and Textiles Research Journal http://ctr.sagepub.com/

Undesigned: A Study in Sustainable Design of Apparel Using Post-Consumer Recycled Clothing Carol Young, Charlotte Jirousek and Susan Ashdown Clothing and Textiles Research Journal 2004 22: 61 DOI: 10.1177/0887302X0402200108

The online version of this article can be found at: http://ctr.sagepub.com/content/22/1-2/61

Published by:

http://www.sagepublications.com

On behalf of:

International Textile and Apparel Association

Additional services and information for Clothing and Textiles Research Journal can be found at:

Email Alerts: http://ctr.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts

Subscriptions: http://ctr.sagepub.com/subscriptions

Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav

Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav

Citations: http://ctr.sagepub.com/content/22/1-2/61.refs.html

>> Version of Record - Jan 1, 2004

What is This?

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 Undesigned: A Study in Sustainable Design of Apparel Using Post-Consumer Recycled Clothing

Carol Young Charlotte Jirousek Susan Ashdown

Abstract This article provides a summary of a study exploring sustainable apparel design methods incorporating the use of post-consumer recycled clothing and materials in the design of new products. The name undesigned was assigned to the garment line that was developed for consumers defined as urban nomads. The key concept for this undertaking is described in the term undesigned and was intended to emphasize the quality of the garments as deconstructed and reconstructed or undesigned and redesigned objects with a prior history, as opposed to conventionally designed and produced clothing. Used clothing, available for purchase by the bale through rag dealers, is an abundant source of raw material. Recent trends show that there is a growing market for post-consumer recycled clothing. The collection designed in 1999 for this study focused on the clothing design needs of urban nomads, a demographic consisting of people living in urban areas who commute using ecologically sensitive public and human-powered modes of transportation. In this study designs that fill the functional clothing needs of this population were created based on sustainable processes . A general audience’s sensitivity to and acceptance of the ecological benefits of a clothing production system defined within sustainability parameters were evaluated in response to these designs.

Young, C., Jirousek, C., & Ashdown, S. (2004). Undesigned: A study in sustainable design of apparel using post- consumer recycled clothing. Clothing and Textiles Research Journal, 22(1/2), 61-68. Key Words: apparel design, sustainable design, recycling, post consumer.

That which we throw away, we fail to value. When to accommodate the unique process of working with PCR we design and plan things to be discarded, we clothing. The central idea for this undertaking centered exercise insufficient care in designing... around the term undesigned, a word chosen to emphasize Victor Papanek, Design for the Real World the quality of the garments as deconstructed and recon- (1971, p.74) structed or undesigned and redesigned objects with a prior history, as opposed to conventionally designed and produced clothing. This undesigned line of clothing targeted the needs of urban nomads—young professionals living in urban ar- Process and Project Organization eas who commute using ecologically sensitive public and human-powered modes of transportation. Multiple sets of an urban nomadic clothing system in a range of sizes with The goal of this project was to develop a system of urban explanatory labels and hangtags were exhibited in an inter- nomadic women’s apparel produced from post-consumer active installation. The project was divided into four phases: recycled (PCR) clothing and PCR textiles. The garment Design, Production, Exhibition and Evaluation. The designs designs were grounded in a framework of sustainable eco- were evaluated by a general audience via questionnaire and logical principles and produced using methods developed silent bidding. Feedback collected from the exhibition was then used to evaluate the project in terms of personal, envi- ronmental, and economic value. Offering the garments for sale in a retail environment further tested the acceptability Authors’ Address: Cornell University, Department of Textiles and Apparel, 208 Martha Van Rensselaer Hall, Ithaca, NY 14853-4401. and viability of the concept.

