1683

LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY

2015-16-17-18

FIRST SESSION OF THE FIFTY-SIXTH PARLIAMENT

______

VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS

No. 170

WEDNESDAY 2 MAY 2018

______

1 MEETING OF THE HOUSE

The House met at 10.00 am pursuant to adjournment. In the absence of the Speaker at the commencement of the sitting, the Deputy Speaker took the Chair, read the prayer and acknowledged the traditional owners, thanking them for their custodianship of country.

2 NOTICES OF MOTIONS (GENERAL NOTICES)

3 TRANSPORT ADMINISTRATION AMENDMENT (SYDNEY METRO) BILL

The order of the day was read for the resumption of the adjourned debate, on the motion of Mr , That this bill be now read a second time.

Question again proposed and debate resumed.

Mr obtained an extension of time.

Debate continued.

Question put.

The House divided.

AYES 50

Mr Anderson, Mr Aplin, Mr Ayres, Mr Brookes, Mr Conolly, Mr Constance, Ms Cooke, Mr Coure, Mr 1684 VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW SOUTH WALES LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 2 May 2018

Crouch, Mrs Davies, Mr Dominello, Mr Donato, Mr Elliott, Mr A.W. Evans, Mr Fraser, Mr George, Ms Gibbons, Ms Goward, Mr Griffin, Mr Gulaptis, Mr Hazzard, Mr Henskens, Mr Humphries, Mr Johnsen, Mr Kean, Dr Lee, Mr Maguire, Mr Marshall, Mr Notley-Smith, Mr O’Dea, Mrs Pavey, Mr Perrottet, Ms Petinos, Mr Piper, Mr Provest, Mr Roberts, Mr Rowell, Mr Sidoti, Mr Speakman, Mr Stokes, Mr Taylor, Mr Toole, Mr Tudehope, Ms Upton, Mr Ward, Mr Williams, Mrs Williams and Ms Wilson.

Tellers: Mr Bromhead and Mr Patterson.

NOES 32

Ms Aitchison, Mr Atalla, Mr Bali, Mr Barr, Ms Car, Ms Catley, Mr Crakanthorp, Mr Daley, Mr Dib, Ms Doyle, Ms Finn, Mr Foley, Mr Greenwich, Mr Harris, Ms Harrison, Ms Hornery, Mr Kamper, Ms Leong, Mr Lynch, Dr McDermott, Ms McKay, Mr Mehan, Mr Minns, Mr Park, Mr Parker, Ms T.F. Smith, Ms Tesch, Mr Warren, Ms Washington and Mr Zangari.

Tellers: Mr Scully and Ms Watson. In the Chair: Mr L.J. Evans.

Pairs: Mr Barilaro—Mr Chanthivong; Ms Berejiklian—Ms Cotsis; Mr Grant—Ms Haylen and Mrs Hancock—Mr Lalich.

Question passed.

Bill read a second time.

Mr Andrew Constance moved, That this bill be now read a third time.

Question put and passed.

Bill read a third time. ______

It being after 1.15 pm, community recognition statements proceeded with. ______

4 COMMUNITY RECOGNITION STATEMENTS ______

The Temporary Speaker (Mr ) left the Chair at 1.51 pm.

The Deputy Speaker resumed the Chair at 2.15 pm. ______

5 DEPUTY SPEAKER’S STATEMENT—MILLICENT PRESTON STANLEY

The Deputy Speaker made a statement in relation to the display in the Legislative Assembly vestibule, until July 2018, of the 1950 portrait of Millicent Preston Stanley by Mary Edwards hanging next to the Parliament’s own 1953 portrait. The Deputy Speaker also informed the House of the addition to the Parliament’s collection of Volume Two of Millicent Preston Stanley’s My Daily Message.

6 NOTICES OF MOTIONS

7 NOTICES OF MOTIONS SOUGHT TO BE ACCORDED PRIORITY

Mr —Medich Donations. Mr —State Taxation.

1685 VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW SOUTH WALES LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 2 May 2018

8 QUESTION TIME ______

(1) Following a request from Mr Mark Taylor pursuant to standing order 131 (3), the Premier provided additional information.

(2) Following a request from Mr pursuant to standing order 131 (3), the Deputy Premier, Minister for Regional New South Wales, Minister for Skills, and Minister for Small Business provided additional information.

(3) Following a request from Ms pursuant to standing order 131 (3), the Minister for Education provided additional information.

(4) Following a request from Mr Lee Evans pursuant to standing order 131 (3), the Minister for Planning, Minister for Housing, and Special Minister of State provided additional information.

(5) Following a request from Mr pursuant to standing order 131 (3), the Minister for Health, and Minister for Medical Research provided additional information.

