The Sikh Bulletin Mwg 536 January 2005
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Sikh Bulletin mwG 536 January 2005 <siqguuuuuuuur pRRRswid ] is`K bulytn The Sikh Bulletin A Voice of Concerned Sikhs World Wide January 2005 mwG 536 nwnkSwhI [email protected] Volume 7, Number 1 Published by: Khalsa Tricentennial Foundation of N.A. Inc; Sikh Center Roseville, 201 Berkeley Ave, Roseville, CA 95678. Fax (916) 773-6784 Khalsa Tricentennial Foundation of N.A. Inc. is a religious tax-exempt California Corporation. In This Issue/qqkrw EDITORIAL Editorial : Issues and Personalities………………..1 Issues and Personalities Sant Babe, Yogis, Jathedars and other Notable Since my active involvement with Sikh affairs in 1993, I have come to the Sikh Personalities…………………………………2 sad realization that the entire Sikh leadership, whether political or Dr. Gurmel Singh Deol…………………………...6 The Future of Sikh Children in a Multi-Ethnic religious, is so morally corrupt and spiritually bankrupt and the practice of and Multi-Cultural Society………………………7 Sikhi that is prevalent in all the Gurdwaras, without exception, is so out of Reflection on Mata Gujri Ji……………………...11 line with Gurbani, that nothing short of revolution will be needed to bring Fake It and You’ll Make It……………………....13 into light the message of Guru Nanak. Sikh Community and Singh Sabha International...14 How To Reconcile……………………………….16 To bring about any change you need good reformers, leaders and Water Forum……………………………………..16 followers. Unfortunately there is a scarcity of all three among Sikhs. A Letters To The Editor…………………………....18 vast majority of us who call ourselves Sikhs are either ignorant of Sikhi or gurbwxI-pwT……………………………………...19 allow our selfish interests to cloud our judgment and dictate our actions no nvIN CpI kqwb mUMdwvnI dy rUbrU………………….21 matter how ridiculous or how harmful to the community they may be. The rwgmwlw bnwm rwmrOlHw…………………………..23 remaining handfuls who are trying to do something can’t seem to work roopV dI Adwlq v`loN sMq dljIq isMG iSkwgo together with each other. vwilAW v`loN id`qI qlwk dI ArzI Kwirj………...24 igAwnI sMq isMG mskIn jI nUM Ku`lI ic`TI…….….24 Time and again, since the publication of The Sikh Bulletin began in kI iehI hY gurmq iPlwsPI? jW gurmq dI November 1999, I have been advised by some well meaning people that srwsr byAdbI?.....................................................27 we should focus on issues and not the personalities. What that really means kUV inKuty nwnkw aVik sic rhI………………...28 is that, if it is criticism, do not name the person because that will invite K.T.F. of N.A. Inc. 2004 Annual Statement…….31 controversy but if it is praise and the person belongs to the establishment Book Page ......................................................... .32 or an organization that has become an institutution, name identification is Editor in Chief ok. What I have found is that issues and personalities are intertwined. If Hardev Singh Shergill you do not identify the personalities you are discussing the issues in a Editorial Board vacuum. Gurpal Singh Khaira Avtar Singh Dhami After two years of search I found one reformer who was prepared to bell Gurcharan Singh Brar the cat and who, we, I and those whose judgment I respect, thought, had Production Associates not only put his finger on the crux of the problem but also suggested a Amrinder Singh very simple solution. The reformer we found was S. Gurbaksh Singh Sachleen Singh Kala Afghana, crux of the problem he identified was ‘Bipran Ki Reet’ that had crept into the practice of Sikhi and his solution was to re-examine our The Sikh Bulletin is distributed free around the World. All historical and religious literature in the light of Gurbani and introduce you have to do is ask. We invite offers of help in disribution in other countries. Gurmat practices in the Gurdwaras. Tribune News Service dated Dec.7, You may make copies for free distribution. 2004 reports that re-editing of Suraj Parkash has already begun to remove mythological content that is in direct contradiction with Gurbani and Gurmat. That is precisely what Gurbaksh Singh Kala Afghana has been saying. For this, instead of getting an Honorary D.Lit from Guru Nanak The views expressed by the authors are their Dev University, which he richly deserved, he got excommunicated, own. Please send the feedback and inputs to: because in the course of his writings he had examined the writings of [email protected] Gurbachan Singh of Damdami Taksal and Randhir Singh of Akhand Website: www.sikhbulletin.com Kirtani Jatha upon which he commented with the support of Gurbani. He The Sikh Center Roseville, 201 Berkeley Ave, Roseville, CA. 95678 1 The Sikh Bulletin mwG 536 January 2005 also commented on Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale’s role, among when the personality