Perdue Didn't Pay for State Flights, Either
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INSIDE THIS ISSUE: DEPARTMENTS EPA ‘dust’ North Carolina 2 C A R O L I N A Education 7 regulations Local Government 10 Interview 16 could harm Higher Education 17 agriculture, Books & the Arts 20 Opinion 24 BBQs/6 A MONTHLY JOURNAL OF NEWS, ANALYSIS AND OPINION Parting Shot 28 JOURNALFROM THE JOHN LOCKE FOUNDATION November 2010 Vol. 19 No. 11 STATEWIDE EDITION Check us out online at carolinajournal.com and johnlocke.org Perdue Didn’t Pay For State Flights, Either Gov.’s office says Dozens involved flights were deemed in provider program ‘gifts to the state’ for Perdue, Easley By Don Carrington By Don Carrington Executive Editor Executive Editor RALEIGH RALEIGH Carolina Journal review of 2007- n late October, Gov. Bev Perdue 08 expenditures by the office of confirmed that a federal grand jury then-Lt. Gov. Beverly Perdue has subpoenaed several people Areveals that, in addition to not paying Iconnected to her 2008 campaign. Wake for a number of County District Attorney Colon Wil- campaign-related loughby, who has launched a criminal flights, she also When Perdue flew on official state business in David King’s Cessna Citation jet, investigation of Perdue’s campaign made no pay- pictured above, she didn’t pay him because she considered the flight a gift to the flights and other fundraising issues, ments to private state, her office said on Oct. 27. (Photo courtesy FlightAware.com) said Oct. 22 that several witnesses who aircraft owners for business was treated by the Office of fined the Perdue Committee $30,000 had been talking to him have gone si- travel related to the Lieutenant Governor as a gift to the — $10,000 each for the 2006 general lent, citing the federal probe. official state busi- state from those providing the flights. election, 2008 primary election, and Last year, the elections board ness. Perdue also has acknowledged 2008 general election cycles — for be- fined former Gov. Mike Easley’s cam- Gov. Beverly R e c o r d s that her campaign committee did not latedly reporting and paying for flights paign $100,000 for accepting free flights Perdue show flights that pay a number of aircraft providers for on private aircraft. In September, Wake from Raleigh businessman McQueen were a combina- campaign-related County District Campbell and his family, a violation of tion of official business and campaign airplane travel in a Attorney Colon campaign finance laws. Apparently in events. Perdue spokeswoman Chrissy timely manner. Willoughby asked reaction to the spotlight on Easley, in Pearson acknowledged the flights and Issues with Many reported the State Bureau 2008 Perdue’s committee began paying told CJ that travel provided to Perdue Perdue’s flights of Investigation for some flights and amending cam- when she was conducting official state go back at least to flights involved to ask more ques- paign reports. 2004, but CJ has tions about the The free flight issue is far from not yet requested official state flights. over, as the recent subpoenas of Perdue Perdue records for It’s widely supporters show. Investigators may be 2004-06. business as well suspected that interested in why Perdue waited so Perdue cam- federal investiga- long to report and pay for a number PAID as political paign committee tors, along with of flights, or if the campaign had no RALEIGH, NC U.S. POSTAGE records turned or campaign Willoughby, are intention of paying for them. Federal PERMIT NO. 1766 NONPROFIT ORG. over to the State seeking more in- prosecutors are interested in Easley’s Board of Elec- events formation from a free flights, his real estate deals, and a tions earlier this system of “aircraft lucrative job for his wife at N.C. State year show that she providers” the Bev University. He has not been charged, sometimes used Perdue Committee but several people have been subpoe- privately owned aircraft for trips that had created and who were identified naed to appear in front of a grand jury. were entirely related to official state in elections board reports. Moreover, several people impli- business. On many other flights, she In some cases, the reports found, cated in the Easley investigation also combined official business as lieuten- Perdue reported the flights weeks or had a role in the Perdue campaign. ant governor with political events in months after they took place, a viola- What follows is an alphabetical her quest to become the state’s chief tion of election laws. In other instanc- listing of known aircraft providers for executive. es, the committee claimed flights as Perdue (and in some cases, Easley), For those flights, someone in the in-kind donations to the campaign. based on reporting from Carolina Jour- Perdue campaign made calculations to Additional listings failed to report the nal, the Raleigh News & Observer, and separate the purported costs