INSTITUTE FOR GLOBAL LAW & POLICY HARVARD LAW SCHOOL

2012-2013 Annual Report

INSTITUTE FOR GLOBAL LAW & POLICY AT HARVARD LAW SCHOOL CAMBRIDGE, MA 02138 | WWW . IGLP . LAW . HARVARD . EDU new thinking global regulation and policy

social justice

how are poverty, conflict and inequality reproduced?

political economy

linking leading and lagging sectors, nations, economies

rethinking human rights

revitalizing comparative inquiry Annual Report 2012-2013 Table of Contents

THE INSTITUTE IGLP EVENTS 2012 - 2013

Mission 1 The Workshop 11

Research Agenda 1 The Conference 13

The Network 2 Pro-Seminars 13

Scholarly Resources 2 Colloquium 14

Institute Administration 4 Other Events 15

Faculty Contributors 5 IGLP RESEARCH 2012 - 2013 Councils 6 Current Research Projects 22 Program Partners & Sponsors 7 Collaborative Research Grants 23

IGLP WORKING FORMATS PEOPLE AT THE IGLP 2012 - 2013 The Workshop 9 Visiting Researchers & Scholars 27 The Pro-Seminars 9 Grant Recipients: Doha 28 The Colloquium 9 Grant Recipients: Visa 34 The Conference 9 Other Grant Recipients 36 Other Workshops & Conferences 10 Travel Grants 36 Policy Rountables 10 Event Participants 39 Student Initiatives 10

Lectures & Informal Seminars 10 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Mission & Research Agenda Much about how we are governed at the everyone thinks an economy is a market for global level remains a mystery. Scholars at allocating resources to their most efficient “At IGLP, we are convinced the Institute are working to understand and use in the shadow of a price system, a great map the levers of political, economic and deal has changed. That is also governance. that governance is not legal authority in the world today. The In- The transformation of ideas about what an only rules, institutions and stitute continues the tradition developed at “economy” is, whether it is national or glob- procedures. Harvard’s European Law Research Center by al, autonomous or institutionally embed- focusing on young scholars and policy mak- ded, can be as important as transforming ers from the global south, who bring new the institutions that sustain the operations Ideas also matter” ideas and perspectives to comparative and of that economy. At the IGLP, we encourage international legal research and policy. The research into the genealogy of governance IGLP aims to facilitate the emergence of a ideas as they have played out in the fields creative dialog among young experts from of international law, international economic around the world, strengthening our capac- law, regulatory policy, human rights and de- ity for innovation and cooperative research. velopment policy. The Institute for Global Law and Policy (IGLP) The Institute is also an international collab- All of our academic programming is de- at Harvard Law School is a collaborative fac- ulty effort to nurture innovative approaches orative project to foster research and policy signed to support our research agenda, to global policy in the face of a legal and dialog about the structure and potential for starting with our signature IGLP Doha Work- institutional architecture manifestly ill- global governance and international law af- shop for young scholars, and continuing equipped to address our most urgent glob- fecting pressing issues of global regulation through opportunities for Workshop alum- al challenges. Global poverty, conflict, injus- and policy. We are particularly focused on ni and IGLP scholars to build collaborative tice and inequality are also legal and institu- the relationship between the transnational teams, deepen their thinking and develop tional regimes. The IGLP explores the ways regulatory environment and the potential research for publication through multi‐ in which they are reproduced and what for sound economic development. The In- year participation in our various Streams, might be done in response. We aim to pro- stitute aims to foster innovative approaches Pro-Seminars and Colloquia. We also aim to vide a platform at Harvard for new thinking to global policy and political economy, and provide a framework at Harvard for students about international legal and institutional new thinking about international legal and and faculty interested in pursuing innova- arrangements, with particular emphasis on institutional arrangements. At the IGLP, we tive and heterodox research on foundation- ideas and issues of importance to the glob- are convinced that governance is not only al questions of theory and history as well as al south. Professor David Kennedy serves as rules, institutions and procedures. Ideas also pressing issues of global policy. Institute Director. matter. If for a generation everyone thinks an “economy” is an input output mecha- nism to be managed, and then suddenly “We have developed a large global network of scholars and policy makers...”

1 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu

Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

At the same time, we continue our history of transform the ways in which policy experts, engaging the policy community and spon- intellectual leaders and citizens understand Since 2010 over 500 people soring important transnational dialog. In our common global situation. from 75 countries have recent years, we have convened policymak- joined our network through ers and scholars in Colombia, Chile, Brazil, This IGLP network portal on our website is participation in the IGLP Thailand, Russia, China, and Spain, as well designed to strengthen that network and annual workshop. as in the United States to engage with our to assist all those who share our critical im- ongoing research activities. pulse and concern about the ideas which govern our world to share new ideas, events, research, and experiences with others in the he etwork field. This space is designed to be a haven of T N collaboration and sharing, all with the pur- Scholarly The IGLP encourages academic collabora- pose of advancing global governance think- tion and progressive research to nurture ing and ideas. Resources alternative ideas about international law, Fellowship Program society, and political economy. Over the last Members of the IGLP community are encour- Inaugurated in 2006, the Fellowship Pro- few years, we have developed a large global aged to reach out to IGLP staff so updates gram offers full or partial student and network of scholars and policy makers who about their work, syllabi and their ideas can post‐doctoral fellowship support to a small share our belief that ideas matter, and our be shared through the Network News, New number of scholars pursuing research in commitment to new voices and viewpoints Thinking/New Writing, Events of Interest, or areas related to the IGLP’s ongoing work. for thinking about global governance, social Working Papers sections of our website. The number of Fellowships awarded each justice and economic policy. year depends upon the available funding. The community can also connect with each Applicants considered for Fellowships are other by posting on IGLP’s Facebook, follow- Our common goal is to better understand those whose work is challenging, original ing us on Twitter and by signing up to receive how power is exercised in the world today, and focuses on progressive and alternative our bi-monthly e-newsletter. and how original and critical thinking can ideas within international law. Often work of this nature is not supported by mainstream institutional resources and the IGLP strives to give opportunities for diverse ideas to flourish.

IGLP Fellows are integral members of the In- stitute and provide valuable programming insight and assistance with the execution of our conferences and workshops.

(Cont.)

2 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Visiting Researchers Program open to current Harvard Law School stu- projects funded through this program are The IGLP accommodates a small number of dents and alumni of IGLP: The Workshop. promoted as sponsored Research Initiatives Visiting Researchers and Visiting Scholars Grants are awarded to students working on of the IGLP at Harvard Law School. each academic year. Visiting Researchers serious research and writing projects relat- and Scholars apply to do research at the ed to our core activities and projects. We Santander Doha Research Grants Law School for a minimum of three months. hope to encourage more students to focus The Harvard Law School Doha Grants Pro- In making selections, the Institute considers on the life of the mind, on interdisciplinary gram is generously supported by our Lead- the applicant’s background, field of interest, reading, and on developing the intellectual ing Sponsor Santander Universities to aid scholarly achievements, availability of Har- background to understand and contribute research by the IGLP alumni and faculty vard Law School faculty for consultation in to critical analyses of global law and social pursuing innovative scholarship aiming to the proposed research area, and English lan- justice. Preference is given to current doc- revitalize the Arab and Islamic traditions of guage proficiency. Applicants should have toral students and awards are limited to law and governance and issues of compara- completed their basic legal studies with students who have been invited to present tive law, global law, and policy in Qatar, the high academic standing. their scholarly work at academic confer- Middle East, and North African Region. The ences. grants are intended to further the dialogue Applicants at a relatively senior stage of which begun at the January IGLP Workshop their professional career may be designated Collaborative Research Grants through long-term research collaboration. Visiting Scholars. This designation is made Our Collaborative Research Grant Program on the basis of the nature of the applicant’s provides modest funding to small groups Visa International, Inc. Grants proposal, the expected duration of their of young scholars who are seeking to carry In 2013, with the generous support of our research and prior academic experience. out substantive research on projects related leading sponsor Visa International, Inc., the Visiting Scholar applicants are also required to the core research mission of the Institute. IGLP launched a new Grant Program de- to be affiliated with a university, research The IGLP encourages the development of signed to support research projects on li- institute or governmental program in their progressive and alternative ideas about in- quidity in the global economy, financial ser- home country. ternational law, society and political econo- vices regulation in emerging markets, and my by supporting original, provocative and financial inclusion. Grant recipients include Travel Grants challenging intellectual work that might not graduate students, post-doctoral schol- The IGLP provides modest research and otherwise find support from mainstream in- ars and junior faculty. Priority was given to travel support to a small number of scholars stitutional resources and which contributes proposals that aimed to generate written conducting research in areas closely related to the emergence of new approaches to in- work suitable for submission for publication to the IGLP’s ongoing work. Applications are ternational law and global social justice. All during the summer or autumn of 2013.

3 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Administration

Faculty Director of the Institute: Administrative Director: David Kennedy Neal O’Connor Neal joined European Law Research Center in 2003. In David is the Manley O. Hudson Professor of Law at Harvard Law 2010, with the launch of the new Institute for Global School. He teaches international law, international economic policy, Law and Policy, Neal was appointed Program Manager legal theory, law and development and European law. He joined the and in 2012, he became Administrative Director. Harvard Law faculty in 1981 after teaching in Germany. He holds a He oversees the organizational and administrative functions for the Institute. Neal received a degree in Ph.D. from the Fletcher School at Tufts University and a J.D. from Har- history from Harvard University. vard. He is the author of numerous articles on international law and global governance. His research uses interdisciplinary materials from Events Manager: sociology and social theory, economics and history to explore issues Kristen Verdeaux of global governance, development policy and the nature of profes- Kristen joined the IGLP in July of 2013 as Events sional expertise. He has been particularly committed to developing Manager. She has a B.A. in English and Political Science new voices from the third world and among women in international from the University of Connecticut. Kristen specializes affairs. Professor Kennedy also has extensive experience as a prac- in non-profit event planning, program management, ticing lawyer, having worked on numerous international projects, and service delivery. both commercial and public, including work with the United Nations, the Commission of the European Union, and with the private firm Web & Communications Coordinator: of Clearly, Gottlieb, Steen and Hamilton in Brussels, where his work Laura Christoffels combined European antitrust litigation, government relations advis- Laura joined the IGLP in July of 2013 as Web and ing and general corporate law. A member of the Council on Foreign Communications Coordinator. She has a B.A. in Relations, he is past Chair of the World Economic Forum’s Global Advi- Communications from the University of New York and sory Council on Global Governance. At Harvard, he served as Chair of is a graphic and web designer with experience in brand the Graduate Committee and Faculty Director of International Legal development and management. Studies. He founded the European Law Research Center at Harvard in 1991 and has served continuously as Faculty Director. He has advised Program Coordinator: a number of educational institutions on their academic programs, Melinda Peterson and lectured as a Visiting Professor at numerous universities across Melinda joined the Institute in September of 2012. the world. In 2008-2009, he served as Vice President for Internation- Melinda received a B.A. in Legal Studies and Criminal al Affairs, University Professor of Law and David and Marianna Fisher Justice from the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. University Professor of International Relations at Brown University. Melinda administers the Institute’s grants and financials, and assists with general office administration.

IGLP Fellows (2012-2013): Read more about IGLP’s Fellows for 2012-2013 on page 36.

Zinaida Miller is a doctoral (Ph.D.) candidate in International Heidi Matthews is a doctoral (S.J.D.) candidate at Harvard Law Relations at The Fletcher School, Tufts University. School.

Lisa Kelly is a doctoral (S.J.D.) candidate at Harvard Law School. Yun-Ru Chen is a a post doctoral fellow at Harvard Law School. She received her doctorate (S.J.D) in 2013.

4 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute Harvard Law School Faculty

The Institute also draws on the expertise Gerald Frug’s work on international local Lucian Bebchuck, Reinier Kraakman, and experience of a wide range of government law has sparked a number Robert Clark, Guhan Subramanian, Harvard Law School faculty. Each year, we of events, and we have supported his Allen Ferrell, Howell Jackson and Alan endeavor to work closely with faculty who comparative research on the city as a Dershowitz have all been participants have compatible projects concerning legal concept. in our conferences on corporate law global law and policy. Numerous faculty and regulation, while Einer Elhauge members have mentored our Visiting We have provided assistance to clinical has joined our annual conference Researchers over the years. projects in Africa developed by Lucie on European and American antitrust White in the fields of global health policy enforcement for several years. Christine Desan contributes regularly to and human rights. our program on the history of capitalism We work closely with the graduate and the global economy, while Duncan David Barron, Janet Halley, Allen program at the law school, encouraging Kennedy is a regular participant in our Ferrell, Elizabeth Bartholet, Martha interactions among doctoral students work on comparative law, globalization Field, Terry Fisher, Mark Ramseyer, and their faculty colleagues, and are and social theory. Jesse Fried, Steven Shavell, Cass grateful for William Alford’s ongoing Sunstein, and Scott Brewer have engagement and support. We have long supported Janet Halley’s participated in our Spanish training work in the fields of comparative family programs co-organized with the law, social theory and the feminist Garrigiues law firm. legacies of global governance.

5 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School Honorary, Advisory, and Academic Councils

HONORARY COUNCIL Daniela Caruso ACADEMIC COUNCIL Susan Marks Fernando Henrique Cardoso Boston University Gianmaria Ajani London School of Economics and Former President of Brazil Boston, Massachusetts University of Turin, Turin, Italy Political Science H.M. Juan Carlos I Matthew Craven Philip Allott London, United Kingdom King of Spain, as Honorary President SOAS, University of London Trinity College; Cambridge University Pratap Bhanu Mehta of the Real Colegio Complutense London, United Kingdom Cambridge, England Centre for Policy Research Gil Carlos Ridriguez Iglesias Christine Desan Helena Alviar New Delhi, India Former President of the Court Harvard Law School Universidad de Los Andes Vasuki Nesiah of Justice of the European Cambridge, Massachusetts Bogotá, Colombia New York University Communities Spain Karen Engle Yishai Blank New York, New York Jacques Delors University of Texas, Austin, Texas Faculty of Law, Tel Aviv University Ileana Porras Former President of the Jorge Esquirol Tel Aviv, Israel University of Miami Commission of the European Miami, Florida Communities France Florida International University Hilary Charlesworth Miami, Florida The Australian National University Philippe Sands Claus-Dieter Ehlermann University College London Senior Counsel at WilmerHale Gerald Frug Canberra, Australia Brussels, Belgium; European Harvard Law School B.S. Chimni London, United Kingdom University Institute, Fiesole, Italy; Cambridge, Massachusetts Jawaharlal Nehru University Calixto Salomao Filho former member of the Appellate Antonio Garrigues Walker New Delhi, India University of Sao Paulo Body World Trade Organization Sao Paulo, Brazil Geneva, Switzerland J&A Garrigues, S.L. Dan Danielsen Madrid, Spain Northeastern University Law School Amr Shalakany Dr. Alfred Gusenbauer Boston, Massachusetts The American University in Cairo Former Chancellor of Austria Janet Halley Harvard Law School Dennis Davis Cairo, Egypt José Manuel Ramos-Horta Cambridge, Massachusetts High Court of Cape Town Gunther Teubner Former President of the Democratic South Africa Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe- Republic of Timor-Leste Duncan Kennedy Harvard Law School James Der Derian University, Frankfurt, Germany Ricardo Lagos Escobar Cambridge, Massachusetts University of Sydney Chantal Thomas Former President of Chile Martti Koskenniemi Sydney, Australia Cornell Law School Mark Malloch-Brown University of Helsinki Dr. Günter Frankenberg Ithaca, New York Former UN Deputy Secretary Helsinki, Finland Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe- David Trubek General, and Former Minister of University Frankfurt, Germany University of Wisconsin-Madison, State in the British Foreign Office Salvador Medina Chao Ciudad Grupo Santander Eduardo Garcia de Enterria Madison, Wisconsin Jacques Santer Madrid, Spain Complutense University Jean-Francois Verstrynge Former Member of the European Kerry Rittich Madrid, Spain Honorary Director General Parliament; former President of Commission of the European the Commission of the European University of Toronto Christophe Jamin Toronto, Canada Communities Brussels, Belgium Communities, Brussels, Belgium; Sciences Po Law School Michel Waelbroeck Paris, France former Prime Minister of the Grand Leopold Specht University of Brussels Duchy of Luxembourg Sprecht Böhm Vienna Emmanuelle Jouannet Brussels, Belgium Belgrade–Budapest – Kiev– Surakiart Sathirathai Director of CEDIN, University of Robert Wai Moscow–Prague–St. Petersburg Paris, Paris, France Former Foreign Minister and York University Deputy Prime Minister of Thailand Joseph Stiglitz Sorajak Kasemsuvan Toronto, Canada Columbia University, New York, New Chulalongkorn University Mikhail Xifaras York Bangkok,Thailand ADVISORY COUNCIL Science Po Law School Romano Subiotto Kishore Mahbubani Paris, France Carlos Andradas Heranz Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen & Hamilton Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Universidad Complutense de Brussels, Belgium Policy, National University of Madrid, Madrid, Spain Roberto Unger Singapore Jose Maria Beneyto Harvard Law School Cambridge, Gómez-Acebo & Pombo Massachusetts Madrid, Spain

6 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute Program Sponsors & Partners

The IGLP is particularly grateful to our Sponsors, who continue to show their faith in our efforts to provide a focal point for European, international and comparative law, and economic development study at Harvard Law School.

and to revitalize Arab law and governance traditions.

An integral part of its law fessionals distributed across 17 school project is to contribute Santander countries, coordinates and man- to higher education world- Universities ages Banco Santander’s com- wide by convening a global joined the Institute as a Leading mitment to higher education. network of young scholars of Sponsor in 2010. Between 1997 and 2012, Banco law and governance, and to Santander channeled $1 billion place young scholars and as- Santander Universities, was into sponsorship of academic, piring leaders from the region created by Banco Santander on research and technological proj- in dialog with global peers. the conviction that the best way ects in support of higher educa- The Qatar of contributing to growth and tion. There are now over 1,000 Foundation The Foundation aims to ex- economic and social process is academic institutions receiving was established with a mis- tend its global outreach by by backing the higher educa- support from Banco Santander sion to lead human, social, and supporting institutions that tion and research system. Ban- for the development of academ- economic development of share its belief in the values co Santander’s commitment to ics initiatives including Harvard Qatar, through education and of global dialogue and re- progress finds its expression in University and the IGLP. research; making Qatar a van- search, in a way that help the the Santander Universities Glob- guard for productive change Foundation fulfill its mission. al Division, whose activities form Santander Universities is the in the region and a role model The Foundation now seeks to the backbone of the bank’s social Lead Sponsor of our June Confer- for the broader international support the capacity of the action and enable it to maintain ence, Colloquium, and Pro-Semi- community. IGLP to develop projects and a stable alliance with the aca- nars at Harvard. pursue research of interest to demic world in Latin America, As part of its flagship project, the global community and the China, United States of America, Online: region. Hamad bin Khalifa Universi- Spain, Morocco, Portugal, Unit- www.santanderuniversities.us ty (HBKU), the Foundation is ed Kingdom, Germany, Poland, seeking to establish a global The Qatar Foundation is the Singapore, and Russia. Santand- law school and research cen- Lead Sponsor, and HBKU the er Universities Global Division, ter in Doha, with a mission to host of our intensive Work- a team of more than 2,100 pro- become a leader in new think- shop held in January in Doha. ing about law and governance Online: www.qf.org.qa

The Real Colegio Complutense Cambridge, MA

The Real Colegio Complutense, Cambridge, MA, is a non-profit organization established in 1990 by Complutense University of Madrid, Spain in order to foster scholarly and scientific exchange between Harvard University and Spanish universities and institutions.

