S T A T E O F M I C H I G A N

BEFORE THE MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

* * * * *

In the matter of the joint requests for Commission ) approval of interconnection agreements and ) amendments. ) )

At the April 15, 2020 meeting of the Michigan Public Service Commission in Lansing,

Michigan.

PRESENT: Hon. Sally A. Talberg, Chairman Hon. Daniel C. Scripps, Commissioner Hon. Tremaine L. Phillips, Commissioner

ORDER

The following parties have filed joint applications for approval of interconnection agreements or amendments to an interconnection agreement:

Case No. U-12798 AT&T Michigan and Broadwing Communications, LLC Application filed February 27, 2020, for approval of an eighteenth amendment to the interconnection agreement (replaces Section 3.8 in Article III (Interconnection Pursuant to Section 251(c)(2)).

Case No. U-13302 AT&T Michigan and Bullseye Telecom, Inc. Application filed March 26, 2020, for approval of a fourteenth amendment to the interconnection agreement (modifies certain provisions related to Operation Support Systems (OSS) and/or Data Connection Security Requirements; and updates the existing notice provisions).

Case No. U-14152 AT&T Michigan and , LLC Application filed February 27, 2020, for approval of a thirteenth amendment to the interconnection agreement (replaces Section 3.5 in Appendix NIM (Network Interconnection Methods)).

Case No. U-15027 AT&T Michigan and Telcove Operations, LLC Application filed February 27, 2020, for approval of a fifth amendment to the interconnection agreement (replaces Section 3.5 in Appendix NIM (Network Interconnection Methods)).

Case No. U-16440 AT&T Michigan and Telecom Management, Inc., d/b/a Pioneer Long Distance Application filed March 2, 2020, for approval of a second amendment to the interconnection agreement (adds terms and conditions to implement the Petition of US Telecom for Forbearance Pursuant to 47 U.S.C. 160(c) to Accelerate Investment in Broadband and Next-Generation Networks, WC Docket No. 18-141, FCC 19-66 and FCC 19-72, filed May 4, 2018).

Case No. U-17501 AT&T Michigan and MEI Telecom, Inc. Application filed March 6, 2020, for approval of a fourth amendment to the interconnection agreement (adds terms and conditions to implement the Petition of US Telecom for Forbearance Pursuant to 47 U.S.C. 160(c) to Accelerate Investment in Broadband and Next-Generation Networks, WC Docket No. 18-141, FCC 19-66 and FCC 19-72, filed May 4, 2018).

Case No. U-17504 AT&T Michigan and Zayo Group, LLC Application filed March 3, 2020, for approval of a second amendment to the interconnection agreement (adds terms and conditions to implement the Petition of US Telecom for Forbearance Pursuant to 47 U.S.C. 160(c) to Accelerate Investment in Broadband and Next-Generation Networks, WC Docket No. 18-141, FCC 19-66 and FCC 19-72, filed May 4, 2018).

Case No. U-17550 AT&T Michigan and Voxbeam Telecommunications, Inc. Application filed April 2, 2020, for approval of a first amendment to the interconnection agreement (adds terms and conditions to implement the Petition of US Telecom for Forbearance Pursuant to 47 U.S.C. 160(c) to Accelerate Investment in Broadband and Next- Generation Networks, WC Docket No. 18-141, FCC 19-66 and FCC 19-72, filed May 4, 2018).

Case No. U-18130 AT&T Michigan and Airespring, Inc. Application filed March 10, 2020, for approval of a first amendment to the interconnection agreement (adds terms and conditions to implement the Petition of US Telecom for Forbearance Pursuant to 47 U.S.C. 160(c) to Accelerate Investment in Broadband and Next- Generation Networks, WC Docket No. 18-141, FCC 19-66 and FCC 19-72, filed May 4, 2018).

Page 2 U-12798 et al. Case No. U-20737 AT&T Michigan and Barry County Telephone Company Application filed February 26, 2020, for approval of a traffic termination agreement.

47 USC 252(e)(2) and (3) provides in part:

(2) The State commission may only reject (A) an agreement (or any portion thereof) adopted by negotiation under subsection (a) of this section if it finds that-- (i) the agreement (or portion thereof) discriminates against a telecommunications carrier not a party to the agreement; or (ii) the implementation of such agreement or portion is not consistent with the public interest, convenience, and necessity; . . . .

(3) Notwithstanding paragraph (2), but subject to section 253 of this title, nothing in this section shall prohibit a State commission from establishing or enforcing other requirements of State law in its review of an agreement, including requiring compliance with intrastate telecommunications service quality standards or requirements.

After reviewing the applications, the Commission finds that they should be approved. The

Commission finds that the agreements and amendments are consistent with federal and state law and are in the public interest. Under 47 USC 252(i) and MCL 484.2359(2), the services provided under the agreements shall be made available to other telecommunications carriers upon the same terms and conditions.

THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that:

A. The interconnection agreements and amendments listed above are approved.

B. Approval of the interconnection agreements and amendments does not alter the duty of the parties to comply with relevant federal and state law and past and future Commission orders and rules.

Page 3 U-12798 et al. The Commission reserves jurisdiction and may issue further orders as necessary.

Any party aggrieved by this order may file an action in the appropriate federal District Court under 47 USC 252(e)(6). To comply with the requirement to notify the Commission of an appeal, appellants shall send required notices to both the Commission’s Executive Secretary and to the

Commission’s Legal Counsel. Electronic notifications should be sent to the Executive Secretary at [email protected] and to the Michigan Department of the Attorney General - Public

Service Division at [email protected]. In lieu of electronic submissions, paper copies of such notifications may be sent to the Executive Secretary and the Attorney General - Public

Service Division at 7109 W. Saginaw Hwy, Lansing, MI 48917.

MICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

______Sally A. Talberg, Chairman

______Daniel C. Scripps, Commissioner

______Tremaine L. Phillips, Commissioner

By its action of April 15, 2020.

______Lisa Felice, Executive Secretary

Page 4 U-12798 et al. P R O O F O F S E R V I C E

STATE OF MICHIGAN )

Case No. U-12798 et al.

County of Ingham )

Brianna Brown being duly sworn, deposes and says that on April 15, 2020 A.D. she electronically notified the attached list of this Commission Order via e-mail transmission, to the persons as shown on the attached service list (Listserv Distribution List).

______Brianna Brown

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 15th day of April 2020.

______Angela P. Sanderson Notary Public, Shiawassee County, Michigan As acting in Eaton County My Commission Expires: May 21, 2024 Service List for Case: U-12798

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] Broadwing Communications LLC [email protected] Gary Black [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-13302

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] BullsEye Telecom Inc. [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected] Thomas F. Tisko [email protected] William H. Oberlin [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-14152

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] Beverly A. Smith [email protected] Gary Black [email protected] Level 3 Communications LLC [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-15027

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] Gary Black [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected] TelCove Operations LLC [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-16440

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected] Scott Layman [email protected] Telecom Management Inc. [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-17501

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] David Stoll [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected] MEI Telecom Inc. [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-17504

Name Email Address

AT&T Corp. [email protected] Delia A. Di Vito [email protected] Harry O'Brien [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected] Zayo Group LLC [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-17550

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected] Ryan Rapolti [email protected] Voxbeam Telecommunications Inc. [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-18130

Name Email Address

365 Wireless LLC [email protected] Airespring Inc. [email protected] Airespring Inc. [email protected] AT&T Corp. [email protected] Broadvox-CLEC LLC [email protected] Budget PrePay Inc. [email protected] CenturyLink [email protected] David Lonstein [email protected] Earthlink Business LLC [email protected] Infotelecom LLC [email protected] Kyle V. Bertrand [email protected] Lisa M. Bruno-Herline [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected] New Cingular Wireless PCS LLC 1 of 2 [email protected] New Cingular Wireless PCS LLC 2 of 2 [email protected] O1 Communications Central LLC [email protected] Patrick D. Crocker [email protected] Peerless Network of Michigan LLC [email protected] Racc Enterprises LLC [email protected] RVP Fiber Company LLC [email protected] US Xchange of Michigan LLC [email protected]

Service List for Case: U-20737

Name Email Address

AT&T Michigan [email protected] Barry County Telephone Company [email protected] David Stoll [email protected] Mark R. Ortlieb [email protected]

TELEMOTION ELECTRONIC SERVICE LIST [email protected] Global Connection Inc. of America [email protected] IDT America, Corp. [email protected] Blanchard Telephone Association, Inc. [email protected] AT&T Comm of MI, TCG Detroit Hold [email protected] AT&T Michigan [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] No Name Available [email protected] Velocity [email protected] David Bailey [email protected] American Broadband & Telecom [email protected] Crystal Auto Sys dba Casair [email protected] Bandwidth.com CLEC, LLC [email protected] Clear Rate Comm, Inc. [email protected] Trans National Comm [email protected] Comcast Business Communications, LLC [email protected] Ernest Communications, Inc. [email protected] First Communications, LCC [email protected] [email protected] Intrado Communications, Inc. [email protected] McGraw Communications, Inc. [email protected] Media Gate Communications, Inc. [email protected] Metropolitan Communications [email protected] Nexus Communications

