DOCSLIB.ORG

University of Warwick Institutional Repository

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
University of Warwick Institutional Repository University of Warwick institutional repository: http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap/4203 This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. Reviving An Ancient-Modern Quarrel: A Critique of Derrida's Reading of Plato and Platonism A Thesis Presented For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Jones A. Irwin December 1997 University of Warwick Supervisors: Mr. Martin Warner Dr. Cyril Barrett ABSTRACT This thesis begins from an analysis of Derrida's specific readings of Plato and Platonism, identifying there a modernist bias, which interprets these metaphysical systems as if they were coextensive with Cartesian rationalism. Against Derrida, I argue for a repositioning of Plato and Platonism in the context of an ancient-modern quarrel. In replacing Descartes's "clarity and distinctness" with a pre-modern emphasis on "faith" (pistis), I am seeking to challenge Derrida's diagnosis of a perplexity or impasse (aporia) which cannot be overcome by philosophy. With specific reference to the Meno and the Phaedrus, one can locate a three-tiered Platonic dialectic beginning with an assertionof knowledge, followed by a necesary deconstruction of this knowledge with, thirdly, a tentative reconstruction of philosophy based on faith rather than knowing. In later chapters, I examine this dialectic as it is developedin the Neo- and Christian- Platonist traditions, particularly through the work of Plotinus, Boethius and Augustine. On my interpretation, deconstruction remains at the second level of the Platonic dialectic, that of impasse and perplexity (one of Derrida's most recent texts is in fact entitled Aporias). Again with reference to an ancient-modern quarrel, it is my contention that Derrida's unstinting stress on the "aporetic" is due to an overemphasis of the Cartesian paradigm. Derrida identifies the exhaustion of what Deeley calls "the classical modern paradigm" with the exhaustion of philosophy per se. But this identification of philosophy with Cartesianism can be seriously challenged through a renewed foregrounding of the premodern philosophical resources which Descartes (and now Derrida) have sought to obscure. 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Many thanks to my supervisors, Martin Warner and Cyril Barrett, for their help and encouragement over the last three years. As my main mentor, Martin has been an untiring Stoic in reviewing my explorations. This thesis would never have seen the light of day without the personal friendship of many, most especially Floris, Paul, Ben, Darren, the two Adrians. Additional thanks to the Philosophy secretaries Josie and Julia (and now Lynda) for their tolerance and humour, to Angie Hobbes for being such a stalwart of the Ancients and to Keith A. P. for infectious enthusiasm. Institutional thanks to the British Academy and Warwick University for making it all financially possible. The final honours are reserved for my parents for being so supportive and loving and to Melissa, for being the greatest force in my life, ever. Eros, friends, Jones Irwin Coventry / Ireland [December 1997]. 3 To Melissa, in eternal love REVIVING AN ANCIENT-MODERN QUARREL: A CRITIQUE OF DERRIDA'S READING OF PLATO AND PLATONISM CONTENTS LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS 8 INTRODUCTION 10 CHAPTER 1- Derrida on the "Moderns" and the "Ancients" 21 1.1 - Prefatory Remarks 22 1.2 - Derrida and Descartes 33 1.3 -A Poison (PJiarmakon) Deserved CHAPTER 2- From the Presocratics to Plato :A Meditation on a Complex Metaphysical Unity 55 2.1 - Prefatory Remarks 57 2.2 - Heraclitus and Parmenides 69 2.3 - Heraclitus and Plato Plato 76 2.4 - Parmenides and CHAPTER 3- Pla to contra Derrida I: The Case of the Meno 3.1 - Prefatory Remarks 84 3.2 - The Meno 88 3.3 - Philosophy's Doing Battle (diamkhoimen) 101 5 CHAPTER 4- Plato contra Derrida II : The Case of the Phaedrus 111 4.1 - Forms in the Phaedrus 124 4.2 - "Wisdom" in the Phaedrus CHAPTER 5- Derrida on "Platonism" : Deconstruction, Apophasis and Dialectic Remarks 144 5.1 - Prefatory Derrida's "Crisis" On the 5.2 - Questioning - Problem of the "Problem" 149 The Gift Death 160 5.3 - On "Denials" and of CHAPTER 6- Platonism