11-21-19-BOA-Meeting
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FULTON COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSORS Regular Meeting Agenda November 21, 2019 12:30 PM Call to Order Roll Call 19-1121-100 – Approval of Agenda Invocation 19-1121-101 – Approval of November 7, 2019 Minutes Citizen Time Development Authority of Fulton County 19-1121-102 – ATL FAIRBURN JV LLC 19-1121-103 – Halperns’ Steak and Seafood Company LLC Development Authority of Atlanta 19-1121-104 – Arrowrock II Aerotropolis North LLC – 1st Amendment – BLC Industrial Venture I – CO 6 LLC Section Reports 19-1121-201 – Homestead Exemption Changes Page 5 19-1121-202 – Exemption Approvals Page 18 19-1121-203 – Exemption Denials Page 22 19-1121-204 – Make Taxable Page 25 19-1121-205 – Personal Property Administrative Changes Page 30 19-1121-206 – Personal Property Releases Page 32 19-1121-207 – Commercial Administrative Changes Page 33 19-1121-208 – Residential Administrative Changes Page 38 19-1121-209 – 2016-2018 Appeal No Changes Page 58 19-1121-210 – 2019 Appeal No Changes Page 61 19-1121-211 – 2018 Appeal Value Changes Page 334 19-1121-212 – 2019 Appeal Value Changes Page 335 19-1121-213 – 2019 Appeal Value Changes w/Value Freeze Page 353 19-1121-214 – 2018 Appeal Second Reviews w/Value Freeze Page 354 19-1121-215 – 2019 Appeal Second Reviews w/Value Freeze Page 355 19-1121-216 – 2019 Arbitration No Changes Page 356 19-1121-217 – 2019 Arbitration Appraisal Accepted Page 357 19-1121-218 – 2019 Hearing Officer No Changes Page 358 19-1121-219 – 2019 Hearing Officer Value Changes Page 359 19-1121-220 – 2019 Appeal Withdrawals Page 360 19-1121-221 – 2017 Appeal Pending Withdrawals Page 366 19-2212-222 – 2019 Appeal Pending Withdrawals Page 367 19-1121-223 – 2019 Appeal 299c Value Rolls Page 370 19-1121-224 – 2019 Appeal No Changes (Personal Property) Page 402 19-1121-225 – 2019 Appeal Withdrawals (Personal Property) Page 413 Chief Appraiser’s Report Fulton County Board of Assessors Regular Meeting Minutes – November 07, 2019 Board Member Attendance: Salma Ahmed, Chair; Michael Fitzgerald, Vice-Chair; Edward London, Pamela Smith and Lisa Aman. Staff Attendance: Bradford Fleming Sr., Assistant Secretary/Senior Appraiser; Dwight Robinson, Chief Appraiser; Curtis Broden, Tara Parker & Kevin Whitman, Deputy Chief Appraisers; Vincent Clark, Gaetjens Coreus, Brian Gardner & Corey McDaniel, Appraisal Managers; Florence Brooks, Homestead Manager; Henry Brigham, Information Systems Manager; Jacqueline Davis, Administrative Coordinator; Hasell Brown, Network Specialist; Jessica Corbitt, Department of External Affairs; Cheryl Ringer & Kimberly Alexander, Office of the Fulton County Attorney. Presenters: Sandra Zayac, Lauren Woodyard, Mia Foster – Fulton County Development Authority Salma Ahmed called the meeting to order at 12:35 p.m. 19-1107-100 – Approval of Agenda – Motion to approve: Fitzgerald, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Invocation – Dwight Robinson led the invocation. 19-1107-101 – Approval of October 17, 2019 Minutes – Motion to approve: London, Second: Aman. The motion passed unanimously. Citizens – There were no speaker cards submitted. Fulton County Development Authority 19-1107-102 – Perimeter Project Owner LLC – 1st Amendment – BCDPF Perimeter LLC – Motion to approve: Fitzgerald, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. 