Evolution Vs. Intelligent Design a Torah
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1"ti::i. ?v m:l'"iN:! ''M"V ?:i•n:; 111 O"M '; ::in:i 1"0111n JO'l 1V1M ?111 "1::no::nx 1V'X11V!1"::i iT.lXl'.l::J ,;n J'lll::J 1l'?x 1l!l1;J1V m?xv? ;i:11111n::i .;i!l::i ;1:.'':.'T.l nw1!l::i ':ixi1V' n1UX ;iopiv m':i1v!l;i 11V1nn 11•1 •;nx 111/)ll ':i"m ;nxn::i 11mn111 O'i::i1;i l'':i;;m 0'1V:.''11 m'?W!l'11V i';i::i;i? m1::11 .;ii riv::i m?1n111;i;; 1!l1K •::i:i':i ;inv1 nx o•!lp111m ,;i1m;i ,,,,, n::iv1r.i ov p1p11m no'pJ ''::i ,vi::i;i::i mvv;i? ;i:i•1:s ;ii xw1J::i m':i1nw;i;i111 ,;inv o:i 1mv1 111 ,1K 1mv1? nx ':>:io? ;i?1l:>v;i n>i1?in;i n11111pn;n D'l1n')l'1l:l n;m•r.i ::i? nmvn n11v•111 '::JT.l1!l::i m'?W!l oKn;;::i nxm ;;111,:i? mll'.lKJ::J ;ip::i1 ?x1w' n1uK .;i!l::i ;i:;•::ir.i ?v ;;n;;;; l\';'1111 ;ii-on;i mv;i .N::io l:>Ni1U' ?111 ;i::i;1::n un:n1;i? inv? ?x11V' nitiK n'mi;ir.i 1i111p::i1 ,;i1vo;i 1:i1n::i imv;i ?;nn;i ?111 nv:s::i o•!lnniun umx OK ,i::i1;i •1:;1 K? trn ,n?vm? ;ii K'1'1V ;iv1;i 1l'?v ;i?::ipm x? ,cir.ix .o"Oi!l'11'l'l)l::i 1? ::i1vn;;? "Ii1Vl'.l;i ?111 1m:ir ':iv j?iX' N1l n"1'V ?111 mx•;::i;i "I1111r.i ov 1"117'.lnn ?Ki1V' n-mx n•:i1;;? nm:ir.i m';i':i ;i::l'1:.' ?mn? i11v':> im'::i ;;?1?v;i m':nniu;i;iv 1inv1 .;il:>x 1r.i:i O'l'lV:! .mp1i•n;i? 1V1'l\1V O'T.l1;11':i 11j?l'.l;'1 x1;i ]'XV ?::i1pl'.l1 O:J01T.l 111:! .i"~ ,ji1X' Kil ,{own i"l': 1Z11n? i":i /"::m? ::i"1:1 ;1V'T.ln 01•:i omn;i ?v ux:i i"J.'1 -(jiff?».. o~ fi]j (r!i~U!;;u 2~1;i i~trc-b ryrnnNB {ll (J"'4J' c:i i .. (Free Translation) In the Nissan 5766 issue of The Jewish Observer, Rabbi Chaim Dovid Zwiebel described at length the actions taken by Agudath Israel on the issue of metzitza b'peh. In response to certain questions that have been directed to us regarding this matter, we wish to make it clear that the actions and positions described in that article were executed after long and careful deliberation with the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah, and reflect our view as to how this matter should have been handled. We believed then, as we do now, that shtadlonus on this issue should be done quietly and behind the scenes, without taking public actions that would generate additional attention in the newspapers and general media that could be counterproductive to Statement the cause of protecting metzitza b'peh. Agudath Israel has faithfully adhered to this of Moetzes approach, in accordance with our direction and the traditional Jewish way. We are sympathetic to the pain of the individual mohel at the center of the recent Gedolei controversy, and we instructed Agudath Israel to help him in his individual case. However, we did not believe it would be productive or appropriate for Agudath Israel HaTorah of to contest the New York City Health Department's right to be involved in such matters altogether. In our opinion, the shtadlonus approach most likely to help