The AMICA BULLETIN AUTOMATIC MUSICAL INSTRUMENT COLLECTORS’ ASSOCIATION JULY/AUGUST 2002 VOLUME 39, NUMBER 4
THE AMICA BULLETIN AUTOMATIC MUSICAL INSTRUMENT COLLECTORS' ASSOCIATION Published by the Automatic Musical Instrument Collectors’ Association, a non-profit, tax exempt group devoted to the restoration, distribution and enjoyment of musical instruments using perforated paper music rolls and perforated music books. AMICA was founded in San Francisco, California in 1963. ROBIN PRATT, PUBLISHER, 630 EAST MONROE ST., SANDUSKY, OH 44870-3708 -- Phone 419-626-1903, e-mail: [email protected] Visit the AMICA Web page at: http://www.amica.org Associate Editor: Mr. Larry Givens
VOLUME 39, Number 4 July/August 2002 AMICA BULLETIN
Display and Classified Ads FEATURES Articles for Publication Letters to the Publisher Leo Ornstein — 139 Chapter News Positive Consequences — 145 UPCOMING PUBLICATION DEADLINES The Early Welte Mignon — 150 The ads and articles must be received Edwin Welte’s Steinway Piano — 156 by the Publisher on the 1st of the Odd number months: Mechanical Music — 158 January July March September Street Organ — 157 May November Bulletins will be mailed on the 1st week DEPARTMENTS of the even months. Robin Pratt, Publisher AMICA International — 134 630 East Monroe Street Sandusky, Ohio 44870-3708 President’s Message — 135 Phone: 419-626-1903 e-mail: [email protected] From the Publisher’s Desk — 135 Calendar of Events — 136 Letters — 137 People — 140 MEMBERSHIP SERVICES Chapter News — 163 New Memberships ...... $42.00 They Shall Be Remembered — 175 Renewals ...... $42.00 Classified Ads — 177 Address changes and corrections Front Cover: Atlantic Garden, contributed by Mike Kukral Directory information updates Inside Front: Duo-Art Piano Roll, OOPS! , discovered by Gabe Della Fave Additional copies of Member Directory . . . . $25.00 Back Cover: What AMICA Means To Me was written before the 1978 Dayton Convention. At that time, there was a strong emphasis on pianos and not as much Single copies of back issues interest in the various other instruments that many of us own today. However, the ($6.00 per issue - based upon availability) feelings expressed have not changed so I asked Robin to reprint it. I appreciate the honor of being Convention Coordinator from 1985-2001. When Terry Smythe asked William Chapman (Bill) me to do it, I never dreamed I would be around so long. I will always cherish the 53685 Avenida Bermudas Carrousel Horse that was presented to me at the Arkansas Convention. Besides the La Quinta, CA 92253-3586 Bulletin, conventions are a wonderful way of communicating and getting to know the (760) 564-2951 people that you may only have read about. Many thanks to all the past convention e-mail: [email protected] chairmen and their committees who helped me so much to further our mutual To ensure timely delivery of your interests in all mechanical musical instruments. ~ Liz Barnhart BULLETIN, please allow 6-weeks advance notice of address changes. Inside Back Cover: Apollo Magazine Ad, October 1922, contributed by Robin Pratt
AMICA Publications reserves the right to accept, reject, or edit any and all submitted articles and advertising.
Entire contents © 2002 AMICA International 133 AMICA INTERNATIONAL
INTERNATIONAL OFFICERS CHAPTER OFFICERS PRESIDENT Dan C. Brown BOSTON AREA NORTHERN LIGHTS N. 4828 Monroe Street Pres. Bill Koenigsburg -(978) 369-8523 Pres: Dave Kemmer Spokane, WA 99205-5354 Vice Pres: Bob Tempest Vice Pres: Phil Baird 509-325-2626 Sec: Ginger Christiansen Sec: Jason E. Beyer - (507) 454-3124 e-mail: [email protected] Treas: Karl Ellison Treas: Howie O’Neil PAST PRESIDENT Linda Bird Reporter: Don Brown Reporter: Dorothy Olds 3300 Robinson Pike Board Rep: Sandy Libman Board Rep: Dorothy Olds Grandview, MO 64030-2275 Phone/Fax 816-767-8246 CHICAGO AREA PACIFIC CAN-AM e-mail: OGM [email protected] Pres: George Wilder - (630) 279-0872 Pres: Kurt Morrison - (253) 952-4725 VICE PRESIDENT Mike Walter Vice Pres: Curt Clifford Vice Pres: Don McLaughlin 65 Running Brook Dr., Sec: Jo Crawford Sec: Halie Dodrill Lancaster, NY 14086-3314 Treas: Joe Pekarek Treas: Bev Spore 716-656-9583 Reporter: Kathy Stone Septon Reporter: Carl Kehret e-mail: [email protected] Board Rep: Marty Persky Board Rep: Carl Dodrill SECRETARY Christy Counterman FOUNDING CHAPTER SIERRA NEVADA 544 Sunset View Drive, Akron, Ohio 44320 Pres: John Motto-Ros - (209) 267-9252 330-864-4864 Pres: Bing Gibbs - (408) 253-1866 Vice Pres: Karen Ann Simons Vice Pres: Sonja Lemon e-mail: [email protected] Sec/Treas: Doug & Vicki Mahr Sec: Lyle Merithew & Sandy Swirsky Reporter: Nadine Motto-Ros TREASURER Wesley Neff Treas: Richard Reutlinger 128 Church Hill Drive, Findlay, Ohio 45840 Board Rep: John Motto-Ros Reporter: Tom McWay Registered agent for legal matters 419-423-4827 e-mail: [email protected] Board Rep: Richard Reutlinger SOWNY (Southern Ontario, Western New York) GATEWAY CHAPTER Pres: Mike Walter - (716) 656-9583 PUBLISHER Robin Pratt Pres: Yousuf Wilson (636) 665-5187 630 E. Monroe Street, Sandusky, Ohio 44870-3708 Vice Pres: Mike Hamann 419-626-1903 Vice Pres: Tom Novak Sec/Mem. Sec: John & Diane Thompson e-mail: [email protected] Sec,/Treas: Jane Novak Treas: Holly Walter Reporter: Mary Wilson Photographer: Garry Lemon MEMBERSHIP SECRETARY William Chapman (Bill) Board Rep: Gary Craig 53685 Avenida Bermudas, La Quinta, CA 92253-3586 Reporter: Frank Warbis 760-564-2951 – Fax 775-923-7117 HEART OF AMERICA Board Rep: Mike Walter e-mail: [email protected] Pres: Ron Bopp - (918) 786-4988 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA — COMMITTEES — Vice Pres: Tom McAuley Pres: Frank Nix - (818) 884-6849 Sec/Treas: Robbie Tubbs Vice Pres: Richard Ingram AMICA ARCHIVES Stuart Grigg Reporter: Joyce Brite Sec./Reporter. Shirley Nix 20982 Bridge St., Southfield, MI 48034 - Fax: (248) 356-5636 Board Rep: Ron Connor Treas: Ken Hodge Board Rep: Frank Nix AMICA MEMORIAL FUND Judy Chisnell LADY LIBERTY 3945 Mission, Box 145, Rosebush, MI 48878-9718 517-433-2992 Pres: Bill Maguire (631) 261-6799 TEXAS Vice Pres: Keith Bigger AUDIO-VISUAL & TECHNICAL Harold Malakinian Pres: Jerry Bacon - (214) 328-9639 2345 Forest Trail Dr., Troy, MI 48098 Sec: Richard Karlsson Vice Pres: Tony Palmer (817) 261-1334 CONVENTION COORDINATOR Frank Nix Treas: Ira Malek Sec./Treas: Janet Tonnesen 6030 Oakdale Ave., Woodland Hills, CA 91367 818-884-6849 Reporter:Buzz Rosa Board Rep: Dick Merchant Board Reps: Marvin & Dianne Polan Bulletin Reporter: Bryan Cather HONORARY MEMBERS Jay Albert Newsletter Editor: Bryan Cather 904-A West Victoria Street, Santa Barbara, CA 93101-4745 MIDWEST (OH, MI, IN, KY) (805) 966-9602 - e-mail: [email protected] Pres: Judy Chisnell - (517) 433-2992 SOUTHERN SKIES PUBLICATIONS Robin Pratt Vice Pres: Stuart Grigg Pres: Debra Legg - (727) 734-3353 630 E. Monroe St., Sandusky, OH 44870-3708 Sec: Judy Wulfekuhl Vice Pres: Bill Shrive Treas: Alvin Wulfekuhl WEB MASTER Meta Brown Sec: Howard Wyman (813) 689-6876 400 East Randolph Street, Apt. 3117, Chicago, IL 60601 Reporter: Christy Counterman Treas: Dee Kavouras (352) 527-9390 312-946-8417 — Fax 312-946-8419 Board Rep: Liz Barnhart Reporter: Dick & Dixie Leis Board Rep: Debra Legg AFFILIATED SOCIETIES AND ORGANIZATIONS ATOS INTERNATIONAL PIANO NETHERLANDS MECHANICAL PLAYER PIANO GROUP President - Nelson Page ARCHIVES AT MARYLAND ORGAN SOCIETY - KDV Julian Dyer, Bulletin Editor The Galaxy Theatre Performing Arts Library,University of Maryland A. T. Meijer 5 Richmond Rise, Workingham, 7000 Blvd East, Guttenberg, NJ 07093 2511 Clarice Smith Performing Arts Center Wilgenstraat 24 Berkshire RG41 3XH, United Kingdom Phone: (201) 854-7847 Fax: (201) 854-1477 College Park, MD 20742 NL-4462 VS Goes, Netherlands Phone: 0118 977 1057 E-Mail: [email protected] Phone: (301) 405-9224 Email: [email protected] Editor - Vernon P. Bickel Fax: (301) 314-7170 NORTHWEST PLAYER PIANO 786 Palomino Court E-Mail: [email protected] ASSOCIATION SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION San Marcos, CA 92069-2102 Everson Whittle, Secretary Division of Musical History Phone: (760) 471-6194 Fax: (760) 471-9194 INT. VINTAGE PHONO & MECH. 11 Smiths Road, Darcy Lever, Washington, D.C. 20560 E-Mail: [email protected] MUSIC SOCIETY Bolton BL3 2PP, Gt. Manchester, England SOCIETY FOR SELF-PLAYING C.G. Nijsen, Secretaire General Home Phone: 01204 529939 AUSTRALIAN COLLECTORS OF MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS 19 Mackaylaan Business Phone: 01772 208003 MECHANICAL MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS Gesellschaft für Selbstspielende 5631 NM Eindhoven 19 Waipori Street Musikinstrumente (GSM) E.V. Netherlands PIANOLA INSTITUTE St. Ives NSW 2075, Australia Clair Cavanagh, Secretary Ralf Smolne DUTCH PIANOLA ASSOC. MUSICAL BOX SOCIETY 43 Great Percy St., London WC1X 9RA Emmastr. 