Bienvenue to the Armenian Bar Association

NEWSLETTER A PUBLICATION FOR 1989 MEMBERS AND FRIENDS OF THE ARMENIAN BAR ASSOCIATION

Volume 24, Number 2 Fall 2012 Message from the Chair “TOGETHER FORWARD” elcome to the W24th year of the Armenian Bar Association. It is a privilege to serve as the Chair- Garo Ghazarian man of this great organization.

attended an Armenian Bar Confer- ence,I fondly more remember than 20 the years first ago time in I Washington, D.C. At every meeting since, I have experienced the warmth, support and fellowship that are the Montreal Says Bienvenue to benchmarks of our Association. This year, as we rededicate ourselves the Armenian Bar Association to the vision of inclusiveness of ontreal--a city known for Committee, led by ArmenBar Vice world class shopping, Chair Harry Dikranian, has put Hovannisian, we encourage former M membersour founder, and the new Honorable generations Raffi K.of historical landmarks, internation- together an excellent agenda of lawyers, judges, and law students to al flair, and host of the 1976 Olym- events for the weekend. join us as we together go forward. pic Games--will be the site of the The Montreal Committee even Armenian Bar Association’s Mid- While we continue to gain our tried to resolve the National Hock- momentum, we should take stock Year Meeting the weekend of Octo- ey League’s players lock-out in of where it all began. We shall soon ber 19-21, 2012. Anthony Bour- order to give members a chance begin an ambitious oral history and dain recently featured Montreal to bask in the once glorious Cana- online scrapbook project to ensure in his famous The Layover Travel diens. The ongoing labour (note that the voices and events of the past Show. In it, he appropriately the “u”) dispute means Mid-Year are chronicled with the likes of our describes Canada as a great coun- Meeting participants will instead esteemed Chairman Emeritus, Vicken try because of this city. focus their attention on great of our Association in 1989-1990, the Members planning to attend will panels of speakers, in a first class inimitableI. Simonian, David and by Balabanian, the first Chairman whose be treated to a spectacular array location, in the heart of downtown words to all of us at our 23rd Annual of receptions, tours, meetings, and Montreal. lectures. The Montreal Organizing See Mid Year Meeting Preview, pg. 23 See Message from the Chair, pg. 27 2 Fall 2012

Armenian Bar Association Annual Meeting Renews Commitment to Rule of Law Initiatives, Elects New Executive Leadership n the weekend of May 18-20, 2012, the Arme- Onian Bar Association hosted its 23rd Annual Meeting at the Glendale Hilton in Glendale, California. The weekend was highlighted by the presentation of the coveted Hrant Dink Free- dom of Speech Award to Edik Baghdasaryan, Editor-in-Chief of Hetq.am, a forum for honest and investigative reporting of issues dealing with democracy and Edvin Minassian, two-term chairperson of the Armenian Bar Association (center), justice in Armenia. receives highest honors from Garo Ghazarian, the ABA’s newly-elected chairperson, and treasurer Sara Bedirian The weekend also included the election and swearing in ceremony of the Association’s Board of Governors. Well-known and highly-respected criminal defense attorney Garo B. Ghaz- arian of Glendale, California was selected by unanimous vote of the entire Board as the Association’s new Chairman. In addition to his federal and state litigation-based law practice, Ghazarian also serves as Dean of the People’s College of Law in Los Angeles ABA banquet keynote speaker Eric Garcetti (4th from left) and the Armenian Bar’s and as a Civil Service Commis- “Hrant Dink Freedom of Speech Award” recipient Edik Baghdasaryan (5th from sioner for the City of Glendale. left) flanked by (from left to right) Judge Zaven Sinanian, David Balabanian, Garo Among numerous television and Ghazarian, Edvin Minassian, Sonya Nersessian, Armen K. Hovannisian, Gary Moomjian, Robert Cannuscio and Harry Dikranian radio appearances as an expert legal commentator, Ghazarian further gratitude when he stat- has been interviewed on Larry of our organization, in assisting ed “I wish to thank immedi- - thoseRaffi K. in Hovannisian, need, of helping the to founder estab- ate Past Chair Edvin Minassian tise with Jane Vellez-Mitchell on lish the rule of law in Armenia, for his exemplary and tireless herKing program Live and concerning shared his current exper and protecting the legal rights service of the last two years, with legal issues. of Armenians everywhere.” said whom I was honored to serve “I am humbled and very Ghazarian during a sold-out gala as Vice-Chair of the bar the last honored for the opportunity to banquet held on May 19, 2012, at two terms and whose insight serve as Chair of the Armenian the luxurious Armenian Society and wisdom I will continue to Bar Association and I pledge to of Los Angeles Banquet Hall. seek and employ.” Ghazarian Chairman Ghazarian expressed See Glendale Annual Meeting, pg. 24 continue to fulfill the vision of Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 3

Armenian Bar Association And Armenian-American Health Professionals Organization Strike Gold In Atlantic City n June 2, 2012 members of the Armenian Bar Asso- Ociation traveled from all parts of the country to join their medical brothers and sisters for a captivating day in Atlan- tic City. The site was the Golden Nugget Hotel and many attendees arrived on Friday and departed on Sunday. The Armenian-Amer- ican Health Professionals Orga- nization (AAHPO) began the day with a seminar covering medi- cally current topics. This was followed by a joint luncheon in which ArmenBar and AAHPO The attentive audience at the ArmenBar/AAHPO lecture in Atlantic City members had the pleasure to mingle. Following lunch was the centerpiece event, a Medical Legal Update seminar presented by ArmenBar. Legal attendees, who received 3.5 CLE credits, were joined by many AAHPO members. The legal seminar was chaired by Sonya Nersessian from Massachusetts, a former Chairperson of ArmenBar. Panel- ists included Michael Varadian, Executive Director, Rhode Island Department of Behavioral Health- care, Developmental Disabilities & Hospitals. Mr. Varadian spoke of National Health Reform – Chairman Garo Ghazarian addresses the audience at the Golden Nugget Evolution and Legal Implications. Attendees’ interest in this topic Los Angeles to present Workers’ tion Medications and the Law. Mr. was evidenced by the numerous Compensation Laws – Covered Ghazarian, who is LA-based, has questions following the presenta- Illnesses and Compensation of represented a number of high- tion. The next speaker was Edvin Physicians. ArmenBar and AAHPO Minassian, an attorney special- members alike were absorbed by shared a number of anecdotes profile and celebrity clients, and izing in workers’ compensation the topic. Finally, ArmenBar’s to interest the audience. Garo is matters and the immediate past newly-elected Chairman, Garo also the Dean and Law Professor, Chair of ArmenBar. Mr. Minassian Ghazarian, delighted the crowd Peoples College of Law and Vice with his presentation, Prescrip- traveled from his hometown in See ArmenBar & AAHPO pg. 25 4 Fall 2012

Members in the News and on the Move Ara Babaian recently was se- for her new position. In 2008, lected as a “Rising Star” by Super she was appointed Judge of the Lawyers, which is awarded to less Probate Court in the City of East than 2.5% of attorneys in Califor- Providence, and in 2009 became nia each year who are either 40 years old or younger or in prac- Island. She earned that designa- tice for 10 years or less. He also tionthe first from “Green the US Lawyer” Green inBuilding Rhode was selected as one of the “Best Council’s Leadership in Energy LGBT Lawyers Under 40” by the and Environmental Design pro- National LGBT Bar Association. gram. On July 1, 2012, Ara became the Chairman of Gay & Lesbian Elder Souren A. Israelyan, a member of Armenian Bar Association with and only affordable housing to - low-incomeHousing, which LGBT provides elders, the as wellfirst izing on representing personal as social services that allow the Kathryn Ossian injuryan office plaintiffs, in New Yorkon May City 30, special 2012, elders to age in place. The afford- after a month and a half long trial, able housing building, known as Board Member Kathryn Ossian took a verdict in Queens County Triangle Square, is located in Hol- was recently named “2012 Detroit Supreme Court in Figueroa v. HLM lywood, California, and has inde- Information Technology Lawyer Electric, Ltd., et al. in the amount pendent apartments for 115 ten- of the Year” by Best Lawyers in of $3,184,302.77. ants. The organization’s model America. Best Lawyers is an in- This is Mr. Israelyan’s second recently received both national ternational publication which has million dollar verdict since he and international attention for - its unique service model for elder gal professionals for several years. and fourth case resolving over housing. Thebeen award designating is based high-profile on multiple le millionformed dollars. his own Mr. firm Israelyan in 2008, is a factors, including recognition by board member of New York State Catherine Karayan has be- fellow attorneys in the particular Trial Lawyers’ Association and a gun a two-year clerkship with the - member of NYS Bar Association’s United States Tax Court in Wash- ner in the prestigious Detroit law standing committee on Civil Pro- ington, DC. In May, Catherine area of practice. Kathryn is a part cedure Law and Rules. earned her LL.M. in Taxation from been on the Armenian Bar Board Last year, Mr. Israelyan briefed New York University, where she offirm Governors of Miller, since Canfield, 2010. and has and argued one of the most im- edited The Hotchpot and chaired portant decisions at New York’s the Tax LL.M. Class Gift Commit- Christine Engustian, Board highest court concerning protec- tee. An active member of the Cali- Member and former and Vice- tions available to construction fornia State Bar, Catherine gradu- Chairperson, was recently ap- workers, resulting in the change ated from USC, Gould School of pointed General Counsel of the of the existing law and expansion Law in May 2011, where she was Rhode Island Builder’s Associa- of protections available to work- a judicial extern under Hon. Za- tion. She took over the position ers at work sites. See Wilinski v ven Sinanian, founded and was from her mentor, James M. Sloan, 334 East 92nd Hous. Dev. Fund the President of the USC Art Law III, who served that post for 53 Corp., 18 N.Y.3d 1 (NY Court of Society, and served as Content years. Engustian is an expert in Appeals 2011). Editor for the Southern California land use and development, which Interdisciplinary Law Journal.

makes her especially qualified Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 5

Armenian Bar Leader Garo Ghazarian Elected Vice-Chair of Glendale Civil Service Commission aro Ghazarian, Esq. is the Devine, the incumbent Chair of GChairman of the Board of the Commission was nominated Governors of the Armenian by Commissioner Ghazarian to Bar Association, which boasts serve another term as Chair. Chair members throughout the United States, Canada, Armenia, Europe, unanimous vote of the Commis- South America, Asia and beyond. sioners.Devine was also confirmed by a Just seven months after being In addition to his nationwide unanimously appointed by the criminal defense law practice, Mr. City Council of Glendale to the Ghazarian is also the Dean and a City’s Civil Service Commission, professor of law at Peoples College Commissioner Ghazarian was of Law in Los Angeles. Mr. Ghazar- nominated to the position of ian has lectured extensively to law Vice-Chair of the Commission by enforcement agencies and is a Commissioner John Gantus, a two- former guest instructor at the FBI time former Chair and a 12-year Academy in Quantico, Virginia. He Chairman Garo Ghazarian member of the Commission. On is a board member of the Mexican June 27, 2012, Mr. Ghazarian was American Bar Association - Politi- al and International Studies, a unanimously elected by his fellow cal Action Committee, and serves research and educational institute Commissioners and assumed his on its Judicial Evaluations Commit- which promotes the rule of law post as Vice-Chair of the Commis- tee. He also is a board member of and civil and human rights in the sion. Also on June 27th, Art The Armenian Center for Nation- Republic of Armenia.