© International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005 Volume 22 #1/2 2004 61

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 “waste” in the form of second hand clothing and also pro- Background vide a viable market for innovative uses of this material. These populations have particular clothing needs based on their use of mass- and human-powered transportation in- This apparel design project is grounded in the broader stead of personal automobiles, a choice determined by both context of the sustainable design movement that has practicality and in some cases sensitivity to ecological ben- emerged in the last decade. At the core of the sustainable efits of these transportation choices. The phrase urban design movement is the need to completely rethink how we nomads was chosen for this study to identify this group of design, what we produce, how we use materials and re- people as a unique demographic. Urban nomads who use sources, and what processes we choose to implement in a less polluting modes of transportation need clothing with way that is equally beneficial to the environment and its aesthetic properties suitable for an urban environment paired inhabitants. William McDonough, architect and leader in with the functional properties of active wear. Garments the sustainable design movement, advocates the closed - capable of multiple functions and style changes should last loop concept “waste equals food”. This phrase defines a longer in the average while accommodating the concept in which objects that are ordinarily discarded as mobile urban lifestyle and providing comfortable clothes for useless may instead be recreated into something useful a variety of conditions. The clothing designed for this study (McDonough & Braungart, 1998). An example of “waste was also designed to fill both the functional clothing needs equals food” sustainability of resources found in nature is of this specific demographic and to explore its sensitivity the closed-loop oxygen-carbon dioxide cycle used by ani- and acceptance of the ecological benefits of a clothing pro- mals and plants. This biological model is offered as a duction system based on sustainable design. metaphor that can be applied to the problem of human-cre- Some consideration was given to designing a unisex ated waste, such as discarded clothing. According to line of clothing, but in the end the decision was made to McDonough “one of the most difficult questions for any- design this initial clothing system for a female end user. one designing something today is ‘What is an ecologically sound material?’”(McDonough & Braungart, 2001). For the apparel designer, one possible answer is post-consumer recycled (PCR) clothing. Design Process Currently the US is experiencing a clothing glut due to the “planned obsolescence” inherent in the apparel industry and the widespread availability of inexpensive clothing Problem definition. The research and problem identi- (Kilborn, 1999; Packer, 2002). The production of excess fication stage of the design process began with a focus group clothing depletes natural resources, contributes to overflow- meeting of six females and four males, ages 19-30, who ing landfills and often relies on the exploitation of human had lived in an urban setting within the last five years. The labor. Export of PCR clothing can also disrupt textile and participants were recruited using flyers and word of mouth. clothing industries in developing countries by glutting local The focus group participants discussed definitions of ur- markets with cheap clothing (Hansen, 1994; Packer, 2002). ban nomads, their clothing needs and concerns, and their As an alternative, using PCR clothing as raw material for opinions about second-hand clothing. Individual defini- new garments allows us to redirect excess post-consumer tions of urban nomad varied among the participants; how- textiles that would otherwise enter the waste stream by har- ever, there was general agreement on the definition pro- nessing this “waste” as a raw material for the design of vided in the section above. The group discussed various environmentally and socially conscious apparel—a clear situations, climates and environments that urban nomads application of McDonough’s “waste equals food” model. face on a daily basis. Subway travel was identified as the Current media coverage shows that there is a viable most problematic, especially during extreme weather con- market for clothing created from PCR textile materials; de- ditions. Generally, subways are crowded during rush hour signers and lines such as Miguel Adrover, Ggrippo and are often a different temperature from the outside en- for trash-a-porter, Koi, ynnub, and VICC, are being praised vironment. Artificial environments, such as air-conditioned for their innovative reconfigurations of Burberry , or heated offices, stores and restaurants, also create extreme mattresses, t-, , and (Heimstra, 2001; temperature variations. Limnander, 2000; Yabroff, 2001). If these current trends Though the conditions faced by a bicycle rider and that favor recycling and reuse of post-consumer recycled subway rider, for example, seem on the surface to be very clothing continue, they will create an even more viable market different, all urban modes of travel have much in common; for deconstructed ready-to-wear (R-T-W) garments. The goal extremes of temperature, necessity of carrying many items, of this project is to explore the design potential of PCR. moderate to extreme physical activity and the need to be Target Market: The urban nomad. An urban nomad visible at night. The group made several suggestions for can be defined as a person who lives in an urban center, better designs: 1) clothes with many easily accessible pock- relies on mass transit and human-powered transportation for ets, 2) clothes that work from day to night since they seldom mobility, is highly mobile on a daily basis, does not return go home to change, 3) use of stretch fabrics or designs with home between work and social activities, and carries items built-in movement for increased mobility, 4) less bulkiness needed for smooth transition from day to night. and weight in general, 5) lightweight, thin clothing layers High concentrations of people in urban settings with that “slide” and have less friction between layers, and 6) medium to high incomes both generate much clothing that are easy to remove and store.

