The Effect of Divided Attention on Encoding and Retrieval in Episodic Memory Revealed by Positron Emission Tomography

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Effect of Divided Attention on Encoding and Retrieval in Episodic Memory Revealed by Positron Emission Tomography The Effect of Divided Attention on Encoding and Retrieval in Episodic Memory Revealed by Positron Emission Tomography Tetsuya Iidaka University of Toronto Downloaded from http://mitprc.silverchair.com/jocn/article-pdf/12/2/267/1758705/089892900562093.pdf by guest on 18 May 2021 Nicole D. Anderson Princess Margaret Hospital Shitij Kapur Fukui Medical University Roberto Cabeza University of Alberta Fergus I. M. Craik University of Toronto Abstract & The effects of divided attention (DA) on episodic memory dorsolateral-prefrontal areas. Regions more active during encoding and retrieval were investigated in 12 normal young encoding than during retrieval were located in the hippocam- subjects by positron emission tomography (PET). Cerebral pus, temporal and the prefrontal cortex of the left hemisphere, blood flow was measured while subjects were concurrently and regions more active during retrieval than during encoding performing a memory task (encoding and retrieval of visually included areas in the medial and right-prefrontal cortex, basal presented word pairs) and an auditory tone-discrimination ganglia, thalamus, and cuneus. DA at encoding was associated task. The PET data were analyzed using multivariate Partial with specific decreases in rCBF in the left-prefrontal areas, Least Squares (PLS), and the results revealed three sets of whereas DA at retrieval was associated with decreased rCBF in neural correlates related to specific task contrasts. Brain a relatively small region in the right-prefrontal cortex. These activity, relatively greater under conditions of full attention different patterns of activity are related to the behavioral (FA) than DA, was identified in the occipital-temporal, medial, results, which showed a substantial decrease in memory and ventral-frontal areas, whereas areas showing relatively performance when the DA task was performed at encoding, more activity under DA than FA were found in the cerebellum, but no change in memory levels when the DA task was temporo-parietal, left anterior-cingulate gyrus, and bilateral performed at retrieval. & INTRODUCTION two processes because differences in performance Recent advances in functional neuroimaging techniques could be due to differences in encoding or retrieval. enable us to measure activity in the human brain while Neuroimaging studies provide the unique opportunity the subject is listening, thinking, paying attention, or to observe encoding and retrieval processes separately. remembering. In particular, memory functions in normal Previous studies of episodic memory using verbal mate- subjects have been investigated intensively by using rials indicate that left-prefrontal regions of the brain are positron emission tomography (PET), and these studies predominantly activated during episodic memory enco- have shed light on the neural correlates of encoding and ding; and, conversely, right-prefrontal regions are pre- retrieval processes in episodic memory (for reviews, see dominantly activated during episodic retrieval (Fletcher Cabeza & Nyberg, 1997; Fletcher, Frith, & Rugg, 1997). et al., 1995; Shallice et al., 1994; Tulving, Kapur, Craik, In behavioral studies of recall and recognition, it is Moscovitch, & Houle, 1994). In contrast, Kelley et al. impossible to disentangle the separate effects of the (1998) and Wagner et al. (1998) reported that the right- D 2000 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12:2, pp. 267±280 Downloaded from http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1162/089892900562093 by guest on 25 September 2021 prefrontal area is activated during encoding of nonverbal In the present study, subjects performed a memory materials. task and a secondary task concurrently; the memory task One of the main purposes of the present study was to involved encoding or retrieval of visually presented word examine the effects of divided attention (DA) on enco- pairs and verbal responses, whereas the secondary task ding and retrieval processes in human episodic memory involved easy or difficult auditory tone discrimination by using PET. When subjects are engaged in two differ- and manual responses. Based on previous results for ent tasks at once, they have to divide attention between verbal-memory tasks, we expected to see left-prefrontal the tasks and allocate mental resources to each task. activation associated with FA encoding (Tulving et al., Behavioral studies have shown that DA at encoding is 1994), and that this activation would be reduced in the associated with a substantial decrement in later memory DA condition (Fletcher et al., 1995; Shallice et al., 1994). Downloaded from http://mitprc.silverchair.com/jocn/article-pdf/12/2/267/1758705/089892900562093.pdf by guest on 18 May 2021 performance, whereas DA at retrieval results in compara- Similarly, we expected to find right-prefrontal activation tively slight declines in memory (Anderson, Craik, & associated with FA retrieval, and given that DA at Naveh-Benjamin, 1998; Craik, Govoni, Naveh-Benjamin, retrieval has only small effects on memory performance, & Anderson, 1996; Baddeley, Lewis, Eldridge, & Thom- we speculated that deactivation due to DA might be son, 1984). This pattern of results was found in cases small. where secondary task costs were equivalent for enco- ding and retrieval, so it is not the case that retrieval is RESULTS simply protected at the expense of the concurrent task. It seems, rather, that whereas encoding is easily dis- Behavioral Data rupted by other ongoing processes, retrieval is more or Table 1 shows cued recall performance and mean less