DOCSLIB.ORG

Sep 16 2010 Libraries

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Sep 16 2010 Libraries Planning Tremd: The Community Development Field in a Post-Katrina World by MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY Leigh Taylor Graham SEP 16 2010 B.A. Sociology Brandeis University, 1997 LIBRARIES M.B.A. Management and Finance ARCHIVES Leonard N. Stem School of Business, New York University, 2001 SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF URBAN STUDIES AND PLANNING IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN URBAN AND REGIONAL PLANNING AT THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY September 2010 0 2010 Leigh Taylor Graham. All rights reserved. The author hereby grants to MIT permission to reproduce and to distribute publicly paper and electronic copies of this thesis document in whole or in part. Signature of Author: 3!151 Department of Urban Studies and Planning August 20, 2010 C-) 7 Certified by: j1~ Professor J. Phillip Thompson Da ment of Urban Studies and Planning Th-+ Vpervisorit Accepted by: Professor Eran Ben-Joseph Chair, PhD Committee Department of Urban Studies and Planning Page 1 of 271 Planning Tremd: The Community Development Field in a Post-Katrina World by Leigh Taylor Graham Submitted to the Department of Urban Studies and Planning on September 3, 2010 in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Urban and Regional Planning ABSTRACT A Network of community development (CD) organizations in New Orleans and nationwide collectively framed Hurricane Katrina in 2005 as the result of willful government failure to protect an original American city and its most vulnerable residents. They saw their efforts to equitably redevelop the city as seeding a renewed social movement for economic and racial justice that would result in the self-determination of local low-income communities of color. This interpretation built on their shared activist histories, especially the movement origins of the CD field that championed the self-determination of low-income urban African-American and Latino neighborhoods. Yet, chronic tension within CD between the field's enduring movement aims and its institutionalized practices emphasizing housing production seriously constrained the Network's efforts. By late 2006, Network organizations had split apart over the future of New Orleans public housing. This dissertation is an in-depth case study of the first 15 months after Katrina that uses participant-observation to explore this tension and its implications for the movement possibilities of the CD field. I argue that there are three mechanisms of institutionalization that stratify the field and constrain its movement aims: a) the marketization of community development, b) the reformation of poverty, and c) the radicalization of community organizing repertoires. In New Orleans, these three mechanisms combined with intense civil society conflict, the roll-out of neoliberal deconcentration policy, a weak local political economy, and competing cultural repertoires within the Network to undermine collective action. Institutionalized race and class inequalities were reproduced within the Network and urban space. When the federal government proposed to demolish 70% of the city's public housing, one Network cohort agreed to redevelop the Lafitte projects while another filed a resident class action lawsuit against the Department of Housing and Urban Development. The Lafitte redevelopment cohort came to control a substantial portion of land in Tremd/Lafitte and the resident participation process in redevelopment. Resident participation was a narrowly construed process of site planning, especially compared to principles of resident participation enshrined in neighborhood recovery planning serving mostly middle-class New Orleanians. This unanticipated Network polarization proved instructive. Economic human rights and equitable development activism has grown out of the Network and the Gulf Coast. This suggests Page 2 of 271 possibilities for movement renewal in the institutionalized community development field, particularly by re-appropriating the mechanisms of marketization, poverty reform, and the radicalization of community organizing. Community development's incorporation into the neoliberal political economy has opened up spaces for political resistance by practitioners working within the system. A new discourse of economic human rights points to a reorientation of the field around low-income residents' right to the city. Finally, community organizing can be reintegrated into CD, beginning with internal organizing processes as a means to develop a new theory of power to transcend historical institutional distrust within the sector. Thesis Supervisor: J. Phillip Thompson Title: Associate Professor of Urban Politics Page 3 of 271 Acknowledgments This dissertation is dedicated to the residents and activists of New Orleans and beyond who rose to meet the challenges unleashed by Hurricane Katrina, and have since been tirelessly championing an equitable and just life for all current and