62 Clothing and Textiles Research Journal © International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 The second half of the discussion revolved around gen- ets and closures can be retained to take advantage of their eral attitudes and stigmas associated with used or second- existing function as well as add character. hand clothing. Of the ten participants, two refused to wear Men’s suiting provides a formal, conservative style, or purchase used clothing. Reasons varied from “question- quality fabric, classic construction details, and useable fab- able hygiene” and “aversion to hand-me-downs” to social ric amounts due to consistency of garment shapes and gen- stigmas due to purely psychological reluctance. erally large sizes. Existing features such as the notched col- Based on this discussion, project goals were established. lar, internal and external pockets, and original closures can General project goals were to develop a viable method to be reinterpreted in new designs. use PCR clothing in new designs, to incorporate T-shirts and sweatshirts are typically constant in form functionalities important to the urban nomad, and to pre- and size and mainly vary only in the location of logo or serve and communicate through labels and hangtags the decoration. Because of this uniformity, they lend themselves history and meaning of the original garments. to a myriad of transformations. The fabric is comfortable, Ideation: Design approaches. The design process for stretchable, and easy to care for. the prototype garments began by seeking out which PCR gar- Wool , also commonly in shape, were ments were readily available at the Salvation Army in Ithaca, chosen for their warmth, texture, comfort, and color. At a New York. An abundance of jeans, T-shirts, sweatshirts, seminar B. Tatarka (Personal Communication, September button-down collar shirts, sweaters and men’s suits were 14, 1999) showed samples of wool coats she had made of found. Through Internet research it was found that it is fea- felted wool PCR sweaters. Wool sweaters are often dis- sible to acquire garments of these types by the bale through carded because of their worn out look due to moth holes, rag dealers, which would lower the cost of these materials snags and pilling. The felting process Tatarka had applied (http://www.cannamm.net, http://www.stuartrags.com). to the sweaters minimized flaws while adding thickness and The inherent qualities of jeans are sturdiness, easy texture to the fabric. care, patina-like aging and soft flexibility. Denim from used In addition to functional qualities and style, the color, jeans will not shrink as they are already well laundered. The material, form, technological compatibility, material oppor- twill-weave contributes to wind-resistance and abrasion tunism, labor saving convenience, perceived need and simple resistance. Original features such as flat-felled seams, pock- visual appeal of the designs were important factors in the

Figure 1. Figure 2.

© International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005 Volume 22 #1/2 2004 63

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 Figure 3. Figure 4.

prototype design process. To design with PCR garments garments such as a T- could be cut and used much like the material was used as one would use an animal hide or a a narrow width fabric; more complex garments such as a fabric produced on a narrow loom; the shape and amount of required extensive manipulation on the form. material from the PCR garments influence the shape of the The Reverse Denim Raincoat (Plate XV), the Reverse newly designed garment (Burnham, 1973). Denim Raintrench, and the Denim Wave (Figure 1) Implementation. The next step was to decide which are the three styles derived from denim jeans. The Reverse recycled garments would lend themselves as raw materials Denim Raincoat and Raintrench were made from leg por- for urban nomadic clothing. Five garment types, 1) denim tions of men’s denim jeans, water-resistant , reflec- jeans, 2) men’s suiting, 3) T-shirts, 4) sweatshirts and 5) tive piping, and metal D-rings. The nylon side of these wool sweaters, were chosen because they possess qualities reversible styles provides water resistance for protection in appropriate to successful deconstruction and reuse. light rain, a center back pleat for mobility, reflective piping In addition to PCR clothing, new fabrics made from for nighttime visibility, and princess-seam zipper vents for PCR materials were chosen. Eco Fleece® and Eco Wool® torso ventilation. The Denim Wave Skirt was developed made by Dyersburg Mills with Wellman’s Ecospun® fibers using an entire pair of women’s jeans with the original (made from post-consumer recycled plastic containers) were and pocket features. chosen for their lightweight yet insulating quality. Other Men’s suiting was transformed into the Pod Skirt (Fig- materials were needed to provide functional qualities that ure 2), Backpack Vest (Figure 3), and Reverse Reflect Vest could not be readily acquired from PCR textile materials. (Figure 4). Suit were used to make the Pod Skirt Water-resistant lightweight rip-stop nylon, separating zip- using the original waistband. An adjustable back bustle pers, reflective piping and metal D-rings were sourced. allows for style flexibility as well as walking mobility. The Choices were made based on functional characteristics as Backpack Vest was made from a . This style well as quality. incorporates padding for increased wearer comfort in areas The prototype design process began by deconstructing where a backpack rests on the body. The Backpack Vest some basic garments and draping them on the dress form to also has hidden pockets for convenient storage of small items find the best use of existing features and material. Simple and an adjustable buckle closure. The Reverse Reflect Vest