obligatory once the retrieval cue is provided or reaction times in the tone-discrimination task in the generated (Craik et al., 1996). An important question four experimental conditions. Recall performance was in this regard is whether there exists one common pool lowered substantially (0.79 to 0.58) when attention of attentional resources that can be allocated differen- was divided at encoding, but recall was affected only tially to various mental operations, depending on the minimally (0.78 to 0.75) when attention was divided relative importance of each operation. Some studies at retrieval. A two-way analysis of variance conducted have suggested an affirmative answer to this question. on cued recall performance showed a main effect of For example, event-related potential studies using the encoding/retrieval, F(1,11)=7.31, p<.05, a main effect dual-task paradigm have shown that there exists a of attention (FA vs. DA), F(1,11)=13.46, p<.01, and a reciprocity in the availability of resources for the primary significant interaction between attention and enco- task (visual detection) and the secondary task (auditory ding/retrieval, F(1,11)=11.15, p<.01. This is similar detection), and the allocation of resources may vary to the pattern reported by Craik et al. (1996). The according to the relative difficulty of the tasks (Wickens, tone-task data show that response times were slower Kramer, Vanasse, & Donchin, 1983). Other authors have in the two-tone (DA) condition than in the one-tone talked in terms of cortical control functions, rather than (FA) condition. A two-way ANOVA on these data in terms of processing resources. For example, Duncan's revealed a significant main effect for attention only, (1995) notion is that tasks, which show large drops in F(1,11)=21.22, p<.01. performance from full attention (FA) to DA conditions, require substantial amounts of controlled processing. By PET Data Duncan's view, episodic encoding tasks, which show a large performance drop under DA conditions, should Latent Variables and Task Contrasts require greater amounts of frontal control than episodic The Partial Least Squares (PLS) analysis produced three retrieval tasks, which show comparatively small drops LVs depicting the distribution of brain activity related under DA conditions. to particular task contrasts. The design scores for each Several previous studies have used PET in the DA latent variable (LV) are shown in Figure 1. The first LV (dual-task) paradigm, but to our knowledge, only two (LV1) distinguished FA from DA; the difference between have used episodic memory as one of the tasks (Fletcher, FA and DA design scores was larger during encoding Shallice, & Dolan, 1998; Shallice et al., 1994). These than during retrieval. Therefore, the singular image for investigators studied verbal learning while performing LV1 segregates brain activity related to DA from brain either an easy or a difficult perceptual-motor task. The activity related to FA, particularly during encoding. experiment thus examined the effects of DA during the The second LV (LV2) distinguished retrieval from encoding phase of a memory task; the effects of DA at encoding; the difference between retrieval and enco- retrieval were not studied. The major finding relevant to ding design scores was larger under conditions of FA the present experiment was thatÐrelative to the easy than DA. Therefore, the singular image for LV2 segre- distracting taskÐperformance of the difficult distracting gates brain activity related to retrieval from activity task greatly reduced activation in the left-prefrontal related to encoding, particularly under FA conditions. cortex. The last LV (LV3) revealed an interaction of the 268 Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience Volume 12, Number 2 Downloaded from http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1162/089892900562093 by guest on 25 September 2021 Table 1. Behavioral Performance on the Memory Task and the ratio
Recommended publications
  • Compare and Contrast Two Models Or Theories of One Cognitive Process with Reference to Research Studies
    ! The following sample is for the learning objective: Compare and contrast two models or theories of one cognitive process with reference to research studies. What is the question asking for? * A clear outline of two models of one cognitive process. The cognitive process may be memory, perception, decision-making, language or thinking. * Research is used to support the models as described. The research does not need to be outlined in a lot of detail, but underatanding of the role of research in supporting the models should be apparent.. * Both similarities and differences of the two models should be clearly outlined. Sample response The theory of memory is studied scientifically and several models have been developed to help The cognitive process describe and potentially explain how memory works. Two models that attempt to describe how (memory) and two models are memory works are the Multi-Store Model of Memory, developed by Atkinson & Shiffrin (1968), clearly identified. and the Working Memory Model of Memory, developed by Baddeley & Hitch (1974). The Multi-store model model explains that all memory is taken in through our senses; this is called sensory input. This information is enters our sensory memory, where if it is attended to, it will pass to short-term memory. If not attention is paid to it, it is displaced. Short-term memory Research. is limited in duration and capacity. According to Miller, STM can hold only 7 plus or minus 2 pieces of information. Short-term memory memory lasts for six to twelve seconds. When information in the short-term memory is rehearsed, it enters the long-term memory store in a process called “encoding.” When we recall information, it is retrieved from LTM and moved A satisfactory description of back into STM.
