DOCSLIB.ORG

Programme Sierra Leone - Virtual Programme for Committee Chairs & Clerks 5, 7, 9 October 2020 2 Contents

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Programme Sierra Leone - Virtual Programme for Committee Chairs & Clerks 5, 7, 9 October 2020 2 Contents PROGRAMME SIERRA LEONE - VIRTUAL PROGRAMME FOR COMMITTEE CHAIRS & CLERKS 5, 7, 9 OCTOBER 2020 2 CONTENTS BACKGROUND 1 IMPACT, OUTCOMES & OUTPUTS 2 GENERAL INFORMATION 2 PROGRAMME 3 COMMITTEE EXERCISE BRIEFING 6 SPEAKER BIOGRAPHIES 14 DELEGATE BIOGRAPHIES 17 ABOUT CPA UK 20 NOTES 21 BACKGROUND Welcome to the virtual programme for committee Chairs and clerks from the Parliament of Sierra Leone, facilitated by CPA UK from 5 – 9 October 2020. This three half-day virtual programme will focus on the roles of Chairs and clerks in effectively running parliamentary committees, and the key skills and techniques used during inquiries. This programme is part of CPA UKs parliamentary partnership programme with the Parliament of Sierra Leone to help strengthen a more effective, accountable and inclusive parliament. CPA UK has held a number of capacity-building activities over the past few years, including a Post-Election Seminar to train newly elected parliamentarians in 2018 and a Committee Scrutiny Workshop held in Freetown in 2019. In addition, CPA UK and the Parliament of Sierra Leone published a Vision for the Future, in which staff presented their vision for the new Parliament, and the necessary actions of Members and staff to ensure a strong and robust Parliament. Building on this work, this programme will bring together seven Chairs and three committee clerks to further the skills and capacity of participants in running efficient and effective committees. Delegates will have the opportunity to hear from Members, peers and clerks from the UK Parliament on the UK select committee system, and compare approaches taken at the Parliament of Sierra Leone and the UK Parliament respectively. Speakers and participants will share good practice, common challenges and solutions, and new ways of working necessitated by the response to the Covid-19 pandemic. Hosted in Freetown in collaboration with the British High Commission, this programme aims to strengthen the existing relationship between the UK Parliament and the Parliament of Sierra Leone and continues CPA UK’s support to parliamentarians and clerks in ensuring committees’ capacity to provide effective scrutiny through their inquiries. 1 IMPACTS, OUTCOMES & OUTPUTS Impact. The Parliament of Sierra Leone is more inclusive, transparent and accountable, particularly with regards to the efficiency and effectiveness of committees. Output 1. A three half-day virtual programme successfully delivered to committee chairs and clerks from the Parliament of Sierra Leone. Output 2. Seven committee Chairs and three clerks have strengthened their skills and capacity within their respective roles in order to ensure effective parliamentary scrutiny through committee inquiries. Outcome 1. Increased mutual understanding between the UK Parliament and the Parliament of Sierra Leone on procedures of the committee systems and good practice within these. Outcome 2. Improved relations between the two Parliaments, through discussions and meetings between members and clerks. Monitoring and evaluation. As part of CPA UKs monitoring and evaluation process, delegates will be asked to complete pre- and post-assessment forms at the start and end of the programme. Indicators in the feedback are used to determine whether programme outcomes have been achieved. All data collected is strictly for internal use only and assists CPA UK in planning future activities. GENERAL INFORMATION Venue Delegates will be hosted at the Residence of the British High Commissioner, located at Runneymede, Main Hill Station Road, Freetown. Please arrive at 11:30 am to ensure a prompt start on Monday 5 October. Remaining Covid-19 Secure Delegates are requested to wear a facemask for the duration of their time in the Residence. Social distancing measures will also be in place, with guidance given by High Commission staff. Virtual Guidelines Participants are asked to kindly turn off mobile phones during the programme. Although discussions will be held virtually, participants are encouraged to interact with speakers throughout meetings, in particular during question and answer sessions. Photographs and Recordings Throughout the programme photographs may be taken