the mohel Agudath should be directed toward factually establishing, in an agreed and accepted way, that he was not the source of any infections that occurred to the infants. Israel of Signed this Thursday, the 42nd day of the Omer, 27 lyar 5766, New York. America Rabbi Simcha Bunim Ehrenfeld Rabbi Shmuel Kamenetsky Rabbi Yaakov Perlow Rabbi Ahron Feldman Rabbi Avrohom Chaim Levin Rabbi Aaron Schechter Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah of Agudath Israel of America -·-··· ---.~ -.. ~ -.- .:_ -.. _·· .·· ...- .- ..•.-· .. -l IN THIS ISSUE THE JEWISH OBSERVER (ISSN) 0021-6615 IS l'UBl.ISHEO MONTHLY. EXlTl~T JIJLY & Al!GUST ANO A COMBINE!) ISSUE FOR 4 NOTED IN SORROW JANllAllY/fEBl{UARY, BY THE AG\IDATH ISRAF.L 01' AMERICA, 42 BROADWAY. NF.W YoRK, NY !0004. PERIODICALS POSTAGE PAID IN Nr:;w YORK, NY. SUBSCRIPTION S\!5.00/YEAR; EVOLUTION VERSUS INTELLIGENT DESIGN \!YEARS, S46.oo; 3 YEARS, S69.00. OUTSIDE OF THE UNITED STATES (lJS 5 INTRODUCTION HINDS DRAWN ON A tJS BANK ONLY) Sts.oo SURCHARGE PER y~:AR. SINGLE COPY S3,50; OUTSIDE NY AREA S3,95; 6 EVOLUTION VERSUS INTELLIGENT DESIGN FOREIGN S4.50. - A TORAH PERSPECTIVE, POSTMASTER: SEN!) ADDIH:ss CliANGES T(); THE Jr-:WISH 0BSEl~VER Rabbi Chaim Dov Keifer 42 BROADWAY, NY, NY 10004 TEL 212-797-9000, fAX 646-254-1600 I. THE EVOLUTION WARS: PRINTED IN THE lJSA RABBI N!SSON WOLPIN, Editor LEGISLATIVE AND LEGAL FRONTS Editorial Board II. THE COSMIC QUESTION: RABBI JOSEPH EuAS, Cbairmao RABBI ABBA BRlJDNY RANDOM EVOLUTION OR JOSEPH l'RIEDENSON RABRI YISROEL MEIR KlRZNER RABBI NossoN SCHERMAN !NTELUGENT DESIGN? PROf. AA RON TWf.l~SKI Ill. THE ATTEMPTED SYNTHESIS OF TORAH tiJUnders DR. ERNST L. BODENHEIMER ZHI. AND EVOLUTION RABB! MOSHE SME!H\R z~I. Management Board 22 THE THIRD WORD, Dr. Chaim Presby NAFTOLI HIRSCH. ISA,._C KIRZNER, RABB! SHE.OMO !.ESIN, 27 THE MYTH OF SCIENTIFIC OBJECTIVITY, DAVID SINGER, NACMUM STEIN Man(}ging fdit(}r Yonoson Rosenblum RABBI YOSEF C. GOLDIN(; PUBLISHED BY AGUDATH !SRAEI. OF AMERICA 35 REBBE AND FATHER: THE PNEI MENACHEM, 11.S. TRADE i)IST!UBUTOR FEl.OflEIM PUBLISHERS RABBI PINCHOs MENACHEM ALTER, ?•·:;7, 208 Airport fa·ecutire ft1rh Nanurt.NYrn9;>4 Rabbi Avrohom Birnbaum BRITISH REPRESENTA'JIVF M.T. BIBFLMAN Grosvenor \~brhs Mount Plcasa11l l/i// London l:j 9NE f.NGIAND 43 SIMCHOS VS. QUALITY OF LIFE, f'JlENCH REPRESl,NTATIVE RABBI BAMBERGER Rabbi Aryeh Zev Ginzberg 21 &mlITard ftiixhons 57000 Metz. FRANC!: ISRAELI REPIH':SENTATIVE INTNL. MEDIA PLACEMENT f'OB 71.95 I 97 Jaffa Road STATEMENT OF POLICY }cr11salem 94:;40. !SRAE:L THE ]EW!Sfl OBSERVER HAS DEVOTED A GREAT DEAL OF SPACE TO BELGIAN RF.PitESENTATIVE HIE PERILS OF THE INTERNET AND TO THE NF.ED FOR EVERYONE TO MR. E.Al'TER BE EXTREMELY VIGILANT IN ITS USE. WE l·l."