19-1107-103 – JLB 99 West Paces Ferry LLC (Series 2019A) – Motion to approve: London, Second: Fitzgerald. The motion passed unanimously. 19-1107-104 - JLB 99 West Paces Ferry LLC (Series 2019B) – Motion to approve: London, Second: Fitzgerald. The motion passed unanimously. Section Reports Motion Second Vote 19-1107-201 – Field Book Changes London Aman Unanimous 19-1107-202 – Homestead Exemption Changes London Aman Unanimous 19-1107-203 – Exemption Aman London Unanimous 19-1107-204 – Special Properties Fitzgerald Aman Unanimous 19-1107-205 – Conservation Use Approvals London Smith Unanimous 19-1107-206 – Personal Property Administrative Changes Fitzgerald London Unanimous 19-1107-207 – Personal Property Releases Smith London Unanimous 19-1107-208 – Residential Administrative Changes Fitzgerald London Unanimous 19-1107-209 – Commercial Administrative Changes Fitzgerald Smith Unanimous 19-1107-210 – 2019 Appeal No Changes Aman London Unanimous 19-1107-211 – 2019 Appeal Value Changes Smith London Unanimous 19-1107-212 – 2019 Appeal Value Changes w/Value Freeze Aman London Unanimous 19-1107-213 – 2019 Appeal Second Reviews w/Value Freeze Fitzgerald Smith Unanimous 19-1107-214 – 2019 Appeal Second Reviews Fitzgerald Aman Unanimous 19-1107-215 – 2019 Hearing Officer ValueFulton Changes BOA Meeting - 11-21-19Smith - Page 2London Unanimous 19-1107-216 – 2019 Arbitration No Changes Fitzgerald Aman Unanimous 19-1107-217 – 2019 Arbitration Value Changes Smith London Unanimous 19-1107-218 – 2019 Arbitration Appraisal Accepted Fitzgerald Smith Unanimous 19-1107-219 – 2019 Appeal Withdrawals Fitzgerald Aman Unanimous 19-1107-220 – 2019 Appeal 229c Value Rolls Fitzgerald London Unanimous 19-1107-221 – 2019 Appeal Value Changes (Personal Property) Fitzgerald Smith Unanimous 19-1107-222 – 2019 Appeal Withdrawals (Personal Property) London Aman Unanimous Additional Items 19-1107-300 – Adoption of 2019 Public Utility Values London Smith Unanimous 19-1107-301 – Approval of 2020 Board Meeting Schedule** Fitzgerald London Unanimous 19-1107-302 – 2018 Comcast Appeals Certified to Sup. Court Aman Fitzgerald Unanimous **This item was tentatively approved pending board members reviewing their 2020 calendars. Pulled Items Parcel Identification Owner Name Year(s) Page # Item # 1 11-0184-0058-060-0 JONES CLARENCE R 2019 105 143 2 11-0242-0122-022-2 LISSO MARK 2019 107 156 3 11-0630-0016-069-2 BAYARD HOMEOWNERS ASSC 2019 121 253 4 11-0631-0018-053-3 THORNHILL HOMEOWNERS ASSC 2019 121 254 5 12-1600-0266-034-5 MANAVI DAVID 2019 126 289 6 12-1907-0387-025-7 GOULDING AT HISTORIC WINDY PINES TRL 2019 127 295 7 12-2400-0611-115-4 ROSWELL MANOR HOMEOWNERS ASSC 2019 133 341 8 12-2400-0611-117-0 ROSWELL MANOR HOMEOWNERS ASSC 2019 133 342 9 12-3200-0890-029-9 SANCTUARY AT RIVERMONT COMMUNITY 2019 150 462 10 22-4190-0195-037-3 BLUE VALLEY COMMUNITY ASSC INC 2019 371 2009 11 22-4190-0195-044-9 BLUE VALLEY INVESTMENTS I LLC 2019 372 2010 12 22-4190-0196-053-9 BLUE VALLEY INVESTMENTS I LLC 2019 372 2011 13 22-4190-0237-043-1 BLUE VALLEY COMMUNITY ASSC INC 2019 372 2012 14 22-4300-0988-075-1 LAKE HAVEN COMMUNICTY ASSC INC 2019 374 2024 15 22-4480-1104-119-6 