of ongoing sessions, for use on CPA UK’s social media platforms. As the programme will include CPA UKs first virtual committee exercise, this practical session will be recorded for internal evaluation purposes. Twitter CPA UK will be tweeting about the programme using @CPA_UK. We encourage delegates to join us. PROGRAMME PARTNERS & SUPPORTERS 2 PROGRAMME Day 1: The Westminster Committee System Monday 5 October 2020 British High Commissioner’s Residence TIME SESSION 11:30 Arrive at the British High Commissioners Residence, Runneymede, Main Hill Station Road 11:50 - 12:10 Welcome Delegates will be welcomed by the British High Commission and CPA UK. Speakers: Alistair White, British Deputy High Commissioner to Sierra Leone Jon Davies, Chief Executive, CPA UK 12:10 - 13:00 Session 1: Overview of the UK Parliament and Committee System This first session of the programme will begin with introductions from delegates from the Parliament of Sierra Leone and the CPA UK team, as well as an outline of the virtual programme for the week. This session will provide a brief introduction to the Westminster system, with a particular focus on the different types of committees in the House of Commons and the House of Lords, as well as the changes to parliamentary procedure during the Covid-19 pandemic, including the introduction of a virtual parliament. Speakers: The Baroness Barker, Deputy Chairman of Committees, House of Lords, UK Parliament Ben Sneddon, Senior Clerk, Petitions Committee, House of Commons, UK Parliament 13:00 - 13:10 Break After the break, Committee Chairs and clerks will be split into two rooms for the following session. 13:10 - 13:55 Session 2a: Responsibilities of Committee Chairs This session will explore the roles and responsibilities of a committee Chair. Speakers and delegates will be able to compare and contrast their approaches to chairing committees and balancing key responsibilities, sharing best practice as well as exploring common challenges. Looking at their influential role and leadership in inquiries, the discussion will explore how Chairs can be most effective in their role and foster productive relationships with fellow members and support staff. Speakers: Rt Hon Hilary Ben MP, Chair, Committee on the Future Relationship with the European Union, House of Commons, UK Parliament Christian Matheson MP, Shadow Minister for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport 13:10 - 13:55 Session 2b: The Role of Committee Clerks In this session for clerks, the discussion will focus on the role of a committee clerk and outline the responsibilities in supporting committees and their inquiries in the UK, identifying differences and similarities between the two Parliaments. The discussion will also explore approaches from the UK Parliament, such as the use of Standards of Service, in promoting effective working relationships between committee clerks and Chairs. Speaker: Chris Shaw, Deputy Principal Clerk and Clerk of the Foreign Affairs Committee, House of Commons 13:55 - 14:10 Session 3: Feedback, Recap and Closing In this session Chairs and clerks will reconvene to share their thoughts on building productive working relationships, in order to effectively conduct committee business. The day will end with a brief feedback session and a look ahead at the second day of the programme. Facilitator: Rahel Kibru, Programme Officer, CPA UK 14:10 End of day 1 Parliament of Sierra Leone | Virtual Programme for Committee Chairs and Clerks | October 2020 3 Day 2: Cross-Party Consensus and Diversity Wednesday 7 October 2020 British High Commissioner’s Residence TIME SESSION 11:45 Arrive at the British High Commissioners Residence, Runneymede, Main Hill Station Road Committee Chairs and clerks will be split into two rooms for the following session. 12:00 - 12:50 Session 4a: Committee Consensus and Cross-Party work The second day of the programme will commence with a session exploring how committee Chairs can build consensus and cohesion amongst members and promote cross-party working to support the effective running of a committee inquiry. Delegates will also discuss how to ensure evidence before the committee is carefully considered, without party politics impeding strong evidence-based recommendations. Speaker: Sarah Champion MP, Chair, International Development Committee, House of Commons, UK Parliament 12:00 - 12:50 Session 4b: Producing Impactful Reports In this session, clerks will explore what makes an inquiry report impactful, and compare the role of the clerk in the Parliaments of the UK and Sierra Leone in preparing these. The discussion will emphasise the importance of making realistic, specific, and time-bound recommendations to government, as well as the role of national media in publicising inquiry findings to the wider public. Speakers: Rebecca Usden, Senior Committee Specialist, House of Commons, UK Parliament Alex Knight, Senior Economist, Scrutiny Unit, House of Commons, UK Parliament 12:50 - 13:00 Break After the break, Chairs and clerks will reconvene in the same room for the following session. 