contra Derrida I: The Cases of Plotinus and Boethius Remarks 180 6.1 - Prefatory "First Existent" in Plotinus 181 6.2 - On "The One" or Philosophy 191 6.3 - On The Consolation of CHAPTER 7- Platonism contra Derrida II : The Cases of Augustine and De Cusa 199 7.1 - Prefatory Remarks Wisdom 203 7.2 - Augustine's Love of "Wisdom" 215 7.3 - De Cusa on CONCLUSION I-A General Overview 227 II - Murdoch, Weil and a Postmodern Platonism 240 6 NOTES 248 BIBLIOGRAPHY 254 ABBREVIATIONS [Note: Quotationsfrom translationsgiven except where otherwise indicated] I- Works by Derrida "Cogito" - "Cogito and the History of Madness" translated by Alan Bass in WD [see below]. "Cogito et Histoire de la Folie" "Denials" - "How to avoid speaking: Denials" translated by Ken Frieden in Languages of the Unsayable: The Play of Negativity in Literature and Literary Theory. Edited by Sanford Budick and Wolfgang Iser [New York, Columbia University Press, 1989]. "Comment ne pas parler: D6n6gations" in Psyche: Inventions de lautre [Paris, Galilee, 1987] by Barbara Johnson [Chicago, Chicago DS - Dissemination translated University Press, 1981]. La Dissemination [Paris, Editions du Seuil, 1972] by Wills [Chicago, Chicago GD - The Gift of Death translated David University Press, 1995]. "Donner la mori" in L'ethique du don, Jacques Derrida et la pensee du don [Paris, 1992] "Origin Geometry ": An Introduction OG - Edmund Husserl's of translated by John P. Leavey Jr. [Lincoln, University of Nebraska Press, 1989]. Introduction a ` L'Origine de la geoinetrie" par Edinund Husserl [Paris, Presses Universitaires de France, 1962] Wood OTN - On the Naine translated by John P. Leavey Jr., David and Ian McLeod [Stanford, Stanford University Press, 1995]. This is a unified translation of three separate French texts: Sauf le None [Paris, Editions GalilCe, 1993], Passions [Paris, Editions Galilde, 1993] and Khora [Paris, Editions GalilCe, 1993] Johnson in DS. "La PP - "Plato's Pharmacy" translated by Barbara Pharmacie de Platon" in La Dissemination Theory SP - Speech and Phenomena and Other Essays on Husserl's of Signs edited and translated by David B. Allison [Evanston, Northwestern University Press, 1973]. La Voix et le phcnomene. Introduction au problente dausigne dans la phinomn nologic de Husserl [Paris, Presses Universitaires de France, 1967] by Alan Bass [Chicago, Chicago WD - Writing and Difference translated University Press, 1978]. L'Ccriture et la difference [Paris, Editions du Seuil, 1967] Platonists II - Works by Plotinus by Stephen MacKenna [London, Penguin, Enn. - The Enneads translated 1986]. Plotini Opera, editio maior in 3 volumes [Paris /Brussels, 1951-73] 8 Boethius Consol. - The Consolation of Philosophy translated by V. E. Watts [London, Penguin, 1969]. Boethii Philosophiae Consolatio edited by Ludovicus Bieler Corpus Christianorunz Series Latina XCIV [Turnholti, 1957] Augustine EA - The Essential Augustine edited by V. Bourke [Indiana, Hackett, 1964]. For Latin references for Augustine cf. Bibliography. De Cusa "CW" - "Concerning Wisdom" in UR. "De Sapientia" in "De "OLI" - "Of Learned Ignorance" UR. Docta Ignorantin" Selected Writings Nicholas De Cusa by John UR - Unity and Reform: of edited Patrick Dolan [University Of Notre Dame Press, 1962]. Opera Oinnia [Leipzig, Felix Meiner, 1932-] Iris Murdoch Mystics: Writings Philosophy Literature EM - Existentialists and on and [London, Random House, 1997] Simone Weil Ark, 1952] GG - Gravity and Grace [London, III - Other Abbreviated Titles From Thales Aristotle GP - W. K. C. Guthrie The Greek Philosophers: to [New York, Methuen, 1967] On Derrida ID - Rodolphe Gasch6 Inventions of Difference: Jacques [Harvard University Press, 1994] in Companion PL - G. R. F. Ferrari "Platonic Love" The Cambridge to Plato edited by Richard Kraut [Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1992] 9 REVIVING AN ANCIENT-MODERN QUARREL: A CRITIQUE OF DERRIDA'S READING OF PLATO AND PLATONISM Introduction Those who would like to consider "deconstruction" a symptom of modern or postmodern nihilism could indeed, if they wished, recognise in it the last in testimony - not to say the martyrdom of faith the present fin de siecle. This reading will always be possible. Who could prohibit it? In the name of what? But what has happened, so that what is thus permitted is never necessary as such? Derrida, "Denials" (p. 