DOCSLIB.ORG

Broken Silence What Chris Kahui Told the Inquest, Booze Babies and Why the Coroner Foetal Alcohol Syndrome Didn’T Believe Him and Its Role in Crime

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Broken Silence What Chris Kahui Told the Inquest, Booze Babies and Why the Coroner Foetal Alcohol Syndrome Didn’T Believe Him and Its Role in Crime INVESTIGATE NEW ZEALAND’S BEST NEWS MAGAZINE VITAMIN D New book blasts health authorities over vitamin D and sunscreen safety Power Play Democracy’s death by a thousand cuts Broken Silence What Chris Kahui told the Inquest, Booze Babies and why the Coroner Foetal Alcohol Syndrome didn’t believe him and its role in crime Aug/Sep 2012, $8.60 CURRENT AFFAIRS, TOYS, CARS, FRANKLY-EXPRESSED OPINIONS & MORE contents features Aug/Sep 2012 12 BROKEN SILENCE The long-awaited Coroner’s verdict on the deaths of the Kahui twins has finally been released. IAN WISHART lays out the testimony that became Chris Kahui’s downfall 20 BORN FREE We may have been born free, but we are creeping toward political slavery, writes AMY BROOKE 28 BOOZE BABIES Foetal alcohol syndrome is a the centre of a US death row debate, but how much does it contribute to New Zealand crime? MELISSA WISHART has more HERS VITAMIN D A new book blasts authorities on the safety of sunscreens and takes a long hard look at the vitamin D debate 12 contents departments OPINION EDITOR 4 Speaks for itself, really COMMUNIQUES 6 Your say EYES RIGHT 8 Richard Prosser STEYNPOST 10 Mark Steyn ACTION INVEST Peter Hensley on money 32 SCIENCE The shuffle is a giveaway 40 MUSIC Beachboys are back 42 GADGETS The latest toys 34 The Mall 35 42 Touch friendly office 36 Online with Chillisoft 38 MINDFUEL BOOKCASE 44 Michael Morrissey’s 34 winter picks CONSIDER THIS 46 Amy Brooke THE QUESTION 48 Matt Flannagan 40 32 CSEUPHORI A0511I 1219. pdf Page 1 11/ 05/ 11, 12: 31 PM Editor The book got it right A year ago, this country was in uproar at the prospect of a book published by yours truly on the truth behind the Kahui twins murders. They were baying for my blood in the streets. People cancelled their subscriptions. The public were egged on by Kahui’s credibility and not to be relied upon.” The hounds of hell were unleashed as legal team, not deliberately but purely in The Coroner has found that baby twins community fury reached a zenith. the way they hung Macsyna out to dry to Chris and Cru Kahui were killed while You know why it did? Because this the jury as an alternative suspect, with a they were in the sole care and custody of murder case had been tried by the series of badly woven conspiracy theories. their biological father Chris Kahui. media, and tried badly in the process. So now that we have waited a year, “There is not a scintilla of evidence” Fifty thousand armchair critics who what has the Coroner actually found? said the Coroner, that Macsyna King was thought they knew it all signed up to a Firstly, that the Kahui legal team’s involved in any way with the murders. Facebook page demanding a boycott of conspiracy theories about Macsyna Of the cellphone call conspiracy Breaking Silence. How dare the mother King having the opportunity to kill theory, the Coroner after hearing all speak. “We’ll wait for the Coroner’s were “not…evidentially tenable. the evidence from cellphone providers report, he’ll put King and Wishart in Accordingly, each falls to be rejected.” and traffic experts, says it is “inherently their place!,” said one. Of the claim that as a mother King implausible that Macsyna would have As this magazine was going to press, “must have known”, the Coroner says interrupted her evening out with her news broke that the Coroner’s verdict bluntly: sister to return to Courtenay Crescent, was finally being released. “The court finds that Macsyna King happened to arrive during the 20 min- We’ve devoted stories in both halves was materially misled by Chris Kahui ute period when her partner happened of this magazine to the case, both the as to the health of the twins,” despite to be out, fatally assaulted the twins details of the Coroner’s report, and her attempts to find out. and then left, devised an alibi that was separately the cross examination (or a Materially misled, as in “lied to”, consistent with cellphone records that portion of it extracted from the book false explanations, and a cover-up by she was unaware of [Coroner’s empha- Breaking Silence) of Chris Kahui. Chris