The Real Colegio Complutense was a founding partner of the ELRC and has been leading sponsor of the IGLP since 2010. To obtain more information on Complutense University contact: The Real Colegio Complutense, 26 Trowbridge Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 Telephone: 617-495-3536 / Fax: 617-496-3401) / Online: www.ucm.es

7 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School Program Sponsors & Partners

Visa International, Inc. is a global payments technology company that con- nects consumers, businesses, banks and governments in more than 200 countries and territories, en- abling them to use digital currency instead of cash and checks. Visa International, Inc., has built one of the world’s most advanced processing networks. It’s capable of handling more than 20,000 transactions per second, with reliability, convenience and security, including fraud protection for consumers and guaranteed payment for merchants.

Visa International Inc., does not issue cards, extend credit or set rates and fees for consumers. Its innovations, however, enable its bank customers to offer consumers more choices: Pay now with debit, ahead of time with prepaid or later with credit products. In fact, approximately 70 percent of Visa International Inc., payment transactions in the United States are debit and prepaid, not credit. Governments here and abroad have switched to digital currency instead of checks for benefits payments and purchasing in order to increase efficiency and lower costs, saving taxpayers money.

From the world’s major cities to remote areas without banks, people are increasingly relying on digital currency along with mobile technology to use their money any time, make purchases online, transfer funds across borders and access basic financial services — all of which makes their lives easier and grows economies.

Visa International Inc., is the Lead Sponsor of our Program on Global Financial Regulation. Online: www.corporate.visa.com

A leading international law firm cultures of the countries in which with 12 offices located in major fi- it operates, and its success in mul- nancial centers around the world, tiple jurisdictions, Cleary Gottlieb Cleary Gottlieb received Chambers & Partners’ in- Steen & Hamil- augural International Law Firm of the Year award. Founded in 1941, law, particularly during the ton LLP has helped shape J&A Garrigues, country’s transition to de- the globalization of the legal pro- To obtain more information con- mocracy. Playing key roles fession for more than 60 years. tact: S.L.P. is one of the lon- in the development of the Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen & Hamilton LLP gest established law firms country and its laws ensured Their worldwide practice has a New York City’s office at One Liber- in Spain. During the second that Garrigues became one proven track record for innovation ty Plaza; New York, NY 10006-1470 half of the twentieth cen- of the most knowledgeable and providing work of the highest Telephone: 212-225-2000 tury, J&A Garrigues was a and respected law firms in quality to meet the needs of our Fax: 212-225-3999 central pillar of the Spanish Spain. More information domestic and international clients. Online: www.cgsh.com legal profession and was about Garrigues can be In recognition of the firm’s strong routinely consulted on all found on their website. global practice, its effectiveness in key reforms to Spanish dealing with the different business Online: www.garrigues.com.

8 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute IGLP Working Formats scholarly writing and advance their work towards publication. Pro-seminars are typically convened by Harvard Law School, or senior IGLP faculty.

IGLP: The Colloquium Each June, we convene an invitation only Collo- quium at Harvard for IGLP Core Faculty, Docents and guests to strengthen our own work through intensive discussion and engagement with lead- ing scholars from other disciplines. Each year’s Colloquium pursues a common theme across a range of research fields. In 2012, the Colloquium focused on the political economy of the modern global order. In 2013, we focused on questions of method raised by the effort to think vertically about the relationship between global and local, macro and micro; and to think horizontally about comparison and differentiation among local or IGLP: The Workshop their global peers as they develop innovative national arrangements. To explore these themes, Held in Doha, Qatar each January, the Workshop ideas and alternative approaches to issues of we invite innovative intellectuals from a range of is an intensive residential program designed for global law, economic policy, social justice and disciplines to join us in Cambridge. doctoral and post-doctoral scholars and junior governance. Intensive writing workshops offer faculty. Hosted by Hamad bin Khalifa University participants the opportunity to receive valuable IGLP: The Conference (HBKU), a member of the IGLP’s leading sponsor feedback on their own research from their peers In 2013 we convened our first international con- the Qatar Foundation, each year IGLP: The Work- and more senior colleagues in small group set- ference at Harvard bringing together over 350 shop brings more than 100 young scholars and tings. scholars and friends working on innovative ap- faculty from around the world for serious research proaches to global governance, social justice collaboration and debate. While in residence in Doha, participants review current scholarly devel- IGLP: The Pro-Seminars and economic policy for two days of scholarly Pro-seminars are designed for small groups of opments, reconsider canonical texts and network exchange. IGLP: The Conference will be held ev- with colleagues from across the world. scholars engaged in collaboration aimed towards ery other June at Harvard Law School and is open publication. They bring together between ten to all those who are interested in pursuing new Our aim is to strengthen the next generation of and fifteen scholars, by invitation and application, thinking about law and global policy, including scholars by placing them in collaboration with working on a common topic. They typically meet those who are new to our network, as well as IGLP in June at Harvard to brainstorm their evolving

9 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School going debate about various themes of interest to alumni and friends. Our aim is to provide an on- Policy Roundtables going opportunity for scholars connected to the The IGLP sponsors policy roundtables, ranging in both students and scholars associated with our Institute to return to Cambridge to present their duration from one to three days, concerning spe- ongoing work. We also regularly provide support research, to reconnect with peers from across the cific issues important to one or more of the IGLP’s for student groups at the school pursuing proj- globe, and to find new opportunities for collab- constituencies, in which experts from industry, ects related to our research mandate. orative research with other innovative scholars. the practicing profession, government, and ac- ademia discuss topics of common interest in a Lectures & Informal ther onferences O C & relaxed setting. Seminars Workshops During the academic year, the IGLP sponsors a The IGLP regularly sponsors conferences and variety of lectures and informal seminars in which tudent nitiatives workshops, ranging from informal events at the S I faculty and professional scholars share ongoing The IGLP additionally supports activities orga- Harvard Faculty Club to large meetings conven- research in the areas of global law and policy. nized and led by doctoral students and Visiting ing over 100 scholars in Cambridge and Doha, These events, which are generally open to all Researchers at the Law School. Students often Qatar for intensive discussion. Our most import- members of the Harvard community, aim to bring prepare presentations based on their current the best new thinking about global law and pol- ant annual events take place in January and June. research or invite smaller groups of students to icy to the community for discussion and debate. informal discussions. These formats facilitate on-

10 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute IGLP Events The Doha, Qatar,

WORKSHOP January 4-14, 2013 From January 4-14, 2013, the IGLP hosted its and cultural activities already underway in are promising professionals from the public 4th annual Workshop, and first in Qatar, Education City. or private sector with an interest in sharing as part of our exciting new collaboration their ideas with global peers. In addition with the Qatar Foundation. At the 2013 Workshop we continued our to participating in the Workshop Stream tradition of seeking new ways of deepening lectures and discussions, participants in IGLP: The Workshop, hosted by Hamad the network of collaboration among our the YPP program had the opportunity to bin Khalifa University (HBKU), a member Workshop Alumni as well as invigorate our explore workshop themes and policy and of the Qatar Foundation, brought 110 core program with new participants and governance processes and challenges with doctoral, post-doctoral scholars, and ju- themes. We hosted a second group of IGLP select Workshop faculty during afternoon nior faculty together in Doha with a core Alumni Docents, each of whom assisted one discussion groups. group of senior IGLP faculty from around or more Core Faculty with the organization the world for a unique series of lectures and of a Workshop Stream or convened a Writ- In 2013 our new themes included explor- intensive interdisciplinary debates. While in ing Workshop or Stream Discussion Group. ing comparative law as a constituent part residence in Doha, participants reviewed Prior to the larger Workshop, we also con- of global policy and legal practice, seeing current scholarly developments, reconsid- vened a two-day Specialized Workshop for the potential to renew the Arab tradition ered canonical texts and networked with IGLP Core Faculty and Docents. This Spe- of law and governance, and reviewing the colleagues from across the world. Intensive cialized Workshop offered the group the op- modern significance of the Islamic legal tra- writing workshops offered participants the portunity to explore the Workshop themes dition. We continued our effort to stimulate opportunity to receive valuable feedback in greater depth; to engage with one an- new thinking about the legal foundations on their own research from their peers and other’s work, and to discuss ongoing IGLP of global monetary affairs, economic de- more senior colleagues in small group set- research projects. At the 2013 Workshop, velopment policy, global political econo- tings. Qatar offered a perfect location for we also inaugurated a new program for my and the struggle for social, political and convening scholars from countries outside Young Policy Professionals (YPP). The pro- economic justice. As an extension of the the North Atlantic area, allowing us to focus gram was designed for young professionals core curriculum the Workshop also featured on recent developments in the region and from Qatar and the surrounding region who guest speakers and panel discussions. to benefit from synergies with intellectual are not currently academics or scholars, but (See page 39 for list of participants)

11 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

The 2013 The Corporation in Global Society Globalization and Labor (GL) Law and Economic Development Workshop Streams (CGS) Convener: (LED) Conveners: Katherine Stone (United States) Conveners: Dan Danielsen (United States) UCLA School of Law Kerry Rittich (Canada) Northeastern University Law School Docents: Dennis Davis (South Africa) Vidya Kumar (Canada) University of Toronto, Faculty of Law Revitalizing the Arab and Islamic High Court of Cape Town University of Birmingham Chantal Thomas (United States) Legal Traditions (AILT) Docents: Brishen Rogers (United States) Cornell Law School Conveners: Boris Mamlyuk (United States) Temple University, Beasley School David Trubek (United States) Moatasem El-Gheriani (Egypt) University of Memphis of Law University of Wisconsin Alexandria University Karolina Zurek (Poland) Docents: Günter Frankenberg (Germany) Swedish Institute for European Human Rights and Social Justice Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe University Diogo Coutinho (Brazil) Policy Studies (HRSJ) University of Sao Paulo Baber Johansen (United States) Conveners: Harvard University Global Law and Political Economy Karen Engle (United States) Mario Gomes Schapiro (Brazil) Amr Shalakany (Egypt) (GLPE) University of Texas Law School Fundação Getulio Vargas Law The American University in Cairo Conveners: Vasuki Nesiah (United States) School Chantal Thomas (United States) Matthew Craven (United Kingdom) New York University Law School Cornell Law School SOAS, University of London Docents: Docents: Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Lucas Lixinski (Brazil) Plenary Lectures and Panel Vanja Hamzic (Bosnia and Herzegovina) Melbourne Law School University of New South Wales Discussions King’s College London Docents: Heidi Matthews (Canada) Usha Natarajan (Australia) Luis Eslava Arcila (Australia) Harvard Law School Not a Global City The American University in Cairo Melbourne Law School Convener: Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) International Economic Law and Gerald Frug (United States) Comparative Legal Studies (CLS) The American University in Cairo Regulation (IELR) Conveners: Harvard Law School Conveners: Commentator: Jorge Esquirol (United States) Andrew Lang (United Kingdom) Florida International University Global Science and Technology London School of Economics and Robert Wai (Canada) College of Law Studies (GSTS) Political Science Osgoode Hall Law School Günter Frankenberg (Germany) Convener: Robert Wai (Canada) Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe University Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Osgoode Hall Law School Panel Discussion on the Arab Horatia Muir-Watt (France) Harvard Kennedy School Docents: Spring Sciences Po Law School Docents: Michael Fakhri (Canada) Panelists: Docents: Aziza Ahmed (United States) University of Oregon School of Law Damjan Kukovec (Slovenia) Bassam Haddad (United States) Northeastern University Law School Tor Krever (United Kingdom) George Mason University Harvard Law School Gustavo Ribeiro (Brazil) London School of Economics and Derek McKee (Canada) Harvard Law School Political Science Amr Shalakany (Egypt) Université de Sherbrooke The American University Cairo Noura Erekat (United States) Temple University, Beasley School of Law

Discussion on Arab and Islamic Legal Traditions Convener: David Mednicoff (United States) University of Massachusetts, Amherst Commentator: Hani Sayed (Egypt) The American University in Cairo

Law and the Challenge of the Transcendental Convener: Philip Allott (United Kingdom) Trinity College, University of Cambridge

Discussion on Human Rights and Social Justice Conveners: Karen Engle (United States) University of Texas Law School Vasuki Nesiah (United States) New York University Law School

Law and Global Political Economy Convener: David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School

12 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

“New Directions in Global IGLP: The Conference, which will “Over 350 Thought” was a celebration of be held every other year in Cam- scholars from the IGLP’s first five years and bridge, is designed to showcase more than brought together more than the new thinking about law and 60 countries 350 scholars from over 60 coun- global policy among our network participated in our tries to share their work over the of IGLP alumni and friends. Our inaugural course of the two days. We con- aim for the Conference is to pro- conference this vened over 55 panels on topics vide an ongoing opportunity for June at Harvard.” ranging from human rights to scholars connected to the Insti- economic policy to comparative tute to return to Cambridge to law. More than 50 faculty and present their research, reconnect students from Harvard participat- with peers from across the globe, Harvard Law School, ed as panelists or moderators in and find new opportunities for June 2-3, 2013 2013 including Harvard Faculty collaborative research with other The IGLP’s Inaugural internation- members David Kennedy, Chris- innovative scholars. al Conference took place this past tine Desan, Janet Halley, Sheila (See page 42 for participants and panels). June at Harvard Law School. Jasanoff and Duncan Kennedy. IGLP Pro-Seminars June 5-7, 2013 | Harvard Law School

In 2011 the IGLP inaugurat- PRO-SEMINAR 5: Re- PRO-SEMINAR 8: Con- ed a Series of Pro-Seminars Theorizing Liquidity temporary Legal Thought designed for small groups of In 2013 This Pro-Seminar, which (1970-Present) PRO-SEMINAR 10: Economies Scholars engaged in collabo- was convened by Christine This Pro-Seminar, convened of Desire ration aimed towards publi- Desan (Harvard Law School), by Duncan Kennedy (Harvard This Pro-Seminar, Convened cation. The IGLP Pro-Seminars focused on Critical Approaches Law School), Kerry Rittich by Janet Halley (Harvard Law bring together between ten to Monetary Design. It brought School), continues the work and fifteen active scholars, (University of Toronto, Faculty together scholars and students half selected by invitation, and of Law), and Justin Desautels- of the 2011 Pro-Seminar on from law, economics, and histo- half by application, who are all Stein (University of Colorado Gender in Post-Colonial Legal ry who approach the monetary working on a common topic. Law School), addresses the Orders. In 2013 the group the Pro-Seminars typically meet system with critical perspec- broad topic of “Contemporary group met to engage with ca- each June at Harvard to brain- tive, with the aim of developing nonical critical scholarship on storm their evolving scholar- both analytic capacity to un- Legal Thought,” in an effort to desire, sex, gender, affect, inti- ly writing and advance their derstand the current monetary contribute to the elaboration, work towards publication. In order and constructive thought evaluation, and critique of the macy, sexuality, and family. 2013 we hosted the following about its revision. idea. (See page 54 for all participants). Pro-Seminars at Harvard:

13 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

IGLP 2013 Colloquium Harvard Law School | June 5 - 7, 2013

Harvard Law School, scholars from other disciplines. and the micro, or the theoretical we understand the relationships June 5-7, 2013 Each year’s Colloquium pursues and the practical, is no easy mat- among local or national arrange- a common theme across a range ter. What can we learn from the ments? As a matter of technical IGLP: The Colloquium was of research fields. In 2012, the history of trying? How might we similarities and cultural differ- launched in 2012 as part of our Colloquium focused on the po- develop better accounts of the ences – or vice versa? As a pat- continuing effort to strengthen litical economy of the modern “whole” by placing our accounts tern of historical influences? As the network of collaboration global order. The 2013 IGLP Col- of local and national legal, politi- a system of centers and periph- among our Workshop alumni loquium explored two questions cal and economic arrangements eries? As we do each year at the and faculty. Each June, the Col- of method. First, people talk in relationship to accounts of Colloquium, we invited intellec- loquium brings together select about linking the global and the the international or transnation- tuals from a range of disciplines IGLP Core Faculty, invited guests local, “seeing” them together, al or global? If “global and local” to join us in Cambridge to share and IGLP Docents to strengthen appreciating their “interconnec- suggests a vertical axis of scale, their own thoughts on these our own work through sever- tions” — but just how can this “comparison” suggests a hori- quite general questions and the al days of intensive discussion be done? After all, across the so- zontal axis of differentiation. ways they have arisen in their and engagement with leading cial sciences, linking the general Our second question focused own work. and the particular, or the macro on this horizontal axis: how can Panels and Presentations

Facilitator: Facilitator: Deval Desai (United Kingdom) Diffusion and Comparison in Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Janet Halley (United States) Harvard Law School Science & Technology Studies Harvard Kennedy School Harvard Law School Heidi Matthews (Canada) Speakers: Harvard Law School James Benjamin (United States) Reading Marx: Local Boy The Political Economy of Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh) Arizona State University Makes Good Global and Local: Global Value Jahangirnagar University Kaushik Sunder Rajan (United States) Speaker: Chains Facilitator: University of Chicago Andrew Parker (United States) Speakers: Lisa Kelly (Canada) Rutgers University Gary Gereffi (United States) Harvard Law School Duke University Mike Morris (South Africa) Comparativism: The Local, the University of Cape Town School of Economics Global in Legal Education, Facilitators: A Dean’s Roundtable Dan Danielsen (United States) Speakers: Northeastern University School of Law Christophe Jamin (France) Dennis Davis (South Africa) Science Po Law School High Court of Cape Town Daniel Jutras (Canada) Jason Jackson (United States) McGill University University of Pennsylvania Facilitator: Brishen Rogers (United States) David Kennedy (United States) Temple Law School Harvard Law School Culture, Imperialism, and the Governing Life: Local and Machinery of Local and Global Global Geontologies Speaker: Speaker: Partha Chatterjee (India) Elizabeth Povinelli (United States) Columbia University Columbia University Facilitator: Facilitator: Vasuki Nesiah (Sri Lanka) Karen Engle (United States) New York University School of Law University of Texas School of Law “Death of a Prisoner”: Interpreting Guantanamo Bay (See page 54 for all participants). Speakers: Aziza A hmed (United States) Northeastern University School of Law