HEARTHSTONE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSC INC 2019 377 2046 16 22-4640-1105-177-0 HEARTHSTONE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSC INC 2019 380 2069 17 22-4640-1128-139-3 HEARTHSTONE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSC INC 2019 380 2071 18 22-4680-0190-164-7 NORTHPOINT FOREST HOMEOWNERS ASSC 2019 383 2087 19 22-4680-0243-165-1 NORTHPOINT FOREST HOMEOWNERS ASSC 2019 383 2088 20 22-4960-1124-469-0 EDGEMONT ON MAIN TOWNHOME ASSC 2019 387 2118 21 14F-0029- LL-033-4 KIMBERLY ROAD DEVELOPMENT LLC 2019 455 40 Chief Appraiser’s Report - A copy of the report is included with the minutes of this meeting. Executive Session - Motion for executive session to discuss litigation. Aman, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously. Motion to end executive session and return to the regular meeting: Smith, Second: Fitzgerald. The motion passed unanimously. Additional Motions Made 1. Michael Fitzgerald made a motion seconded by Edward London to respond to the James Jones who attended the October 17, 2019 meeting in reference to his request to grant CUVA on his property for tax year 2019. The motion passed unanimously. Fulton BOA Meeting - 11-21-19 - Page 3 2. Lisa Aman made a motion seconded by Edward London to discuss the Chief Appraiser’s performance review document at the November 21, 2019 meeting. The motion passed unanimously. Adjournment: Motion to adjourn: Aman, Second: London. The motion passed unanimously and the meeting was adjourned at 2:45 p.m. Submitted by: Bradford L. Fleming, Sr., Assistant Secretary Fulton BOA Meeting - 11-21-19 - Page 4 11/18/2019 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF HT536GAFUL 21 November, 2019 HEC Homestead Exemption Changes HOMESTEAD DIVISION PARCEL ID OWNER NAME PREVIOUS YEAR REASON CURRENT NOTES CHANGE APPRAISER 1 07 -0200-0047-077-6 GALLEGOS LOPEZ CARMELO 89,000 2019 Continuing occupancy 89,000 APPLIED BEFORE DEADLINE 0 AW 2 07 -3100-0070-079-7 LANDERS MILLARD J & CAROLYN Y 126,200 2019 Homestead removal 126,200 TAXPAYER DECEASED IN 2010 0 FB 3 09F-2703-0123-062-3 ISIDORE DENROY J 202,400 2019 Continuing occupancy 202,400 APPLIED BEFORE DEADLINE 0 AW 4 09F-4000-0160-625-7 AUGUSTUS JAMES JR & 249,000 2019 Homestead removal 249,000 PER TAXPAYER REQUEST 0 AW 5 09F-4000-0161-214-9 LEWIS PAULA M 196,600 2017 Homestead removal 196,600 DOES NOT OCCUPY PROPERTY 0 FB 6 09F-4000-0161-214-9 LEWIS PAULA M 201,100 2018 Homestead removal 201,100 DOES NOT OCCUPY PROPERTY 0 FB 7 09F-4000-0161-214-9 LEWIS PAULA M 205,900 2019 Homestead removal 205,900 DOES NOT OCCUPY PROPERTY 0 FB 1 Fulton BOA Meeting - 11-21-19 - Page 5 11/18/2019 BOARD OF TAX ASSESSORS MEETING OF HT536GAFUL 21 November, 2019 HEC Homestead Exemption Changes HOMESTEAD DIVISION PARCEL ID OWNER NAME PREVIOUS YEAR REASON CURRENT NOTES CHANGE 8 11 -0622-0215-039-4 BRANDT MELANIE D 346,200 2019 Continuing occupancy 346,200 APPLIED BEFORE DEADLINE 0 AW 9 11 -0804-0305-002-3 PEARLSTEIN STEVEN L & 255,500 2017 Homestead removal 255,500 DOES NOT OCCUPY PROPERTY 0 FB 10 11 -0804-0305-002-3 PEARLSTEIN STEVEN L & 316,100 2018 Homestead removal 316,100 DOES NOT OCCUPY PROPERTY 0 FB 11 11 -0804-0305-002-3 PEARLSTEIN STEVEN L & 323,600 2019 Homestead removal 323,600 DOES NOT OCCUPY