Kahui. sis] and then successfully persuaded Much of New Zealand, relying on This is the same Chris Kahui who Stuart King, Emily King and Pou Hepi uninformed debate on talkback, at the never took the witness stand at his to cover this up.” pub, at work or on Facebook, and much murder trial. Who appeared every day Ironically, the book Breaking Silence of that fuelled by incorrect media reports in court, clean-shaven, baby-faced and remains the only place you are going of the original case, had assumed that shy. The jury never heard him lie. But to read most of the evidence in the because Chris Kahui was “not guilty” the Coroner and this journalist did. Kahui case. The Coroner’s ruling is 50% and had been acquitted in one minute, “The Court found his evidence seri- suppressed in places and is not being LOWER PRINTING that therefore it had to be Macsyna King. ously conflicting in nature, lacking in released to the public. COST VS COLOUR LASER* The Coroner has found that baby twins Chris and Cru Kahui were killed while they were in the sole care and custody of their biological father Chris Kahui 4 HISMAGAZINE.TV | Aug/Sep 2012 65773 65773 Epson Investigate 210x285.indd 1 23/11/11 3:57:11 PM 50% LOWER PRINTING COST VS COLOUR LASER* 65773 65773 Epson Investigate 210x285.indd 1 23/11/11 3:57:11 PM Communiques We need major investment in new roading infrastructure, but are New Zealanders being unwittingly fleeced of billions in the process? That’s the question IAN WISHART attempts to answer as he compares the cost of Auckland’s proposed new harbour crossing with similar projects overseas - ou hear the numbers being bat ted around in the news so much that it’s easy to become immune - to them: $3.9 billion, $5.6 bil nt lion, $6.7 billion. They represe r Y stings for either a new harbou various co nnel. Auckland, or a harbour tu bridge for her Throw in government reports of eit tunnel first BRIDGING $2.8 billion for the Waterview t Albert proposed for Helen Clark’s M rate, or $1.4 billion for a surface electo eventu- motorway on the same route (and ain, at half ally $1.4 billion for a tunnel ag the original planned length). Then add entral rail ARTICLE WENT A BRIDGE FINANCE $2.4 billion for the proposed c a highway between tunnel, $2.5 billion for - ARE WE PAYING FAR TOO MUCH Pakuranga and Onehu nga. If your eye in your head balls aren’t rolling around s on a one- FOR INFRASTRUCTURE? by now like the lemon icon y armed-bandit at Sky City, you’re probabl already comatose. It’s like Monopoly, but without the ng up a Community Chest chance of picki TOO FAR? card advising “Congratulations, bank . on error in your favour” makes $15 billi eams this expenditure planned, t With all ro- corporates are drafting p of boffins and users posals suggesting taxpayers and road h flat rate share the capital cost burden, wit considered tolls as high as $8 per trip being for any vehicle using the motorways. lly being With all this money potentia Firstly I have to say enjoy Investi- pockets each sucked out of the public’s you’d hope we were getting the best Volume 10, Issue 133, ISSN 1175-1290 [Print] day, re possible prices on our infrastructu projects, wouldn’t you? Maybe, maybe not. ate magazine A comparison by Investig of New Zealand infr astructure costs similar projects in Asia , compared with ues- the US, Australia and Europe raises q gate magazine very much and like w much fat is built into tions about just ho ets. the project budg of scene, let’s examine some To set the e the biggest engineering marvels of th last two decades. 13 the way some PC hot topics are not HISMAGAZINE.TV June/July 2012 June/July 2012 Chief Executive Officer Heidi Wishart 12 HISMAGAZINE.TV Group Managing Editor Ian Wishart shunned away from. I do have, as a civil engineer I reckon you get the point and I NZ EDITION with a bit of insight in these mat- was merely just somewhat disap- Advertising Josephine Martin ters, some comments to make on pointed with the article being less 09 373-3676 the article on infrastructure costs well investigated than the standard [email protected] ‘Bridging Finance’. (I hope) normally is or seems to be. Contributing Writers: Hal Colebatch, Amy Yes, the Waterview Connection Edwin Zwanenburg, via email Brooke, Chris Forster, Peter Hensley, Mark Steyn, has a budget of 1.4B, that is correct, Chris Philpott, Michael Morrissey, Miranda however it is not just the 2.5km of Editor responds: Devine, Richard Prosser, Claire Morrow, James tunnel but a full new interchange Thanks for your comment. Yes, Morrow, Len Restall, Laura Wilson, and the worldwide resources of MCTribune Group, UPI at the northern end tying into SH16 I tried to get a feel by talking to a and Newscom and a few km of motorway to the senior figure in the industry. Each south, tying into the current Maioro location has its hindrances, and Art Direction Heidi Wishart Street interchange as well.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Survey of Recent New Zealand Writing TREVOR REEVES
