Hour ___O1 Notepacket Issue Investigation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Name _________________________________________ Date ____________ Hour _______ Issue Investigation: There are numerous ways to investigate scientific issues … we focus on Environmental Issues. The following issue investigation technique is ONE way to handle your decision making. Step 1: ___________ Identify the problem __________ • What is the _________ condition __________________ that is at risk in this scenario? • Try to put this in a _____ question ___________form if possible to ____ eliminate _________ bias. Step 2: _________ Identify the players and their positions ______________ • Players are ____________________ People involved in the issue ___________________________ • Animals and plants __________ cannot be players _______________________________ • Positions – Where does each ______ player _______________ stand on the _____ issue ________. Step 3: ________ Identify the values ___________________________________ • Each person comes with their _ own set of values __ which influences their _____ decision _____. • Common values that we use include: o _____ Aesthetic _______ = beautiful, pleasing to the eye o ____ Cultural/Social _____ = relating to culture, has significance upon that culture or social aspects (like bald eagle to U.S., fried cheese curds to WI, a particular joke to your family) o ______ Ecological/Environmental ____ = relationships between organisms and their environment, conservation of the natural world o ______ Economical ____ = management of material wealth , production and consumption through measureable variables, affects finances, increase revenue, more jobs, etc. o ______ Educational ________ = giving knowledge, concerned with education , enrichment o ______ Egocentric _______ = interested in personal needs , all about me! o _____ Legal ______ = related to law, legally significant, like endangered species act o _________ Medicinal _____ = having properties that can be used to treat illnesses o ________ Recreational __________ = used for pleasure, activity performed during ones leisure time , useful to outdoor enthusiasts Step 4: __________ Identify Solutions _______________ • Come up with ________ as many ways to resolve ________this issue as you can … be creative! • List at least _____ 4 or 5 _____ possible ways to solve it. Step 5: _______________ Choose your solution/Defend it _____________ • Pretend that you rule the world. • How would YOU _____ resolve this conflict _______ and ____ why __? O1 Notepacket Ethanol Powered Cars While gasoline/electric hybrid cars have been on the road for awhile now, a more recent car choice facing consumers today is to drive a car based on ethanol fuels. Again, you have to do decide if it is a good option for the consumer or not based on the information we currently have on this technology. Ethanol is a wheat-based fuel additive, based on corn, barley or wheat that has been around for many years. E85 is the most popular "brand" of ethanol; it is a blend of 85 percent ethanol and 15 percent gasoline. Sam Hollen is a local farmer in Southern Wisconsin and he believes that ethanol production should be expanded. He offers the following reasons for his opinion--The benefit of this fuel is that it increases the octane in your fuel and reduces emissions. E85 also costs less for the consumer than traditional gasoline. Because the fuel is crop-based, many American farmers support ethanol and want to grow corn to fuel the country's escalating fuel needs. Ethanol is a good thing: it's domestically produced, crop-based and puts out reduced emissions. Evaline Mutos believes that Ethanol based fuel is a good thing if for one reason and that reason is to, “reduce our dependence on foreign oil”. She also mentioned that she owns a flex-fuel vehicle and so far she’s been happy with its performance. A flex fuel vehicle is one that can run on the E85 or the more traditional blend E10. This reduces the need for special fueling stations for people who own the Ethanol powered vehicles. Evaline works at the GM plant in Janesville, WI which produces many of the Flex-fuel vehicles for GM Motors. Connie Brider feels these cars are too limited yet. “We shouldn’t allow WI to jump on the bandwagon of ethanol production until the science has been proven to be effective.” She worries that we will learn that the Ethanol isn’t providing us the emissions reductions we thought and that many companies based on ethanol production will not survive if we build too many, too soon. She is an economist for the state of WI. 2 Practice Issue Investigation—Ethanol Powered Cars: Read the article and then try to complete the 5-step issue investigation process. Issue: (Write as a question in a sentence.) Should Americans switch to ethanol fueled vehicles? Or Why use ethanol based fuels? Lots of possibilities Background: (Write a paragraph summarizing the history and events leading up to the issue. What is its current status?) Consumers today