Alexander, Midas, and the Oracle at Gordium Author(S): Ernest A. Fredricksmeyer Source: Classical Philology, Vol. 56, No. 3 (Jul., 1961), Pp
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Alexander, Midas, and the Oracle at Gordium Author(s): Ernest A. Fredricksmeyer Source: Classical Philology, Vol. 56, No. 3 (Jul., 1961), pp. 160-168 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/265752 Accessed: 24/01/2009 15:23 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=ucpress. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. JSTOR is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1995 to build trusted digital archives for scholarship. We work with the scholarly community to preserve their work and the materials they rely upon, and to build a common research platform that promotes the discovery and use of these resources. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. The University of Chicago Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Classical Philology. http://www.jstor.org ALEXANDER, MIDAS, AND THE ORACLE AT GORDIUM1 ERNEST A. FREDRICKSMEYER IN THE spring of 333 B.C., at Gor- tion, had been told by an oracle that dium, the capital of Phrygia, an they stood in need of a king and that oracle identified Alexander as the they should acclaim as such the man destined ruler over Asia. The purpose of they first found driving up in a wagon. this study is to examine this incident There arrived a Phrygian peasant riding and to appraise the importance which in a wagon; they made him king; and it had for Alexander. he dedicated the wagon as thank offering Alexander arrived at Gordium in the to Zeus the King. spring of 333. On the acropolis, in the The accounts of the two writers temple of Zeus Basileus, stood an differ in several details. The main ancient' wagon dedicated to this god. disagreement, however, is on the name An old oracle was known to the of the man who became king and Phrygian people that the man who dedicated the wagon to Zeus: according would undo the knot attached to the to Justin it was Gordius the father of yoke of this wagon would become lord Midas, according to Arrian (cf. Plut. over Asia. The knot was formed by the Alex. 18. 1; Curt. 3. 1. 11 and 14; cord which latched the yoke to the pole Aelian. NA 13. 1) it was Midas himself.5 of the wagon. Alexander drew out the It is impossible to determine which wooden pole pin, the end (or ends) of version is older. This much is certain: the cord thereby became exposed, and there existed a Phrygian legend which he was able to untie the knot.2 regarded Midas as the first king in W. W. Tarn (Alexander the Great, II Phrygia and as the dedicator of the [Cambridge, 19481, 262ff.) has shown wagon.6 Alexander, too, believed, as we that this version of how Alexander dealt shall see, that the man was Midas, not with the knot, reported by Aristobulus,3 Gordius. is probably the correct one, not the Now, in Macedonia there existed vulgate account which has him cut the some traditions relevant to the Phrygian knot with his sword.4 tradition. The Phrygians apparently In either case, so the historian Arrian considered themselves autochthonous, (2. 3. 8) reports, on leaving the wagon and they believed the founder of the Alexander apparently believed that he Phrygian dynasty was a native of had duly met the condition of the Phrygia, the peasant who had arrived oracle; he regarded a thunderstorm in the wagon. But in Macedonia, He- which occurred that night as divine rodotus (7. 73) reports, there was the confirmation, and on the following day tradition that the Phrygians had once he performed a sacrifice in thanks- been neighbors of the Macedonians, giving. that they later emigrated to Asia and Arrian (2. 3. 2-6; cf. 2. 3. 1) and changed their name from Brigians to Justin-Trogus (11. 7. 5-14) relate this Phrygians. Strabo (7. Frag. 25) says that legend about the earlier history of the these Brigians, before crossing to Asia, wagon: The Phrygians, during a revolu- occupied the area of Mount Bermium [CLASSICALPHILOLOGY, LVI, July, 1961] 160 ALEXANDER,MIDAS, AND THE ORACLEAT GORDIUM 161 (actually, the Bermium was a mountain off Midas and other kings who had held range).7 parts of the country. In speaking of We further learn from Herodotus Caranus, then, as the Argead con- (8. 