Submission for the Inquiry Into the Harm Being Done to Australian Children Through Access to Pornography on the Internet
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Jàguar Lacroix 9th March 2016 1 Submission for the Inquiry into the harm being done to Australian children through access to pornography on the internet Jàguar Lacroix MAPs, Grad. Dip. Psych., Grad Dip. Coun, ADOM Animal Rights, Human Rights Activist; Doctoral candidature pending (2016) Thank you for this opportunity to express my thoughts and ideas. It is my hope that they make a constructive contribution to the debate. Jàguar Lacroix 9th March 2016 2 Submission for the Inquiry into the harm being done to Australian children through access to pornography on the internet "During times of universal deceit, telling the truth becomes a revolutionary act." George Orwell When legal scholar Catharine MacKinnon (19931) wrote that, we live in a porn saturated world I thought she was exaggerating. Upon educating myself on this subject I find she could not have been more correct. In fact pornographic imagery is increasingly emulated in fashion, advertising, celebrity blogs and in all forms of media (please see appendix A. for examples). Soft porn has gone mainstream, one wonders if hardcore, now accessible by any smartphone in a free wi-fi zone is soon to follow? March 8th, International Women’s Day 2016: Having read all seventeen current submissions to the Submission for the Inquiry into the harm being done to Australian children through access to pornography on the internet, I find that little can be added to the recommendations of Professor Freda Briggs or the heartfelt concerns of mothers and parents; I have therefor chosen in this submission to focus on causation or what I perceive to be the sociological origins and outcomes of pornography production and consumption. I am doing this because I feel that many of you will be shocked by the easy access and content of violent forms of pornography online. I also find it quite hypocritical of a government to display concern about children’s viewing of pornography while announcing in the latest politically correct catchphrase to be “preventing domestic violence” through respect for women—when the prostitution of women and girls is legal in all but two states in Australia. Sexual access to a woman by buying the use of her body hardly promotes respect; the issue of prostituted persons "consent" will be covered later. Notwithstanding that all of these manifestations occur within a larger socio-historical context and the world. When we look at the immediate Australian society we find legalised prostitution, when we look at the larger world we see the rampant cruelty and sexual abuse of women and children, everywhere we see porn we see a loud message for both children and adults, that message for women and girls is: this is all you are worth—accept your status, for men and boys: this is all a woman or girl is worth—use her. 1 “Pornography makes the world a pornographic place… As society becomes saturated with pornography, what makes sexual arousal, and the nature of sex itself change” (MacKinnon, 1993, p. 25). Jàguar Lacroix 9th March 2016 3 What is Pornography For? In this paper, limited as it is in its scope I will first argue that pornography is just one of the symptoms of a predominantly privileged white-male-supremist mode of systemic oppression. Pornography supports the male-supremist system of oppression of those who do not benefit in any way from pornographies production and dissemination—women and children. Observing that the microcosm reflects the macrocosm, political forms of subjugation may be reflected in dictatorship in the family, for example in domestic violence, or the sexual abuse of children, just as social hierarchies mimic larger global politics - as can be seen in the macho posturing of Putin and previously Bush junior in his daddy pleasing role of world savior through a genocidal illegal war in Iraq2. Pornography is just one of the ways a masculine identity is constructed and reinforced through domination and entitlement to all the bodies below. i) Situating the adult porn industry as an effective arm of the patriarchy I will seek to describe a phenomenological investigation into pornography's destruction of humanistic values in social bonds and the sexual-spiritual dimension of intimate partner relationships. ii) The debate on how pornography affects children has been extensively covered in the previous submissions, therefore rather than repeat these viewpoints I will seek to look instead at the sociological structures that have brought about a world where sexually explicit material is accessible almost anywhere with just two clicks of a mouse or a few taps on a touchscreen. iii) I will argue that cybersex pornography is the predictable outcome at the nexus of patriarchy: the confluence of a mythic-infantile-male-domination-fantasy (infinite sex—immortal life), capitalism3 and digital technology creating a perfect triune storm for the ongoing abuse and erosion of the “right to human status” of women and children as a form of class discrimination. I will further posit a thread of deep fear of feminine power and sexuality identifiable in ancient and recorded history that drives the misogyny needed to produce and consume porn. iv) It will be argued that porn's unopposed force in the marketplace and representation of women and girls as consumable objects situates porn as a subversive and potent means of female oppression. 