Page 1 of 4

TELEMOTION ELECTRONIC SERVICE LIST [email protected] NOS Communications, Inc. [email protected] Osirus Communications, Inc. [email protected] Quantum Shift Communications [email protected] Quick Communications [email protected] Quick Communications, Inc. [email protected] Reliant Communications, Inc. [email protected] Trinsic Communications, Inc. [email protected] United Comm, Inc. dba Call One [email protected] Baraga Telephone Company [email protected] Carr Telephone Company [email protected] Chapin Telephone Company [email protected] Climax Telephone Company [email protected] Cypress Comm Oper Company, [email protected] Hiawatha Telephone Company [email protected] IBFA Acquistion Company [email protected] Kaleva Telephone Company [email protected] Lennon Telephone Company [email protected] Ogden Telephone Company [email protected] Pigeon Telephone Company [email protected] Sand Creek Telephone Company [email protected] Springport Telephone Company [email protected] Springport Telephone Company [email protected] Sprint Communications Company, L.P. [email protected] TNCI Operating Company, LLC [email protected] U.S. Signal Company, LLC [email protected] Waldron Telephone Company [email protected] Allband Communications Cooperative [email protected] FairPoint Communications Solutions Corp. [email protected] New Horizons Comm Corp. [email protected] Range Corporation [email protected] TruComm Corporation [email protected] Jie Cui [email protected] CynergyComm.Net, Inc. [email protected] DayStarr, LLC [email protected] Bell South Long Dist Inc., dba AT&T [email protected] RACC Enterprises, LLC [email protected] Deerfield Farmers [email protected] Lisa Felice [email protected] Vicki Goodburne

Page 2 of 4

TELEMOTION ELECTRONIC SERVICE LIST [email protected] Grid4 Communications Inc. [email protected] Bulls Eye Telecom Inc. [email protected] Intrado Communications Inc. [email protected] TouchTone Communications Inc. [email protected] Verizon North Inc. [email protected] PTGi Intl Carrier Services, Inc. [email protected] Kreucher, Jon D. [email protected] Thomas Krichel [email protected] Deborah Kuhn, Verizon [email protected] France Telecom Corporate Solutions L.L.C. [email protected] Birch Telecom of the Great Lakes, Inc. [email protected] Level3 Comm [email protected] BT Communications Sales LLC [email protected] Bingham McCutchen LLP [email protected] Lucre, Inc. [email protected] Telecom Management, Inc., dba Pioneer Long [email protected] Robert McCausland [email protected] MetroNet-Telecom, Inc [email protected] Metropolitan Telecomm of MI [email protected] Ace Telephone Company of Michigan, Inc. [email protected] Charter Fiberlink- Michigan, LLC [email protected] Fibernet of Michigan [email protected] Frontier Communications of Michigan [email protected] Local Exchange Carriers of Michigan, Inc. [email protected] Chrissie Pearce- MPSC [email protected] MiTel NetSolutions [email protected] ATI Network,s Inc [email protected] Bright House Network [email protected] Broadview Networks & A.R.C. Networks, [email protected] GVC Networks, LLC [email protected] Intellifiber Networks, Inc. [email protected] JAS Networks & EagleNet [email protected] NextG Networks [email protected] Ygnition Networks, Inc.

Page 3 of 4

TELEMOTION ELECTRONIC SERVICE LIST [email protected] Technologies Management [email protected] Access One, Inc. [email protected] Onvoy, Inc. [email protected] Access Point, Inc. [email protected] ACN Comm Services, Inc. [email protected] Bright House Networks Information Services [email protected] Easton Telecom Services, L.L.C. [email protected] Wholesale Carrier Services, Inc. [email protected] XO Communications Services, Inc. [email protected] Sigecom, LLC dba WOW! Interent, Cable and P [email protected] Gloria Silas, Verizon [email protected] Compliance Solutions, Inc. [email protected] Crexendo Business Solutions [email protected] Crexendo Bus Solutions. [email protected] Spectrotel, Inc. [email protected] Crystal Automation Systems [email protected] T2 Communications [email protected] TC3 Telecom Inc. [email protected] Advanced Intergrated Technologies, Inc. [email protected] CMC Telecom, Inc. [email protected] IBC Telecom [email protected] Matrix Telecom, Inc. & Trinsic Communicatio [email protected] TDS Telecom, Inc. [email protected] Empire One Telecommunications, Inc. [email protected] Voxbeam Telecommunications [email protected] Barry County Telephone [email protected] Chippewa County Telephone [email protected] Quality Telephone, Inc. [email protected] Buckeye Telesystem, Inc. [email protected] Buckeye Telesystem [email protected] Accutel of Texas, L.P.; Phone Co, L.P. [email protected] tncii.com (No Name Available) [email protected] MCIMetro Access Transmission [email protected] Communications Venture [email protected] WiMacTel, Inc. [email protected] Castle Wire, Inc., f/k/a Business Communica [email protected] Nextlink Wireless, Inc. [email protected] Telnet Worldwide, Inc., Superior Spectrum T [email protected] No Name Available

Page 4 of 4