77) Unhappy Aristotle! Who invented for these men dialectics, the art of building up and pulling down, an art so far-fetched in its conjectures, so harsh in its arguments, so productive of contentions - embarassing even to itself, retracting everything, and really treating of nothing! Tertullian, "On Prescription Against Heretics" My aim in this thesis is in a sense quite simple: to repose the question "What is Philosophy? ". John Deeley in his New Beginnings: Early Modern Philosophy and Postmodern Thought [1] makes the claim that the "premoderns" interrogated the presuppositions of modernity more powerfully than any of the "postmoderns" have so far achieved [p. xii, Santella-Brago Preface to Deeley]. My own claim in this thesis is more moderate to the extent that it focuses on specific strands of the premodern and postmodern epochs in thought - that of Platonism on the one side and deconstruction on the other. But given this more restricted scope, my claim is perhaps more radical; that in the case of Derrida's thinking, deconstruction is not only less questioning of 10 modernity than Platonism, but is in fact a reinforcing of the modern paradigm. Derrida, on my interpretation, is a neo-modern rather than a post-modern; deconstruction is in effect a more developed form of Cartesianism.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • This Thesis Has Been Submitted in Fulfilment of the Requirements for a Postgraduate Degree (E.G
    This thesis has been submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for a postgraduate degree (e.g. PhD, MPhil, DClinPsychol) at the University of Edinburgh. Please note the following terms and conditions of use: • This work is protected by copyright and other intellectual property rights, which are retained by the thesis author, unless otherwise stated. • A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge. • This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author. • The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author. • When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given. Writing animals, speaking animals: the displacement and placement of the animal in medieval literature. Submitted for the degree of PhD University of Edinburgh 2003 David Moses ACKNOWLEDGMENTS DEDICATION To my parents for their unwavering love, and for daring us to believe that all things are possible. To my wife Clare, and sons James and Ethan for making it all worthwhile. To my sister Caroline for believing that it does matter. To my beloved dog Flash, who is missed so much: 'In that day I will make a covenant with the beasts of the field, with the birds of the air ... I will betroth you to Me forever; Yes I will betroth you to Me in righteousness and justice, in lovingkindness and mercy' (Hosea 2. 18- 19).
    [Show full text]
  • These Disks Contain My Version of Paul Spade's Expository Text and His Translated Texts
    These disks contain my version of Paul Spade's expository text and his translated texts. They were converted from WordStar disk format to WordPerfect 5.1 disk format, and then I used a bunch of macros and some hands-on work to change most of the FancyFont formatting codes into WordPerfect codes. Many transferred nicely. Some of them are still in the text (anything beginning with a backslash is a FancyFont code). Some I just erased without knowing what they were for. All of the files were cleaned up with one macro, and some of them have been further doctored with additional macros I wrote later and additional hand editing. This explains why some are quite neat, and others somewhat cluttered. In some cases I changed Spade's formatting to make the printout look better (to me); often this is because I lost some of his original formatting. I have occasionally corrected obvious typos, and in at least one case I changed an `although' to a `but' so that the line would fit on the same page. With these exceptions, I haven't intentionally changed any of the text. All of the charts made by graphics are missing entirely (though in a few cases I perserved fragments so you can sort of tell what it was like). Some of the translations had numbers down the side of the page to indicate location in the original text; these are all lost. Translation 1.5 (Aristotle) was not on the disk I got, so it is listed in the table of contents, but you won't find it.