64 Clothing and Textiles Research Journal © International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 was also derived from a man’s suit jacket. The original interviewed about the fit and style of the garments. Wear with additional reflective materials can be worn to the out- testers’ comments and responses were incorporated in the side at night for visibility, while the suiting side could be redesign of several of the garments. This redesign process worn for a more formal office look. continued throughout the production phase as interactions T-shirts were cut apart and treated as a narrow width of among the graded ready-to-wear pattern shapes, the limita- fabric. Initial designs were developed using a combination tions of the PCR garments, and the desired style and func- of flat patternmaking and draping. The Bubble Elbow Shirt tional features of the designs were resolved. was made out of one T-shirt with the ECO Wool and Fleece® (Plate XVI). The Bubble Elbow Shirt features an action elbow for movement, a thumbhole for warmth and hand pro- tection while cycling, and lightweight for of wearing Production Processes and Issues under a jacket or . The felted wool sweaters were also cut apart and used as a narrow width of fabric. The end results were two torso The next step in the process was to resolve the produc- warming hooded garment variations, the Decon tion issues inherent in creating this line of garments using (Figure 5) and Decon Hoodie Pullover. Each style sustainable design methods. Issues related to patternmaking, was made from a collage of sweaters, sweatshirts and ECO material preparation, and garment construction were ad- Wool and Fleece. dressed. Labels and hangtags were also designed to commu- Evaluation. Constant evaluation of style and function nicate issues related to the intrinsic value of the collection. are an essential part of the design process. After the initial Computer-aided pattern making and grading. Patterns designs were created they were wear-tested by nomadic from the prototype designs were digitized into the com- student subjects to assess style, fit, and function. Garments puter using Lectra Modaris software and graded into a range were tested daily for a period of one week and worn while of sizes from 28 to 42 (bust measurement) and 34 to 44 (hip walking through campus, travelling by bus, and riding bi- measurement) using standard X-Y grading methods. Dif- cycles. Wear-test subjects maintained a “garment diary” ficulties arose from the irregular pattern shapes due to shapes that included sections on environmental conditions, com- of the fabric pieces from the used clothing (Figure 6). Pat- fort, function, and general acceptability. Subjects were also tern changes needed to be made to allow the full range of sizes to be cut. The changes allowed for the use of key elements from existing features of the PCR clothing, such as pockets for the Backpack Vests and the jean fly for the Denim Wave . This resulted in slight variations in the design.

Figure 6.