56 Nederlandse Pianola Vereniging INTERNATIONAL England D-45130 Essen, Germany Eikendreef 24 P. O. Box 297 Phone: **49-201-784927 5342 HR Oss, Marietta, OH 45750 Fax:. **49-201-7266240 Netherlands Email: [email protected] 134 President’s Message Thanks to the Heart of America Chapter for putting on a great convention. As you can see in the photo of me in front of the Bopp’s Bruder organ, I did my best to get in the spirit of things. The board meeting was productive and you’ll get the full details in the September/October Bulletin. Some highlights include clarification of who may attend AMICA conventions and the creation of the “Adopt A Piano Campaign”, spearheaded by Richard Reutlinger. This campaign will collect funds from chapters and individuals interested in restoring a player piano which is owned by a non-profit organization and is on public display (the collections in Virginia and Nevada City, Montana were first mentioned as potential sites for our attention). The restored instrument would carry a plaque listing the donors of funds. I also agreed to form an advisory group to help Robin review articles submitted for publication in the Bulletin and to search through vintage Bulletin issues for articles to be republished. Details on this committee should be finalized soon. Congratulations to Ginny and Robert Billings for the Leo Ornstein Literary Award, Janet and Richard Tonneson for the AMICA International Award, and Bill Knorp for the President’s Award. This is a small token of our appreciation for all you’ve done for AMICA. Two jobs remain unfilled, so I thought I’d list some of the duties in hopes that volunteers may be found to assume these duties. Memorial Fund: to receive and deposit donations and send acknowledgment notes to the survivors of the member being recognized. Judy Chisnell currently handles this duty and can provide answers to any of your questions about the position. Technicalities: to select and compile technical articles from Bulletin issues in prepartion for their republication (from issues published after Technicalities Volume VII). Terry Smythe has just completed Volume VII and can answer your questions on the topic. This is a volunteer organization and Judy and Terry have been generous in donating their time. Think about stepping forward and helping AMICA continue these important tasks. I’m already getting excited about Portland, Oregon in 2003. Stay tuned for details. Amicably, Dan Brown From the Publisher’s Desk
Hi There, Well, how often do you see a piano let alone a reproducing piano in a post card?!?! Art Reblitz sent his in some time ago and I have been waiting for a spot to place it. Unfortunately I never could find a really appropriate spot other than this one so here it is!
The original penned message is amusing: “Looking from living room thru hall dining room. “note the canned music.”
Wow, even then (whenever that was since there is no date on this picture)! If anyone has a clue a to where this was taken, please let us know. Or if you have a similar post card or photo, please share it with the other members. Thanks! Robin
135 CALENDAR OF EVENTS AMICA CHAPTER MEETINGS Memorial Fund Donations Founding/Sierra Nevada Chapter Please think of AMICA as a place to Saturday, September 7, 2002 at 1:30 pm at the home of John and remember your friends and family with a Nadine Motto-Ros, 110 Allen Ranch Road, Sutter Creek, CA. donation to the AMICA Memorial Fund. This will be a joint meeting and an afternoon BBQ. Contact John or Nadine at 209-267-9252 or Send to: [email protected] Judith Chisnell Heart of America Chapter 3945 Mission, Box 145 December, 2002 - Barbara and Doug Cusick will host the Rosebush, Michigan 48878-9718 annual Christmas meeting in Leawood, KS. 517-433-2992 May, 2003 - The Tulip Festival will be held in Pella, IA. [email protected] Ideal for monkey organs, but not big organs. Organized by the Railsbacks and Craigs. September, 2003 - Meeting in Branson, MO hosted by Billie & Bill Pohl.
Texas Chapter MBSI Sunbelt/AMICA Texas Chapter Band Organ Rally & Meeting Visit the at the Texas State Fair September 27th, 28th & 29th, 2002
~ AMICA August 20-24, 2003 AMICA Convention, Portland, Oregon Web page at Contact: Carl Dodrill 4488 W. Mercer Way Mercer Island, WA 98040 http://www.amica.org Phone (206) 236-0067 E-mail: [email protected]
DRAWINGS MADE WITH MUSICAL CHARACTERS.
1. The Piano Virtuoso 2. Paganini 3. The Primadonna 4. An Egyptian Musician 5. Scarlatti’s Cat 6. “The Flying Dutchman” 7. The Capellmeister 8. Napoleon
136 Letters…
Dear Editor, I read with keen interest Jeff Morgan’s Tech Tip on page 89 in the most recent issue of the AMICA Bulletin (May/June 2002). Most of his commentary concerns questionable (and inappropriate) technical material contained in the Heebner obituary appearing in the earlier March/April Bulletin. I am quite familiar with the Morgan articles referred to in Jeff’s piece and wish to go on record as being in complete agree- ment with what he says. Jeff’s two articles appearing on pages 81 and 83 in the March/April 2000 AMICA Bulletin are the most plausible and cogent explanation of the early Welte-Mignon recording process. It’s a shame that these two articles don’t enjoy wider circulation. Cordial regards, Larry Givens
CURT MANGEL APPOINTED CURATOR OF THE WANAMAKER ORGAN IN PHILADELPHIA By Robert Ridgeway Curt Mangel was appointed Curator of the famous Wanamaker Organ in the Grand Court at Lord & Taylor in Philadelphia in March 2002. Previous to his appointment, Mr. Mangel served as supervisor of the 8-person restoration facility of Jasper Sanfilippo in Barrington Hills, Illinois, a position he held for 11 years. During that time he used his considerable talents in the restoration of several million dollars worth of pipe organs, orchestrions, steam engines, clocks and arcade machines that constitute the bulk of the famous Sanfilippo Collection. In the early 1970s, Mr. Mangel spearheaded the saving of Shea’s Theatre in Buffalo, New York, and the restoration of its original Wurlitzer, including extensive fund-raising responsibilities. Later he did the same thing for the Paramount Theatre in Denver. He moved to Chicago and applied his knowledge and techniques for the historic Uptown Theatre. He restored the tower clock in the Pullman Building and the Waveland clock and carillon on the Chicago Lakefront. Through these clock and carillon restorations he became known to Jasper Sanfilippo, who hired him to restore several he was including in his museum. There, Mr. Mangel restored the 50 hp Spencer organ blower for the Sanfilippo instrument and the mechanical console lifts and controls. He is recognized as one of the leading organ-blower experts in the Nation. Sanfilippo curator Robert Ridgeway remarked, “A person who possesses all of the skills of a Curt Mangel is a rare individ- ual indeed, and our loss is certainly Philadelphia’s gain. The Wanamaker Grand Court Organ at Lord & Taylor couldn’t be in better hands. Curt’s mechanical and deductive-reasoning skills are the best I have ever encountered.” Also previous to his appointment at Lord & Taylor, Mr. Mangel headed the Friends of the Wanamaker Organ Symposium program, which brings the Nation’s top organ technicians to Philadelphia for a series of workshops on the fine art of historic- organ restoration. This program is continuing during his Lord & Taylor tenure.