    [Show full text]
  • Iconoclasm: a Christian Dilemma
    ICONOCLASM: A CHRISTIAN DILEMMA - A BYZANTINE CONTROVERSY By STEPHEN CHARLES STEACY •• Bachelor of Arts Oklahoma State University Stillwater, Oklahoma 1969 Submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate College of the Oklahoma State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS December, 1978 ICONOCLASM: A CHRISTIAN DILEMMA - A BYZANTINE CONTROVERSY Thesis Approved: '. ~- Dean of the Graduate College 1019541 ii P~F~E This thesis is concerned with Iconoclasm, the religious upheaval which troubled the Byzantine conscience for over a century. There have been numerous theories adduced by his­ torians to account for this phenomenon. It is the purpose of this study to view the varying interpretations, analyze their shortcomings, and to put forth a different view of the controversy, one that more adequately expresses the deeply rooted religious nature of the movement, a movement not only of the eighth and ninth centuries but an idea which was nurtured in fertile soil of the Old Testament and Apostolic Christianity. The author wishes to express heartfelt appreciation to his thesis adviser, Dr. George Jewsbury, whose unflagging solicitude, support, and inspiration were instrumental in the preparation of this work. A note of thanks is given to Mrs. Karen Hoyer, whose typing expertise, in the final analysis, made the difference between success and failure. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page I. INTRODUCTION AND HISTORIOGRAPHICAL ESSAY 1 II. THEOLOGICAL AND PHILOSOPHICAL COURSES OF THE CONTROVERSY. • • . • . • • . • . 13 Genesis of the Cult of Icons .•.• 13 The Scriptures as the Foundation of Iconoclasm. 26 Precursors of ·the Iconoclast Movement . 30 Origen . 31 Eusebius .
    [Show full text]
  • The Theodicy of Plato's Timaeus
    Georgia State University ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University Philosophy Theses Department of Philosophy 8-10-2021 Reincarnation and Rehabilitation: the Theodicy of Plato's Timaeus John Garrett Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/philosophy_theses Recommended Citation Garrett, John, "Reincarnation and Rehabilitation: the Theodicy of Plato's Timaeus." Thesis, Georgia State University, 2021. https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/philosophy_theses/298 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Philosophy at ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Philosophy Theses by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. REINCARNATION AND REHABILITATION: THE THEODICY OF PLATO’S TIMAEUS by JOHN GARRETT Under the Direction of Timothy O’Keefe, PhD A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in the College of Arts and Sciences Georgia State University 2021 ABSTRACT Plato wonders why a good God might allow the existence of evil. This problem is especially pertinent to his dialogue Timaeus, in which Plato describes the creation of the cosmos by a benevolent divine craftsman called the Demiurge. A justification for why God allows evil to exist is called a theodicy. Readers of the Timaeus have interpreted the theodicy of this dialogue in many ways. After showing the shortcomings of some common interpretations, I offer a largely original interpretation of the theodicy of the Timaeus. I claim that in the Timaeus evil is caused by conflict between souls, and this conflict is something that the good (but not omnipotent) Demiurge could not avoid.
