DOCSLIB.ORG

July 2015 Sentencing for Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Contexts

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
July 2015 Sentencing for Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Contexts Report for the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse JULY 2015 SENTENCING FOR CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE IN INSTITUTIONAL CONTEXTS ARIE FREIBERG FACULTY OF LAW, MONASH UNIVERSITY HUGH DONNELLY JUDICIAL COMMISSION OF NEW SOUTH WALES KAREN GELB CONSULTANT CRIMINOLOGIST Sentencing for Child Sexual Abuse in Institutional Contexts Arie Freiberg Emeritus Professor, Faculty of Law, Monash University Hugh Donnelly Director, Research and Sentencing, Judicial Commission of New South Wales Karen Gelb Consultant Criminologist July 2015 The Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse commissioned and funded this research project. The following researchers carried it out: Arie Freiberg, LLD Hugh Donnelly, LLM Karen Gelb, PhD Disclaimer The views and findings expressed in this report are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of the Royal Commission, or of the Judicial Commission of NSW. This report reflects the law as at 1 May 2015. Copyright information Freiberg, A, Donnelly, H and Gelb, K, 2015, Sentencing for Child Sexual Assault in Institutional Contexts, Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Sydney. ISBN: 978-1-925289-20-6 © Commonwealth of Australia 2015 All material in this report is provided under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Australia licence. Please see www.creativecommons.org/licenses for conditions and the full legal code relating to this licence. Published date July 2015 Preface On Friday, 11 January 2013, the Governor-General appointed a six-member Royal Commission to inquire into how institutions with a responsibility for children have managed and responded to allegations and instances of child sexual abuse. The Royal Commission is tasked with investigating where systems have failed to protect children, and making recommendations on how to improve laws, policies and practices to prevent and better respond to child sexual abuse in institutions. The Royal Commission has developed a comprehensive research program to support its work and to inform its findings and recommendations. The program focuses on eight themes: 1. Why does child sexual abuse occur in institutions? 2. How can child sexual abuse in institutions be prevented? 3. How can child sexual abuse be better identified? 4. How should institutions respond when child sexual abuse has occurred? 5. How should government and statutory authorities respond? 6. What are the treatment and support needs of victims/survivors and their families? 7. What is the history of particular institutions of interest? 8. How do we ensure the Royal Commission has a positive impact? This research report falls within theme five. The research program means the Royal Commission can: obtain relevant background information fill key evidence gaps explore what is known and what works develop recommendations that are informed by evidence, can be implemented and respond to contemporary issues. For more on this program visit: www.childabuseroyalcommission.gov.au/research Executive Summary............................................................................................... 1 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 1 The scope of this report ................................................................................. 1 Sentencing and the Criminal Justice System ....................................................... 1 Sentencing and attrition rates........................................................................ 1 Purposes of Sentencing ..................................................................................... 2 Sentencing Factors ............................................................................................ 2 Sentencing Standards ........................................................................................ 4 The Institutional CSA Sentencing Study .......................................................... 4 Perceptions of Child Sexual Abuse Offences, Sentencing and Sanctions.............. 5 Ancillary Orders and Special Provisions for Sex Offenders .................................. 6 Institutional Offending: The Limits of the Law.................................................... 7 Chapter 1 .............................................................................................................. 9 Sentencing: Background and Context .................................................................... 9 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 9 The scope of this report ............................................................................... 10 Definitions................................................................................................... 12 Child sexual abuse in institutions ................................................................. 13 Sentencing individualism ............................................................................. 14 Dangerousness, Sex Offenders and Sentencing ................................................ 15 Sentencing and the Criminal Justice System ..................................................... 18 Sentencing and attrition rates...................................................................... 