Chemical Abundances in Virgo Spiral Galaxies II: Effects of Cluster
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CHEMICAL ABUNDANCES IN VIRGO SPIRAL GALAXIES I I EFFECTS OF CLUSTER ENVIRONMENT Evan D Skillman Astronomy Department University of Minnesota Church St S E Minneap olis MN skillmanzonspaumnedu Rob ert C Kennicutt Jr Steward Observatory University of Arizona Tucson AZ robkasarizonaedu Gregory A Shields Astronomy Department University of Texas Austin TX shieldsastroasutexasedu and Dennis Zaritsky UCOLick Observatory and Board of Astronomy and Astrophysics astro-ph/9511019 03 Nov 95 University of California Santa Cruz CA dennislickucscedu Received accepted Based on observations obtained at the Multiple Mirror Telescope a joint facility of the University of Arizona and the Smithsonian Institution ABSTRACT We present new measurements of chemical abundances in H II regions in spiral galaxies of the Virgo cluster and a comparison of Virgo galaxies and eld spirals With these new data there now exist nine Virgo spirals with abundance measurements for at least four H II regions Our sample of Virgo galaxies ranges from H I decient ob jects near the core of the cluster to galaxies with normal H I prop erties far from the cluster core We investigate the relationship b etween H I disk characteristics and chemical abundances to determine whether dynamical pro cesses that remove gas from the disk such as ram pressure stripping by the intracluster medium also aect the chemical abundances We divide the nine Virgo spirals into three groups of three galaxies each those with strong H I deciencies intermediate cases and those with no H I deciencies The three most H I decient Virgo spirals have larger mean abundances to dex in OH than the spirals on the p eriphery of the cluster This suggests that dynamical pro cesses asso ciated with the cluster environment are more imp ortant than cluster membership in determining the current chemical prop erties of spiral galaxies There is also weak evidence of shallower abundance gradients in the H I decient Virgo spirals We also compare the abundance prop erties of our Virgo sample to a large sample of eld spirals studied by Zaritsky Kennicutt Huchra Those authors found that the mean abundance of the disk gas increases with increasing maximum circular velocity increasing luminosity and decreasing earlier Hubble type but with a large disp ersion in the mean abundances and abundance gradients The disp ersion in the prop erties of eld galaxies and the small size of the Virgo sample make it dicult to draw denitive conclusions ab out any systematic dierence b etween the eld and Virgo spirals Nevertheless the H I decient Virgo galaxies have larger mean abundances than eld galaxies of comparable luminosity or Hubble type while the spirals at the p eriphery of the cluster are indistinguisha ble from the eld galaxies Simple illustrative chemical evolution mo dels with infall of metalp o or gas are constructed and compared to mo dels in which the infall is terminated The mo dels are constrained by comparison with observed gas mass fractions current star formation rates and gas consumption times The mo del results indicate that the curtailment of infall of metalp o or gas onto cluster core spirals may explain part of the enhanced abundance However additional work is needed particularly mo deling of the eects of truncating the outer gaseous disk within the context of mo dels with radial gas transp ort The increased abundances in cluster core latetype spirals relative to eld galaxies may b e imp ortant in the interpretation of observations of these galaxies Sp ecically we p oint to p ossible eects on the TullyFisher and Cepheid variable distance determinations and the interpretation of colors in the ButcherOemler eect Subject headings galaxies abundances galaxies clustering galaxies evolution galaxies interstellar medium galaxies intergalactic medium galaxies structure galaxies distances nebulae H II regions INTRODUCTION Spiral galaxies are mo died by the environment within a rich cluster of galaxies see reviews by Haynes and Whitmore and the introduction to Henry et al Such eects as tidal stripping ram pressure stripping and ablation by the intracluster medium must aect galaxy evolution The cluster environment clearly inuences galaxy morphology Dressler Postman Geller and so a natural question is whether it also aects the star formation history and chemical evolution of galaxies Do es the cluster environment predetermine galaxy morphology by solely inuencing initial conditions or do es it continually inuence the evolution of a member galaxy Comparing the chemical abundances of eld and cluster members may provide clues to these fundamental questions Moreover a systematic abundance dierential b etween cluster