(6) Following a request from Mr John Sidoti pursuant to standing order 131 (3), the Minister for Transport and Infrastructure provided additional information. ______

Disorder: At 2.55 pm, the Deputy Speaker directed Ms Jodi McKay to leave the Chamber for two hours.

Disorder: At 2.56 pm, the Deputy Speaker directed Ms to leave the Chamber for two hours. ______

9 PAPER

Mr tabled the report of the Border Fence Maintenance Board for 2017.

10 PETITIONS

The Clerk announced that the following members had each lodged petitions for presentation:

Mr —from certain citizens opposing the sale of animals in pet shops.

Mr Alex Greenwich—from certain citizens requesting the Government ban the permanent conversion of homes into short-term holiday lets and introduce a registration system so appropriate controls can be enforced.

Ms —from certain citizens requesting the Legislative Assembly ensure the development of West Byron will not detract the importance of Byron Bay as a tourist attraction and adversely affect Ewingsdale Road, the koala population, wetlands and Cape Byron Marine Park.

Mr Alex Greenwich—from certain citizens requesting the Government upgrade rather than rebuild the Sydney Football Stadium and direct the savings into health, education and community sports facilities.

Mr Alex Greenwich—from certain citizens requesting the Government implement an independent environmental impact assessment of the Glebe Island multi-use facility and enforce conditions on maritime and freight operations to protect the amenity of adjacent residential areas.

11 RE-ORDERING OF GENERAL BUSINESS

Ms moved, That the general business notice of motion (general notice) given by her 1686 VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW SOUTH WALES LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 2 May 2018

this day (St Florian’s Day – International Firefighters Day) have precedence on Thursday 3 May 2018.

Debate ensued.

Question put.

The House divided.

AYES 45

Mr Anderson, Mr Aplin, Mr Ayres, Mr Brookes, Mr Conolly, Ms Cooke, Mr Coure, Mr Crouch, Mrs Davies, Mr Dominello, Mr Elliott, Mr A.W. Evans, Mr L.J. Evans, Mr Fraser, Ms Gibbons, Ms Goward, Mr Grant, Mr Griffin, Mr Gulaptis, Mr Hazzard, Mr Henskens, Mr Humphries, Mr Johnsen, Mr Kean, Dr Lee, Mr Maguire, Mr Marshall, Mr Notley-Smith, Mr O’Dea, Mrs Pavey, Ms Petinos, Mr Provest, Mr Rowell, Mr Sidoti, Mr Speakman, Mr Taylor, Mr Toole, Mr Tudehope, Ms Upton, Mr Ward, Mr Williams, Mrs Williams and Ms Wilson.

Tellers: Mr Bromhead and Mr Patterson.

NOES 31

Ms Aitchison, Mr Atalla, Mr Bali, Mr Barr, Ms Car, Ms Catley, Mr Crakanthorp, Mr Daley, Mr Dib, Mr Donato, Ms Doyle, Ms Finn, Mr Greenwich, Mr Harris, Ms Harrison, Ms Hornery, Mr Kamper, Ms Leong, Mr Lynch, Dr McDermott, Mr Mehan, Mr Minns, Mr Park, Mr Parker, Mr Piper, Ms T.F. Smith, Ms Tesch, Mr Warren and Mr Zangari.

Tellers: Mr Scully and Ms Watson. In the Chair: Mr George.

Pairs: Mr Barilaro—Mr Chanthivong; Ms Berejiklian—Ms Cotsis; Mr Constance—Mr Foley; Mrs Hancock—Ms Haylen; Mr Perrottet—Mr Hoenig; Mr Roberts—Mr Lalich and Mr Stokes—Ms Mihailuk.

Question passed.

12 NOTICES OF MOTIONS SOUGHT TO BE ACCORDED PRIORITY

(1) Mr John Sidoti made a statement in support of his notice being accorded priority over the other business of the House.

(2) Mr Ryan Park also made a statement in support of his notice being accorded priority—

That this House:

(1) Notes that the Government has made New South Wales the highest taxing state in the history of the Australian Federation.

(2) Expresses concern that New South Wales residents now pay on average $4,570 of taxes per year which is $1,246 more than what they paid in 2011-12 and $321 more than what Victorian residents pay.

(3) Condemns the Government for wasting this increased taxation on a $2.2 billion stadiums splurge, cost blowouts for the CBD light rail and WestConnex, and advertising campaigns for failed policies such as the Fire and Emergency Services Levy, greyhound racing ban and forced council amalgamations.

Question—That the motion of the member for Drummoyne be accorded priority—put.