itself is an issue as is the case with the others. position of mukh sewadar of Akal Takhat. We all respect the institution of Akal Takhat but the mukh sewadar as an All this did not sit well with the two organizations that these individual has to earn that trust, especially since all the mukh personalities belonged to and S. Kala Afghana started receiving sewadars of recent times have not been worthy of that trust. death threats just as Dr. Sangat Singh had upon writing ‘Sikhs in Until and unless we all understand this distinction and stop History’ and ‘Jathedar’ Iqbal Singh alleges to be receiving from courting these people just because they hold that office we are ‘Jathedar’ Vedanti now for opposing Giani Gurdit Singh’s book doing injustice to the integrity and moral authority of Akal ‘Mundavani’. Giani Gurdit Singh, as a member of the SGPC Takhat itself. Dharam Parchar committee, supported the excommunication of S. Kala Afghana which Vedanti carried out under pressure both Issues are many and they all have personalities attached to from AKJ and Damdami Taksal and upon learning that Kala them. One reason for that may be that we have come to believe Afghana’s critique of his publication ‘Gurbilas Patshahi 6’ had the distortion of Guru’s message by these middlemen and lost reached the publishers. Now both Vedanti and Giani Gurdit sight of the true meaning. Some like ‘Sant Babas’ Atar Singh, Singh are targets of excommunication at the hands of Iqbal Nand Singh and Isher Singh deliberately became the Singh, ‘Jathedar’ of Patna Sahib for not recognizing ‘Ragmala’ middlemen and created the environment for a locust of not so as part of AGGS. Would it not be in the Panthic interest to ‘noble’ that followed them. Others created separate movements apologize to Kala Afghana and invite him to join a group of in the name of Sikhs of the Guru perhaps against the wishes of real Sikh scholars, not the plagiarizing kind, to clean out anti these people. Ram Singh, a Sikh of Guru Nanak, has been gurmat myths from Sikh literature? elevated one big step above the Guru and a chair established for ‘Sat Guru Ram Singh’ at mere ‘Guru’ Nanak Dev University. Recently I came across this in The Economist: “The Economist First Published in September 1843 to take What follows in this issue is a specific mention of a few of such part in a severe contest between intelligence, which presses personalities in the words of their observers. The purpose of forward and an unworthy, timid ignorance obstructing our this is not to belittle them. Rather it is to give wider publicity to progress.” This seemed to apply to the reasons for the their words and deeds for the diaspora Sikh sangat’s publication of The Sikh Bulletin, except that the ignorant information and let the sangat be the judge as to who is helping obstructing our progress are not timid. On the contrary, because the Sikh cause and should be helped and who is harming it and of the powers behind them, they are outright bullies. According should be hindered. Hardev Singh Shergill to news in The Tribune dated Nov.26, 2004, Mr. Prithipal Singh ***** Sandhu, who is a mere sala of ‘Jathedar’ Vedani but often acts SANT BABÉ, YOGIS, JATHEDARS AND as if he is himself ‘Jathedar’, while referring to SSI-WSC at OTHER NOTABLE SIKH PERSONALITIES Dixie Road Gurdwara in Mississauga, “alleged that the Sikh SANT BABÉ scholars had used most derogatory language against the I like to show the positive side of things, show the way ‘Jathedar’ during the function.” The reality is that these two forward, and do not like to just criticize and be negative. But characters have dragged the good name of Akal Takhat down to recently I had an overdose of sant babé, and for the sake of my an all time low. For the most appropriate words to describe them own sanity I just have to write this sant baba column. one will have to look to what Gurbani says about a manmukh. Remember, a Sikh should follow only one Sant Baba, Guru Their commitment is not to the Guru nor to the Sikh Community Granth Sahib! but to the powers that appointed them. In their battle royale about the book ‘Mundavni’ the two ‘Jathedars’ of Akal Takhat The Guru Amar Das Gurdwara in Southall, a dera of sant-baba and Patna Sahib are at each other’s throat. What goes around Jaswant Singh Jalandhar wala, organised a 'nagar kirtan' comes around. There was a time when Giani Gurdit Singh through Southall to the Guru Nanak School in Hayes to recommended excommunication of Gurbaksh Singh Kala commemorate 400 years of the Ádí Granth. This was followed Afghana and ‘Jathedar” Vedanti carried it out. Now, over the by a programme at the Guru Nanak School, where ex Jathedar book ‘Mundavni’, Giani Iqbal Singh, ‘Jathedar’ of Patna Sahib, Professor Darshan Singh and Giani Sant Singh Muskeen is threatening to excommunicate these two.