More Members in the News Robert Cannuscio, a past addition of overseeing CLE Armenian Bar Association meetings throughout the year, Chairman and current Board Robert will also be master of member, has been elected ceremonies for the PIPLA’s President of the Philadelphia Judges Dinner, a gala at the Intellectual Property Law National Constitution Center that Association (PIPLA) for the draws several hundred judges, 2012-2013 year. The PIPLA lawyers and dignitaries in the was established in 1923 and Philadelphia region. Robert is the Philadelphia region’s is a partner in the Intellectual largest intellectual property Property Group at Drinker Past Chairman and Current Board bar association and one of the Biddle & Reath LLP, and can be Member Robert Cannuscio, a partner in the law firm of Drinker, Biddle & Reath, oldest intellectual property bar reached at 215-988-3303; robert. LLP associations in the country. In [email protected] 6 Fall 2012

Edvin Minassian -- A Leader on Multiple Fronts ongtime member and two-term Armenian Diaspora. Limmediate past Chairman of the Prior and parallel to being Armenian Bar Association, Edvin re-elected Chairman of O.I.A., Edvin Minassian, who currently serves on Minassian has served in all other ArmenBar’s Executive Committee capacities of executive leadership of the Armenian Bar Association. re-elected as Chairman of the Organizationas Chair Ex-Officio, of Istanbul was Armenians recently The Armenian Bar Association (O.I.A.). selection of its Chairman for a second The O.I.A., which was created consecutivecongratulates term the and O.I.A. looks on forward its fine in 1976, boasts the largest to collaborative joint projects in membership outside of Turkey of service of our common goal, the Istanbul-originating Armenians. It maintenance and enhancement of is a vibrant and active organization the Armenian Diaspora’s vibrancy with several functioning arms, and vitality now and well into the among them its scholarship and future. youth committees, and many Immediate past Chairman of the Armenian projects incorporating the civic, Bar Association Edvin Minassian historical and cultural aspects of the

From Gravel to Gavel, Justice Armand Arabian’s New Book rmand Arabian, Associate Justice Justice Arabian was appointed as Aof the California Supreme Court the 105th associate Justice of the (retired) has written a new book Supreme Court. He authored 104 entitled “From Gravel to Gavel.” The majority opinions and retired in book chronicles Justice Arabian’s life, 1996. his impressive career on the bench, After his career on the bench, and his Armenian background. Justice Arabian became president Arabian is an Honorary Member of of ARMS Providers, Inc., which is the Armenian Bar Association and engaged in alternative dispute reso- has been a frequent lecturer for lution such as arbitration and media- ArmenBar. tion in all areas of law. Justice Arabian was raised in New His honors are extensive. He received the St. Gregory the Illumi- Armenian immigrants who came to nator Medal of Honor in 2004 by His York; he was the first born son of America after surviving the Arme- - nian Genocide of 1915. He received arch and Catholics of all Armenians, Reception Hall at the Chatsworth a Juris Doctor Degree in 1961 from andHoliness the Albert Karekin Einstein II, Supreme Gold Medal Patri Superior Court Building. Boston University’s School of Law of Honor and the Russian Academy “We congratulate Justice Arabian and became a deputy district attor- of Natural Sciences award in 2003. ney of Los Angeles County. In 1972, on his newest publication, which Governor Ronald Reagan appointed In 2005, the Justice Armand Arabi- offers a window into the Arabian him Justice of the Municipal Court, an Judicial Reception Hall was dedi- family and chronicles his important and then in 1973, he was appointed cated at the Constitutional Court in contributions to the judiciary in Cali- to the Superior Court. In 1983 he was Yerevan, Armenia, and in 2006, the fornia,” said Vicken Simonian, Chair- appointed as an Associate justice of County Board of Supervisors dedi- man Emeritus of the Armenian Bar the Court of Appeal, and in 1990, cated the Justice Armand Arabian Association. Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 7

Armenian Bar Association Member, Professor Anahid Gharakhanian, Appointed Vice Dean for Academic Affairs at Southwestern Law School Professor Anahid Gharakha- are invaluable and wide-ranging. nian, a longtime member of the Her mentoring of so many of our Armenian Bar Association, has new attorney members as well been appointed as Vice Dean for as our law student members is Academic Affairs at Southwestern unparalleled and has been unher- Law School on whose faculty she alded for too long.” has served since 2002. In her new capacity, she will be in charge of the Chair of the Armenian Bar Associ- overall academic program, faculty ation,Armen a former K. Hovannisian,colleague of Profes Vice- appointments, faculty develop- sor Gharakhanian’s at Chadbourne ment, and Southwestern’s self- & Parke LLP, and the Armenian study process, and will continue to Bar’s representative to the South- serve as Director of the Externship western Armenia Fellowship with Program. the Ministry of Justice in Armenia, As a member of the faculty for added, “Anahid is so many good Professor Anahid Gharakhanian more than a decade, Dean Ghara- things all rolled into one, most has agreed to expand her adminis- khanian has taught legal research certainly a wonderful model for trative role, as we have a very busy and writing and a unique course not only the student body of South- year ahead.” on Correctional Education, was western, but to all women and instrumental in the redevelop- men who aspire to combine posi- Dean Gharakhanian earned her ment of Southwestern’s unique tive meaning and purpose with the B.A., magna cum laude and Phi Legal Analysis, Writing and Skills legal profession.” (LAWS) program, greatly expand- University of California, Los Ange- Edvin Minassian, Chairman Beta Kappa, in Philosophy at the ed the Externship Program to be les. She completed her J.D., cum one of the largest in the country, laude, at Harvard Law School and Association, credited Profes- is a member of the California State and served as Faculty Advisor to sorEx-Officio Gharakhanian of the Armenianwith heeding Bar the PLEAS part-time day program. Bar. Upon graduation from law the call to service and with play- - She is also Faculty Advisor to the ing a key role in bringing to life Armenian Law Students Asso- bourne & Parke LLP in Los Angeles. the vision of the Armenian Bar’s Duringschool, sheher joined six-year the tenure firm of Chadthere, ciation and recently spearheaded commitment to the rule of law efforts to create the new South- she handled the pre-trial phases of in Armenia. “We look forward to a variety of civil litigation matters western Armenia Fellowship with many more collaborative efforts the Ministry of Justice in Armenia. as well as arbitration proceedings. with Southwestern and, naturally, Subsequently, she was appointed Garo Ghazarian, Chairman of with Dean Gharakhanian, who we Vice President of E-commerce the Armenian Bar Association, wish much success in her new Development for an online retail- remarked, “On behalf of the Arme- and deserving position at the law er. She has also served as a tempo- nian Bar Association, I congratu- school.” rary judge in Los Angeles Superior late Professor Anahid Gharakha- In announcing the appointment, Court’s Small Claims Court and nian on her appointment and I Dean Austen Parrish said, “Dean has worked on a pro bono basis in applaud Southwestern Law School Gharakhanian is a very talented the areas of domestic violence and for her selection. Professor Ghara- and dedicated teacher and admin- other family law matters. khanian’s contributions to the legal istrator, and I am delighted that she community and to our Association 8 Fall 2012

Garen Nazarian Selected as First Southwestern Law and Armenia Justice Ministry Fellow outhwestern Law School, nile trials (adjudications) before with the Armenian Bar judges. He also settled hundreds of SAssociation as a member of cases through negotiation. the steering committee, has part- “We are very happy to welcome nered with the Republic of Arme- Garen Nazarian as the inaugural nia’s Ministry of Justice to create Southwestern Armenia Fellow an opportunity for an American- with the Ministry of Justice,” said trained lawyer to spend a year Honorable Hrayr Tovmasyan, working directly with the Minis- Armenia’s Minister of Justice. “His try to cultivate Armenia’s legal arrival is timely as it coincides system. The cooperation between with the kickoff of our country’s these entities has resulted in the historic 2012-16 State Plan on establishment of the Southwest- Legal and Judicial Reforms, and ern Armenia Fellowship. Attorney we anticipate that he’ll play a key Garen Nazarian, a member of the role in its implementation. Having Armenian Bar Association, has Fellow with such accomplished participate in this unique program. credentials,our first Southwestern expertise and Armeniaenthusi- been selected as the first Fellow to In September, Mr. Nazar- - of Southwestern half-way across ian began serving in this year- the globe as well as an excellent long position in Yerevan, Arme- toasm Armenia gives us through high hopes the andanticipat confi- choice for the important work nia. Throughout the course of his eddence 5-year in the Fellowship.” far-reaching benefits of the Southwestern Armenia Fellow.” Fellowship, Mr. Nazarian will work Southwestern Interim Dean on several critical projects includ- Austen Parrish commented on Mr. Nazarian, who earned his ing: development of the new Penal Mr. Nazarian’s appointment from J.D. degree from UCLA School of Code, establishing probation in the a pool of excellent applicants. Law and his B.A. from U.C. Berke- “The enthusiastic response from ley, said he hopes that he will have the Criminal Procedure Code and a number of high-credentialed an impact on the Armenian justice criminal justice system, finalizing potentially developing a parole candidates to the Southwestern system that lasts beyond the term system. Armenia Fellowship position has of his Fellowship. With an extensive background been overwhelming,” he said. “In addition to the practical, I in criminal justice, Mr. Nazarian Dean Parrish explained why Mr. am also looking for ways to bring brings the experience and exper- new ideas and approaches to the tise that is essential to effectively unique position. “We’re thrilled serve in this role. He spent seven thatNarazian Garen is Nazariansuch a good is servingfit for this as judges, law professors, and law years in the Los Angeles County studentsgovernment who officials,will ultimately lawyers, be - Fellow. Mr. Nazarian’s years of working toward the developing a variety of cases, ranging serviceour first in the Southwestern public sector, Armenia exper- ment of Armenia’s criminal justice fromPublic theft Defender’s to murder. Office, He was defend the tise in the criminal justice system, system,” Mr. Nazarian said. “In the lead attorney in over 30 felony and can-do commitment to help United States, the rule of law is and misdemeanor jury trials and develop the rule of law in Armenia conducted more than 20 juve- make him an ideal representative See Garen Nazarian pg. 25 Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 9

