New York State Salt Marsh Restoration and Monitoring Guidelines
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NEW YORK STATE SALT MARSH RESTORATION AND MONITORING GUIDELINES George E. Pataki, Governor Alexander P. Treadwell, Secretary of State John P. Cahill, Commissioner, Department of Environmental Conservation New York State Salt Marsh Restoration and Monitoring Guidelines prepared by: Nancy L. Niedowski for the New York State Department of State Division of Coastal Resources 41 State Street Albany, NY 12231 - and - New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Division of Fish, Wildlife and Marine Resources Bureau of Marine Resources 205 N. Belle Meade Road East Setauket, NY 11733 December 15, 2000 The Salt Marsh Restoration and Monitoring Guidelines were prepared under the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Coastal Services Center Coastal Management Fellowship Program, which places recent graduates in coastal management and related fields with state coastal programs to conduct special two-year projects. The Coastal Management Fellowship Program is administered by NOAA Coastal Services Center, 2234 South Hobson Avenue, Charleston, South Carolina 29405. Additional financial assistance was provided through a federal grant from the U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management, under the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended. The New York State Coastal Management Program is administered by the New York State Department of State, Division of Coastal Resources, 41 State Street, Albany, New York 12231. December 2000 PREFACE All salt marsh restoration activities are regulated, and require permits and approvals. Using this guidance document does not relieve the reader of regulatory requirements, nor does it guarantee receipt of a permit. This document does not waive existing regulatory standards. Using this document should not be substituted for communication with permit staff regarding a proposed salt marsh restoration project. Regional permit staff should always be contacted by a project proponent early in the planning process and prior to submission of permit applications. This document is primarily intended to guide voluntary restoration projects, not mitigation projects. Mitigation projects are constrained by specific regulatory standards. This document does not modify or waive any program standards for mitigation. In addition, while voluntary projects are more flexible in goal-setting and design, such projects will nevertheless be subject to regulatory requirements, including permits and approvals from the State and federal government. The Salt Marsh Restoration and Monitoring Guidelines are primarily intended for use with projects sponsored by municipalities. Individuals with ideas for restoration projects are strongly encouraged to collaborate with their municipality, and to contact regional Department of Environmental Conservation staff prior to project planning. Activities in identified tidal wetlands, including salt marshes on private property, are regulated by the State of New York, and require permits and approvals. TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES ..............................................v LIST OF TABLES .............................................. vi 1. INTRODUCTION ..............................................1 1.a. Purpose of the Salt Marsh Restoration and Monitoring Guidelines ...2 1.b. Intended Audience and Format of the Guidelines ................2 1.c. Overall Goal Setting for Habitat Restoration in New York State ....4 1.d. Definitions of Terms .....................................6 1.e. Principal Planning Considerations in Salt Marsh Restoration .......7 2. TEMPERATE SALT MARSH HABITAT CHARACTERIZATION ...11 2.a. Salt Marsh Development .................................11 2.b. Salt Marshes in New York State ...........................11 2.c. Salt Marsh Vegetation ...................................12 2.d. Salt Marsh Fish and Wildlife ..............................13 2.e. Salt Marsh Functions ....................................14 2.f. Conceptual Model for Salt Marsh System Restoration ...........16 2.f.1. Introduction to Conceptual Models ...............16 2.f.2. Controlling Factors ...........................16 2.f.3. Attributes of the Controlling Factors ..............17 2.f.4. Structural Elements ...........................18 2.f.5. Attributes of the Structural Elements ..............19 2.f.6. Functions ...................................20 2.f.7. Specific Functional Parameters ..................21 2.g. Generic Activities Affecting Salt Marshes and Adjacent Habitats ..22 3. HUMAN DISTURBANCES ....................................22 3.a. Ditching .............................................23 3.b. Filling ...............................................23 3.c. Restricted