14 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Other Events Development Strategies in Emerging Markets of the ASEAN Region: Research Mission and Workshop in Bangkok Bangkok, Thailand, August 29 -31, 2012 In August 2012, the IGLP convened a research mission and workshop Our sessions focused on the following three themes: in Bangkok focused on new financial services regulation and develop- ment strategies in the emerging markets of the ASEAN region. • Liquidity in the Global Economy and Capital as Legal Institutions. The workshop brought a core group of IGLP affiliated faculty and stu- dents together with government officials, industry representatives • Financial Inclusion and scholars from throughout the ASEAN region for a series of discus- sions and presentations. • The Structure of Financial Services in Emerging Markets

Participants:

John Barry (United States) During the four day mission the group met This Bangkok initiative is part of a multi- Head of Government Affairs, APCEMEA, with the following academic experts and year, broad-ranging IGLP research initiative Visa International, Inc. policy professionals: undertaken in collaboration with Leading Sponsor Visa International, Inc. to explore Gabriel Davel (Thailand) Jiranan Pupat, (Thailand) the themes of liquidity in the global Alliance for Financial Inclusion, Bangkok Senior Vice President, Central Food Retail economy, productive financial services Company Limited of Thailand Ermal Frasheri (Albania) regulatory structures in emerging markets, Harvard Law School and financial inclusion. We launched the Bandit Sotthipalarit (Thailand) David Kennedy (United States) initiative at Harvard Law School in the spring President of Islamic Bank of Thailand Harvard Law School of 2012 with a free-ranging discussion to identify a core group of researchers Lawrence Kego Masha (Tanzania) Yongyut Tariyo (Thailand) and policy-makers with the interest and Ishengoma, Karume, Masha & Magai Senior Executive Vice President, expertise to join with us as we pursue these Advocates of Tanzania Government Savings Bank of Thailand issues over the coming years. Scott Newton (United States) SOAS, University of London Sakda Thanitcul (Thailand) Dean of the Faculty of Law at Nadav Orian Peer (Israel) Chulalongkorn University Harvard Law School Kanich Punyashthiti (Thailand) Pansak Vinyaratn (Thailand) Chulalongkorn University Chief Policy Advisor of the Prime Minister of Thailand, Yingluck Shinawatra Kerry Rittich (Canada) University of Toronto, Faculty of Law Pornchai Prasertsintanah (Thailand) Shunko Rojas (Argentina) Managing Director, Credit Suisse Harvard Law School Securities Limited of Thailand Surakiart Sathirathai (Thailand) Former Thai Deputy Prime Minister, Natee Khlibtong (Thailand) Foreign Minister and Finance Minister Chief Executive Officer and Secretary- of Thailand General, National Village and Urban Community Fund Office of Thailand Nicholas John Sherry (Australia) Former Labor Senator of Tasmania Vorapol Socatiyanurak (Thailand) Leopold Specht, (Austria) Secretary-General, Securities and Sprecht Böhm Vienna Exchange Commission of Thailand Erin Pham Steinhauer (United States) Head, Corporate Responsibility, Asia Krirk Vanikkul (Thailand) Pacific, Central Europe, Middle East and Deputy Governor, Financial Institutions Africa, Visa International Inc., Singapore Stability, Bank of Thailand

15 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Program on the Study of Capitalism: Fall and Spring Speaker Series Harvard Law School, Fall 2012-Spring 2013

During this past academic year the IGLP and the Program on the Study of Capitalism, hosted a series of workshops at Harvard Law School focused on “The Political Economy of Modern Capitalism.” The workshops provided a forum for scholars interested in the intensive interdisciplinary study of capitalism and the role it has historically played in the process of regulating social relations.

Fall 2012 / Spring 2013 Speaker Series: October 29: February 11: ”An Inexhaustible Treasure: Slavery as the Foundation for the “This Standard Which Is Not One: Gold and Multiple Liquidity Regimes” English Financial Revolution” Roy Kreitner (Israel) Carl Wennerlind, (United States) Tel Aviv University School of Law Barnard College Comment: February 25: Sophus Reinert, (United States) “Against Market Totalitarianism: Thinking Through Legal Technique” Harvard Business School Annelise Riles (United States) Cornell Law School November 12: ”Moneymaking: A Monetary System Design” March 11: Morgan Ricks (United States) “The Federal Reserve and the Banking Crisis of 1931” Vanderbilt Law School David Moss (United States) Comment: Harvard Business School Amar Bhide (United States) Roger Lowenstein (United States) Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy Journalist/Author

November 26: March 25: “Finance Capital: An Extremely Brief History of the Politics, and “The Foundations of Finance,” from A Modern Way of Knowing: Vice Versa, ca. 1898-2010” The History of Financial Modelling” James Livingston (United States) Mary Poovey, (United States) Rutgers University New York University Comment: Stephen Marglin (United States) Harvard University

16 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

5th Annual North American Lawyers Program Spain, September 20-21, 2012 From September 20 - 21, 2012 the IGLP and Harvard Law School professors David “Recent Developments in Intellectual our Leading Sponsor J&A Garrigues, S.L.P. Kennedy, Terry Fisher and Mark Tushnet Property Law” hosted our 5th Annual “North American each made presentations at this event. Terry Fisher presented in Barcelona and Lawyers Program” at the Garrigues law Valencia. offices in Madrid, Barcelona, and Valencia. Topics included: The event focused on International Legal “International Law in U.S. Courts” “The Traditions of American Legal Thought” Practice and the American Legal System. Mark Tushnet presented in Madrid and David Kennedy presented in Madrid and Valencia. Barcelona.

A Comparative Perspective on Old and New Problems of Corporate and Financial Law Harvard Law School, September 24-27, 2012

From September 24 - 27, 2012, the IGLP and Financial Law”, at Harvard Law School. Jesse Fried, Guhan Subramanian, John and our Leading Sponsor the Real Colegio The event featured presentations and Coates and Reinier Kraakman each made Complutense hosted the 10th Annual Busi- roundtable discussions focused on compar- presentations at this event. ness Law Seminar, “A Comparative Perspec- ative issues between US and European cor- tive on Old and New Problems of Corporate porate law. Harvard Law School Professors (See page 57 for participants)

Discussion: Global Trade Policy and Rush to Bilateralism: Peter Sutherland Harvard Law School, October 11, 2012

On October 11, 2012, The IGLP and The He presented a talk on trade issues as part General of the European Commission Renee Minda de Gunzburg Center for European of the Challenge Series at the Center for Haferkamp. The discussion was chaired by Studies hosted a dinner in honor of Peter European Studies. Harvard Law School Harvard Law professor Einer Elhauge . Sutherland, former Attorney General of professors John Coates, Allen Ferrell, Ireland and former Director-General of the and Mark Wu participated in the dinner World Trade Organization. discussion along with former Director

17 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Conference: Impunity, Justice, and the Human Rights Agenda Austin, Texas, February 7-8, 2013

From February 7 - 8, 2013 The IGLP and The Inside” , “The Criminal Law Paradigm”, Bernard and Audre Rapoport Center for and “Criminalization and the Politics of Human Rights and Justice at the University Transition.” of Texas School of Law held the 9th annual “Impunity, Justice, and the Human Rights ParticipantsParticipants and anddiscussants: Discussants: Hani Sayed (Syria) Agenda Conference”. Professor Karen Daniel Brinks (United States) The American University in Cairo Engle, IGLP Advisory Board member and Bernard and Audre Rapoport Center for Zinaida Miller (United States) co-director of the Rapoport Center, chaired Human Rights and Justice, University of Tufts University the event which brought together human Texas rights advocates, scholars, and policy Natalie Davidson (United States) makers from around the globe to critically Dennis Davis (South Africa) Tel Aviv University School of Law analyze the human rights movement on High Court of Cape Town Fabia Vecoso (Brazil) anti-impunity. Panel topics included “The Vasuki Nesiah (United States) Faculdade de Direito do Sul de Minas Anti-Impunity Professional: A View from New York University School of Law

IGLP and Program on Science and Technology Studies Expertise Seminar, “Energy Politics: After Carbon Democracy” Harvard Law School, March 5, 2013 Discussants: On March 5, 2013, the Program on Science, Aziza Ahmed (United States) David Kennedy (United States) Technology and Society (STS) and the IGLP Northeastern University Law School Harvard Law School co-sponsored a discussion led by Professor Timothy Mitchell (Columbia University) on Ahmed Ragab (Egypt) Ingrid Metzler (Austria) the themes raised in his 2011 publication Harvard Divinity School Harvard Kennedy School “Carbon Democracy: Political Power in the Age of Oil”. Mr. Mitchell argues that no Andrew Lang (United Kingdom) James McCarthy (United States) nation escapes the political consequences London School of Economics Harvard University of our collective dependence on oil and that the politics of the West have become Betsy Bartholet (United States) Sheila Jasanof (United States) dependent on an undemocratic Middle Harvard Law School Harvard Kennedy School East. Mr. Mitchell shared his thoughts as they have developed after completing his Brice Laurent (France) Steve Caton (United States) most recent books and reflected on the Harvard Kennedy School Harvard University forms of politics that may arise in tandem with future energy transitions. Dan Danielsen (United States) Northeastern University Law School

18 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

The International Public Interest Legal Establishment: What Public? Whose Interest? Harvard Law School, March 14, 2013 On March 14, 2013 at Harvard Law School, University), Zinaida Miller (Tufts University), perspective that will open up new ways of the IGLP co-sponsored the Unbound and Aminu Gamawa (Harvard Law School) thinking about the way public interest legal Spring Panel: “The International Public led a discussion about public interest legal work is organized and practiced. Interest Legal Establishment: What Public? work in an international context. The aim Whose Interest?”. Vasuki Nesiah (New York of the event was to help develop a critical

Views from the Bench on Legal Education Harvard Law School, March 13, 2013 On March 3, 2013 the IGLP and the Harvard Manuel José Cepeda Espinosa (former The panel discussion was part of the SJD Law School SJD Association co-sponsored a Justice and President of the Constitution- Association’s ongoing inquiry into glob- panel discussion at Harvard Law School on al Court of Colombia) and Judge Wanjiru al legal education. Co-Sponsors included: Views from the Bench on Legal Education. Karanja, (Kenya Court of Appeal). Harvard Committee on African Studies, the Mil- The event featured discussion on the pres- Law School Dean Martha Minow deliv- bank Tweed Student Conference Fund and ent state of legal education with current ered opening remarks, and Professor David the Weatherhead Center for International and former judges including Justice Rosalie Wilkins (Harvard Law School) moderated Affairs, Canada Program. Abella (Supreme Court of Canada) Professor the discussion.

13th Annual Harvard Graduate Student Conference on International History Harvard Law School, March 14-15, 2013

From March 14-15, 2013, the IGLP co-spon- “Lincoln’s Lawyers in Africa” “Citizenship, Development, And sored the 13th Annual Harvard Graduate Marco Basile (Italy) Constitutionalism In The South Atlantic: Student Conference on International History Harvard Law School The Connected Corporatist Experiments Of Portugal And Brazil, 1930-1945” (ConIH) which focused on “Law and Inter- “Uncertain Transcripts: Modernizing Melissa Teixeira (United States) national History”. In 2013, ConIH brought Customary Law Courts in Coastal Kenya, 1945- Princeton University together graduate students from around the 1981” United States and the world to present their Reynolds Richter (United States) “Beyond the Limits of War Crimes Trials: New York University American, British and Canadian Responses to research. The participants aim to interrogate Jurisdictional Failures in Pacific ‘Minor’ War the role of law in international, global, and “A Widow’s Plea, or the Reach of Prize Law from Crimes Trials” transnational history, and to think critically the Barracks of Kronstadt to the Houses of Mark Sweeney (Canada) about law as a concept and a tool in historical Parliament, 1816-1819” Tri University analysis. Laura Bention (Professor of History Julia Leikin (United Kingdom) University College London “Arab Women, The League of Nations and the and Affiliate Professor of Law, New York Uni- Politicization of Women’s Rights” versity School of Law) delivered the Keynote “l’ONU, c’est quelle tribu? The United Nations Nova Robinson (United States) Address at this year’s conference. Intervention in the Congo, 1960-1961” Rutgers University Lydia Walker (United States) Harvard University “Pettifoggers contesting the state: Judicial The conference was structured around a misconducts, legal cultures and justice series of panels. Twelve graduate students “Equality Before Efficiency: American Antitrust administration in late and post-colonial presented their work and then received Law and European Integration” Colombia and Venezuela.” individual comments from senior scholars in Benjamin Brady (United States) William San Martin (Chile) their field. University of Virginia University of California at Davis “From Extraterritoriality To Special Economic “Damages and Colonial Difference: American Presenters: Zones: Anti-Imperialism And Foreign Tort Law in Early Twentieth Century Philippine Investment, 1970-1990” Jurisprudence” “The Non-recognition by the West of the Chris Miller (United States) Clara Altman (United States) Annexation of the Baltic States” Yale University Brandeis University Una Bergamane (France) Sciences Po Law School

19 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Facts and Futures: Expertise Between Science and Law Workshop Harvard law School, April 18-19, 2013

On April 18-19, 2013, the IGLP and the whom do they represent, what are the expertise is defined, constituted, challenged, Program on Science and Technology sources of their authority, and how can defended, or defeated in contemporary Studies (PSTS) at the Kennedy School of expertise be held accountable? What kinds societies. The April Workshop focused on Government hosted a Workshop on “Facts of institutions employ expertise, and what the following core themes: and Futures: Expertise between Science and are the organizational characteristics of Law”. This Workshop was part of the joint such institutions? How does the growing “Bureaucratic Logics of Expertise I”, and IGLP/PSTS project aimed at strengthening global reliance on experts affect the quality, “Bureaucratic Logics of Expertise II” research that links efforts to understand effectiveness, and accountability of public Chair: Sheila Jasanoff (United States) the role of expertise in global governance policy and governance? Through readings Harvard Kennedy School among IGLP scholars with parallel work and/or presentations from several fields— undertaken in the Science and Technology including law, anthropology, history, “Human Rights, Bio-power, & Expertise”, Studies field. Questions under discussion sociology, and science and technology and “Expertise, Authority, Modernity” at the workshop included: Who are experts, studies—participants considered the ways Chair: David Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School

Forced Labor in the New Economy Harvard Law School, March 26, 2013

On Tuesday, March 26, 2013, at Harvard and discussed the new legal and organizing and the National Guestworker Alliance Law School, the IGLP hosted Jennifer strategies that are emerging to protect and (NGA), both based in New Orleans. Her work (J.J.) Rosenbaum (Harvard Law School, strengthen low-wage and migrant workers focuses on the intersection of workers’ rights, J.D. 2002), who spoke about her new book faced with the stringencies of the new civil rights, immigration, and constitutional “Forced Labor in the New Economy: Legal economy. Ms. Rosenbaum is the Founding law. IGLP Advisory Council member Janet Strategies for Workers in the Walmart, Legal and Policy Director of the New Orleans Halley convened this discussion. Hershey’s Chocolates and McDonald’s Cases”, Workers’ Center for Racial Justice (NOWCR)

The Next Left: Framing a New Narrative Barcelona, Spain, May 10-11, 2013

On May 10-11, 2013 the IGLP Director Other speakers and panelists: Yiannis Drossos (Greece) David Kennedy spoke at a policy Athens Law School roundtable on “The Next Left: Framing a Pere Navarro (Spain) Paolo Guerrieri (Italy) New Narrative ” hosted by the Foundation First Secretary of the Partit dels Socialistes University of Rome ‘La Sapienza’ University for European Progressive Studies (FEPS) de Catalunya Carles Rivera (Spain) at the Idec-Univsersitat Pompeu Fabra in Esther Niubó (Spain) University Pompeu Fabra Barcelona, Spain. The event focused on the Director of the Fundació Rafael Campalans Roçio Martinez Sampère (Spain) contemporary state of social democratic Anton Hemerijck (Netherlands) Catalan Socialist Party politics and the potential for a progressive Free University of Amsterdam Karl Duffek (Austria) global agenda for the 21st century. The Matjaz Nahtigal (Slovenia) Director of the Karl Renner Institute and event was co-organized by Fundacio University of Primorska Vice‐President of the Foundation for Rafael Compalans and co-sponsored by Leopold Specht (Vienna) European Progressive Studies the IGLP and the Renner Institute. Among Sprecht Böhm Vienna Juan Moscoso (Spain) those taking part in the discussion were Dr. Anna Terron (Spain) Economist and Politician, Former member Alfred Gusenbauer, former Chancellor of Former Member of European Parliament of Spanish Parliament Austria, Massimo D’Alema, President of Amandine Crespy (France) Ernst Stetter (Germany) FEPS and former Prime Minister of Italy, and Université Libre de Bruxelles Secretary General of the Foundation for a delegation of researchers and experts from European Progressive Studies across the globe.

20 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Law and New Development Strategies: Brazil and Beyond Sao Paolo, Brazil, July 1-4, 2013 The following scholars participated: From July 1-4, 2013 in Sao Pau- policy-making factory”, the is- David Kennedy (United States) Michelle Sanchez Badin (Brazil) lo Brazil, The IGLP sponsored sues these developments have Harvard Law School Fundação Getulio Vargas/São a seminar on the “Law and for the law and for the economy, Lucie E. White (United States) Paulo Law School New Development Strategies: and about how the emerging Harvard Law School Kerry Rittich (Canada) Brazil and Beyond.” The sem- law and development debate David Trubek (United States) University of Toronto Faculty of Law inar emerged out of the IGLP in Brazil relates to global trends University of Wisconsin Law School Alvaro Santos (Mexico/United States) Research Project on “Law and in the field. The event culminat- John Ohnesorge (United States) Georgetown Law School the New Developmental State” ed with a writing workshop for University of Wisconsin Law School Dan Danielsen (United States) (LANDS) and brought togeth- graduate students working on Diogo Rosenthal Coutinho (Brazil) Northeastern University School of Law er scholars and policy makers issues surrounding the chang- University of São Paulo Law School Mushtaq Khan (United Kingdom) to explore the emerging forms ing roles of state and law in Carlos Portugal Gouvêa (Brazil) SOAS, University of London of new state activism in Brazil development policies. Support University of São Paulo Law School Helena Alviar Garcia (Colombia) and elsewhere and examined for the Workshop generously Jean Paulo Veiga Rocha (Brazil) Universidad de los Andes Law School the theoretical work in political provided by the IGLP’s Leading University of São Paulo Law School Jason Jackson (United States) economy that has accompa- Sponsor Santander Universi- Mario Gomes Schapiro (Brazil) University of Pennsylvania nied these turns in state policy. ties as well as from the David Fundação Getulio Vargas/São Paulo Gustavo Sampaio A. Ribeiro (Brazil Discussion also focused on the Rockefeller Center for Latin Law School and United States) practices behind the “Brazilian American Studies at Harvard. Mariana Pargendler (Brazil) Harvard Law School Fundação Getulio Vargas/São Paulo Marcus Faro de Castro (Brazil) Law School University of Brasília Law School

Lectures and Presentations by Professor David Kennedy Professor David Kennedy, IGLP Director, participated in a number of conferences and seminars this past year, giving lectures or serving as a panelist in many of them. In 2012‐2013, these included:

”Development Policy, Global Governance & the New Development State”, “Critical Approaches to International Law and Warfare”, The American presented at the conference “Global Governance: Critical Legal Perspectives University in Cairo, Egypt, March 10, 2013. Liber Amicorum” with David M. Trubek, at European University Institute, Florence, June 28, 2012. Interview, Pricewaterhouse Coopers, Washington DC, March 28, 2013.