    A Survey of Recent New Zealand Writing TREVOR REEVES O achieve any depth or spread in an article attempt• ing to cover the whole gamut of New Zealand writing * must be deemed to be a New Zealand madman's dream, but I wonder if it would be so difficult for people overseas, particularly in other parts of the Commonwealth. It would appear to them, perhaps, that two or three rather good poets have emerged from these islands. So good, in fact, that their appearance in any anthology of Common• wealth poetry would make for a matter of rather pleasurable comment and would certainly not lower the general stand• ard of the book. I'll come back to these two or three poets presently, but let us first consider the question of New Zealand's prose writers. Ah yes, we have, or had, Kath• erine Mansfield, who died exactly fifty years ago. Her work is legendary — her Collected Stories (Constable) goes from reprint to reprint, and indeed, pirate printings are being shovelled off to the priting mills now that her fifty year copyright protection has run out. But Katherine Mansfield never was a "New Zealand writer" as such. She left early in the piece. But how did later writers fare, internationally speaking? It was Janet Frame who first wrote the long awaited "New Zealand Novel." Owls Do Cry was published in 1957. A rather cruel but incisive novel, about herself (everyone has one good novel in them), it centred on her own childhood experiences in Oamaru, a small town eighty miles north of Dunedin -— a town in which rough farmers drove sheep-shit-smelling American V-8 jalopies inexpertly down the main drag — where the local "bikies" as they are now called, grouped in vociferous RECENT NEW ZEALAND WRITING 17 bunches outside the corner milk bar.
    [Show full text]
  • The One Story and the Four Ways of Telling
    The One Story and the Four Ways of Telling: The relationship between New Zealand literary autobiography and spiritual autobiography. A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Masters of Arts in English in the University of Canterbury DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH UN!VEf,SITY OF c,wrrnmnw By CHRISTCHURCH, N.Z. Emily Jane Faith University of Canterbury 2001 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank everyone who has given various forms of support during this two­ year production. Thanks especially to my Mum and Dad and my brother Nick, Dylan, my friends, and my office-mates in Room 320. Somewhere between lunch, afternoon tea, and the gym, it finally got done! A special mention is due to my supervisor Patrick Evans for his faith in me throughout. The first part of my title is based on Lawrence Jones' a1iicle 'The One Story, the Two Ways of Telling, and the Three Perspectives', in Ariel 16:4 (October 1985): 127-50. CONTENTS Abst1·act ................................................................................................................... 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................... 2 I. A brief history of a brief history: New Zealand literary autobiography (and biography) ................................................................................ 2 II. The aims and procedures of this thesis ................................................... 9 III. Spiritual autobiography: the epiphany .................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Towards 'Until the Walls Fall Down' an Intended History of New Zealand Literature 1932-1963