    [Show full text]
  • Episodic Memory in Transient Global Amnesia: Encoding, Storage, Or Retrieval Deficit?
    J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.66.2.148 on 1 February 1999. Downloaded from 148 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1999;66:148–154 Episodic memory in transient global amnesia: encoding, storage, or retrieval deficit? Francis Eustache, Béatrice Desgranges, Peggy Laville, Bérengère Guillery, Catherine Lalevée, Stéphane SchaeVer, Vincent de la Sayette, Serge Iglesias, Jean-Claude Baron, Fausto Viader Abstract evertheless this division into processing stages Objectives—To assess episodic memory continues to be useful in helping understand (especially anterograde amnesia) during the working of memory systems”. These three the acute phase of transient global amne- stages may be defined in the following way: (1) sia to diVerentiate an encoding, a storage, encoding, during which perceptive information or a retrieval deficit. is transformed into more or less stable mental Methods—In three patients, whose am- representations; (2) storage (or consolidation), nestic episode fulfilled all current criteria during which mnemonic information is associ- for transient global amnesia, a neuro- ated with other representations and maintained psychological protocol was administered in long term memory; (3) retrieval, during which included a word learning task which the subject can momentarily reactivate derived from the Grober and Buschke’s mnemonic representations. These definitions procedure. will be used in the present study. Results—In one patient, the results sug- Regarding the retrograde amnesia of TGA, it gested an encoding deficit,
    [Show full text]
  • Post-Encoding Stress Does Not Enhance Memory Consolidation: the Role of Cortisol and Testosterone Reactivity
    brain sciences Article Post-Encoding Stress Does Not Enhance Memory Consolidation: The Role of Cortisol and Testosterone Reactivity Vanesa Hidalgo 1,* , Carolina Villada 2 and Alicia Salvador 3 1 Department of Psychology and Sociology, Area of Psychobiology, University of Zaragoza, 44003 Teruel, Spain 2 Department of Psychology, Division of Health Sciences, University of Guanajuato, Leon 37670, Mexico; [email protected] 3 Department of Psychobiology and IDOCAL, University of Valencia, 46010 Valencia, Spain; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected]; Tel.: +34-978-645-346 Received: 11 October 2020; Accepted: 15 December 2020; Published: 16 December 2020 Abstract: In contrast to the large body of research on the effects of stress-induced cortisol on memory consolidation in young people, far less attention has been devoted to understanding the effects of stress-induced testosterone on this memory phase. This study examined the psychobiological (i.e., anxiety, cortisol, and testosterone) response to the Maastricht Acute Stress Test and its impact on free recall and recognition for emotional and neutral material. Thirty-seven healthy young men and women were exposed to a stress (MAST) or control task post-encoding, and 24 h later, they had to recall the material previously learned. Results indicated that the MAST increased anxiety and cortisol levels, but it did not significantly change the testosterone levels. Post-encoding MAST did not affect memory consolidation for emotional and neutral pictures. Interestingly, however, cortisol reactivity was negatively related to free recall for negative low-arousal pictures, whereas testosterone reactivity was positively related to free recall for negative-high arousal and total pictures.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effects of a Suggested Encoding Strategies on Achievement
    The Effects of Metacognition 17 The Effects of Metacognition and Concrete Encoding Strategies on Depth of Understanding in Educational Psychology Suzanne Schellenberg, Meiko Negishi, & Paul Eggen, University of North Florida The study compared the academic achievement, as measured by final examination scores, of an experimental group of undergraduate educational psychology students who were provided with concrete mechanisms designed to promote metacognition and the use of specific encoding strategies to the achievement of a control group of similar students who were not provided with the same concrete mechanisms. The two groups were taught by the same instructor, who used the same teaching methods and identical class activities, homework, quizzes, and tests. The results indicated a statistically significant difference between the two groups, favoring the experimental group. Implications of the study for instruction and suggestions for further research are included. This study explored instructional capacity working memory that designs that encourage learners to consciously organizes information into become responsible for their own conceptual structures that make sense to learning. Responsible learners are the individual, a long-term memory that metacognitive, strategic, and high stores knowledge and skills in a achievers. Therefore, researchers have relatively permanent fashion, and become interested in investigating ways metacognitive monitoring that regulates to foster learners’ metacognition and this processing (Atkinson & Shiffrin, strategy use. 1968; Chandler & Sweller, 1990; Mayer The purpose of the study was to & Chandler, 2001; Paas, Renkl, & examine the impact of concrete Sweller, 2004; Sweller, 2003; Sweller, mechanisms for promoting van Merrienboer, & Paas, 1998). The metacognition and the conscious use of way knowledge is stored in long-term encoding strategies on the achievement memory has an important impact on of undergraduate educational learners’ ability to retrieve that psychology students.