former residents of this irrepressible city. I am writing these acknowledgements on August 29, 2010, the five year anniversary of Hurricane Katrina's landfall, as New Orleanians and residents of SE Louisiana and the Gulf Coast celebrate their recovery, honor the memories of lost lives, homes and ways of life, and simultaneously deal with new challenges brought about by the Deepwater Horizon/BP Gulf oil spill. This unique region of the country deserves our support, investment and respect long after today's tributes and reflections draw to a close. I am indebted to my committee, Chair J. Phillip Thompson and members Diane E. Davis and JoAnn Carmin, for their keen input and support not only on this thesis, but in their encouragement and feedback over the last five years of my involvement with Hurricane Katrina recovery. I am particularly grateful to Phil for opening up tremendous work and scholarship opportunities for me in the Gulf Coast. Our time together working in the region with community development practitioners and scholars was instructive and invaluable. Professor Michele Lamont of the Department of Sociology at Harvard, former Visiting Professor Gus Newport in the Department of Urban Studies & Planning (DUSP) at MIT, Professor Larry Vale at DUSP, and Professor Renia Ehrenfeucht at the University of New Orleans were also tremendously helpful in making sense of my fieldwork and research agenda. To protect anonymity, I cannot thank particular Katrina colleagues by name. But I would like to express my thanks to the individuals representing the range of community development, labor, social justice and advocacy organizations I had the privilege of working with and learning from over the past five years. From direct action pro-public housing activists to executives at national unions and community development intermediaries, Katrina responders made room for me at their tables and in their demonstrations (be they programmatic or protest). I would like to thank the Unitarian Universalist Service Committee, Oxfam America, and especially The Mertz Gilmore Foundation, the Leonard & Louise Riggio Foundation/Project Home Again and the Louisiana Disaster Recovery Foundation for underwriting my applied work in the region through 2010. The Social Science Research Council and the Hal Horowitz Fund at MIT supported my research in its later stages. My colleagues in the PhD program in the Department of Urban Studies & Planning were immensely supportive of this work; I send a special thanks to all of those who attended my defense in July 2010. Their friendly faces and encouraging words meant the world to me. Furthermore, it has been my pleasure to work with and explore New Orleans with the crew of fellow MIT students who also came to the region with good intentions and a desire to contribute to the city's rebirth. Lastly, I thank Sandy Wellford, Karen Yegian, and all the staff in the Page 4 of 271 department who facilitated my research and travel in and out of the Gulf Coast while a full-time student at MIT. I send an enthusiastic shout out to all my Facebook friends, who cheered me on while I was writing this thesis and provided regular reprieves while I was holed up in my office. I could not have considered a PhD nor seen this through to completion without the unconditional love of my parents, Sue and Steve and Jack and Julianne. Their bemused pride in my pursuit of a PhD, with its significant financial opportunity costs, has been a foundation for me in this endeavor. The chance to return home to Massachusetts to attend MIT also gave me the pleasure of living close to my extended family again, and helped me renew some wonderful relationships, especially with my aunts and cousins who shared with me their own insights on public housing while I was consumed with the fate of New Orleans's projects. Finally, I cannot imagine navigating this experience without my husband, Steve Moga, by my side. He is easily the best discovery I made at MIT. I don't recommend to any household trying to write two dissertations at once, but I do hope those who are dealing with such trials have the solid love and warmth of a partner like I have with Steve. He helped me clarify ideas, make sense of what I was seeing, fed me well, and generally made my life happier and more fulfilling. I look forward to our future explorations as we move on from MIT. Page 5 of 271 Table of Contents Chapter Page 1: Hurricane Katrina and the Community Development Field pp. 7-33 2: Mechanisms of Institutionalization and the Crisis of Katrina pp. 34-66 3: Planning
Load more

Recommended publications
  • University of California
    UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles Space, Place, and Music in New Orleans A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Ethnomusicology By Julie Michelle Raimondi 2012 © Copyright by Julie Michelle Raimondi 2012 ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Space, Place, and Music in New Orleans By Julie Michelle Raimondi Doctor of Philosophy in Ethnomusicology University of California, Los Angeles, 2012 Professor Anthony Seeger, Chair This dissertation explores ways in which many people in New Orleans use, experience, form emotional attachments to, and make sense of space through music. It analyzes how music intersects with geography and how the musical experiences of New Orleanians bring meaning to the built form. It examines the role of the agent in the social construction of space, and how people use music as a spatial enabler in New Orleans. It proposes that music enables people to socially construct space because it accesses the nexus of memory and emotion, operates in a greater cultural context, and is a useful tool for variable expression. In order to present varied experiences with the musical construction of space, this dissertation approaches its subject through four case studies: place attachment through the “second line” parading tradition and North Claiborne Avenue, the fixing of memories in space at the Ernie K-Doe Mother-in-Law Lounge, the negotiation of public space through musical performances in various contexts, and the creation and growth of a music community in the New Orleans Habitat Musicians’ Village. In so doing, it illustrates that New Orleans, as a musical city, is greater than a soundscape or a cultural identity—it is the sum of myriad musical experiences that individuals in New Orleans have had as they interact with the space around them.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Rise Hospitals, Schools, Energy Work Take Shape Throughout the Region
    top construction projects 2013 PERIODICAL SUPPLEMENT TO NEW ORLEANS CITYBUSINESS AND DAILY JOURNAL OF COMMERCE On the rise Hospitals, schools, energy work take shape throughout the region TOP 10 OF 2013 • 2012 TOP PROJECTS UPDATE • CONSTRUCTION LISTS From the Traditional to the Eclectic ProSource Wholesale Floorcoverings is Designed to let You be the Pro! Created to serve Trade Professionals, our Member-Only showroom provides access to over 20,000 flooring selections, giving you and your clients endless design options for every budget. ProSource of New Orleans And 1525 Edwards Ave. • Harahan, LA 70123 Wholesale 504-733-3070 Kitchen & Bath www.prosourcefloors.com/neworleans Showroom Introduction . .5A Top 10 Orleans Parish Public Schools . .8A Valero Refinery expansion . .9A Huey P. Long Bridge . .10A Public housing rebuild . .11A University Medical Center . .12A New Orleans street repairs . .13A Veterans Affairs Hospital . .14A Nine Mile Point Entergy plant . .15A Nucor steel plant . .16A National World War II Museum expansion . .17A TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS 2013 2012 Project Progress Report . .18A Lists Architects . .20A CONTENTS Engineering firms . .24A General contractors . .29A Landscape contractors . .31A Published by NOPG LLC The entire contents of this publication are copyrighted by NOPG LLC, 2013, with all 3445 N. Causeway Blvd., rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without Suite 901, Metairie, La. 70002 permission, of editorial or graphic content 504-834-9292; Fax: 504-832-3534 in any manner is prohibited. NOPG LLC, 3445 N.
    [Show full text]
  • New Orleans Claiborne Avenue Redevelopment Study: a University of New Orleans Analysis of Best Practices and Public Opinion
    University of New Orleans ScholarWorks@UNO UNOTI Publications UNO Transportation Institute 8-2011 New Orleans Claiborne Avenue Redevelopment Study: A University of New Orleans Analysis of Best Practices and Public Opinion John L. Renne University of New Orleans, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.uno.edu/unoti_pubs Recommended Citation Renne, John L., "New Orleans Claiborne Avenue Redevelopment Study: A University of New Orleans Analysis of Best Practices and Public Opinion" (2011). UNOTI Publications. Paper 9. https://scholarworks.uno.edu/unoti_pubs/9 This Study is brought to you for free and open access by the UNO Transportation Institute at ScholarWorks@UNO. It has been accepted for inclusion in UNOTI Publications by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UNO. For more information, please contact [email protected]. New Orleans Claiborne Avenue Redevelopment Study A University of New Orleans Analysis of Best Practices and Public Opinion MURP 4062: Applied Techniques for Transportation Planning, Spring 2011 August 2011 Professor John Renne, Ph.D., AICP | Alena Anderson | Emilie Bahr | Peter Bennett | Timothy Brathwaite| Luis Cabrera| Casey Chimento | Christopher Clark | Jennifer Clark | Jennifer Dhir | Lachea Deamicis | Jonathan Dodson | Morgan Ford | Nicolette Jones | Taylor Marcantel | Mariana Marmol | Sophie O’Neill| Robert Pamplin | Marc Santos | Carl Seifert| Vivek Shah | Tara Tolford | Max Williamson New Orleans Claiborne Avenue Redevelopment Study Table of Contents Executive Summary
    [Show full text]
  • Distribution Agreement