Thanks! We extend our thanks to Larry and Jean Williams, hosts for our April Texas Chapter meeting. As usual, we had a wonderful visit and enjoyed music on the Ampico and Larry’s talk about the “Favorite Fifty” Ampico piano rolls. Texas Chapter
Dear Editor, This is to inform you that the hard drive on my computer at Keystone Music Rolls crashed in early July 2002. Because of this sad event, I have lost all emails sent to me from about June 15, 2002 forward. I have contacted my server and they are saving my emails from about July 15, 2002 onward until such time as I can get my computer up and running. Sincerely, Richard Groman, Keystone Music Rolls
137 Letters…
Memorial Fund Donation acknowledgements:
Our condolences to the families and friends of these AMICA members who have recently passed away and been honored with a donation to the Memorial Fund in their name:
Chester Kuharski of Monona, Wisconsin Phil McCoy of Santa Clara, California Jack Riffle of Ukiah, California John Schaller of Santa Barbara, California Bill Ullstrom of Port Orchard, Washington
Judy Chisnell, Memorial Fund Committee Chairman
Sent in by Robert M. Taylor
138 THE ECONOMIST MARCH 16, 2002 LeoLEO OrnsteinORNSTEIN Sent in by Robert M. Taylor
Leo Ornstein, a radical Composer, died on February 24, aged 108 or 109
In the 1920s had you asked a concert-goer who were the “At Twilight” was a typical title. Exactly when he joined the most innovative composers of the time, the names suggested “bad boys” of music, as they were called, is unclear. But within would probably have been Igor Stravinsky, Arnold Schoenberg a year or two his piano was suffering grievous bodily harm and Leo Ornstein. Some would have ranked Mr. Ornstein first. from such numbers as “Wild Men’s Dance”. His “Suicide in an Airplane”, a piano work, dazzled the critics. A biography published when Mr. Ornstein was a mere 26 This was music at the frontier of composition. Beyond it, said sought to suggest that there was something a bit unnatural about Mr. Ornstein threateningly, was chaos. He filled the concert his prodigious talent. halls of the United States, Europe and South America with To many he represents an evil musical genius sounds played with a frenzy that threatened to damage the wandering . . . in a weird no man’s land haunted mechanism of his piano, and left members of the audience in a with tortuous sound, with wails of futuristic state of shock. despair, with cubist shrieks and post-impressionist The 20-year period from say 1912, when Leo Ornstein, crises and crashes. He is the great anarch, the aged 20, began composing in a highly individual style, was iconoclast . . .His gospel is black heresy. perhaps the most creative of the 20th century. Stravinsky’s Such invention brought in the crowds but in fact he was a “Rite of Spring” burst into life in 1913. Schoenberg first used remarkably balanced man, with a stable family life and a his 12-tone technique in an entire work in his suite for piano in marriage that lasted for 67 years. In a memoir his daughter 1923. In the visual arts Marcel Duchamp’s “Fountain”, a urinal, described Mr. Ornstein’s liking for the countryside, how he established in 1917 “readymade” art, which continues to be enjoyed climbing mountains and how the family grew their own practiced, especially in Britain. By the 1920s Picasso’s “Les food. Whether all this contributed to his astonishing longevity Demoiselles d’Avignon” had become the driving force is anyone’s guess. He was healthy with it. Our photograph was behind cubism, although painted much earlier. “Ulysses” was taken shortly after his 103rd birthday; or it might have been his published in Europe in 1922. Painting, literature and music 104th. The year of his birth is in dispute. His wife Pauline, also were seen to belong together. Mr. Ornstein’s furious music was an accomplished pianist, lived to 91. compared to Futurism, the name given to the painting and His decision to abandon the public stage had a rationale writing of an Italian group that aimed to glorify the machine. too. The constant traveling from concert to concert, the In the 1930s Mr. Ornstein ended his public performances relentless need to practice amounted to a kind of tyranny. and was hardly heard of again. A good thing too, some said. Mr. Mr. Ornstein became suspicious of the fragility of fame. If his Ornstein’s music was of “insufferable hideousness”, according music has any value, he told a reporter, it will be picked up and to one critic. The excitement of the previous decades for new played. “If it has no value, it deserves its neglect.” In 1935 he sounds seemed to have died. If the avant-garde was still heard and Pauline founded a school of music in Philadelphia and ran in the concert hall, the programme would be sugared with it for more than 20 years. Mozart and Beethoven. The music-loving public decided that In the 1970s Leo Ornstein was not exactly rediscovered, after all it didn’t really love Mr. Ornstein and his contemporary but he was re-noticed. He received a number of honorary composers, although what they did was undoubtedly clever. doctorates. The early biography was reprinted. The manuscripts ONE OF THE BAD BOYS of some of his compositions were deposited at Yale. It turned Leo Ornstein’s cleverness apparently became evident at the out that he was still composing. Enthusiasts recorded some of age of three when he started to learn the piano. There was his pieces. America was going through one of its periodic bouts music in the family. His father was the cantor in his local of nationalism about its culture. It is not entirely content that it synagogue in St. Petersburg. At ten Leo was admitted to the St. gave birth to jazz and that its magical popular composers, Petersburg Conservatory and became a pupil of Alexander Gershwin, Berlin, Kern, Porter and so on, produced melodies to Glazunov, a much admired composer of the time. But Jews rival Schubert’s. Mr. Ornstein produced a body of work that were suffering in tsarist Russia, partly because they were included a violin sonata, several string quartets and a piano associated with revolutionary forces, and in 1907, when Leo concerto. You may not hear a lot of his music these days, but was 14, the family moved to New York. He gave his first public no one doubts that it is high art. recital at 18. It was a conventional debut, with pieces by Chopin and Bach. His earliest compositions were far from alarming.
139 THE NEW YORK TIMES MAY 12, 2002 PeoplePEOPLE By Daphne Sashin A Tale of Requited Love: A Man and a Pipe Organ
Keith Bigger has been restoring the This is a love story about a man instrument at the Baptist Temple for and a pipe organ. The man, Keith 15 years. To save time, he even sleeps Bigger, 55, has worked for the phone at the church company since he was 22. In warmer weather, his uniform is a short-sleeved the church. One night, he saw a button-down shirt and Sears trousers. mattress propped up against the wall. He carries a beeper and two bundles He realized that he could accomplish of keys, including ones to the Baptist more if he slept there. Mr. Bigger, who Temple in Boerum Hill, Brooklyn. “had some girlfriends way back” but never married, has been living near the In that temple, in 1951, the 5-year organ ever since. old Keith first saw the 2,533-pipe J.W. Steere & Son organ, built in 1918. He Six nights a week, Mr. Bigger had sneaked into the empty sanctuary sleeps on a cot next to one of the during the annual church supper, and organ chambers. On Saturdays, he in the dim light, he saw the brass drives his Buick Le Sabre – license pipes glimmering in the distance. plate JWSTEERE – to his childhood home in Cambria Heights, Queens, It took 36 years for him to return. which he shares with his brother, to do And as it turned out, Mr. Bigger his laundry. ended up rebuilding that organ – the restoration is in its 15th year – and Photographs by Barton Silverman/The New York Times After 15 years, the restoration moving into the church to do it. continues. Into the church, Mr. Bigger has moved a microwave oven and a His love for the instrument goes back to his childhood. bookcase’s worth of organ-building books. He keeps an When he arrived at Thomas Edison Vocational High, he started anteroom stocked with canisters of bow-tie noodles and a taking organ lessons at a nearby church. When he was 22, jumbo-sized bottle of Hershey’s chocolate syrup. He will move he spent two years building his own organ in his family’s out if anyone asks, but no one has suggested it. basement. The organ was in playable condition by 1991, but Mr. In 1987, he met a couple who belonged to the Baptist Bigger continues to do repairs on the instrument and anything Temple, where he had seen those gleaming pipes, and made else that needs fixing. “What’s the sense of fixing the organ if some inquiries. He learned that the congregation had dwindled, the roof leaks?” he said. the roof leaked and only three of the five keyboards were playing. Few current church members had even heard the He patches leaks in the roof. He automated the heating instrument. system. He changed the lights in the chandeliers to long-life fluorescents. Mr. Bigger volunteered to restore the organ – the church would have to pay for parts only – and the longtime church Mr. Bigger says he may go home someday, but for a administrator, Arthur Norregaard, happily agreed. complete restoration, the organ’s pedal board still needs to be restored and every bit of leather must be replaced. “It’s his “We said, ‘Go!’” Mr. Norregaard said. “It’s a beautiful lifework,” said Betsy Mitchell, a church member. “Some people organ, one of the finest-sounding organs around.” never find their lifework.” Two years into the restoration, Mr. Bigger, then on strike from the phone company, was spending more and more time at
140 GRAND VALLEY HISTORY VOLUME 18,2001 PeoplePEOPLE By Lee Barnett Sent in by Bill Burkhart Max Kortlander: King of the Player Piano
Not a film star or a sports figure or a His mother guided Max as he practiced for military hero or a politician, player-piano hours every week on one of the family’s quartet impresario Max Kortlander was nevertheless of instruments. As he progressed, she also a celebrity in Grand Rapids, a local boy who insisted that he write at least two songs a day. made good but never severed his hometown ties. While Max did not particularly care for the long A talented pianist as a child, Kortlander became practice sessions that took him away from more a highly regarded performer and composer. typical boyhood pursuits, he did enjoy music Later, at a time when player pianos were at the composition, a gift that would serve him well as height of their popularity, Kortlander worked an adult. Though he was brought up in an and performed for the QRS Music Company of environment that favored classical music, by the Chicago, the nation’s largest and most successful age of 14 he was playing popular songs player-piano-roll manufacturer. Despite his and performing at an assortment of places success, Kortlander retained his Grand Rapids around town. connections and returned regularly to visit After his graduation from Central High family and friends in his hometown. Today, the School, Kortlander further enhanced his skills Kortlander family residence still stands on by enrolling for a year at the Oberlin College Cherry Street, and the family cottage on Beach Conservatory in Ohio for specialized music Drive in Spring Lake remains in the hands of courses and then attending the American 1 Max Kortlander was, during his Kortlander’s relatives. lifetime, a well-known composer Conservatory in Chicago for advanced piano Maximillian (Max) Kortlander was born in and performer of player-piano lessons. While in Chicago, Max helped to the Kortlander family home at 614 Cherry SE on music who ultimately headed the support himself by entertaining at upscale world’s largest maker and distrib- September 1, 1890. His father, Joseph, was an utor of piano rolls. (Unless other- supper clubs. It may have been in this capacity Indiana native who had relocated to Grand wise noted, all illustrations are that he met the vice president of the QRS Music Rapids in 1864, and his mother, the former courtesy of William Burkhardt.) Company, a major manufacturer of piano rolls Elizabeth M. Boxheimer, was the daughter of founded in 1900 and headquartered in the pioneer Grand Rapids residents. Max was their Windy City. Soon, he was hard at work third child, and first son, in four years of arranging and playing piano-roll recordings. marriage. The Kortlanders were a well-known As historians reflect upon the last century, Grand Rapids family. Joseph initially owned a they will almost surely conclude that one of the barrel factory, and in 1884 he and his three marvels it produced was the player piano. This brothers formed the Kortlander Company, a remarkable device – by the imaginative use of wholesale liquor business operating out of the sprockets, spools, shafts and springs – has Kortlander Building at Fulton Street and astounded and amused the world for a hundred Commerce Avenue. One of the brothers, years and has, literally and figuratively, let the William, was also a local artist of note. good times roll. Prior to the invention of the Max Kortlander showed promising player apparatus, years of lessons and practice musical talent at a very young age. That he were usually required to coax pleasing sounds would manifest such skills is not surprising, from a piano. But with the creation of this since his mother was a leader in the city’s mechanical device, no music education or musical life. She was a singer of recognized formal training was necessary to pump the ability, an active member of the St. Cecilia pedals and produce the music. Society, and she, her three sisters, and an aunt One of the most important elements of the were all piano teachers at various times. With player piano is the piano roll, a cylinder core four Mason & Hamlin grand pianos in the Slots of varying lengths in the roll holding a strip of paper about 11 inches wide Kortlander home, Max was destined by determined the notes and how long and 25 feet long. The paper has holes or slots circumstances if not by inheritance to be a they were were played on a player piano. punched into it, each one corresponding to a keyboard artist.
