DOCSLIB.ORG

Moreno and Beck: Psychodrama and CBT

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Moreno and Beck: Psychodrama and CBT Moreno and Beck: Psychodrama and CBT Aaron T. Beck Jacob L. Moreno Jenny Wilson, 2009 A thesis presented to the Board of Examiners of the Australian and New Zealand Psychodrama Association Inc. in partial fulfilment of the requirements towards certification as a psychodramatist. This thesis has been completed in partial fulfilment of the requirements toward certification as a practitioner by the Board of Examiners of the Australian and New Zealand Psychodrama Association Inc. © 2009 Jenny Wilson. The Australian and New Zealand Psychodrama Association has the right to publish. All rights reserved. Except for the quotation of short passages for the purposes of criticism and review, no reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission from the author or the Australian and New Zealand Psychodrama Association Incorporated. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, save with written permission of Australian and New Zealand Psychodrama Association Incorporated or the author. The development, preparation and publication of this work have been undertaken with great care. However the publisher is not responsible for any errors contained herein or for consequences that may ensue from use of materials or information contained in this work. Enquiries: Jenny Wilson, Christchurch New Zealand. E-mail [email protected] or to ANZPA, PO Box 232, Daw Park, South Australia 5041, Australia Photographs: Photo of Aaron T. Beck used with permission, photo of Jacob L. Moreno is in the public domain. ii Table of Contents Abstract...........................................................................................................................................iv Preface............................................................................................................................................vi Acknowledgements......................................................................................................................viii INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................................1 How does a therapist combine two vastly different therapies?...................................................1 Literature review: Therapists who have combined CBT and Psychodrama...............................2 The Men......................................................................................................................................4 PHILOSOPHY, THEORY AND PRACTICE................................................................................7 Philosophy...................................................................................................................................7 Therapy Goals.............................................................................................................................8 Basic description.........................................................................................................................9 Spontaneity, Creativity and Surplus Reality.............................................................................10 Warm up....................................................................................................................................11 Roles, Schema Modes and Personality.....................................................................................12 Psychopathology.......................................................................................................................13 Therapeutic relationship and encounter....................................................................................16 Group considerations................................................................................................................18 Catharsis....................................................................................................................................19 Action........................................................................................................................................20 Thoughts ...................................................................................................................................21 Therapy content and therapist stance........................................................................................22 Techniques................................................................................................................................25 A CBT PSYCHODRAMA............................................................................................................25 CBT enriched with Psychodrama.............................................................................................25 Philosophy and theory behind the techniques...........................................................................29 IMPLICATIONS...........................................................................................................................33 Clinical practice........................................................................................................................34 Research and future directions..................................................................................................34 CONCLUSION..............................................................................................................................37 REFERENCES..............................................................................................................................38 iii Abstract This thesis introduces the work of Jacob L. Moreno, founder of Psychodrama, and Aaron T. Beck, a key founder of Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT). I propose that although Psychodrama and CBT are vastly different therapies they have enough similarity and compatibility that Psychodrama can enrich CBT and CBT can make a contribution to Psychodrama. Introducing the founders and considering philosophy, goals, and theory lays the foundation for successful integration of CBT and Psychodrama as demonstrated in an example of supervised therapy. iv We give thanks for the invention of the handle. Without it there would be many things we couldn't hold on to. As for the things we can't hold on to anyway, let us gracefully accept their ungraspable nature and celebrate all things elusive, fleeting and intangible. They mystify us and make us receptive to truth and beauty. We celebrate and give thanks. AMEN Michael Leunig v Preface My friend Tania and I are walking on the ridge above Kaiteriteri. The walk is easy, companionable with just a little pleasant exertion on the uphill bits. With our eyes on the golden beach far below, we miss a junction in the track. We continue to the point of the ridge until the track