Office of Hawaiian Affairs V. Housing and Community Development Corp
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
--- P.3d ---- Page 1 --- P.3d ----, 2008 WL 257181 (Hawai'i) (Cite as: --- P.3d ----) Office of Hawaiian Affairs v. Housing and Community Development Corp. of Hawai‘i (HCDCH) Hawai‘i,2008. Only the Westlaw citation is currently available. NOTICE: THIS OPINION HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED FOR PUBLICATION IN THE PERMANENT LAW REPORTS. A PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION IN THE SU- PREME COURT MAY BE PENDING. Supreme Court of Hawai‘i. OFFICE OF HAWAIIAN AFFAIRS, Rowena Akana, Haunani Apoliona, Dante Carpenter, Donald Cataluna, Linda Dela Cruz, Colette Machado, Boyd P. Mossman, Oswald Stender, and John Waihe‘e, IV, in their official capacities as members of the Board of Trustees of the Of- fice of Hawaiian Affairs, Pia Thomas Aluli, Jonathan Kamakawiwo‘ole Osorio, Charles Ka‘ai‘ai, and Keoki Maka Kamaka Ki‘ili, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION OF HAWAI‘I (HCDCH), Robert J. Hall, in his capacity as Acting Executive Director of HCDCH, Charles Sted, Chair, Stephanie Aveiro, Francis L. Jung, Charles King, Lillian B. Koller, Betty Lou Larson, Theodore E. Liu, Travis Thompson, Taiaopo, Tuimaleialiifano, Members of the Board of Directors of HCDCH, State of Hawai‘i, and Linda Lingle, in her capacity as Governor, State of Hawai‘i, Defendants-Appellees. No. 25570. Jan. 31, 2008. Background: Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA), and native Hawaiians, brought action for declaratory and injunctive relief against State and against Housing and Community Devel- opment Corporation of Hawai‘i (HCDCH), seeking to enjoin defendants from alienating ceded lands from the public lands trust. After jury-waived trial, the First Circuit Court, Sabrina S. McKenna, J., entered partial judgment for defendants, and certified the judgment for inter- locutory appeal. Holdings: The Supreme Court, Moon, C.J., held that: (1) joint resolution of United States Congress, and related State legislation, give rise to State's fiduciary duty to preserve the corpus of the public lands trust, i.e., the ceded lands, un- til such time as unrelinquished claims of native Hawaiians are resolved; (2) earlier action did not have collateral estoppel effect; (3) action was not barred by sovereign immunity; (4) Office of Hawaiian Affairs did not waive its claims, through its conduct; © 2008 Thomson/West. No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works. --- P.3d ---- Page 2 --- P.3d ----, 2008 WL 257181 (Hawai'i) (Cite as: --- P.3d ----) (5) claims were ripe; (6) action did not present a nonjusticiable political question, and (7) issuance of permanent injunction was warranted. Vacated and remanded. [1] Appeal and Error 30 1008.1(5) 30 Appeal and Error 30XVI Review 30XVI(I) Questions of Fact, Verdicts, and Findings 30XVI(I)3 Findings of Court 30k1008 Conclusiveness in General 30k1008.1 In General 30k1008.1(5) k. Clearly Erroneous Findings. Most Cited Cases Trial court's findings of fact are reviewed on appeal under the clearly erroneous standard. [2] Appeal and Error 30 1008.1(5) 30 Appeal and Error 30XVI Review 30XVI(I) Questions of Fact, Verdicts, and Findings 30XVI(I)3 Findings of Court 30k1008 Conclusiveness in General 30k1008.1 In General 30k1008.1(5) k. Clearly Erroneous Findings. Most Cited Cases A finding of fact is “clearly erroneous” when: (1) the record lacks substantial evidence to sup- port the finding, or (2) despite substantial evidence in support of the finding, the appellate court is nonetheless left with a definite and firm conviction that a mistake has been made. [3] Evidence 157 597 157 Evidence 157XIV Weight and Sufficiency 157k597 k. Sufficiency to Support Verdict or Finding. Most Cited Cases “Substantial evidence” is credible evidence which is of sufficient quality and probative value to enable a person of reasonable caution to support a conclusion. [4] Appeal and Error 30 893(1) 30 Appeal and Error 30XVI Review 30XVI(F) Trial De Novo 30k892 Trial De Novo 30k893 Cases Triable in Appellate Court © 2008 Thomson/West. No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works. --- P.3d ---- Page 3 --- P.3d ----, 2008 WL 257181 (Hawai'i) (Cite as: --- P.3d ----) 30k893(1) k. In General. Most Cited Cases The appellate court reviews the trial court's conclusions of law de novo. [5] Appeal and Error 30 842(2) 30 Appeal and Error 30XVI Review 30XVI(A) Scope, Standards, and Extent, in General 30k838 Questions Considered 30k842 Review Dependent on Whether Questions Are of Law or of Fact 30k842(2) k. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. Most Cited Cases A conclusion of law is not binding upon an appellate court and is freely reviewable for its cor- rectness. [6] Appeal and Error 30 842(2) 30 Appeal and Error 30XVI Review 30XVI(A) Scope, Standards, and Extent, in General 30k838 Questions Considered 30k842 Review Dependent on Whether Questions Are of Law or of Fact 30k842(2) k. