KEMI COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT REPORT Kemikalieinspektionen Da'e Swedish Chemicals Agency July 2016 Authorisations and Guidance Comparative assessment report: Creosote; versus other wood preservatives, other materials or techniques. Version Changes Date Version 1.0 First version January 2016 Version 1.1 Coftection July 2016 Updated page numbering Section 1.1.1: Updated names of product families and members. Added information on asset number. Section 1.9 Overall conclusion: Correction of risk ratios in the marine environment. Updated page numbering Evaluating Competent Authotity: Sweden Swedish Chemicals Agency Mailing address Visit & delivery Invoicing address Phone & fax Internet V AT No Box 2 Esplanaden 3A FE 124 Phone +46 8 519 41 100 www.kemi.se SE202100388001 SE-172 13 Sundbyberg SE-172 67 Sundbyberg SE-838 80 Froson Fax +46 8 735 76 98
[email protected] Sweden Sweden Sweden Swedish Chemicals Agency COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT REPORT Contents 1 Comparative assessment 3 1.1 Background: 3 1.1.1 Products falling within the scope of the assessment 4 1.2 Legislation and guidance 6 1.3 Documentation 8 1.4 Intended uses of the biocidal product 9 1.5 Screening phase of the comparative assessment 11 1.6 Tier I. Comparison to other authorised BPs 13 1.7 Tier II. Comparison to non-chemical alternatives 14 1.7.1 Possible alternative materials to be used for railway sleepers 14 1.7.2 Alternative materials for utility poles to be used for electric power transmission and telecommunication 17 1.7.3 Alternative materials for fence posts for use in the agricultural