    [Show full text]
  • The Benefits of Stimulus-Driven Attention for Working Memory
    Journal of Memory and Language 69 (2013) 384–396 Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect Journal of Memory and Language journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jml The benefits of stimulus-driven attention for working memory encoding ⇑ Susan M. Ravizza a, , Eliot Hazeltine b a Department of Psychology, Michigan State University, United States b Department of Psychology, University of Iowa, United States article info abstract Article history: The present study investigates how stimulus-driven attention to relevant information Received 18 July 2012 affects working memory performance. In three experiments, we examine whether stimu- revision received 30 May 2013 lus-driven attention to items can improve retention of these items in working memory. Available online 22 June 2013 Lists of phonologically-similar and dissimilar items were presented at expected or unex- pected locations in Experiment 1. When stimulus-driven attention was captured by items Keywords: presented at unexpected locations, similar items were better remembered than similar Verbal working memory items that appeared at expected locations. These results were replicated in Experiment 2 Attentional capture using contingent capture to boost stimulus-driven attention to similar items. Experiment Short term memory 3 demonstrated that stimulus-driven attention was beneficial for both similar and dissim- ilar items when the latter condition was made more difficult. Together, these experiments demonstrate that stimulus-driven attention to relevant information is one mechanism by which encoding can be facilitated. Ó 2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Introduction strated in research examining the detrimental effects on WM performance when stimulus-driven attention is cap- Working memory (WM) keeps information in an active tured by irrelevant distractors (Anticevic, Repovs, Shul- state for a short period of time so that it can be readily ac- man, & Barch, 2009; Majerus et al., 2012; Olesen, cessed and manipulated in the service of immediate task Macoveanu, Tegner, & Klingberg, 2007; West, 1999).
    [Show full text]
  • Encoding Time and Allocation of Attention in Analogical Development
    Encoding time and allocation of attention in analogical development Nina Simms ([email protected]) Department of Psychology, 2029 Sheridan Road Evanston, IL 60202 USA Dedre Gentner ([email protected]) Department of Psychology, 2029 Sheridan Road Evanston, IL 60202 USA Abstract become increasingly adept at reasoning on the basis of relational rather than object similarity (Gentner & The aim of the current studies was to explore encoding time differences in objects and relations and to investigate whether Rattermann, 1991). these differences lead to differences in allocation of attention For example, Gentner and Toupin (1986) gave 6-year-old to object similarity. Using a match-to-sample paradigm with children a simple story and asked them to reenact it with 5- to 6-year-olds and adults, we found that (1) objects were new characters. They performed well when the encoded faster than relations for both adults and children, and corresponding characters were highly similar between the that (2) children, but not adults, preferentially allocated two stories, but performed very badly when similar attention to object similarity. Ultimately, these questions are characters played different roles across the two stories (the aimed at identifying the factors responsible for the cross-mapped condition). Further studies have corroborated development of adult-like analogical reasoning. We suggest this finding that when relational similarity is pitted against that changes in selective attention over development may account for the pattern of results seen across these two object similarity children tend to be highly influenced by studies. object matches and less able to attend to relational matches. For example, Richland and colleagues (2006) found the Keywords: analogical development; relational reasoning; same pattern of results in a picture-matching task.