Armenian Bar Association Condemns The Killing Of Dr. Vahe Avetyan, Calls For Truth, Justice And Accountability For All

he leadership of the Arme- of the Republic of Armenia, will nian Bar Association has from a culture of lawlessness. Our not have been in vain. Tbeen closely following the collectiveby those whocomplacency espouse in and the profit past developments related to the beat- has, in part, paved the way for the ing-to-death in Yerevan of Dr. Vahe present tragedy. Armenia and its Garo Ghazarian Avetyan, a military hospital top people are entitled to and deserve Chairman of the Board, surgeon and Major of the Arme- a social, economic, and political ARMENIAN BAR ASSOCIATION nian Armed Forces. culture of dignity and lawfulness. We call upon the authorities Anything less is an affront to the entrusted with the administration New York Attorneys of criminal justice in the Republic who gave, and give, so much to sacrifices and integrity of all those Meet at New Lebanese- of Armenia to ensure that no one maintain and enhance our home- - with respect to whom there is land. Armenian Restaurant credible basis or probable cause Dr. Vahe Avetyan’s death must be embers of the New York linking such a person to a crime, the last straw, both for those who Marea Armenian Bar Associ- and especially this crime - is above ation and other local Armenian- the law. those who adhere to the concept of American lawyers gathered on flout and diminish the law, and for All those against whom exists fundamental human rights with- Thursday evening, September 6, probable cause to suspect they out regard to the title or status that 2012, at the recently opened are the perpetrators of the brutal- the offender may enjoy in the hier- archy of the Republic of Armenia. Lebanese-Armenian restau- ity resulting in Dr. Avetyan’s tragic rant, Al Mayass, in New York death, and all those against whom It is time to resist the usurpa- City. Some 20 attorneys met, exists probable cause to suspect tion of power by those who wreak networked and caught up with that they are the accomplices, the havoc on civilized society. We call each other over drinks and accessories before or after the fact, for a fair and impartial investiga- mezze. Joining the attorney or, that they are the co-conspira- tion. Should such an even-handed group was carpet magnate and tors of these acts, must be brought inquiry ultimately implicate any Tufenkian Foundation sponsor, to justice and made sure to account member of the National Assembly James Tufenkian, himself a law for and answer to the people of the in the death of Dr. Avetyan, then we school graduate. Republic of Armenia in a court of call upon the National Assembly to competent jurisdiction. act expeditiously in considering the lifting of protective or legisla- Moomjian, James Tufenkian We strongly condemn all prior Kudos to Grace Kurdian, Gary tive immunities. The enemies of and Lori Asquith for conceiv- incidents that disregard human ing and orchestrating the affair. and civil rights of Armenia’s citi- Armenia, both foreign and domestic, including reigning oligarchies The event was intended to be zens. Those entrenched in the informal and small, and the power structure of the Republic that appear to operate under the notion that they enjoy absolute number of attendees exceeded of Armenia should neither boldly expectations. Attendees were so nor brazenly behave as though the power and protection from justice, must be confronted. delighted that there were talks long arm of the law does not or of having other such get-togeth- cannot reach them. Only then would we consider ers. Rule of law and respect for the that the senseless death of Major law have been previously ignored Dr. Vahe Avetyan, a great servant 10 Fall 2012

Armenian Bar Association Condemns The Extradition Of Convicted Azeri Murderer From Hungary To Azerbaijan As “Justice For Sale’’

hen two nations engage of nations, in this case Hungary. an innocent Armenian, like the Win conduct circumventing President Ilham Aliyev’s country he is from and belongs and bartering justice, as Azer- pardon of the murderer Safa- to, is above the law. baijan and Hungary have done in rov is a shameful repudiation of What are the United States the case of convicted murderer another sovereign as well as of its and Canada going to do about it Azeri Ramil Safarov of Armenian people whose laws, after being ? What is the European Union Gurgen Markaryan, their actions violated and spat upon, have going to do about it ? What are speak volumes about their lack been rendered a nullity. the United Nations and the civi- of respect for the rule of interna- To add despicable insult to lized nations of the world going tional law and principles of post- to do about it ? conviction extradition and pris- heinous injury, Safarov, after oner transfers. gloating and luxuriating in Baku’s The President of the Repub- red-carpet welcome, is being lic of Armenia, Serge Sargsyan, Either the government in Buda- paraded around Azerbaijan as a has announced that its govern- pest is complicit in this blatant national hero. ment has cut diplomatic ties disregard and exploitation of with the government of Hunga- international law, or itself has Such conduct is also an affront now been victimized and is the to the Republic of Armenia, its people and its government, the starters, where do we go from latest nation of a long list of here?ry. Whereas Where thatdo Armenia may be andfine thefor nations which have been hood- Armenian nation worldwide, as well as the international commu- Armenian people worldwide go winked by the deceptiveness of from here? the Azeri government, which nity, from the European Union to continues to engage in conduct the United Nations. Thus far only one thing is clear: to solely advance its “Holier than Such conduct is no different justice was for sale in Hungary Thou” narcissistic view of itself than an ally of the United States and the Azeri government just and the sense of entitlement with engaging in atrocities and in the bought Hungarian justice. But, which it operates. killing of innocent lives anywhere more importantly and far more alarmingly, the Azeri government Such a mode of operation may on the globe, with the United States sitting and watching idly also bought international justice, very well be attempted by those or, at the least, hijacked it. who subscribe to behavior which by. disregards accepted norms of The Azeri government and its Whether buying justice or international conduct, then ratio- President, with the stroke of a hijacking it is worse may be nalized perhaps as diplomacy pen, just smeared and desecrat- debated. However, one thing and politics. However, at its core, ed all international documents, which reasonable minds and it is anything but diplomacy or treaties, laws and any notion of nations cannot disagree upon is politics. fundamental fairness and justice. that the Azeris now are the proud owners of international justice, Such conduct is perpetuating In so doing, this rogue nation declared to all civilized nations bought and paid for by the blood the previous victimization and of an innocent Armenian. murder of an innocent Armenian that their people, in the absence of any aggression or provocation, The Armenian Bar Association Hungarian soil and, now it seems, are above being held accountable. condemns “Justice for Sale.” insoldier, an abyss not onof autter battlefield, disrespect but onof Azerbaijan has declared that its soldier, a convicted murderer of the legal systems and legitimacy See ArmenBar Condemns pg. 27 Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 11

Armenian Bar Association Letter to President Obama regarding Safarov Extradition and Pardon September 3, 2012 President Barack Obama The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, DC 20500 Dear President Obama: Greetings to you on behalf of the Armenian Bar Association, the largest and most diverse group of Armenian-American judges, lawyers, and students who are bound together by the greatest--and often elusive--universal interest, namely justice. Your life and career have been guided by the North Star of our times, carrying within its glow the promise of enlightenment. These two principles--enlightenment and justice-- form the ligament which holds civilized men and women and civilized nations together. The Executive Committee of the Armenian Bar Association shares your deep concern over Azeri President Ilham Aliyev’s illicit pardon of Azeri Ramil Safarov, who was convicted in Hungarian courts of axing to death an innocent Armenian, Gurgen Markaryan. The painful irony of the crime is that it occurred during a training program in Budapest under the auspices of NATO’s Partnership for Peace program. Whereas communicating to Azerbaijan’s authorities your disappointment about the decision to pardon Safarov is welcome news to us, we hope there will be more said and more done by you about the affront to international law and fundamental notions of, simply, what is right and what is wrong. land and have led to the support of millions of Americans, including the support of countless Armenian-Americans. We ask that you follow your own conscience and sense of justice which have elevated you to the highest office in our Mr. Aliyev’s decision to pardon Safarov is a repudiation of your and American efforts to bring peace, reduce regional tensions and promote reconciliation. This week, as you accept the nomination of the Democratic Party and, as anticipated, share with the nation the importance of the rule of law and, as you remind the world about the United States of America being the champion of freedom current state of friendly relations with the regime in Azerbaijan. and democracy, we ask that you please take a moment to reflect on how those declarations can be reconciled with the We urge you to let the world see you as the brave leader for whom justice is above and for all. Very Truly Yours, Garo B. Ghazarian Chairman Board of Governors Armenian Bar Association Edvin Minassian

Vice-ChairmanChairman, Ex-Officio HarryArmen Dikranian K. Hovannisian Join the Armenian Bar Association today! Vice-Chairman Sara Bedirian For more information, visit Treasurer www.armenianbar.com today. Hovanes Margarian Secretary Vicken I. Simonian Chairman Emeritus 12 Fall 2012

Armenian Bar Association Petitions The United States Supreme Court In Genocide Recovery Lawsuit he Armenian Bar Asso- -are the esteemed Attorneys representing plaintiffs include ciation has prepared and General of the States of Califor- Armenian Bar members Mark T - nia, Michigan, Nevada, Rhode ments with the United States Island and several federal and and Lee Crawford Boyd. Igor Supremefiled Court written in legalan effort argu state legislators. Geragos and Brian Kabateck, to reverse an appellate court Edvin Minassian, the two- Timofeyev of the law firm of decision in Movsesian v. Versi- term immediate past Chair- appeal on behalf of plaintiffs, Paul Hastings filed the original man of the Armenian Bar Asso- urging the high court to over- California statute allowing for ciation, is owed a huge debt of turn the Ninth Circuit’s en banc thecherung pursuit AG, of which Genocide-relat nullified a- gratitude for his wise coun- ruling. ed life insurance recoveries. sel and active participation in Also lending support to the Earlier this year in the Movse- the joint efforts to serve and Supreme Court petition are sian case, the Ninth Circuit protect the legal interests of our partners, the ANCA, the Court of Appeals struck down the Armenian community, this Zoryan Institute for Contempo- a California law which extend- time all the way to the steps and rary Armenian Research and ed the statute of limitations through the doors of the coun- Documentation, Inc., Genocide for Genocide-era life insurance - Education Project, Jewish Alli- claims on the grounds that the nal. With Mr. Minassian’s sharp ance for Law & Social Action, United States’ alleged position focustry’s ultimateand commitment and final tribuand the Center for the Study of of non-recognition trumped with the compelling advocacy Law & Genocide, and the Inter- California’s efforts to allow for of Mr. Balabanian, the Arme- national Human Rights Clinic the legal redress of these insur- nian Bar Association has, for of the University of Southern ance claims. The Armenian Bar California Gould School of Law. Association urged the Supreme the Supreme Court asking that The ANCA, through the crucial Court to reconsider the errant itthe uphold first time,the rights weighed of the in Arme with- efforts of its Legislative Direc- appellate decision and to allow nian Genocide’s victims and for the enforcement of the Cali- their heirs. ArmenBar member, played fornia insurance-oriented law tor Kate Nahabetian, also an Due to the leadership of our a critical role in securing the which pertains to an area of former Chairmen Edvin Minas- on-the-record support of the fundamental state sovereignty. sian and David Balabanian, aforementioned States Attor- Joining the Armenian Bar our resolve is clearly at an all neys General. Association on its amicus brief, time high. Claims for unpaid which was written and assem- life insurance policies dating bled on a pro bono basis by a back to the Armenian Genocide team of lawyers from the law Join the Armenian Bar Association today! attorney Vartkes Yeghiayan, a and helmed by the Armenian Lifetimewere first Honorary brought byMember plaintiffs’ of Downlaod and fill out application available on Bar’sfirm offounding Bingham Chairman--the McCutchen the Armenian Bar Association. armenianbar.com today. renowned David Balabanian- Attorneys who have also been Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 13

Son of Santa Clara County Judge Killed in Action in Afghanistan

ur hearts and deepest sympathies go out to our friend and colleague Judge Socrates OPeter Manoukian and his family for the tragic loss, while on active duty in Afghanistan, of their son and brother, Captain Matthew Manoukian. In the service of his country and of his fellow citizens of the United States, Captain Manoukian personi-

ancestral Armenian heritage and devoted his life to thefied defense the high-minded of life and liberty ideals the and world sacrifices over. of his Five years ago, a blast from an improvised explo- sive device slammed into Capt. Matt Manoukian. Even with a debilitating concussion, the Marine leader scrambled to the aid of one of his men, quickly applying a tourniquet to his leg that saved the soldier’s life. But Manoukian’s bravery and resourcefulness couldn’t save him this week from a surprise attack in southern Afghanistan by an insurgent disguised as an Afghan policeman. Manoukian, the 29-year-old son of a Santa Clara County judge and state appellate Matthew Patrick Manoukian, Captain in the U.S. Marine Corps court justice, and two other Marines were fatally shot after a pre-dawn meal and security meeting at a police checkpoint. It was the third pita bread. When he first opened the door, the porch light attack on coalition forces by their Afghan counterparts in “I thought they were Jehovah’s Witnesses,” the judge said, wasn’t on and all he saw in the gloom were four figures. a week. his voice cracking. “Then I saw the insignia and I thought, The meal took place before dawn because of Ramadan, ‘Oh, this isn’t good.’ “ the month in which Muslims abstain from food during Matt’s mother, Associate Justice Patricia Bamattre- daylight hours. Manoukian’s father, Judge Socrates “Pete” Manoukian, was returning home from Southern Califor- Manoukian, said Friday that his son was observing the nia and couldn’t be reached for comment. holiday out of profound respect for the people of Afghan- Matt Manoukian had dreamed of becoming a Marine istan and Iraq, whom he made a point to get to know since he was 10 years old. After making the dean’s list, he during his four tours of duty. graduated from the University of Arizona in 2005 with a “He was very into their culture,” the judge said. “He - managed to learn Arabic and worked on opening up a cer candidate school in Quantico, Va., and then infantry school and setting up a police station and got a court- schooldegree inin 2007. political science. A year later, he attended offi house running with some of his people. He even taught As a platoon commander in Iraq, he was supposed to little kids to play baseball after one of our friends sent patrol in a Humvee. But Matt didn’t want to be cut off baseballs and bats. from the locals. “Who knows, one of these days, maybe little Abdul will be “He didn’t believe in that,” his father said. “So he always the leadoff batter for the Giants because of Matt.” walked into town with his guys and talked to little kids Notice of Matt’s death came Thursday night with a knock and shopkeepers.” on the door of the family’s Los Altos Hills home while the judge was preparing fattoush, a Lebanese salad made of See Captain Manoukian pg. 20 14 Fall 2012

