Tracing Exhumation and Orogenic Wedge Dynamics in the European Alps with Detrital Thermochronology
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Tracing exhumation and orogenic wedge dynamics in the European Alps with detrital thermochronology Barbara Carrapa Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Wyoming, Laramie, Wyoming 82071, USA ABSTRACT lag time upsection (e.g., Bernet et al., 2001; Detrital cooling ages from the pro-foreland and retro-foreland basins of the European Carrapa et al., 2003a) (Fig. 2). In turn, the rate Alps record distinctive exhumation trends that correlate with orogenic wedge states inferred of migration of the fl exural wave into the fore- from thrust front propagation rates. Periods of rapid hinterland exhumation correlate with land is expected to be slower during subcritical relatively slow propagation of deformation toward the foreland and are interpreted to rep- conditions and faster during supercritical condi- resent subcritical wedge conditions, whereas periods of slow hinterland exhumation corre- tions. If those processes have infl uenced Alpine late with rapid propagation of deformation toward the foreland and indicate supercritical exhumation along and across strike, we should wedge conditions. Similar lag time trends recorded in both the pro-foreland and retro-fore- expect to fi nd characteristic trends in the detri- land thus mimic orogenic wedge behavior and suggest that local tectonics and/or climate tal record (von Eynatten et al., 1999; Spiegel et events do not overprint the regional signal. al., 2001, 2004; Carrapa et al., 2003a, 2004a, 2004b; von Eynatten and Wijbrans, 2003). INTRODUCTION These processes, combined with later deforma- The internal structure, kinematic history, tional and thermal events, produced the distri- ALPINE FORELAND BASIN RECORD and surface topography of contractional moun- bution of thermochronological ages observed The area considered in this study covers the tain belts are products of complex interactions today (Fig. 1). entire orogenic system (Fig. 1) and the prove- between crustal shortening and/or thickening The Alps are formed by two oppositely verg- nance of most of the samples is well constrained and exhumation. Numerous studies have shown ing tapered orogenic wedges (Figs. 1B and 2), by sandstone and conglomerate petrography and that mountain belts can be successfully mod- and loading of the upper plate by these wedges paleocurrent data (e.g., Brügel, 1998; Carrapa eled as critically tapered orogenic wedges (e.g., produced foreland basins on both sides of the and DiGiulio, 2001; Evans and Elliott, 1999; Davis et al., 1983; Suppe and Medwedeff, 1990; orogen (Naylor and Sinclair, 2008). Critical Spiegel et al., 2002; Dunkl et al., 2001, and Willett et al., 1993; Koons, 1994; DeCelles and taper theory (e.g., Chapple, 1978; Davis et al., Carrapa et al., 2004a, and references therein). Mitra, 1995). Critical taper models make predic- 1983) predicts that the front of an orogenic Medium- to low-temperature detrital thermo- tions about the kinematic history of an orogenic wedge develops taper and propagates toward chronological data from the pro-foreland and wedge in response to changes in mass distribu- the foreland when the sum of the angles of retro-foreland basins of the Western, Central, tion, which in turn is controlled by exhumation. the basal and upper slopes (referred to as the and Eastern Alps (Fig. 3) show that different Therefore, in order to understand the relation- taper value) reaches a critical value. When the thermochronometers record similar patterns of ships between exhumation and kinematic pro- taper value is less than the critical value (sub- exhumation. This suggests that differences in lag cesses it is essential to determine the timing, critical), the wedge will shorten internally by time responses for different thermo chrono meters rates, and spatial distribution of exhumation. out-of-sequence thrusting and/or duplexing to are undetectable at this scale of observation and The European Alps are a classic example of build thickness and increase taper. Among other that sediment reworking is not a problem. a strongly asymmetrical continent-continent col- things, subcritical conditions could be caused In the pro-foreland of the Central and Eastern lisional orogen and one of the few cases of a dou- by enhanced erosion due to wetter or more sea- Alps, the decreasing lag-time trend (Fig. 3A) bly verging orogen with two foreland basin sys- sonal climate. If the taper value is greater than suggests increasing exhumation from ca. 30 to 10 tems (e.g., Naylor and Sinclair, 2008). The North the critical value (supercritical), the orogenic Ma, suggesting subcritical taper conditions. The and South Alpine foreland basins provide a natu- wedge will broaden and reduce the overall pro-foreland of the Western Alps records increas- ral laboratory in which to explore the distribu- taper angle by forward thrust propagation