have more choices in their cars. They can choose and electric car, or hybrid car, or drive a car that uses ethanol fuels. Ethanol is a wheat-based fuel additive, based on corn, barley or wheat that has been around for many years. E85 is the most popular "brand" of ethanol; it is a blend of 85 percent ethanol and 15 percent gasoline. Player: (Describe the player. Position: (Describe the position of the Values: (Describe the values you think are Players may be individuals or player. How would they respond to the issue held by the player. Explain why you think the organizations.) question?) player has those values.) Sam Hollen he believes that ethanol Economical - American farmers farmer in Southern production should be can grow crops used to produce Wisconsin expanded ethanol More cost efficient, increases octane in the fuel Environmental – reduces emissions Evaline Mutos Ethanol based fuel is a good Economical - works at GM plant works at the GM plant thing to reduce our where they produce flex fueled dependence on foreign oil vehicles Reduces need for special fueling stations Connie Brider cars are too limited yet Environmental – won’t provide economist for the state the emission reductions they of WI hope Economical – many businesses based on ethanol may not survive if grow too fast too soon Possible Solutions: (Explain how the issue could be addressed. These solutions might be provided by a player or you may create them on your own. You need at least 4-5 possible solutions.) Solutions will vary – must be at least 4 options Your Opinion: (How would you personally answer the issue? Explain why you feel that way.) Explain why chose option you did. 3 Practice Issue Investigation—Cotton Growing in the U.S.: Issue: (Write as a question in a sentence.) Background: (Write a paragraph summarizing the history and events leading up to the issue. What is its current status?) Player: (Describe the player. Position: (Describe the position of the Values: (Describe the values you think are Players may be individuals or player. How would they respond to the issue held by the player. Explain why you think the organizations.) question?) player has those values.) Possible Solutions: (Explain how the issue could be addressed. These solutions might be provided by a player or you may create them on your own. You need at least 4-5 possible solutions.) Your Opinion: (How would you personally answer the issue? Explain why you feel that way.) 4 Easter IslandIsland————LessonsLessons learned Where? Island in Pacific Ocean What happened? Who? Used up natural People on resources like Easter What have we learned about trees for cooking, Island sustainability? making ocean originally To manage our resources so that going vessels, from they are there for future usage. Do etc. Polynesia not use more resources than can be Trees became replaced. Take care of what extinct, lead to resources you do have so don’t end animals up like Easter Islanders. extinction. Rats ate seeds that would normally have allowed for regrowth. How did it end? People began to starve When? War broke out Before Government fell apart 1700’s Knocked over each others statues 5 Living Planet Report: Graphing Analysis: Directions : Use the graphs to answer the related questions. Most questions must be answered in complete sentences. The exception to answering in complete sentences is for questions where a line is provided. Use Figure 22 to answer these questions. 1. What is the title of the graph? ______ Ecological footprint per person by country, 2005 _____ 2. What type of graph is used to display the data? ________ Bar graph _________ 3. What is the x-axis showing? _____ country in order of decreasing footprint ______ 4. What is the y-axis showing? ______ global hectares per person (footprint) ______ 5. Why is the bar shown in multiple colors? What do the multiple colors indicate? The footprint is broken down by different categories of resource use. Each color represents a different use of the land. 6. What does the green line that runs across all the bars represent? The green line represents the total productive area of the earth or biocapacity in global hectares per person . 7. What information is provided by this graph? [In other words, what can you learn by reading this graph?] You can tell how much of each land resource a country uses. You can compare total use with biocapacity or see how far over or under biocapacity a country is. 8. What was the criterion for including a country on the list? [ Hint : Look at the description of the figure.] Countries with populations over 1 million were included in this graph. 9. Which two countries have the highest carbon footprint? a. _____ United Arab Emirates ________ b. _________ Kuwait ______________ 10. Which country has the largest use of grazing land per person? ____ Uraguay _____ 11. Describe one significant difference in the pattern of countries with the highest ecological footprint per person with the countries with the lowest ecological footprint per person.