Textile preparation. Preparing PCR clothing as raw ma- terial requires disassembly and cleaning prior to use by the end users. Jeans, T-shirts and sweatshirts were the easiest garments to process. They were simply washed with deter- gent in hot water and tumble-dried at a high heat. Cleaning the suiting was more difficult. Rather than wash before production, suiting was first deconstructed, then recon- structed into the new garment and finally dry-cleaned. Fin- Figure 5. ished reconstructed garments could be either dry-cleaned or

© International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005 Volume 22 #1/2 2004 65

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 carefully hand washed in cold water. The felting of PCR jects with a prior history instead of typically designed and sweaters was the most time-consuming textile preparation produced clothing. Customer interaction with the clothing process. Felting the wool sweaters required a minimum of and communication of the design concepts were crucial two hot water machine washes with detergent (Synthrapol) elements that drove the “store” layout. Posters were de- and tumble drying with high heat. Felting occurred best signed to describe the ecological concept and the ‘history’ when 1) the washing machine was packed 2) a pair of jeans of the PCR clothing. “Customers” were able to try on gar- was added to the wash and 3) felted sweaters were ironed ments, to make silent bids and respond to the designs by on high heat with steady pressure and steam. When color filling out questionnaires over the course of a two-week purity is desired it is necessary to wash contrasting colors period. A total of 34 questionnaire responses and 31 silent separately since the different colored fibers intermingle if bids were collected for evaluation. The questionnaire’s washed together. topics covered garment appeal, function and market value, Garment construction. A hybrid method of cutting and response to the overall ecological concepts, and social ac- assembling the garments was developed. Each garment was ceptance of second-hand clothing. individually cut by hand and then all garment pieces were Although the gallery presentation did not take place bundled to be sewn in an assembly line fashion. This hybrid in an urban environment many of the residents of Ithaca method of production, hand cutting with assembly line sew- and the members of the College where it took place are ing, combined individual treatment when necessary with originally from urban areas or have participated in intern- partial industrial application. ships or study abroad in urban areas. Because of highly Labels and hangtags. Labels were designed to provide restricted parking on campus most students do not use cars information about wash and care, and also to communicate for transportation. the garment’s reconstruction history (Figure 7). Each label Evaluation. Focus group responses, garment diaries and showed a prototypical image of an original PCR garment. exhibit questionnaire data were evaluated for personal, en- For example, pictures were chosen of a pair of used jeans vironmental, and economic value. The data from the urban for denim items, wool sweaters for felted wool items, and a nomad focus group and the garment diaries were analyzed suit jacket for garments made from suiting. The original using content analysis, and the exhibit questionnaires using item dictated the care instructions, but the labels advised descriptive statistics. The results were as follows: hanging to dry when possible to conserve energy. Personal value. An understanding of the personal val- ues of the respondents was sought throughout the project. Questions were asked about the: 1) acceptance of second- hand clothing for use in creating new clothing, 2) response to the functional value of the designs for urban nomadic wear, and 3) reactions to the value of the clothing’s built-in his- tories expressed through the informational hangtags and labels. In addition, the concept of added value through his- tory was explored further by asking for responses to the concept of clothing made from the second-hand clothing of Figure 7. people known to the wearer, for example their grandfather’s suit, or a set of sweaters from close friends. Respondents found the garments appealing, valued the design, uniqueness, environmental principles and function- Hangtags were designed as fabric bookmarks to live on ality of each garment. They found the labels and hangtags past their life as opposed to disposable hangtags (Plate XIV). informative and valued the added information about garments’ These bookmarks had images of the appropriate recon- histories. In addition, it was found that the deconstruction structed garment with the style name (i.e. Pod Skirt) and and reconstruction of second-hand clothing into new garments style code -size numbers (i.e. “This is SK2-36”). Material made the wear of second-hand clothing more socially ac- information was presented in the form of prior garment ceptable; eleven of the thirty-four exhibit respondents claimed history (i.e. “In her former life she was…) that would clue they do not wear second-hand clothing yet found the study the purchaser in to the past history in the garment’s life. garments wearable and appealing. Twenty-four of the ex- hibit respondents said they would value the garments more if they were made from clothing of friends and family, sug- gesting a potential market for custom as well as mass pro- Exhibition and Project Evaluation duction. However, it was clear from reactions to the gar- ments that good design is a crucial first step for the environ- mental principles to be understood and accepted. Once the Exhibition. The clothing collection was displayed in a design is accepted by the wearer/consumer/audience, then gallery space on campus; however, a retail store format was the value through personal identification with the concepts used to encourage people to interact with the clothing as if may take place; the concepts cannot stand alone without good they were shopping for clothing instead of just viewing the design. Good design is seamlessly incorporated in modern garments. The concept for the exhibit was a prototypical life, and addresses all of its intrinsic and extrinsic needs. Undesigned store; the store name was chosen to emphasize Ultimately, the power of the environmental concepts is that the quality of the garments as re-made urban nomadic ob- they can strengthen the value of the accepted design.