    [Show full text]
  • Jorge J. E. Gracia
    . Jorge J. E. Gracia PERSONAL INFORMATION Father: Dr. Ignacio J. L. de la C. Gracia Dubié Mother: Leonila M. Otero Muñoz Married to Norma E. Silva Casabé in 1966 Daughters: Leticia Isabel and Clarisa Raquel Grandchildren: James M. Griffin, Clarisa E. Griffin, Sofia G. Taberski, and Eva L. Taberski Office Addresses: Department of Philosophy, University at Buffalo 123 Park Hall, Buffalo, NY 14260-4150 Phone: (716) 645-2444; FAX (716) 645-6139 Department of Comparative Literature, University at Buffalo 631 Clemens Hall, Buffalo, NY 14260-4610 Phone: (716) 645-2066; FAX (716) 645-5979 Home Address: 420 Berryman Dr. Amherst, NY 14226 Phone: (716) 835-5747 EDUCATION High School Bachiller en Ciencias and Bachiller en Letras, with highest honors, St. Thomas Military Academy, La Habana, 1960 College/University B.A. in Philosophy, with honors, Wheaton College, 1965 M.A. in Philosophy, University of Chicago, 1966 M.S.L. in Philosophy, magna cum laude, Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies, 1970 Ph.D. in Medieval Philosophy, University of Toronto, 1971 Other Studies One year of graduate study and research at the Institut d'Estudis Catalans, Barcelona, 1969-70 One year of study at the School of Architecture, Universidad de La Habana, 1960-61 One year of study at the Escuela de Artes Plásticas de San Alejandro, La Habana, 1960-61 Doctoral Dissertation "Francesc Eiximenis's Terç del Crestià: Edition and Study of Sources," Toronto, 1971, 576 pp. Dissertation Committee: J. Gulsoy, A. Maurer, E. Synan AREAS OF SPECIALIZATION IN PHILOSOPHY Systematic:
    [Show full text]
  • SPECTRES of a CRISIS: READING JACQUES DERRIDA AFTER the GLOBAL FINANCIAL CRISIS of 2008 by JOHN JAMES FRANCIS a Thesis Submi
    SPECTRES OF A CRISIS: READING JACQUES DERRIDA AFTER THE GLOBAL FINANCIAL CRISIS OF 2008 by JOHN JAMES FRANCIS A thesis submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Modern Languages School of Languages, Culture, Art History, and Music College of Arts and Law University of Birmingham JUNE 2019 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. ABSTRACT This thesis investigates a theoretical response to the question of what constitutes the political implications of the 2008 Global Financial Crisis. This thesis, working within the tradition of critical and cultural theory, undertakes a sustained engagement with the works of Jacques Derrida to theorise the traditions, norms, and practices that inform a response to an event such as the crisis of 2008. This thesis works with his proposals that: the spectre of its limitations haunts politics; that this has led to the ‘deconstruction’ of the meaning of politics through complex textual frameworks; and that this dynamic leads to a tension between the arrival of new political possibilities on the one hand and new forms of political sovereignty on the other.
    [Show full text]
  • Derrida, Logocentrism, and the Concept of Warrant on the Semantic Web
    D. Grant Campbell — University of Western Ontario Derrida, Logocentrism, and the Concept of Warrant on the Semantic Web Abstract The highly-structured data standards of the Semantic Web contain a promising venue for the migration of library subject access standards onto the World Wide Web. The new functionalities of the Web, however, along with the anticipated capabilities of intelligent Web agents, suggest that information on the Semantic Web will have much more fl exibility, diversity and mutability. We need, therefore, a method for recognizing and assessing the principles whereby Semantic Web information can combine together in productive and useful ways. This paper will argue that the concept of warrant in traditional library science, can provide a useful means of translating li- brary knowledge structures into Web-based knowledge structures. Using Derrida’s concept of logocentrism, this paper suggests that what while “warrant” in library science traditionally alludes to the principles by which con- cepts are admitted into the design of a classifi cation or access system, “warrant” on the Semantic Web alludes to the principles by which Web resources can be admitted into a network of information uses. Furthermore, library information practice suggests a far more complex network of warrant concepts that provide a subtlety and rich- ness to knowledge organization that the Semantic Web has not yet attained. Introduction The concept of warrant in traditional library science has been a cornerstone of our under- standing of, and our training in, the major tools of subject access, including the Library of Congress Subject Headings, Library of Congress Classifi cation, and the Dewey Decimal Classifi cation.