NY Lawyer Gives Back to Community The Armenian Bar Association is proud to share this profile of dedication and duty of one of its young and inspirational members. The original article appeared in The Armenian Weekly which the Armenian Bar thanks for the opportunity to republish. By Lilly Torosyan “While I was preparing for my college admission exams, I had to study under the candle light in a room where my whole family slept,” recounts Yelena Nersesyan. Witnessing the collapse of the Soviet Union, Nersesyan experienced a turbulent shift in her studies—from communist laws to an independent legal system, mirroring that of the West. “While we were studying, new criminal and civil codes were adopted. It was an exciting and interesting time to study the law and witness those fundamental changes,” she tells the Weekly.

Yelena Nersesyan movies” were one of her inspirations for seeking a profession in law, a She jokes that “beautiful and confident female attorneys in Hollywood Although her work today mainly deals with residential and commercial real estate and business law, Nersesyan is field where men far outnumbered women in Soviet (and newly independent) Armenia. also involved in organizations that educate adolescents about their civic and political roles in society. This past September, the Armenian lawyer participated in the New York State Bar Association’s Law, Youth, and Citizenship Program, where attorneys volunteer to educate school children about the Constitution and the freedoms bestowed on the population. In 2004, Congress passed legislation requiring all educational institutions that receive federal funding to present a program each year on Constitution and Citizenship Day, which is celebrated annually on Sept. 17. understanding their role in a representative democracy. They are made aware of the fact that all elected representa- tivesNersesyan represent explains each and that every “the oneprogram of them—not makes a only specific their emphasis parents. Theyon the also importance learn that of they children could sendin society letters and to their local elected representatives and their opinions really matter.” Nersesyan is hopeful that a program like this can one day be started in schools in Armenia. “Armenia is a civil law country, based on statutory laws, while the U.S. legal system is based on the principles of common law, which are rooted in precedent. Nevertheless, in 2005, Armenia joined the trend toward a hybrid legal system, incorporating the use of case law in its judicial system to a certain degree,” she explains. As a 20-year-old nation, Armenia has made many advancements in government, and is slowly on its way to becoming a fully integrated representative democracy, although the journey will be grueling. According to Nersesyan,

She also emphasizes government’s ability to ensure that the current legal system enables its citizens to exercise their constitutional“Armenia has to rights. undergo “We a have number to remember of phases thatto increase Armenia the is transparencystill a relatively and new accountability nation and theseof its electedchanges officials”. will not

- come easy. But I remain confident that they will happen.” ing a successful career. “When I meet young Armenian students or professionals who consider moving to the U.S., whetherNersesyan for studyconsiders or just hard to work,gain some networking, work experience, professional I always curiosity, share and my confidence conclusions the and four observations, main factors which in attain are based on my personal experiences. Luckily, those cold winters, the lack of electricity and heat is all behind us, and the current generation is in a better position, equipped with better tools, to plan their future,” she continues. that shook the country last year. She became acquainted with Geragos through the various Armenian social, professional,Nersesyan and political is part networksof entertainment in the U.S. lawyer Mark Geragos’s defense team for the high-profiled Medicare scandal See Lawyer Gives Back pg. 28 Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 15

San Diego Attorney Dick Semerdjian Named Chair of American Bar Association Tort Trial and Insurance Practice Section

SAN DIEGO, CA - Schwartz and practice. Semerdjian Ballard & Cauley, LLP is “It’s an honor to take this posi- proud to announce that on August tion,” states Semerdjian. “I’ve 5, 2012 at the American Bar Asso- enjoyed my service to the ABA, ciation (ABA) annual meeting in Chicago Illinois, partner Dick for nearly two decades. I consid- Semerdjian will be sworn in as erand this specifically an opportunity the TIPS to take section, my the Chair of the ABA Tort Trial and leadership to the next level.” Insurance Practice Section (TIPS). Semerdjian, who specializes in Semerdjian has been a dedicated civil litigation and trial practice, member of the ABA since 1986 has completed a two year leader- law. In 1994, he was appointed by when he first began practicing positions of Chair-Elect and Vice- the State Bar of California to the ship track as an ABA officer with ABA House of Delegates where he Chair ever in the 80 year history of served for nine years and gained theChair. ABA Semerdjian to practice will in San be Diego.the first insight into the policy and legisla- On a local level, he has been on tive arm of the association. Today, The ABA is the largest voluntary the Board of Governors for the he continues as Vice-Chair of the San Diego County Bar Associa- professional membership organi- Business Litigation Committee – zation in the world, boasting more tion, President of the San Diego one of the most successful commit- Barrister’s Club, on the Board of than 400,000 members. As the tees in the TIPS section. national voice of the legal profes- the San Diego Trial Lawyers Asso- sion, the ABA works to improve Over the years, Semerdjian has ciation (now Consumer Attorneys the administration of justice, made positive contributions to the of San Diego), a member of the promotes programs that assist many TIPS General and Special Judicial Nominations Committee lawyers and judges in their work, Standing Committees in which for the San Diego’s Lawyers Club accredits law schools, provides he’s been involved. In addition, and acted as Chairman for the San continuing legal education and he has served as a faculty member Diego International Sports Coun- works to build public understand- for the National Trial Academy in cil and Foundation (now the San ing around the world of the impor- Reno, Nevada, and in 2009 and Diego Sports Commission/Hall of tance of the rule of law. 2012, he addressed the ABA/TIPS Champions trustee) and Chair of International Law Committee in the UCSD Athletic Board. The ABA Tort Trial & Insur- Tsinghua University and at the ance Practice Section is a national Respect and professional China Council for the Promotion acknowledgment have been plen- source of expertise in tort, trial and of International Trade in Beijing, insurance law and brings lawyers tiful for Semerdjian throughout his China, speaking on the subjects career. He has been selected for together to share information and of Legal Challenges to Chinese speak out on issues of importance. inclusion in “The Best Lawyers in Companies doing business in the America” – an honor based on an The section has more than 32,000 United States and Litigation in members and 34 general commit- extensive review by peers, includ- America. He is currently a liaison - tees that focus on substantive and for the ABA Standing Committee procedural matters in areas across tial evaluations by top attorneys on Judicial Independence and ABA ing more than 2.8 million confiden the broad spectrum of civil law American Jury Project. See Dick Semerdjian pg. 26 16 Fall 2012

Daily Journal Names Garo Mardirossian Among Top 100 California Lawyers ivil rights cases are often personal injury disputes Cin which people’s constitutional rights have been violated, Mardirossian said. “Coming from people who have been persecuted over the centu- ries, I wanted to do what I could to help those in this country who have been persecuted,” said Mardirossian, who is of Armenian heritage. In 1989, he found his calling when he ended up representing the Dole family, who were his friends, in a lawsuit against the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Depart- Attorney Garo Mardirosian named Top 100 California Lawyer by Daily Journal ment stemming from charges the son and husband of Noriko camera. that deputies had brutalized 36 Uno, who was killed in a 2009 The case has attracted attention partygoers at a wedding shower accident when her 2006 Camry in Cerritos. abroad, Mardirossian said, recall- allegedly sped out of control, forc- ing his conversation at a fast-food Mardirossian obtained a jury ing her to turn into oncoming traf- emporium with police who had verdict and judgment of $24.8 heard about the incident. million - the largest judgment in In another emotional case, history against the department. fic on a one-way street in Upland. “I was in London for the Olym- Mardirossian represents the pics and my son and I went to Since then, Mardirossian has father of a homeless, mentally ill McDonald’s,” Mardirossian said. tackled a number of landmark man who died after an encounter “There were a couple of Brit- products and negligence cases ish bobbies there, and they were with multimillion-dollar verdicts. In July, Ron Thomas, the father shaking their heads. They were with six Fullerton police officers. Currently, he is preparing for shocked at the quick call-to-arms - Orange County Superior Court and beatings by American police.” wether personal injury case to of Kelly Thomas, filed suit in what will be the first state bell go on trial in California next year involved. Thomas v. City of Fuller- Journal in the closely-watched Toyota ton,against 30-2012-00581299 the city and the (Orange officers By PAT BRODERICK / Daily unintended acceleration litigation. Toyota Motor Cases, JCCP Super. Ct., filed July 5, 2012). Join the Armenian Bar Association today!

22, 2010). fatalThe beating, lawsuit which was filedwas oncaught the Downlaod and fill out application available 4621 (L.A. Super. Ct., filed March Mardirossian is representing onfirst a anniversary nearby police of Kelly surveillance Thomas’ on armenianbar.com today. Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 17

Armenian Bar Association Conducts Seminar On Immigration Issues s part of its continuing legal ed EB-1, EB-2, EB-3, and EB-5. education program, the Judge Hoogasian gave intro- AArmenian Bar Association ductory remarks and provided hosted a seminar program entitled the perspective from the bench “A Survey of Immigration Issues on the issues presented.Those in Confronting Business Clients” on attendance were able to interact September 13, 2012, at Phoenicia with the panelists and provided Restaurant in Glendale, Califor- a healthy array of questions on nia. The seminar was yet another the topics discussed. ArmenBar in a series of outstanding CLE CLE Chair Ara Babaian once again programs presented by ArmenBar in recent months. panelists for yet another outstand- The panelists included an all-star ingassembled CLE seminar. a first-rate Those groupin atten of- list of immigration practitioners dance received 1.5 units of credit. and was moderated by the Honor- “Our immigration seminar was able Amy C. Hoogasian, Immigra- both informative and thought- tion Judge of the San Francisco provoking,” said Armenian Bar Immigration Court. The speakers Chairman Garo Ghazarian. “I’m included Alice Yardum-Hunter, proud of the high quality of legal Lucy Avedissian, and Hagop Tashji- education programs that our orga- an. Yardum-Hunter and Avedissian nization presents to our members on a regular basis. The immigra- immigration and nationality law, Members and guests at Immigration CLE tion seminar was no exception.” Seminar andare Tashjian both certified is another specialists expert in national immigration seminars. the field and a frequent lecturer at The panelists discussed immigration issues facing business people wanting to work and live in the United States. The discussion covered the options for both immigrant and non-immigrant visas as well as the impact of criminal matters on an applicant’s visa application, such as DUI’s, domestic violence and controlled substance violations. The group used a series of hypotheticals based on real life scenarios faced by clients in the workplace. Non- immigrant visa categories included B-1, H-1, E-2, L-1, R-1, and O-1. From left to right, participants in the Immigration Seminar included Hagop Tashjian, Ara Babaian, Judge Amy Hoogasian, Lucy Avedissian and Alice Yardum-Hunter Immigrant visa categories includ- 18 Fall 2012