”The American Approach to Global Law and Policy” and “International Keynote Panel, “Reducing Poverty and Inequality: Persistent Challenges and Economic Regulation”, lectures in the International Business Law Program, New Solutions,” The Lauder Institute and the Wharton School, Philadelphia, presented at Garrigues law firm, Madrid, July 3-5, 2012. PA, April 11-12, 2013.

Remarks, “Development Strategies in the Emerging Markets of the ASEAN Moderator, Koskenniemi Workshop: “Does International Law Needs a Region”, IGLP-Visa Roundtable, Bangkok, August 30-31, 2012. ‘Progressive’ Idea of History?” Temple University, Philadelphia PA, April 12- 13, 2013. Remarks, “Asian Peace and Reconciliation Council Preparatory Meeting”, Bangkok, September 4, 2012. Speaker, “American Conference Institute’s 29th National Forum on the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act,” Pricewaterhouse Coopers, New York, NY, April ”American Legal Thought”, lectures presented at the Garrigues law firm, 16-17, 2013. Barcelona and Madrid, September 20-21, 2012. ARPC Council Meeting, Beijing, China, April 23-25, 2013. “Law and Global Political Economy”, IGLP Workshop, Doha, Qatar, January 11, 2013. Opening Remarks, “Formulating a Global Agenda, Next Left: Framing a New Narrative,” FEPS Conference, IDEC-Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona, “Critical Legal Scholarship”, Birkbeck Law School, London, January 24, 2013. Spain, May 9-11, 2013.

“Risk Management and Corporate Anti-Corruption Compliance Strategies -- Opening Remarks / Keynote Speaker, LANDS Conference, Fundação Getulio A Discussion with Dr. David Kennedy”, American Bar Association, Washington, Vargas (FGV) / São Paulo Law School, São Paulo, Brazil, July 1-4, 2013. D.C., February 14, 2013.

“Global Governance for the Political Economy of Today”, Rafael del Pino Foundation, Madrid, Spain, February 21, 2013. [Transcript] 21 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

IGLP Research 2012-2013 Our Current Research search seminar on Financial Capitalism which work undertaken in the Science and Technology Projectsent Research Projects focused on the structures of finance and money, Studies field. The focal point for collaboration has Research at the IGLP is organized in multi-year with an eye towards the financial crisis. been a series of lectures, research workshops and projects spearheaded by our affiliated faculty. an inter-faculty reading group organized by IGLP Together, these projects provide a focal point at Project on Global Financial Regula- Director David Kennedy (Harvard Law School) Harvard Law School for new thinking in the fields tion and Financial Inclusion and Sheila Jasanoff (Harvard Kennedy School). of comparative law, global governance and inter- This project, supported by one of the IGLP’s Lead- Questions under discussion include: Who are national law. Our current on-going research proj- ing Sponsors VISA International, Inc., encom- experts, whom do they represent, what are the ects include: passes inquiries into three related areas: liquidity sources of their authority, and how can expertise in the global economy, including foundational re- be held accountable? What kinds of institutions Rethinking the Legal Structure of search on the nature of global liquidity and cap- employ expertise, and what are the organization- Liquidity and the Nature of Money in ital as legal institutions; financial inclusion and al characteristics of such institutions? How does the Global Economy banking services for the “unbanked” as an aspect the growing global reliance on experts affect This project, organized by IGLP Advisory Council of development policy; and financial service regu- the quality, effectiveness, and accountability of Member Christine Desan (Harvard Law School) lation in emerging markets and alternative paths public policy and governance? The research ini- focuses on the lessons of heterodox and institu- to economic development. Through a series of tiative is supported by a seminar jointly taught by tionalist traditions in both economic and legal sponsored student and faculty research projects Ms. Jasanoff and Mr. Kennedy at Harvard Law science for understanding global political econo- and public policy discussions, we seek to develop School and Harvard Kennedy School each spring. my in the aftermath of the crisis. We are particu- a transnational research network of young schol- larly interested in the relationships among private ars and IGLP faculty working on research themes The Next Left – The Challenges and law, private ordering, national regulation and op- related to global financial regulation. The initia- Opportunities for Social Democratic portunities for multilateral governance or coordi- tive’s inaugural event was a policy workshop on Politics in a Global Economy nation. We are exploring the significance of dis- March 30, 2012, which brought scholars from the This project, which we are co-sponsoring with articulation and intended inefficiencies in global IGLP network into sustained conversation with IGLP Honorary Council Member Alfred Gusen- systems in avoiding systemic risk – when intro- high-level government officials and industry rep- bauer (Former Chancellor of Austria), encourages duced both within the transnational governance resentatives. In August 2012, the IGLP convened dialog among those rethinking the politics of the of private financial institutions and through regu- a research mission and workshop in Bangkok fo- left after globalization in various regions of the lation. The project focuses on the legal structure cused on new financial services regulation and world, with a particular emphasis on the dynam- of money, credit and financial liquidity. It con- development strategies in the emerging markets ics within Europe and between Europe and Latin siders capital dynamics as a matter engineered of the ASEAN region. In 2012 and 2013, the ini- America. over time by different government, non‐govern- tiative sponsored a competitive research grant mental organizations and private actors, paying program for young scholars awarding grants to On May 10 -11, 2013, the IGLP co-sponsored the particular attention to the ways in which capital six graduate scholars. policy roundtable, “Next Left: Framing a New Nar- dynamics cross borders, studying the domestic rative”, in Barcelona, Spain. The event explored and global dimensions of capital dynamics in Expertise and Governance topics such as restoring sense of politics, distin- tandem. During the 2012-2013 academic year, This project aims to strengthen research linking guishing modern progressivism, and building a we co-sponsored a graduate student-faculty re- efforts to understand the role of expertise in glob- welfare society. al governance among IGLP scholars with parallel (Cont.)

22 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Global Genealogy of Family Laws activism in Brazil and elsewhere and examined butional effects of the developmental pathways The rise of colonialism, capitalism, liberalism, the theoretical work in political economy that that they identify. modernity and nationalism across much of the has accompanied these turns in state policy. At world was strongly inflected by the idea that the seminar, scholars and policy experts learned IGLP Collaborative Research legal and social life divides naturally into two about the practice behind the “Brazilian poli- Grants opposite orders – the market and the family. cy-making factory”, the issues these develop- In 2011 the Institute launched a new Collabora- The idea was that the market was or should be ments have for the law and for the economy, and tive Research Grant Program designed to provide governed by contract law that would ideally be how the emerging law and development debate modest funding to small groups of young schol- uniform across the world and that would enable in Brazil relates to global trends in the field. ars who are seeking to carry out substantive re- contracts giving effect to the will of the parties; search on projects related to the core research while the family was or should be governed by In July 2013 we celebrated the publication of mission of the IGLP. The program aims to facili- family law that gave effect to the spirit of each “Law and the New Developmental State: The tate innovative group research and writing proj- national people and that enforced interpersonal Brazilian Experience in Latin American Context“ ects in international law and policy, and deepen duties. which emerged out of the LANDS initiative. The the network of collaboration among our Harvard project was spear-headed by David Trubek (Uni- Law School graduate students, IGLP Workshop This IGLP project, led by IGLP Advisory Counsil versity of Wisconsin) in conjunction with other alumni, and IGLP faculty. IGLP Collaborative member Janet Halley (Harvard Law School), IGLP alumni including Diogo Coutinho (Univer- Research Grants are designed for small teams seeks to compare the spread of this idea and its sity of São Paulo Law School), Mario Schapiro of two or more scholars. Preference is given to various implementations across the world, both (Fundação Getulio Vargas/São Paulo Law School), groups whose ideas or projects emerged out of in the formation of colonial relations and in the Shunko Rojas (Harvard Law School), Alvaro breakdown of the colonial system. We believe Santos (Georgetown Law School), Michelle that by understanding it genealogically and Ratton Sanchez Badin (Fundação Getulio Vargas/ comparatively, we can better pry away the glue São Paulo Law School), and Helena Alviar Garcia fixing us to it even today. (Universidad de los Andes Law School). The book explores the emergence of a new developmental Law and the New Developmental state in Latin America and its significance for law State and development theory. This collaborative faculty project led by IGLP Academic Council Member David Trubek (Uni- Global Poverty and Heterodox De- versity of Wisconsin) examines the modern re- velopment Pathways vival of the developmental state. Although state This project, led by Lucie White (Harvard Law activism came under attack in the hey-day of School) and Jeremy Perelman (Sciences Po Law neo-liberalism, today states in many developing School), is a collaborative effort among critical countries are once again actively promoting eco- law and development scholars to present, map, nomic growth and social development. These and critique alternative development pathways initiatives build on prior experiences but often that are emerging in the confused phase of take new forms as states cope with the challeng- the post-Washington Consensus. The initiative es of growth under conditions of globalization. was launched as a Pro-Seminar in 2012, where As part of this initiative, the IGLP co-sponsored members of the group presented short papers a seminar and research mission to Brazil in July that tease out the methodological features of 2013 exploring the emerging forms of new state their respective approaches, as well as the distri-

23 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

the IGLP’s Annual Workshop on Global Law and tice, peace, legality, addressing impunity and these overarching narratives to positive interna- Economic Policy. accountability. What is missing from the main- tional law. stream debate are the possible complicities of The Collaborative Research Projects current- ICL in injustice, conflict, exclusions, and biases. The organizers hosted a workshop in June of ly underway: This project seeks to examine these complici- 2013 at the University of Cambridge to explore ties and limitations in the contemporary under- these themes with the goal of producing an Critical Approaches to International standing of ICL. The organizers hosted a confer- edited volume of essays to serve as a critical in- Criminal Law ence on “Critical Approaches to International troduction to different ways of thinking about, Organized by IGLP Workshop Alumni Michelle Criminal Law” at the University of Liverpool describing, and designing international law. Burgis-Kasthala (University of St. Andrews), Paul School of Law and Social Justice in December Kingsley Clark (Garden Court Chambers), Tor of 2012. Global Law in Context Krever (London School of Economics and Political Organized by Henrique Carvalho (King’s Col- Science), Heidi Matthews (Harvard Law School), Turf and Texture: Narrating the lege London), Luis Eslava (Melbourne Law John Reynolds (National University of Ireland) and Legal International School), Vanja Hamzic (City University Lon- Christine Schwobel (Liverpool Law School). Organized by IGLP Workshop Alumni Lucas don), Vidya Kumar (University of Birmingham), Lixinski (University of South Wales), Nikolas Yoriko Otomo, Oishick Sircar (University of The field of International Criminal Law (ICL) has M. Rajkovic (University of Kent Law School), Melbourne) recently experienced a significant surge in schol- and Surabhi Ranganathan (University of Cam- arship, in institutions, and in the public debate. bridge). The aim of this project is to provide an introduc- The contemporary debate is predominantly tory textbook with the underlying theme, ‘Glob- focused on ICL’s contribution to projects of jus- Current debates in international law seem to al Law in Context.’ The book would be targeted be informed by different narratives about what to law students around the world and would the international legal order “is” or “should be”. offer fresh and under-explored perspectives on These narratives inform the way in which we global law as they relate to the core law subjects. perceive and articulate international law; at- The project organizers feel that current global tempting to explain alleged convergences and law texts do not reflect the rich variety of ways divergences of international legal rules and in- in which law is being produced and used across stitutions. Dominant approaches in the narra- jurisdictions, scales of governance and social tion of the legal international include familiar contexts today. Through the ‘Global Law in Con- labels such as “global administrative law,” “the text’ project they seek to explore more deeply constitutionalization of international law,” “inter- the plurality of legal concepts and systems that national legal pluralism,” and “the fragmentation co-exist/conflict across national boundaries of international law.” and epistemological traditions. The organizers Each of these approaches brings something began drafting the introduction at a working different to the table, but little work has been group session at the end of 2012. Following a done in scrutinizing the contribution of these more detailed scoping of the project they may narratives to an idea of the “legal international.” extend a call for contributions to other IGLP This project is aimed at understanding these Workshop alumni. processes and evaluating the contribution of (Cont.)

24 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Locating Nature: Making and in June at Harvard Law School prior to the com- and Vik Kanwar (Jindal Global Law School). Unmaking International Law mencement of IGLP’s Conference. This research initiative looks to examine the trans- Organized by Usha Natarajan (The American formations currently at work in the International University in Cairo), Sergio Latorre (Oñati Inter- Rethinking Political Economy laws of terrorism, crime, and war. The old image national Institute for the Sociology of Law) and Organized by Jason Jackson (The Wharton of a battlefield packed with regular combatants in Vanessa Ruegger (University of Fribourg), Dee- School, University of Pennsylvania) and Anush uniform is certainly a war image of a bygone era. pa Badrinarayana (Chapman University), Ileana Kapadia (Harvard University). New military technologies and the proliferation Porras (University of Miami School of Law), Karin of armed conflicts between states and hostile Mickelson (University of British Columbia), Kis- This project seeks to address the narrow nature of non-state actors have blurred the delimitation of han Khoday (Energy and Environment Practice the academic and policy discourse around the so- the battlefield and the distinction between com- Leader for Arab States, United Nations Develop- cioeconomic and governance challenges we face, batants and civilians. A restrictive interpretation ment Programme, Canada), Tyler McCreary (York perhaps best epitomized by the financial crisis, of the law of war is mostly advanced by interna- University), Vanessa Lamb (York University). but also in long-standing debates on economic tional lawyers situated at the Western centers of development and global governance. It looks to the globe who see the law from the perspective This project brings together alternative and criti- promote new thinking on economic governance of the interest of the international community. It cal viewpoints with the aim to publish a collective that takes into account issues such as the distri- is remarkable, however, that there is no view in- work on the relationship between international butional implications of the crisis and the ways terpreting rules and balancing policy objectives law and the environment. Environmental change in which the response was constructed through in light of the interests and the position of weaker and resource scarcity have emerged as existential political contestation, rather than the dominant states of the semi-periphery, states that are most threats in recent years. While international law- (depoliticized) view of these being technocratic commonly affected by military intervention. The yers have focused on disciplinary solutions to the outputs from “experts.” Through a series of work- research project seeks to fill this gap. Through a challenge of ecological change, less attention is shops and conferences, the organizers seek to series of workshops, the organizers plan to pro- given to the role of international law in creating create a space where young scholars from across duce a series of scholarly articles for publication scarcity and unsustainability. This project ex- different disciplines who share similar views can as a volume . plores how understandings of nature shaped come together to work collaboratively on issues seminal international law concepts. The organiz- of political economy, and collaborate on scholarly ers share an intuition that understanding and writing for publication. unpacking assumptions about nature will help us think our way out of destructive development Pursuing your Enemies in the South: patterns. The research group seeks to publish a International Law and the War collection of six articles on the relationship be- against Crime and Terror tween international law and the environment in Organized by Arnulf Becker Lorca (Brown a leading international law journal. To review re- University), Justin Desautels-Stein (University search progress, the collaborative research group of Colorado), John Haskell (Mississippi College members also held a one-day project workshop of Law), Akbar Rasulov (University of Glasgow),

25 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Before and After Method: Histories The organizers plan a two-year project on the (University of St. Andrew), and Zinaida Miller and Sociologies of International Law methodologies of international legal scholarship (Tufts University). Organized by John Haskell (Mississippi College to “sociologize” the enterprise of international le- This project examines critical approaches to of Law), Alejandro Lorite Escorihuela (Helinski gal historiography. The recent turn to history in human rights with an eye towards understand- Collegium for Advanced Studies), Umut Özsu international legal scholarship has generated a ing where and how the critiques have become (University of Manitoba), and Akbar Rasulov significant degree of theoretical reflection, with absorbed into mainstream human rights work (University of Glasgow). issues of Eurocentrism and centre-periphery re- without significant transformation of the field. lations receiving increasingly sophisticated con- Despite a plethora of sustained critique, little sideration. evidence exists for significant shifts within main- stream human rights theory and practice. In re- For this research effort, each participant has been sponse, the organizers propose convening two invited to prepare a paper that analyzes a partic- workshops to provide an opportunity to rethink ular jurist, school, doctrine, or tradition in its so- and re-examine these critiques in relation to the cio-historical context. The organizers convened current moment in human rights. at a small workshop to discuss draft papers in Cambridge, MA in June 2013 followed by a small The project will bring together junior scholars for workshop in the UK. The organizers hope to have a critical reading of key critical texts on human revised versions of the papers published in the rights in September 2013 at Northeastern Univer- form of a broadly interconnected set of essays by sity, followed by a workshop with senior scholars a leading academic publisher. to discuss draft papers for an edited volume or special journal issue. Critical Approaches to Human Rights Organized by Aziza Ahmed (Northeastern Uni- versity School of Law), Michelle Burgis-Kasthala

26 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

People at the IGLP 2012 - 2013

Visiting Researchers and Karen Engle (United States) Andrew Lang (United Kingdom) Scholars University of Texas London School of School of Law Economics The IGLP accommodates a small number of Ms. Engle is Minerva Mr. Lang is a Reader in Visiting Researchers and Visiting Scholars House Drysdale Re- Law, and teaches Public each academic year. gents Chair in Law and Founder and Co-di- International Law, with a rector of the Bernard and Audre Rapoport specialty in International Economic Law. Visiting Researchers and Scholars apply Center for Human Rights and Justice. She He has a combined B.A./LL.B. from the Uni- to do research at the Law School for a teaches courses and specialized seminars versity of Sydney, and his Ph.D. is from the minimum of three months. In making se- in public international law, international University of Cambridge. He is a co-found- lections, the Committee at the Institute human rights law and employment dis- er of the Society of International Econom- considers the applicant’s background, crimination. Ms. Engle received her J.D. ic Law. He sits on the Editorial Committee field of interest, scholarly achievements, from Harvard Law School and her under- of the Modern Law Review, the Editorial availability of Harvard Law School faculty graduate degree from Baylor University. Boards of the Journal of International Eco- for consultation in the proposed research Following law school, she clerked for Judge nomic Law and the Law and Development area, and English language proficiency. Ap- Jerre S. Williams on the 5th Circuit Court of Review, and is a Book Review Editor for the plicants should have completed their basic Appeals, and then served as a post-doctor- International and Comparative Law Quar- legal studies with high academic standing. al Ford Fellow in Public International Law at terly. He has taught as the World Trade Visiting Scholar applicants are also required Harvard Law School. She was Professor of Institute’s Masters of International Law and to be affiliated with a university, research Law at the University of Utah prior to join- Economics (MILE) program, the University institute or governmental program in their ing the University of Texas. Ms. Engle writes of Barcelona’s IELPO course, as well as the home country. and lectures extensively on international IIEM Academy of International Trade Law in human rights law. She is author of The Elu- Macau. His current research is focused on a Visiting Researchers sive Promise of Indigenous Development: number of themes around global economic 2012-2013: Rights, Culture, Strategy (Duke University governance, including the relationship be- Press, 2010), which received the Best Book tween law and expert knowledge, interna- Award from the American Political Science tional law and economics, and sociological Association Section on Human Rights. approaches to the study of international Luwam Dirar (Eritea) economic law. Cornell Law School

Ms. Dirar is a J.S.D. can- didate at Cornell Law Julio González García José María Puyol (Spain) School and Schlesinger (Spain) Universidad Compultense Fellow. Prior to joining Universidad Cornell Law School, she served as a legal Complutense Mr. Puyol is a tenured adviser to the Minister of Justice of the Professor of History of State of Eritrea, and clerked for the honor- Mr. García is Full Law at the Department ary Justice Habteab Yemane of the Highest Professor of Admin- of History of Law and Appellate Court of Eritrea. Ms. Dirar has istrative Law at the Institutions at the Uni- worked on various capacity building proj- Universidad Complutense de Madrid. His versidad Complutense de Madrid, as well ects in the justice sector, and has served research focuses on public goods, public as a Visiting Professor at Sciences Po Law in different position in drafting of laws procurement, economic globalization, ad- School, Paris, His research focuses on ad- and proclamations in Eritrea. In addition, ministrative intervention in public services, ministration of justice and capital punish- she has also held various fellowships, and education and university Law, and Europe- ment in the XIXth century, history of the served as an editor of the Cornell Interna- an Law. spanish university (XIXth and XXth century) tional Law Journal. Her current research and political and administrative institutions project for her J.S.D. dissertation examines during the peninsular war (1808-1814). the European Union as an exogenous fac- Mr. Puyol received his Ph.D. in Law from tor in the integration schemes of Southern Universidad Complutense. African Countries.

