Nonlinear Acoustic Synthesis in Augmented Musical Instruments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Nonlinear Acoustic Synthesis in Augmented Musical Instruments Herbert H.C. Chang Lloyd May Spencer Topel Dartmouth College Dartmouth College Dartmouth College Bregman Studios Bregman Studios Bregman Studios Hanover, NH 03755 Hanover, NH 03755 Hanover, NH 03755 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] ABSTRACT observe nonlinearities that arise in analog electronics and This paper discusses nonlinear acoustic synthesis in aug- engineer physical systems as comparable since they obey mented musical instruments via acoustic transduction. Our similar mathematical constructions. With control over the work expands previous investigations into acoustic ampli- finer mechanics of intermodulation in specific conditions, tude modulation, offering new prototypes that produce in- it is possible to enhance and control rich nonlinear timbre termodulation in several instrumental contexts. Our results modification in augmented acoustic instruments. show nonlinear intermodulation distortion can be generated The sections of this paper are structured as follows: We and controlled in electromagnetically driven acoustic inter- discuss the motivations for nonlinear acoustic synthesis and faces that can be deployed in acoustic instruments through prior work in Section 2, and we present several implemen- augmentation, thus extending the nonlinear acoustic syn- tations of nonlinear acoustic instrument prototypes in Sec- thesis to a broader range of sonic applications. tion 3. Section 4 constructs the mathematical framework of intermodulation and demonstrates the machinery required to synthesize and control intermodulation products in terms Author Keywords of frequency and amplitude. Section 5 presents the main acoustic synthesis, acoustic signal modulation, intermodu- experimental methods which are evaluated and discussed in lation, acoustic sound module, augmented instrument, har- section 6, finishing with conclusions in Section 7. monic oscillators, nonlinear interfaces, acoustic waveshap- ing 2. MOTIVATION AND PRIOR WORK 2.1 Motivation ACM Classification Due to the easy access to large-scale audio storage, there H.5.5 [Signal analysis, synthesis, and processing]|Sound is reduced demand in music creation for emulation of mu- and Music Computing, H.5.5 [Modeling]|Sound and Music sical instrument timbres via FM synthesis for instrument Computing, J.2 [Physics]|Physical Sciences and Engineer- timbres [5], voice [6], and other novel digital synthesis tech- ing niques, such as Physical Modeling Synthesis [1, 12]. Yet, it is possible to apply sophisticated digital processing tech- 1. INTRODUCTION niques in acoustic systems via augmentation to transform nearly all acoustic instruments into expressive modular syn- Acoustic instruments and speakers exhibit circumstantial thesizers, extending both timbre and control. Bridging the nonlinear distortions, generating additional frequency com- virtual to the physical is thus the primary motivation for ponents [11]. In speaker design, for instance, these distor- this work, offering new ways contextualize electronic music tions are seen as undesirable, spurious, and warranting mit- in the acoustic domain. Additionally, the method used to igation [8]. Instead of suppressing these nonlinear distor- bridge the virtual and physical should be readily applicable tions, we discuss several ways nonlinear distortions can be to existing instruments and interfaces. controlled in simulated and experimental physical systems. Specifically, we define nonlinear acoustic synthesis as the 2.2 Prior Work amplification, excitation, and control of frequency content Modulation is often used in sound synthesis to reduce the not salient or present in the original signal or excitation number of oscillators needed to generate complex timbres sources of any acoustic instrument. by producing additional signal components prior to the out- At the center of this investigation is intermodulation (IM), put. For example, FM Synthesis is employed to emulate a phenomenon summarized as the high-order sum and dif- rich timbres of acoustic instruments [5]. Another method of ference of frequency harmonics generated by a nonlinear modulation synthesis is via Intermodulation (IM), a form of system. Unlike mixing amplifiers and wave-shaping circuits amplitude modulation acting on the signal harmonics from that produce intermodulation in an electrical system, we are two or more injected signals. Harmonics arise from nonlin- primarily interested in producing intermodulation through earities intrinsic to electrical or physical systems. acoustic transduction via solids, gases, and fluids. One can IM is found in electrical systems such as amplifiers and effects for musical purposes. For example, "power chords" played on electric guitars are an effect resulting from IM within an over-driven mixing amplifier [2]. IM can produce Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution strong subharmonics by injecting two harmonic-rich signals 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). Copyright into a nonlinear electrical amplifier. We propose here a me- remains with the author(s). chanical method that generates intermodulation and para- NIME’17, May 15-19, 2017, Aalborg University Copenhagen, Denmark. metric acoustic timbres in an acoustic system, such as an . augmented musical instrument or effect systems. 