66 Clothing and Textiles Research Journal © International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 Environmental value. The project was evaluated for en- market with a higher-priced product (Kotler, 1997, p.396). vironmental value to determine whether the use of post-con- The complete inversion of devalued “second-hand clothing” sumer clothing as raw material is a viable option that has the to revalued and highly valued new garment must occur in potential to reduce the amount of post-consumer textile order for the product to be successful. products entering the waste stream and the amount of new resources needed to make new apparel. The use of PCR clothing as a base material was suc- cessful on some levels and problematic on others. During Implications of the Study the deconstruction of the second-hand garments about 20% of the material became scrap not used for the selected de- signs. Other methods of fiber recycling implemented in a To take full advantage of the potential for PCR design, commercial setting could make some of this “waste” useful. a three-tier system that would have three different price- Garments designed from the PCR clothing took advantage points is proposed —1) mass-produced sustainable apparel, of original garment details, such as pockets and closures, re- 2) deconstructed ready-to-wear (R-T-W), and 3) commis- using these features and saving construction time and en- sioned re-constructions. ergy. According to Ecospun’s informational hang tag, “via Tier I: Mass-produced sustainable apparel. The first recycling, Wellman is able to keep 2.4 billion plastic con- tier would utilize new materials with less environmental im- tainers out of landfills annually... Recycling has the poten- pact, such as organic cotton and recycled fleece. Designs tial to save 650,000 barrels of oil and eliminate 375,000 tons could be variations of the second tier’s deconstructed R-T- of harmful air emissions.” The use of these PCR materials W but would use new materials and be manufactured using satisfied functional garment needs and contributed to the mass production, thus yielding a lower price. The afford- overall ecological concept of “waste equals food” as applied able price would allow a wider range of consumers the choice to an industrial product. of environmentally sensitive clothing. Satisfying the needs of urban nomads such as durabil- Tier II: Deconstructed R-T-W. The second tier would ity, protection, and thermal comfort required compromises utilize PCR clothing as the base material and the production in material choice. New materials, such as the rip-stop water methods developed in this study. Because of the more com- resistant nylon, were chosen for their functional rather than plex design and production methods, these garments would environmental characteristics. Choices for new closures, be priced higher than the mass-produced versions. The such as invisible zippers and plastic buckles, were made to garments would be completely unique, limited edition per- maintain quality control and to address specific functional sonal items with a built-in history; they would include docu- design and aesthetic purposes. The reflective piping for the mentation of the deconstructed garment similar to the study’s jackets was used for its visibility function. Collaboration and labels and “bookmark” hang tags. Garments from this tier compromise are necessary steps in the process of develop- would fall into a niche market catering to customers who ing sustainable clothing design. Although the method is not are willing to spend more for a more individual product. yet perfected and waste is still generated, the choice of Subsequent to the formal completion of this project, seven materials addresses some of the issues of post-consumer of the collection garments were placed at the ACCI artists’ waste while satisfying functional and aesthetic apparel needs. cooperative gallery in Berkeley and displayed in the gallery Economic value. According to McDonough, “commerce gift shop in order to test the viability of this concept. Al- is the engine for change (McDonough & Braungart, 1998).” though the garments were priced to cover complete produc- Economically feasible design and production methods for tion costs plus a profit for both producer and retailer, five of harnessing discarded clothing as a raw material were explored the seven garments sold within the first week, and gener- since economic sustainability is crucial for implementing ated much customer interest. The gallery manager reported social and environmental changes. The concept of custom that customers were delighted by the hangtag portraits of production was explored, as well as mass production. In each garment and valued each garment’s uniqueness and terms of economic viability, design for production efficiency their environmental qualities. is necessary to make the use of PCR clothing economically Commissioned reconstructions. The third tier would fall feasible. The design, patternmaking, and production pro- in the premium or couture price range with customers bring- cesses developed for this project used some mass production ing in personal items to be reconstructed into completely techniques, but required additional labor as compared to the new garments. The level of customization would range from average mass-market item. Therefore it is doubtful that the deconstructing/reconstructing the customers’ clothing using average consumer would place a high enough value on the pre-developed designs (i.e. patterns already developed for environmental concepts to purchase these reconstructed items the deconstructed R-T-W tier) to custom designing garments that had to be higher priced than the average garment. for customers from “family heirloom” pieces. One wear Additional application of mass production methods would tester from this study said she would value a garment such reduce price, however. Nonetheless, garments with higher as her grandfather’s suit “morphed into something to fit me price points would have to be marketed to consumers with that I could have a memento of him,” thus crossing genera- higher incomes. The appeal of these garments depends on tions and genders. Study participants met this concept with the social and aesthetic views of the consumer, as well as the enthusiasm. The creation of one-of-a-kind garments that are purchasing criteria required by the consumer (product qual- meaningful, symbolic and cherished is a viable option that ity, content, aesthetics, individuality and function). The would have value for the customer, strengthening social garments produced in this project therefore target a niche connections while making use of old clothing.