    Towards 'Until the walls fall down' An intended history of New Zealand Literature 1932-1963 LAWRENCE JONES Those inclusive dates point to two generations, and crucial to my intended history is the distinction Lawrence fones is Associate Professor of English at the Uni­ between them. The first is that of the self-appointed versity of Otago. He is the author of Barbed Wire and makers of a national literature, mostly born after 1900 Mirrors - Essays on New Zealand prose. The following and before World War I. They arrive in three waves. text was presented at a Stout Research Centre Wednesday First there is a small group beginning Seminar, on 5 October 1994. in Auckland in the mid- and late-1920s- Mason (born 1905), A.R.D. I would like first to look at the terms of my title. 'To­ Fairburn (1904), and, off to one side and associated wards' and 'intended' are the first operative terms. This by them with the maligned older generation, Robin seminar is given at the beginning of a process of inten­ Hyde (1906). Then come the Phoenix-Unicorn-Griffin sive research, and any writing beyond notes and an and the Tomorrow-Caxton groups in Auckland and outline is an intention at this point, and the outline is Christchurch, (and some of their outlying friends), something to work towards, modifying and filling in. arriving between 1932 and 1935, incorporating Fairburn Next there is 'New Zealand Literature, 1932-1963', and Mason, and including M.H . Holcroft (1902), Frank with those oddly specific dates. The first is probably Sargeson (1903), Roderick Finlayson (1904), Winston obvious enough, the publication of the Phoenix at the Rhodes (1905), E.H.
    [Show full text]
  • Composed on a Summer's Evening
    A New Zealand QEarter!Jr"" VOLUME SIXTEEN Reprinted with the permission of The Caxton Press JOHNSON REPRINT CORPORATION JOHNSON REPRINT COMPANY LTD. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10003 Berkeley Square House, London, W. 1 LANDFALL is published with the aid of a grant from the New Zealand Literary Fund. Corrigendum. Landfall 61, March 1962, p. 57, line 5, should read: day you will understand why', or even, 'Learn this now, because I First reprinting, 1968, Johnson Reprint Corporation Printed in the United States of America Landfall A New Zealand Quarterly edited by Charles Brasch and published by The Caxton Press CONTENTS Notes 3 Two Poems, C. K. Stead 6 Lily of a Day, Ruth Dallas 8 Notes from the Welfare State, Keith Sinclair r8 Three Songs from the Maori, Allen Curnow and R. S. Oppenheim 20 Two Poems, Michael Jackson 23 Henry Ware, Neva Clarke 25 Composed on a Summer's Evening, Rowley Habib 30 Two Poems, Maurice Duggan 3 I World Enough, and Time, Stuart Slater 35 New Zealand Since The War (6), Leo Fowler 36 COMMENTARIES: Disaster in the Primary School, Margaret Dalziel 49 Townscape, P. M. Hill 61 Stravinsky et al., Royer Savage 64 New Zealand Opera, Jeremy Commons 68 New Plays in Wellington,]. L. Roberts 72 REVIEWS: After Anzac Day, Thomas Crawford 75 An Affair of Men, R. A. Copland 77 Short Story One, E. A. Horsman 79 The Cradle of Erewhon, etc., J. C. Beaglehole 82 Early Travellers in New Zealand, etc., Peter Maling 84 Children's books, Patricia Guest 87 University magazines, R.
    [Show full text]
  • •Ÿexegesis to His Cryptic Utteranceâ•Ž
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Research Online Kunapipi Volume 29 Issue 1 Article 11 2007 Riley’s handbook: ‘Exegesis to his cryptic utterance’ Joel Gwynne Follow this and additional works at: https://ro.uow.edu.au/kunapipi Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons Recommended Citation Gwynne, Joel, Riley’s handbook: ‘Exegesis to his cryptic utterance’, Kunapipi, 29(1), 2007. Available at:https://ro.uow.edu.au/kunapipi/vol29/iss1/11 Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: [email protected] Riley’s handbook: ‘Exegesis to his cryptic utterance’ Abstract On her departure in 1920, the novelist Jane Mander described New Zealand as ‘a positively exciting country’ (Belich 335). On her return in 1932, she lamented ‘the barren wastes of Victorian philistinism’, the ‘brain-numbing, stimulus-stifling, soul-searing silence’ (335) of colonial provincialism. Ironically, her grievances were expressed in a year that witnessed the birth of the vibrant literary journals Tomorrow and Phoenix; journals that would soon establish their reputation as preeminent voices of contention to a cultural landscape described by Frank Sargeson as ‘The Grey Death, puritanism, wowserism gone most startlingly putrescent’ (quoted in King 255). This journal article is available in Kunapipi: https://ro.uow.edu.au/kunapipi/vol29/iss1/11 137 JOEL GWYNNE riley’s Handbook: ‘Exegesis to His cryptic Utterance’ on her departure in 1920, the novelist Jane Mander described New zealand as ‘a positively exciting country’ (belich 335).
