Artistic Virtuosity and Degeneration Theory in Fin De Siècle Fiction
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, IRVINE Angels and Degenerates: Artistic Virtuosity and Degeneration Theory in Fin de Siècle Fiction DISSERTATION submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in English by Rosanna Nunan Dissertation Committee: Associate Professor Hugh Roberts, Chair Associate Professor Ann Van Sant Associate Professor Laura O’Connor 2015 © 2015 Rosanna Nunan DEDICATION To Susan and Tom Nunan, in thanks for all of the wonderful opportunities they’ve given me. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS iv CURRICULUM VITAE v ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION vi INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER 1: Urban Depravity, Rural Unsophistication: Hereditary Taint in Hardy’s Tess of the D’Urbervilles 25 Degeneration, The City, and Social Purity 31 The Aristocracy and the City versus the Unsophisticated Country 47 Sensibility and the Degenerate: Tess as Artist 57 Conclusion 66 CHAPTER 2: The Innovations of Art and Science in H.G. Wells’s The Wonderful Visit 72 Classificatory Thought through the Lens of Degeneration Theory 75 Modern Art and Proper Scientific Inquiry 93 Conclusion: Modern Music and Morality in a Taxonomical World 108 CHAPTER 3: Rethinking Hysteria through Artistic Genius in Trilby and Human Personality and its Survival of Bodily Death 118 Victorian Reconsiderations of Hysteria and Degenerative Illness 122 Writing the Moral Hysteric 130 The Psychology of Hysteria and Musical Virtuosity 138 Conclusion 153 120Data Interpretation 135 CHAPTER 4: Artistic Suppression and the Woman of Genius: The Feminist Response to Francis Galton 158 Feminists and Degeneration Theory at the Fin de Siècle 160 Sarah Grand’s The Beth Book and the Genius Temperament 170 Destruction of Musical Genius in The Daughters of Danaus 184 Conclusion 205 BIBLIOGRAPHY 213 iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would first like to thank my dissertation chair, Professor Hugh Roberts, for sticking with this project from start to finish, despite a rather circuitous drafting process. His conscientiousness as an advisor and attention to detail are truly remarkable. This dissertation would never have come into being if not for his constant assistance. Many thanks also go to my dissertation committee members. Professor Ann Van Sant’s ongoing support since my first year of graduate school has been instrumental to my success and I will never forget all the help and advice she has given me over the years. Thank you sincerely to Professor Laura O’Connor for her willingness to join this committee somewhat late in the game and for her invaluable guidance and feedback this past year. My two most outstanding friends and colleagues, Anna Finn and Erin Sweeney, helped me in too many ways to number. I would like to thank them for reading chapter drafts, sharing lesson plans, attending conferences together, and showing me the true value of collaboration and mutual encouragement. I am indebted to the University of California, Irvine, for financial support to complete this dissertation, including a Regents’ Fellowship and a School of Humanities Summer Dissertation Fellowship. Thank you especially to my family for all of their help. Without them this project certainly would have been abandoned long ago. Finally, thanks to Andrew Spink. It is hard to believe that we did not meet until my fifth year in Irvine. It is hard to forget how dull life was before then. iv CURRICULUM VITAE Rosanna Nunan 2008 B.A. in English and music, University of Richmond 2009 M.A. in English, University of California, Irvine 2015 Ph.D. in English, University of California, Irvine FIELD OF STUDY Nineteenth Century British Literature v ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Angels and Degenerates: Artistic Virtuosity and Degeneration Theory in Fin de Siècle Fiction By Rosanna Nunan Doctor of Philosophy in English University of California, Irvine, 2015 Professor Hugh Roberts, Chair My aim in “Angels and Degenerates: Artistic Virtuosity and Degeneration Theory in Fin de Siècle Fiction” is to complicate the popular image of the fin de siècle as uniformly pessimistic by examining the continuities between a range of novelists, as well as other late nineteenth century writers from such disparate fields as psychology and cultural criticism, as they critique degeneration theory. Some of these writers, like Thomas Hardy, H.G. Wells, and Sarah Grand, are typically read as promoting a degenerationist agenda, while others, like George Bernard Shaw and Mona Caird, are recognized today for their outspoken opposition to degeneration theory. In uniting these apparently contradictory perspectives, I demonstrate that skepticism of degeneration theory, awareness of its inconsistent logic, and discomfort with