27 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

In 2013 we awarded 13 IGLP/Santander Doha Grants:

Noha Aboueldahab (Egypt) Durham University IGLP Workshop Participant 2013 Prosecution of Political Leaders in the Arab Region

This grant funded travel to Libya and Yemen for field research on the social, legal and political processes regarding decisions to prosecute (and not to prosecute) in those countries.

Ms. Aboueldahab presented her research in June 2013 at IGLP: The Conference in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Her paper, which she hopes to publish in an academic journal, addresses issues of individual criminal accountability of high-ranking government officials in the Arab region.

Ermin Sinanovic (Bosnia/Herzegovina) Karen Rhone (United States) United States Naval Academy University of Chicago IGLP Workshop Participant 2012 IGLP Workshop Participant 2013 Islamic Political Thought Capturing Moral and the Arab Uprisings Imagination: Islam, Development, and This grant funded travel to Egypt for Knowledge Regimes archival and ethnographic research on Islamic political thought and This grant funded travel to the emergence of Islamic political Amman, Jordan and research on knowledge regimes and their parties after the Arab Uprisings, with the goal of producing a understandings, proclivities and hesitations about Islamic ideals. book for publication by the end of 2013. The analysis was executed as a comparative case study between Qatar Foundation (QF) in Doha and Konrad-Adenauer- The main thesis of his book indicates the recent Arab Uprisings, Stiftung Foundation (KAS) in Amman. While the goals of both also known as the Arab Spring, have created important new foundations are quite similar, they vary in their focus as well as developments in Islamic political thought, which have produced the knowledge regimes they will likely rely on and reproduce. Ms. a marked departure from many positions held in classical Islamic Rhone plans to use her research in her dissertation as well as to political thought. The book is an attempt to trace, discover, produce an article for publication. and understand these changes by examining the writings, statements, and actions of Islamist actors prior, during, and after the Arab Uprisings.

28 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Participants from 2013 IGLP Colloquium

29 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

30 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Principal Investigator: Principal Investigator: Chantal Thomas (United States) Amr Shalakany (Egypt) Cornell Law School The American University in Cairo IGLP Workshop Faculty IGLP Workshop Faculty Contemporary Law and the Arts in the Approaches to Arab Middle East Today and Islamic Law and This collaborative research project Governance aims to map the doctrinal arrange- This collaborative research project ments, institutional structures and aims to canvass innovative trends market practices governing “Law and in the fields of Arab and Islamic the Arts” in the Middle East today. The focus is on the legal systems law by convening young scholars to assess the current state and of Egypt, Lebanon, Turkey, Qatar, the UAE, and Iran, with compar- future directions of comparative work in these fields. The project ative references to select East Asian, American and European ju- plans to develop an historical understanding of approaches to risdictions, along with public international law and international law and governance the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) that economic and trade law. This project continues thematic discus- unites study of Islamic law and Arab legal traditions. This project sions begun at the Doha Workshop in January 2013 in the research draws insight and support from existing collaborative projects stream on “Contemporary Approaches to Arab and Islamic Law and already supported by the IGLP at Harvard Law School, including Governance” by focusing on the specific case study of law and the Pro-Seminars on Heterodox Development and Transnational arts. This grant supported the first stages of what is envisioned as Labor Law and Social Policy. The grant will support a conference a two-year project. A core group of interested researchers plans in New York City in Fall 2013 which will bring together experts to meet four times over the ensuing two years to share research on comparative and international law, global governance, and results, review completed work, and fine-tune the project publica- development, modern Middle East studies, and Islamic legal tions. Each meeting will also include select “guest speakers” as the thought. The envisioned research outcomes include an edited meeting’s theme. The project will culminate with an edited volume volume and a casebook to be published in 2014 or 2015. (one part theory, the other a casebook on Law in the Middle East Today) in both Arabic and English.

Nadia Ahmad (United States) Dawood Ahmed (Pakistan) Sustainable Development Strategies Group University of Chicago IGLP Workshop Participant 2013 IGLP Workshop Participant 2013

Cautionary Approach to An Analysis of ‘Shariah Biofuel Production in the Clauses’ in the Middle East: The Dilemma Constitutions of Muslim of Food Security and Majority Countries Energy Demands

This grant funds research into laws The goal of this research project is to further contribute to the and policies related to the deployment of biofuels in the Middle scholarship on comparative constitutional design. The project East and supports research on regulatory and governance undertakes a comparative analysis of the constitutions of selected mechanisms to analyze the consequences of biofuel production. Muslim majority countries to analyze and understand the origins Through this project, Ms. Ahmad aims to evaluate the Islamic of sharia provisions and their evolution and relationship with perspective on sustainability and economic jurisprudence human rights provisions in constitutions. principles as it relates to energy development and examine how agricultural demands for food cultivation may be undercut by ramped up biofuel production in Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Bahrain, Jordan, and Kuwait. The intended outcome for this research is a published law review article.

31 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Muhammad Azeem (Canada/Pakistan) Cyra Choudhury (United States) Osgoode Hall Law School, York University Florida International University IGLP Participant 2013 IGLP Workshop Docent 2012

The Role of the Judiciary in Avenues of Legal Reform ‘Political Governance’ in Egypt of Transnational and This project focuses on the role of the International Labor Laws in judiciary in ‘political governance’ in the Gulf and Saudi Arabia Pakistan with a compartative study of Egypt, which has strong parallels with Pakistan. The main areas of This grant funded research in the comparison are Pakistan’s and Egypt’s relation to (U.S.) imperial laws governing migrant labor in the Gulf and Saudi Arabia. The interests, its long tradition of liberal Islam, its military position, grant additionally supported travel to South Asia (India and and the recent popular upsurge that has led to the rise of the Bangladesh) to study male and female laborers who work in role of the judiciary in intra-elite struggles. The grant funded the Middle East. The aim of the project is to produce research travel to Egypt to collect relevant case-law, interview jurists, and in support of a legal reform proposal. Additionally, the hope interact with Egypt intellectuals who have been studying these is to publish an article on this topic and to follow up with a issues. Mr. Azeem plans to publish an article and invite Egyptian collaborative project involving a number of IGLP alumni and scholars to Pakistan to develop further collaborative projects. faculty in a long-term research collaboration.

Ignacio De La Rasilla Luis Eslava (Australia/Colombia) Del Moral (Spain) Melbourne Law School Brunel Law School IGLP Workshop Docent 2012 and 2013 IGLP Workshop Participant 2011 Challenges and Arab and Islamic Legal Opportunities for Urban and International Legal Residents Thought This grant supported Luis Eslava’s participation in and travel to the This grant funded research on the workshop, “Study Space VI: Planning contribution of Arab and Islamic international legal thought for Disaster: Place, Population, to international law in Spain during the formative period for Culture, and the Environment,” which was held in Istanbul from European international law in the period 1550-1700. The grant March 31 to April 6, 2013. Study Space VI is a joint project of supported visits to the main universities of Andalusia in Southern the Center for the Comparative Study of Metropolitan Growth Spain (University of Granada, University of Cordoba and (Georgia State University College of Law) and Bahçesehir University of Seville) as well as to the Spanish National Library University (Istanbul, Turkey), in cooperation with the Payson (Madrid) to provide coverage of the Arab and Islamic Traditions Center for International Development (Tulane University Law of International Law on the entries “Medieval International School). During the workshop, Mr. Eslava conducted discussion Law” and the “History of International Law: 1550-1700” which groups and completed fieldwork visits around Istanbul. As a have been commissioned by Oxford University Press – Oxford result of his participation in the workshop, he seeks to produce Bibliographies. an original research paper for publication in a journal. The paper will focus on the challenges and opportunities experienced by urban residents, given Istanbul’s location within the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, yet being part of a nation that is in the process of integration to the European Union.

32 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Vanja Hamzic (Bosnia/Herzegovina) Zinaida Miller (United States) City University London Tufts University IGLP Workshop Docent 2012 and 2013 IGLP Docent 2012 and 2013

Towards an Interruptive The History of History of Islamic Law International Activity in Palestine from the League Through this project, Mr. Hamzic seeks of Nations until the to critically assess the potentials and Contemporary Era the limits of the two major streams of historiography of Islamic law in order This grant supports research on to investigate many significant factors that have shaped the course both past and present international intervention in Palestine and contents of Islamic Legal Tradition that have been overlooked, through archival research and present-day interviews. Ms. Miller including those of (cyclical) globalization(s), vernacular knowledge conducted field interviews with international aid workers in systems, cultural revolutions, crude periodizations and modernist the occupied Palestinian territories, and returned to Palestine re-configurations. The grant supported further archival research to conduct follow-up interviews to further her research. in the conducted in the United Kingdom and Egypt, as well as travel spring of 2013 she traveled to Geneva to research the Permanent to relevant meetings and conferences, and translation of several Mandates Commissions Archives to explore the interwar Arabic texts into English. The objective is to publish an article on discourses of intervention with regard to Palestine. The ultimate “An Interruptive History of Islamic Law”, produce a new module outcome of the grant is to support dissertation research and the for students of Islamic law at City University London, and to publication of a law review article. organize an expert conference on the contemporary issues in the historiographic research of Islamic Law in Doha or London.

33 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

In 2013 we awarded 6 IGLP / Visa International , Inc. Project Grants:

Visa Research Grants In 2013 with the generous support of our Leading Sponsor Visa International, Inc. the IGLP launched a new Grant Program designed to support research projects on liquidity in the global economy, financial services regulation in emerging markets, and financial inclusion. Grant recipients include graduate students, post- doctoral scholars and junior faculty.

The first set of awards was announced on May 1, 2013. Priority was given to proposals that aimed to generate written work suitable for submission for publication during the summer or autumn of 2013.

Ermal Frasheri (Albania) Jonathan Greenacre (Australia) Harvard Law School University of New South Wales

What Can Banks Do? The The Regulation of Provision of Non-Financial Mobile Money: Narrow Services for Small and Banking Licences for Medium-Sized Enterprises in Telecommunication Emerging Markets Companies? This project examines how banks provide This paper explores whether, and if so non-financial services as a component of how, telecommunication companies providing mobile money their development strategies in emerging markets and explores can be regulated through ‘narrow banking’ licenses. Such li- how the framework under which banks and bankers are operat- censes are common in ‘advanced’ financial systems as a means ing in this new capacity is related to socio-economic factors. Mr. of restricting banks’ activities to providing basic financial ser- Frasheri seeks to explore the legal regimes which enable banks vices, such as savings and loans, and prohibiting participation and specialized financial institutions to reach strata that have in the more speculative products that contributed to the global previously been unable to access mainstream banking services financial crisis, such as proprietary trading. This paper looks at and how these regimes can transfer tremendous power to the this topic through a comparative regulatory analysis of three bankers, effectively transforming them into the main power bro- countries that have applied aspects of narrow banking licenses kers of local communities. to telecommunication companies: Ghana, Kenya, and Tanzania.

34 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Rohan Grey (United States) Rafael Sakr (Brazil) Columbia Law School Columbia Law School

Mobile Payment Systems The Brazilian National in Developing Countries: Bank For Economic And Policy Implications and Social Development: Potential An Experimentalist Financial Institution For Mr. Grey’s project aims to address, in Development Finance small part, the dearth of scholarship Policies on the implications of Chartalist principles for developing nations seeking to generate sustainable payment and banking Since the 2008 financial crisis, there has been a reemergence of services. Mr. Grey examines the viability of using public development banks as powerful financial institutions shaping telecommunications infrastructure to introduce and manage a the global economy. Mr. Sakr’s research project seeks to national currency and modern payment system in developing demonstrate how the Brazilian National Bank for Economic and countries where robust fiscal authorities do not exist. Using a Social Development (BNDES) is a good laboratory to examine single developing country as a case study, this project reviews development finance, which continuously reimagines its legal the various political, legal and technological issues presented arrangements in order to realize its developmental mandate. by such a system, as well as the broader implications for Through his research, Mr. Sakr explores how development current debates on financial inclusion, economic development, banking expertise frames legal institutions and creates a domain technology and free speech. to propose alternative paths for development finance.

Shanthi E. Senthe (Canada) Aditi Singh (India) Duke University Harvard Law School

Decoding the Political Economy of Commercialization Microfinance in Asia of Microfinance and Latin America: Institutions: Regulating Alternative Institutional Financial Inclusion Strategies for their Impact Ms. Senthe conducted fieldwork in Sri Lanka to examine the un- Various studies in the past used derlying regulatory and policy interventions within the finan- isolated contexts to examine the differential evolution and the cial inclusion paradigm. The project looks to understand the resulting impact of microfinance in societies. Ms. Singh’s re- relationship between financial inclusion initiatives and the fiscal search proposes to bring these contexts together and explore conduits through an examination of legal mechanisms. Field re- their interaction and interdependence by way of a three-pronged search was conducted as part of her dissertation, and will further analysis: examining the contribution of dominant political and serve as a basis for a paper contribution for the IGLP. The paper economic paradigms in the adoption of alternative institutional, envisages a discussion on the linkages between the practices regulatory and ideological strategies for microfinance; explore and behaviors of state and non-state actors with respect to the the economic, political and ethical implications of adopting dif- governance of microfinance deployment in a global pluralistic ferent institutional strategies; build on the lessons from a cumu- setting involving layers of complex arrangements. lative understanding of the contexts and understand how the regulatory and institutional landscape of microfinance needs to be cognizant of various political, economic and cultural contexts for the poor.

35 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Fellowship Program The goal of IGLP’s Fellowship Program is to encourage the development of progressive and alternative ideas about international law, society and political economy by supporting original, provocative and challenging intellectual work that might not otherwise find support from mainstream institutional resources and which contributes to the emergence of new approaches to international law and global social justice. Scholars appointed as Institute Fellows would also assist in the management and direction of the academic programs of the Institute.

2012-2013 Institute Fellows: search Council of Canada. She holds a B.A. to early 20th century Taiwan. It examined from the University of British Columbia, a various family law discourse of legal think- Zinaida Miller is a doctoral (Ph.D) candidate J.D. from the University of Toronto, Faculty of ers ranging from European legal advisors in International Relations at The Fletcher Law, and an LL.M. (waived) from Harvard Law seeking to draft the Japanese codes, to School, Tufts University. Her dissertation ana- School. After law school, Lisa articled with German-trained Japanese jurists opposing lyzes international intervention and the con- the Department of Justice in Ottawa and French-inspired codes, to anti-colonial Tai- struction of the ‘international community’ by also clerked for Justice Marshall Rothstein of wanese activist journalists resisting legal examining the framing and institutional de- the Supreme Court of Canada. assimilation, all of whom worked within dif- sign of, as well as resistance to, internation- ferent legal regimes to formulate their own al activity from the League of Nations until Heidi Matthews is a doctoral (S.J.D.) candi- visions of family law. She argues that the dis- the contemporary era. Her research interests date at Harvard Law School where her re- tinctiveness of family law and universality of include critical examinations of transitional search focuses on the intersection of crimi- market law were interdependently related. justice, international intervention, human nal law, the law of war, and human rights Family law was designed to safeguard na- rights, and the politics of humanitarian aid. law. Her dissertation undertakes a political tional culture, be it neo-traditionalist or pro- Her publications include Effects of Invisibili- theory of modern international criminal law, gressive. In contrast, market law was formu- ty: In Search of the ‘Economic’ in Transitional with a view to understanding how the crim- lated to promote commerce and trade on an Justice (International Journal of Transitional inalization of political violence depoliticizes international scale. One of her next projects Justice, 2008). She holds a B.A. from Brown the subjects of international law. Heidi is a will focus on the modernization of Chinese University, a Masters in Law and Diplomacy Fellow at the Film Study Center at Harvard family law and its relation to Chinese nation- from The Fletcher School, and a J.D. from University and a Byse Fellow at Harvard Law alism starting from the late 19th century. It Harvard Law School. School. will explore the series of debates revolving around the neo-Confucian family ideology, Lisa Kelly is a doctoral (S.J.D.) candidate at Yun-Ru Chen’s academic research focuses considered the essential core of Chinese cul- Harvard Law School where her research fo- on the intersection of law, family, and East ture, and its relationship with family law. She cuses on family law, education law, and law Asia studies in a global setting. Her disser- also has launched another research project and sexuality. Her doctoral dissertation tation, The Emergence of Family Law in Co- on how 19th and 20th century Bostonian analyzes the legal regulation of the child at lonial Taiwan: A Genealogical Perspective, family corporations participated in the ex- school and the law and politics of universal analyzes the genealogy of the dichotomous pansion of Euro-American law to Asia along schooling. Lisa is a Trudeau Scholar, a Frank construction of family law and market law with the growth of a global market for tea, Knox Memorial Fellow, and a Doctoral Fellow starting from early 19th century Germany, silk, and opium, and on their encounters of the Social Sciences and Humanities Re- to late 19th century Japan, and all the way with the Chinese legal system.

