Cd1d-Unrestricted NKT Cells Are Endowed with a Hybrid Function Far Superior Than That of Inkt Cells
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CD1d-unrestricted NKT cells are endowed with a hybrid function far superior than that of iNKT cells Alexander R. Farra, Weisheng Wub, Bongkum Choia, James D. Cavalcolib, and Yasmina Laouara,1 Departments of aMicrobiology and Immunology and bComputational Medicine and Bioinformatics, University of Michigan School of Medicine, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 Edited* by Richard A. Flavell, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, and approved June 27, 2014 (received for review December 17, 2013) Invariant natural killer T (iNKT) cells to date represent the best can be misleading, the criteria that best describes an NKT cell is example of cells known to have a hybrid function, representing the ability to perform with a hybrid function between an NK cell both innate and adaptive immunity. Shared phenotypic similarities and a T cell (2). with NK cells together with a rapid response to a cytokine stimulus Nonetheless, the concept of hybrid function is also an elusive and a productive TCR engagement are the features that underline notion allowing for a gradient of functions. A number of works the hybrid nature of iNKT cells. Using these criteria, we provide refer to an NKT hybrid function as the ability of a T cell with molecular and functional evidence demonstrating that CD1d-inde- phenotypic similarities to NK cells to perform with innate-like pendent (CD1dind) NKT cells, a population of CD1d-unrestricted response. The best example of cells endowed with a hybrid NKT NKT cells, are endowed with a hybrid function far superior to that cell function are thought to be iNKT cells (2). In this study, we of iNKT cells: (i) an extensive shared program with NK cells, (ii) provide molecular and functional evidence demonstrating that a closer Euclidian distance with NK cells, and (iii) the ability to CD1dindNKT cells—a population of MHC-unrestricted T cells— respond to innate stimuli (Poly:IC) with cytotoxic potential in the are endowed with a hybrid function that associates them to the ind same manner as NK cells identify a hybrid feature in CD1d NKT NK cell lineage in a manner far superior to the known link be- cells that truly fulfills the dual function of an NK and a T cell. Our ind tween NK and iNKT cells. An extensive shared program with NK finding that CD1d NKT cells are programmed to act like NK cells cells, a similarity in the gene expression profile with NK cells, in response to innate signals while being capable of adaptive and their ability to respond (like NK cells) not only to cytokine responses is unprecedented, and thus might reemphasize CD1d- signals (IL-12 plus IL-18) but also to innate stimuli [in vivo unrestricted NKT cells as a subset of lymphocytes that could treatment with Poly:IC (Fisher)] with massive production of key affect biological processes of antimicrobial and tumor immunity effector players of the cytotoxic pathway collectively identify in a unique way. ahybridfeatureinCD1dindNKT cells that uniquely fulfills the function of an NK cell and a T cell. granzyme B | CD1d | MHC | NK receptors Results ind INFLAMMATION atural killer T (NKT) cells are increasingly regarded as cells Extensive Phenotypic Similarities Place CD1d NKT Cells Closer to the IMMUNOLOGY AND Nendowed with a hybrid function between an NK cell and a T NK Cell Lineage. Based on the differential expression of CD3 and cell (1, 2). The current classification of NKT cells places them of CD1d tetramer, NK1.1-expressing cells can be divided into − into three categories: type I, type II, and NKT-like cells (1). Type three known cell types: NK cells that are among the CD3 gate, I comprises invariant NKT (iNKT) cells that recognize the gly- iNKT cells that are typically identified by positive staining with colipid α-galactosylceramide (α-GalCer) loaded into the MHC CD1d tetramer, and CD1dindNKTcells that are among those class I molecule, CD1d, and contain an invariant TCR repertoire cells that express NK1.1 similar to NK cells and CD3 similar to of Vα14-Jα18 (3–5). Type II NKT cells are also CD1d dependent conventional T cells but negative for CD1d tetramer (Fig. 1A). but do not respond to α-GalCer in the same way as iNKT cells do To confirm that these cells are distinct from the iNKT cell type, (6, 7). NKT-like cells encompass all other NKT cells and are CD1d we examined this phenotype in CD1d-deficient mice and con- ind independent (CD1d ) (8); they are by far the most heterogeneous clusively demonstrated that these cells are bona fide CD1dindNKT and the least characterized. cells (Fig. 1B). Recent studies have increasingly shown a shared expression of + NK cell-related receptors on other effector cells. CD8 T cells Significance are known to up-regulate NK markers, such as NK1.1, and can even