358 3. NONLINEAR ACOUSTIC SYNTHESIS motor (VCM) generating a periodic signal B, detailed in 3.1 General Model Figure 2. The basic concept for the instrument is to generate in- We proposed a modular instrument exhibiting intermodula- termodulation through periodic damping of sound propa- tion shown in Figure 3 [3]. Expanding on this work we gen- gation, and thus can be generalized and embedded into any eralize our approach aimed at designing or modifying mu- wind instrument where the primary port is located at the sical instruments capable of producing controllable nonlin- end of the instrument. ear acoustic synthesis. Figure 1 illustrates the basic model 3.3 Idiophone and Membranophone Prototypes Idiophone and Membranophone instrument prototypes were Excitation Source Modulation Source (signal A) (signal B) implemented with equivalent functional design as the Side- Band modular acoustic synthesizer shown in Figure 3. The system consists of a tuning fork that behaves as a Harmonic Oscillator (signal A) when driven by an electromagnetic ac- Bridge Interface tuator. The tuning fork acoustically transduces a signal into a T-Frame bridge interface. A voice coil motor generates the modulation source (signal B) that effects the interaction be- nonlinear interaction tween the bridge and soundboard. The entire system and function is further discussed in [3]. To test the membranophone condition, we simply replaced Physical Medium the soundboard with a drumhead, allowing the bridge to in- teract directly with the membrane at a distance determined acoustic output through experimentation. Likewise, for the idiophone con- dition simply required us to use the original soundboard from the SideBand instrument. As an extension of this Figure 1: Block Diagram Model for Nonlinear model, we also replaced the wooden soundboard with low- Acoustic Synthesis. carbon steel and acrylic soundboards to test the specific material properties in relation to nonlinear acoustic synthe- for nonlinear acoustic synthesis, where the primary system sis. components consist of an excitation source and a modu- lation source that mix in a bridge interface as to produce nonlinear synthesis between a bridge and a physical medium 4. THEORY OF INTERMODULATION such as a gas, solid, or liquid. Such mediums in musical IM was first discovered in the context of radio engineer- instruments are included those categorized as idiophones, ing, and subsequently in speaker design along with other membranophones, chordophones, and aerophones [13]. The engineering contexts [7]. For the sake of generality, we first acoustic output is then simply the acoustic mechanism in- analyze intermodulation as a mathematical construct be- herent in the modified instrument or design, such as a res- tween two harmonic oscillators, A cos(!at) and B cos(!bt), onator, waveguide, or vent. or Oscillator A and B, respectively. We define the specific elements of the block diagram the When a signal passes through an arbitrary nonlinear sys- following way: tem, harmonic multiples appear. For example, if the input signal of a nonlinear system is cos !t, then there will be • Excitation Source: An arbitrary signal source A output signals consisting of the harmonics cos 2!t, cos 3!t, acoustically transduced into a bridge interface. cos 4!t,::: cos N!t. N will later be defined as the order of intermodulation. In the case where two or more signals • Modulation Source: A signal source B capable are injected into a nonlinear system, as is the case with a of interaction with the excitation source within the harmonic oscillator, then all harmonics will be present. Am- bridge interface. plitude modulation then occurs on both the injected signal and their respective harmonics, as defined in Appendix A.1. • Bridge Interface: The bridge interface provides the When two harmonic oscillator A and B inject signals critical mixing stage for the two signals A and B re- A cos(! t) and B cos(! t) respectively into a nonlinear sys- spectively, whose coupled behavior with the physical a b tem, the output signal contains IM products. The products medium produces nonlinear acoustic synthesis are dependent on the order of intermodulation. The IM • Physical Medium: The matter