Cumulative Impacts of Hurricanes on Florida Mangrove Ecosystems: Sediment Deposition, Storm Surges and Vegetation Author(S): Thomas J
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Cumulative Impacts of Hurricanes on Florida Mangrove Ecosystems: Sediment Deposition, Storm Surges and Vegetation Author(s): Thomas J. Smith III, Gordon H. Anderson, Karen Balentine, Ginger Tiling, Greg A. Ward, and Kevin R. T. Whelan Source: Wetlands, 29(1):24-34. Published By: The Society of Wetland Scientists DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1672/08-40.1 URL: http://www.bioone.org/doi/full/10.1672/08-40.1 BioOne (www.bioone.org) is a nonprofit, online aggregation of core research in the biological, ecological, and environmental sciences. BioOne provides a sustainable online platform for over 170 journals and books published by nonprofit societies, associations, museums, institutions, and presses. Your use of this PDF, the BioOne Web site, and all posted and associated content indicates your acceptance of BioOne’s Terms of Use, available at www.bioone.org/page/terms_of_use. Usage of BioOne content is strictly limited to personal, educational, and non-commercial use. Commercial inquiries or rights and permissions requests should be directed to the individual publisher as copyright holder. BioOne sees sustainable scholarly publishing as an inherently collaborative enterprise connecting authors, nonprofit publishers, academic institutions, research libraries, and research funders in the common goal of maximizing access to critical research. WETLANDS, Vol. 29, No. 1, March 2009, pp. 24–34 ’ 2009, The Society of Wetland Scientists CUMULATIVE IMPACTS OF HURRICANES ON FLORIDA MANGROVE ECOSYSTEMS: SEDIMENT DEPOSITION, STORM SURGES AND VEGETATION Thomas J. Smith III1,GordonH.Anderson2, Karen Balentine2,GingerTiling3,GregA.Ward4,and Kevin R. T. Whelan5 1U.S. Geological Survey, Florida Integrated Science Center, 600 Fourth Street South, Saint Petersburg, Florida, USA 33701. E-mail: [email protected] 2U.S. Geological Survey, Florida Integrated Science Center, Everglades Field Station, 40001 SR 9336, Homestead, Florida, USA 33034 3Jacobs Technology, Inc., c/o 600 Fourth Street South, Saint Petersburg, Florida, USA 33701 4Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc., 2481 Boca Raton Blvd., Boca Raton, Florida, USA 33431 5U.S. National Park Service, South Florida – Caribbean Inventory and Monitoring Network, 18001 Old Cutler Road, Suite 419, Palmetto Bay, Florida, USA 33157 Abstract: Hurricanes have shaped the structure of mangrove forests in the Everglades via wind damage, storm surges and sediment deposition. Immediate effects include changes to stem size-frequency distributions and to species relative abundance and density. Long-term impacts to mangroves are poorly understood at present. We examine impacts of Hurricane Wilma on mangroves and compare the results to findings from three previous storms (Labor Day, Donna, Andrew). Surges during Wilma destroyed < 1,250 ha of mangroves and set back recovery that started following Andrew. Data from permanent plots affected by Andrew and Wilma showed no differences among species or between hurricanes for % stem mortality or % basal area lost. Hurricane damage was related to hydro-geomorphic type of forest. Basin mangroves suffered significantly more damage than riverine or island mangroves. The hurricane by forest type interaction was highly significant. Andrew did slightly more damage to island mangroves. Wilma did significantly more damage to basin forests. This is most likely a result of the larger and more spatially extensive storm surge produced by Wilma. Forest damage was not related to amount of sediment deposited. Analyses of reports from Donna and the Labor Day storm indicate that some sites have recovered following catastrophic disturbance. Other sites have been permanently converted into a different ecosystem, namely intertidal mudflats. Our results indicate that mangroves are not in a steady state as has been recently claimed. Key Words: basal area, ecosystem change, Hurricane Andrew, Hurricane Donna, Hurricane Wilma, Labor Day Storm, mortality, persistence, stability, steady state INTRODUCTION from hurricane storm surges resulted in mangrove mortality. The deposited materials interfere with Hurricanes impact mangrove forests through root and soil gas exchange leading to eventual death three primary mechanisms: wind damage, storm of the trees. Prolonged flooding from water remain- surges, and sediment deposition. High winds snap ing after the storm surge may have a similar effect. and topple stems, break off branches, and defoliate The damage inflicted by each of these mechanisms the canopy (Smith et al. 1994, Doyle et al. 1995). As often varies according to species of mangrove (Smith a storm surge comes ashore stems taller may be 1992, Woodroffe and Grime 1999, Imbert et al. uprooted and knocked over, yet when covered by 2000, Sherman et al. 2001). Descriptions of hurri- the surge, shorter stems may be protected from the cane impacts on mangroves have been reported hurricane’s winds (Smith et al. 1994). Storm surges many times in the literature. Rollet (1981) listed .30 carry suspended sediment that is deposited on the reports published prior to 1976. Since then, the forest floor as the surge recedes (Risi et al. 1995). number of descriptive articles has increased sub- The impact of sediment deposition in the forest stantially. depends on the depth and type of sediment Only recently, however, have studies appeared deposited. Craighead and Gilbert (1962) and Ellison that followed mangrove forest recovery using (1998) reported that very fine sediments deposited repeated measures over time from permanent forest 24 Smith et al., CUMULATIVE HURRICANE IMPACTS ON MANGROVES 25 plots. A value of a permanent plot network is that was related to damage from previous hurricanes. cumulative impacts can be measured accurately over Additionally, because mangrove forest structure is time (Smith 2002). Imbert et al. (1996, 2000) studied the result of hydrology and geomorphic setting the impact of Hurricane Hugo on the mangroves of (Woodroffe 1994, Twilley and Rivera-Monroy Guadeloupe over an eight year period. Baldwin et al. 2005), we specifically tested the hypothesis that (2001) examined regeneration dynamics in man- damage varied according to hydro-geomorphic type groves recovering from Hurricane Andrew in of mangrove forest (e.g., basin, island, riverine). southeast Florida over a seven year period. Ward Finally, we use historic reports concerning impacts et al. (2006) worked on the southwest coast of from Hurricane Donna and the Labor Day Hurri- Florida and reported on 13 yrs of recovery following cane to examine cumulative impacts. Hurricane Andrew. Our study represents an oppor- tunity to examine cumulative impacts of repeated hurricanes over time using permanent research plots METHODS in mangroves. We began work on the southwest Study Area coast of Florida immediately following the passage of Hurricane Andrew in August 1992 (Smith et al. The study area comprises the far southwest coast 1994). All of the plots that were established of Florida from Flamingo north to Panther Key and following Hurricane Andrew were impacted by lies mostly within Everglades National Park (Fig- Hurricane Wilma in October 2005. Prior to our ure 1). Included are Big Sable Creek (BSC), a large work, the southwest coastal Everglades had been tidal creek system with little freshwater runoff, and struck by the Labor Day Storm of 1935 (Reimann the Shark, Harney, Broad, Lostmans, and Chatham 1940), and Hurricane Donna in 1960 (Craighead Rivers that drain the major freshwater sloughs of the and Gilbert 1962). The Labor Day Storm was the Everglades. Approximately 10 to 20 km upstream first Saffir-Simpson Scale category 5 storm to hit the from the Gulf of Mexico the rivers enter a series of United States and Hurricane Donna was a category shallow, interconnected bays. This mosaic of tidal 4 (Houston and Powell 2003). These two storms rivers and bays breaks the coastal zone up into a followed relatively similar and parallel tracks. They network of large islands that comprise the southern moved northwest crossing the middle Florida Keys. portion of the 10,000 Islands (Schomer and Drew Hurricane Donna crossed Cape Sable and then re- 1982). The intertidal vegetation is comprised pri- curved and made landfall near Naples, Florida marily of mangrove forests with Rhizophora mangle (Dunn 1961). The Labor Day Storm passed west of L., Laguncularia racemosa (L.) Gaertn. f., and Cape Sable, then moved northward off the west Avicennia germinans (L.) Stearn all present in Florida coastline and made landfall near Cedar Key varying abundance. The interiors of the largest (McDonald 1935). Hurricane Andrew made landfall islands are composed of brackish and freshwater on the southeast Florida coast as a Category 5 marshes dominated by Spartina bakeri Merr., storm, crossed the Florida peninsula, and exited into Cladium jamaicense Crantz, and Juncus roemerianus the Gulf of Mexico just north of the Lostmans River L. Tidal amplitudes range from 1–1.7 m and there is as a Category 4 storm (Landsea et al. 2004). a marked annual variation in sea-level of 25 cm, Andrew’s forward motion was rapid (< 35 km/hr) with the high in October and the low in February and it had a small, compact eye, only some 32 km in (Stumpf and Haines 1998). width (Mayfield et al. 1994). Hurricane Wilma approached south Florida from the southwest and Storm Surges made landfall near Everglades City as a Category 3 hurricane (Pasch et al. 2006, Beven et al. 2008). We measured storm surge at four hydrological Wilma had an extremely large eye at landfall, with monitoring stations that comprise a downstream to the northern eyewall passing south of Naples and upstream gradient along the Shark-Harney River the southern eyewall passing over a wide area from system (Figure 1, see Smith 2004). The datum is the Lostmans River south to Cape Sable (Pasch et NAVD88. Big Sable Creek (BSC) is in a short al. 2006). (, 3 km) tidal creek on the northwest corner of The objectives of our study were to: 1) accurately Cape Sable. Some 200 m of mangrove forest and quantify the damage to mangroves from Hurricane 200 m of mudflat separate it from the Gulf of Wilma both extensively over the landscape and Mexico.