141 particular note. After the notes from sheet the appropriate background music. But the music or an artist’s performance are debut of talking films in 1927 created a properly translated into the holes or slots on sensation, and many people left their player the strip of paper, the roll can be passed over pianos to enjoy the cinema with sound. the player mechanism by pumping the The third new ruler of recreation was the pedals, and the piano reproduces the song, record player. Gramophones and acoustic making every player-piano owner a maestro reproductions had been around for some in his own home. years, but with cranking required for Initially, piano rolls offered only operation and generally poor sound instrumental music, but the industry soon quality, they remained short of their began featuring the popular songs of potential. When the nicely styled, the day, making listeners want to sing electrically amplified phonograph appeared along while they played. Since not in the mid-1920s – offering full orchestras everyone knew the lyrics to these tunes, the and vocalists on shellac disks – the owners manufacturers began putting the words of player pianos abandoned their solo along the margins of the rolls at the point instruments and listened to someone else do where they were to be sung, much like the singing. words on a TelePrompTer. When the Great Depression began just a Although simple in design and fairly few years later, few people any longer had easy to produce, the first piano rolls were discretionary income for purchasing pianos not cheap. With initial prices set at around a or music rolls. This turn of events was This diagram shows how a player piano dollar apiece, the purchase of a single roll works. When the foot pedals are pumped, a fatal blow to many in the player-piano once consumed half a day’s wages for the the air in the chamber labeled (A) is drawn business and helped finish off the instrument average worker. Currently a roll costs about out, creating a vacuum. When a perforation as a favorite source of listening pleasure or a $11 new, or just one hour’s salary for the in the piano roll passes over the opening in required accessory in any well-appointed typical worker. the tracker bar (B) air rushes into the tube residential parlor. (C) and inflates the leather bag (D). As the There was a time in America when no inflated bag rises it lifts a valve (E) which, Max Kortlander and the QRS Company home could be considered complete without in turn, closes the opening above it (F) and likewise felt the impact of the failing a player piano. In the heyday of this craze, opens a small port (G) that connects a small economy. QRS started out in 1900 as bellows with the vacuum chamber. Vacuum one in four American homes had a player from the chamber collapses the bellows a small, owner-operated enterprise with piano, and the instrument was the supreme causing its lower, moveable side or leaf to a few employees. Over the years, however, form of home entertainment. People all collapse and rise. The leaf is attached to the firm bought up about 25 other across the land gathered around player piano action (J) and the note is played. companies and became the largest piano pianos to listen to the characteristic sounds (QRS Company Diagram) roll factory in the world, with manufacturing that helped add to the English language such plants in the United States, Canada, words as “ricky-tick,” “rinky-tink,” “plinkity-plink,” and Europe, and Australia. “honky-tonk.” From the early 1900s to the closing days of the During its halcyon days, the company employed the Roaring Twenties, 2.5 million player pianos were sold, services of some of the leading pianists in the field of popular with peak sales of 200,000 in 1923. So great was the demand music. In its stable of piano roll artists were such legends as that from approximately 1910 through 1925 an amazing Victor Arden, Zez Confrey, J. Lawrence Cook, Lee S. Roberts, 85 percent of all pianos made in the United States were said to Thomas “Fats” Waller, and Pete Wendling. Together, these and be automated. other talented individuals on the staff turned out 25 to 50 new The popularity of the player piano fell off markedly songs per month, giving hours of listening pleasure to people beginning in 1927. This sudden reversal was due to the around the globe. emergence of three new kings in the world of entertainment. Max Kortlander had begun cutting rolls for QRS in about The first of these upstart lords of leisure was radio, which 1916, and over the next ten years he arranged and performed became available in 1921. By 1926 a plug-in version was more than a thousand different scores for the company. He introduced, radio networks were formed, and people began quickly became one of the hot names in piano roll sales, with flocking to a medium that allowed them to listen to a wider many fans buying his rolls not only for the melodies but for his variety of music and other programs at less cost and without playing style, an energetic and embellished technique that did even pumping pedals. In a sense, the nation turned from the much to define the piano-roll sound for the ensuing decade. bellows in pianos to windbags on the air. Kortlander also released rolls under the pseudonyms of Ted The second of the new sovereigns of spare time was Baxter and Jeff Watters, using the fictitious names when he movies. Motion pictures had been in existence for many years accompanied himself in a mechanically contrived, four-hand as silent films, and piano rolls had even been cut to accompany arrangement and thus needed to list a second performer in the them for those theaters that did not have a live pianist to create duet, or when he produced songs that were considered
142 QRS piano roll box labels increasing interest in the player piano as well as the rolls picture the well-known that made it work. In the 1950s he helped fund the development tunes, performers, and of the player spinet, an instrument that could be played composers who were associated with the either manually or automatically and eventually debuted in company in its New York City in 1957 under the name of the Hardman Duo heyday. Piano. Today, many firms make sophisticated electronic versions of the player piano, and one company – Classic objectionable in some Player Piano of Seneca, Pennsylvania – still manufactures an quarters because old-fashioned, paper-roll-playing model under the famous they were written by brand name of Story & Clark. or associated with With a resurgence in the sales of player pianos and rolls as African Americans. the 1960s began, Max’s prospects looked bright. But his While Max was enjoyment of this revival was cut short on October 11, 1961, turning out large when he died while working in his Bronx office. His wife, who numbers of piano rolls, he was also actively writing songs. inherited the business, hired Max’s brother, Herman, to run the ASCAP listings and other records show that between 1917 and operation. Five years later, she sold the firm, and its operations 1940 he composed about sixty-five melodies, including such were moved to its present location at 1026 Niagara Street in well-received titles as “Any Time, Any Day, Any Where” and Buffalo, New York. Known today as QRS Music, the company “Bebe-D” (dedicated to Bebe Daniels, a Grand Rapids native continues to be the largest of its kind on the planet, with current and former Hollywood musical comedy and film star). His sales of about 300,000 rolls annually. Each year thousands of 1919 fox trot “Tell Me” sold for $100,000, the highest lump people visit the QRS factory to see how piano rolls are made. sum paid for any popular song up to that time. The original roll-cutting machine is still used, and in 1992 the But as Max worked his way up in the QRS Company, his American Society of Mechanical Engineers designated the QRS creative time was sacrificed to his management responsibilities. Music Company a National Historic Mechanical Engineering Shortly after World War I, he was made general manager of the Landmark. 2 firm’s recording laboratories in New York City where the rolls After running his brother’s company successfully until it were cut, and by 1926 his administrative duties had grown to was sold, Herman Kortlander eventually returned to his Grand the point where he personally produced no more rolls. Rapids hometown. His death in July of 1987 brought to a close In 1927, the QRS Music Company sold a reported a long chapter in which a man from Grand Rapids dominated 10 million rolls, its greatest output ever. Not long afterwards the the piano roll industry. bottom fell out of the economy and the firm began edging towards bankruptcy. Seeking to save the enterprise from its About the Author impending demise, Max Kortlander mortgaged his home in 1931 and bought the now-struggling firm, changing its name to Lee Barnett recently Imperial Industrial Corporation because with a name like that retired from his post with he could easily go into some other business if he was unable to the state archives and now continue selling piano rolls. In fact, the company rode out the devotes his time to research long drought in piano roll orders during the depression by also and writing about Michigan making paper rolls for automatic office equipment. history. World War II saw a brief increase in the demand for QRS music products as a flurry of patriotic songs and full employment got people in the singing and spending mood again. But the advent of television shortly after the war saw the market for piano rolls again decline, with the lowest point in sales occurring in 1952. This 1920s QRS Company In part through the efforts of Max Kortlander, this trend advertisement emphasized the was reversed and the firm’s bottom line slowly became healthy stylishness and ease of player- again. Retaining the QRS brand name, Max eventually returned piano entertainment. (QRS the company to profitability. He was careful to produce piano Company photograph) rolls that included contemporary popular tunes along with old-time favorites, thus always having ready for sale the songs and musical styles the public wanted to hear. His success was Notes also attributable to his arranger of many years, J. Lawrence 1. The author wishes to acknowledge the help of player-piano expert Cook, one of America’s great black keyboard technicians and Bill Burkhardt of Grand Rapids in preparing this article. the creator of more piano rolls than any other artist. 2. Anyone seeking additional information about QRS or its products Max knew that his company’s prospects depended upon should call 1-800-24ROLLS or go to its website at www.qrsmusic.com.
