Arxiv:1403.1675V1 [Astro-Ph.SR]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Draft version March 10, 2014 A Preprint typeset using LTEX style emulateapj v. 5/2/11 AN OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPIC STUDY OF T TAURI STARS. I. PHOTOSPHERIC PROPERTIES Gregory J. Herczeg1,2,3,4 & Lynne A. Hillenbrand2 Draft version March 10, 2014 ABSTRACT Measurements of the mass and age of young stars from their location in the HR diagram are limited by not only the typical observational uncertainties that apply to field stars, but also by large systematic uncertainties related to circumstellar phenomena. In this paper, we analyze flux calibrated optical spectra to measure accurate spectral types and extinctions of 283 nearby T Tauri stars. The primary advances in this paper are (1) the incorportation of a simplistic accretion continuum in optical spectral type and extinction measurements calculated over the full optical wavelength range and (2) the uniform analysis of a large sample of stars, many of which are well known and can serve as benchmarks. Comparisons between the non-accreting TTS photospheric templates and stellar photosphere models are used to derive conversions from spectral type to temperature. Differences between spectral types can be subtle and difficult to discern, especially when accounting for accretion and extinction. The spectral types measured here are mostly consistent with spectral types measured over the past decade. However, our new spectral types are 1-2 subclasses later than literature spectral types for the original members of the TW Hya Association and are discrepant with literature values for some well known members of the Taurus Molecular Cloud. Our extinction measurements are consistent with other optical extinction measurements but are typically 1 mag. lower than near-IR measurements, likely the result of methodological differences and the presence of near-IR excesses in most CTTSs. As an illustration of the impact of accretion, spectral type, and extinction uncertainties on the HR diagrams of young clusters, we find that the resulting luminosity spread of stars in the TW Hya Association is 15-30%. The luminosity spread in the TWA and previously measured for binary stars in Taurus suggests that for a majority of stars, protostellar accretion rates are not large enough to significantly alter the subsequent evolution. Subject headings: stars: pre-main sequence — stars: planetary systems: protoplanetary disks matter — stars: low-mass 1. INTRODUCTION In the last decade, dedicated optical and IR searches Classical T Tauri stars are the adolescents of stellar revealed thousands of young stars, typically con- evolution. The star is near the end of its growth and firmed with spectral typing (e.g. Hillenbrand 1997; almost fully formed, with a remnant disk and ongoing Briceno et al. 2002; Luhman et al. 2004; Rebull et al. accretion. The accretion/disk phase typically lasts ∼ 2010). However, significant differences in extinction 2 − 5 Myr, though some stars take as long as 10 Myr and accretion properties between different papers and before losing their disks and emerging towards maturity. methods has lead to confusion in the properties of even Strong magnetic activity leads to pimply spots on the the closest and best studied samples of young stars. stellar surfaces. Some T Tauri stars are still hidden inside Some of this confusion is exacerbated by stochas- their disks, not yet ready to emerge. Manic mood swings tic and rotation variability of T Tauri stars. While change the appearance of the star and are often explained manic and depressive periods provide fascinating diag- with stochastic accretion. Depression has been seen in nostics of the stellar environment and star-disk inter- arXiv:1403.1675v1 [astro-ph.SR] 7 Mar 2014 lightcurves on timescales of days to years. Sometimes actions, they also pose significant problems for assess- every classical T Tauri star seems as uniquely precious ing the stellar properties and evolution of the star/disk as a snowflake. system. How disk mass, structure and accretion rate T Tauri star properties were systematically char- change with age and mass requires accurate spectral acterized in seminal papers by e.g. Cohen & Kuhi typing and luminosity measurements (e.g. Furlan et al. (1979); Herbig&Bell (1988); Basri&Batalha 2006; Sicilia-Aguilar et al. 2010; Oliveira et al. 2013; (1990); Valenti et al. (1993); Hartigan et al. (1995); Andrews et al. 2013). While median cluster ages pro- Kenyon & Hartmann (1995); Gullbring et al. (1998). vide an accurate relative age scale between regions (e.g. Naylor et al. 2009), age spreads within clusters may be real or could result from observational uncertain- 1 Kavli Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Peking Uni- versity, Yi He Yuan Lu 5, Haidian Qu, Beijing 100871, People’s ties (e.g. Hartmann et al. 1998; Hillenbrand et al. 2008; Republic of China Preibisch et al. 2012). 