-VE ECHOED TllE PLEAS 1.ange Kiel'ilstr. :w 2018 Antwerp. Bf./_GI/ !M OF OUR GEOOI.IM THAT IT SUOllLI) NOT BE IN llSf;. UNLESS IT IS AN UNAVOIDABLE NECESSITY, AND THEN ONLY WITH ALL SUITABLE SOUTH AFRICAN REPl!ESENTATIVE THE JEWISH OBSERVER Dor;s NOT ASSUME MR. V. TABACK SAFEGUARJ)S, WHILE lTS OANGERS MUST BE Rf:COGNJZED AND CON RESPONSlB!Lll'Y FOR THI; KASURUS OF ANY PROD!ICT, PO Box ,';1552, Rocdrne.jofwnnesburq PUllUC."-TION. OR SERVICE ADVE1n·1sEo IN ITS PAGES TROi.i.ED TO l\VERY POSSIBLE DEGREE, OUR GEDOUM RECOGNIZE THAT 2124 SOU!l-1 AFRICA MANY PEOPLE AND BUSINESSES REQUIRE ITS !!SE, AND THl'REFORE IT COPYRIGHT © 2006 HAS NOT BF.EN BANNED. Tu1s IS WHY WE ACCEl'T ADVERTISEMENTS AUSTRALIAN REPRESENTATIVE DR.A.DINNEN USTING w~:BS!Tf, ADDRESSES, BUT IN NO WAY DOES THIS IMPLY THAT n 81rri90 Rood MAY 2006 ! VOLUME xxxrx fl!E GEDOUM OR THE JEWISH 0BSEnVER CONDONE CASUAi. USE OF Bellevue Jfi/f. !VS\V 202.J. AUSTRAUA NO. lJ THE INT!": RN ET. --~---A-Y--~·-- -o o 6 -·-·------"--·----------.. -- ---- =l },•,' Noted in sorroi • Since our previous issue, Kial children, as well as his older brother, and chessed institutions were success Yisroef has suffered three irreplace the Sigheter Rav, did not survive. The fully established with his blessing and able losses in the leadership of our Rebbewas liberated from Theresienstadt under his guidance, and the Rebbe's people. We note with sorrow the in May, 1945. remarkable leadership abilities became petira of each of these extraordinary Rav Moshe married his present apparent. Despite his many communal men, in order of their passing. Rebbetzin, daughter of Rabbi Aharon responsibilities, he wrote the five-vol Teitlebaum of Wolowo, afrer the war. ume Beirach Moshe al Ha Torah, as well He first returned to Sighet, where he as a sefer called Maram (Moreinu Rav RABBI MOSHE TEITELBAUM 7"Yt took up the rabbinical position previ Moshe) Tav (TeitelBaum) on Torah and ously held by his brother, but under the mo'adim, and Haggada Beirach Moshe. On Monday, April 24/26 Nissan, If the Satmar schools in New York there was palpable grief throughout the were part of the public school net Chareidi world at the sad news of the work, they would be the fourth-largest petira of Rabbi Moshe Teitelbaum ?"Yt, system in the state, after those of New the Satmar Rebbe, at age 91. Leader of York City, Buffalo and Rochester. In the world's largest Chassidic group, with addition to the main Satmar kehillos well over 100,000 followers, the Rebbe in Williamsburg and Kiryas Yoe!, the was born at the beginning of World Rebbe had large numbers of Chassidim War I. He was the second son of Rabbi in Yerushalayim, Bnei Brak, Boro Park, Chaim Tzvi Teitelbaum ?"Yt, the Atzei Monsey, Lakewood, Montreal, London, Chaim of Sigh et (then Romania, now Manchester, Antwerp and other Hungary), and his Rebbetzin, a daughter Orthodox communities, who mourn of Rabbi Shulem Eliezer Halberstam ?'':>n the passing of their loyal manhig who of Ratzfert, a son of the Divrei Chayim served as a link to the great Rebbes of the of Sanz 7"Yt.