18 Prosecution and victims ............................................................................... 19 Sentencing and prosecution ......................................................................... 20 Charge negotiations generally ..................................................................... 21 Delay in charging and stay of proceedings .................................................... 22 Overcharging and severance ........................................................................ 24 Representative charges ............................................................................... 25 Rolled-up charges ........................................................................................ 28 Taking admitted offences into account ........................................................ 30 Chapter 2 ............................................................................................................ 36 Principles and Purposes of Sentencing ................................................................. 36 Purposes of Sentencing ................................................................................... 36 Just deserts/proportionality ........................................................................ 37 Victoria ............................................................................................................. 38 South Australia ................................................................................................. 38 Denunciation ............................................................................................... 39 Deterrence .................................................................................................. 42 Community protection ................................................................................ 45 Victoria ............................................................................................................. 46 South Australia ................................................................................................. 46 Tasmania .......................................................................................................... 47 Queensland ...................................................................................................... 47 Northern Territory ........................................................................................... 48 Western Australia ............................................................................................ 48 Rehabilitation .............................................................................................. 48 Victims, restoration and reparation ............................................................. 50 Effectiveness ................................................................................................... 50 Chapter 3 ............................................................................................................ 52 Sentencing Factors .............................................................................................. 52 Introduction .................................................................................................... 52 The Nature of the Crime .................................................................................. 52 Maximum penalty ....................................................................................... 52 Culpability and degree of responsibility ....................................................... 58 Effect of mental disorder ............................................................................. 58 Prior sexual abuse ....................................................................................... 60 Vow of celibacy ........................................................................................... 60 Method of commission: grooming ............................................................... 61 Commonwealth ................................................................................................ 61 Victoria ............................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Introduction
    INTRODUCTION In August 2002 Mr George Birmingham SC presented a preliminary report on child sexual abuse involving Roman Catholic priests in the Diocese of Ferns to the Minister for Health and Children. Mr Birmingham had been asked by the Minister to investigate the background to allegations of child sexual abuse in the Diocese with a view to recommending an appropriate form and Terms of Reference for an Inquiry to inquire into the issue. As recommended by Mr Birmingham, the Minister for Health and Children established a non-statutory private inquiry to investigate allegations or complaints of child sexual abuse which were made against clergy operating under the aegis of the Diocese of Ferns. The Ferns Inquiry was established as a three-person team under the chairmanship of Mr Justice Francis D Murphy, formerly of the Supreme Court. The two other members of the Inquiry are: Dr Helen Buckley, senior lecturer in the Department of Social Studies, Trinity College, Dublin; and Dr Laraine Joyce, deputy director of the Office for Health Management. The Inquiry was formally established by the Minister for Health and Children on 28 March 2003. Counsel to the Inquiry was Mr Sean Ryan SC and Mr Declan Doyle SC. Mr Ryan was nominated as a Judge of the High Court in September 2003 and was succeeded by Mr Finbarr Fox SC. The Secretrary to the Inquiry was Mrs Marian Shanley BCL Solicitor. Solicitor to the Inquiry was Mr Joseph O’Malley BCL LLM Solicitor, of Hayes Solicitors, Lavery House, Earlsfort Terrace, Dublin 2. The Inquiry was assisted in its work by the following people: Stephen O’Brien BA, Administrative Officer of the Department of Health and Children; David Begley, Clerical Officer of the Department of Health and Children.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposed Inquiry Into the Handling of Allegations of Child Sex Abuse Relating to the Diocese of Ferns