Travel Grants The IGLP provides modest* research and travel support to scholars conducting research in areas closely related to the IGLP’s ongoing work. Applications are open to current Harvard Law School students and alumni of IGLP: The Workshop.

Marisa Taney (United States) Harvard Law School Saptarishi Bandopadhyay (India) Ms. Taney received a grant to travel to Argentina to study immigration and Harvard Law School asylum as a part of a continuing clinical project with the Harvard Immigration Mr. Bandopadhyay Received a travel grant to present a research paper at and Refugee Clinic (HIRC). the “18th Annual Interdisciplinary Graduate Conference” at the University of British Columbia”. Damjan Kukovec (Slovenia) Harvard Law School Ching-Fu Lin (Taiwan) Mr. Kukovec received a grant to travel to the London School of Economics to Harvard Law School attend the conference “Europe’s Justice Deficit? Beyond Good Governance” Mr. Lin received a travel grant to present his paper “Global Food Safety and to present his paper “Justice in the EU Constitutional and Free Movement Governance: Regime Competition between Public and Private Regulatory Discourse and the European Periphery”. Sites” at the “9th Viterbo Global Administrative Law Seminar” in Rome, Italy.

Arnulf Becker (Chile) Jorge Gonzalez- Jacome (Columbia) Brown University Harvard Law School Mr. Becker received a travel grant to attend the conference “Religion, Empire Mr. Gonzalez-Jacome received a travel grant to present his paper “The and International Law in Zaragoza”. Struggle Against Constitutional Exceptions: Human Rights in Argentina, Chile, and Columbia During the 1980s” at the “2013 International Graduate Legal Research Conference at King’s College” in London.

*Travel grants are not available to students who have received other funding from Harvard Law School for the same trip. Generally, Institute support does not exceed $500 toward the cost of travel for conferences in the United States and $1,000 for conferences outside the United States. 36 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

37 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Participants from IGLP:The Workshop Doha, 2013

38 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Event Participants IGLP: The Workshop Jorge Esquirol (United States) Pier Giuseppe Monateri (Italy) Doha, Qatar, Florida International University College of University of Turin, Faculty of Law January 4-14, 2013 Law Vasuki Nesiah (United States) FACULTY Khaled Fahmy (Egypt) New York University School of Law The American University in Cairo Philip Allott (United Kingdom) Scott Newton (United States) University of Cambridge Günter Frankenberg (Germany) SOAS, University of London Goethe-University Dan Brinks (United States) Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) University of Texas School of Law Gerald Frug (United States) University of Melbourne Harvard Law School Matt Craven (United Kingdom) Kerry Rittich (Canada) SOAS, University of London Bassam Haddad (United States) University Of Toronto Faculty of Law George Mason University Dan Danielsen (United States) Hani Sayed (Syria) Northeastern University School of Law Sheila Jasanoff (United States) The American University in Cairo Harvard Kennedy School of Government Dennis Davis (South Africa) Amr Shalakany (Egypt) High Court of Cape Town Baber Johanssen (United States) The American University in Cairo Harvard Divinity School Moatasem El-Gheriani (Egypt) Leo Specht (Austria) Alexandria University School of Law David Kennedy (United States) Specht Böhm, Vienna Harvard Law School Karen Engle (United States) Katherine Stone (United States) University of Texas School of Law Andrew Lang (United Kingdom) University of California at Los Angeles London School of Economics and Political School of Law Science Noura Erakat (United States) Temple University, Beasley School of Law Chantal Thomas (United States) David Mednicoff (United States) Cornell Law School University of Massachusetts, Amherst (Cont.)

39 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

David Trubek (United States) Vanja Hamzic (Bosnia and Herzegovina) Teresa Almeida Cravo (Portugal) University of Wisconsin-Madison Law School City University London University of Coimbra, Faculty of Economics

Robert Wai (Canada) Lisa Kelly (Canada) Ahmad Alshorbagy (Egypt) Osgoode Hall Law School Harvard Law School Alexandria University School of Law

Horatia Muir‐Watt (France) Damjan Kukovec (Slovenia) John Ansah (Ghana) Sciences Po Law School Harvard Law School University of Cape Coast

Mikhail Xifaras (France) Lucas Lixinski (Brazil) Anna Aseeva (Russia) Sciences Po Law School University of New South Wales Sciences Po Law School

DOCENTS Boris Mamlyuk (United States) Matej Avbelj (Slovenia) University of Memphis Law School Graduate School of Government and Tor Krever (Australia) European Studies London School of Economics and Political Heidi Matthews (Canada) Science Harvard Law School Kingsly Awang (Cameroon) University OF Bamenda Vidya Kumar (Canada) Derek McKee (Canada) University of Birmingham Universite de Sherbrooke Oluwakemi Ayanleye (Nigeria) Olabisi Onabanjo University Charlotte Peevers (United Kingdom) Zinaida Miller (United States) Law Faculty, University of Technology The Fletcher School, Tufts University Muhammed Azeem (Canada) Sydney Osgoode Hall Law School Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Nikolas Rajkovic (Canada) The American University in Cairo Jose-Manuel Barreto (United Kingdom) European University Institute-Robert Goldsmiths, University of London Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies Gustavo Ribeiro (Brazil) Harvard Law School Marija Bartl (Croatia) Mario Schapiro (Brazil) University of Amsterdam Fundação Getulio Vargas Law School Brishen Rogers (United States) Temple University Beasley College of Law Qingxiu Bu (People’s Republic of China) Diogo Coutinho (Brazil) Queen’s University University of Sao Paulo PARTICIPANTS Lina Buchely (Colombia) Michael Fakhri (Canada) Mohamed Salem Abou El Farag (Egypt) Universidad de los Andes University of Oregon School of Law Qatar University Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) Luwam Dirar (Eritrea) Noha Aboueldahab (Egypt) University of St Andrews Cornell Law School University College London Giacomo Capuzzo (Italy) Christine Schwöbel (Germany) Yonas Adinew (Ethiopia) University of Perugia University of Liverpool Addis Ababa University Pola Cebulak (Poland) Outi Korhonen (Finland) Nadia Ahmad (United States) Universite Libre de Bruxelles University of Turku Sustainable Development Strategies Group Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh) Dawood Ahmed (Pakistan) Melbourne Law School Department of Law & Justice, Jahangirnagar University of Chicago University Meredith Coffey (United States) Suzanne Akila (Australia) University of Texas School of Law Ermal Frasheri (Albania) Australian National University Harvard Law School Veronica Corcodel (Romania and Moldova) Mohammed Al-Khulaifi (Qatar) Sciences Po Law School Aziza Ahmed (United States) Qatar University College of Law Northeastern University School of Law Johanna Cortes (Colombia) Feroz Ali (India) Universidad del Rosario Karolina Zurek (Poland) Duke University School of Law Swedish Institute for European Studies (Cont.) Shannon Allen (United States) Luis Eslava Arcila (Australia) Alternate Defense Counsel Melbourne Law School

40 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Douglas Coulson (United States) Zoran Oklopcic (Croatia) Maria Varaki (Greece) University of Texas School of Law Carleton University Department of Law and Hebrew University, Faculty of Law Legal Studies Joshua Curtis (Australia) Ana Maria Vargas Falla (Colombia) Irish Centre for Human Rights Eyene Okpanachi (Nigeria) University of Milan University of Alberta Deval Desai (United Kingdom) Fabia Veçoso (Brazil) Harvard Law School Volha Parfenchyk (Belarus) Faculdade de Direito do Sul de Minas University of Bologna Bonolo Dinokopila (Botswana) Dina Waked (Egypt) University of Botswana, Department of Law Elena Paris (Romania) Sciences Po Law School University of Bucharest Law School Laura Elder (United States) Nurfadzilah Yahaya (Singapore) Saint Mary’s College Carlos Portugal Gouvea (Brazil) Washington University University of Sao Paulo Karen Ellis (United States) Mingzhe Zhu (People’s Republic of China) American Bar Foundation Jothie Rajah (Singapore) Sciences Po Law School American Bar Foundation, Chicago Hanna Haile (Eritrea) (Cont.) Cornell Law School Jean-Paul Rocha (Brazil) University of São Paulo Law School Mohammad Hamdy (Egypt) Harvard Law School Shunko Rojas (Argentina) Harvard Law School Joel Hanisek (United States) Trinity College Assel Rustemova (Kazakhstan) Gediz University Daniela Hrzan (Germany) Humboldt-University Berlin Lena Salaymeh (United States) University of California at Berkeley School Ben Hurlbut (United States) of Law Arizona State University Nahed Samour (Germany) Muhammad Kamaldeen Imam-Tamim Humboldt University Faculty of Law (Nigeria) University of Ilorin Islam Shiha (Egypt) Alexandria University School of Law Dilini Imiyage (Sri Lanka) University of Colombo Muhammad Osama Siddique (Pakistan) Lahore University of Management Sciences Onur Ince (Turkey) Cornell University Ermin Sinanovic (Bosnia and Herzegovina) United States Naval Academy Suha Jubran-Ballan (Israel) Tel Aviv University Adrian Smith (Canada) Carleton University, Department of Law & Joseph Kikonyogo (Uganda) Legal Studies University of Melbourne Ukri Soirila (Finland) Emmanuelle Lê (France) University of Helsinki Sciences Po Law School Anna Su (Philippines) Roni Liberson Yokhin (Israel) Harvard Law School Tel Aviv University Peter Szigeti (Hungary) Roger Merino Acuna (Peru) Harvard Law School University of Bath Wijdan Tariq (Pakistan) Rebecca Monson (Australia) University of Durham Australian National University College of Law Rene Urena (Colombia) Universidad de Los Andes

41 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

The Conference Supreme Court in Brasil: Does Formalism Banks: Ideology, Power and Institutional Harvard Law School, Favor Democracy? Design June 2-3, 2013 Daniel Vargas (United States) Yueh-Ping Yang (People’s Republic of China) Panels: Harvard Law School Harvard Law School The Legitimacy of Social Movements: Creative Society in the Making - Social Economic Development, Financial Stability, Views from Brazil Creativity and New Forms of Civism and Profit Maximization: Developmental States’ Moderator: Trilemma in Corporate Governance of Banks Lillian Aponte-Miranda (United States) Theorizing Development Banks Florida Internationl University Moderator: Theories of Property Aminu Gamawa (Nigeria) Moderator: Panelists: Harvard Law School Erum Sattar (Pakistan) Maria Aguena (Brazil) Harvard Law School Tribunal de Justiça do Distrito Federal e dos Panelists: Territórios (TJDFT) Muhammad Azeem (Canada and Pakistan) Panelists: Constitutional Right to Privacy and Biometric Osgoode Hall Law School Xiaoqian Hu (People’s Republic of China) Voter Registration (BVR) Reconstructing which Political Economy? Harvard Law School What Property? A Critique of “Clear and Strong Maria Paula Bertran Muñoz (Brazil) Arpita Gupta (India) Property Rights” in the Chinese Context University of São Paulo University of Wisconsin-Madison Loan for Consumption In Brazil: How the ‘Law and Development’ Revisited through Ali Malik (United States) Superior Court PrecedentMay Change the Risk Perspective York University Debate As Natural As the Air We Breathe: Intellectual Rafael Sakr (Brazil) Property and the Naturalization of Structural Maria Cristina Cardoso Pereira (Brazil) Harvard Law School Violence A Critical Legal Theory of Development Universidade Federal de Goiás (Cont.)

42 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Shitong Qiao (People’s Republic of China) La Trobe University Jennifer Langlais (Canada) Yale Law School Law and Development after the Financial Harvard Law School Land Sales and Commitment: Chinese Crisis: Toward a Post-Washington Consensus The Origins of Multicultural Governance in Property Law Reform and Beyond Canada Vlad Perju (United States) Namita Wahi (India) Boston University School of Law Panthip Pruksacholavit (Thailand) Harvard Law School Washington University in St Louis The Tension Between Property Rights and Kim Lane Scheppele (United States) Intersectional Discrimination in Employment Socioeconomic Rights Princeton University All is not Quiet on the Eastern Front Before and After Method: Histories and Chen Zhao (People’s Republic of China) Sociologies of International Law Washington University in St. Louis Sex and the Family in Transnational Law Moderator: Public Use in the US and China Moderator: Gustavo Ribeiro (Brazil) Claire Houston (Canada) Harvard Law School Humanity, Justice and the “Common Harvard Law School Good” Panelists: Moderator: Panelists: John Haskell (United States) Akande Opeyemi (Nigeria) Alberto Abad Suarez Avila (Mexico) Mississippi College School of Law; Durham Harvard Law School UNAM Institute for Legal Research University School of Law International Human Rights Law Influences An Anti-Biography of Francis-Lieber: Towards Panelists: in the Judicial Adjudication of Women’s A Structuralist Jurisprudence in the History of Katherine Fallah (Australia/Lebanon) Reproductive Rights in Latin America International Law Sydney Law School Corporate Construction of ‘Humanitarianism’: Edit Frenyo (Hungary) Umut Özsu (Canada/Turkey) The Regulatory Impact of Self- Georgetown University Law Center University of Manitoba Characterization of the Private Military Transnational Families and Childhoods Provincializing Jus Cogens? An Analysis of an Industry at Intersections of GlobalMigration and International Legal Field Development Sinja Graf (Germany) Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) Cornell University Ivana Isailovic (France/Serbia) University of Glasgow Universal Crime & Cosmopolitanism Sciences Po Law School and New York The British Tradition of International Law University School of Law Before and After Method: Histories Ernesto Mieles González (Columbia) Recognition, Private International Law Free University Berlin and Identity( ies): Same Sex Unions and Weighing the Effects of International Transitional Justice: Counter-Hegemonic Tool Transnational Family Law Criminal Law or an Instrument of Global Governmentality? Moderator: Ukri Soirila (Finland) Heidi Matthews (Canada) Law and Development after the Financial University of Helsinki Harvard Law School Crisis: Beyond the Washington Consensus Smothered to Death: Silence and the ECtHR Moderator: Panelists: Ermal Frasheri (Albania) Governing Difference Kerstin Carlson (United States/Ireland) Harvard Law School Moderator: American University of Paris Jorge Gonzalez (Columbia) Rarely a Plea, Never a Bargain: Plea Bargains Panelists: Harvard Law School Before the ICTY and Reconciliation in the Bojan Bugaric (Slovenia) Former Yugoslavia University of Ljubljana Panelists: Rule of Law in Context: Between Chinese Netta Barak-Corren (Israel) Peter Galbraith (United States) Pragmatism in East European Big Bang Harvard Law School Former US Ambassador to Croatia Approach Compliance with the Law Under Religion- based Normative Conflicts: A Behavioral Peter Robinson (United States) Martin Krygier (Australia) Analysis International Criminal Tribunal for the former University of New South Wales Yugoslavia Rule of Law Promotion: Between Parochial Kristen Barnes (United States) Do International Criminal Courts Deter Universalism and Contextual Universalism University of Akron School of Law Atrocities? Substituting Race: A Comparative Analysis Alenka Kuhelj (Slovenia) of French and U.S. Strategies for Attaining Jamie Rowen (United States) University of Ljubljana Equality in Education American Bar Foundation Conflict between Declared Roma Minority “Truth” in Bosnia: Challenges and Rights and European Practice: Why the Legal Nkatha Kabira (Kenya) Opportunities of a Regaional Truth Framework Doesn’t Work in Reality? Harvard Law School Commission Commissions as Governance: The Case of Randall Peerenboom (United States) Akiwumi Commission (Cont.)

43 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Don Webster (United States) Alvaro Santos (Mexico) Rene Uruena (Columbia) Attorney Georgetown University Law Center Universidad de los Andes Learning from Karemera et al. Drug Trafficking and its Discontents Panelists: International Law and its Discontents Andrew Strauss (United States) Peter Dirou (Australia) Moderator: Widener University School of Law University of Melbourne Barbara Stark (United States) Global Economic Governance: Why Applying Heterodox Economics to Questions Maurice A. Deane School of Law Democracy Matters of Global Policy

Panelists: Jeanne Woods (United States) Onur Ince (Turkey) Fran Ansley (United States) Loyola University New Orleans Cornell University University of Tennessee Nomos of Capital Sweet Kisses to Bitter Pill: Exchange Students The Law of Killing Expose Toxic Ingredients at Hershey’s Moderator: Maja Savevska (Macedonia) Chocolate Vivek Kanwar (United States) University of Warwick and Universite Libre de Jindal Global Law School Bruxelles Dan Danielsen (United States) Corporate Social Responsibility: A Promising Social Northeastern University School of Law Panelists: Innovation or Neoliberal Strategy in Disguise? Private Ordering and Instrumental States: Arnulf Becker (Chile) Reassessing the Role of States and Watson Institute, Brown University Law and Money: An Alternative Approach Regulation in Global Crisis The Law of Killing: A Semi-Peripheral to Law and Economics Orientation Moderator: Dianne Otto (Australia) Christine Desan (United States) Melbourne Law School Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) Harvard Law School Decoding Crisis in International Law: A queer University of Saint Andrews feminist perspective Exceptional Emergencies? The Construction Panelists: of Legal Discourses on Targeted Killings in Matthew Forstater (United States) Ileana Porras (United States) the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict University of Missouri University of Miami School of Law Taxation: A ‘Secret’ of Colonial Capitalist (so- Justin Desautels-Stein (United States) called) Primitive Accumulation Jennifer Rosenbaum (United States) University of Colorado Law School New Orleans Workers’ Center for Racial Justice International Law’s Wheelhouse Fadhel Kaboub (Tunisia) Sweet Kisses to Bitter Pill: Exchange Students Denison University Expose Toxic Ingredients at Hershey’s Chocolate Heterodox and Critical Political Economy Policy Implications of Money as a Creature of Moderator: the State (Cont.)

44 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Mark Peacock (Canada) Rachel Rebouche (United States) The Law and Politics of Regional York University University of Florida Levin College of Law Integration Wergeld and the Origins of Money Moderator: Transitional Punishments: Anti-Impunity Nkatha Kabira (Kenya) Governance Feminism: Sex, Reproduction and Transitional Justice Harvard Law School and the Family Moderator: Moderator: Karen Engle (United States) Panelists: Amy Cohen (United States) University of Texas School of Law John Ansah (Ghana) Ohio State University College of Law University of Cape Coast Panelists: The Politics of Regional Integration in Africa Panelists: Diane Bernard (Belgium) Aziza Ahmed (United States) FNRS Belgium Luwam Dirar (Eritrea) Northeastern University School of Law Passages of Violence Harvard Law School “Rugged Vaginas” and “Vulnerable Rectums”: Rethinking Epistemological Pluralism and Epidemiology, Human Rights, and the Co- Zinaida Miller (United States) Conceptual Understanding of Regional Production of Identity in the Global HIV The Fletcher School, Tuf ts University; Harvard Integration in Southern Africa Epidemic Law School (Re-)Distributing Transition: Costs and Mark Toufayan (Canada) Cyra Choudhury (United States) Consequences of Criminalization University of Ottawa Florida International University African Regional Trade Agreements and The Political Economy of Transnational Vasuki Nesiah (United States) the Developmental Alliance with the Surrogacy and Its Legal Regulation New York University Heterogeneous in Law and Development Transitional Justice, Civil Society and the Debates Claire Houston (Canada) Civilizing Mission Harvard Law School Pieter Van Cleynenbreugel (Belgium) Conceiving the Child in Domestic Violence Fabia Veçoso (Brazil) University of Leuven Faculdade de Direito do Sul de Minas The Imperial Political Economy of Supra- Lisa Kelly (Canada) Between Human Rights Absolutism Neoliberal European Union Governance in Harvard Law School and Contextual History: Aspects of the the Wake of Global Crisis Narrating Innocent Suffering in Abortion Law Experience of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (Cont.)