    [Show full text]
  • Derridean Deconstruction and Feminism
    DERRIDEAN DECONSTRUCTION AND FEMINISM: Exploring Aporias in Feminist Theory and Practice Pam Papadelos Thesis Submitted for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Discipline of Gender, Work and Social Inquiry Adelaide University December 2006 Contents ABSTRACT..............................................................................................................III DECLARATION .....................................................................................................IV ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ......................................................................................V INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................... 1 THESIS STRUCTURE AND OVERVIEW......................................................................... 5 CHAPTER 1: LAYING THE FOUNDATIONS – FEMINISM AND DECONSTRUCTION ............................................................................................... 8 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 8 FEMINIST CRITIQUES OF PHILOSOPHY..................................................................... 10 Is Philosophy Inherently Masculine? ................................................................ 11 The Discipline of Philosophy Does Not Acknowledge Feminist Theories......... 13 The Concept of a Feminist Philosopher is Contradictory Given the Basic Premises of Philosophy.....................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Medieval Philosophy: an Historical and Philosophical Introduction
    MEDIEVAL PHILOSOPHY ‘Dr Marenbon’s book is an authoritative, comprehensive, yet accessible survey of medieval philosophy, written by an expert at the height of his critical powers. Not only does the book guide the reader through the diverse issues of medieval philosophy, but provides sagacious instruction and illuminating commentary on the central topics of its chosen period of study.’ Martin Stone, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium. ‘Marenbon has managed to write about an enormous array of topics in a lucid and accessible way. His prose is clear without being condescending, informative without being either patronizing or importunate. The beginner will find it approachable and unpretentious.’ Peter King, University of Toronto, Canada This new introduction replaces Marenbon’s best-selling editions Early Medieval Philosophy (1983) and Later Medieval Philosophy (1987) to present a single author- itative and comprehensive study of the period. An entirely new book, written in the light of the scholarship of the last twenty years, it will be the standard companion for all students of medieval philosophy. It gives a lucid and engaging account of the history of philosophy in the Middle Ages, discussing the main writers and ideas, the social and intellectual contexts, and the important concepts used in medieval philosophy. Medieval Philosophy gives a chronological account which: • treats all four main traditions of philosophy that stem from the Greek heritage of late antiquity: Greek Christian philosophy, Latin philosophy, Arabic philos- ophy and Jewish philosophy • provides a series of ‘study’ sections for close attention to arguments and shorter ‘interludes’ that point to the wider questions of the intellectual context • combines philosophical analysis with historical background • includes a helpful detailed guide to further reading and an extensive bibliography All students of medieval philosophy, medieval history, theology or religion will find this necessary reading.
    [Show full text]
  • NICOLA POLLONI Gundissalinus and Avicenna
    NICOLA POLLONI Gundissalinus and Avicenna : Some Remarks on an Intricate Philosophical Connection Dominicus Gundissalinus is a peculiar figure in the twelfth-century cultural landscape. Born in the Iberian Peninsula between 1115 and 1125, he received his philosophical education in Chartres possibly under Thierry of Chartres and William of Conches as many traces in his original productions indicate1. At least since 1148, Gundissalinus was archdeacon of Cuéllar, a village not far from Segovia, where supposedly he was resident until 11612. Then, he moved to Toledo, where he was based from 1162. This fact is to be linked to the presence, in the Castilian town, of the Jewish philosopher Abraham ibn Daud. As pointed out by Bertolacci3, Ibn Daud’s translation of the prologue to Avicenna’s Liber sufficientiae — i.e., the Kitāb al-Šifāʾ — is to be seen as an invitation to the Toledan archbishop, John II, to sponsor and support a series of translations into Latin of Avicenna’s work. As a result, Gundissalinus arrived in Toledo, his presence probably required there by the same archbishop with the purpose of collaborating with Ibn Daud on the ‘Avicenna project’, the first accomplishment of which was the Latin translation of Avicenna’s De anima, realized before 11664. 1 SISMEL. EDIZIONI DEL GALLUZZO Cf. N. HÄRING, Thierry of Chartres and Dominicus Gundissalinus, « Mediaeval Studies », 26, 1964, pp. 271-286 ; K. M. FREDBORG, The Latin Rhetorical Commentaries by Thierry of Chartres, Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies, Toronto 1988 ; EAD., The Dependence of Petrus Helias’ Summa super Priscianum on William of Conches’ Glosae super Priscianum, « Cahiers de l’Institut du Moyen Âge grec et latin », 11, 1973, pp.