and/ ing exhumation between 38 and 36 Ma (suggest- tion of exhumation along (east-west) and across or internal extension in order to regain balance ing a subcritical state) and decreasing exhuma- (north-south) the orogen over tens of millions of between driving and resisting forces. Exhuma- tion between ca. 16 and 8 Ma (supercritical state) years. This paper documents the relationships tion of material from the wedge may be viewed (Fig. 3B). Deep and rapid exhumation is also between orogenic wedge taper and exhumation as a response to changing taper states (Davis et indicated by ca. 34 Ma 40Ar/39Ar ages from peb- in the Alps with detrital thermochronology. al., 1983; DeCelles and Mitra, 1995). Therefore, bles in early Oligocene synorogenic conglomer- if the Alps obey wedge theory, increasing hin- ates in the French Alps (Morag et al., 2008). WEDGE TECTONICS, terland exhumation refl ects a subcritical wedge In the retro-foreland of the Western Alps EXHUMATION, AND DETRITAL state, whereas decreasing hinterland exhuma- (Fig. 3C) the youngest thermochronological THERMOCHRONOLOGY tion refl ects a supercritical wedge state. Increas- signal (ca. 32–38 Ma) remains constant for >30 The Alpine chain formed as a consequence of ing exhumation will be recorded by detrital m.y. This represents rapid cooling and episodic convergence and subsequent collision between minerals within foreland basin strata with an exhumation of the internal crystalline massifs the Eurasian and African continents from early upsection-decreasing lag time (e.g., Garver et (e.g., Dora Maira) between ca. 38 and 32 Ma to middle Cenozoic time (e.g., Stampfl i and al., 1999) between cooling and depositional (e.g., Carrapa et al., 2003a) and of the Periadri- Marchant, 1997; Rosenbaum and Lister, 2005). ages, whereas decreasing exhumation will be atic plutons (e.g., Bergell) in the Central Alps This was responsible for signifi cant shortening recorded by an increasing lag time upsection. (e.g., Garzanti and Malusá, 2008), suggesting (as much as 195 km; Ford et al., 2006; Schmid Episodic exhumation will be recorded by an subcritical wedge conditions. This was fol- and Kissling, 2000; Pfi ffner et al., 2000), crustal increasing lag time upsection, whereas steady- lowed by slower cooling (~10°/m.y.), indicating thickening of the upper plate, and exhumation. state exhumation will be recorded by a constant a supercritical wedge state. It is interesting that © 2009 Geological Society of America. For permission to copy, contact Copyright Permissions, GSA, or [email protected]. GEOLOGY,Geology, December December 2009; 2009 v. 37; no. 12; p. 1127–1130; doi: 10.1130/G30065A.1; 4 fi gures. 1127 48°N ages from the Friuli-Venetian foreland (Eastern A (11) Alps derived) indicate a change in lag time trend Pro-foreland ca. 12 Ma that may correspond to a change in tectono-thermal regime, possibly related to (9) exhumation of the Lepontine Dome (Spiegel et A (10)(10)* 47°N al., 2004; von Eynatten and Wijbrans, 2003). Swiss Molasse basin Aar G THRUST FRONT PROPAGATION, K-Ar and40 Ar/ 39 Ar ages: 140–60 Ma LD SUBSIDENCE, AND EXHUMATION 30–60 Ma From ca. 40 to 30 Ma the North Alpine pro- 30–15 Ma 46°N 15–0 Ma foreland basin (Swiss Molasse Basin) was an MB DB ZFT ages < 20 Ma (1)(2)(5) ~100-km-wide, deeply underfi lled fl exural AFT ages < 15 Ma G SL trough with <200 m of sedimentary fi ll. The AFT ages < 5 Ma B GP pro-wedge thrust front advanced northward at Milano (6) Retro-foreland high rates of 10–20 mm/a (Sinclair and Allen, Torino 45°N Po Plain 1992; Burkhard and Sommaruga, 1998). This TPB correlates to a supercritical wedge behavior. (7) (8) Between 30 and 22 Ma, both the thrust front Pro-foreland DM Alpes de and the distal foreland basin depositional pin- Arg Apennine(3)(4) foreland (12)(12*) Proven e (4)* chout migrated northwestward at a slower rate Digne Haute 44°N Valensole ç of ~5 mm/a (Fig. 4). Increased tectonic subsi- basin Bâ rreme dence (2.7 km) produced a basin that was totally basin Nice Ligurian Sea fi lled above sea level by sediment (Sinclair and Allen, 1992; Burkhard and Sommaruga, 1998). The thermochronological lag time decreased 43°N during this time (30–12 Ma), indicating increas- 4E° 5°E 6°E 7°E 8°E 9°E 10°E 11°E 12°E ing exhumation (Fig. 3A) and subcritical taper B Pro-foreland Retro-foreland conditions. An increase in sediment fl ux into the A AU MA MO HE PF NCA PA AU PA IL SA B foreland basin, between 30 and 22 Ma (Kuhle- mann et al., 2002), correlates with an increase VA SU B TA in source exhumation. From 22 to 12 Ma, the Aar 10 AD foreland basin depositional pinchout continued GO A A 20 1 34 5 to migrate northwestward at a slower rate. The B 2 B km basin had a width of ~100–140 km, and rapid Figure 1. Digital elevation model of Alps and fl anking foreland basins with compilations of subsidence continued (Burkhard and Somma- 40Ar/ 39Ar ages younger than 140 Ma (after Hunziker et al., 1992, and references therein), zircon ruga, 1998).