of official amount charged for the flight, the date, the State Board of Elections: state business from expenses related to or the destination. her gubernatorial campaign. The John Locke Foundation 200 W. Morgan St., #200 Raleigh, NC 27601 The elections board in August Continued as “Perdue,” Page 14 Continued as “Dozens” Page 14 PAGE 2 NOVEMBER 2010 | CAROLINA JOURNAL North CaroliNa C A R O L I N A N.C. Dog Breeders Wary of Missouri Referendum By Karen MCMahan JOURNAL Contributor Rick Henderson RALEIGH Managing Editor nimal-rights activists may have lost a two-year battle earlier Don Carrington this year to pass “puppy mill” Executive Editor Alegislation in North Carolina, but the war isn’t over. David N. Bass, Sara Burrows North Carolina farmers and Anthony Greco, Mitch Kokai commercial dog breeders are casting Michael Lowrey Associate Editors a wary eye toward a referendum on Missouri’s November ballot: Proposi- tion B, the “Puppy Mill Cruelty Pre- Jana Benscoter, Kristy Bailey vention Act.” Opponents see the ballot Kristen Blair, Roy Cordato measure as an avenue for animal rights Becki Gray, Sam A. Hieb groups in other states to regulate a lot Animal-rights advocates in North Carolina say current state and federal laws do not Lindalyn Kakadelis, George Leef more than commercial dog breeding address problems with what they term ‘puppy mills.’ Karen McMahan, Donna Martinez operations. trary number of animals. “Poor treat- drews said. Karen Palasek, Lee Raynor Opponents say the referendum ment and cruelty can occur no mat- The Alliance says the real agenda Marc Rotterman, Michael Sanera ter how many animals someone may behind Proposition B is to control ani- Jim Stegall, George Stephens would not prevent cruelty and neglect Jeff Taylor, Michael Walden because it does not address all dogs, own,” Peterson said. “The number of mal enterprise completely and abolish Karen Welsh, Hal Young just those that are part of a breeding animals has nothing to do with wheth- animal ownership. Both Andrews and John Calvin Young program. Instead, critics say the law er they’ll receive good care.” Johnson cited a quote by HSUS Presi- Contributors would cause economic harm to respon- In 2009, Sen. Don Davis, D-Pitt, dent Wayne Pacelle: “We [HSUS] have sible licensed dog breeders by forcing introduced Senate Bill 460, a bill to no problem with the extinction of do- them to comply with arbitrary, costly, regulate commercial dog breeders in mestic animals.” Alex Gill, Steven Holden and unenforceable regulations, such as North Carolina. Many groups opposed Proposition B also has a gap- Sara Riggins, Kellie Slappey a limit on the number of dogs an indi- the bill, including the American Veteri- ing loophole, Andrews said. Because Amanda Vuke vidual can own. Missouri’s vote on the nary Medical Association, the Ameri- it covers only commercial breeders, it Editorial Interns measure took place after press time. can Kennel Club, the North Carolina would exempt HSUS and other non- While many federal, state, and Sporting Dog Association, the Animal profits operating animal shelters from Published by local laws regulate animal welfare in Agriculture Alliance, the National Ani- the standards of care it would man- The John Locke Foundation North Carolina, animal-rights groups mal Interest Alliance, and the North date. 200 W. Morgan St., # 200 say that existing laws are insufficient. Carolina Agribusiness Council. People naturally want to help Raleigh, N.C. 27601 Current laws do not address standards The House Finance Commit- when they see videos and photos of (919) 828-3876 • Fax: 821-5117 of care, and that’s why puppy mill and tee pulled the bill from consideration abused or neglected dogs, cats, and www.JohnLocke.org related animal-welfare legislation is in late August, and Davis told CJ that other animals, Peterson said, but they needed, said Kimberley Alboum, state he has no plans to refile the bill next don’t always understand the implica- Jon Ham session unless there’s more interest in tions of the laws being proposed and Vice President & Publisher director of the North Carolina office of the Humane Society of the United passing it. mistakenly believe that such laws will John Hood States. (HSUS is a major supporter of Alboum promised there will be prevent the type of abuse they see por- Chairman & President Propsition B.) Without standards, ani- another puppy mill bill and other an- trayed in these disturbing images. mal control and other law enforcement imal-welfare bills in next year’s Gen- “Those who fail to obtain a dog- Bruce Babcock, Herb Berkowitz officers in North Carolina are unable to eral Assembly. Alboum told CJ she breeding license are already breaking Charlie Carter, Jim Fulghum take action on neglect or abuse until it didn’t know who’d be sponsoring any the law and are unlikely to follow new Chuck Fuller, Bill Graham rises to the level of animal cruelty.