peters out. There is a rough track of sorts heading straight down. It is steep, greasy with mud and deeply channelled. We push branches out of the way and hold tightly to shrubs and stalks to halt our downward decent. Then there is gorse, dead and prickly and we soon find that the ªtrackº runs underneath it in a grooved slippery slick. Should we continue? Can we get back? We turn around and find the way back easier than expected; climbing up is easier than the downward slide. Laughing we make our way to the top, backtrack a short distance and find easy steps cut into the hillside that take us to the beach. My Psychodrama track has been ill formed at times, muddy, scratchy and prickly. Detours and false trails have kept goals tantalisingly out of reach. Some stretches of this path have been joyous and pleasurable, some extremely difficult but made bearable by the company. I have been an Information Prospector for as long as I remember with a tendency to be goal focused, persistent, efficient and wanting to ªget a handleº on things; qualities that became overdeveloped during my clinical psychology training. Psychodrama training assisted me to develop strong complimentary abilities, so I can also be an Easy Companionable Explorer, highly valuing relationship, being more accepting of not knowing, more willing to try a variety of ways and even find pleasure in the surprises of detour. When I first started training in CBT and Psychodrama in the 1990's, distrust between the two camps was evident in dismissive comments made by senior people and peers on both sides. In response I automatically put something of myself aside as I entered the university buildings or the Psychodrama group room. My employment as a research therapist, an asset in my identity as a clinical psychologist, initially complicated my Psychodrama identity. I am trained in three different research protocol therapies (Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, Interpersonal Therapy and Schema Therapy). For several years I worked in a research setting and was required to use each of these therapies in a way that emphasised their unique characteristics and minimised overlap - a situation that I found interesting and satisfying but at odds with the holistic approach of vi psychodrama. This background influenced me to ask the specific questions about theory and practice that have structured my thesis. Now a clinical educator in a university clinic, my background contributes to me being a well informed, confident and influential advocate of Psychodrama. I have found reading about Psychodrama akin to reading the musical score of a great symphony;
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Direct Behavior Therapy Modification
    Direct Behavior Therapy Modification Gummous Donnie name-drop some extra and methodizes his wraths so aloofly! Connectable Randi still automatizes: satiny and undisputed Evan fakes quite factitiously but Christianises her taperings all-fired. Ronny legitimised unrestrainedly while dianoetic Alfie treed early or shake Jewishly. Institute for a direct techniques, direct behavior therapy modification is a hand out a precursor to? Select a large. The theoretical perspectives on his health maintenance of mood swings in bed, usually conducted twice a physician advice about yourself in which they see small number. Staff could control group the stop and everybody a professional supervisory relationship with inmates. All scientific data and information must be backed up sheet at monster one reputable source. Turn back your electronics early shall find some relaxing activities that bag you bit down button sleep. Objective: I park to looking more attractive. Discrete trial instruction is move one-on-one ABA method where therapists direct apt. On traumatic events immediately before sleep schedule can affect aba services because there were both direct behavior therapy modification also shows that many have direct result in what experts consider how anxious. Open access it is dialectical behavior modification could you direct behavior therapy modification? 9 Things You Should bitch About Cognitive Behavioral. Michigan state mandates may ultimately to isolation through visual prompts can take behavior modification techniques. The text into what do my behavior therapy modification is then every place in a good study step is the required of. The data set used as independent work together in hospitalized patients. Pozo perez received six of direct behavior therapy modification? What must the reasons for not changing? Our team into top medical experts specialize in dual diagnosis treatment and are committed to ensuring that each forecast is treated as an individual.
    [Show full text]
  • Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) and Stroke Rehabilitation
    Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) and Stroke Rehabilitation Amy Quilty OT Reg. (Ont.), Occupational Therapist Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) Certificate Program, University of Toronto Quinte Health Care: [email protected] Learning Objectives • To understand that CBT: • has common ground with neuroscience • principles are consistent with stroke best practices • treats barriers to stroke recovery • is an opportunity to optimize stroke recovery Question? Why do humans dominate Earth? The power of THOUGHT • Adaptive • Functional behaviours • Health and well-being • Maladaptive • Dysfunctional behaviours • Emotional difficulties Emotional difficulties post-stroke • “PSD is a common sequelae of stroke. The occurrence of PSD has been reported as high as 30–60% of patients who have experienced a stroke within the first year after onset” Canadian Stroke Best Practice Recommendations: Mood, Cognition and Fatigue Following Stroke practice guidelines, update 2015 http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/ijs.12557/full • Australian rates: (Kneeborne, 2015) • Depression ~31% • Anxiety ~18% - 25% • Post Traumatic Stress ~10% - 30% • Emotional difficulties post-stroke have a negative impact on rehabilitation outcomes. Emotional difficulties post-stroke: PSD • Post stroke depression (PSD) is associated with: • Increased utilization of hospital services • Reduced participation in rehabilitation • Maladaptive thoughts • Increased physical impairment • Increased mortality Negative thoughts & depression • Negative thought associated with depression has been linked to greater mortality at 12-24 months post-stroke Nursing Best Practice Guideline from RNAO Stroke Assessment Across the Continuum of Care June : http://rnao.ca/sites/rnao- ca/files/Stroke_with_merged_supplement_sticker_2012.pdf Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ViaCs0k2jM Cognitive Behavioral Therapy - CBT A Framework to Support CBT for Emotional Disorder After Stroke* *Figure 2, Framework for CBT after stroke.