143 SONGS COMPOSED BY MAX KORTLANDER (Entirely or in Collaboration With Others)
Ragtime Sailor Man ...... 1917 I Hate to Think What Would Happen to Me ...... 1924 Drop Me Down in Dixieland ...... 1918 I’m a good Gal, But I’m a Thousand Miles From Home .1924 Look Out for the Melody Moon ...... 1918 Rose of Old Madrid ...... 1924 Why Shouldn’t Old King Solomon Get the Blues ...... 1918 Lover’s Waltz ...... 1925 Along the Moonlit Way ...... 1919 Ain’t I Got Rosie ...... 1926 Bigamous Blues ...... 1919 I’ll Look to the West ...... 1926 Some Day You’ll Know ...... 1919 Scatter Your Smiles ...... 1926 Tell Me Why the Nights Are Lonesome ...... 1919 To Be With You ...... 1926 Any Time, Any Day, Any Where ...... 1920 Trying to Keep Away From You ...... 1926 As We Live and Love We Learn ...... 1920 What Cha Call Em Blues ...... 1926 Blue Clover Man ...... 1920 I’m Longing for My Old Gal Sal ...... 1927 Hot Tamale Mollie ...... 1920 Mississippi Flood Song ...... 1927 Like We Used to Be ...... 1920 What Are We Waiting For ...... 1927 Bebe-D ...... 1921 Whatever You Say ...... 1927 In Santa Barbara ...... 1921 Always in My Dreams, Never in My Arms ...... 1928 I’ve Lost My Heart to the Meanest Gal in Town ...... 1921 Felix the Cat ...... 1928 Sleepy Eyes ...... 1921 When You Give Your Smile to Someone Else ...... 1928 Bygones ...... 1922 She’s My Girl (Oh What a Difference That Makes) . . . . .1929 Eeny Meeny Chinee Mo ...... 1922 Why Do You Give Your Smiles to Someone Else ...... 1929 Hunting the Ball Rag ...... 1922 I Thank You Mr. Moon ...... 1931 Pleasant Dreams ...... 1922 Lullaby Lady ...... 1933 The Sun Will Soon Be Shining ...... 1922 Moonlight Down in Lover’s Lane ...... 1933 Too Many Kisses Mean Too Many Tears ...... 1922 If You Love Me, Say So ...... 1934 Whenever You’re Lonesome Just Telephone Me ...... 1922 I’m the One Who Loves You ...... 1937 Deuces Wild ...... 1923 Something to Live For ...... 1940 Gee, I’ll Miss You When You’re Gone ...... 1923 Papa’s Blues ...... 1923 Undated Red Clover ...... 1923 Funeral Rag Red Moon ...... 1923 Let’s Try It Shimmie Shoes ...... 1923 Li’l Joe Some Winter’s Night ...... 1923 Tantalizin’ Mamma ...... 1923
Butterfingers ...... 1924 Max Kortlander’s best-known composition, “Tell Me,” was a Home for the Rest of My Life ...... 1924 popular piano roll and sold Hottentot Trot ...... 1924 well as sheet music.
144 THEATRE ORGAN MAGAZINE JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2002 POSITIVEEnormousCONSEQUENCES By Robert Ridgeway
February 4, 2002
Enclosed is a copy of the January/February 2002 issue of Theatre Organ Magazine for you. There is, beginning on page 46, an article I wrote about the Symphonic Organ Society Symposium and the work they have accomplished on the Grand Court Organ at Lord and Taylor in Philadelphia. Since this was all the brainchild of my most worthy col- league, Curt Mangel, I wanted to make sure he got proper acknowledgement for his hard work. I hope you will enjoy having this magazine to chronicle how this all began and to reflect upon how far the instrument has come in the past few years. The best years of this magnifi- cent pipe organ are yet to come. Daniel Burnam designed organ case in the Grand Court of Lord & Warmest personal regards, Taylor with the three string chamber shutter openings above Robert (shades have been reinstalled).
How A Small Event Can Have Enormous Positive Consequences
Several years ago the Joliet Area Theatre Organ Enthusiasts week of their time toward working on the Wanamaker organ at (JATOE) www.jatoe.org sponsored an organ trip, as they do Lord and Taylor. He got only positive responses from these men every couple of years, so the participants could see and hear who realized that this national treasure must not be allowed to pipe organs in other parts of the country. This particular year it deteriorate. Curt then dispatched a letter to the New York main was to the East Coast, taking in the Wanamaker Grand Court offices of Lord and Taylor outlining this offer of free help Organ at Lord and Taylor in Philadelphia, Longwood Gardens for one week on the organ. Lord and Taylor immediately in Kennett Square, and Dickinson High School in Wilmington, recognized the value of this offer and agreed wholeheartedly. Delaware. Among the group was Jim Stemke, the JATOE The fine organization, The Friends of the Wanamaker President (a long-time ATOS member and an ATOS Director) Organ, www.wanamakerorgan.com was able to raise donations and Curt Mangel, the Supervisor of the Sanfilippo Restoration of hotel rooms and meals so no technician would be Shop and co-curator of the Sanfilippo 5/80 Wurlitzer. Curt has out-of-pocket except for their travel. The group was devised as been involved in ATOS since he personally spearheaded the The Symphonic Organ Society, a symposium where all these saving of the Shea’s Buffalo Theatre www.sheas.org and the various men could show their special skills to each other and restoration of its magnificent 4/28 Wurlitzer as well as his enhance each other’s knowledge while performing essential subsequent efforts in behalf of the Denver Paramount and its tasks to restore large portions of the organ that had begun to twin-consoled Wurlitzer. fail. The symposium idea was so successful that it was repeated This trip would radically change the course of their lives for a week the following year and now is restructured to at least and of the musical scene of America. They discovered that the one long weekend every month. Organ men from all around this Grand Court Organ was in a dire state of repairs. Even though country (and even from France) have gathered to releather the store has had two full-time curators for years, the scale of pouches, replace armatures, repair broken pipework, regulate the instrument and the fact that, because of its age, nearly all of ranks that have been out of service for years, and steadily bring the replaceable components were wearing out at the same time. enormous portions of the instrument back to full voice. The This would make it difficult for even veteran pipe organ Symposium has been a daunting proposition to coordinate and technicians to stay ahead of the maintenance. organize but Curt Mangel and Jim Stemke have been on track When Curt Mangel returned to Barrington Hills, he with this effort since the beginning. Lord and Taylor is the first formulated in his mind a wonderful solution to this problem. He owner of the store in years and years to recognize what a contacted many fine professional organ technicians around the treasure they have and they are more than willing to expend the country and asked them if they would be willing to donate a funds necessary to get major tasks accomplished. Curt is their
145 First year Symposium participants in front of the center swell openings on the fourth-floor string division. With all the shutters removed for servicing you can see the scale of this chamber which contains 88 ranks of Kimball strings restoration consultant, working closely with Patrick Hamilton, L & T Head of engineering, and Arthur Snoznick, L & T Vice President of Planning and Development, from New York. Curt travels to Philadelphia one weekend a month and consults with the Grand Court Organist, Peter Richard Conte, about what problems need attention. He then meets with the curatorial staff to make sure everyone is working toward these same goals. The first Symposium concentrated on the famous String Division. All 48 swell shades were removed and new bushings and bearings installed top and bottom throughout. Also patching plates were mounted on the interior sides of the shades where major splitting had developed over the years. Where necessary, swell motors and bumper pneumatics were recovered in the organ shop on professional progress on the organ immeasurably; these include the second floor of the store. The armatures for the magnets people such as: Sam Hughes, Peter Bachelder, John Adams, were all cleaned and recovered with a thin punching of leather and Bill Czelusniak (an ATOS member), among others. The on one side and a slightly heavier punching on the other. This interchange of ideas and techniques among these individuals is allowed the chest magnets to seal properly and not be held exciting and informative at all times. Every work session on by residual magnetism. The participants for this first increases everyone’s knowledge and the organ keeps getting Symposium read like a who’s-who in the pipe organ craft. Ohio better and better. organbuilder Charles Kegg (ATOS member and restorer of the For those of you who may not have been in the Grand Kilgen theatre organ in the Canton Palace Theatre) and veteran Court and heard the organ in many years, the new acoustic will Pennsylvania organ expert Brantley Duddy (former ATOS be a revelation to you. Because the actual Wanamaker building National Board member) were involved. Terry Kleven and Bob is now owned by an outside company and Lord & Taylor only Swaney (long-time ATOS members) came from Minneapolis. lease the first three floors (and the entire Grand Court), the From the Chicago area Robert Ridgeway, Curt Mangel, Jim upper four floors have been converted to office space and Gruber, and Jim Stemke donated their time and efforts. Nelson double plate glass windows have been installed which look Barden and Sean O’Donnell came from the Boston area. By the down into this vast space. The result is an unexpected benefit to end of this first Symposium the entire String Division worked the organ in the form of a 3.5-second reverberation time. flawlessly. For those who may have forgotten the statistics on that particular division, it was built for the Wanamaker Organ One of the major problems plaguing the Wanamaker Organ by Kimball and contains in one chamber 88 ranks of string, since its installation has been the dryness of the store in the including two 32’ stops. Included with this article is a winter months, which render whole sections unplayable. This photograph of the Symposium group and the Grand Court was caused by two major factors: one, the chest bottom boards Organ curators sitting on the front ledge of the fourth floor just fasten directly to the chests with machine screws and washers outside the String Division while all the swell shades have been and never had any compression springs to adjust the tightness removed for the bearing work. You can get some perspective on during humidity changes, and second, there was no decent way the scale of this endeavor from that photograph. to humidify the entire instrument in the winter. The second Symposium solved the first problem by installing nearly The second (and last) week-long Symposium featured 15,000 new (and longer) machine screws and washers with some new additions to the group including Olivier Glandaz compression springs on the chest bottom boards. The second from France, Mike Rider, Michael Madeira, Timothy Patterson, problem was solved by careful analysis by Curt Mangel. Up John Mussina, Larry Trupiano, Patrick Murphy, Carl Loeser, until this time, seven organ blowers had spray nozzles forcing Bard Wickkiser, Bob Lockridge, and Wayne Becker. Providing streams of water directly into their intakes. This was additional assistance were several valuable Friends of the unsatisfactory for several reasons. First it only supplied moist- Wanamaker Organ including Ray Biswanger, Wally McLean, ened air to the organ while it was playing and second it was Stephen Ross, Ben Epstein, and Rudy Lucente. Since the beginning to rust the blower fans and cage. Curt had been second Symposium many august names in the organ field have friends with Mike Coup of Wichita for many years and knew been added to the monthly efforts and this has increased the that he humidified his pipe organ with a swamp cooler, which is