Armenian Bar Co-Sponsors Debate for Los Angeles County District Attorney n a little corner of Italy and in the heart of the old ethnic core Iof Los Angeles, the Armenian Bar Association joined the Italian American Lawyers Association (IALA) to host a debate between the top two contenders for Los Angeles County District Attorney. The special forum was organized and presented by the IALA and co-sponsored and attended by From left to right, Saro Kerkonian, Hovanes Margarian, Armen K. Hovannisian, many members of the Armenian Candidate Jackie Lacey, Garo Ghazarian and Sara Bedirian Bar. Within the august appointments the debate. After the brief intro- of the historic Casa Italiana Cultur- ductions of the candidates, each al Center, on September 19, 2012, delivered a three-minute open- the contenders--Deputy District ing statement touching on a range Attorneys Alan Jackson and Jackie of issues. Then, the candidates Lacey--faced off with each other opined, agreed and disagreed on and dug into the hot-button issues several points, such as the need as a precursor to the upcoming for transparency of the district run-off election on November 6, legislation, immigration regu- 2012. Candidate Jackie Lacey and ArmenBar lationsattorney’s and office, reform, the three the strikesdeath Chair Garo Ghazarian The event was well attended by penalty, and criminal appeals. The more than two hundred lawyers debate ended with a discussion and judges, many of whom have about the problem of California’s become familiar with and admir- budget crisis and both candidates ers of the good work of the Arme- expressed concern over the effect nian Bar Association. Those senti- ments seem to have been shared offering their perspectives on by candidates Jackson and Lacey, From left, Garo Ghazarian, Candidate whatof fiscal may deficits be done on tocourt improve closures, the Alan Jackson and Armen K. Hovannisian administration of justice in the attention to the Armenian Bar remarks singled out and empha- current environment. sizedboth oftheir whom close during relationships their official with delegation, which included the the Armenian Bar. The evening ended with the majority of the Association’s Exec- utive Committee as well as several The attendees of the forum scholarships and our very own current members. The evening enjoyed an evening of authentic boardIALA member raffle benefiting and Chair student of the marked a wonderful opportunity Italian food and wine, while the Armenian Rights Watch Commit- for the legal community to get a tone of the affair was rife with chance to meet these two candi- humor and substance. Retired winner of the one--and only--prize dates and hear their perspective Federal Judge George Schiavelli, gifttee, basket.Saro Kerkonian, was the lucky leading up to the November 6th who also tipped his hat from the elections. podium towards the Armenian Bar Mr. Jackson and Ms. Lacey met Association, was the moderator of with and paid close and personal 19 Fall 2012

Armenian Bar Association Letter To The United Nations and The League Of Arab States September 18, 2012

United Nations The League of Arab States 760Ban Ki-moon,United Nations Secretary Plaza, General 1100Nabil 17thElaraby, Street, Secretary NW General, New York, New York 10017 Washington, D.C. 20036 Laura Dupuy Lasserre, Human Rights Council President

CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) Palais des Nations TO: SECRETARY GENERAL - UNITED NATIONS, AND U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL TO: SECRETARY GENERAL - LEAGUE OF ARAB STATES TO: PRESIDENT - UNITED NATIONS HUMAN RIGHTS COUNCIL Dear Secretary General, Nation Representatives, Ambassadors, and President: The Armenian Bar Association is the largest organized group of Armenian Diasporan attorneys, judges and law students in the world. We bring to you as multinational bodies, and through each of you to your respective countries and citizens, the plight of the Armenians in Syria. Our Association shares with the Republic of Armenia and all other civic, religious and humanitarian organizations, which serve the Armenian people worldwide, the memories and pain of the Armenian Genocide of 1915 and the bloody ethnic purges which indelibly marked it. It is with those historically well-documented atrocities in mind that we ask you to not allow history to repeat itself, while you, your respective multi-national collectives, your individual countries, and each of your respective governments watch- es from afar. With due respect, you must not allow man’s inhumanity to man to occur yet again, as it did almost a century ago during the Armenian Genocide and the Great Dispossession of entire cities, towns and villages. Please join us in saying Not Again! As the 21st century’s gatekeepers of security and civilization, and as nations that have come together under the umbrella of peace, at what point might you extend that cover to provide shelter from the rainfall of rockets, shrapnel and bullets hailing onto the innocent civilians and citizens of Syria, Armenians and non-Armenians alike?

Syria’s borders to hoped-for safety, the Armenians in Syria, some of whom can trace their ancestors as far back to the sixth Incentury a conflict B.C., that and has the claimed bulk of thosemore thanwho 20,000arrived casualtiesin successive thus waves, far and either has sent as survivors hundreds of of the thousands Armenian more Genocide, fleeing orbeyond later, dire consequences due to the current situation on the ground. Unless,between of 1925 course, and you 1945, and fleeing your leagues persecution of nations in Turkey act, andand actseeking now. refugeUnless in you Syria, and now your once respective again face countries uncertainty engage and in

Armenians, wherever they have resided in Arab lands, or in countries spanning the four corners of the globe, have always beenbrokering loyalists a ceasefire to their and host bringing countries about and lastingto their peace adopted to the homelands. people of SyrianSyria. Armenians are no exception to this positive subscription and good citizenry. The Syrian Armenians, and indeed all of the people in Syria, deserve the peace and security which your charters, constitu- tions, and consciences charge you with helping attain and preserve. The Armenian Bar Association looks to each of you and your respective nations to deliver on that promise and to replenish the certainty of life and future to Syria and its citizens, including the Syrian-Armenians. Sincerely, Garo B. Ghazarian - President & Chairman Armenian Bar Association

HarryEdvin MinassianDikranian - Vice-ChairmanPast President & Chairman Ex-Officio SaraArmen Bedirian K. Hovannisian - Treasurer - Past President & Vice-Chairman Hovanes Margarian - Secretary Vicken I. Simonian - Past President & Chairman Emeritus 20 Fall 2012

The Armenian Bar Association Welcomes The U.S. Supreme Court’s Request For Further Briefing In The Movsesian Case n response to a group of Armenian- case that the relevant state legisla- the Supreme Court will be in a posi- IAmerican claimants’ appeal to the tion to evince the constitutionality United States Supreme Court in the law or policy. The Supreme Court’s of state legislation in an area of law Movsesian matter, which dealt with tion did not conflict with federal (insurance) which has traditionally the issue of a state’s (California’s) since one of the issues in the case is been within the purview of states’ right to enact legislation concern- whetherorder is of the considerable federal government significance has rights.” ing the pursuit of Genocide-era life a policy about states recognizing the Minassian cautioned that much insurance proceeds, the Supreme Armenian Genocide and, if so, what work lies ahead to ensure that the Court has ordered the Solicitor the policy is. Armenian Genocide is not politi- Edvin Minassian, the Armenian cized so as to be manipulated as the views of the United States as - an excuse by Genocide denialists General to file a brief expressing to whether the Court should grant cio, remarked: “We are encouraged to inappropriately undermine the review of the Ninth Circuit Court thatBar Association’sthe Supreme Chairman Court has Ex-Offi asked legitimacy and constitutional- of Appeals’ troubling decision that that the Solicitor General weigh ity of state legislation. “Those who states may have no such rights. in on the issue, with the hope that politicize the Armenian Genocide The Armenian Bar Association, Solicitor General will not disavow, for nefarious purposes shall not through the auspices of the Bing- and instead outright accept, the deter us in the Movsesian case and Genocide’s reality and its prior beyond,” said the former two-term - recognition by the federal govern- Chairman of the Armenian Bar. usham briefs firm in and the itsunderlying senior partnerfederal ment, both of which have been appellateDavid Balabanian, proceedings had making filed amic the amply documented. In doing so,

Captain Manoukian bringing up his grandfather, who had Continued from pg. 13 nearly starved to death as a victim of the Turkish genocide of Armenians. Matt was checking out an abandoned accepted. His grandfather wouldn’t approve of building in 2007 in hopes of opening He wanted to be a public defender, his wasting food, even soda, Matt insist- a substation there when the IED went father said. ed, disarming his dad. off. He received a Purple Heart, just “Matt said he wanted to be one He displayed that same pluck in one of several commendations over combat, winning a reputation in the years. because he was always accused in school of something he didn’t do,” special ops as “just fearless,” his father He joined Camp Pendleton’s 1st Judge Manoukian said. said. Marine Special Operations Battal- To his younger brothers, Martin and ion after enduring a grueling train- Michael, the tall handsome Marine ing program that only 40 of 100 men chops, recalling how his son stood His father said he definitely had the was their hero. passed, his father said. Matt was in up to him once after returning home with a detention slip. A teacher had “Matt was the man,” Martin said. fortitude, the men had to stay awake told Matt to throw away his soda. Matt “Everybody looked up to him.” forthe four top days. five. Among other tests of had capped the bottle and complied. Arrangements for services will be But then he had a friend retrieve it announced at a later time. After seven years of service, Matt and was drinking it again when he ran was looking forward to leaving the back into the teacher, who was livid. Marines at the end of the year. He was Posted: 08/11/2012 10:26:57 AM So was his father, who as a judge is By Tracey Kaplan / Mercury News planning to attend law school in the PDT fall of 2013, possibly at Golden Gate accustomed to having the last word. University where he’d already been But Matt deftly argued his case by 21 Fall 2012

Armenian Bar Association Awards Scholarships To Two Promising Stars he Armenian Bar Asso- Marshall Law School profes- ciation has announced sor Ann Lousin, Ms. Melkonian Tthe names of two deserv- returned to academia, complet- ing students in connection with ing her undergraduate classroom its Seventh Annual Scholar- requirements at Los Angeles ship Program. The recipients Valley College and then receiving are Lena Melkonian, currently a Bachelor of Arts degree. a third-year student at Glen- Ms. Melkonian has been an dale University College of Law’s active promoter of Armenian four-year evening program, cultural and national interests, - both in Armenia and the United Lena Melkonian nian national now pursuing the States. For more than ten years, and Ani Kocharyan, an Arme Master of Laws (LLM) at Colum- she has been a board member of bia University Law School. The the Visit Armenia, It Is Beauti- Scholarship Program is designed ful campaign, an effort with the to support meritorious students purpose of both encouraging of Armenian descent attending, tourism in Armenia and advising or accepted for admission to, an local governments on the best approved law school in the Unit- measures to foster that economic ed States, Armenia or elsewhere. sector. At a more personal level, Recipients must demonstrate an she has sponsored youngsters outstanding academic record as whose family lives have been well as a strong commitment to - the Armenian community, partic- ciaries of her support, Stepan ularly in humanitarian and/or disrupted. One of the benefi- law-related endeavors. ing against Armenia’s national (whose father died while fight Lena Melkonian has spent enemies), was able to complete Ani Kocharyan the better part of the past three his formal education and is now decades in legal work. Starting practicing law. Her more imme- tion of university studies, Ms. out as a receptionist in a legal diate interests include participa- - tion in the Rose and Alex Pilibos ment service, with duties of over the years to positions of PTA, the Burbank chapter of the ever-increasingKocharyan entered responsibility. govern increasingoffice in 1983, responsibility. she progressed For the Armenian Cultural Association, These included preparing docu- past two decades she has served and as a lead actress in Armenian mentation for Armenia’s formal theatre productions. participation in more than 80 Los Angeles attorney Daniel V. multi-lateral treaties, represent- as a paralegal in the offices of Behesnilian. As Ms. Melkonian Soviet Armenia. Reacting on a ing Armenia at the Council of describes it, she had long want- personalAni Kocharyan level togrew the up regional in post- Europe’s Committee of Experts ed to pursue a legal career, but chaos threatening Armenia in Public International Law, and family priorities put those aspi- - preparing and implementing rations on hold for many years. dence, she chose to specialize national programs for the promo- However, at the behest (and induring international the first years law ofduring indepen her with the encouragement) of John university years. Upon comple- See Scholorship Awards pg. 26 22 Fall 2012