its implications is a more important feature of fin de siècle culture than has hitherto been acknowledged. The writers are further united by a common impulse to utilize the figure of the artistic genius to defy degeneration theory. Tess of the D’Urbervilles, The Wonderful Visit, Trilby, The Beth Book, and The Daughters of Danaus incorporate protagonists whom we can identify as either incipient or realized artistic geniuses through the telltale signs of genius that originated in late eighteenth and early nineteenth century Romanticism. Added to the familiar conception of vi Romantic genius in the late Victorian era is a newfound emphasis on the biological and hereditary dimensions of the genius’s innate creative wellspring. By concentrating on the conventionally constructive qualities of the genius figure, including visionary power, aesthetic perceptiveness, intuitive sympathy, and artistic virtuosity, the novelists produce a system of values that both degenerationists and antidegenerationists uphold in their writings. I argue that the novelists expose this shared value system and interrogate its inconsistent usage in scientific contexts, using the genius to reject widespread pathologization and destructive applications of evolutionary theory to the human population at the end of the nineteenth century. vii INTRODUCTION The subject of this dissertation, degeneration and the artist at the fin de siècle, developed out of my initial interest in representations of fallen women in late nineteenth century novels. As my research took shape, the project evolved in the direction of examining representations of degenerate genius rather than fallen women, although the basic contours of my approach to the subject remained the same, as did two of the characters, fallen women Tess and Trilby. The popularization of the theories of degeneration and eugenics, though not explicitly a feminist issue, is so intimately tied to what Angelique Richardson terms the “biologization of morality” and the related pathologization of sexual deviance that there is no way to study the implications of degeneration without taking into account its relationship to women’s rights and other sexual liberation efforts in the late Victorian era (Love and Eugenics 48). In Love and Eugenics, Richardson provides an account of the origins of the social purity movement and rational reproduction, which developed not only out of fears of the growing slum conditions in cities, but also out of a desire to police the activities of London prostitutes. Purity activists associated prostitution and other acts of sexual transgression with the spread of venereal diseases, especially syphilis, that were increasingly figured as physical markers of hereditary moral depravity. Moral depravity, perhaps the most conceptually elastic and physically indeterminate form of degeneration, could be stretched to accommodate all manner of unconventional sexual behavior, or any unconventional behavior, period, when perpetrated by women, homosexual men, or other oppressed groups whose identities were inextricable from their sex or sexuality (the working class population, when hypersexualized as uncontrollably fecund and reproductive, also fits within this category). 1 Considering degeneration’s value as an ideological instrument to police sexual liberation efforts and challenges to conventional morality, it came as no surprise to me that the novels that critique the false science behind degeneration also tend to incorporate characters whose social positions make them particularly vulnerable to the influence of degeneration theory. Thus, the novels I analyze in the forthcoming chapters exhibit commonalities pertaining to the concept of fallenness or questionable virtue, a theme that in turn links the protagonists to theories of hereditary moral depravity at the fin de siècle. Tess of the D’Urbervilles and Trilby explore the plight of the fallen woman in bourgeois society. H.G. Wells’s work of fantasy, The Wonderful Visit, similarly portrays a fallen Angel of questionable sexual identity and his encounter with the bourgeois Philistines. The two novels that are the focus of my last chapter, Mona Caird’s The Daughters of Danaus and Sarah Grand’s The Beth Book, concentrate explicitly on New Women heroines, feminist characters who consciously transgress the parameters laid out for members of their sex in Victorian culture. What was curious to me about fin de siècle representations of fallen virtue or moral depravity was the deliberate equivalence novelists repeatedly make between moral depravity and the Romantic conception of artistic genius. As this pattern emerged, I realized that to reconstitute the fallen heroine or hero it was for some reason expedient to cast them in the familiar role of artistic genius, characterized by the traits of aesthetic sensibility, visionary power, virtuoso