respond quickly like NK cells (9). Other work has described The Immunological Genome Project Consortium has recently NKT cells that express NKp46 (10), a marker selectively asso- identified a gene-expression program that links invariant nat- ciated with conventional NK cells and NK22 cells in the gut (11). γδ ural killer T (iNKT) cells to NK cells. While this is true, our study Moreover, T cells have been shown to express NK markers provides molecular and functional evidence demonstrating and display an innate-like response (12). Collectively, these that CD1d-independent NKT cells are uniquely programmed reports converge to raise the following key questions. What with a hybrid function far superior to that of iNKT cells. Such qualifies as an NKT cell? Do the cells need to express only a unique feature enables this subset of NKT cells to contribute NK1.1 and CD3 to be eligible for NKT nomenclature? With the to adaptive immunity (like T cells) and at the same time act as continuous development of both NK and T-cell fields, the sim- a prominent player in innate defense (like NK cells). plistic definition that NKT cells are subsets of T cells that express the NK1.1 marker is becoming increasingly misleading and Author contributions: Y.L. designed research; A.R.F. and B.C. performed research; A.R.F., even inaccurate. For instance, NK1.1 complex is expressed in W.W., B.C., and J.D.C. analyzed data; and A.R.F. and Y.L. wrote the paper. the BALB/c strain but there are allelic divergences with the The authors declare no conflict of interest. polymorphism leading to the PK136 antibody not reacting to *This Direct Submission article had a prearranged editor. the BALB/c NK.1.1 (NKrp1) complex (13). This definition is 1To whom correspondence should be addressed. Email: [email protected]. also limited in the C57BL/6 strain because of the discovery of − + This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10. NK1.1 CD1d NKT cells (14). Although phenotypic similarities 1073/pnas.1323405111/-/DCSupplemental. www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1323405111 PNAS | September 2, 2014 | vol. 111 | no. 35 | 12841–12846 Downloaded by guest on September 29, 2021 NK1.1+ NK1.1+ age with a kinetic of development reaching optimum at adult age - A 5 3 B Total cells CD1d-Tatramer ind WT (Fig. S4B). Finally, results from CD1d NKT cell culture in the 2 1.4 11 -/- CD3 CD1d 89 WT presence of γc cytokines suggested that their survival could fit CD1d-Tetramer ** both NK and T-cell lineages (Fig. S5). Taken together, these 2 0.2 15 ind -/- CD1d Frequency (%) results show that CD1d NKT cells, as identified in our study by 95 60 13 + − + + CD3 NK1.1 ind CD3 CD1d tetramer NK1.1 DX5 phenotype, exhibit a unique CD122 CD1d-Tetramer DX5 NK iNKT CD1d NKT DX5 profile at the intersection between NK and T cells. Fig. 1. CD1dindNKT cells resemble NK cells more than iNKT cells resemble + Global Genome Expression Reveals Higher Similarity Between NK and NK cells. (A) Distribution of CD3 versus CD1d tetramer among NK1.1 cells CD1dindNKT Cells than Between NK and iNKT Cells. The Immuno- in the spleen. Distribution of CD122 versus DX5 is shown among gated + + + + + − logical Genome Project Consortium has recently identified NK1.1 CD3 CD1d tetramer (green), NK1.1 CD3 CD1d tetramer (red), + − − and NK1.1 CD3 CD1d tetramer (blue) cells. Numbers indicate the per- a gene-expression program that links iNKT cells to NK cells (2). centage of cells expressing DX5 and high levels of CD122 among each Although it is clear that iNKT cells share patterns with NK cells, ind gate. (B) Distribution of NK1.1 versus CD1d tetramer in the spleen of WT our data placed CD1d NKT cells closer to the NK cell lineage and CD1d−/− mice. (B, Left) Distribution of CD3 versus CD1d tetramer than iNKT cells (Fig. 1 and Figs. S1–S4). To ascertain this + − is from gated NK1.1 CD1d tetramer cells (red). (B, Right) The graph finding, we used a global genome expression analysis and di- − − + + summarizes the frequency of NK (CD3 CD1d tetramer NK1.1 DX5 ), + + + rectly compared the genetic basis for similarities between NK iNKT (CD3 CD1d tetramer ), and CD1dindNKT cells (CD3 CD1d ind − + + − − and CD1d NKT cells versus NK and iNKT cells (Fig. 2 and tetramer NK1.1 DX5 ) in WT and CD1d / mice. Mean ± SEM; **P < 0.001. = Fig. S6). Data are representative of three independent experiments with n 5mice Although iNKT cells confirmed shared patterns with NK cells, per experiment in A and n = 3 mice per experiment in B. our results revealed extensive similarities between CD1dindNKT and NK cells (Fig. 2A). Strikingly, most of these similarities were To better characterize their phenotype, we used a panel of related to the NK cell program, including the killer cell lectin- T- and NK cell markers and directly compared their profile with like receptors (Klr), the NK cell receptors 2B4 (cd244) and that of NK and iNKT cells.