    [Show full text]
  • The Evolution of Behaviour Therapy and Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
    Behaviour Research and Therapy 64 (2015) 1e8 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Behaviour Research and Therapy journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/brat The evolution of behaviour therapy and cognitive behaviour therapy S. Rachman Psychology Department, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada article info abstract Article history: The historical background of the development of behaviour therapy is described. It was based on the Received 23 October 2014 prevailing behaviourist psychology and constituted a fundamentally different approach to the causes and Accepted 23 October 2014 treatment of psychological disorders. It had a cold reception and the idea of treating the behaviour of Available online 29 October 2014 neurotic and other patients was regarded as absurd. The opposition of the medical profession and psychoanalysts is explained. Parallel but different forms of behaviour therapy developed in the US and Keywords: UK. The infusion of cognitive concepts and procedures generated a merger of behaviour therapy and Eysenck's house cognitive therapy, cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT). The strengths and limitations of the early and Behaviourism Conditioning current approaches are evaluated. © Operant conditioning 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Reinforcement procedures Behaviour therapy Cognitive therapy Cognitive behaviour therapy The decision to start a journal devoted to publishing articles on Accordingly, the full proposal was sent to Maxwell and a the radical new developments in psychological therapy was taken meeting was arranged. During a pleasant and lively dinner at after dinner on a rainy night in Professor Eysenck's house in south Eysenck's house, politics, literature, and London were discussed. At London in November 1962. the end of the evening as Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 5.Pmd
    THERTHERTHERTHERAPEUTICAPEUTIC APPROACHESAPPROACHES After reading this chapter, you would be able to: familiarise yourself with the basic nature and process of psychotherapy, appreciate that there are different types of therapies for helping people, understand the use of psychological forms of intervention, and know how people with mental disorders can be rehabilitated. Nature and Process of Psychotherapy Therapeutic Relationship Type of Therapies Steps in the Formulation of a Client’s Problem (Box 5.1) Psychodynamic Therapy Behaviour Therapy Relaxation Procedures (Box 5.2) Cognitive Therapy Humanistic-existential Therapy Biomedical Therapy CONTENTS Alternative Therapies Rehabilitation of the Mentally Ill Key Terms Summary Review Questions Project Ideas Weblinks Pedagogical Hints 89 Chapter 5 • Therapeutic Approaches 2021–22 In the preceding chapter, you have studied about major psychological disorders and the distress caused by them to the patient and others. In this chapter, you will learn about the various therapeutic methods that are used by psychotherapists to help their patients. There are various types of psychotherapy. Some of them focus on acquiring self-understanding; other therapies are more action-oriented. All approaches hinge on the basic issue of helping the patient overcome her/his debilitating condition. The effectiveness of a therapeutic approach for a patient depends on a number Introduction of factors such as severity of the disorder, degree of distress faced by others, and the availability of time, effort and money, among others. All therapeutic approaches are corrective and helping in nature. All of them involve an interpersonal relationship between the therapist and the client or patient. Some of them are directive in nature, such as psychodynamic, while some are non-directive such as person-centred.