    [Show full text]
  • Memory Formation, Consolidation and Transformation
    Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 36 (2012) 1640–1645 Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews journa l homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/neubiorev Review Memory formation, consolidation and transformation a,∗ b a a L. Nadel , A. Hupbach , R. Gomez , K. Newman-Smith a Department of Psychology, University of Arizona, United States b Department of Psychology, Lehigh University, United States a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t Article history: Memory formation is a highly dynamic process. In this review we discuss traditional views of memory Received 29 August 2011 and offer some ideas about the nature of memory formation and transformation. We argue that memory Received in revised form 20 February 2012 traces are transformed over time in a number of ways, but that understanding these transformations Accepted 2 March 2012 requires careful analysis of the various representations and linkages that result from an experience. These transformations can involve: (1) the selective strengthening of only some, but not all, traces as a function Keywords: of synaptic rescaling, or some other process that can result in selective survival of some traces; (2) the Memory consolidation integration (or assimilation) of new information into existing knowledge stores; (3) the establishment Transformation Reconsolidation of new linkages within existing knowledge stores; and (4) the up-dating of an existing episodic memory. We relate these ideas to our own work on reconsolidation to provide some grounding to our speculations that we hope will spark some new thinking in an area that is in need of transformation.
    [Show full text]
  • Encoding Processes for Recall and Recognition: the Effect of Instructions and Auxiliary Task Performance
    Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society 1977, Vol. 9 (2),127·130 Encoding processes for recall and recognition: The effect of instructions and auxiliary task performance STEPHEN A. MAISTO. RICHARD J. DeWAARD. and MARILYN E. MILLER University of Wisconsin. Milwaukee, Wisconsin 59201 The present experiment investigated the hypothesis that encoding for recall involves organization of input stimuli. while recognition entails encoding to achieve discriminability of individual items. Subjects were given either recall or recognition instructions. one or three presentations of a list of nouns, and did or did not perform an auxiliary task of repeating the words aloud at input. All subjects received recall and recognition tests. The results showed higher recall with recall instructions in the no-task condition. Oral repetition produced a decrement in recall following recall instructions, but had no effect with recognition instructions. Also, the auxiliary task had no effect on recall with recognition instructions, but with recog­ nition instructions recognition performance was increased to the level of recall subjects. The results are discussed in terms of current models of recall and recognition. In accounting for free recall performance, models encoding of that item" (Tversky, 1973, p. 285). of recall and recognition have incorporated the However, if retrieval processes are important for finding that organization (i.e., forming associations recognition, then there should be much overlap in among items) of target items is positively related to how information is encoded following instructions for efficient retrieval of those items from memory recall and recognition tests. (Klatzky. 1975). However, models of recall and Several researchers have examined encoding differ­ recognition can be distinguished on the basis of the ences in recall and recognition.
    [Show full text]
  • Cognitive Functions of the Brain: Perception, Attention and Memory
    IFM LAB TUTORIAL SERIES # 6, COPYRIGHT c IFM LAB Cognitive Functions of the Brain: Perception, Attention and Memory Jiawei Zhang [email protected] Founder and Director Information Fusion and Mining Laboratory (First Version: May 2019; Revision: May 2019.) Abstract This is a follow-up tutorial article of [17] and [16], in this paper, we will introduce several important cognitive functions of the brain. Brain cognitive functions are the mental processes that allow us to receive, select, store, transform, develop, and recover information that we've received from external stimuli. This process allows us to understand and to relate to the world more effectively. Cognitive functions are brain-based skills we need to carry out any task from the simplest to the most complex. They are related with the mechanisms of how we learn, remember, problem-solve, and pay attention, etc. To be more specific, in this paper, we will talk about the perception, attention and memory functions of the human brain. Several other brain cognitive functions, e.g., arousal, decision making, natural language, motor coordination, planning, problem solving and thinking, will be added to this paper in the later versions, respectively. Many of the materials used in this paper are from wikipedia and several other neuroscience introductory articles, which will be properly cited in this paper. This is the last of the three tutorial articles about the brain. The readers are suggested to read this paper after the previous two tutorial articles on brain structure and functions [17] as well as the brain basic neural units [16]. Keywords: The Brain; Cognitive Function; Consciousness; Attention; Learning; Memory Contents 1 Introduction 2 2 Perception 3 2.1 Detailed Process of Perception .