13:00 - 13:50 Session 5: Diversity and Inclusion in Committees Ensuring committees engage a range of organisations and witnesses that are representative of wider society is vital when making policy recommendations to government. In pushing for such diversity, committees can obtain quality evidence
Load more

Recommended publications
  • House of Lords
    THE STANDING ORDERS OF THE HOUSE OF LORDS RELATING TO PUBLIC BUSINESS 2016 PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY OF THE HOUSE OF LORDS HL Paper 3 THE STANDING ORDERS OF THE HOUSE OF LORDS RELATING TO PUBLIC BUSINESS Ordered to be printed 18 May 2016 PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY OF THE HOUSE OF LORDS HL Paper 3 © Parliamentary copyright House of Lords 2016. Re-use of this material is permitted under the terms of the Open Parliament Licence, which is published at www.parliament.uk/site- information/copyright/open-parliament-licence/ Please address enquiries to the Clerk of the Journals, House of Lords, London SW1A 0PW. These Standing Orders are also published at www.parliament.uk/business/publications/house-of-lords- publications/rules-and-guides-for-business/ 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS Standing Order Page Arrangements when Her Majesty is present 1. Arrangements when Her Majesty present 7 Lords and the manner of their introduction 2. Lords not to sit in Parliament before twenty-one 8 3. Peers by descent not to be introduced 8 4. No fee to be paid on introduction 8 5. Difference in form or style of writs 8 6. Bishops Lords of Parliament to be introduced 8 7. Lords’ higher titles to be used 8 8. Precedency 8 Excepted Hereditary Peers 9. Hereditary peers 9 10. Hereditary peers: by-elections 10 11. Register of hereditary peers 10 Expulsion or suspension of a member 12. Expulsion or suspension of a member 11 The House and its arrangements 13. Right to be present in House when sitting 12 14. Duties and powers of Black Rod 12 15.
    [Show full text]
  • Assembly Committee Structures
    National Assembly for Wales Research paper Assembly Committee Structures April 2013 Research Service The National Assembly for Wales is the democratically elected body that represents the interests of Wales and its people, makes laws for Wales and holds the Welsh Government to account. The Research Service provides expert and impartial research and information to support Assembly Members and committees in fulfilling the scrutiny, legislative and representative functions of the National Assembly for Wales. Research Service briefings are compiled for the benefit of Assembly Members and their support staff. Authors are available to discuss the contents of these papers with Members and their staff but cannot advise members of the general public. We welcome comments on our briefings; please post or email to the addresses below. An electronic version of this paper can be found on the National Assembly website at: www.assemblywales.org/research Further hard copies of this paper can be obtained from: Research Service National Assembly for Wales Cardiff Bay CF99 1NA Email: [email protected] Twitter: @NAWResearch © National Assembly for Wales Commission Copyright 2013 The text of this document may be reproduced free of charge in any format or medium providing that it is reproduced accurately and not used in a misleading or derogatory context. The material must be acknowledged as copyright of the National Assembly for Wales Commission and the title of the document specified. Enquiry no: 13/0836 Paper number: 13 /027 National Assembly for Wales Research paper Assembly Committee Structures April 2013 Alys Thomas and Owain Roberts This paper summarises the ways in which committees in the National Assembly for Wales have developed since 2007, particularly in relation to how they have dealt with the scrutiny of legislation.