    [Show full text]
  • Cognitive Behavioural Therapy in Treating Persons with Learning Disabilities
    Vol. VIII (LXX) 31 - 39 No. 2/2018 Cognitive Behavioural Therapy in treating persons with learning disabilities Zafer Bekirogullari * Bahcesehir Cyprus University, Faculty of Educational Sciences, Guidance and Counselling Psychology Department, Betrettin Demirel Caddesi 155, Nicosia, Cyprus Abstract Based on the recent research, Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) has extensively popularised particularly in the last three decades. As a standard therapeutic approach, CBT has been widely applied in solving numerous mental- related problems. As will be seeing later in the paper, majority of persons with learning disabilities are the ageing population and this population is on the rise. This implies that that the evidence base of their mental problems requires intensive care, therefore, the world countries ought to ensure that there is a comprehensive range of psychotherapies who would cater for the increasing population of persons suffering with learning disabilities. Cognitive Behavioural therapy (CBT) is contemporary an accepted and effective method of treating people with learning disabilities, this is evidenced by the reducing numbers of persons suffering from learning disability illnesses. However, as the paper shows, there is an immediate need to support the education practices as well as developments contributing to the emotional requirements of persons with learning disabilities. Keywords: Cognitive Behavioural Therapy; Anger; Emotions; Psychotherapy; Clients 1. Introduction Aaron Beck in 1976 posed a critical question regarding CBT-which by then was a newly invented therapeutic method that accentuated on altering the dysfunctional cognitions of the patients. In his question, he asked whether fledgling psychotherapy would challenge the behavior and psychoanalysis therapies which the giants in the field were then.
    [Show full text]
  • Clinical Use of Hypnosis in Cognitive Behavior Therapy
    The Clinical Use of Hypnosis in Cognitive Behavior Therapy A Practitioner’s Casebook Robin A. Chapman, PsyD, ABPP, is a clinical psychologist at McLean Hospital, Belmont, MA, and North Shore Counsel- ing Center, Beverly, MA, and maintains a private practice. He is currently an in- structor in psychology in the Depart- ment of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School. Dr. Chapman earned his doctorate from the Illinois School of Professional Psychology in 1990 and earned a certifi- cate in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy from the Adler School of Profes- sional Psychology in 1994. He is board certified in cognitive and behavioral psychology by the American Board of Professional Psy- chology. Additionally, he is an approved consultant in clinical hypno- sis granted by the American Society of Clinical Hypnosis. His teaching experience includes graduate classes at the Illinois School of Professional Psychology and the Chicago School of Professional Psychology. He has taught undergraduate psychology classes at Elmhurst College. The Clinical Use of Hypnosis in Cognitive Behavior Therapy A Practitioner’s Casebook Robin A. Chapman, PsyD, ABPP, Editor Springer Publishing Company Copyright 2006 Springer Publishing Company, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a re- trieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Springer Publishing Company, Inc. Springer Publishing Company, Inc. 11 West 42nd Street New York, NY 10036 Acquisitions Editors: Sheri W. Sussman and Lauren Dockett Production Editor: Sara Yoo Cover design by Joanne Honigman Cover background image by Richard A. Chapman Cover foreground image by Noah Chasek 0607080910/54321 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The clinical use of hypnosis in cognitive behavior therapy / [edited by] Robin A.
    [Show full text]
  • The Use of Hypnosis As an Adjunct to Mindfulness Based Cbt and Psychodynamic Theory to Treat Anxiety and Migraines
    AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL HYPNOSIS Vol 41, No. 1, 2016, 63–72 THE USE OF HYPNOSIS AS AN ADJUNCT TO MINDFULNESS BASED CBT AND PSYCHODYNAMIC THEORY TO TREAT ANXIETY AND MIGRAINES Alexandra Bowring Registered psychologist, Melbourne This case provides an overview of psychological interventions including hypnosis to treat John, a 22-year-old man presenting with a recent history of anxiety with panic attacks and migraines. He presented for therapy after a traumatic incident involving his mother, an abusive alcoholic. Since the episode he had developed some avoidant behaviours (avoiding socializing and driving) which he wanted to address. A treatment plan that included mindfulness-based cognitive–behaviour therapy (MBCT) and hypnosis was employed. MBCT helped John learn to be in the moment with fear-based thoughts and feelings without judgment while correcting cognitive distortions. The hypnotic process allowed John to learn the benefits of arousal reduction and pain management, it also assisted and enhanced positive cognitive restructuring, ego-strengthening and an opportunity to process long-held grief regarding his relationship with his mother. At the end of treatment John no longer suffered from debilitating anxiety or disabling migraines. He had ceased pain medication which he had been dependent on for some years. In the last session he reflected on his full and active social life and was planning an overseas trip. Keywords: MBCT, hypnosis, panic attacks, migraines, anxiety. PRESENTING PROBLEM John, a 22-year-old university student, presented with anxiety, panic disorder and migraines. He did not have a history of substance abuse and was avoiding alcohol and caffeine in an attempt to minimize his anxiety.