    Proposed inquiry into the handling of allegations into child sex abuse relating to the Diocese of Ferns Item Type Report Authors Department of Health and Children;Birmingham, George Citation Department of Health and Children, Birmingham, George. 2002. Proposed inquiry into the handling of allegations into child sex abuse relating to the Diocese of Ferns. Dublin: Department of Health and Children. Publisher Department of Health and Children Download date 01/10/2021 10:16:39 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10147/575375 Find this and similar works at - http://www.lenus.ie/hse Proposed Inquiry into the Handling of Allegations of Child Sex Abuse Relating to the Diocese of Ferns A Report to Mr MicheaI Martin TD Minister for Health & Children by Mr George Birmingham SC 1 August 2002 CONTENTS Part I Introduction Background 1 Terms of reference Staffing 2 Disclosures 2 Options 3 Part II Methodology Introduction 4 Current and past inquiries 4 interviews with victims 5 Church co-operation 6 Garda and health board co-operation 8 Interviews with cross-section of interested parties 8 Part III An overview of the factual backdrop Introduction 10 The term 'child sex abuse' 11 Forms of reference to parties 11 Priest' A' 12 Priest' B' 12 Priest 'C' 13 Priest '0': Fr James Grennan 16 Priest' E' 22 Priest 'F': Monsignor Miceal Ledwith 28 Priest 'G' 43 Priest' H' 44 Priest'j': Fr Sean Fortune 49 Priest 'K': Fr Donal Collins 63 Priest'L' 66 Part IV Bishop Brendan Comiskey's response and related issues Introduction 67 Bishop Comiskey's approach to complaints
    [Show full text]
  • How the Catholic Church Sexual Abuse Crisis Changed Private Law
    CARDINAL SINS: HOW THE CATHOLIC CHURCH SEXUAL ABUSE CRISIS CHANGED PRIVATE LAW MAYO MORAN* ABSTRACT For several decades now, the unfolding of the Catholic Church sexual abuse crisis has been front-page news. It has wreaked havoc on hundreds of thousands of lives, cost the Church billions of dollars, and done irreparable harm to a once-revered institution. Along the way, it has also helped to transform the all- important private law of responsibility. When the crisis began to break in the early 1980s, the few survivors who sought legal redress faced a daunting array of obstacles. Limitations periods alone had the effect of barring almost all child sexual abuse claims. Immunities also helped to shield the Church. Private law itself was generally hostile to institutional liability, particularly where the harm resulted from the criminal act of an individual. All of that has changed. Among the catalysts for change within private law, the Catholic Church sex abuse crisis looms large. The scale of the crisis and the universal nature of the Church were certainly both important factors, but so too was the Church's response. From the initial impulse to cover up instances of abuse to choices made in the legal and political arenas, it appeared willing to do almost anything to protect itself. Yet the Church had traditionally bene®ted from special treatment precisely on the ground that it was not an ordinary, self-interested legal actor. The tension between the Church's mission and its approach to covering up abuse began to attract notice. Courts and legislators were prompted to act.
    [Show full text]
  • Barriers to Truth Recovery in the Aftermath of Institutional Child Abuse in Ireland
    An Inconvenient Truth: Barriers to Truth Recovery in the Aftermath of Institutional Child Abuse in Ireland McAlinden, A-M. (2013). An Inconvenient Truth: Barriers to Truth Recovery in the Aftermath of Institutional Child Abuse in Ireland. Legal Studies, 33(2), 189-214. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-121X.2012.00243.x Published in: Legal Studies Document Version: Peer reviewed version Queen's University Belfast - Research Portal: Link to publication record in Queen's University Belfast Research Portal General rights Copyright for the publications made accessible via the Queen's University Belfast Research Portal is retained by the author(s) and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy The Research Portal is Queen's institutional repository that provides access to Queen's research output. Every effort has been made to ensure that content in the Research Portal does not infringe any person's rights, or applicable UK laws. If you discover content in the Research Portal that you believe breaches copyright or violates any law, please contact [email protected]. Download date:24. Sep. 2021 Legal Studies, 2012 DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-121X.2012.00243.x An inconvenient truth: barriers to truth recovery in the aftermath of institutional child abuse in Irelandlest_243 1..26 Anne-Marie McAlinden* School of Law, Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland Contemporary settled democracies, including the USA, England and Wales and Ireland, have witnessed a string of high-profile cases of institutional child abuse in both Church and State settings.