    Distribution agreement In presenting this thesis or dissertation as a partial fulfillment of the requirements for an advanced degree from Emory University, I hereby grant to Emory University and its agents the non-exclusive license to archive, make accessible, and display my thesis or dissertation in whole or in part in all forms of media, now or hereafter known, including display on the world wide web. I understand that I may select some access restrictions as part of the online submission of this thesis or dissertation. I retain all ownership rights to the copyright of the thesis or dissertation. I also retain the right to use in future works (such as articles or books) all or part of this thesis or dissertation. Signature: __________________________________ _________ Matthew L. Miller Date Bounce: Rap Music and Local Identity in New Orleans, 1980-2005 By Matt Miller Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Institute of Liberal Arts American Studies _________________________________________ Allen E. Tullos, Advisor _________________________________________ Timothy J. Dowd Committee Member _________________________________________ Anna Grimshaw Committee Member Accepted: _________________________________________ Lisa A. Tedesco, Ph.D. Dean of the Graduate School __________ Date Bounce: Rap Music and Local Identity in New Orleans, 1980-2005 By Matt Miller B.A., Emory University, 1992 Advisor: Prof. Allen E. Tullos, Ph.D. An abstract of A dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Emory University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Institute of the Liberal Arts 2009 Abstract Bounce: Rap Music and Local Identity in New Orleans, 1980-2005 By Matt Miller Through a detailed, chronological examination of rap’s emergence and establishment in New Orleans, this dissertation shows how music and a sense of place are engaged in a dynamic relationship of mutual influence.
    [Show full text]
  • Twice Displaced: Katrina and the Redevelopment of the Magnolia
    University of New Orleans ScholarWorks@UNO University of New Orleans Theses and Dissertations Dissertations and Theses Fall 12-18-2015 Twice Displaced: Katrina and the Redevelopment of the Magnolia Gabriella A. Garza University of New Orleans, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.uno.edu/td Part of the Sociology Commons Recommended Citation Garza, Gabriella A., "Twice Displaced: Katrina and the Redevelopment of the Magnolia" (2015). University of New Orleans Theses and Dissertations. 2075. https://scholarworks.uno.edu/td/2075 This Thesis is protected by copyright and/or related rights. It has been brought to you by ScholarWorks@UNO with permission from the rights-holder(s). You are free to use this Thesis in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights- holder(s) directly, unless additional rights are indicated by a Creative Commons license in the record and/or on the work itself. This Thesis has been accepted for inclusion in University of New Orleans Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UNO. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Twice Displaced: Katrina and the Redevelopment of the Magnolia A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the University of New Orleans in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Sociology By Gabriella Garza B.A. San Francisco State University, 2012 December 2015 Acknowledgements I would like to extend my utmost gratitude to my mentor and chair throughout this process, Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • New Orleans Affordable Housing Assessment
    NEW ORLEANS AFFORDABLE HOUSING ASSESSMENT: LESSONS LEARNED A REPORT ON THE RESPONSES TO HURRICANES KATRINA, RITA AND WILMA AND THEIR EFFECT ON THE STATE OF HOUSING Presented to Mercy Corps by David Schrayer July 2007 Introduction In late August 2005, hurricane Katrina tore through the central gulf coast of the United States. The infamous storm was the largest natural disaster in United States history. The total impact to the area is difficult to calculate and almost impossible to comprehend. Damages to the area have been estimated at up to $200 billion-- an order of magnitude higher than any other U.S. natural disaster. More than one million people became displaced, creating a diaspora covering 50 states and several countries. Up to 300,000 homes were significantly damaged or destroyed. The storm demolished the majority of housing in New Orleans and uprooted over 80 percent of its 450,000 citizens. As of June 2007, according to estimates based on postal deliveries, the population had risen to only 64% of pre-Katrina levels. Some of New Orleans’ poorest communities suffered the worst devastation, including the Lower Ninth Ward and the Florida/Desire neighborhood. Damages to infrastructure-- including bridges, highways and roads, utilities, police and fire stations, schools, hospitals and energy generation and refining plants-- will take decades to rebuild completely. The extensive flooding to New Orleans caused by multiple breeches to its levee system triggered mandatory evacuations for several weeks. This process was repeated when hurricane Rita hit only three weeks later. This paper will focus on the impact of the storms, efforts to rebuild New Orleans housing stock, and the hurdles to creating affordability in housing in general.
    [Show full text]