Sustainable Energy Access in Eastern Indonesia-Power Generation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Sustainable Energy Access in Eastern Indonesia—Power Generation Sector Project (RRP INO 49203) Environmental Impact Assessment Project Number: 49203-002 February 2019 INO: Sustainable Energy Access in Eastern Indonesia ─ Power Generation Sector Project Kaltim Peaker 2 Core Subproject Annexes Prepared by Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN) for the Asian Development Bank. This is an updated version of the draft originally posted on 9 March 2018 available on {http://www.adb.org/projects/49203-002/documents}. This environmental impact assessment is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the “terms of use” section on ADB’s website. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. Annexes A. Maps of the project site and the investigation area B. Public Participation and Meetings C. Air Quality Modeling D. Noise Control Feasibility Report E. Biodiversity Study F. Rapid Hazard Risk Assessment (HAZIP) G. Emergency Preparedness and Response Policies and Procedures COORDINATION AND CONSULTATIVE MEETING/INTERVIEW Meetings Environmental Team ISSUES DISCUSSED/ No. ACTIVITIES DATE/PLACE PARTICIPANTS DATA PROVIDED KALTIM PEAKER 2 1 Coordination 09-08-16 PLN Pusat Introductions Meeting PLN Region (K3L Division) Confirmation information/data of Kaltim East Kalimantan PLN Region Peaker 2 and Tanjung Batu PP PLN UIP Discussion plan for field trip to Tanjung PPTA Team Batu Power Plant 2 Consultative 10-08-16 PLN Pusat Documents about power plants, meeting/ PLN Tanjung (K3L Division) operation and monitoring interview Batu PLN UIP discussions with staff PLN Tanjung site survey of the power plant Batu team PPTA Team 3 Coordination 15-03-17 PLN Pusat Introductions Meeting PLN Region (K3L Division) Confirmation information/data of Kaltim East Kalimantan PLN Region Peaker 2 and Tanjung Batu PP PLN UIP Discussion plan for field trip to Tanjung PPTA Team Batu Power Plant 4 Consultative 16-03-17 PLN Pusat Fuel purchase agreement meeting/ PLN Mahakam (K3L Division) Waste disposal agreement interview Sector PLN UIP Power plant organization PPTA Team Staff training plan Environmental Management Plan (EMP) Implementation document Confirmation that zero accident within PLN Mahakam Sector 5 Consultative 16-03-17 PLN Pusat Power plant organization and total staff meeting PLN Tanjung (K3L Division) Water abstraction license/similar Batu PLN UIP Hazardous waste management PLN Tanjung evidence Batu team Emission/air quality monitoring PPTA Team Field survey 6 Consultative 16-03-17 PLN Pusat There is no objection from community, meeting/ FGD Forum Adat (K3L Division) especially villager of Tanjung Batu Tanjung Batu PLN UIP regarding the 3 power plants within PLN area. Village Secretary village and The villagers never complain about head of Forum noise and dust that may occur from Adat Tanjung Batu Power Plant area. PPTA Team Community only complain about coal fire power plant which generate dust and contaminate the water. the Forum Adat inform that community from Tanjung Batu need to deliver 3 points as following: 9 Involve the community as worker in PLN, based on their skill e.g. as ISSUES DISCUSSED/ No. ACTIVITIES DATE/PLACE PARTICIPANTS DATA PROVIDED security or other position; 9 Improvement of the access road that built by PLN and the water supply as part of CSR (the head of Forum Adat informed that there is no CSR from PLN Tanjung Batu sector); 9 Hazardous management would be better cooperating with Forum Adat instead of giving to personal that “said” he is on behalf of the village community. Meetings social team No. Activities Date/Place Participants Issues Discussed/Agreements PLN-PUSAT 1 Coordination 14-10-16 - PLN 1. Agreed on scope of work for PPTA Social Team meeting PLN HQ Safeguards 2. Agreed on Field Visit Plan - PPTA Social 3. Discussed PLN Social Safeguard Institutional Safeguards Arrangements KALTIM PEAKER 2 12 Coordination 19-10-16 - PLN Pusat 1. Introductions and orientation; agreed on work Meeting PLN UIP/ - PLN UIP program for due diligence Sector Office - PLN Sector 2. Details on Land Acquisition Compensation in the East 1990s explained/described and documents provided - PPTA Team Kalimantan 3. Presented PLN CSR programs and procedures 13 Consultative 19-10-16 - PLN Pusat 1. Details on Land Acquisition Compensation of Desa meeting/ BPN Local Staff: Tanjung Batu, Kecamatan Tenggarong Seberang, interview Office - PLN UIP Kab Kutai Kartanegara, East Kalimantan Province Tenggarong - BPN (Land 2. Representative of BPN Local Office confirmed all – Kutai Agency) Local documents of land acquisition process in the 1990s Kartanegara Office onward are recorded by their office as part of the ‘Warkah’ - PPTA Team 3. Land acquisition in Desa Tanjung Batu followed regulation for land acquisition before year 2000, i.e.: - Regulation of the Minister of Home Affairs No. 15 