    [Show full text]
  • Roman Catholic Church in Ireland 1990-2010
    The Paschal Dimension of the 40 Days as an interpretive key to a reading of the new and serious challenges to faith in the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland 1990-2010 Kevin Doherty Doctor of Philosophy 2011 MATER DEI INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION A College of Dublin City University The Paschal Dimension of the 40 Days as an interpretive key to a reading of the new and serious challenges to faith in the Roman Catholic Church in Ireland 1990-2010 Kevin Doherty M.A. (Spirituality) Moderator: Dr Brendan Leahy, DD Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 2011 DECLARATION I hereby certify that this material, which I now submit for assessment on the programme of study leading to the award of Ph.D. is entirely my own work and has not been taken from the work of others save and to the extent that such work has been cited and acknowledged within the text of my work. ID No: 53155831 Date: ' M l 2 - 0 1 DEDICATION To my parents Betty and Donal Doherty. The very first tellers of the Easter Story to me, and always the most faithful tellers of that Story. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS A special thanks to all in the Diocese of Rockville Centre in New York who gave generously of their time and experience to facilitate this research: to Msgr Bob Brennan (Vicar General), Sr Mary Alice Piil (Director of Faith Formation), Marguerite Goglia (Associate Director, Children and Youth Formation), Lee Hlavecek, Carol Tannehill, Fr Jim Mannion, Msgr Bill Hanson. Also, to Fr Neil Carlin of the Columba Community in Donegal and Derry, a prophet of the contemporary Irish Church.
    [Show full text]
  • Theorising Gender Justice in the Context of Catholic Clerical Child Sexual Abuse in Ireland and Australia
    2016 Thematic: Responsibility and Redress 779 14 RESPONSIBILITY AND REDRESS: THEORISING GENDER JUSTICE IN THE CONTEXT OF CATHOLIC CLERICAL CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE IN IRELAND AND AUSTRALIA KATE GLEESON* I INTRODUCTION Justice for survivors of institutional child sexual abuse is a defining theme of this age. Inspired by remedies associated with transitional justice and human rights abuses, various governments have sought to investigate and make amends for institutional child abuse perpetrated in the context of welfare and services provided on behalf of states, often by autonomous organisations such as Christian churches. The investigatory-commission model of justice predicated on individual ‘truth recovery’ and restorative outcomes for survivors has predominated since the Republic of Ireland’s Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (‘Ryan Commission’) commenced in 1999.1 Internationally, outcomes for complainants have varied, with all investigatory bodies and redress schemes facing limitations regarding the forms and functions of justice that may be delivered at the meta level of state apparatus.2 In some countries, much more than others, civil justice has been delivered as the outcome of mass and individual lawsuits brought against religious organisations and individuals with a duty of care to protect children.3 In general, the international institutional child abuse scandal of the past 30 years presents a conundrum concerning the ways in which sexual harms are understood. Institutional child abuse has been a feature perhaps * [email protected]. Senior Lecturer, Macquarie Law School. Earlier versions of this article were presented to the International Conference on Public Policy, Milan; the University of Technology Sydney, Feminist Legal Research Group; and the Macquarie Law School Staff Seminar Series.
    [Show full text]
  • Post-Catholic Ireland in Literature and Popular Culture
    P O S T - C A T H O L I C I R E L A N D I N L I T E R A T U R E A N D POPULAR CULTURE Lisa McGonigle A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand April 2013 ABSTRACT This thesis proposes the concept of turn-of-the-millennium Irish culture as “post-Catholic”. It outlines how the Catholic Church had occupied so powerful a position in the post- independent Irish State, but recent decades have seen such profound changes in the moral and political authority ceded to the Church. This thesis therefore argues that the dissolution of the Church’s hegemony constitutes a paradigm sociopolitical and cultural shift, which it defines as the move from a Catholic to post-Catholic society. It also argues that this shift has been both reflected in and effected by literature and popular culture, focusing in particular on issues of gender and sexuality in selected cultural texts. Chapter One examines how Marian Keyes uses the chick-lit novel to write back against conservative Catholicism and the maternalisation of Irish women, supplanting the “Irish Catholic Mammy” with a younger, sexually active generation of Irish women who do not define their subjectivity in terms of their maternal duties. It argues that Keyes’ hostility towards the Catholic Church affects, indeed directs, the sexual politics and frankness of her work and her treatment of topics such as abortion and divorce. Chapter Two investigates how popular novelist Maeve Binchy explores female sexuality and desire in opposition to a traditional Catholic discourse of sin and virtue.
