The Language of Corporate Code of Ethics: an Industry-Related Perspective
LEGALISTIC AND COMMITMENT- ORIENTED CORPORATE CODES OF ETHICS A CORPUS BASED ANALYSIS WH-QUESTIONS • WHAT? • WHO? • WHERE? • WHEN? • WHY? WHO: CODE ADOPTERS • first corporate codes appeared more then a century ago • 70% of the codes in the US were created after the year 1990 (Guillén et al. 2002) • Europe lagged behind the U.S. in 80s /‘90s (Kaptein/Wempe 1998) • Today 100% code adopters in US, UK and Europe, not in Asia (Cho-Kwai 2015) WHERE: WEBSITE SECTIONS • Corporate Governance • CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) • Other (“Who we are” / “About us”) formalizing behavioural standards (Weaver, 1993) WHEN 2018 8/17 2017 1/17 2016 2/17 2015 2/17 No date 3/17 WHY: REASONS FOR CODE ADOPTION Morally driven reasons ManagerialManagerial strategystrategy Morally driven reasons (ex. Stevens 2009) (es. Stevens 2009) linguistic analysis to unveil authors’ intentions RELEVANT LITERATURE -1 Codes investigated mostly by researchers of non-linguistic disciplines: - business ethics (ex.Stevens 2007, Scott 2002) - socio-psychology (ex. Fairfax 2007) - organizational studies (ex. Brown/Ainsworth/Grant 2012) - management studies (ex. Gillespie et al., 2012) RELEVANT LITERATURE -2 • Content analysis (ex. Krippendorff 2013) Other approaches: • perception of code users (Schwarts 2004) • physical appearance: length, visuals, format • code quality (Erwin 2011) led the way for language-focused research… PURPOSE AND METHODOLOGY • CDA to help explain the role of managerial discourse in the construction of one of companies’ intangible asset corporate identity + automatic computer query to confirm HYPs RESEARCH QUESTIONS RQ ❶ Can we identify distinctive traits of legalistic approach and commitment-oriented approach at macro-textual level? RQ ❷ Are the two approaches industry-related? CORPUS • 17 codes from FTSE 100 constituents • 9 non-financial sectors (mining, media, food, tobacco, beverages, pharmaceuticals, aerospace & defense, oil & gas, personal goods) • 150,000 word tokens • 8,481 word types LEGALISTIC VS.
[Show full text]