and eld galaxies would have implications for the stellar p opulations and could impact a number of currently p opular distance indicators The Virgo cluster due to its proximity provides the logical starting p oint for the study of environmental eects on abundances in cluster spirals The Virgo cluster is irregular and in some resp ects this compromises the study of environmental eects However the extensive catalog of the p ositions morphologies and radial velocities of galaxies by Binggeli Sandage Tammann allows a denition of the clusters structure In addition the structure of the hot gas comp onent which has b een revealed through sensitive mapping of the Xray emission made p ossible by ROSAT Boringer et al is very similar to the galaxy distribution Substantial evidence p oints to dierences b etween the spiral galaxies in the core of the Virgo cluster and eld spiral galaxies Davies Lewis rst p ointed to a deciency in H I gas in Virgo spirals when compared to eld spirals Giovanelli Haynes showed that galaxies in the outer parts of the Virgo cluster and eight other clusters were less decient in H I than the galaxies in the core of the cluster From H I synthesis observations of Virgo cluster spirals Warmels concluded the H I deciencies could b e attributed to a depletion of the H I at large galacto centric radii This was supp orted by Cayatte et al CKBG Because the star formation history of a galaxy is related to its gas content it is logical to ask if the chemical abundances in the cluster spirals are dierent from those of eld galaxies Shields Skillman Kennicutt SSK presented sp ectrophotometry of H II regions in ve Virgo spirals The Virgo spirals app eared to b e considerably more metal rich dex than the typical galaxy in their eld sample SSK suggested that such a dierence could result from dierences in infall or radial inow rates Henry et al HPLC and Henry Pagel Chincarini HPC conducted intensive studies of two Virgo spirals and found the evidence of a Virgoeld dierential less convincing Hence the issue of chemical abundance anomalies in the Virgo cluster is unresolved The existing data sets have b een to o small to address the most fundamental physical question whether the chemical prop erties of the H I decient galaxies in the core of the Virgo cluster are dierent from those of undisturb ed galaxies in Virgo or elsewhere We have undertaken a larger investigation which is aimed at addressing these problems in four ways by enlarging the Virgo sample choosing galaxies within Virgo that span the range of observed H I prop erties using published data on the H I distributions within galaxies to examine the relationship b etween the H I distribution and chemical abundance and by comparing the prop erties of the Virgo galaxies to a much larger sample of eld spirals than was previously available This study includes measurements of more H II regions in the strongly H I decient galaxies NGC and NGC for which SSK had only one H II region each and in several spirals with mo derate or no H I deciency Our work increases the number of Virgo spirals with abundance measurements of four or more H II regions to nine For a comparison eld sample we use the data for eld spirals recently published by Zaritsky Kennicutt Huchra ZKH In this pap er we describ e the observations and discuss the implications for the questions raised ab ove In Section we discuss the sample selection new observations data reduction pro cedures and OH abundance determinations In Section we discuss the abundance prop erties of the Virgo spirals test for any dep endence of abundance prop erties on cluster lo cation or H I deciency and use the ZKH results to determine whether there are any systematic dierences b etween the eld and cluster galaxies In Section we characterize and quantify the abundance dierential seen for the H I decient spiral galaxies In Section we assess these results in the context of a simple mo del for environmental eects on chemical evolution and in Section we outline future observational pro jects and discuss the implications of elevated abundances for other studies of cluster spirals OBSERVATIONS Galaxy Selection The primary ob jective of this program is to measure H II region abundances for a large number of Virgo cluster spirals that span a larger range of H I deciency Following SSK we chose to restrict our sample to latetype spirals those classied as type Sb c or later in the Revised ShapleyAmes Catalog RSA Sandage Tammann This was done to limit the variation in abundances due to variations in galaxy type Oey Kennicutt OK ZKH and to take advantage of the brighter H II regions in latetype galaxies We compiled a list of spirals in this type range that were mapp ed in H I by Warmels or Cayatte et al We then selected a subset of galaxies exhibiting the full