    [Show full text]
  • Clergy Sexual Abuse
    CLERGY SEXUAL ABUSE BIBLIOGRAPHY OF SELECTED SOURCES RELATED TO CLERGY SEXUAL ABUSE, ECCLESIASTICAL POLITICS, THEOLOGY AND CHURCH HISTORY Thomas P. Doyle Revised May 3, 2015, 2015 1 CONTENTS SEXUAL ABUSE BY CLERGY: BOOKS ..................................................................................3 SEXUAL ABUSE BY CLERGY: ARTICLES .........................................................................15 TOXIC RELIGION, NON-BELIEF AND CLERICALISM ...................................................23 THEOLOGICAL AND GENERAL: BOOKS ..........................................................................30 THEOLOGICAL AND GENERAL: ARTICLES ....................................................................40 SOCIOLOGY AND PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION: BOOKS .............................................43 CANON LAW: BOOKS ..............................................................................................................46 CANON LAW: ARTICLES .......................................................................................................48 CANON LAW AND PROPERTY OWNERSHIP: ARTICLES .............................................54 CIVIL LAW: BOOKS .................................................................................................................56 CIVIL LAW: ARTICLES ...........................................................................................................57 HISTORY: BOOKS ....................................................................................................................66
    [Show full text]
  • Doyle Bibliography
    CLERGY SEXUAL ABUSE BIBLIOGRAPHY OF SELECTED SOURCES RELATED TO CLERGY SEXUAL ABUSE, ECCLESIASTICAL POLITICS, THEOLOGY AND CHURCH HISTORY Thomas Patrick Doyle Revised June 20, 2021 1 PREFACE This bibliography started off as a 5-page table of references for a report I was asked to prepare for an attorney. The subject of the report was general prior knowledge of bishops and popes of sexual abuse of children minors by Catholic clergy. Shortly after this report had been circulated among some attorneys, I was asked to prepare variations on it. This entailed expanding the table of resources. My original motivation for the bibliography was for strictly private use: I had been collecting articles, scholarly and otherwise, since the emergence of the sexual abuse issue in 1984. I also began buying books about clergy sexual abuse once they started coming out. The very first book that I am aware of that was written about Catholic clergy sexual abuse was Assault on Innocence, written by Hilary Stiles and published in 1987. Hilary Stiles was the pseudonym used by Jeanne Miller. Jeanne is one of the original courageous pioneers who challenged the Catholic hierarchy (The Archdiocese of Chicago) and founded one of the two original victim support and action groups. Originally known as Vocal the name was later changed to The Linkup. The following year I discovered a second book, Clergy Malpractice, written by the late Robert McMenamin and published in 1988. Robert had been a Church attorney who switched and began representing victims. The bibliography began to grow as I purchased every book I could find related to clergy sexual abuse.
