Cleavage in Some Sedimentary Rocks of the Central Valley and Ridge Province, Maryland
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Cleavage in Some Sedimentary Rocks of the Central Valley and Ridge Province, Maryland P. A. GEISER Department of Geology, University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut 06268 ABSTRACT Limited field evidence suggests that the preferred orientation shown by burrow cross sections may be controlled by paleocurrent The Cacapon Mountain anticline of the folded Appalachian directions, making the burrows a possible current indicator. Fi- Mountains contains rocks ranging in age from Early Silurian to nally, it is suggested that the fabric imposed by the burrowing or- Early Devonian. The Middle Silurian Bloomsburg Formation ap- ganisms may have localized and controlled the development of the proximates a thin, viscous plate embedded in a less viscous Sp cleavage. Key words: structural geology, finite strain, Silurian medium. The presence of scolithuslike burrows, useful as strain ichnology. markers, makes the Bloomsburg Formation an excellent unit for studying the folding of a sedimentary plate. INTRODUCTION Examination of the microscopic fabric of rock containing a so- This paper analyzes the deformation of some unmetamorphosed called "fracture cleavage" reveals the presence of discontinuous, sedimentary rocks in the folded Appalachian Mountains. Although platy zones containing tectonically oriented quartz and mica frag- numerous strain studies have been made in metamorphic terranes, ments. It is deduced that the shape and orientation of the quartz strain analysis has only infrequently been applied to sedimentary fragments is largely due to differential solution; however, there is rocks that have not undergone regional penetrative deformation some evidence of mechanical rotation of the fragments. As the (Nickelsen, 1966; Breddin, 1956; Plessman, 1966). "fracture cleavage" does not fit the classical definition (being lo- The Bloomsburg Formation in the Cacapon Mountain anticline cally penetrative), it has been designated Sp cleavage for the pur- is a thin (15-m) plate of siliceous siltstone, embedded in a thick se- poses of this paper. quence of incompetent sedimentary rocks. This is physically Finite strain analysis shows that the cleavage postdates analogous to a thin, viscous elastic plate embedded in a less viscous lithification, that it formed perpendicular to bedding and parallel to medium. The Bloomsburg Formation also contains natural strain the plane of the finite strain ellipsoid containing X! and X2, and that markers in the form of small vertical burrows, making it an excel- it is a plane of flattening. The Sp cleavage is interpreted as a lent unit to use in a deformation study. phenomenon marking a transition point in the material behavior of The Hancock region of the Cacapon Mountain anticline (Stose the rock. The transition point was reached after the rock under- and Swartz, 1912, p. 129-131; Swartz, 1923) is located im- went a maximum two-dimensional irreversible strain of e = 0.06. mediately west of Hancock, Maryland (Fig. 1). The anticline lies in This small strain is in contrast to the values of e = 0.30 that have the eastern half of the Valley and Ridge province of the central Ap- been suggested for slaty cleavage. During progressive deformation, palachians and west of the "tectonite" front (Fellows, 1943). the Sp cleavage became structurally passive, permitting it to be used Geologic mapping of the region was done by Stose and Swartz as a strain marker in the determination of strain about fold profiles (1912), and Swartz (1923, p. 152) did detailed stratigraphy. (ac surface). Rocks ranging in age from earliest Silurian to Early Devonian are Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 85, p. 1399-1412, 19 figs., September 1974 1399 Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/85/9/1399/3428958/i0016-7606-85-9-1399.pdf by guest on 29 September 2021 1400 P. A. GEISER Study Samples containing burrows were collected at 17 localities (Fig. Area P*• 2). Where a fold is well exposed, three samples were collected from KWJH anco c k the same bed — a sample from each limb and one from the crest of the fold. At all other localities only one sample was collected. Each sample was cut in three perpendicular directions. The ini- tial cut was perpendicular to the cleavage and approximately paral- lel to bedding (a in Fig. 3). The second cut was perpendicular to W. Va. both bedding and cleavags (b in Fig. 3), and the third cut was paral- lel to cleavage and perpendicular to bedding (c in Fig. 3). DESCRIPTION OF CLEAVAGE IN THE BLOOMSBURG FORMATION The Bloomsburg and lower Wills Creek Formations show a con- sistent cleavage as a conspicuous plane of parting, roughly perpen- dicular to the bedding (Fig. 4). This cleavage, frequently as promi- Figure 1. Location of study area. nent as bedding, has been mentioned only briefly in the literature on the central folded Appalachians. exposed in the anticline. The lower units consist of shale