146 basically a large box with evaporative period of months with Larry pads on all sides which water flows Kerecman and Curt Mangel working down all the time. A fan in the together. The scope of the lighting for swamp cooler sends this massively this animated show is staggering . . . it humidified air into the various blower requires 2600 amperes of three-phase rooms as it is called for. The solution electricity to power the entire that Curt arrived at for the program. At the same time, the curtain humidification of the organ all the backdrop was designed not to block time was even more ingenious. Since the famous Daniel Burnham-designed the organ has a mixture of ventil and organ case of the organ. Then Lord Pittman chests, wherein the air is cut and Taylor further engaged Larry off to the various ranks except when Kerecman to design and install they are being called for, there was no Symposium participants in the center of the world’s permanent programmable spotlights largest string division. Kneeling in front is Curt Mangel, way to have air flow through all the Symposium Organizer and Lord & Taylor Restoration for the entire façade that can be chests. The problem was solved by Consultant. Back row from left: Peter VanderSpek ( changed in color and intensity constructing a 1” valve similar to a former Grand Court Organ Curator), Sean O’Donnell, automatically or from the organ Reisner or Wicks chest magnet Brant Duddy, Robert Ridgeway, Jim Stemke, Charles console by the organist. The final without the coil and drilling a Kegg, Bob Swaney, Sam Whitcraft (assistant Curator), touch to the package was the and Terry Kleven. 3/4”hole on the bottom boards of all revamping of this computerized show the chests where these Pittman with its pre-recorded music and actions are located. The spring on this valve is light enough that narrative soundtrack. Now, instead of the finale being an when the organ is turned off it falls open. When the organ anemic rendition of a Christmas Carol through small blowers are started the pressure of the air in the manifolds is loudspeakers while the illuminated figures flash, the entire more-than-sufficient to close these valves. The second organ is played at a volume never ordinarily used during store requirement was achieved with the co-operation of the hours with the crowds jumping to their feet in approval. The management of Lord and Taylor who was willing to make the incorporation of the organ into this Philadelphia holiday expenditure for all new solid-state variable frequency drives for tradition now absolutely insures that hundreds of thousands of ALL the blowers (including the enormous 60 hp Spencer). people are exposed to this greatest musical marvel throughout There are humidity sensors in all the chambers sending the season. With shows every hour on the hour, people who information back to their respective blower rooms. If the chests have never experienced the excitement of the Grand Court need humidity the system turns on the swamp cooler and starts Organ are now able to appreciate what all the fuss is about. An up the blower at only 100 r.p.m. This is hardly perceptible but entirely new generation of audience members is being exposed quite sufficient to send this moist air throughout all the chests to organ music and that can only be good news for the and chambers. This past winter was the first time that the entire instrument and our hobby. Who would have thought that operable parts of the organ could be played even when the an innocent field trip would lead to such an important humidity in the store was quite low. Various organ builders transformation? from around the country are now looking at Curt’s solution for The most recent exciting news to emerge from Philadelphia some of their more problematic organ installations. is the spectacular recording project undertaken this past June. The next giant challenge was to revamp the entire Peter Richard Conte is the finest Grand Court Organist to grace Christmas Show that has been a Grand Court tradition in the bench in the history of the store. His transcriptions and Philadelphia for decades. The original show was suspended musicianship are of the highest standards. There has been no from a catwalk on the sixth floor and secured in front of a high quality professional recording made of this instrument heavy velour curtain that obscured the entire organ. Since the since the famous Virgil Fox Command Records release in 1964. organ is played twice each and every day (11:15 to noon and Dorian Records of Troy, New York (www.dorian.com) changed 5:15 to 6 p.m.), the muffling of the organ for the two months that significantly with their efforts for three weeks in June. The that this show was in place was a disaster. Fortunately, Lord and Dorian recording session is certain to make history, in that two Taylor wanted to replace all the lighting and sequencing separate high-resolution formats were recorded simultaneously. controls for this elaborate light show and asked Curt if he could The PCM recording was mastered in four channels of 24-bit, suggest someone. He immediately contacted Larry Kerecman in 176.4khz, and the Sony DSD (Direct Stream Digital) format Colorado, who is an engineer specializing in computerized that produces the SACD (Super Audio Compact Disc) was also lighting and control systems AND is a long-time organ mastered in four channels. This now allows Dorian the supporter beginning with his days at Cornell, and thus sensitive flexibility to release this recording in various formats. Curt to the dual requirements of the Christmas Show and the organ Mangel handled the rigging of thousands of feet of aircraft being heard. The decision was made to replace all the rigging cable for the microphones in the nearly 150’ high Grand Court and the entire front curtain that forms the backdrop for the to permit the capture of the true sonic beauty of the instrument show. A new acoustically transparent fabric curtain was in the best position possible. Jim Stemke, a nationally known installed and the new Christmas Show was created over a recording engineer in his own right, assisted in the nightly recording sessions. Custom built microphone electronics,
147 Pacific Microsonics HDCD converters, and custom fiber optic and tinkerers because they will have to equipment was used to send the signals back to the third floor take up the burden when we are gone. in-store studio over 500’ away. The anticipated release date for Look around your community and this new recording is November 2001. Watch for this new see how your efforts can make a recording, called MAGIC, featuring Peter Richard Conte in a difference. All it takes is a vision and spectacular sound never heard before. I had the privilege of persistence and all of us can make a hearing some of the session playback through Dorian’s positive change in our world. multi-thousands of dollars worth of equipment and I was stunned by the quality and I have been recording organ music professionally for over 35 years and I can recognize the *Robert Ridgeway has been a member of ATOS (American Theatre Grand Court Organist, fantastic from the merely good. The fact that this material was Peter Richard Conte, recorded in the two major up-and-coming formats bodes well Organ Society) [then ATOE] since at the six-manual because no matter what eventually wins out in the marketplace, 1962. He founded the Central Ohio Wanamaker console. Dorian will be ready for it. The listening public, eager for Chapter of ATOS and was involved impressive material to play on their new home theatre and with the removal and initial restoration surround systems will buy this disc for its sonic impact and of the RKO Albee 3/19 Wurlitzer in quite possibly become converts to the world of organ music, Cincinnati. He has been a recording and sound engineer since much as the world of stereo was transformed through the early the late ‘60s and has dozens of albums to his credit. He was recordings by George Wright. We shall never know how many part of the installation and restoration team for the Sanfilippo people were influenced into our hobby as a result of hearing project and personally wired the entire Sanfilippo 5/80 Wurl- excellent organ albums. itzer. He has been the Curator of the Sanfilippo Collection in Barrington Hills, Illinois for nearly ten years, overseeing not This article was written to enlighten the readers to another only the largest theatre organ in the world but one of the largest world beyond theatre organ. The Wanamaker Grand Court collections of automatic musical instruments in the world. Organ at Lord and Taylor in Philadelphia is the largest and most Because of the large number of charity events that are held at magnificent musical machine ever built and deserves the the Sanfilippo Estate throughout each and every year, the the- attention and respect of our members. It was further written to atre organ is exposed to thousands of new listeners all the time emphasize how any of us may contribute to our musical world and hopefully ensuring an audience for generations to come. and effect great changes in it if we are observant and focused. We certainly do not want this to be the last generation to enjoy the theatre organ. We have to encourage our younger players
Sent in by Jeffrey Morgan
148 149 THEWelte-MignonEARLY WELTE-MIGNON
By Jeffrey Morgan The Early Welte-Mignon Recording Process Q & A
In my two previous articles (AMICA Bulletin, March/April undersides of the piano keys is a certainty if this early system 2000, pp. 81 & 83) about the early Welte-Mignon recording was to yield acceptable readings of dynamics. process, I critiqued Ben Hall’s faulty description of it, In fact, the choice of a carbon-rod-mercury-trough contact which was first published in a booklet accompanying the system gives yet another clue as to how this seemingly “Welte Legacy of Piano Treasures” recordings. More recently, primitive apparatus could give reasonably good indication of Hall’s description was reprinted in Bowers’ Encyclopedia dynamic intensity. Remember that such a contact system would (p. 327). While much of his presentation of this process is be quite cumbersome and expensive as opposed to a simple problematic and most likely stems from his imperfect phosphor-bronze contact system commonly available ca. 1904. understanding of technology, some of what he relates should be taken as true. What follows is a slightly different approach to the veracity of the early Welte-Mignon recording process and how it could, One aspect he describes that can be taken at face value is indeed, have worked – but not the way Hall says it did. the carbon-rod-mercury-trough contact system. Presumably, this contact system was described to Hall by the late Richard C. Simonton who, in turn, had it explained to him by both Edwin Q. What could the cumbersome, elegant and expensive Welte and Karl Bockisch. Moreover, surviving photographs of carbon-rod-mercury-trough contact system (as utilized by the early Welte-Mignon recording equipment strongly support the early Welte-Mignon recording process) accomplish that the existence of a mercury trough. simple phosphor-bronze contacts couldn’t? Almost as soon as Hall’s dubious presentation appeared A. Handle LARGE amounts of current