    [Show full text]
  • Continuum of Discourse in Recent New Zealand Criticism
    All in the Family: Continuum of Discourse in Recent New Zealand Criticism PETER SIMPSON Long ago was the then beginning to seem like now As now is but the setting out on a new but still Undefined way. That now ,the one once Seen from far away, is our destiny No matter what else may happen to us. It is The present past of which our features, Our opinions are made. The things that were coming to be talked about Have come and gone and are still remembered As being recent. There is a grain of curiosity At the base of some new thing, that unrolls Its question mark like a new wave on the shore. 1 — JOHN ASHBERY, "Blue Sonata" I IT IS WITH A SENSE OF participating in an inescapable con• tinuum of discourse, such as is expressed in John Ashbery's poem, that I contemplate the five books lined up on my desk,2 and the opportunity they present to consider the state of recent literary criticism in New Zealand. All five books are miscellaneous collections of critical writing (essays, reviews, lectures, introductions, radio talks, editorial notes, interviews, etc.), much of it previously published in peri• odicals or pamphlets, and written over a period of at least two decades. Dates of the earliest and latest pieces in each book will indicate the time span involved : Cunningham, Sargeson : 1935/ 1980; Watson, Brasch: 1947/1969; McKay, Baxter: 1950/ 4 PETER SIMPSON 1971 ; Pearson, Sleepers: 1952/1973; Stead, Glass Case: 1957/ 1981. Three collections are posthumous, compiled by editors other than the author, Baxter having died in 1972, Brasch in 1973, and Sargeson in 1982.
    [Show full text]
  • Frank Sargeson [Norris Frank Davey], 1903 – 1982
    157 Frank Sargeson [Norris Frank Davey], 1903 – 1982 Lawrence Jones ‘It is not often a writer can be said to have become a symbol in his own lifetime. It is this quality of your achievement that has prompted us to remember this present occasion’. So Frank Sargeson’s fellow New Zealand fiction-writers ended ‘A Letter to Frank Sargeson’, published in Landfall in March 1953 to mark his fiftieth birthday. They were affirming his status as the most significant writer of prose fiction to emerge from that generation that began in the 1930s to create a modern New Zealand Literature. They were celebrating him first as the creator of the New Zealand critical realist short story and short novel, the writer who provided the literary model with which most of those signing the letter had started. But they were also celebrating him as a symbol and a model not only for what he wrote but for where and how he wrote it. In the editorial ‘Notes’ to that same issue of Landfall Charles Brasch stated of Sargeson that ‘by his courage and his gifts he showed that it was possible to be a writer and contrive to live, somehow, in New Zealand, and all later writers are in his debt’. Not only did he show by his example that it was possible to be a serious New Zealand writer without becoming an expatriate, but as mentor and encourager he fostered the careers of a whole generation of fiction writers. At least two of those who signed the letter (Janet Frame and Maurice Duggan) had even lived or were to live in the army hut behind his cottage for a time when they needed the place of refuge and the encouragement, Duggan in 1950 and again in 1958, Frame in 1955-1956.