© International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005 Volume 22 #1/2 2004 67

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 The first step towards changing our society starts with and the construction of identity in Zambia’s third re- educating the consumer about social and environmental is- public. Public Culture, 6, 503-523. sues. Clothing is a universal object that everyone in the Heimstra, B. (2001, June/July). Revisions. One Design Mat- world uses and understands; it is a ubiquitous part of our ters, pp. 30,32. society. When in use it is a mobile visual object open for Kilborn, P. T. (1999, July 19). Prosperity builds mounds of interpretation and discussion; it is not tied down to any one cast-off clothes. New York Times, p. A1. location, but may travel far and wide with its wearer. Suc- Kotler, P. (1997). Marketing Management: Analysis, Plan- cessful design will be well worn and loved by its owner, and ning, Implementation and Control (9th ed.). Upper possibly passed down to a new generation for another rota- SaddleRiver, NJ: Prentice Hall. tion in the clothing lifecycle. In essence, it is an ideal object Limnander, A. (2000 March). Please recycle. Vogue, 290, with which to communicate and experiment. This study 297. explored the creation of meaningful, functional, re-valued McDonough, W., & Braungart, M. (1998 October). The clothing from the discarded clothing of our current dispos- NEXT Industrial Revolution. The Atlantic Monthly. able society. The garments act as vehicles for encouraging McDonough, W., & Braungart, M. (2001 June/July). The recycling and reuse. By inverting what we once considered Five Steps to Reinventing the World, Step 2: Personal “waste” into “food” for thought and continued use we are Preferences (from scientific experience). Green@Work able to reassess our relationship with what our current soci- Magazine. Retrieved November 15, 2003 from http:// ety undervalues. mbdc.com/MBDC_ReinventingTheWorld.pdf Packer, G. (2002, March 31). How Susie Bayer’s t-shirt ended up on Yusuf Mama’s back. New York Times Magazine, p. 54. References Papanek, V. (1971). Design for the Real World: Human Ecology and Social Change. New York: Pantheon Books. Burnham, D. K. (1973). Cut My Cote. Toronto: Royal Yabroff, J. (2001 August/September). Los Angeles: Street Ontario Museum. Fashion. One Design Matters, p. 91. Hansen, K. T. (1994). Dealing with used clothing: Salaula

68 Clothing and Textiles Research Journal © International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 Plate XIV. Hangtags as Fabric Bookmarks

Plate XV. Reverse Denim Raincoat Derived from Denim Jeans

© International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005 Volume 22 #1/2 2004 51

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012 Plate XVI. Bubble Elbow Shirt with Functional Design Plate XVII. “Silk Bridge”. Features.

Plate XVIII. “Cathedral”.

52 Clothing and Textiles Research Journal © International Textile & Apparel Association, 2005

Downloaded from ctr.sagepub.com at OKLAHOMA STATE UNIV on March 31, 2012