Year 1975, concerning Regulations for Land Acquisition; - Presidential Decree of the Republic of Indonesia Number 55 Year 1993 regarding Land Procurement for the Implementation of Construction in the Interest of Public (17 June 1993) 14 Consultative 19/20-10- - PLN Pusat - Provided profile of the AH community meeting/ 16 - PLN UIP - Described land acquisition process carried out FGD Home of - Head of RT5 around 1994. AH leader with wife (AH) - Land acquired by PLN belonged to their parents in RT5, - 10 other AHs - Losses included house, land, and trees/crops. Tanjung No. Activities Date/Place Participants Issues Discussed/Agreements Batu - PPTA Team - Unsatisfied with compensation since value of compensation received was not sufficient to buy new same size agriculture/ farmland - Compensation for trees/crops were in accordance with their expectation - People now do not have land for farming, instead borrowing land owned by PLN. - One of the area bought by PLN also cover cemetery, so they have to relocate their family grave to other location (TPU Tanjung Batu Atas). Compensation for relocation were Rp 40,000 for children’s graves, and Rp 70,000 for adult graves. - Overall expressed support about the project but to provide more support to affected communities 15 Consultative 20-10-16 - PLN Pusat - Participants have heard about the project, but still meeting/ Home of - PLN UIP lack full information. FGD leader in - 11 HHs of - They accept the project and are excited about it. Bukit Raja Bukit Raja They highly expect to be involved in the project in accordance with their skills, not only during the - PPTA Team construction period, but also during the operational period. - They also expect that PLN will provide assistance to them, to improve their knowledge and skills during construction period so they can work in PLN – hoping that like PT CFK who recruited 50% of their workers from villages around CFK. - They expect PLN to support them by providing desa road improvement, street lightning, and improvement of culverts in front of Masjid Al Mukminun (due to flooding). Minutes of Coordination Meeting for Preparation of Environmental Documents and Environmental Permit for Gas Pipeline PK52 Badak Export Manifold - Electrical Center Tanjung Batu TRANSLATION Minutes of Meeting Date/Time 9 August 2016 / 09.00 - Venue PT PLN (Persero) UIP Kalimantan Timur Attachment - Attendance List PLN Pusat DlVK3L, UIP Kaltim, Wilayah Kaltimra (attached) 1. MEETING AGENDA Coordination Meeting for Preparation of Environmental Documents and Environmental Permit for Gas Pipeline PK52 Badak Export Manifold - Electrical Center Tanjung Batu 2. BACKGROUND Nota Dinas Kepala Satuan GBM Nomor : .......... tanggal .......... Perihal ................... and Faks KDIVK3L nomor 2474.FAC/STH.03.01/DIVK3L/2016 Tanggal 8 Agustus 2016 re abovementioned agenda 3. DISCUSSION NOTES 1. PLN will build a Gas Pipe Line Badak Export Manifold (BEM) - Electricity Centre Tanjung Batu of 55 km which is located at 2 Government areas (Kutai Regency and Municipality of Samarinda). The pipeline will use the existing pipelines ROW of VICO and Pertamina EP. 2. Based on the results of the feasibility study, the current condition of the existing ROW is land owned by the Government, but in some areas land is used for illegal settlements and estates by local residents, and the pipe line passes several small mineral and oil mines, a road and rice fields. 3. PLN Region Kaltimra reports: a. PLN and the Institute of Research, Development and Innovation of the Research Institute for Development of Dipterocarp Forest Ecosystems are preparing a cooperation agreement for the construction of the Badak Gas Export Manifold - Electrical Centre Tanjung Batu. b. A PPLB agreement is in the process of signature (PLN, VICO and Pertamina) c. PLN needs to immediately prepare a security cooperation agreement between PLN, Pertamina and VICO supervised by DIVK3L (MS K3). d. The gas pipeline is expected to be operational by October 2017. 4. DIVK3L states that: a. Due to the pipeline passing through two Regional Government areas, the approval authority is with the Provincial Environmental Environment Agency (BLH), involving two District BLHs. b. Information related to environmental documents for the existing pipe lines owned by Pertamina and VICO has to be taken into consideration. c. PLN UIP Kalbagtim shall immediately coordinate with BLH related to preparation of environmental documents for the existing pipeline. 5. The starting point of the BEM pipeline (PK52 - tap connection pipe) is located in a Forest Research area, so an agreement between PLN and the Research Center is required. 6. The original plan for land acquisition along the 3 km in oil palm plantations is abandoned considering required time and the high cost, so the pipeline will be rerouted following the path of the existing Pipeline belonging to VICO. 1 | 3 7. Documents prepared for the construction of the pipeline a.