    [Show full text]
  • Six Poems from the Maori, Roger Oppenheim and Allen Curnow 4 Eli Eli Lama Sabachthani, John Caselberg IO Oakleigh, Basil Dowling 33 the Return, ]Ames K
    lit ' && A New Zealand Qgarter!Jr VOLUME ELEVEN 1957 Reprinted with the permission of The Caxton Press JOHNSON REPRINT CORPORATION JOHNSON REPRINT COMPANY LTD. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10003 Berkeley Square House, London, W. 1 LANDFALL is published with the aid of a grant from the New Zealand Literary Fund. b9/ 4-9"- First reprinting, 1968, Johnson Reprint Corporation Printed in the United States of America Landfall A New Zealand Quarterly edited by Charles Brasch and published by The Caxton Press CONTENTS Notes 3 Six Poems from the Maori, Roger Oppenheim and Allen Curnow 4 Eli Eli Lama Sabachthani, John Caselberg IO Oakleigh, Basil Dowling 33 The Return, ]ames K. Baxter 34 Play the Fife Lowly, Maurice Shadbolt 35 Way, Lily H. Trowern 54 Distilled Water, M. K. ]oseph 55 Letter to a Chinese Poet, Ruth Dallas 56 Cook's Journals, Denis Glover 6o Commentaries : SUEZ AND NEW ZEALAND'S FOREIGN POLICY, E. A. 0/ssen 67 OPERATIC OCCASIONS, f. M. Thomson, Frederick Page 70 THE CHINESE CLASSICAL THEATRE, Bruce Mason 72 Reviews: I, FOR ONE ••.., A. W. Stockwell 75 IMMANUEL's LAND, R. A. Copland 77 A BOOK OF AUSTRALIAN VERSE, M. K. foseph 80 scHOLAR ERRANT, H. N. Parton 85 NEW ZEALAND NOW, D. H. Monro 86 ANCIENT VOYAGERS IN THE PACIFIC, Roger Duff 88 Correspondence, Paul Day, Maurice Shadbolt 91 Photographs by Hester Carsten VOLUME ELEVEN NUMBER ONE MARCH I9S7 Notes SINCE there was a notable dearth of stories among the manuscripts sent to Landfall last year, it looked as if writers were saving up their work for the Prose Award.
    [Show full text]
  • HISTORY OR GOSSIP? C.K. STEAD the University of Auckland Free
    HISTORY OR GOSSIP? C.K. STEAD The University of Auckland Free Public Lecture Auckland Writers Festival 2019 How do literary history and literary gossip differ? On p. 386 of his biography of Frank Sargeson, Michael King reports that in 1972 Frank ‘had another spirited exchange of letters with Karl Stead when Stead reported that [Charles] Brasch had visited him in Menton.’ I had more or less accused Brasch of being an old fake and asked why everyone was so pious about him. In terms of what it was acceptable to say about Brasch at the time, when he was well known as almost the only wealthy benefactor the Arts in New Zealand had, this was outrageous – and no doubt unfair and unjust. Brasch was a good man who did his best for literature and the visual Arts. But he was irritatingly precious, and snobbish – not the snobbishness of wealth and social status, but of ‘good taste’. He suffered from an overload of discriminations and dismissals – and these had no doubt provoked my ‘spirited’ (to use Michael King’s word) outburst in the letter to Frank. Frank wrote back to me, ‘Look you simply can’t write things like that.’ He reminded me that his correspondence was being bought by the Turnbull Library – in other words his papers were becoming literary history, and if he had not rescued me by sending my letter back, I would have gone on record as having said Bad things about Brasch! King records that my reply was, ‘I wrote to you, Frank, not to the Turnbull Library, or to The Future.’ 1 But this was a reminder that when you put pen to paper or fingers to keyboard, if you are an aspirant to literature, you may be committing literary history.
