Arxiv:1801.03223V2 [Gr-Qc] 12 Apr 2018
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Shadows, Signals, and Stability in Einsteinian Cubic Gravity Robie A. Hennigar∗ Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, N2L 3G1 Mohammad Bagher Jahani Poshtehy Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, N2L 3G1 and Department of Physics, Institute for Advanced Studies in Basic Sciences (IASBS), Zanjan 45137-66731, Iran Robert B. Mannz Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, N2L 3G1 and Perimeter Institute, 31 Caroline St. N., Waterloo, Ontario, N2L 2Y5, Canada We conduct a preliminary investigation into the phenomenological implications of Einsteinian cubic gravity (ECG), a 4-dimensional theory of gravity cubic in curvature of interest for its unique formulation and properties. We find an analytic approximation for a spherically symmetric black hole solution to this theory using a continued fraction ansatz. This approximate solution is valid everywhere outside of the horizon and we use it to study the orbit of massive test bodies near a black hole, specifically computing the innermost stable circular orbit. We compute constraints on the ECG coupling parameter imposed by Shapiro time delay. We then compute the shadow of an ECG black hole and find it to be larger than its Einsteinian counterpart in general relativity for the same value of the mass. Applying our results to Sgr A*, we find that departures from general relativity are small but in principle distinguishable. I. INTRODUCTION Recently, a new theory of gravity has been proposed in [20] which, in four dimensions, is the most general up- The study of higher curvature corrections to general to-cubic-order-in-curvature dimension-independent the- relativity has attracted significant attention in recent ory of gravity that shares its graviton spectrum with decades, as these corrections seem to be generic conse- Einstein theory on constant curvature backgrounds. This quences of quantizing gravity. Higher curvature correc- theory, which is coined Einsteinian cubic gravity (ECG), tions can lead to a renormalizable theory of quantum is neither topological nor trivial in four dimensions. ECG gravity [1], and it is also understood that low energy ef- belongs to a class of theories that generalizes the quasi- fective actions derived from string theory result in various topological theories | generalized quasi-topological grav- higher-derivative gravities [2{4]. More broadly, higher ity [21, 22] | and black hole solutions in these theories curvature theories have been exploited as toy models have been shown to have a number of interesting prop- within the AdS/CFT correspondence, to make contact erties. with a wider class of CFTs and study effects beyond the The ECG field equations admit natural generalizations large N limit [5{9]. of the Schwarzshild solution, i.e. static, spherically sym- A problem plaguing most higher curvature theories is metric (SSS) solutions with a single metric function, that the linearized equations of motion allow for negative 2 2 2 dr 2 2 energy excitations, or ghost-like particles [10]. There- ds = −fdt + + r dΩ(2) : (1) fore, attention has been devoted to present theories of f gravity which have no ghost degrees of freedom in their This non-trivial fact not only significantly simplifies the propagator [11{13]. The most general class of theories study of black holes in the theory, but is also responsi- arXiv:1801.03223v2 [gr-qc] 12 Apr 2018 that are ghost-free on any background is Lovelock grav- ble for the absence of ghosts and integrability: the field ity, which is the natural generalization of Einstein grav- equation is a total derivative, and gives a non-linear sec- ity to higher dimensions [14]. However, Lovelock terms ond order differential equation upon integration, with the of order k in the curvature are topological in d = 2k integration constant being related to the mass [23]. This dimensions, and vanish identically for d < 2k. Quasi- integrability allows for exact, analytic studies of black topological theories [15{17] provide additional examples hole thermodynamics, despite the lack of exact solutions1 in five and higher dimensions and have led to a number of to the field equations [25, 26]. These studies have re- interesting results in the context of holography [18, 19]. vealed that small, asymptotically flat black hole solu- However, all quasi-topological theories are trivial in four tions become stable, a result that may have implications dimensions. in light of the information loss problem [27]. Studies of ∗ [email protected] y [email protected] 1 Note that, in the special case of the critical limit of the theory, z [email protected] certain exact solutions can be found [24]. 