    [Show full text]
  • 1St Report of Session 2019-21
    HOUSE OF LORDS Procedure Committee 1st Report of Session 2019–21 Appointment of Parliamentary Works Sponsor Body Spokesperson and Sponsor Body members General and balloted debates for the new parliamentary session Committee statements Privileges Committee: consequences of establishing the Conduct Committee Terms of reference of the European Union Committee Ordered to be printed 2 March 2020 Published by the Authority of the House of Lords HL Paper 29 Procedure Committee The Select Committee on Procedure of the House is appointed each session to consider any proposals for alterations in the procedure of the House that may arise from time to time, and whether the standing orders require to be amended. Membership The members of the Procedure Committee are: Lord Ashton of Hyde Lord McAvoy Lord Bew Lord McFall of Alcluith (Chair) Lord Eames Lord Morris of Aberavon Baroness Evans of Bowes Park Lord Newby Lord Foulkes of Cumnock Baroness Smith of Basildon Lord Fowler (Lord Speaker) Lord Stoneham of Droxford Lord Geddes Baroness Thomas of Winchester Baroness Harris of Richmond Viscount Ullswater Lord Judge Baroness Warwick of Undercliffe Lord Mancroft Alternate members: Baroness Browning (for backbench Conservative members) Baroness Finaly of Llandaff (for Crossbench members, other than the Convenor) Lord Scriven (for backbench Liberal Democrat members) Lord Turnbull (for the Convenor) Declaration of interests A full list of Members’ interests can be found in the Register of Lords’ Interests: http://www.parliament.uk/mps-lords-and-offices/standards-and-interests/register-of-lords-
    [Show full text]
  • Committee of Selection
    COMMITTEE OF SELECTION Gender balance of House of Lords Select Committee membership - July 2021 1. In December 2018 the UK Gender Sensitive Parliament Audit1 recommended that a Parliamentary body monitor the gender breakdown of MPs and peers and those in leadership positions. The House of Lords Commission subsequently asked the Committee of Selection to carry out annual monitoring of Lords committee membership and chairing.2 2. This is the second such report. Since the first was published in April 2020 there have been significant changes to the structure of House of Lords select committees, with the European Union Committee and its sub-committees replaced by six new sessional committees and one sub-committee. The changes required to establish this new committee structure took place between January and April 2021. 3. The numbers in the table below show the 2021 gender balance of House of Lords select committee membership. The committees included in the table are those whose members are proposed by the Committee of Selection before being appointed by way of motions on the floor of the House. As of 22 July 2021 33.9% of select committee members were female and 66.1% were male.3 The gender balance of the membership of the House of Lords as a whole at the beginning of July 2021 was 28.1% female and 71.9% male.4 When we published the equivalent figures last year 32.6% of select committee members were female and 67.4% were male, while the gender balance of the membership of the House of Lords as a whole was 27.7% female and 72.3% male.
    [Show full text]
  • Constitution Unit Monitor 72 / June 2019
    1 Constitution Unit Monitor 72 / June 2019 But, with the pressure of an immediate deadline gone, Brexit and the changing and with looming European Parliament elections that she had never wanted to hold, the perilous politics of logic of British politics a cross-party deal proved unnavigable. Following her The Brexit tumult goes on, and is increasingly promise that a proposed Withdrawal Agreement Bill challenging some central tenets of British politics. would include a referendum clause, Theresa May’s cross-party flirtations sufficiently infuriated sections of Having been due to leave the European Union on 29 her party that she was eventually forced to acknowledge March, the UK will now remain until at least 31 October. defeat. On 24 May she announced her intention to step Right up to the original deadline, the government down, triggering a contest for the leadership of the was making frenetic efforts to negotiate addenda to Conservative Party and (very likely) for the country. the Withdrawal Agreement (see page 2), but it could not gain concessions adequate to persuade MPs to Throughout these months of tumult the role of accept the deal (see page 4). Extensions were agreed, parliament has been central, and hotly contested. first just for two weeks, then for seven months. A key The 2016 referendum initiated such tension, by pitting obstacle is fragmentation on the government side, with popular sovereignty against the conventional logic of Conservative MPs (mostly those who are pro-Brexit) parliamentary sovereignty. Most recently there has refusing to compromise. With great reluctance, the Prime been a long battle of wills between government and Minister ultimately turned to seeking a pact with the parliament.