Armenian Bar Leaders Meet with Ambassador Edward Djerejian n October 5, 2012, Armenian Bar Associa- Otion Chairman Garo Ghazarian and Chairman Ex-Officio Edvin Minassian, accompanied by Arme- personally met with the Honorable Edward P. Djere- jian,nian theRights former Watch United Committee States ChairAmbassador Saro Kerkonian, to Israel and to the Republic of Syria. The meeting took place on the occasion of Ambassador Djerejian’s lecture entitled the “The Arab Awakening, The Turkish Role in the Region, and the Future of Armenians in the Middle East.” - tunity to confer privately with Ambassador Djere- jianGhazarian, on the Minassiancrisis facing and the Kerkonian Armenians had anof opporSyria, discussed the recent actions taken by the Armenian Bar Association to address the urgency of the situation, and engaged Ambassador Djerejian in a discussion on other means by which the Association could render assistance. The Ambassador congratulated the Armenian Bar for addressing its recent letters to multi-national world bodies (United Nations, League of Arab States and U.N. Human Rights Council) and emphasized the appropriateness of selecting the From left to right, Edvin Minassian, Ambassador Edward specific recipients of the letters, as well as the inclu- Djerejian and Garo Ghazarian sive remarks expressing concern for the safety of Manoukian Center in Pasadena, California, with a Syria’s citizens, Armenians and non-Armenians alike, standing-room only audience in attendance, and was which Mr. Djerejian found to be very commendable. hosted by the AGBU Asbeds organization. The lecture took place at the AGBU Vatche & Tamar

Armenian Bar Executives Meet With Armenia’s Foreign Minister

rmenian Bar Association question of the plight of the Syrian continuing efforts and full commit- AChairman Ex-Officio Edvin Armenians and invited Mr. Nalban- ment to not only the Armenians of Minassian and current Chairman dian to share with those present Syria, but also to our Compatriot Garo Ghazarian attended a private Armenia‘s efforts and commit- Armenians in the Middle East and luncheon on September 25, 2012, ment to advocacy and action indeed to all Armenians, wherever with the Republic of Armenia‘s before world inter-governmental they may be and on all fronts. Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mr. and collective organizations, the In response to questions on Edward Nalbandian, within the United Nations, the League of Arab other matters of concern by vari- stately and impressive building of States and others. Inquiry was ous other guests, Mr. Nalbandian the Consulate of the Republic of also made as to Armenia ‘s open- provided a rare and insightful Armenia in Glendale , California door policy and assistance being look into the workings of Arme- . The intimate lunch was hosted provided to those Armenians of nia ‘s Foreign Ministry and into its by Armenia ‘s Consul General, the Syria who seek temporary refuge foreign policy, both in the region Honorable Grigor Hovhannisyan. in Armenia . and globally. During the luncheon, the Arme- The Foreign Minister assured nian Bar Association posed the those gathered of Armenia’s Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 23

Mid-Year Meeting Preview continued from pg. 1 Hotel reservations can made at the Fairmont Queen Elizabeth at the deeply discounted Armenian Bar rate of $159.00 Canadian per night. You can book by calling (800) 257-7544. The week-end activities are lined up as follows: Friday, October 19, from 4:30 p.m.-6:00 p.m. there will be a Board of Governors meeting at the Queen Elizabeth, then from 6:30 p.m.-9:30 p.m. there will be a warm welcoming reception at City Hall in Old Montreal. As guests of the President of City Council Harout Chitilian, Armenian Bar conference attendees Stepan Partamian will discuss the significant inven- will enjoy a sumptuous cocktail get-together, with tions by Armenians in North America, featured in wonderful music, in the heart of Old Montreal, a mere his two book series “Yes We Have” and “Yes We Have 15 to 20 minute walk from the hotel. Too.” Stepan will also provide anecdotal information On Saturday, October 20, 2012, conference regis- on the inventions, the patents and the lives of truly tration and continental breakfast will be served in exceptional Armenians. the Fairmont Queen Elizabeth’s Mackenzie Room. In The organizing committee has also set up an option- the first lecture of the conference, three partners and al city tour, following the luncheon. Participants will leaders in their fields offer the following CLE presen- be treated to an extensive tour of the city and its many tation: “Current Issues Facing Social Media and the treasures. After the tour, members are free to spend Law.” time among the city’s museums, shopping venues, Eloïse Gratton of McMillan will focus on employee and, of course, the charm of Old Montreal. liability for postings and comments on blogs or twit- Members will also have the opportunity to partici- ter and how to develop policies with a comparative pate in a group dinner at the famed Altitude 737. approach between Canada and the United States. Seti Atop the premiere high-rise Place Ville Marie, across Hamalian of Lapointe Rosenstein Marchand Melan- the street from the Fairmont Queen Elizabeth Hotel, çon will discuss licensing practices and the effect Altitude 737 was modeled on the Windows of World of social media in the online world. Board member bar and restaurant of the World Trade Center in New York. Attendees will enjoy a spectacular dinner and brand hijacking and will provide concrete examples of the best views of the city available in a very popular howKathryn such Ossian matters of haveMiller been Canfield dealt willwith discuss in the courts. online Montreal destination. Another lecture will be presented, entitled “Intro- ducing the Armenian Story to the World Using the Written Word: Fiction and Non-Fiction.” Acclaimed best selling authors speaking together for the first time, Margaret Ahnert and Dr. Agop Hacikyan, will each discuss their recent works and their efforts to bring about Genocide awareness to non-Armenian readers. An interesting luncheon presentation will be “Arme- nian Contributions to North America through Patents and their Inventors.” Acclaimed California and Arme- nia television personality, author and music producer 24 Fall 2012

Glendale Annual Meeting continued from pg. 2 also noted the continued service on the Board of Governors of Minassian’s predecessor Chair, Sonya Nersessian, and vowed to build upon the legacy of these two exceptional past chairs and their service to the bar and the Armenian communities of the world and to Armenia these past four years. Ghaz- arian concluded his remarks by stating that “Each of the 17 board members is capable of leading the Walter Karabian (center) receives Honorary Membership Armenian Bar, and though I may be the face of the from the Armenian Bar Association’s (from left to right) Harry Dikranian, Michael Amerian, Edvin Minassian, and Garo bar during my tenure as Chair, the leaders of the Ghazarian bar remain, as they always have been, each one of Chairman Emeritus. my fellow colleagues and friends on the Board of Governors.” The weekend conference also featured presentations concerning civil, environmental and human Joining Garo Ghazarian on the Executive Commit- rights issues in the Republic of Armenia, moder- tee of the board are Vice-Chair (West Coast) Armen Foundation, and included investigative journalist Chair (East Coast) Harry Dickranian of Montreal, ated by Antranig Kasbarian of the Tufenkian K. Hovannisian of Los Angeles, California, Vice- Canada, Treasurer Sara Bedirian of Beverly Hills, Founder and President of Armenian Environmen- California, and Secretary Hovanes Margarian of talEdik Network, Baghdasaryan and Sara of Anjargolian, Hetq.am, Ursula an attorney Kazarian, and Sherman Oaks, CA. Outgoing Chair Edvin Minas- documentarian from Los Angeles, California, who sian will continue to serve the Executive Commit- has spent many years in Armenia advocating for the advancement of civil and human rights. said, “I look forward to working closely with Garo Ghazariantee of the boardin the as comingits Chair year Ex-Officio. and keeping Minassian the momentum which the Armenian Bar Association of the Armenian Bar Association and the youngest has realized in recent years, growing ever stronger SpeakerWalter ever Karabian, in the onehistory of the of the founding California members State under Garo’s leadership.” Assembly, was honored by the Association as an Honorary Life Member, an honor bestowed on only The general membership in attendance at the a select few who have achieved the highest levels by voting in favor of the following long-standing George Deukmejian, California Supreme and Appel- conference also filled five vacancies on the board members: The Honorable Judge Amy Hoogasian lateof achievement Court Justices in theMarvin legal Baxter, field such Armand as Governor Arabian (U.S. Immigration Judge, San Francisco), Assistant and Chuck Poochigian, and Association Founder United States Attorney John Lulejian (Los Angeles), Hovanes Margarian (Sherman Oaks), Sonya Nerses- The afternoon sessions of the conference saw Raffi K. Hovannisian, to name a few. remaining current members of the board--Chris- one of America’s most prominent attorneys, David tinesian Engustian(Boston) and (Providence), Saro Kerkonian Michael (Glendale). Amerian (Los The M. Balabanian of Bingham, McCutcheon, and Angeles), Robert Cannuscio (Philadelphia), Gary National Committee in Washington, D.C., discuss - theKate history Nahabetian, and potential an attorney implications with the of the Armenian United lesMoomjian County (NewSuperior York), Court Katherine Judge Zaven Ossian Sinanian (Detroit) on States Court of Appeal’s Genocide-related decision theand banquetLaura Karabulut podium where (Toronto)--joined Judge Sinanian Los admin Ange- in the case of Movsesian v. Versicherung. serves on the Board of Governors in his capacity as See Glendale Annual Meeting pg. 28 istered their oaths of office. Vicken I. Simonian also Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 25

No Time to Spare for Armenian Bar Garen Nazarian Chairman and Chairman Ex-Officio continued from pg.8 s a prelude to what has become to assist the Armenian Cause highly developed and well estab- Aan unprecedented level of through the work of the Arme- lished – the public respects and engagement in issues concern- nian Bar Association, Chairman accepts that fact. The Repub- ing the Armenian community, on - lic of Armenia just turned 21 cio Minassian have embarked on years old. For 70 years before on May 20, 2012—the day that aGhazarian campaign and where Chairman virtually Ex-Offi every- independence, it was under the firstArmenian full day Bar of theirAssociation’s tenures, day they are meeting face-to-face, Soviet rule. Thus, this society’s 23rd Annual Meeting conclud- by email or by telephone with justice system and the public’s nearly every Armenian commu- view toward it are still in the Chairman, Edvin Minassian and nity organization to determine developmental phase. But from Garoed-- Ghazarian, Chairman respectively Ex Officio and the needs of the community and everything I have seen, heard, jointly, appeared on the Armenian develop effective means by which and experienced here so far, the National Committee of America’s the Armenian Bar Association can country is on the right path.” Annual Telethon. In front of a bring to bear the expertise of its The Armenia Fellowship Exec- world-wide audience, they spoke global membership. The event utive Committee plans to sustain of the Armenian Bar Association’s the Fellowship for at least 5 years efforts and commitment towards at the helm of the Armenian Bar and continue its fundraising with the ANCA on the first day goal of $300,000 for long-term Armenian issues and assisting the but certainly has not been the last, support of the project. An over- Armenianfulfilling its Cause,mission wherever of addressing the ofAssociation ArmenBar’s was theoutreach first example, to the view of the Southwestern Arme- need may arise. community. nia Fellowship is available online At the conclusion of the tele- Under the leadership of Ghaz- at www.swlaw.edu/armeniafel- vised interview, Minassian and arian and Minassian, the Execu- lowship. Tax deductible dona- Ghazarian pledged the sum of tive Committee of ArmenBar will tions to the new Fellowship fund $3,000.00 on behalf of themselves, continue its active involvement in can also be made online at www. in their individual capacities, and the pursuit of justice and protec- swlaw.edu/giving (select Arme- on behalf of Chairman Emeritus tion of the legal rights of the Arme- nia Fellowship under Gift Desig- Vicken Simonian. nian communities of the world. nation) or by calling Associate Dean Debra Leathers in South- In pursuit of their pledge western’s Institutional Advance-