2 the thermodynamics of AdS black branes have revealed of the black holes in ECG and investigate the orbit of novel phase structure, suggesting this class of theories massive particles around it. In Sec.IV we constrain the will provide rich holographic toy models [28]. coupling constant of ECG by using Shapiro test in solar One of the most interesting aspects of ECG is that system. In Sec.V we study the null geodesics in ECG it is non-trivial in four dimensions. Consequently it is and present our results for Sgr A* shadow in Sect.VI. We of phenomenological interest, all the more so because no conclude our paper in VII. A number of useful results are dimensional reduction is required to interpret its solu- summarized in the appendices. We work in units where tions. The aim of this paper is to begin an investigation G = c = 1. of how compatible ECG is with observational tests. Of particular interest will be constraints that arise from so- lar system tests and potential signatures from black hole II. BLACK HOLES IN EINSTEINIAN CUBIC shadows that could be constrained by the Event Horizon GRAVITY Telescope (EHT) [29]. The latter will provide important constrains on any deviations from general relativity in The action for ECG reads, the strong field limit. 1 Z p λ An obstacle to performing these studies is the lack of an S = d4x −g R − P ; (2) 16π 6 analytic solution, combined with the difficulty of produc- ing a numerical one. To remedy this, we employ a con- where R is the usual Ricci scalar and tinued fraction ansatz and obtain a highly accurate ana- P = 12R b dR e f R a c + RcdRef Rab lytic approximate solution to the field equations. Similar a c b d e f ab cd ef ac bd b c a techniques have recently been applied with success in a − 12RabcdR R + 8RaRbRc : (3) variety of contexts [30{33]. The continued fraction ap- proximation is not only useful for the present analysis, We restrict ourselves to asymptotically flat, static and but will prove useful in future investigations, e.g. con- spherically symmetric vacuum black holes. In this case, cerning quasi-normal modes. the only independent field equation is, With the continued fraction solution in hand, we study f 03 1 2 − (f − 1)r − λ + f 02 − f(f − 1)f 0 new properties of the SSS black hole in ECG. Specifi- 3 r r2 cally we analyze the motion of particles around the black 1 hole, constraining the coupling with solar system tests, − ff 00(rf 0 − 2(f − 1)) = 2M; (4) and investigating the properties of its shadow [34{41] (see r also [42]). where a prime denotes differentiation with respect to r. We constrain the ECG coupling constant λ using The quantity M appearing on the right-hand side of the Shapiro time delay, which is the tightest constraint pro- equation is the ADM mass of the black hole [21, 26], and vided by solar system tests. We find that ECG can be we will assume λ > 0 in what follows. compatible with solar system tests whilst maintaining Unfortunately, the field equations cannot be solved an- relatively large values of the coupling. Furthermore, we alytically (except in certain special cases [24]), and ei- find that the radius of the innermost stable circular orbit ther numerical or approximate solutions (or some com- (ISCO) around an SSS ECG black hole and the angular bination) must be computed to make progress. We will momentum of a test body at this radius increase with review the construction of a numerical solution, before increasing λ as compared to their corresponding values presenting a continued fraction expansion that provides in general relativity. an accurate and convenient approximation of the solution We likewise employ the continued fraction metric func- everywhere outside of the horizon. tion to study null geodesic around ECG black holes. We We begin by solving the field equations via a series find in general that its shadow is enlarged compared to expansion near the horizon using the ansatz a non-rotating black hole in general relativity. We apply n=1 our results to the supermassive black hole Sagittarius A* X n fnh(r) = 4πT (r − r+) + an(r − r+) ; (5) (Sgr A*) at the center of our Galaxy, and show that the n=2 angular radius of the shadow increases with increasing λ which ensures that the metric function vanishes linearly by an amount tantalizingly close to what could be exper- 0 imentally detected, whilst maintaining consistency with at the horizon (r = r+), and T = f (r+)=4π is the Hawk- solar system tests. This suggests that EHT observations ing temperature. Substituting this ansatz into the field could (at least in principle) provide important constraints equations (4) allows one to solve for the temperature and on λ and on ECG in general. mass in terms of r+ and the coupling λ: The outline of out paper is as follows. In the next sec- r3 q M = + r6 + (2λ − r4 ) r4 + 4λ ; tion we review the near horizon and asymptotic solution 12λ2 + + + as well as the numeric one.