    [Show full text]
  • Guidance on Hybrid House and Hybrid Grand Committee from the Procedure and Privileges Committee: 9Th Edition, 9 March 2021, to Take Effect from 9 March
    GUIDANCE ON HYBRID HOUSE AND HYBRID GRAND COMMITTEE FROM THE PROCEDURE AND PRIVILEGES COMMITTEE: 9TH EDITION, 9 MARCH 2021, TO TAKE EFFECT FROM 9 MARCH Introduction 1. This guidance sets out the procedures for hybrid House sittings and hybrid Grand Committee sittings. It supports the Orders of the House relating to hybrid sittings.1 This guidance has the same authority as the Companion to the Standing Orders, and is reviewed and updated regularly by the Procedure and Privileges Committee.2 Principles underpinning hybrid sittings Status and quorum of the hybrid House and Grand Committee 2. Sittings of the hybrid House have the same status and authority as normal sittings of the House. There must be a physical quorum in the Chamber of at least three members. The quorum of 30 for divisions on bills and subordinate legislation under Standing Order 57 is made up of members participating physically or remotely. 3. Hybrid Grand Committees also require a physical quorum of at least three members and can take the decisions that a Grand Committee can usually make. Parity of treatment 4. Where practicable, there is parity of treatment between remote and physical participants in hybrid sittings. With the exception of proceedings specified at paragraph 68, all members participating need to be included on the published speakers’ list. The Chair calls each speaker and members are not able to intervene spontaneously, save when the Government Whip does so physically in the Chamber or Grand Committee in order to assist management of proceedings. Chairing and advising hybrid sittings 5. The hybrid House is chaired from the Woolsack.
    [Show full text]
  • Government Whips' Office House of Lords
    GOVERNMENT WHIPS’ OFFICE HOUSE OF LORDS FORTHCOMING BUSINESS 14 APRIL 2021 [Notes about this document are set out at the end] WEDNESDAY 14 APRIL 2021 Last day to table amendments for the marshalled list for: Overseas Operations (Service Personnel and Veterans) Bill – Third Reading Financial Services Bill – Report (day 3) Business in the Chamber at 12noon 1. Oral questions (40 minutes) 2. Financial Services Bill – Report (day 2) – Earl Howe Business in Grand Committee in Committee Room 2A at 2.30pm 1. Debate on the case for building an inclusive society in the post-pandemic world and of the actions necessary by both national and local government to achieve this in the UK – Baroness Lister of Burtersett/Lord Greenhalgh (time limit 5 hours) THURSDAY 15 APRIL 2021 Last day to table amendments for the marshalled list for: Non-Domestic Rating (Public Lavatories) Bill – Third Reading Business in the Chamber at 12noon 1. Oral questions (40 minutes) 2. National Security and Investment Bill – Report – Lord Callanan Business in Grand Committee in Committee Room 2A at 2.30pm 1. Draft Recognised Auction Platforms (Amendment and Miscellaneous Provisions) Regulations 2021 – Lord Agnew of Oulton (time limit 1 hour) 2. Common Organisation of the Markets in Agricultural Products (Wine) (Amendment, etc.) Regulations 2021 – Lord Gardiner of Kimble (time limit 1 hour) 3. Draft Plant Health etc. (Fees) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2021 – Lord Gardiner of Kimble (time limit 1 hour) FRIDAY 16 APRIL 2021 Last day to table motions or amendments for: Air Traffic Management and Unmanned Aircraft Bill [HL] – consideration of Commons amendments Fire Safety Bill – Consideration of Commons reasons Business in the Chamber at 11.00am 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Guidance on Hybrid House and Hybrid Grand Committee from the Procedure and Privileges Committee: 6Th Edition, 24 November 2020, to Take Effect from 24 November
    GUIDANCE ON HYBRID HOUSE AND HYBRID GRAND COMMITTEE FROM THE PROCEDURE AND PRIVILEGES COMMITTEE: 6TH EDITION, 24 NOVEMBER 2020, TO TAKE EFFECT FROM 24 NOVEMBER Guidance on hybrid House Introduction 1. On 22 May, the House of Lords Commission agreed that “hybrid House” sittings, with members participating both remotely and from the Chamber, should operate with effect from 8 June. The Procedure and Privileges Committee has drawn up this guidance to inform the operation of the hybrid House. It supports the Orders of the House relating to hybrid sittings agreed on 4 June and 28 July. 2. The 4 June and 28 July Orders make provision for this Committee to support the hybrid House and the hybrid Grand Committee by issuing guidance to vary the provisions of the Companion to the Standing Orders. This guidance underpins the hybrid House and hybrid Grand Committee and has the same authority as the Companion. The first edition of this guidance was agreed at a Procedure and Privileges Committee meeting on 5 June; the second edition was agreed at a meeting on 21 July; the third edition at a meeting on 22 September; and the fourth edition by correspondence on 1 October. The fifth edition was agreed at a Procedure and Privileges Committee meeting on 6 October and provisions relating to Lords Consideration of Commons Amendments in the hybrid House were approved by the House on 12 October. This sixth edition, which makes minor amendments to the procedures relating to Consideration of Commons amendments in the hybrid House (see paragraphs 89 and 90) and to the rules about taking part in concurrent items of business (see paragraph 22), was agreed by correspondence on 23 November.