2 UNICEF and the Government of Iraq, Child and Maternal Mortality Survey, cited in John Pilger, New Rulers of the World, Verso, 2002. 3 In North America eighty percent of pornographic content is produced in the San Fernando area of Los Angeles. In 2001, 11,000 new hardcore videos were released (Jensen, 2007). 13,588 were released in 2005 (http://internet-filter- review.toptenreviews.com/internet-pornography-statistics.html). Jàguar Lacroix 9th March 2016 4 v) I will argue unapologetically that the pro-porn consumer's voice signals a sexual-spiritual disconnection—a fear of intimacy and a negation of the empathy required to call oneself human. Section 01 Panic Stations—How to Close the Stable Door After the Horse has Bolted Children online – EU and in Australia—79% of 5 to 8 year olds go online at home. In 2008, European Commission (EC) research indicated that, across the continent, 42% of children aged 6, and 52% of those aged 7, are internet users. The EC includes a range of nations (including those from the former Soviet bloc) that have only recently adopted the internet. The figures in early-adopter countries are much higher. In South Korea 92.5% of 3-9 year olds use the internet for an average of 8 – 9 hours per week, and this reflects their country’s status as the nation with the world’s greatest high-speed internet take-up (Jie, 2012). According to Gutnick et al (2011), the figures are different in the USA. While nearly 70% of 8 year olds go online everyday, about half of 5 year olds do so, and 25% of 3 year olds. The comparative Australian statistic indicates that 79% of 5 to 8 year olds go online at home (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2012). (Holloway, Green, & Brady, 2013, p. 2) In May 2013 the UK Office of the Children's Commissioner published a report entitled, "Basically... porn is everywhere" - A Rapid Evidence Assessment on the Effects that Access and Exposure to Pornography has on Children and Young People (Horvath, et al., 2013). The Office of the Children's Commissioner for England on its website called for “…urgent action to protect children from exposure to pornography” and: urgent action to develop children's resilience to pornography following a research report it commissioned which found that: a significant number of children access pornography; it influences their attitudes towards relationships and sex; it is linked to risky behaviour such as having sex at a younger age; and there is a correlation between holding violent attitudes and accessing more violent media. (http://www.childrenscommissioner.gov.uk/news/we-call-urgent- action-protect-children-exposure-pornography) Two direct quotes from the subsequent report: Maggie Atkinson, Children's Commissioner for England: This report is based on an assessment of the available evidence. It points out the gaps in our knowledge as well as providing compelling evidence that exposure to pornography influences children's attitudes to relationships and sex. We are living at a time when violent and sadistic imagery is readily available to very young children, even if they do not go searching for it, their Jàguar Lacroix 9th March 2016 5 friends may show it to them or they may stumble on it whilst using the internet. We all have a duty to protect children from harm - it is one of their rights enshrined in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child - and the time has come for immediate and decisive action to do so. For years we have applied age restrictions to films at the cinema but now we are permitting access to far more troubling imagery via the internet. We do not fully understand the implications of this. It is a risky experiment to allow a generation of young people to be raised on a diet of pornography. Sue Berelowitz, Deputy Children's Commissioner for England: As part of our Inquiry into the sexual exploitation of children in gangs and groups we have seen that young perpetrators of sexual abuse describe their activity as ‘like having been in a porn film.' This report provides the evidence to support there being a high correlation between exposure to pornography and it influencing children's behaviour and attitudes. We cannot expect children to know that sexual violence is wrong unless we teach them so.