2 Caltech, MC105-24, 1200 E. California Blvd., Pasadena, CA The uncertainties in stellar parameters affect our 91125, USA interpretation of stellar evolution. For example, 3 Max-Planck-Institut f¨ur extraterrestrische Physik, Postfach 1312, 85741 Garching, Germany Gullbring et al. (1998) found accretion rates an order of 4 Visiting Astronomer, LERMA, Observatoire de Paris, ENS, magnitude lower than those of Hartigan et al. (1995) and UPMC, UCP, CNRS, 61 avenue de l’Observatoire, 75014 Paris, attributed much of this difference to lower values of ex- France 2 Herczeg TABLE 1 Observation Setup and Log Blue Setup Red Setup Telescope Dates Instrument Slit Grating Wavelength Res. Grating Wavelength Res. Palomar 18-21 Jan. 2008 DoubleSpec 1–4′′ B600 3000–5700 700 R316 6200–8700 500 Palomar 28-30 Dec. 2008 DoubleSpec 4′′ B600 3000–5700 700 R316 6200–8700 500 Keck I 23 Nov. 2006 LRIS 0′′. 7 − 1′′ B400 3000–5700 900 R400 5700–9400 1000 Keck I 28 May 2008 LRIS 1′′ B400 3000–5700 900 R400 5700–9400 1000 tinction. The Gullbring et al. (1998) accretion rates of TABLE 2 −8 −1 10 M⊙ yr means that steady accretion in the CTTS Flux Calibration phase accounts for a negligible amount of the final mass Wavelength G191B2B LTT 3864 of a star. However, subsequent near-IR analyses have A˚ Absolute Scatter in Fluxes revised extinctions upward (e.g. White & Ghez 2001; 3500 0.067 0.087 Fischer et al. 2011; Furlan et al. 2011). These higher ex- 4300 0.056 0.046 −7 −1 tinctions would yield accretion rates of 10 M⊙ yr , 5400 0.041 0.047 fast enough that steady accretion over the ∼ 2 − 3 Myr 6300 0.063 0.091 CTTS phase would account for ∼ 20 − 50% of the final 8400 0.061 0.089 stellar mass, or more with the older ages measured by Flux ratio Scatter in Flux Ratios Bell et al. (2013). The uncertainties in stellar properties F7020/F7140 0.007 0.005 introduce skepticism in our ability to use young stellar F8400/F6300 0.016 0.014 populations to test theories of star formation and pre- F6300/F5400 0.057 0.101 main sequence evolution. F4300/F5400 0.034 0.051 F /F 0.048 0.087 For classical T Tauri stars, minimizing the uncer- 3500 5400 tainties in spectral type, extinction, and accretion (of- lished in Herczeg et al. (2009). The Atmospheric Dis- ten referred to as veiling of the photosphere by ac- persion Corrector (Phillips et al. 2006) was used for the cretion) requires fitting all three parameters simul- May 2008 run but was not yet available in November taneously (e.g. Bertout et al. 1988; Basri et al. 1989; 2006. Both DBSP and LRIS use a dichroic to split the Hartigan & Kenyon 2003). In recent years, such fits light into red and blue beams at ∼ 5600 A.˚ Details of the have received increasing attention and have been ap- gratings and spectral coverage are listed in Table 1. plied HST photometry of the Orion Nebula Clus- On DBSP, the blue light was recorded by the CCD ter (da Rio et al. 2010; Manara et al. 2012), broadband 23 detector, with 15µm (0′′. 389) pixels in a 2048 × 4096 optical/near-IR spectra of two Orion Nebular Cluster format. The red light was recorded by the Tektronix stars (Manara et al. 2013), and to near-IR spectroscopy detector, with 24 µm (0′′. 468) pixels in a 1024 × 1024 (Fischer et al. 2011; McClure et al. 2013). format. The red detector has since been replaced. On In this project, we analyze low resolution optical blue- LRIS, the blue E2V and the red LBNL detectors both red spectra to determine the stellar and accretion proper- have 2048 × 4096 pixels with a plate scale of 0′′. 135. ties of 283 of the nearest young stars in Taurus, Lupus, Our typical observing strategy consisted of 3–10 short Ophiucus, the TW Hya Association, and the MBM 12 (1-60s) red exposures and 1–2 long (60–900s) blue expo- Association. This first paper focuses on spectral types sures obtained simultaneously. Most DBSP observations and extinctions of our sample. The primary advances in Jan. 2008 were obtained with the 2′′. -width slit, though are the inclusion of blue spectra to complement com- a few sources were observed with the 1′′. or 4′′. -width slits, monly used red optical spectra and accretion estimates adjusted for seeing. All Dec. 2008 observations were ob- to calculate the effective temperatures and luminosities tained with the 4′′. -width slit. Our LRIS observations with a single, consistent approach for a large sample of were obtained with the 0′′. 7 and 1′′. 0 slits. Seeing during stars. Discrepancies are found between our results and both Palomar runs typically varied from 2–4′′, though near-IR based extinction measurements. We then dis- for a few hours the seeing reached ∼ 1′′. The seeing was cuss how these uncertainties affect the reliability of age ∼ 0′′.