and Gair (1949, p. 30) described it as "appearing to be fracture fine-grained sandstone. The rocks become increasingly calcareous cleavage." Stevens (1959, p. 25—30) referred to "radial joints nor- upward, and the highest units are limestone. A generalized strati- mal to bedding," attributed to early tensional stresses. Cloos graphic column is given in Table 1. (1951, p. 156) described the structure simply as "cleavage normal The structures exposed in the western Maryland railroad cuts at to the bedding and fanning through a large angle." Roundtop and Woodmont have been described by Gair (1949), Both the fanning nature of the cleavage and its occasional sig- Cloos (1951), and Stevens (1959), but there has been no systematic moidal form have been described by Stevens (1959) and Cloos study of strain or use of strain markers. Because the rocks are in the i'1951). Cloos suggested that the cleavage formed early and possi- early stages of deformation, they retain an almost complete strain bly prior to folding. Gair also implied an early origin for the cleav- history. age, finding that the "fracture cleavage" in the Wills Creek induced Finite strain was measured in 20 samples from 17 different no preferred crystallographic orientation. The lack of preferred localities (Fig. 2). X-ray photographs were made of 15 samples to orientation suggested to Gair that the cleavage may have formed reveal internal structure. prior to consolidation. Field Methods. Mapping was done on parts of the two W2' A second type of cleavage found in the Bloomsburg Formation is quadrangles (U.S. Geological Survey, 1951a, 1951b), enlarged to a restricted to the shaly unirs and is characterized by a small angle, scale of 1:6,156. A total of 837 stations were made over the 32.7 between 5° and 45°, made with bedding (B-3 in Fig. 4b). This 2 km mapped, with three to four measurements made per station. In cleavage has been designated Sa. The so-called "fracture cleavage," an effort to utilize as much of the generally poor exposures as pos- approximately perpendicular to bedding, is designated Sp. The two sible, traverses were made close to one another with some lines cleavages never occur in the same bed. only 164 m apart. TABLE 1. GENERALIZE: STRATIGRAPHIC SECTION Sp CLEAVAGE AT HANCCCK, MARYLAND* Macroscopic Description Age Formation Thickness Llthology Or) The Sp cleavage is a set of prominent subparallel irregular sur- faces (Figs. 4a, b), which are usually 1 to 2 cm apart. Examination Oriskany Group 65.5 Massive orthoquartzite; thin, dis- continuous cherty layers at base of the bedding surfaces shows a faint lineation parallel to the Helderberg Formation 52.4 Thin- to massive-bedded limestone cleavage-bedding intersection designated Lx. with occasional shale interbeds or scattered chert layers One of the most consistent characteristics of the cleavage is its angle with bedding. The angles between cleavage and bedding Keyser Limestone 95.} Massive, nodular limestone at base; poles from 130 stations were measured on a stereographic net, and grades upward to thin-bedded limestone with considerable shale the sets were plotted on ?. frequency diagram (Fig. 5). Half the Tonoloway Limestone 132.0 Thin- to medium-bedded laminated angles fall between 82° and 90°; the remainder are scattered over IC limestone with platy appearance the intervals between 58° and 82°. Wills Creek Shale 147.0 Limestone interbedded with calcar- eous shale, sandstone,and mudstone The Sp cleavage ends abruptly at the base of the Bloomsburg Bloomsburg Formation 14.7 Massive red siltstone with a few Formation and gradually disappears upward as the siltstone be- yellow and red shale and sandstone interbeds comes progressively more calcareous and less burrowed. The close correlation between burrowing and Sp cleavage is visi- McKenzie Formation 75.3 Dark calcareous shale and thin argillaceous limestone ble at a number of exposures in a fine-grained sandstone member of Rochester Shale 9.£5 Dark calcareous shale the lower Bloomsburg Formation. The cleavage, well developed in Keefer Sandstone 8.1 Fine- to medium-grain quartz sand- adjacent beds, is completely lacking in the unburrowed sandstone. stone, thin- to medium-bedded Figure 4 shows this relation clearly; S cleavage in burrowed silt- Dark shale with scattered interbeds p of thin- to medium-bedded fine stone ends at the edge of a i>ed (B-3 in Fig. 4b) consisting of inter- Rose Hill Formation 196.5 sandstone bedded shales and sandstone lenses. Thin- to thick-bedded orthoquartzite Tuscarora Formation 124.5 with scattered interbeds of thin Microscopic Description shale Although cleavage is visible in all hand specimens, its develop- * After Swartz (1923Ì. ment varies considerably on the microscopic scale. The framework Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/85/9/1399/3428958/i0016-7606-85-9-1399.pdf by guest on 29 September 2021 CLEAVAGE IN SOME SEDIMENTARY ROCKS OF THE CENTRAL VALLEY AND RIDGE PROVINCE, MARYLAND 1401 of the Bloomsburg siltstone consists of more than 95 percent quartz 42) and Ramsay (1967, p.