2002–03 No. 20, 19 November 2002

Changes in the Australian Oath of The changes in the oath of citizenship In 1947 departed from this The great achievement of Australian over the last 50 years reflect the common code with legislation which citizenship … lies not so much with evolution of from British 'gave Canadians their own Canadian those of us who are Australians born colony to independent multicultural citizenship status whilst continuing to and bred but, rather with those nation. hold British subject status'.4 Prompted millions who … have of their own 8 Background by the 1947 Canadian Act other free will chosen to become citizens. Australian citizenship was vigorously Commonwealth countries, including Changes in the Oath of Allegiance9 debated at the Federation conferences Britain, Australia and The Australian Citizenship Act 1948 held during the 1890s. During this introduced similar legislation. sets out the provisions by which citizenship can be acquired. These are decade the word 'citizen' appeared: Australians, who until 1949 had been by birth, adoption, descent or grant. again and again, in speeches, in the British subjects, were now Australian One of the requirements of the grant press, in the rules and charters of citizens and British subjects provision was that all new citizens take organisations, and in debates about simultaneously. This situation 1 the oath or affirmation of allegiance political entitlement. remained from 1949 until 1984. Surprisingly the final version of the (now the pledge). This is an essential Australian Citizenship rather than a symbolic part of the Constitution did not reflect this intense The legal status of Australian Citizen citizenship process. The changes from debate. came into effect on 26 January 1949 the first to the Although the final Constitution gave the with the passage through Parliament of current pledge are listed below. They Commonwealth the power to make laws the Nationality and Citizenship Act 5 reflect the growing diversity of with respect to naturalisation and aliens, 1948. The Minister for , the Australia's population and the it did not mention or define Australian Hon. Arthur Calwell said: citizenship. The closest statement in the This is an historic occasion in the life development of a more inclusive Constitution on citizenship is found in of our nation. The bill … seeks to approach to citizenship. s. 117 which uses the word 'subject' establish for the first time the 1948 Nationality and Citizenship Act10 rather than 'citizen': principle of Australian citizenship, Oath of Allegiance A subject of the Queen, resident in while maintaining … the common I, A. B; swear by Almighty God that any State, shall not be subject in any bond of British nationality. … this I will be faithful and bear true other State to any disability or bill … will enable Australia to allegiance to His Majesty King discrimination which would not be proclaim its own national citizenship George the Sixth, his heirs and equally applicable to him if he were a and establish the duties and successors according to law, and that subject of the Queen resident in such responsibilities as well as the rights I will faithfully observe the laws of other State. and privileges that are inherent in it.6 Australia and fulfil my duties as an Section 24 uses the phrase 'people of Sir Ninian Stephen, former Justice of Australian citizen. the Commonwealth', and s. 44 uses the the High Court and former Governor- 1966 Amendment: Insertion of term 'citizen' in regard to persons who General of Australia, has suggested renunciation are 'subjects or citizens' of a foreign that the notion of citizenship in fact In his Second Reading Speech on the power and therefore ineligible to stand made very little impact on the 1966 Bill, the Minister for for federal parliament. Australian community: Immigration, the Hon. Hubert The concept of Australian citizenship Australian citizenship has none of the Opperman stated: therefore did not exist—it was not a aura which surrounds the concept of … we have decided that the essential formal legal term.2 being a citizen of the words of renunciation should now be incorporated as part of the oath of In 1914 British nationality was, for the nor … [with] being a citizen of France. This is, I believe, largely allegiance to the Queen. The change first time, defined in legislation. Self- because our citizenship has not had will simplify and shorten the governing member countries of the to be fought for but has come to us naturalisation ceremony and enhance British Empire passed nationality acts gradually, without fanfare and its dignity, and will also, I believe, based on the UK legislation and adopted without struggle.7 eliminate the emotional disturbance a British nationality 'common code' Since 1949 Australian governments felt by candidates due to their which provided British subjects with a have actively encouraged immigrants national and rightful love of their 3 11 common status. to become citizens: homelands. Oath of Allegiance reviewed the Australian Citizenship values of Australia and which is a I, A. B., renouncing all other Act 1948 in 1982 and recommended bonding instrument, and we can do allegiance, swear by Almighty God that the oath or affirmation of this without any disrespect to our 17 that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance should not include sovereign … allegiance