138) that Macedonian legend told queror of Macedonia, Trogus12 is giving of an ancient king in Macedonia named us genuine Macedonian tradition. It is "Midas son of Gordias [Gordius]"8 first reported by Theopompus (FGrH, whose famous rose gardens were situated No. 115, Frag. 393). What Theopompus at the foot of Mount Bermium. Obvi- said about Caranus can be inferred from ously, Midas was the king of the the parallels of Justin 7. 1. 7 f. with Brigians. Euphorion Frag. 30 Scheidw. (schol. Possibly there was even then a Mace- Clem. Alex. Protr. 8. 11.).13 Since donian tradition, which Herodotus Euphorion (loc. cit.) also mentions knew, that Midas joined his people in Midas in connection with Caranus' their migration from Macedonia to settlement of Macedonia, we may infer Asia. Describing the conquest of Mace- that Theopompus did the same. But donia by Perdiccas and his brothers, Euphorion, as cited, differs greatly Herodotus (loc. cit.) says that "they from Trogus in what he has to say came to another part of Macedonia and about Midas. After stating that Caranus settled near the gardens said to be those changed the name of Edessa to Aegae of Midas son of Gordias" (o'cx-rjav t6?Xoc he says that Edessa was inhabited of Tcov X7tOV T ,V ZXyoeVGV mivalxMsaL)o old by Phrygians and Lydians and Tro rFopSco) and that "after winning those who had crossed over to Europe that part of the country they went with Midas. Thus according to Eupho- forth and subdued also the rest of rion the migration of Midas took place Macedonia." As the tense of XcyozLevov in the direction opposite to that indi- shows, the gardens apparently were cated by Trogus. But this notion, that said to belong to Midas at the time Midas moved from Asia to Europe, is when Perdiccas and his brothers settled found only in a few late and secondary near them.9 Perhaps Herodotus in accounts (see Eitrem, RE, XV [1932], speaking of the Phrygians as "neighbors 1526). The information of Trogus, on of the Macedonians" was not thinking the other hand, harmonizes with the of the "Macedonians" in the strict sense, old established Macedonian tradition as the conquerors from Argos, but in a that the Phrygians migrated from general sense, as the people already Macedonia to Asia (Herodotus). It is dwelling in the area. If so, it is possible obvious, therefore, that it is not that Macedonian tradition at Herod- Euphorion who reflects what Theo- otus' time had it that Midas and the pompus had to say about Midas, but Brigians moved to Asia when they were rather Trogus.14It is extremely probable, dislodged from Macedonia by the then, that Trogus' statement that Argead conqueror.10 Midas was ejected from Macedonia Till the beginning of the fourth belongs to an old Macedonian tradition century, the Macedonian tradition was that Midas together with his Brigians that the name of this conqueror was migrated from Macedonia to Asia.15 Perdiccas; then the name Caranus The mythographer Conon (fl. 36 supplanted Perdiccas.11 Justin-Trogus B.C.-A.D. 17), SO Photius tells us,16 (7. 1. 11) states that Caranus gained narrated how Midas ruled over the possession of Macedonia after driving Brigians, and how this people lived in 162 ERNESTA. FREDRICKSMEYER great numbers at the foot of Mount did he discuss, in the first book, the Bermium, and how, during Midas' knot which Alexander undid at Gor- reign, Silenus was seen near the Ber- dium ? Clearly because in treating early mium range, and how, when everything Macedonian history he described the turned to gold for Midas, he persuaded career of King Midas and his journey his subjects to cross the Hellespont to from Macedonia to Phrygia; this gave Asia, and how then their name changed him occasion to touch on Alexander's from Brigians to Phrygians. undoing of the knot since it was The reason given here for the mi- attached to the wagon which had gration is a late invention (see Eitrem, served Midas on his journey. Thus, op. cit., 1530). As for the rest, the Marsyas knew the Macedonian tradition parallels with what is expressly reported about the journey of Midas from by Herodotus as Macedonian legend are Macedonia to Asia; he also believed striking: King Midas, the Brigians, the that the wagon referred to in the oracle migration of the Brigians from Europe about the rule over Asia was the same to Asia, the change of their name from which Midas had used on his journey.