continuously with (ca. 1963), the need to paper over the more glaring weak spots near-ideal heat dissipation. (e.g., “The harder the artist hit the key of the piano, the deeper the carbon rod would plunge into the mercury . . .”) became apparent. Various hypotheses were concocted. Two unlikely Q. Why would a large amount of current be needed to record theories usually revolve around carbon rods that were either notes (only) played by an artist? spring-coupled or free-floating. Thus, the carbon rods would A. It wouldn’t. ostensibly be free to plunge deeper into the mercury in conformity with Hall’s description. Quoting from the first of my two articles “Anyone familiar Q. Well, then, why would you want large current-handling with piano construction will know that the depression (dip) of a capability when recording the playing of an artist? piano key is constant, fixed by the height of the regulating A. You would want large current-handling capability if you punchings on the front rail of the keyframe. Therefore, Hall’s were doing more than just recording notes. statement that the harder the artist hit the key, the deeper the carbon rod would plunge into the mercury, is quite impossible.” Such spring-coupled and free-floating carbon-rod Q. More? Like what? hypotheses are based upon an imperfect understanding A. Like recording dynamics. of physics, mechanics and electromechanical devices. Nevertheless, they are often advanced as some form of validation whenever Hall’s faulty description is questioned. Q. How so? As I pointed out in the latter of my two articles mentioned A. Large amounts of current would clarify and augment above, spring-coupled or free-floating carbon rods would resistance rate-of-change readings given the right actually impede the accurate registering of dynamic resistance value of the carbon rods. information. That the carbon rods were firmly attached to the
150 Q. Why are sizable amounts of current needed to accomplish perforator. However, the resulting first cut was quite rough with this? only the most rudimentary of expression perforations. To get from it to an aesthetically pleasing finished roll required A. It takes a significant amount of current to scrunch soft extensive editing, a laborious and time-consuming process. rubber wheels enough to yield clearly discernible rate-of-change readings. In the film, de Pachmann has just finished making a recording when, magically, an editor appears from stage right with a finished roll (already spooled and perforated) which is Q. Why do you need clearly discernible rate-of-change then played back. De Pachmann suggests a change which readings? is dutifully made; and, then, the roll is re-presented for De Pachmann’s enthusiastic approval. Only the most naïve of A. Such readings can be more easily interpolated into velocity latter-day viewers would believe it. values or, more likely, directly into dynamic intensity (loudness) values. I contend that most of the hype regarding the electrical instant-replay capability of the early Welte-Mignon recording process dates from post World War II! I believe that myths such Q. What phenomenon makes possible the rate-of-change as electrical instant replay (among others) were cooked up in readings? the effort to promote and validate Welte-Mignon recordings and A. Velocity. Vorsetzers to the audiophile mentality of the 1950s and 60s. Repeated allusions to modern audio gear strongly bear this out. For example: “… when the roll was ready to play back, it Q. Velocity of what? was put into a master reproducing Welte Mignon (sic) piano* A. Velocity of the piano key. which ‘read’ the markings in much the same manner that the magnetic ink on bank checks is ‘read’ by automated banking equipment today.” (Similar to audiophiles’ tape recorders – but Q. Why would you want to record the velocity of the key? not so similar as to invite further scrutiny! – J.M.) And, “… as different from the then-current player piano mechanism . . . as A. Because key velocity times five gives a rough today’s stereo recordings are different from Edison cylinders.” approximation of hammer velocity. And, “In its way it seems more remarkable than the electronic wonders of today . . .”
Q. Why would you want to know hammer velocity? Instant-replay myths and others such as: “… specially- aged(sic), thin paper …” (why specially aged?! – J.M.) and; “… A. Because hammer velocity is directly indicative of dynamic run through a chemical bath (just like Ampico’s spark intensity (loudness)! chronograph developing solution – what a coincidence! – J.M.) to fix the colloidal graphite ink …” have caused immeasurable Finally, as to one of the more far-fetched claims Hall harm to the reputation of the Welte-Mignon in particular and attempts to sanctify in his description – that of electrical instant the reproducing piano in general. Such bogus nonsense strains replay prior to perforation – no similar claim seems to have the credulity of the more sophisticated minds of today’s been directly made by M. Welte & Sons ca. 1904-1918! A scan legitimate researchers and undermines the believability of this of literature of the period turns up no such claim. early musical medium’s genuine capabilities. It’s time that this exploitative promotional hyperbole be exposed! In fact, a 1905 announcement for the Mignon (the name under which the Welte-Mignon was first marketed in Europe) translated by the late Claes O. Friberg in Bowers’ Encyclopedia *It’s been stated that there were two of these mythical (see p. 323) states clearly that newly made recordings had to be carbon-track-reading machines and that one survived WWII in “perforated” before they were “thoroughly tested.” a “safe place” according to the late Richard C. Simonton. If one The most amusing evidence presented implying instant of these elusive pianos evaded destruction, why hasn’t it replay capability has to be a promotional early 1920s silent film surfaced?! And, even more mysterious, why haven’t any of the made by the Aeolian Co. Ltd. for the Duo-Art reproducing legendary “specially-aged (sic) … colloidal-graphite-ink … system. It stars Vladimir de Pachmann. And, even this scenario electrically conductive” masters surfaced? implies perforation prior to playback. Unlike most other reproducing piano recording processes which employed some Editor’s Note: Evidently someone else thought there was a bit too much hype associated with 1950’s phonograph recordings of sort of marking system, Duo-Art actually possessed a recording the Welte-Mignon -- see page 152 - 154
151 The Dumesnil Answers By Richard J. Howe
Editor’s Note: This excellent piece first appeared in the May/June 1989 Bulletin.
In 1960 Larry Givens of Wexford, Pennsylvania contacted Maurice Dumesnil, an Ampico (15 rolls) and Due-Art (3 rolls) recording artist, who was living in Michigan at that time. In a letter dated January 20, 1960, Givens asked Mr. Dumesnil, who was then 73 years old, a series of five questions. What follows are transcriptions of Larry’s letter and Dumesnil’s two responses.
January 20, 1960-
Mr. Maurice Dumesnil 167 Elmhurst Avenue Highland park 3, Michigan Dear Mr. Dumesnil, I received your note in yesterday’s mail, and I am delighted that you will help me in my search for information about the history of the reproducing piano. I am most interested in uncovering information about what actually took place while the recording was being played in the recording studio. So far, about all I know is that the pianist sat at a piano and played the selection on it! Therefore, I have a couple of questions on that subject: 1. Was there necessarily any difference between the pianist’s playing while making a recording and his normal playing? In other words, did the pianist have to play in any special manner, or be especially careful of any technical aspect of his playing, when he made a recording – or could he just play as if he were giving a concert performance and not concern himself with the recording which was being made? 2. What was the mechanism like which recorded the pianist’s performance? I believe there was a grand piano in the recording studio on which the pianist played – but how was this connected to the recording mechanism? Were there electrical switches attached to the piano, and if so, where were they attached? I understand that there was a moving piece of paper onto which pencil STYLI were pressed as the notes were played, and this recorded the keys which the pianist depressed – but how was the VOLUME of the pianist’s playing recorded? Did they have an electrical microphone record the volume – or what sort of apparatus did this? I am VERY interest- ed to learn this information about the recording of the volume of the artist’s playing. 3. After the recording procedure was completed, did the pianists return to the recording studio at a later date to listen to the recordings and approve them or “veto” them? Or did the company just issue the recording without consulting the artist after it was made? 4. Were the various pianists who made recordings hired on a “per recording” basis, or was there a contract arrangement for a cer- tain number of recordings? How did the company go about selecting pianists? Did they try to find artists who specialized in the music of the composer whom they were to record, or did they choose artists on a random basis? 5. If you would not consider this question too prying or too personal, I would greatly appreciate your giving me some idea of the fee which an artist was paid per recording. I realize that the fee varied according to the eminence of the artist, but if you could give me just a general idea it would be fine. You do not necessarily need to give me any information regarding your own fees, although if you wish to do so it would be appreciated. If you know the fees which any other artists received, you could mention those instead. Or, if you do not wish to answer this question for personal reasons, I will understand. If there is any other important information which you think would be of interest to me, I would appreciate your mentioning it, even if only briefly. As I mentioned in my last letter, I am accumulating information on the reproducing piano with the idea in mind of writing a book on the subject in a year or two. I have been interested in reproducing pianos for quite a while, and think they are the finest thing ever to have been sold on the musical market. I am a special fan of the Ampico (although I also have a Duo-Art and a Welte-Mignon) – somehow the Ampico seems to be a lit- tle better than the other two. I have about three thousand Ampico rolls, and among my special favorites for the Ampico is your record- ing of “La Campanella” – a beautiful composition and beautifully played by you! Since you played for both the Duo-Art and the Ampico, I would appreciate hearing your own ideas as to the relative merits of the two reproducing mechanisms. I cannot tell you how grateful I will be for your assistance in my search for information about reproducing pianos. Only from a person such as yourself, who was intimately associated with reproducing pianos when they were at the zenith of their popularity, can I obtain the information I seek. I will always be in your debt for the help which you give me. Warmest regards, Austin Givens
152 The Dumesnil Answers continued –
Editor’s note: See highlighted paragraph for Mr. Dumesnil’s unsolicited opinion of 1950s phonograph recordings of Welte-Mignon rolls. Mr. Dumesnil, a noted authority on Debussy, was personally acquainted with the composer.