    [Show full text]
  • Semantic Encoding and Retrieval in the Left Inferior Prefrontal Cortex: a Functional MRI Study of Task Difficulty and Process Specificity
    The Journal of Neuroscience, September 1995, 15(g): 5870-5878 Semantic Encoding and Retrieval in the Left Inferior Prefrontal Cortex: A Functional MRI Study of Task Difficulty and Process Specificity Jonathan B. Demb,’ John E. Desmond,2 Anthony D. Wagner,’ Chandan J. Vaidya,’ Gary H. Glover,2 and John D. E. Gabriel? Departments of ‘Psychology and ‘Radiology, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305-2130 Prefrontal cortical function was examined during semantic Lockhart, 1972). Retrieval refers to the recovery of previously encoding and repetition priming using functional magnetic encoded information from long-term memory and can be mea- resonance imaging (fMRI), a noninvasive technique for lo- sured explicitly, by measuresof intentional recollection, or im- calizing regional changes in blood oxygenation, a correlate plicitly, by measuresof priming, conditioning, or skill learning of neural activity. Words studied in a semantic (deep) en- (Graf and Schacter, 198.5).Priming reflects experience-basedfa- coding condition were better remembered than words stud- cilitation in performance with a stimulus that does not depend ied in both easier and more difficult nonsemantic (shallow) on intentional recollection. For example, subjects make a se- encoding conditions, with difficulty indexed by response mantic encoding decision (e.g., is this word abstract‘?)more time. The left inferior prefrontal cortex (LIPC) (Brodmann’s quickly for a repeated than an initial presentation of a word areas 45, 46, 47) showed increased activation during se- (Gabrieli, Desmond,Demb, Wagner, Stone, Vaidya, and Glover, mantic encoding relative to nonsemantic encoding regard- unpublishedobservations). less of the relative difficulty of the nonsemantic encoding Functional magnetic resonanceimaging (fMR1) and positron task.
    [Show full text]
  • Encoding Processes in Recognition and Recall
    COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY 5, 275-287 (1973) Encoding Processes in Recognition and Recall BARBARA TVERSKY~ Hebrew University The present experiments demonstrate that picture-word stimuli are differentially encoded in anticipation of a recognition test than in anticipa- tion of a free-recall test. Subjects perform better on the retention test of which they have been informed, and different information from the stimuli is used to pass each test. These findings cannot be attributed to stimulus selection nor to pure pictorial encoding in anticipation of recognition and pure verbal encoding in anticipation of recall. Recognition is enhanced by encoding which integrates the details within each item while recall is enhanced by encoding which interrelates the items of a list. The superiority of recognition tests of memory to recall tests has typically been attributed to the fact that less information about an item is needed to pass a recognition test (Postman, 1963). Partial learning may be sufficient to choose the correct alternative or reject an incorrect alternative in a recognition test, but not enough to guarantee correct recall. Recently, several theorists, notably Estes and Da Polito ( 1967), Kintsch ( 1970)) Bahrick ( 1970), and Anderson and Bower ( 1972)) have proposed that an important difference between recognition and recall tests of memory is that the former by-pass the retrieval stage of memory necessary in recall. Since the correct alternative is presented in the recognition test, S presumably does not have to search his memory to find it. To support his contention, Kintsch ( 1970) reviewed and reported data on variables which have different effects on recognition and recall tests of memory.
    [Show full text]
  • A Review of Theories of Human Amnesia LEONARD D
    Memory & Cognition 1981, Vol. 9 (3),247-262 A review of theories of human amnesia LEONARD D. STERN University ofOregon, Eugene, Oregon 97403 Six theories of human amnesia are examined. Each is categorized according to the processing ability that is conceived to underlie the amnesic deficit. The theories fall into one of four categories: consolidation, retrieval, semantic encoding, and context encoding deficit theories. The recently proposed context encoding deficit theories are found to offer the most satis­ factory account of the human amnesic syndrome. It is suggested that the other theoretical approaches are best viewed as special cases of these context encoding deficit theories. The human amnesic syndrome is characterized by a technique in the treatment of psychosis. This surgical severely impaired memory for day-to-day events procedure, used as an alternative to a complete frontal accompanied by normal intelligence, perceptual abilities, lobotomy, was intended to avoid the side effects that and other cognitive functions. Amnesia is typically the lobotomy normally produced (B. Milner, 1966). associated with brain trauma brought about by blows to After 30 of these operations had been performed, it was the head, surgical removal of portions of the brain, or discovered that a serious memory impairment could degenerative processes that accompany excessive and result. Memory deficits were initially discovered in two prolonged alcohol consumption (Korsakoff's syndrome). of Scoville's patients. One patient had undergone surgery The focus of this paper will be on theoretical accounts to treat a psychosis, and the other, the well-known H.M., of the human amnesic syndrome. The theories of amnesia had undergone surgery to control epileptic seizures.
    [Show full text]