    [Show full text]
  • The Robert Burns Fellowship 2019
    THE ROBERT BURNS FELLOWSHIP 2019 The Fellowship was established in 1958 by a group of citizens, who wished to remain anonymous, to commemorate the bicentenary of the birth of Robert Burns and to perpetuate appreciation of the valuable services rendered to the early settlement of Otago by the Burns family. The general purpose of the Fellowship is to encourage and promote imaginative New Zealand literature and to associate writers thereof with the University. It is attached to the Department of English and Linguistics of the University. CONDITIONS OF AWARD 1. The Fellowship shall be open to writers of imaginative literature, including poetry, drama, fiction, autobiography, biography, essays or literary criticism, who are normally resident in New Zealand or who, for the time being, are residing overseas and who in the opinion of the Selection Committee have established by published work or otherwise that they are a serious writer likely to continue writing and to benefit from the Fellowship. 2. Applicants for the Fellowship need not possess a university degree or diploma or any other educational or professional qualification nor belong to any association or organisation of writers. As between candidates of comparable merit, preference shall be given to applicants under forty years of age at the time of selection. The Fellowship shall not normally be awarded to a person who is a full time teacher at any University. 3. Normally one Fellowship shall be awarded annually and normally for a term of one year, but may be awarded for a shorter period. The Fellowship may be extended for a further term of up to one year, provided that no Fellow shall hold the Fellowship for more than two years continuously.
    [Show full text]
  • To the (South) Island: Janet Frame and Southern New Zealand
    1 To the (South) Island: Janet Frame and Southern New Zealand Raquel Hill “Manawhenua is that sense of belonging that connects people and land. The landscape of Aotearoa New Zealand is our cultural centre of gravity, our leading literary theme, our dominant metaphor.” — David Eggleton (1) “She was Malfred Signal, more involved in the landscape of her country than with its people, but as the right and expectation of a South Islander.” — Janet Frame, A State of Siege (2) “Otago has a calmness, a coldness, almost a classical geological order. [...] Perhaps this landscape was of the time before Jesus. I saw an angel in this land. Angels can herald beginnings.” — Colin McCahon (3) Introduction New Zealand has long been at the provincial edge of the world atlas. Geographically, its isolated position as a small group of islands located in the southern reaches of the Pacific Ocean has signalled a physical separation from the “centre,” that is, the former British Empire of 2 which the country was once a colony. Historically, New Zealand was one of the last frontiers to be settled by white immigrants, who are commonly referred to as Pakeha. These factors have helped to perpetu- ate the idea that New Zealand is, to borrow a line from Katherine Mansfield’s 1909 poem “To Stanislaw Wyspianski,” “a little land with no history.” This perceived sense of marginality and a preoccupation with exploring Pakeha New Zealanders’ unsettled identity has been the concern of many writers, including Dunedin-born Janet Frame (1924~2004), New Zealand’s most proclaimed contemporary literary figure.(4) Frame’s dramatic life story became known world-wide with the release of the film An Angel at My Table (1990) based on her autobiographies and directed by Jane Campion (The Piano).
    [Show full text]
  • The University of Auckland Reviews, New Zealand Journal of History, 32
    220 REVIEWS are men.1 Appendix 1 offers additional biographical notes on 43 of these notables, only one of whom is a woman. Arnold even includes an appendix listing the main office- holders in the community's institutions. Arnold is aware of the very male-focused, public nature of his work, and tries to remedy this by including a section on 'Women and Girls in Edwardian Kaponga'. It seems a shame that their presence in Victorian Kaponga remains hidden, and curious that when they do appear it is as 'emancipated' women, who built on the franchise to bring about change in their lives and the lives of those around them. I remain unconvinced that women's greater role in running the local horticultural show is evidence of emancipation. Instead, Arnold's rather odd conclusion to the book, his 'confession of ignorance' regarding the lack of discussion of midwives and childbirth in the area (p.346), seems to me to say more about the place of women in the area and in this book than the few women who made it onto a local committee. In his critique of local history writing, Gibbons argues that the 'writing-out of one people and the writing-in of another is a textual re-enactment as well as recapitulation of colonization'.2 Few Maori appear in Settler Kaponga save for a brief discussion of Parihaka in the Epilogue. Maori, women and children have been colonized by Pakeha men here. Given that Arnold is writing about the area as a fragment of the wider world, perhaps this is appropriate, although there is little recognition by Arnold that this is what is occurring here.
    [Show full text]