Parliamentary Scrutiny of European Union Documents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Parliamentary Scrutiny of European Union Documents Guidance for Departments August 2013 CABINET OFFICE Page 1 PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY OF EUROPEAN UNION DOCUMENTS GUIDANCE FOR DEPARTMENTS KEYWORD INDEX SECTION 1: PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY: OVERVIEW SECTION 2: DEPOSIT OF DOCUMENTS IN PARLIAMENT 2.1 Depositable documents 2.2 Documents the Committees have agreed need not be deposited 2.3 Documents not suitable for deposit 2.4 Procedure for deposit SECTION 3: EXPLANATORY MEMORANDA 3.1 Timetable 3.2 Form and content 3.3 Unnumbered EMs 3.4 Supplementary EMs 3.5 EMs on Proposals subject to the Ordinary Legislative Procedure 3.6 EMs on Proposals subject to the Special Legislative Procedure 3.7 Short EMs 3.8 Corrigenda to EMs 3.9 Circulation of EMs 3.10 Withdrawal of EMs SECTION 4: THE SCRUTINY PROCESS 4.1 The Commons Committee 4.2 The Lords Committee 4.3 Liaison with the Committees 4.4 Preparation for Committee meetings 4.5 Consideration by Committees 4.6 Scrutiny clearance 4.7 Further scrutiny 4.8 Withdrawal of debate recommendations 4.9 Cabinet Office records 4.10 Giving evidence to the Committees 4.11 Commission Legislation 4.12 Correspondence with the Scrutiny Committees SECTION 5: SCRUTINY DEBATES 5.1 Arranging Commons debates 5.2 European Committee Debates 5.3 Floor Debates 5.4 Government Motions and amendments 5.5 Second Debates Page 2 5.6 Debates in the Lords SECTION 6: UNCLEARED PROPOSALS: ACTION TO BE TAKEN 6.1 Government undertaking (Scrutiny Reserve Resolution) 6.2 Action required on uncleared proposals 6.3 Parliamentary scrutiny reserves 6.4 Statements to the House SECTION 7: PROCEDURE TO BE FOLLOWED DURING RECESSES AND BETWEEN PARLIAMENTS 7.1 Procedure during recesses 7.2 Procedure between Parliaments 1. ANNEXES A. Commons Scrutiny Committee – terms of reference B. Lords Scrutiny Committee – terms of reference C. Standing Order 119: European Committees D. Commons Scrutiny Reserve Resolution E. Lords Scrutiny Reserve Resolution F. Lisbon Treaty Protocol on Role of National Parliaments G. Standard form of Explanatory Memorandum H. Example format for a corrigendum/addendum to an EM I. Example format for reference to scrutiny history in EMs. J. Circulation lists for various forms of Memoranda K Blank L Lisbon Treaty Protocol on Subsidiarity and Proportionality M Flow Chart – legislative process where ordinary legislative procedure applies N Pre and Post Council Evidence Procedures O Blank P Commons European Committee debates: Provision of papers and example motions Q Blank R. Blank S JHA Code of Practice: with Baroness Ashton Statement on Scrutiny of JHA Opt-In and Schengen Opt-Out decisions with Lords Scrutiny Resolution and MFE Statement T Blank U Government Undertakings on Scrutiny V Best Practice Tips for Successful Scrutiny W Instructions for Writing to the Committees Page 3 KEYWORD INDEX Subject Paragraph(s) Addenda to EMs 3.3.5, Annex H Amended proposals, handling of 2.1.1(i), 3.2.1, 3.4.1, 3.5, 3.6, 3.7.1, 4.7, 4.8.1b, 5.1.2, 6.2.11, 6.2.15 Anti-dumping measures 2.3.1(i), 2.3.10 Article 308 3.2.5(i) Chief Whip’s Office, role of 4.8.1(b), 5.1.2, 5.1.4-9, 5.2.3, 5.2.11-13, 5.4.2, 5.4.4 Ordinary Legislative Procedure 2.1.1i, 3.1.2, 3.2.5(ii), 3.5.1-3, 6.1.1, 6.2.1, 6.2.10, Annex M Commission legislation 2.1.1, 2.3.1 (iii), 4.11 Common Foreign and Security policy See inter-governmental pillars Comitology 4.11.1-3 Confidential documents, handling of 2.3.1(i-ii), 2.3.4, 2.3.7, 2.3.10, 5.2.6 (see also negotiating mandates, anti-dumping measures and working documents) Consultation documents, handling of 2.1.2 Consultation exercises 2.1.2ii, 2.1.4, 3.2.16, Special Legislative Procedure 3.2.5(ii), 3.6.1-3 Correspondence with Scrutiny 3.2.2, 3.2.17, 3.4.3, 4.10.3, 4.11.3, 4.12.1 Committees Corrigenda to EMs 3.7, Annex H Council Legal Service opinions 3.2.5, 5.2.6 Devolution 2.4.6, 3.1.2-3, 3.1.6, 3.2.3, 3.2.11, 3.9.1 6.1.3 European Economic Area (EEA) 3.2.1, 3.2.6-89 Euros 3.2.15 External Agreements 2.3.1(iv), 2.3.3, 2.3.8-9 European Committees: Operating procedures 5.2.9-13 Provision of papers 5.2.5-6, Annex P Terms of Reference Annex C Page 4 Foreign text 2.3.1(ix), 3.2.19 Fundamental Rights analysis See Human Rights General Approach 6.2.1, 6.2.16 Gibraltar 3.2.5(v) Government Undertakings Annex U Human Rights Act 1998: compatibility 3.2.5(vi), Annex G with Impact Assessment 3.1.2, 3.2.13 Inter-governmental pillars 2.1.1(iii-iv), 2.2.1-5, 2.3.11, 6.1.1 Implementation of legislation 3.2.4(iv), Annex G Justice and Home Affairs See Inter-governmental pillars Limité Documents 2.3.1 Management Committee, documents 2.3.1(iii) arising from disagreement with the Commission Minimum scrutiny period 6.3.4-6 Negotiating mandates 2.3.1(iv), 2.3.3-7 Overrides; Report to Parliament 6.2.10 Political Agreement 6.2.1, 6.2.8, 6.2.11, 6.2.15 Pre and Post Council Scrutiny 4.10.6, Annex N Regulatory Committee See Management Committee and Comitology Scrutiny Committee reports: Commons 4.5.1, 4.5.3, 5.2.6 Lords 4.5.4-7, 4.5.9 Statements to the House 6.2.12-13, 6.5, 7.1.4 Subsidiarity 3.2.10, Annex L Supplementary EMs 3.4.1-4, 4.7, 4.8.1 (b) , 5.4.3, 6.2.15 Terms of Reference: Page 5 Commons Scrutiny Committee 2.1.1, 4.1.1, Annex A Lords Scrutiny Committee 2.1.3, Annex B European Committees 5.2.1, Annex C Unnumbered EMs 2.3.1 (iii), 2.3.6, 2.3.8-10, 3.1.1, 3.3.1-4, 3.4.1, 3.4.4, 3.5.2 (ii), 4.7, 5.4.2, Annex G Unsigned EMs 3.2.1, 3.7.1-3, 3.8, Annex G Withdrawal of debate recommendations: Commons 4.8.1 Lords 4.8.2 Withdrawal of deposited documents 2.4.5 Working documents, handling of 2.1.2, 2.3.1(ii) , 3.3.1(ii), 3.3.2-4, 3.4.1 World Trade Organisation 3.2.12 Page 6 PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY: GUIDANCE FOR DEPARTMENTS 2. SECTION 1 3. PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY: OVERVIEW 1.1 This guidance is for departmental officials who will come into contact with the Parliamentary scrutiny process and provides comprehensive guidance on scrutiny policy and procedures. This section highlights the principles and stages of the process. Detailed practical guidance is given later.. For further advice, contact the European & Global Issues Secretariat of the Cabinet Office.* 4. WHAT IS PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY? 1.2 Parliamentary scrutiny is the process by which Parliament is given the opportunity to examine and express views on proposals for EU legislation and any other documents held to fall within the terms of reference of the Scrutiny Committees of both Houses of Parliament. (See Section 2, and Annexes A and B). The Government is committed to the principle of effective scrutiny of European legislation, and both Houses have agreed scrutiny reserve resolutions which state that Ministers will not agree to proposals in the Council of Ministers except in certain circumstances until scrutiny by the Committees has been completed (see Section 6). The importance attached to scrutiny by national parliaments throughout the EU is reflected in the Protocol on the Role of National Parliaments in the Lisbon Treaty (see Annex F). Parliament now has a direct role in considering the subsidiarity and proportionality implications of proposals (see ad hoc guidance letter (09)25 & (10)19). This role is set out in a protocol attached to the Lisbon Treaty (Annex L.) 1.3 A list of key Government undertakings on scrutiny is at Annex U 5. PRESENTATION OF EU DOCUMENTS TO PARLIAMENT 1.4 The Cabinet Office is responsible for the maintenance of the Government’s scrutiny procedures and is responsible for deciding, in consultation with Departments, and with the Committee clerks where necessary, which EU documents should be deposited in Parliament – taking steps to make sure that these decisions are consistent with the Standing Orders of both Scrutiny Committees. The Cabinet Office will take the initiative in most cases, but Departments must be vigilant in looking for documents that may be eligible for deposit and scrutiny. There will always be grey areas about whether a document should be deposited or whether it is caught by the terms of the scrutiny reserve resolutions, and it is therefore important that the Government is as flexible as possible in its approach to ensure that the spirit of the scrutiny reserve resolutions is respected as far as possible. The Government must not be left open to allegations that it is withholding documents from Parliament. The FCO/MOD and Home Office/MoJ ** Unless otherwise indicated, references to the Cabinet Office in this guide are to the European & Global Issues Secretariat Page 7 take the lead in deciding which documents under the Common and Foreign Security Policy and in the area of Freedom, Security and Justice respectively, should be subject to scrutiny.