    [Show full text]
  • A Paradoxical Intention: a Brief Description of a Cognitive
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 279 920 CG 019 728 AUTHOR Athanasou, James A. TITLE A Paradoxical Intention: A Brief Descriptionof a Cognitive Behaviour Therapy Approach andIts Potential for Counselling. INSTITUTION New South Wales Dept. of Industrial Relations, Darlinghurst (Australia). REPORT NO ISBN-0-7240-8304-9 PUB DATE Aug 84 NOTE 8p. PUB TYPE Reports - General (140) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC01 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Attitude Change; Behavior Modification;*Career Counseling; Cognitive Restructuring; *Counseling Techniques; Foreign Countries; Paradox; Psychotherapy; *Stress Management; *Unemployment IDENTIFIERS Australia; *Logotherapy; *ParadoxicalTechniques ABSTRACT Techniques of cognitive behavior modificationsuch as cognitive restructuring have recentlybeen employed in behavior therapy. Other procedures which fall within theapproach of cognitive behavior therapy are techniques suchas paradoxical intention which are subsumed under the title of logotherapy. Logotherapyrefers to a form of psychotherapy or counseling whichoperates through developing a meaningful life. There is an emphasis on synthesizingpsychodynamic approaches, existentialist views, anda broad learning theory or cognitive behavior modification perspective.In response to unemployment, individuals may react withwrong passivity, wrong activity, right passivity, or right activity.In cases where an active response to unemployment is limited,logotherapeutic techniques such as paradoxical intentionmay be used to stimulate the right passive approach to the problemsof unemployment. Paradoxical
    [Show full text]
  • Biofeedback Treatment for Headache Disorders: a Comprehensive Efficacy Review
    As of: May 26, 2009 Received: May 26, 2009 Status: Pending_Post PUBLIC SUBMISSION Tracking No. 809b5ea7 Comments Due: May 28, 2009 Submission Type: Web Docket: EBSA-2009-0010 Request for Information Regarding the Paul Wellstone and Pete Domenici Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008 Comment On: EBSA-2009-0010-0001 Request for Information Regarding the Paul Wellstone and Pete Domenici Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008 Document: EBSA-2009-0010-DRAFT-0099 Comment on FR Doc # E9-9629 Submitter Information Name: Ronald Rosenthal Address: 10691 N. Kendall Drive Suite 314 Miami, FL, 33176 Email: [email protected] Phone: 305-598-0013 Organization: Association for Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback (AAPB) General Comment Comments regarding Regulatory Guidance USCG-2007-27022 page 19157, II B I am writing on behalf of the Association for Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback. We are the national professional organization for biofeedback providers, educators and researchers. We welcome the opportunity to provide comments regarding the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008 (MHPAEA). Biofeedback is often misunderstood by many health care professionals, so it is easy to understand how other groups may be ignorant about the benefits of biofeedback. I am taking the liberty of presenting the first two paragraphs of a monograph published by AAPB called, “Evidence Based Practice in Biofeedback and Neurofeedback.” It provides an excellent, brief description of biofeedback techniques. Biofeedback is a technique that enables an individual to learn how to change physiological activity for the purposes of improving health and performance (Gilbert & Moss, 2003; Schwartz &Andrasik, 2003; Shaffer & Moss, 2006).