ArmenBar and AAHPO in Atlantic City ment Office at (213) 738-6814. continued from pg.3

Chair of the Glendale Civil Service to bond. Following a short rest currently in planning stages. Commission. period, a large group of ArmenBar Special thanks go to Denise Immediately following the members joined in an impromp- Darmanian, Talar Iskanian- seminar, attendees walked down tu dinner in one of the Golden Hashasian and Gary Moomjian of the hall to a joint wine and cheese Nugget restaurants. Members New York and Jacklin Boyadjian reception. The light-spirited and concurred that the day was a and Lisa Boyadjian of California well-attended reception became complete success. Additional for their hard work in making this another excellent opportunity for events to be held in the greater event possible. ArmenBar and AAHPO members New York Metropolitan area are 26 Fall 2012

Scholarship Awards Dick Semerdjian Elected ABA TIPS Chair continued from pg.21 continued from pg.15 tion of women’s and minority rights. for top Civil Litigator in San Diego County by the San Diego Transcript. in the United States. And in San Diego, he was named as semi-finalist- Looking to the future, Ms. ential and in 2006 as one of the Ten Best Attorneys in San Diego. San DiegoThe Transcript Magazine alsoregularly recognized names himSemerdjian in 2006 as and one 2008 of the as Top a TopAttorneys Influ program of studies at Colum- in San Diego County in the area of Labor and Employment Law. He is Kocharyan hopes that her current bia University will better enable recognized yearly as a Super Lawyer in the area of Business Litigation. her to contribute to understanding, and prospective resolution, Semerdjian says he is excited to continue his leadership commitment of the spectrum of international to TIPS: “I thoroughly enjoy helping to shape policy for our profes- challenges facing today’s Arme- sion. And in my experience with TIPS, I have met excellent attorneys nia, perhaps even extending to a lasting peaceful resolution of the reputation extends far beyond San Diego County and that judges and attorneysand judges throughout throughout the the country country recognize and our clients our name know and that accomplish our firm’s- as well, an increased internation- ments. I am likewise very honored to become the Chair during the 80th alNagorno-Karabakh recognition of the conflict Armenian and, year anniversary of ABA TIPS.” Semerdjian’s theme as Chair will focus Genocide. on “relevance, professionalism, civility and excellence in the profession of law”. All of the year programs and continuing education seminars The Scholarship Program is will focus around this theme and has collaborate with the ABA Judicial primarily funded by donations Division to have a joint meeting in Washington DC in the spring of 2013.. and by fundraising events hosted by the Armenian Bar Associa- “We are excited and proud of our founding partner Dick Semerdjian tion. In addition to the Scholar- as he enters into this key leadership role for our profession” said Ross ship Program, the Armenian Bar Association supports Armenian with community and professional organizations and has instilled to our Schwartz, managing partner of the firm. “Dick has always been involved law students through its varied lawyers the importance in giving back to our community and profes- programs and events including - the mentorship and internship cated to this cause.” sion. We take great pride that each of the attorneys at our firm is dedi programs and presentations by Schwartz Semerdjian Ballard & Cauley LLP, located in downtown San legal scholars. will be celebrating it’s 15th year anniversary of service to it’s clients and theDiego, profession has served of law its clientsby attending since 1998.Semerdjian’s The firm swearing-in and all of it’s ceremony attorneys in Chicago. “We have two wonderful things to celebrate this August: Dick’s swearing in as Chair of ABA/TIPS and our 15th anniversary of provid- ing exemplary legal services to our clients in a spectrum of specialized areas, throughout California and the United States”, said Schwartz. “We are going to have a wonderful time in Chicago with a lot to celebrate and be very proud of.” Join the Armenian Bar Association today! Schwartz Semerdjian is a member of Legus – an association of law For more information, visit www.armenianbar.com today. to improve the quality of legal performance. firms world-wide, which focuses on legal and educational programming Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 27

successful chapter to our proud and churches, schools and including but not Message from the rewarding history. limited to all cultural and professional We have come far and we are ready to groups, based on mutual respect and Chairman go farther still. Our efforts are but a understanding and on common cause. continued from pg. 1 Historically, there has been a manipu- Conference and Banquet in May 2012, and those of our parents and our lation in certain parts of the world of still echo in our minds, vibrate in our ancestors.small sacrifice Starting to achievein July of our 2012 dreams and what justice is and who is entitled to hearts, and reverberate in our souls: in future months, as Chairman of the receive it. Justice and equality have “The Armenian Bar Association has Armenian Bar, I will embark on a jour- been hard fought for by our ancestors, certainly found its soul.” ney to the various Armenian commu- and they continue to be hard fought for nities, to meet with organizational and by Armenians to this day. As educated mere words by a great Armenian- civic leaders and to discuss the ways and empowered people with the abil- AmericanThe foregoing lawyer. reflection It is an assessment is more than by in which our Association may be of ity to make change, it is our responsi- service. bility to advocate for the deliverance we have made, led by the tireless We will speak for people who cannot of justice in tangible ways to those for effortsour first of Chairman my predecessor, of the great our stridesChair- speak for themselves. We will strive to whom these promises have yet to be make our voice travel farther and more realized. we have much more work ahead than effectively than it has before. The way I am excited to work with a dynamic behindman Ex-Officio, us. Noble Edvin causes Minassian. in advancing But to accomplish our mission of protect- group of individuals who comprise the rule of law in Armenia, from respect ing the rights of Armenians, wherever for human and civil rights, the protec- they may be, requires us to adhere to - tion of the environment, to the entitle- the following principle: To reach the ableour officerstalents and dedication, board members and with and ment to fair and transparent elections, destination of any journey we under- theam confidentsupport of that, our with members, their consider we will still beckon. take, we must not hold back on our achieve our goals. That which has been accomplished resources. If we are to continue to stand Please join us in opening doors and by previous Chairs, Boards, and many for ourselves and others, we must be building bridges, as we continue cham- members and supporters who make up prepared to stand solitary and reso- pioning fundamental rights for the ones the Armenian Bar Association family, is lute like a tree; and, if we are to fall or who need and deserve them most. ours not only to preserve and maintain, falter along the way, we must be ready to spring up again as one Association, Warmest Regards, but also to expand and advance. Our Garo B. Ghazarian, task is to achieve progress with an aim united, to work again for those too weak or too meek to fend themselves. Chairman, towards perfection of the rule of law in Armenian Bar Association all of its forms, forums and shades, both Join us in maintaining the honor and in the Diaspora and in Armenia. integrity of the legal profession, wher- As the incoming Chairman, I have been ever each of us calls home; to promote ArmenBar Condemns asked whether I have the requisite and maintain the rule of law in Arme- continued from pg.10 time to take on the primary leadership nia; to further equal opportunity and role of this organization. My answer justice for our communities; to advance We hold the seller, Hungary, the is a simple “Yes.” I say so because the and preserve the integrity of the buyer, Azerbaijan, and all other lawyers and the judiciary in Armenia; Armenian Bar has some of the best, nations which sit silently, account- brightest, and most committed Board and to promote the legal education and general understanding of the legal able for the rapid deterioration of system through pro bono clinics and the integrity, the honor, and the Each member of the Board and of our fundamental notions of account- committeesmembers and dedicates officers guidingcountless the hours way. town hall meetings, one community ability upon which international organizing and volunteering at legal after another. clinics, conferences, continuing educa- To accomplish these objectives, I chal- law and justice are based. tion, and pro bono programs. I believe lenge each of us, including myself, to that each member of the Board is a create an environment of dialog and Garo Ghazarian leader in our community and that, by to enhance the relationship between Chairman, working together, we will add another the Armenian Bar Association and the Armenian Bar Association 28 Fall 2012

Glendale Annual Meeting continued from pg. 24 Harut Sassounian, the Editor- in-Chief of the California Courier, whose editorials are reprinted in over 200 newspapers, jour- nals and periodicals worldwide, presented his dynamic proposal on the formation of a democrati- cally-elected representative body that would be a cross-section of every aspect of diasporan Arme- nian society, organizations and religious denominations. The Los Angeles City Attorney Carmen Trutanich bestows great acclaim on newly-elected elected body would then make Armenian Bar Association Chairman Garo Ghazarian decisions and represent the Bedirian, serving as the graceful interests of the entire diaspora and eloquent Mistress of Cere- before international political and monies, nearly 300 members, legal forums, such as the United guests and family were treated Lawyer Gives Back Nations and the World Court. to keynote speeches from Eric continued from pg. 14 Garcetti, current member and “When I started working as a provided a personal, insightful former president of the Los foreign law consultant, I discov- lookThe at finalthe recent panel parliamentary of the day Angeles City Council, Carmen ered the Armenian Bar Association elections that took place in the Trutanich, the City Attorney for of America (ABA). I immediately Republic of Armenia on May 6, the City of Los Angeles, and the decided to get involved and contrib- 2012. The panel featured Edik Primate of the Diocese of the ute,” Nersesyan explains. The ABA Baghdasaryan and ArmenBar Armenian Apostolic Church of reached out to its members in the Chair Garo Ghazarian. Both were America, His Eminence Hovnan fall of 2010, looking for a New York attorney who spoke Russian and present in Yerevan and traveled Derderian, and Archbishop of the Prelacy of the Armenian Eastern Armenian to assist Gera- to the Armenian countryside to gos and his legal team on an off- Apostolic Church of America, His monitor and observe the election consul basis. “I responded imme- process. The presentation took Eminence Moushegh Mardiros- diately, and joined the team a few a critical look at Armenia’s elec- sian. Association members were days later. For a new attorney like toral process and noted irregu- also recognized for their pro me, it has been a unique opportu- larities that continue to persist, bono efforts during the year. nity to work with an attorney of recognized some improvements The weekend closed with a this caliber and class,” Nersesyan over previous elections, and meeting of the Board of Gover- says. suggested remedies which would nors, on Sunday, May 20, where Although the case is still pending possibly bring about positive the Association’s goals and agen- in court, the experience has been change in the areas of the elec- da were set and plans were made anything but stalled. “[This case] toral process which fail to meet for the Association’s Mid-Year has been a great opportunity to expand my experience as a young international and local norms for meeting in Montreal, Quebec, free and fair elections. attorney,” she says. “All aspiring Canada, the weekend of October Armenian attorneys should consid- On the evening of May 19, 2012, 19-20, 2012. er joining the ABA.” with ArmenBar Treasurer, Sara Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 29