    [Show full text]
  • Divine Love in the Medieval Cosmos Te Cosmologies of Hildegard of Bingen and Hermann of Carintiha
    Divine Love in the Medieval Cosmos Te Cosmologies of Hildegard of Bingen and Hermann of Carintiha By Jack Ford, University College London Love In every constitution of things Gives herself to all things the most cohesive bond is the Most excellent in the depths, construction of love… the one And above the stars bond of society holding every- Cherishing all… thing in an indissoluble knot. (Hildegard of Bingen, Antiphon for Divine Love)1 (Hermann of Carinthia, De Essentiis)2 Introduction12 things is achieved by love which rules the earth and the seas, and commands the heavens,” exclaims Lady Philosophy, in Troughout the Middle Ages love possessed an exalted the Roman statesman Boethius’ (c.476-526) Consolations status in regard to the cosmos. In a tradition stretching of Philosophy.3 Writing at the end of a great Neoplatonic back to Plato and culminating in Dante’s Divine Comedy, tradition, Boethius was naturally heavily infuenced love was synonymous with an expression of divine power. by Platonic cosmology. It is indeed from Plato’s own In numerous cosmological works, love was believed to cosmological myth, the Timaeus, where we fnd the initial constitute the glue and structure of the universe, and idea of the World-Soul: the soul of the world that Timaeus was employed among the Christian Neoplatonists of the tells Socrates “is interfused everywhere from the center twelfth century as a virtual synonym for the Platonic to the circumference of heaven,” and the same World- World-Soul (anima mundi), the force which emanated Soul which Hildegard and Hermann identify with God’s from the Godhead and fused the macrocosm (the planets, force and power that sustains the cosmos with his love for fxed stars of the frmament, and Empyrean heaven) to creation.4 the microcosm (the terrestrial earth and man) in cosmic Perhaps the greatest fgure to make love synonymous harmony.
    [Show full text]
  • Vo» the RHETORIC of POSTHUMANISM in FOUR TWENTIETH- CENTURY INTERNATIONAL NOVELS DISSERTATION Presented to the Graduate Counci
    /vo» THE RHETORIC OF POSTHUMANISM IN FOUR TWENTIETH- CENTURY INTERNATIONAL NOVELS DISSERTATION Presented to the Graduate Council of the University of North Texas in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY By Lidan Lin, B. A., M. A., M. Ed. Denton, Texas August, 1998 Lin, Lidan, The Rhetoric of Posthumanism in Four Twentieth-Century International Novels. Doctor of Philosophy (English), August, 1998,195 pp., works cited, 182 titles. The dissertation traces the trope of the incomplete character in four twentieth-century cosmopolitan novels that reflect European colonialism in a global context. I argue that, by creating characters sharply aware of the insufficiency of the Self and thus constantly seeking the constitutive participation of the Other, the four authors E. M. Forster, Samuel Beckett, J. M. Coetzee, and Congwen Shen all dramatize the incomplete character as an agent of postcolonial resistance to Western humanism that, tending to enforce the divide between the Self and the Other, provided the epistemological basis for the emergence of European colonialism. For example, Fielding's good-willed aspiration to forge cross- cultural friendship in A Passage to India-, Murphy's dogged search for recognition of his Irish identity in Murphy; Susan's unfailing compassion to restore Friday's lost speech in Foe; and Changshun Teng, the Chinese orange-grower's warm-hearted generosity toward his customers in Long River-all these textual occasions dramatize the incomplete character's anxiety over the Other's rejection that will impair the fullness of his or her being, rendering it solitary and empty. I relate this anxiety to the theory of "posthumanism" advanced by such thinkers as Marx, Bakhtin, Sartre, and Lacan; in their texts the humanist view of the individual as an autonomous constitution has undergone a transformation marked by the emphasis on locating selfhood not in the insular and static Self but in the mutable middle space connecting the Self and the Other.
    [Show full text]