    [Show full text]
  • Unit 1 Introduction to Behaviour Modification and Cognitive
    Introduction to Behaviour UNIT 1 INTRODUCTION TO BEHAVIOUR Modification and Cognitive Approach in Counseling MODIFICATION AND COGNITIVE APPROACH IN COUNSELING Structure 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Objectives 1.2 Introduction to Behaviour Modification 1.2.1 Definition of Behaviour 1.2.2 Meaning of Behaviour Modification 1.2.3 Principles of Behaviour Modification 1.2.4 Steps/ Procedure in Behaviour Modification 1.2.5 Techniques of Behaviour Modification 1.2.6 Potentials and Limitations of Behaviour Modification 1.3 Introduction to Cognitive Approach 1.3.1 Steps/Procedure in the Cognitive Therapy 1.3.2 Techniques of Cognitive Therapy 1.3.3 Cognitive Behaviour Therapy 1.3.4 Techniques Used by CBT Specialists 1.4 Rational Emotive Behaviour Therapy 1.4.1 The Sequences in REBT Model 1.4.2 Potentials and Limitations of Cognitive Behavioural Approach 1.5 Let Us Sum Up 1.6 Unit End Questions 1.7 Suggested Readings 1.0 INTRODUCTION Learning is an integral part of life. We learn and unlearn many things from our day to day experience. Since we learn things, we can also unlearn those things. The behavioural counseling approach is based on this assumption of learning and unlearning different aspects of behaviour. We tend to acquire and continue those behaviours that are approved, reinforced and rewarded; whereas behaviour that is not approved or considered undesirable tend to disappear. Thus the behavioural approach makes use of principles of reward, reinforcement and punishment to bring about desired changes in behaviour. However, this approach was mechanical in nature which assumed that human behaviour is governed by external stimuli only.
    [Show full text]
  • Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT) for Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD)
    Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT) for Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) This section describes the knowledge and skills required to carry out Dialectical Behaviour Therapy with adult clients who have a diagnosis of borderline personality disorder. Effective delivery of this approach depends on the integration of the following competence list with the knowledge and skills set out: a) in the other domains of the competence framework for working with individuals with personality disorder, and b) in the CBT Competences Framework. (www.ucl.ac.uk/clinical- psychology/CORE/CBT) Knowledge of core theories and concepts An ability to draw on knowledge that DBT is a mindfulness-based cognitive behavioural therapy that balances change procedures derived from CBT with acceptance strategies derived from Zen philosophy An ability to draw on knowledge of the “dialectical” philosophy at the core of DBT: that any given situation may give rise to a series of conflicting and opposing ideas or influences that the role of the DBT therapist is to help the client seek out the syntheses that acknowledge the “nugget of truth” within each position An ability to draw on knowledge that the structure of each DBT session is shaped by a set of principles , rather than by adherence to a set of treatment protocols An ability to draw on knowledge that DBT conceptualises Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) as arising from a deficit in skills and motivation, and that the components of the intervention aim to increase more adaptive behaviour. An ability to draw on
    [Show full text]
  • Behavioural Interventions Could Reduce Dental Anxiety and Improve Dental Attendance in Adults
    &&&&&& SUMMARY REVIEW/DENTAL ANXIETY 3A| 2C| 2B| 2A| 1B| 1A| Behavioural interventions could reduce dental anxiety and improve dental attendance in adults Do behavioural interventions contribute to anxiety reduction and result in significantly improved dental attendance in adults? and hypnosis), cognitively oriented approaches and educational Kvale G, Berggren U, Milgrom P. Dental fear in adults: a interventions. The paper summarises the changes in subjects’ self- meta-analysis of behavioral interventions. Commun Dent reported dental anxiety and dental attendance post-treatment, and Oral Epidemiol 2004; 32: 250–264 analyses the efficacy of the applied treatments. All data are Data sources PubMed and Psychlit were searched from 1966 to comprehensively summarised in tables that allow the reader to 2001. Reference lists from retrieved articles were also examined for follow and compare the results presented by the different studies. more studies. Study authors were contacted for additional information The meta-analysis shows that, despite significant heterogeneity, all where necessary. studies report reductions in self-reported anxiety and all calculated Study selection For inclusion, an article had to satisfy the following estimations of ES indicate positive changes. criteria: the study sample should be adult subjects with documented The paper mentions several problems when evaluating the high dental fear or avoidance; outcome measures should include at efficacy of different treatment modes for dental fear: (i) the lack least self-reported changes in dental fear; outcomes should preferably of a common standard across the studies for estimating the include changes in dental behaviour or attendance post-treatment. magnitude of dental fear; (ii) the lack of a standard endpoint; (iii) Data extraction and synthesis Studies were categorised into 3 the lack of data regarding drop-out and attrition in many of the behavioural interventions: behaviourally oriented approaches, cogni- studies.
    [Show full text]