2012 ANNUAL MEETING SPONSORS Platinum Sponsors Bedirian & Associates, Inc. Filion Wakely Thorup Angeletti Sara Bedirian, Esq. LLP $5,000 and higher 275 South Beverly Drive, Suite 202 Laura Karabulut Beverly Hills, California 90212 150 King Street West George Ignatius Foundation T: 310-288-9797 Suite 2601 Box 32 (Trustees: George R. Phillips, Esq.; E: sarabedirian@bedirianlawfirm. Toronto, Ontario Michael R. Amerian, Esq.; and com M5H 4B6 Walter J. Karabian, Esq.) T: 416-408-5522 Bryan Cave LLP The Law Offices of Hovanes Nicole Janigian Simonian, Partner Law Office of Garo B. Ghazarian Margarian 120 Broadway, Suite 300 Garo B. Ghazarian, Esq. Hovanes Margarian, Esq. Santa Monica, CA 90401 15915 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 13425 Ventura Blvd., Suite 303 310.576.2117 office 203 Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 E: nicole.simonian@bryancave. Encino, CA 91436 T: 818-990-0418 com T: 818-905-6484 E: [email protected] www.bryancave.com E: [email protected] www.MargarianLaw.com California Chiropractic Care Gourjian Law Group Penny Payroll, Inc. Dr. Alice Chalikian varand gourjian, esq. Ara Kassabian, CPA 221 E. Walnut St. Suite 275 nareg gourjian, esq. 800 East Colorado Blvd., Suite 840 Pasadena, CA 91101 arthur kiureghian, esq. Pasadena, CA 91101 626 765-0555 101 north brand blvd. ste 1220 T: 626-568-9100 www.calichirocare.com glendale california 91203 E: [email protected] T: 818 956 0100 Safarian & Choi LLP gourjianlaw.com Gold Sponsor $3,000 1010 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 515 - $4,999 Los Angeles, CA 90017 Hoffman and Pomerantz LLP 213.785.5611 Gary Hoffman Union Bank [email protected] Andrew Pomerantz 601 S. Glenoaks Blvd., Suite 100 4307 Redondo Beach Blvd. Burbank, CA 91502 Comex Jewelry Lawndale, CA 90260 T: 818-953-4311 Aydin Bedikoglu & Edi Sarafoglu 800-539-3960 E: Arin.Dergevorkian@Unionbank. 310-371-2597 com Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP www.weappear.com www.Unionbank.com Robert Cannuscio Harry S. Cherken, Jr. HOVANNISIAN FAMILY Bronze Sponsor $1,500 Bruce L. Ashton Los Angeles, California Annette Stepanian E: [email protected] Anonymous Ani Agnessa Avetisyan One Logan Square, Ste. 2000 Jonathan Jenkins and Lara Bronze Sponsor $1,000 Philadelphia, PA 19103 Kayayan - $1,999 T: 215-988-3303 8075 W. Third Street, Suite 300 E: [email protected] Los Angeles, California 90048 Armenian American Medical www.drinkerbiddle.com T: 310-984-6800 Society www.jmjenkinslaw.com PO Box 32 Encore Law Group Glendale, CA 91209 Ara A. Babaian, Esq. Kerkonian & Chakerian, LLP T: 818.980.7777 9401 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 900 Saro Kerkonian, Esq. www.aamsc.com Beverly Hills, CA 90212-2974 2505 Canada Blvd. Suite D T: 310.400.5661 Glendale, CA 91208 Atkinson Baker Court Reporters E: [email protected] T: 818-937-9255 Angie Hakopian www.encorelaw.com E: [email protected] 500 N. Brand Blvd., Third Floor Glendale, CA 91203 Fancy Jewelry Manoukian & Associates T: 818-551-7300 Ms. Edna Sarafoglu Nigol Manoukian Toll Free: 800-288-3376 Los Angeles, California 1101 N. Pacific Avenue, Suite 303 E: [email protected] Glendale, CA 91202 www.depo.com T: 818-240-1199 E: [email protected] 30 Fall 2012

2012 ANNUAL MEETING SPONSORS

Mardirossian & Associates, Inc. Red Carpet Mr. and Mrs. Sahak Tuna Garo Mardirossian, Esq. (818) 500-7775 Los Angeles, California 6311 Wilshire Boulevard [email protected] Los Angeles, CA 90048 Friends of the ABA T: 323-653-6311 Law Offices of Vicken I. Simonian Sponsor $250 - $499 TOLL FREE: 800-341-4607 Vicken I. Simonian, Esq. E: [email protected] 131 North El Molino Av, Ste 310 Anya Artan www.garolaw.com Pasadena, California Deputy District Attorney T: 626-584-0043 Margarian Family E: [email protected] Christine J. Engustian Sherman Oaks, California Attorney At Law E: [email protected] Tennenhouse, Minassian & 1 Grove Avenue Adham East Providence, RI 02914 Miller, Canfield, Paddock and Edvin Minassian, Esq. T: 401-434-1250 Stone, PLC 1101 N. Pacific Avenue, Suite 300 E: [email protected] Kathryn L. Ossian Glendale, California 91202-3250 150 West Jefferson, Ste. 2500 T: 818-551-9990 In Memory of Honorable Jack Detroit, MI 48226 E: [email protected] Hoogasian T: 313-496-7644 From Hoogasian Family E: [email protected] Friends of the ABA Sponsor $500 - $999 A Natural Healing Center, Inc. Moomjian, Waite, Wactlar & Dr. & Mrs. Mark Annette Kosker Coleman, LLP Attorney Services, Inc. T: 818-505-9977 Gary T. Moomjian, Esq. Cal West 100 Jericho Quadrangle, Suite 225 (213) 353-9100 John J. Lulejian, Esq. Jericho, New York 11753 Garo Mardigian 1500 United States Courthouse T: 516-937-5900 ext 47 www.calwest.info 312 North Spring Street E: [email protected] 3436 Foothill Blvd. #144 Los Angeles, CA 60012 www.mwwcllplaw.com Glendale, CA 91214 T: 213-894-2434 321 Glendale Blvd., Los Angeles, E: [email protected] N&N Investments CA 90026 Nick Nishanian Med-Legal, LLC 5658 Sepulveda Boulevard, Ste 100 Law Office of Pier Paolo Caputo KIM KOUWABUNPAT Van Nuys, CA 91411 Pier Paolo Caputo Attorney At Law T:(800) 244.3495 (818) 781-0904 275 South Beverly Dr., Suite 202 T:(626) 890.7673 Beverly Hills, Calif. 90212 E: [email protected] Law Offices of Sonya Nersessian T: (213) 488-0377 Sonya Nersessian, Esq. E:[email protected] The Vartazarian Law Firm P.O. Box 1356 Steve Vartazarian, Esq. Dedham, Massachusetts 02027 Doumanian & Associates Collette Vartazarian, Esq. T: 781-899-7866 Nancy P. Doumanian, Esq. 15250 Ventura Blvd., Suite 505 E: [email protected] 500 North Brand Blvd, Ste 1660 Sherman Oaks, CA. 91403 Glendale, California 91203 T: 818-990-9949 Phoenicia Restaurant Telephone: (818) 500-7010 Email: [email protected] 343 N Central Ave Glendale, CA 91203 Law Office of Tony Forberg T: 818.956.7800 Tony Forberg, Esq. www.phoeniciala.com 515 E. Broadway Glendale, CA 91205 Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman T: 310-888-4006 LLP E: [email protected] Gevik M. Baghdassarian, Esq. 725 South Figueroa St, Ste 2800 Sternthal Katznelson & Montigny Los Angeles, CA 90017-5406 Harry Dikranian, Esq. T: 213-488-7580 Suite 1020 Place du Canada E: [email protected] Montreal, Quebec H3B2N2 www.pillsburylaw.com Montreal District, Canada T: 514-878-1011 x 227 E: [email protected] Armenian Bar Association Newsletter 31 Board of Governors and Committee Chairs 2011

BOARD OF GOVERNORS COMMITTEES Armenia Programs Executive Committee Student Affairs Chair - Garo. B. Ghazarian Co-Chairs - E: [email protected] Vahan Bournazian Chair - E: [email protected] Hovanes Margarian Vice Chair- Armen K. Hovannisian E: [email protected] E: [email protected] Deputy Justice Minister Ruben Melikyan Vice Chair - Harry Dikranian [email protected] E: [email protected] AD HOC Committees Treasurer - Sara Bedirian Armenian Rights Watch E: [email protected] Genocide Project Committee

Secretary - Hovanes Margarian Chair - Co-Chairs - E: [email protected] Saro K. Kerkonian Professor Ann M. Lousin Ex-Officio – Edvin E. Minassian E: [email protected] E: [email protected] T: 818.551.9990 Chair Emeritus - Vicken I. Simonian Continuing Legal Education Edvin E. Minassian E: [email protected] T: 818.551.9990 Chair - Members at Large Ara A. Babaian Resource Development/Fundraising Michael Amerian E: [email protected] E: [email protected] Chair - Ara A. Babaian Grants & Scholarship Sara Bedirian E: [email protected] T E: [email protected] Co-Chairs - Robert Cannuscio E: [email protected] Christine J. Engustian Nominations Committee E: [email protected] Christine J. Engustian E: [email protected] Co-Chairs - Honorable Amy Hoogasian Gary Moomjian Honorable Amy Hoogasian E: [email protected] Laura Karabulut Membership Development T: 416.408.5522 Vicken I. Simonian Co-Chairs - Saro Kerkonian E: [email protected] E: [email protected] Nigol Manoukian E: [email protected] John J. Lulejian Social Media Committee E: [email protected] Hovanes Margarian Chair - E: [email protected] Gary T. Moomjian Hovanes Margarian E: [email protected] E: [email protected] Sonya Nersessian Newsletter E: [email protected] Strategic Planning Editor in Chief - Kathryn Ossian Vicken I. Simonian E: [email protected] Co-Chair - E: [email protected] Edvin E. Minassian T: 818.551.9990 Advisory Board Pro Bono Honorable Larry A. Burns E: [email protected] Sonya Nersessian Co-Chairs - E: [email protected] Honorable Dickran Tevrizian Vicken I. Simonian T: 213-620-1133 E: [email protected] Executive Director - Jacklin Boyadjian E: [email protected] Garo B. Ghazarian E: [email protected] Administrative Assistant - Lisa Boyadjian E: [email protected] 32 Fall 2012 33 A AIMS AND STRUCTURE ACTIVITIES AND BENEFITS R M E The Armenian Bar Association is a non-profit, Some of the Association’s operations include: N non-partisan organization, formed in 1989 to enable I attorneys of Armenian heritage to better serve the law, • Worldwide Network of Attorneys A the legal profession, and the Armenian community. • Continuing Legal Education, Seminars & The Association provides pro bono services and N Workshops legal education in Armenian communities across the country and sponsors programs to promote democracy • Pro Bono Program B • Rule of Law Projects in the Republic of A and the rule of law in the Republic of Armenia. Armenia R Coming together socially and professionally, members from around the world have the opportunity • Armenian Rights Watch A to learn from one another as they join their different • Annual National Meeting S backgrounds and experiences in Association activities. • Newsletter S The Association is a democratic organization. It is • Membership Directory O supported and directed by its members, who approve • Amicus Curiae Submission on Issues of Interest C its bylaws, elect its Board of Governors, nominate • Topical and Regional Practice Groups I prominent jurists as honorary members, and set the • Cooperation with other bar associations and Association’s annual goals and policies. A lawyers’ societies T The Armenian Bar Association is committed to I serving the profession of law, addressing the legal O concerns of the Armenian community and fostering N respect for human and civil rights. COMMITTED TO SERVE

The Armenian Bar Association Newsletter is published periodically by the Armenian Bar Association. Members and friends of the Assocation receive a subscription to the Newsletter as part of their membership. Opinions expressed in the Newsletter are those of the authors of the articles and/or the editors of the Newsletter and do not necessarily represent the views of the Armenian Bar Assocation.

Armenian Bar Association P.O. Box 29111 Los Angeles, CA 90029

ADDRESS SERVICE REQUESTED

VISIT US AT www.ArmenianBar.com