    [Show full text]
  • Donnelly Sins of the Father.Pdf
    Edinburgh Research Explorer Sins of the father Citation for published version: Donnelly, S 2016, 'Sins of the father: Unravelling moral authority in the Irish Catholic Church', Irish Journal of Sociology, vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 315-339. https://doi.org/10.7227/IJS.0009 Digital Object Identifier (DOI): 10.7227/IJS.0009 Link: Link to publication record in Edinburgh Research Explorer Document Version: Peer reviewed version Published In: Irish Journal of Sociology Publisher Rights Statement: The final version of this paper has been published in Irish Journal of Sociology, 24/3, December/2016 by SAGE Publications Ltd, All rights reserved. © Susie Donnelly, 2016. It is available at: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.7227/IJS.0009 General rights Copyright for the publications made accessible via the Edinburgh Research Explorer is retained by the author(s) and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy The University of Edinburgh has made every reasonable effort to ensure that Edinburgh Research Explorer content complies with UK legislation. If you believe that the public display of this file breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 01. Oct. 2021 Sins of the Father: Unravelling Moral Authority in the Irish Catholic Church Susie Donnelly1 Abstract It was not until the mid-1990s that the extent of child abuse within the Irish Catholic Church began to be investigated and reported by the Irish media, yet why did take it take so long for these scandals to emerge? This article analyses how the Irish media investigated and reported on the Irish Catholic Church from a socio historical perspective.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Introduction Satanic Apologetics and the Church Sex Abuse Scandal a branch of Christian theological studies called “apolo- getics,” which is the art of refuting criticisms directed against the orthodox interpretation of Christian scripture. Unfortunately, many people whose religious interests could be classified as ‘occult’ also feel the need to resort to “apologetics” when con- fronted by an orthodox Christian with the “Satanic” nature of their beliefs. They claim that there is nothing “Satanic” or “Lucife- rian” about their interests, and that the Christians are simply “mis- interpreting” an ancient tradition that predates the concepts of both Christ and the Devil. Some even claim to be more truly ‘Christian’ than their detractors, throwing around New Age terms like “Christ-consciousness.” The worst perpetrators of “Satanic apologetics” are those who openly call themselves “Satanists,” especially members of the Church of Satan. These people claim to speak for the Satanic tra- dition, and yet they relegate Satan to the position of an “arche- type” with no real existence. To them, Satan merely represents ‘intellectual rebellion.’ Their beliefs are, at bottom, atheistic, and if they worship anyone, it is themselves. What is really annoying is how Church of Satan members assume that all other followers of Satanic traditions are like they are. Thus the practice of Satanic apologetics spreads to the “debunking” of phenomena like Satanic human sacrifice, Satanic Ritual Abuse, and Satanic conspiracy theories. Recently, a Church of Satan rep- resentative appeared on Linda Vester’s ‘Dayside’ show on Fox 2 lucifer’s lodge News, debunking the notion that Laci Peterson could have been killed by Satanists.
    [Show full text]
  • Suing the Pope and Scandalising the People: Irish Attitudes to Sexual Abuse by Clergy Pre-And Post-Screening of a Critical Documentary
    Irish Communication Review Volume 11 Issue 1 Article 6 January 2009 Suing the Pope and Scandalising the People: Irish Attitudes to Sexual Abuse by Clergy Pre-and post-screening of a Critical Documentary Michael J. Breen Hannah McGee Ciaran O'Boyle Helen Goode Eoin Devereux Follow this and additional works at: https://arrow.tudublin.ie/icr Part of the Communication Technology and New Media Commons Recommended Citation Breen, Michael J.; McGee, Hannah; O'Boyle, Ciaran; Goode, Helen; and Devereux, Eoin (2009) "Suing the Pope and Scandalising the People: Irish Attitudes to Sexual Abuse by Clergy Pre-and post-screening of a Critical Documentary," Irish Communication Review: Vol. 11: Iss. 1, Article 6. doi:10.21427/D7JD9Q Available at: https://arrow.tudublin.ie/icr/vol11/iss1/6 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Current Publications at ARROW@TU Dublin. It has been accepted for inclusion in Irish Communication Review by an authorized administrator of ARROW@TU Dublin. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 4.0 License ‘SUING THE POPE’ AND SCANDALISING THE PEOPLE : Irish Attitudes to Sexual Abuse by Clergy Pre- and Post-Screening of a Critical Documentary Michael J. Breen, Hannah McGee, Ciaran O’Boyle, Helen Goode & Eoin Devereux Introduction THE SEXUAL ABUSE OF children became a significant public issue in Ireland in the s, with frequent media reports about the issue. In the main these focused on the issue of abuse of children by members of the clergy and religious orders.
    [Show full text]