    [Show full text]
  • Capacity Building Workshop for Sectoral Oversight Committee Chairs and Officials from the Parliament of Sri Lanka
    2505/SRI/REPORT Capacity Building Workshop for Sectoral Oversight Committee Chairs and Officials from the Parliament of Sri Lanka Houses of Parliament, 23-27 January 2017 Final Report Contents Project Overview ............................................................................................................................................ 4 Project Aim & Objectives .............................................................................................................................. 4 Participants & Key Stakeholders .................................................................................................................. 5 Key Issues ......................................................................................................................................................... 5 Results of the Project .................................................................................................................................... 8 Next Steps ...................................................................................................................................................... 10 Further resources.......................................................................................................................................... 10 Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................................... 10 Annex A - Full Delegate List.......................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Committee of Selection
    COMMITTEE OF SELECTION Gender balance of House of Lords Select Committee membership 1. In December 2018 the UK Gender Sensitive Parliament Audit1 recommended that a Parliamentary body monitor the gender breakdown of MPs and peers and those in leadership positions. The House of Lords Commission subsequently asked the Committee of Selection to carry out annual monitoring of Lords Committee membership and chairing.2 This is the first such report and in the future these statistics will be published annually. 2. The numbers in the table below show the gender balance of House of Lords Select Committee membership as at the end of March 2020; 32.6% of select committee members were female and 67.4% were male. The gender balance of the membership of the House of Lords as a whole at the end of March 2020 was 27.7% female and 72.3% male.3 Female Committee name Male members members Audit 2 5 Commission 5 7 Communications and Digital 6 7 Conduct 6 3 Constitution 4 9 Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform 3 7 Democracy and Digital Technologies 3 10 Economic Affairs 3 10 Electoral Registration and Administration Act 2013 5 7 European Union 7 12 EU Energy and Environment Sub- Committee 3 9 EU External Affairs Sub-Committee 5 7 EU Financial Affairs Sub-Committee 3 9 EU Home Affairs Sub-Committee 2 8 EU Internal Market Sub-Committee 3 10 EU Justice Sub-Committee 3 7 1 https://intranet.parliament.uk/Documents/intranet/news-current- issues/UK%20Parliament_%20Gender%20Sensitive%20Parliament%20Audit_Report_DIGITAL.pdf 2 https://www.parliament.uk/documents/lords-committees/house-of-lords-commission/2017- 19/UK_Parliament_Gender_Sensitive_Report_Response_Combined.pdf 3 These percentages refer to the gender balance of eligible members, and do not include disqualified members or those on leave of absence.
    [Show full text]
  • Constitution Unit Monitor 75 / July 2020
    1 Constitution Unit Monitor 75 / July 2020 COVID-19 has touched almost every aspect of how The constitution under politics is done, and raised new questions about the functioning of some aspects of the UK constitution, as COVID-19 this issue of Monitor sets out. The Coronavirus Bill was As the last issue of Monitor went to press in early March rushed through both chambers of parliament – with the idea that COVID-19 might change everything was consent from the devolved legislatures – in just six days only just dawning. In the subsequent four months, in March. Simultaneously the official ‘lockdown’ was just its impact on politics as well as daily life has been beginning. At the outset this barred most workplaces transformational. Just as the UK hoped to exit one torrid from opening and confined most people – except period of politics dominated by a single issue, a new, when undertaking limited activities – to their homes. still bigger challenge eclipsed it. Brexit has barely The Prime Minister spoke to the nation in a televised featured in the past few months’ political news. Instead, address, and daily Downing Street press conferences Boris Johnson rapidly shifted from the Prime Minister involving ministers and (usually) government scientists who would ‘get Brexit done’ to the one who needed to became the norm, seven days per week. On 6 April Boris steer the nation through a health crisis, and perhaps in Johnson himself was hospitalised with the virus, leaving due course through an economic crisis as well. Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab to deputise (see page 12).
    [Show full text]