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. Most Cited Cases A conclusion of law that is supported by the trial court's finding of facts and that reflects an application of the correct rule of law will not be overturned. [7] Statutes 361 22 361 Statutes 361I Enactment, Requisites, and Validity in General 361k22 k. Introduction and Passage of Joint Resolutions. Most Cited Cases Generally, when a joint resolution of the United States Senate and the United States House of Representatives has emerged from legislative deliberations and proceedings, it is treated as law. [8] Statutes 361 181(1) 361 Statutes 361VI Construction and Operation 361VI(A) General Rules of Construction 361k180 Intention of Legislature 361k181 In General 361k181(1) k. In General. Most Cited Cases Statutes 361 188 361 Statutes 361VI Construction and Operation © 2008 Thomson/West. No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works. --- P.3d ---- Page 4 --- P.3d ----, 2008 WL 257181 (Hawai'i) (Cite as: --- P.3d ----) 361VI(A) General Rules of Construction 361k187 Meaning of Language 361k188 k. In General. Most Cited Cases When construing a statute, the court's foremost obligation is to ascertain and give effect to the intention of the legislature, which is to be obtained primarily from the language contained in the statute itself. [9] Statutes 361 184 361 Statutes 361VI Construction and Operation 361VI(A) General Rules of Construction 361k180 Intention of Legislature 361k184 k. Policy and Purpose of Act. Most Cited Cases Statutes 361 208 361 Statutes 361VI Construction and Operation 361VI(A) General Rules of Construction 361k204 Statute as a Whole, and Intrinsic Aids to Construction 361k208 k. Context and Related Clauses. Most Cited Cases The court must read statutory language in the context of the entire statute and construe it in a manner consistent with its purpose. [10] Statutes 361 181(2) 361 Statutes 361VI Construction and Operation 361VI(A) General Rules of Construction 361k180 Intention of Legislature 361k181 In General 361k181(2) k. Effect and Consequences. Most Cited Cases The legislature is presumed not to intend an absurd result, and legislation will be construed to avoid, if possible, inconsistency, contradiction, and illogicality. [11] Statutes 361 181(2) 361 Statutes 361VI Construction and Operation 361VI(A) General Rules of Construction 361k180 Intention of Legislature 361k181 In General 361k181(2) k. Effect and Consequences. Most Cited Cases A rational, sensible, and practicable interpretation of a statute is preferred to one which is un- reasonable or impracticable. © 2008 Thomson/West. No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works. --- P.3d ---- Page 5 --- P.3d ----, 2008 WL 257181 (Hawai'i) (Cite as: --- P.3d ----) [12] Statutes 361 206 361 Statutes 361VI Construction and Operation 361VI(A) General Rules of Construction 361k204 Statute as a Whole, and Intrinsic Aids to Construction 361k206 k. Giving Effect to Entire Statute. Most Cited Cases Courts are bound, if rational and practicable, to give effect to all parts of a statute, and no clause, sentence, or word shall be construed as superfluous, void, or insignificant if a con- struction can be legitimately found which will give force to and preserve all the words of the statute. [13] Indians 209 152 209 Indians 209IV Real Property 209k152 k. Land Held in Trust in General. Most Cited Cases Public Lands 317 62 317 Public Lands 317II Survey and Disposal of Lands of United States 317II(G) Grants to States for Internal Improvements 317k62 k. Construction and Operation of Grant in General. Most Cited Cases Joint resolution of United States Senate and United States House of Representatives, apologiz- ing to native Hawaiians for overthrow of Kingdom of Hawai‘i, and stating that native Hawaii- ans never directly relinquished to the United States their claims to their national lands and that native Hawaiians were determined to preserve, develop, and transmit to future generations their ancestral territory, could support a claim for return of ceded lands to native Hawaiians, though resolution contained disclaimer that it was not intended to serve as settlement of any claims against United States. Apology Resolution, Pub.L. No. 103-150, 107 Stat. 1510. [14] Indians 209 152 209 Indians 209IV Real Property 209k152 k. Land Held in Trust in General. Most Cited Cases State of Hawai‘i, as trustee for ceded lands held in public lands trust for native Hawaiians, is under an obligation to administer the trust solely in the interest of the beneficiaries and to deal impartially because there is more than one beneficiary. Admission Act of March 18, 1959, Pub.L. No. 86-3, § 5, 73 Stat. 4; Const. Art. 12, § 4. [15] Indians 209 152 209 Indians 209IV Real Property 209k152 k. Land Held in Trust in General. Most Cited Cases © 2008