February 7, 1960
Mr. Austin L. Givens Wexford Pennsylvania Dear Mr. Givens: 1. There was absolutely no difference between playing in one’s studio, or in public, and for recording purposes. 2. The recording piano was a concert grand. There were some cables going from the piano to the outside and if I remember correctly they were attached underneath on the right side. The styli (or any similar device) cut the paper roll and took care of the actual notes. The most important part – the volume – including dynamics, P, PP, MF, F, FF, etc., crescendos and decrescendos, was secured through another apparatus. Once its inventor, Mr. Stoddard, tried to explain to me what it was. But I could not understand the technical aspect beyond remembering that it was done “through a bath of mercury.” He was very proud of this particular point and claimed THAT was the reason why the Ampico was superior to all other reproducing pianos. 3. After the recording was completed, we came back later on to listen to the recording. We found that any wrong note or slip of a finger had been corrected (they do the same now with the wax records, and often pianists go back and make one passage over and over again until it comes out perfect, then the fragment of tape is inserted). This makes it plain that even what we now hear on long playing is NOT the actual playing of the pianist such as one hears it in concert where there can be no corrections. After listening we could either approve, or ask for softer or louder tone coloring, or anything connected with the reproduction of tone, and they did it. Sometimes we went two or three times until this tone reproduction was perfect. 4. Sometimes the recording was on a “per” basis. I received two hundred dollars for each record from the Duo-Art (Aeolian Co.). For the Ampico my recordings were part of a global contract which included playing the Chickering piano (American Piano Co.) and some appearances in comparison with the Ampico. So I am unable to say exactly how much it was each record made, but I imagine it was calculated to be on about the same basis as the Duo-Art. That fee was an average for concert pianists; popular and jazz pianists received less. The recording pianists were selected at random. 5. Answered in the preceding paragraph. 6. When the Ampico was in perfect shape the reproduction was really astounding. But here was the weak point: I said “when it was in perfect shape”. It needed constant attention from a trained specialist. How could such a man be available in smaller cities or in the country? And without that attention the Ampico – as well as the Welte-Mignon and the Duo-Art – became inaccurate. I can give you a typical example: In May 1928 the presentation of the Gaveau-Ampico took place in Paris. It was a big artistic social affair, invitational. Monsieur Gaveau had done all things well. The Lamoureux orchestra conducted by Paul Paray took part. The Salle Gaveau was filled with social and musical luminaries. The program included an overture. Then I played the first movement of Grieg’s Concerto, and later the Chopin Nocturne No. 1, and the first movement of Mozart’s D major Sonata myself. When the Grieg cadenza came, I got up from the piano and started talking with Paray, both of us standing on the side and commenting with admiring looks. Then I took over again for the last “allegro molto”. We went farther (in showmanship) for the Chopin Nocturne. I played the first part, then the lights were gradually put out and it was pitch dark. I got up and quickly went back stage. The lights came on again, progressively. There was a wave of “oh!’s” and “ah!’s” from the audience. Then when the first motive came again we did it in reverse: as the hall was pitch dark again I came back to the piano, the lights were turned on . . . and there I was. It was really stunning. As for the Mozart Sonata, it was stunning too. But concerning the “weak point,” here it is: we had rehearsed the whole thing most carefully during the day. At that time – in the early spring – there was very little electricity used because the day was bright and clear. But at night it was different. Result: the Ampico played a little SLOWER than at the rehearsal, and that was enough to make me feel disappointed. The Mozart lacked vivacity and sparkle. Before I finish, I want to add a few lines about the Welte Mignon. If you heard the Debussy record put out by Columbia, it is an eloquent example of what I say above. That record is an outrage and gives no idea of Debussy’s playing at all, because the Welte-Mignon was an old one abandoned in a cellar and damaged during the war. Someone tried to put it in shape but did not succeed. Therefore the tempi are all wrong, the dynamics are explosive, and the whole interpretation is not even a faint shadow of Debussy’s exquisite playing. The production of such a record advertising the name of Debussy and the fact that one could hear HIM, is a fraud and a deceit that ought to have been stopped by law . . . I hope the above will satisfy you. If there are other points, do not hesitate to write to me. I will be glad to help you with whatever I know. Yours sincerely, Maurice Dumesnil
153 The Dumesnil Answers continued –
February 20, 1960
Mr. Austin L. Givens R.D. No. 1, Wexford, Pennsylvania Dear Mr. Givens: I remember another instance of a big presentation of the Ampico, and that was in the Fall of 1917 at Carnegie Hall in New York. I had just arrived for the first time from South America and was a guest in the box of Mr. And Mrs. Berthold B. Neuer. Mr. Neuer was the manager of Knabe. There was also Mrs. Godowsky and daughter Dagmar. Godowsky was on the program, and so was Leo Ornstein and another pianist whose name I forget. It was a big affair and Carnegie Hall was filled to overflowing (as was the Salle Gaveau in Paris ten years later). But it did not turn out so well. Godowsky came on, sat at the piano (incidentally it WAS a concert grand, as was the Gaveau in Paris; this answers your question concerning size) and played an ENTIRE Chopin number (there was no stunt like the one we did in Paris, of having the lights turned off, my leaving the piano which went on by itself, etc., etc.). Then he moved his chair some fifteen feet away, sat down, took on a pensive attitude with crossed arms and his right hand to his chin and waited. He waited, waited . . and NOTHING happened! Then he turned his head toward backstage, looking so dismayed, and . . . nothing happened. The poor man didn’t know what to do. Finally a tuner rushed on stage, gave a quick examination, and . . crawled under the piano where he laid on his back with his legs up and started to tinker with the mechanics. At that time there was an outburst of giggling all over the hall . . you should have seen B.B. Neuer’s face, in our box. It was a picture of gloom and disappointment. Later on the demonstration resumed and no mishap occurred again, but that was enough and the whole affair was ruined! Most Ampicos and Duo-Arts were of the smaller grand type, and I believe the only concert grands manufactured were only for public demonstration purposes. There was a reason: the installation of an Ampico raised the price exactly 100 percent (for ALL pianos, big or small), so you can imagine how much a concert grand would have come to, probably much too much for the average music lover to afford, unless he was Mr. Rockefeller or Mr. Harriman. I imagine it was the same in England and Germany. (Editor’s Note: Based on available brochures, ads, etc., this was not generally the case, at least as applied to The Ampico. An article on the list prices for many types of player pianos and reproducing pianos manufactured in the United States and Europe will appear in a later issue.) I did not do any promotion for the Duo-Art. But the great French Pianist, Alfred Cortot, did in this country. I remember being in Davenport, Iowa, once when he had been there the week before and I said “Isn’t it too bad, I would have liked so much to see him.” In Europe, the Paris affair was the only one I ever took part in. I never heard of any rolls being made in Europe, except for the Welte-Mignon. Duo-Art or Ampico were undoubtedly shipped from America. Maybe some Duo-Art rolls were made in London, but I am positive there were NO Ampico records made in Europe. In England the Ampico was available in the Marshall and Rose piano. It is likely that the player action was shipped from New York and installed in London, as was the case for the Gaveau-Ampico in Paris. Regarding WHO played for the Welte-Mignon, most of them certainly have passed away. Perhaps one remains: Lucien Wurmser, of Paris. I do not have his address, but he was still alive last summer when I was in France, and I talked about him with friends. He must now be in his eighties. As for the Ampico studios, artists, etc., I have some very precise recollections, and here they are: The studios were way up in the “Chickering Building” at 20 West 57th Street. When you turned the corner from Fifth Avenue you could see the Chickering “Cross of the Legion of Honor” painted in a huge Chickering ad on the wall facing east. Behind the sales rooms there was a very small recital hall. The other half of the main floor (West side) was occupied by the Sohmer Piano Co. Of course I went many times to the recording studios, and here are the names of “the boys”, as they called them or they called themselves, who were there most of the time and had to do with recording, correcting, etc.: Ferdie Grofe, Henry Souvaine, Milton Delcamp, Adam Carroll, and Milton Susskind. As you see, I have quite a memory of names. They were young then, so they must be alive, though I believe Henry Souvaine died some ten years ago. It should not be too difficult for you to investigate and find out about them all. I understand fully what you say about the paper drying and cracking, etc. So it will be a blessing if you succeed in your attempt to find a way of reproducing the rolls. I wish you the best of luck. You certainly know that some time in the late twenties or early thirties the American Piano Company merged with the Aeolian. So I believe you could get a lot of information from the Aeolian Co. regarding both. But . . . does the Aeolian Co. still exist? This I do not know. That was thirty years ago, and things change so fast . . but here again, you can investigate. Yours very sincerely, Maurice Dumesnil
P.S. Another recollection, though a faint one: I believe there was another New York affair, with orchestra, at Carnegie Hall, at which Rudolph Ganz conducted a performance by the Duo-Art of the Liszt E flat concerto recorded by himself. That would have been later by several years than the Godowsky affair. Ganz is now 83 and still teaching actively at the Chicago Musical College of the Roosevelt University in Chicago.
154 Editor’s Note: These two articles first appeared in the September/October 1988 Bulletin