to Her Majesty, Queen renunciation of all other allegiance. Pledge of Commitment Elizabeth the Second, Her Heirs and In 1986 the Minister for Immigration Form of Pledge No. 1 From this time forward, under God, I Successors according to law. and Ethnic Affairs, the Hon. Chris pledge my loyalty to Australia and its Affirmation of Allegiance Hurford MP, described renunciation as people, whose democratic beliefs I I, A. B., renouncing all other 'ambiguous and unnecessary'.14 allegiance, solemnly and sincerely share, whose rights and liberties I Oath of Allegiance promise and declare that I will be respect, and whose laws I will uphold I swear by Almighty God that I will faithful and bear true allegiance to and obey. be faithful and bear true allegiance to Her Majesty, Queen Elizabeth the Form of Pledge No. 2 Her Majesty Elizabeth the Second, Second, Her Heirs and Successors From this time forward, I pledge my Queen of Australia, Her heirs and according to law. loyalty to Australia and its people, successors according to law, and that whose democratic beliefs I share, 1973 Australian Citizenship Act: I will faithfully observe the laws of insertion of reference to Queen of whose rights and liberties I respect, Australia and fulfil my duties as an Australia12 and whose laws I will uphold and Australian citizen. Oath of Allegiance obey. Affirmation of Allegiance I, A. B., renouncing all other The Pledge came into effect in January I solemnly and sincerely promise and allegiance, swear by Almighty God 1994. There have been no changes that I will be faithful and bear true declare that I will be faithful and bear since. allegiance to Her Majesty Elizabeth true allegiance to Her Majesty the Second, Queen of Australia, Her Elizabeth the Second, Queen of heirs and successors according to Australia, Her heirs and successors law, and that I will faithfully observe according to law, and that I will Deirdre McKeown faithfully observe the laws of Politics and Public the laws of Australia and fulfil my Administration Group Australia and fulfil my duties as an duties as an Australian citizen. Information and Research Affirmation of Allegiance Australian citizen. Services I, A. B., renouncing all other 1993 Amendment: introduction of a Views expressed in this Research Note 15 allegiance, solemnly and sincerely Pledge of Commitment to replace the are those of the author and do not promise and declare that I will be oath or affirmation of allegiance and necessarily reflect those of the faithful and bear true allegiance to removal of reference to the Crown Information and Research Services and In 1993 the ALP made a commitment are not to be attributed to the Her Majesty Elizabeth the Second, Department of the Parliamentary Queen of Australia, Her heirs and to 'replace the old Oath of Allegiance Library. Research Notes provide concise successors according to law, and that with a Pledge of Commitment as a analytical briefings on issues of interest Citizen of the Country of Australia'.16 to Senators and Members. As such they I will faithfully observe the laws of may not canvass all of the key issues. Australia and fulfil my duties as an Introducing the legislation the Minister Advice on legislation or legal policy Australian citizen. for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs, issues contained in this paper is provided for use in parliamentary debate 1986 Amendment: removal of Senator the Hon. Nick Bolkus said: and for related parliamentary purposes. renunciation13 and removal of … we need to have an oath of This paper is not professional legal requirement that candidates state their allegiance which reflects the core opinion. names when taking the oath or making  Commonwealth of Australia the affirmation ISSN 1328-8016 The Human Rights Commission Endnotes

1. Helen Irving, 'Citizenship before 1949', Individual Community Nation, Kim Rubenstein (ed.), Australian Scholarly Publishing, Melbourne, 2000, p.10. 2. Kim Rubenstein, Australian Citizenship Law in Context, Lawbook Co., 2002, p. 47. 3. The British Nationality and Status of Aliens Act 1914. Australia passed the Nationality Act 1920 4. Australian Citizenship Council, Australian citizenship for a new century, Canberra, 2000, p. 31. 5. In 1973 the Nationality and Citizenship Act 1948 was renamed the Australian Citizenship Act 1948. 6. House of Representatives, Debates, 30 September 1948, p. 1060. 7. Sir Ninian Stephen, 'Australian citizenship: past, present and future', Monash University Law Review, vol. 26, no. 2, 2001. 8. ibid. 9. For more details of legislative changes see Sarah O'Brien, 'Dual citizenship, foreign allegiance and s. 44(i) of the Australian Constitution', Background Papers, no. 29, Department of the Parliamentary Library, 1992, Appendix A. 10. Commenced 26 January 1949. 11. House of Representatives, Debates, 31 March 1966, p. 833. 12. The Australian Citizenship Act 1973 (Cwlth) effective 1 December 1973, also sought to remove the renunciation in the oath but this was defeated in the Senate. 13. Repeal of renunciation on oath by Australian Citizenship Amendment Act 1986, effective 20 August 1986. 14. House of Representatives, Debates, 19 February 1986, p. 868. 15. Australian Citizenship Amendment Act 1993. 16. Australian Labor Party, Advancing a Multicultural Australia, Immigration and Ethnic Affairs Policy, 1993 federal election. 17. Senate, Debates, 29 September 1993, p. 1439.