45 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

The Trials of International Criminal Law International and Comparative Legal The Global and Local in Regulatory Moderator: Theory and History Regimes Delphine Dogot (Belgium) Moderator Moderator: Sciences Po Law School Lucia Belluci (Italy) Ralph Gill (Canada) University of Milan Harvard Law School Panelists: Mohamed Badar (Egypt) Panelists: Panelists: Brunel University Antoine Duval (France) Erica Gorbak (Argentina) The International Criminal Court and the European University Institute University of Buenos Aires Challenge of Legal Pluralism: The Islamic Lex Sportiva: A Playground for Transnational The Role of Administrative Law in the Pressing Need Law of Rebellion and the Armed Conflict in Legal Theory for Reconstructing Domestic and International Nigeria Order Vis á Vis Global Financial Regulation Siavash Eshghi (Iran) Tamás Hoffmann (Hungary) SOAS, University of London Yugank Goyal (India) Corvinus University Logos v. Nomos: A Critical Reflection on the University of Hamburg The Role of National Courts in the Pronouncements of Law in Cyberspace Regulatory Institutions of the Global South: ‘Hybridization’ of International Law Why are They Different and What Can Be Daniel Ghezelbash (Australia/Iran) Done About It? Damien Scalia (France) University of Sydney Geneva University Identifying Contemporary Legal Transplants Imam Mulyana (Indonesia) International Criminal Law: Perception Of Law Faculty Universitas Padjadjaran The Accused Gustavo Ribeiro (Brazil) The International Law Contribution to the Harvard Law School Establishment of Oil and Gas Regulations in Maria Varaki (Greece) Shapiro’s Legality: Is Law a Social Plan? Indonesia Hebrew University Prosecutorial Dilemmas Between Legality Hengameh Saberi (Iran) Ying Xia (People’s Republic of China) And Legitimacy Osgoode Hall Law School Harvard Law School Formalism Recaptured? A Review of New Regulating Chinese Multinational The Global and Local in Investment and Calls for Formalism in International Law Corporations in Africa Arbitration Moderator: Promises and Perils of Constitutionalism The Corporation in Global Society Namita Wahi (India) Moderator: Moderator: Harvard Law School Kimberly Strovink (United States) Dan Danielsen (United States) Northeastern Univeristy School of Law Northeastern University School of Law Panelists: Kun Fan (People’s Republic of China) Panelists: Panelists: Harvard Yenching Institute Mohamed Abdelaal (Egypt) Grietje Baars (Netherlands) Globalization of Law and Diffusion of Alexandria University School of Law City University London Cultures — Glocalization of Arbitration From Egypt’s Constitution: What Went Wrong? Capital, Corporate Personhood and an East Asian Perspective Legitimacy: The Ideological Force of Ramzan Alnoaimi (Bahrain) ‘Corporate Crime’ in International Law Sotonye Frank (People’s Republic of China) Georgetown University Law Center University of Nottingham The (Lowercase) Vs. (Uppercase) Delusions: Tomaso Ferrando (Italy) Stabilization Clauses: Perceptions versus The Constitutionalism Discourse in the Sciences Po Law School Realties Arabian Gulf Monarchies. Private Legal Transplant: When Multinational Enterprises are Proxies of Legal Rumana Islam (Bangladesh) M. Mohsin Bhat (India) Dissemination University of Warwick Yale Law School Re-conceptualizing the Fair and Equitable Politics and ‘Cultures of Legality’: Muslim Social Boris Mamlyuk (United States) Treatment (FET) Standard in Investment Movements and Constitutionalism in India University of Memphis Treaties Political Economy of a 21st Century Jorge Gonzalez (Columbia) Corporate Mass Merger: Walmart-Massmart Bradley Murg (United States) Harvard Law School and the Future of Global Governance University of Washington States of Exception and the Constitutionalization Foreign Direct Investment and Legal Reform of Human Rights in South America: Argentina, Karolina Zurek (Poland) in Transition Economies: Rethinking Causality Chile and Colombia in the 1980s Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies Political Economy of a 21st Century Nicolás Perrone (Argentina) Thomaz H.J.A. Pereira (Brazil) Corporate Mass Merger: Walmart-Massmart London School of Economics and Political Science Yale Law School and the Future of Global Governance The International Investment Regime as a Private Narratives of Constitutional Entrenchment: Property System: Another View of a Popular Story Eternity Clauses and their Comparative Practices (Cont.)

46 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Law and New Development Strategies: Maria Rosaria Marella (Italy) Panelists: Brazil and Beyond University of Perugia Leopold Specht (Vienna) Moderator: Emerging Commons as a Challenge to the Specht Böhm, Vienna David Trubek (United States) Naturalization of Private Property University of Wisconsin Law School Critical Approaches to Comparative Law Giovanni Marini (Italy) Moderator: Panelists: University of Perugia Gunter Frankenberg (Germany) Helena Alviar (Columbia) Some Thoughts on Balancing and Goethe University Frankfurt Universidad de Los Andes Comparative Law Constitutions as Commodities Diogo Coutinho (Brazil) University of Sao Paulo Guillermo Moro (Argentina) Panelists: Universidad Nacional del Litoral Cornelius Baaij (Netherlands) Mario Gomes Schapiro (Brazil) Not a(nother) Step Back.. The Progressive University of Amsterdam Fundação Getulio Vargas (FGV) Law School Realization of Socioeconomic Rights and the Defying Incommensurability in Cross- Alvaro Santos (Mexico) Politics of the Global Field Cultural Comparative Law Georgetown University Law Center Fernanda Nicola (Italy) PG Monateri (Italy) Strategies in Rights Analysis American University University of Turin Moderator: Is the Wind Changing Again? The Waning The Geopolitics of Law : State of Exception Aziza Ahmed (United States) Influence of US Legal Thought and the Crisis and the ‘Style’ of Legal Systems Northeastern University School of Law of US Legal Education Horatia Muir-Watt (France) Panelists: Indicators as Political Spaces: Prospects Sciences Po Law School Libby Adler (United States) and Limits The Relevance of Comparative Legal Northeastern University School of Law Moderator: Knowledge to the Understanding of the Queer Critique/Gay Rights Sergio Puig (Mexico) Global Stanford Law School Isabel Cristina Jaramillo Sierra (Columbia) State Regulation of the Family Universidad de los Andes Panelists: Moderator: Dark Sides of Distributional Analysis Gloria Marcela Abadía Cubillos (Columbia) Joanna Noronha (Brazil) Universidad de los Andes Harvard Law School Marcin Kilanowski (Poland) A Case Study of Sexual Violence in the Harnessing Gender to Law: A Mosaic Nicolas Copernicus University Colombian Armed Conflict Approach to Domestic Violence Law and Pragmatism and Human Rights: From Policy Universality to Responsibility Lina Fernanda Buchely Ibarra (Columbia) Universidad de los Andes Panelists: Moria Paz (Israel) The Feminist Accounting Project Within Sedoo Manu (Nigeria) Stanford Law School the Narrative of Community Mothers: Harvard Law School The Tower of Babel; Human Rights and the An Example of the Global South’s use of Nigerian Anti-Trafficking Law in the Context Paradox of Languages Indicators as a Counter-Hegemonic Global of Child Labor: Is Fantasy Replacing Reality? Dominance Technique Comparative Law and Contemporary Natalia Ramirez (Colombia) Legal Thought Lina Maria Cespedes Baez (Columbia) Harvard Law School Moderator: Temple University Mine, Not Mine. Agency and Strategies in Justin Desautels-Stein (United States) Far Beyond What Is Measured: Governance Adolescent Pregnancy. A Case Study in University of Colorado Law School feminism and indicators in Colombia Bogotá

Panelists: Jothi Saunthararajah (Singapore) Property and Propriety in the Postcolony: Jorge Esquirol (United States) American Bar Foundation Reflections from India Florida International Universit Rule of Law Indicators Moderator: Saptarishi Bandopadhy (India) Bianca Gardella (Italy) Rene Uruena (Columbia) Harvard Law School Università del Piemonte Orientale Universidad de Los Andes Comparative Law and Harmonization of Indicators and the Law: Exploring the Rule of Panelists: Private Law Law Index as a Space for Contestation Priya Gupta (India) Southwestern Law School Diego Lopez Medina (Columbia) Jurisprudence of Finance Postcolonial Property Rights and Rhetoric in Universidad de Los Andes Moderator: Delhi Constitutional Balancing at the Bolivian Clayton Simmons (United States) Plurinational Constitutional Court Harvard Law School (Cont.)

47 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Dipika Jain (India) Latin American Social Constitutionalism: A Good Thing or Bad? EU Citizenship and the Jindal Global Law School Between Courts and Participation Social Despite the State Social Gendering of Property Rights in India: Reframing of Desires Jorge Contesse (Chile) Damjan Kukovec (Slovenia) Yale Law School Harvard Law School Pooja Parmar (India) Prior Consultation of Indigenous Peoples Osgoode Hall Law School and Social Conflict: The Case of Chile Maria Panezi (Greece) Adivasi Land Claims and the Legalities of Osgoode Hall Law School ‘Paper-Owners’ in Kerala Esteban Hoyos (Colombia) The Legal Aspects of the Greek Financial Crisis Cornell Law School Oishik Sircar (India) Global Clinical Legal Teaching and the Right Philomila Tsoukala (Greece) The University of Melbourne to Free Education in Colombia Georgetown Univeristy Law Center The Anatomy of the Propertied Body: The Eurozone Crisis and the Future of Social Affective Spaces of Desire and Dissent in Domingo Lovera (Chile) Europe Neoliberal India Universidad Diego Portales Latin American Social Constitutionalism: Between the Law: Unmaking of Empire Latin American Twists on Social, Economic Between Courts and Participation through Legal Redress in China and Japan and Cultural Rights Struggles Moderator: Moderator: Social Europe Madeline Chaim (Australia) Helena Alviar (Colombia) Moderator: Melbourne Law School Universidad de Los Andes Daniela Caruso (United States) Boston University School of Law Panelists: Panelists: Krista Hegburg (United States) Amaya Alvez Marin (Chile) Panelists: U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum University of Concepción Afroditi Giovanopoulou (Greece) The Obligation to Receive: The Holocaust, An Anthropologist Responsible for Harvard Law School Reparations, and Romani Political Community the Fulfillment of Chile’s International The Many Lives of European Anti- Obligations Regarding Indigenous Rights: A Discrimination Law Yukiko Koga (Japan) Case Study of the Lafkenche Law Hunter College Dimitry Kochenov (Netherlands) City University of New York Natalia Angel Cabo (Colombia) University of Groningen, Universidad de los Andes (Cont.)

48 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Jaehyung Oh (South Korea) With History on their Side: Self Representa- Comparative Law and Contemporary Seoul National University Law School tion of International Lawyers and the Paradox- Legal Thought II Fragmentation and Individuation: The Case es of the History of International Law Moderator : of ‘Korean B & C Class War Criminals’ Duncan Kennedy (United States) Changing Forms of Property and Citizen- Harvard Law School Between the Scylla of Global Law and the ship Charybdis of Global History Moderator: Panelists: Moderator: Shun-Ling Chen (Taiwan) Kerry Rittich (Canada) Ignacio De La Rasilla Del Moral (Spain) Harvard Law School University of Toronto Brunel Law School Comparative International Law Between the Scylla Panelists: David Trubek (United States) of Global Law and the Charybdis of Global History Rajshree Chandra Ahuja (India) University of Wisconsin Center for the Study of Developing Societies Panelists: Biocultural Rights: Moving Beyond the Idea Bianca Gardella (Italy) Anne Clement (France) of “Benefits” Università del Piemonte Orientale North Carolina State University New Perspectives on the Legal History of the Anna Dolidze (Georgia) Diego Lopez Medina (Columbia) Middle East? Rediscovering Jacques Berque, The University of Western Ontario Universidad de los Andes the “field historian” “Mankind” and its Global Heritage: Explora- tion of the Global Seabed and the Changing Guillermo Moro (Argentina) Matthew Craven (United Kingdom) Conception of Ownership Universidad Nacional del Litoral SOAS, University of London Sreela Sarkar (India) Maria Rosaria Marella (Italy) Yolanda Gamarra (Spain) University of Massachusetts Amherst University of Perugia University of Zaragoza Dispossession and Citizenship in “Global Delhi” Economics and History, The Perfect Symbio- Giovanni Marini (Italy) sis for Global Law Peter Szigeti (Hungary) University of Perugia Harvard Law School Luigi Nuzzo (Italy) Boundaries and Distance in Property and Citizenship (Cont.) University of Salento

49 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Fernanda Nicola (Italy) Panelists: Passages of Violence American University Roger Merino Acuna (Peru) University of Bath Laura Griffin (Australia) Making the Muslim State La Trobe University Moderator: Saptarishi Bandopadhyay (India) Dreaming Of Law: Understanding Critical Cyra Choudhury (United States) Harvard Law School Calls For A Non-Violent Development Florida International University Another History of Knowledge and Decision in Precautionary Approaches to James Benjamin Hurlbut (United States) Panelists: Sustainability Arizona State University Nadia Ahmad (United States) Just knowledge? Conditions of Visibility and Sustainable Development Strategies Group Aurelien Bouayad (France) “Slow Violence” Sustainability as a Waqf: Biofuels in the Sciences Po Law School Middle East For a Legal Sociology of Ecological Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Controversies University of Melbourne and SOAS, Oluwakemi Ayanleye (Nigeria) University of London Olabisi Onabanjo University Sergio Latorre (Colombia) Laws of Encounter The Emerging Islamic Finance in Nigeria: Oñati International Institute for the Sociology of Law Issues and Challenges Creating Nature: Analysis of the Dark Sides of International Law Technologies of Property to Respond to Moderator : Laura Elder (United States) Environmental Concerns Genevieve Painter (United States) Saint Mary’s College Berkeley Law, University of California Moral Derivatives? Deriving ‘Facts’ from Usha Natarajan (Australia) Fiction in the Global Economy The Amercian University in Cairo Panelists: Valentina Azarov (Russia/Ireland) Karen Rhone (United States) Societal Reconstruction After Conflict Al-Quds Bard College University of Chicago Moderator: Operationalising Territoriality and Reliance: Towards a Genealogy of Moral Economy Jenna Pollock (United States) Belligerent Occupation, Self-Determination Harvard Law School of Peoples and the Duty of Non-Recognition Ermin Sinanovic (Bosnia/Herzegovina) United States Naval Academy Panelists: Yifeng Chen (People’s Republic of China) Political Islam and the Arab Uprisings Noha Aboueldahab (Egypt/United Kingdom) Helsinki University University College London Against Communism and Imperialism: Space, Stories, and Self-Reflection: The ‘Blind Spot’ of Transitional Justice: An China’s Early Experiences with ILO 1919-1949 Reconfigurations of the Rule of Law in Inquiry into the Duality of Corruption vs. Development Human Rights Charges in the Prosecution of Golnoosh Hakimdavar (Iran/United States) Moderator: Political Leaders in Egypt and Tunisia Strayer University Deval Desai (United Kingdom) The Politics of Sanctions: Sanctions as an In- Harvard Law School Hamid Khan (United States) strument of Post-Colonial Control Masked as United States Institute of Peace Economic Development and Democracy. Panelists: Islam and Post-Conflict Justice Teresa de Almeida Cravo (Portugal) Giovanni Mantilla (Columbia) University of Coimbra Aurora Sanchez Palacio (Spain) University of Minnesota Rule of Law Reform in the Periphery: A Harvard Law School Coerced Empires Strike Back: The Political Critique of Legal International Intervention Challenges in the Nepalese Constitutional Origins of the International Rules for Internal in Post-Conflict Contexts Process: Federalism, Ethnicity and Conflicts and Wars of National Liberation Representation Rebecca Monson (Australia) Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh) Australian National University Heather Teague (United States) Jahanginagar University (Em)placing Law: Boundaries and Belonging University of Texas School of Law Historicizing ‘Law’ as a Language of Civiliza- in the 2011 Draft Constitution of Solomon Q’eqchi’ Being and Being a Víctima Q’eqchi’: tion and Identity Construction: Penal Law Islands Identification, Recognition, and Personhood Reforms in Colonial India in Guatemalan Reparations Politics Ana Maria Vargas (Columbia) Global Law in Context Lund University International Law and the ‘Slow Violence’ Moderator : Vending for Empowerment: The Impact of of Development Matthew Craven (United Kingdom) Rule of Law Discourses at the Local Level Moderator: SOAS, University of London Ruth Buchanan (Canada) Locating Nature: Making and Unmaking Osgoode Hall Law School Panelists: International Law Luis Eslava (Australia/Colombia) Moderator: Panelists: Melbourne Law School Julia Cadaval Martins (Brazil) Jennifer Leigh Beard (Australia) Harvard Law School University of Melbourne (Cont.)