Tidal Connection ..............................24 3.d. Diking & Impoundment ..................................25 3.e. Pollution .............................................25 3.f. Shoreline Hardening & Structures ..........................27 i 3.g. Sea Level Rise ........................................28 4. NATURAL DISTURBANCES ..................................29 4.a. Seasonal Disturbances ...................................29 4.b. Natural Disasters .......................................30 5. POST-DISTURBANCE CONDITIONS IN SALT MARSHES ........30 5.a. Changes in Tidal Regime ................................30 5.b. Subsidence ...........................................31 5.c. Flooding .............................................32 5.d. Changes in Salinity .....................................32 5.e. Changes in Salt Marsh Vegetation ..........................33 6. OVERVIEW OF RESTORATION METHODS ....................34 6.a. Manipulating Tidal Regime ...............................34 6.a.1. General Considerations ........................34 6.a.2. Measuring Tidal Elevations .....................34 6.a.3. Duration of Inundation ........................35 6.a.4. Sizing of Culverts ............................35 6.a.5. Open Marsh Water Management .................36 6.a.6. Low-lying Structures ..........................38 6.b. Manipulating Elevation, Slope, and Substrate .................38 6.b.1. General Considerations ........................38 6.b.2. Slope ......................................39 6.b.3. Substrate Properties ...........................39 6.b.4. Tidal Channels ..............................40 6.b.5. Heavy Equipment ............................40 6.c. Manipulating Vegetation .................................40 6.c.1. Planting vs. Natural Colonization .................40 6.c.2. Spartina alterniflora—Seeding ..................41 6.c.3. Spartina alterniflora—Stems, Plugs, and Potted Seedlings ..........................................41 6.c.4. Spartina alterniflora—Planting Methods ...........41 6.c.5. Spartina alterniflora—Fertilization ...............42 6.c.6. Spartina alterniflora—Spacing of Plants ...........42 6.c.7. Other Plant Species ...........................43 6.c.8. Estimated Costs for Plants ......................43 ii 6.d. Invasive Species Control: Common Reed ....................44 6.d.1. General Considerations ........................44 6.d.2. Common Reed Habitat ........................45 6.d.3. Disturbances Favoring Common Reed .............45 6.d.4. Natural History of Common Reed ................46 6.d.5. Impacts caused by Common Reed ................46 6.d.6. Ecological Value of Common Reed ...............46 6.d.7. Determining the Need for Control ................47 6.d.8. Control Methods for Common Reed ..............47 6.d.9. Tidal Inundation .............................48 6.d.10. Cutting and Mowing ..............................48 6.d.11. Cutting and Mowing Combined with Other Techniques ...49 6.d.12. Controlled Burning ...............................49 6.d.13. Controlled Burning Combined with Other Techniques ....50 6.d.14. Chemical Control ................................50 7. SALT MARSH RESTORATION—RECOMMENDED MONITORING PROTOCOL ..............................................53 8. COMMON REED CONTROL—RECOMMENDED MONITORING PROTOCOL ..............................................67 9. SALT MARSH BIBLIOGRAPHY ...............................77 10. COMMON REED CONTROL BIBLIOGRAPHY .................95 APPENDIX A FIELD AND REPORTING FORMS FOR RECOMMENDED SALT MARSH RESTORATION MONITORING PROTOCOL .......99 APPENDIX B WORLD WIDE WEB RESOURCES RELEVANT FOR SALT MARSH RESTORATION ..............................107 APPENDIX C RESTORATION PROJECT TIMELINE ........................113 iii APPENDIX D FEDERAL AND STATE LAWS AND REGULATIONS RELATED TO WETLAND RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT .117 APPENDIX E KNOWLEDGEABLE CONTACTS ............................125 APPENDIX F ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ....................................135 iv LIST OF FIGURES PAGE Figure 1. Process and Considerations for Restoration Projects .............8 Figure 2. Recreational Shellfishing ..................................9 Figure 3. Salt Marsh Development Over Time ........................11 Figure 4. Low Marsh Zone .......................................13 Figure 5. Grid Ditching in Long Island Wetlands ......................23 Figure 6. Wetland Filling ........................................24 Figure 7. Tidal Restriction .......................................24 Figure 8. Petroleum Pollution .....................................26 Figure 9. Bulkheading ..........................................27 Figure 10. Walkway Over a Marsh ..................................28 Figure 11. OMWM Ditch Plug .....................................37