50 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Vanja Hamzic (Bosnia/Herzegovina) Rene Uruena (Colombia) Thomas Skouteris (Netherlands) City University London Universidad de Los Andes The American University in Cairo Locating Global Law in Current Literature Time, Space and International Criminal Law and Practice Panelists: Fernando Aith(Brazil) Immi Tallgren (Finland) Vidya Kumar (Canada) University of São Paulo University of Helsinki University of Birmingham National Health Regulatory Agencies and Incantations of Humanity in International Global Law and Methodology Courts in Brazil: A Criminal Law (ICL): Of Mourning and Magic Tense but Necessary Relationship for Health Henrique Randau da Costa Carvalho (Brazil) Development Sujith Xavier (Canada) King’s College London University of Toronto Globalising Criminal Law: Model of a Core Florencia Lebensohn (Argentina) The Coloniality of International Justice? Chapter University of Buenos Aires Taking Stock of TWAIL Regulatory Role of Judicial Courts in Perspectives on International Criminal Law Critique After “War”: Mapping the New Argentina: The Matanza – War Discourse Riachuelo River Basin Case “The Next Left” Agenda: The Future of Moderator: Social Democracy in Europe John Haskell (United States) Carolina Moreno (Colombia) Moderator: Mississippi College School of Law Universidad de los Andes Alfred Gusenbauer (Australia) Redefining Public Administration: The Former Chancellor of Austria Panelists: Colombian Constitutional Alejandra Azuero Quijano (Colombia) Court Intervention in the Solid Waste Rethinking 20 Years of Feminist Law Harvard Law School Collection Service in Bogota and the Rights Reform on Sexual Violence: From the Crimes Against Humanity at the End of War of Recyclers International to the Local (1946-1989) Moderator: Maria Angelica Prada Uribe (Colombia) Janet Halley (United States) Delphine Dogot (Belgium/Argentina) Universidad de los Andes Harvard Law School Sciences Po Law School “Regulating in the Shadow of the Courts: Targeting the New, Killing the Old: Targeted Healthcare Regulation in Colombia and the Panelists: Killings and the “New War Discourse” Inter-American System of Human Rights” Karen Engle (United States) University of Texas School of Law Heidi Matthews (Canada) Santiago Rojas (Colombia) Post-Feminist International Governance of Harvard Law School Universidad de los Andes Sexual Violence in Conflict International Criminal Law and the New War Regulating in the Shadow of the Courts: Discourse Healthcare Regulation in Colombia and the Aya Gruber (United States) Inter-American System of Human Rights University of Colorado Law School The Corporation in Global Society II Experts v. Judges? Courts and Regulatory A Neofeminist Approach to Sexual Violence Moderator: Dennis Davis (South Africa) Critical Approaches to International Prabha Kotiswaran (India) High Court of Cape Town Criminal Law Kings College London Moderator: Governance, Feminism and Postcolonial Panelists: Alejandra Azuero (Colombia) Law: The Politics of Rape Law Reform in India Jose Manuel Barretto (Colombia/United Kingdom) Harvard Law School University of London Fionnuala Ni Aolain (United States) Transnational Law, Corporations and Panelists: University of Minnesota Law School Colonialism Paul Clark (United Kingdom) Where Feminists Have Rarely Strayed: Sex- Garden Court Chambers Based Harms and the Aaron Dhir (Canada) International Criminal Spaces Law of Occupation Osgoode Hall Law School Shareholder Engagement in the Embedded Tor Krever (Canada/Australia) Reconsidering Copyright and Intellectual Business Corporation: Investment Activism, London School of Economics and Political Science Property Law Human Rights and TWAIL Discourse Jottings on ICL: Towards a Critique of Moderator: International Criminal Law Siavash Eshghi (Iran) Mikko Rajavuori (Finland) SOAS, University of London University of Turku John Reynolds (Ireland) Corporate Human Rights Obligations: National University of Ireland Panelists: Lessons from State-owned Enterprises The Coloniality of International Justice? Shun-Ling Chen Taking Stock of TWAIL Harvard Law School Experts v. Judges? Courts and Regulatory Perspectives on International Criminal Law Exposing Professionalism in Copyright Law Governance in Latin America Moderator: (Cont.)

51 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Hayssam Hammad (Egypt) Y-Vonne Hutchinson (United States) Human Rights, and Peoples-Based University of Exeter La Isla Foundation Development Role of Originality Criteria in Reviving Corporate Liability, State Responsibility, And Copyright Law Labor Rights In Thecontext Of Globalization: Elisabeth Costa (Australia) Developing A Framework For Protection Harvard Law School P. Sean Morris (Jamaica) Of Sugarcane Workers In Nicaragua Incentive-Based, City Level Climate Action: University of Helsinki An Alternative Path To Global Emissions Beyond Trade: Global Digital Exhaustion in Daniela Jaros (Australia) Reductions? International Economic Regulation European University Institute The State as Regulator of and Borrower from John Hursh (United States) Ana Santos (United States) the Market: Insights into a Double Role McGill University Duke Law School Access to Water, Access to Land: Removing Strategies to Develop Creative Industries Jaakko Salminen (Finland) Legal and Social Barriers to Natural in the Global South: Rethinking the Role of University of Turku Resources in Morocco Intellectual Property Law and Policy Connected Contracts as a Global Trend: Implications for Policy Erum Sattar (United States) Gabriela Zanfir (Romania) and Practice Harvard Law School University of Craiova Pakistan’s Indus Challenge: Creating the What Happens In The Cloud Stays In The Shanthi Senthe (Canada) Institutional Architecture of Development Cloud, Or Why The Cloud’s Architecture Osgoode Hall Law School Should Be Transformed In ‘Virtual Territorial Micro-deposit Insurance Schemes: Challenging Master Narratives of the International Scope’ the Regulatory Sphere? Legal Order Moderator: Constituting Markets Distributing Development Akbar Rasulov (Uzbekistan) Moderator: Moderator: University of Glasgow Luwam Dirar (Eritrea) Daniel Vargas (United States) Harvard Law School Harvard Law School Panelists: Outi Korhonen (Finland) Panelists: Panelists: University of Turku Constituting Control Amy Cohen (United States) Lillian Aponte Miranda (United States) Ohio State University College of Law Florida International University College of Lucas Lixinski (Brazil) The Laws and Politics of Markets: A Case Law University of New South Wales Study of Food in India The Role of International Law in Intrastate Narrating Heritage Law’s Place in an Natural Resource Allocation: Sovereignty, International Legal Order

52 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Nikolas Rajkovic (Canada) Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Recipies University of Kent Law School Melbourne Law School On Fragments and Geometry: The Of Dams and Damnation: Australian Sanjay Pinto (United States) International Legal Order as Metaphor and Engagement with International Legal Columbia University How it Matters Discourse Ownership and Control in Advanced Capitalism: Current Limits and Future Possibilities Surabhi Ranganathan (India) Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) University of Cambridge The American University in Cairo Sabeel Rahman (United States) The Value Of Narratives: The India-Usa Bakhtin in Addis Ababa Harvard Law School Nuclear Deal In Terms Of Fragmentation, Financial Regulation, Reform Politics, and the Pluralism, Constitutionalization And Global Charlotte Peevers (United Kingdom) Legacy of Legal Realism Administrative Law University of Technology Internationalising the Suez Canal Robert Wai Noah Rosenblum (United States) Osgoode Hall Law School Columbia University Rethinking Political Economy Special Legal Zones and Normal Tribes, Technology, and Visions of Legal Moderator: Transnational Law Order: Three Ontologies of International Law Brishen Rogers (United States) Temple Law School Japanese Legal Thought and Event, Encounter and Engagement in the Globalization Histories of International Law Panelists: Moderator: Moderator: Jason Jackson (United States) Mikhail Xifaras (France) Matt Craven (United Kingdom) University of Pennslyvania Sciences Po Law School SOAS, University of London Traders, Speculators or Captains of Industry? Constructing Cultural Categories of Capitalist Panelists: Panelists: Legitimacy in India Mika Takada Yokoyama (Japan) Suzanne Akila (Australia) Kyoto University Australian National University Anush Kapadia (United Kingdom) Globalisation and Japanese Contact Law How Did Human Rights Get So Righteous? Harvard University Mechanism and Context: On Economic (Cont.)

53 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Kanako Takayama (Japan) University of Missouri Maria Varaki (Greece) Kyoto University Hebrew University Criminal Law in Japan Roy Kreitner (Israel) Tel Aviv University Law School,) PRO-SEMINAR 10: Economies of Desire Hajime Yamamoto (Japan) Keio Law School Modernization and Constitutionalism in Marc Lavoie (Canada) Libby Adler (United States) Japan University of Ottawa Northeastern University School of Law

Jouneys of Expertise Yore and Now Steve Marglin (United States) Aziza Ahmed (United States) Moderator: Harvard University Northeastern University School of Law Olusegun Gabriel Adegbite (Nigeria) Glasgow Caledonian University Mark Peacock (United Kingdom) Grietje Baars (Netherlands) York University City University London Panelists: Anna Aseeva (Russia) Nadav Orian Peer (Israel) Cyra Choudhury (United States) Sciences Po Law School Harvard Law School Florida International University Political Dimensions of Normative Discourses in International Trade and Investment Law Morgan Ricks (United States) Karen Engle (United States) Gearóid Ó Cuinn (Ireland) Vanderbilt Law School University of Texas School of Law Lancaster University Law School Garth Sheldon-Coulson (United States) Aya Gruber (United States) Toby Goldbach (Canada) Harvard Law School University of Colorado Law School Cornell Law School Legal Norms’ Distinctiveness in Legal L. Randall Wray (United States) Vanja Hamzic (Bosnia and Herzegovina) Transplants and Global Legal Pluralism Levy Institute of Bard College City University London

Can Öztaş (Turkey) PRO-SEMINAR 8: Contemporary Legal Dipika Jain (India) Sciences Po Law School Thought (1970-Present) Jindal Global Law School The Role of European Thought in the Construction and the Deconstruction of the Turkish State Mekonnen Ayano (Ethopia) Duncan Kennedy (United States) Harvard Law School Harvard Law School Mingzhe Zhu (People’s Republic of China) Sciences Po Law School Harcourt Bernard (United States) Karl Klare (United States) Universalism in French Legal Thoughts and University of Chicago Northeastern University School of Law Modern Comparative Amy Cohen (United States) Prabha Kotiswaran (India) Other Participants: Ohio State University College of Law King’s College London Nasser Al-Naemi (Qatar Foundation) Mohammed Al-Rwaili (Qatar Foundation) Avinoam Cohen (Tel Aviv University) Benoit Frydman (Belgium) Horatia Muir Watt (France) Moatasem El-Gheriani (Alexandria Universite Libre de Bruxelles Science Po Law School University School of Law) Dawn Jones (Qatar Foundation) Vikvek Kanwar (United States) James Richardson (United States) Jindal Global Law School Harvard Law School The Pro-Seminars Harvard Law School, Amy Ostdiek (United States) IGLP 2013 Colloquium June 5-7, 2013 University of Colorado Law School Harvard Law School, June 5-7, 2013 PRO-SEMINAR 5: Re-Theorizing Liquidity Laura Pratt (United States) University of Colorado Law School Libby Adler (United States) Matthew Forstater (United States) Northeastern University School of Law University of Missouri Rafael Sakr (Brazil) Harvard Law School Aziza Ahmed (United States) Robert Hockett (United States) Northeastern University School of Law Cornell University Pierre Schlag (United States) University of Colorado Law School Nasser Al-Naemi (Qatar) Fadhel Kaboub (Tunisia) Qatar Foundation Denison University John Schlegel (United States) State University of New York at Buffalo Mohammed Al-Rwaili (Qatar) Steve Keen (Australia) Qatar Foundation University of Western William Simon (United States) Columbia Law School (Cont.) Stephanie Kelton (United States)

54 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Helena Alviar (Colombia) Luis Eslava (Australia) Lisa Kelly (Canada) Universidad de los Andes Melbourne Law School Harvard Law School

Mekonnen Ayano (Ethiopia) Jorge Esquirol (United States) Stephanie Kelton (United States) Eastern and Souther African Trade and Florida International University College of Department of Economics, University of Development Bank Law Missouri-Kansas City

Grietje Baars (Netherlands) Mathew Forstater (United States) David Kennedy (United States) City University, London University of Missouri Kansas City Harvard Law School

Paulo Barrozo (Brazil) Günter Frankenberg (Germany) Duncan Kennedy (United States) Boston University School of Law Goethe-Universität, Frankfurt am Main Harvard Law School

Arnulf Becker (Chile) Ermal Frasheri (Albania) Karl Klare (United States) Watson Institute, Brown University New England Law Northeastern University School of Law

Michelle Burgis-Kasthala (Australia) Benoit Frydman (Belgium) Outi Korhonen (Finland) School of International Relations, University Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB) / University of Turku of Saint Andrews Perelman Centre Prabha Kotiswaran (United Kingdom) Daniela Caruso (United States) Gary Gereffi (United States) King’s College London Boston University School of Law Duke University Roy Kreitner (United States) Madelaine Chiam (Australia) Mario Gomes Schapiro (Brazil) Tel Aviv University Melbourne Law School Fundação Getulio Vargas Law School Tor Krever (Canada) Cyra Choudhury (United States) Aya Gruber (United States) London School of Economics and Political Florida International University Law School University of Colorado Law School Science

Amy Cohen (United States) Janet Halley (United States) Damjan Kukovec (Slovenia) Ohio State University College of Law Harvard Law School Harvard Law School

Avinoam Cohen (Israel) Vanja Hamzic (Bosnia and Herzegovina) Vidya Kumar (Canada) Tel Aviv University City University, London University of Birmingham

Diogo Coutinho (Brazil) Bernard Harcourt (United States) Marc Lavoie (Canada) University of Sao Paulo University of Chicago University of Ottawa

Matthew Craven (United Kingdom) Robert Hockett (United States) Lucas Lixinski (Brazil) SOAS, University of London Cornell University Law School University of New South Wales

Dan Danielsen (United States) Jason Jackson (Bahamas) Boris Mamlyuk (United States) Northeastern University School of Law The Wharton School, University of University of Memphis Pennsylvania Dennis Davis (South Africa) Stephen Marglin (United States) High Court, Cape Town Dipika Jain (India) Harvard University Jindal Global Law School, India Christine Desan (United States) Heidi Matthews (Canada) Harvard Law School Sheila Jasanoff (United States) Harvard Law School Harvard Kennedy School Justin Desautels-Stein (United States) Zinaida Miller (United States) University of Colorado Law School Dawn Jones (United States) The Fletcher School, Tufts University and Qatar Foundation Harvard Law School Luwam Dirar (Eritrea) Harvard Law School Fadhel Kaboub (Tunisia) PG Monateri (Italy) Denison University University of Torino, School of Law Moatasem El-Gheriani (Egypt) Alexandria University School of Law Vivek Kanwar (India) Michael Morris (South Africa) Jindal Global Law School University of Cape Town School of Karen Engle (United States) Economics The University of Texas School of Law Steve Keen (Australia) (Cont.)

55 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

Horatia Muir-Watt (France) Charlotte Peevers (United Kingdom) Georgetown Univeristy Law Center Sciences Po Law School University of Technology Sydney Sreela Sarkar (India) Usha Natarajan (Australia) Nikolas Rajkovic (Canada) University of Massachusetts Amherst The American University in Cairo University of Kent Law School Hani Sayed (Syria) Vasuki Nesiah (United States) Gustavo Ribeiro (Brazil) The American University in Cairo New York University Gallatin School of Harvard Law School Individualized Study Pierre Schlag (United States) James Richardson (United States) University of Colorado Law School Scott Newton (United States) Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP SOAS, University of London John Henry Schlegel (United States) Morgan Ricks (United States) State University of New York at Buffalo Fionnuala Ni Aolain (Ireland) Vanderbilt University University of Minnesota Law School Mohammad Shahabuddin (Bangladesh) Kerry Rittich (Canada) Department of Law & Justice, Jahanginagar Nadav Orian Peer (Israel) University of Toronto University Harvard Law School Brishen Rogers (United States) Garth Sheldon-Coulson (United States) Sundhya Pahuja (Australia) Temple University Beasley School of Law Harvard Law School Melbourne Law School Darren Rosenblum (United States) William Simon (United States) Rose Parfitt (United Kingdom) Pace Law School Columbia Law School The American University in Cairo Rafael Sakr (Brazil) Oishik Sircar (India) Mark Peacock (United Kingdom) Harvard Law School The University of Melbourne York University Alvaro Santos (Mexico) (Cont.)

56 Annual Report 2012-2013 The Institute

Leo Specht (Austria) A Comparative Perspective J. Pulgar Ezquerra Specht Böhm, Vienna on Old and New Problems of Universidad Complutense de Madrid Chase Strangio (United States) Corporate and Financial Law J. Quijano González Harvard Law School, Universidad de Valladolid Jeannie Suk (United States) September 24-27, 2012 Harvard Law School J. Rodriguez Hernández Participants: Director General de los Registros y del David Trubek (United States) Notariado. University of Wisconsin-Madison Law School A. Domínguez Universidad Complutense de Madrid J. Sánchez-Calero Maria Varaki (Greece) Universidad Complutense de Madrid Hebrew University A. Muñoz García Universidad Complutense de Madrid Jesse Freid Fabia Veçoso (Brazil) Harvard Law School Faculdade de Direito do Sul de Minas A. Tapia Hermida Universidad Complutense de Madrid John C. Coates Robert Wai (Canada) Harvard Law School Osgoode Hall Law School B. Villanueva García-Pomareda Attorney L. Fernández del Pozo Lucie White (United States) Universidad de Cataluña Harvard Law School C. Alonso Ledesma Universidad Complutense de Madrid L. Garnacho Cabanillas L. Randall Wray (United States) Universidad Rey Juan Carlos Levy Institute of Bard College C. Galán López Universidad Complutense de Madrid L.M. García Martínez Mikhail Xifaras (France) Universidad Complutense de Madrid Sciences Po Law School C. Guerrero Trevijano Universidad Complutense de Madrid M. Fuentes Naharro Karolina Zurek (Poland) Universidad Complutense de Madrid Swedish Institute for European Policy David Kennedy Studies Harvard Law School M. S. Flores Doña Universidad Complutense de Madrid Andrew Parker (United States) E. Gallego Sánchez Rutgers University Universidad de Alicante Martínez Rosado Universidad Complutense de Madrid Partha Chatterjee (United States) E.P. Lucas Martín Columbia University Universidad Complutense de Madrid Navarro Lérida Universidad Rey Juan Carlos Daniel Jutras (Canada) F. Rodríguez Prieto McGill University Faculty of Law O. Fradejas Rueda Guhan Subramanian Universidad Complutense de Madrid Christophe Jamin (France) Harvard Law School, Harvard Business Sciences Po Law School School A. Muñoz García Universidad Complutense de Madrid Elizabeth Povinelli (United States) I. Fernández Torres Columbia University Universidad Complutense de Madrid I. Gómez-Jordana Universidad Complutense de Madrid Benjamin Hurlbut (United States) J. A. García Pérez Arizona State University Banco Santander Reinier H. Kraakman Harvard Law School Kaushik Sunder Rajan (India) J. I. Signes de Mesa (Cont.) University of Chicago Letrado del Tribunal de Justicia de la Unión Europea. R. Palá Laguna Deval Desai (United Kingdom) J. M. Martínez Sierra Universidad Zaragoza. Harvard Law School Real Colegio Complutense (Cont.) S. Senent Martínez Magistrado-Juez de lo Mercantil J. Martínez Rosado Universidad Complutense de Madrid S.Navarro Lérida Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha J. Megías López Universidad Complutense de Madrid

57 www . iglp . law . harvard . edu Institute for Global Law & Policy at Harvard Law School

The graphic above documents the many countries represented by applicants to our annual workshop in Doha, Qatar, January, 2014. Since 2010 over 500 people from 75 countries have joined our network through participation in the IGLP annual workshop. Over 1000 scholars subscribe to our e-newsletter.

58 IGLP Online

email: [email protected] website: www . iglp . law . harvard . edu international network challenging expertise

young scholars

rethinking global finance collaborative teams

alternative thinking about the global situation

economic development

innovative research INSTITUTE FOR GLOBAL LAW & POLICY AT HARVARD LAW SCHOOL CAMBRIDGE, MA 02138 | WWW . IGLP . LAW . HARVARD . EDU