The House divided. 1687 VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW SOUTH WALES LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 2 May 2018

AYES 45

Mr Anderson, Mr Aplin, Mr Ayres, Mr Brookes, Mr Conolly, Ms Cooke, Mr Coure, Mr Crouch, Mrs Davies, Mr Dominello, Mr Elliott, Mr A.W. Evans, Mr L.J. Evans, Mr George, Ms Gibbons, Ms Goward, Mr Grant, Mr Griffin, Mr Gulaptis, Mr Hazzard, Mr Henskens, Mr Humphries, Mr Johnsen, Mr Kean, Dr Lee, Mr Maguire, Mr Marshall, Mr Notley-Smith, Mr O’Dea, Mrs Pavey, Ms Petinos, Mr Provest, Mr Rowell, Mr Sidoti, Mr Speakman, Mr Taylor, Mr Toole, Mr Tudehope, Ms Upton, Mr Ward, Mr Williams, Mrs Williams and Ms Wilson.

Tellers: Mr Bromhead and Mr Patterson.

NOES 31

Ms Aitchison, Mr Atalla, Mr Bali, Mr Barr, Ms Car, Ms Catley, Mr Crakanthorp, Mr Daley, Mr Dib, Mr Donato, Ms Doyle, Ms Finn, Mr Greenwich, Mr Harris, Ms Harrison, Ms Hornery, Mr Kamper, Ms Leong, Mr Lynch, Dr McDermott, Mr Mehan, Mr Minns, Mr Park, Mr Parker, Mr Piper, Ms T.F. Smith, Ms Tesch, Mr Warren and Mr Zangari.

Tellers: Mr Scully and Ms Watson. In the Chair: Mr Fraser.

Pairs: Mr Barilaro—Mr Chanthivong; Ms Berejiklian—Ms Cotsis; Mr Constance—Mr Foley; Mrs Hancock—Ms Haylen; Mr Perrottet—Mr Hoenig; Mr Roberts—Mr Lalich and Mr Stokes—Ms Mihailuk.

Question passed.

13 MOTION ACCORDED PRIORITY—MEDICH DONATIONS

Mr John Sidoti moved, pursuant to notice, That this House calls on Labor to immediately refund all of convicted murderer Ron Medich’s donations to a victims of crime charity.

Upon which Mr Paul Scully moved, That the motion be amended by adding “and calls on the Liberals to withdraw its appeal against the decision ordering it to repay almost $250,000 in illegal donations and provide repayment confirmation by midday Thursday”.

Question proposed—That the amendment be agreed to.

Debate continued.

Question put.

The House divided.

AYES 31

Ms Aitchison, Mr Atalla, Mr Bali, Mr Barr, Ms Car, Ms Catley, Mr Crakanthorp, Mr Daley, Mr Dib, Ms Doyle, Ms Finn, Mr Foley, Mr Greenwich, Mr Harris, Ms Harrison, Ms Hornery, Mr Kamper, Ms Leong, Mr Lynch, Dr McDermott, Mr Mehan, Mr Minns, Mr Park, Mr Parker, Mr Piper, Ms T.F. Smith, Ms Tesch, Mr Warren and Mr Zangari.

Tellers: Mr Scully and Ms Watson.

NOES 42

Mr Anderson, Mr Aplin, Mr Ayres, Mr Brookes, Mr Conolly, Ms Cooke, Mr Coure, Mr Crouch, Mrs Davies, Mr Elliott, Mr A.W. Evans, Mr L.J. Evans, Mr George, Ms Gibbons, Ms Goward, Mr Griffin, Mr Gulaptis, Mr Henskens, Mr Humphries, Mr Johnsen, Mr Kean, Dr Lee, Mr Maguire, Mr Marshall, Mr 1688 VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW SOUTH WALES LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 2 May 2018

Notley-Smith, Mr O’Dea, Mrs Pavey, Ms Petinos, Mr Provest, Mr Rowell, Mr Sidoti, Mr Speakman, Mr Taylor, Mr Toole, Mr Tudehope, Ms Upton, Mr Ward, Mr Williams, Mrs Williams and Ms Wilson.

Tellers: Mr Bromhead and Mr Patterson. In the Chair: Mr Fraser.

Pairs: Mr Chanthivong—Mr Barilaro; Ms Cotsis—Ms Berejiklian; Ms Haylen—Mr Constance; Mr Hoenig—Mr Dominello; Mr Lalich—Mrs Hancock and Ms Mihailuk—Mr Hazzard.

Question negatived.

Question—That the original motion be agreed to—put.

The House divided.

AYES 47

Mr Anderson, Mr Aplin, Mr Ayres, Mr Brookes, Mr Conolly, Ms Cooke, Mr Coure, Mr Crouch, Mrs Davies, Mr Elliott, Mr A.W. Evans, Mr L.J. Evans, Mr George, Ms Gibbons, Ms Goward, Mr Greenwich, Mr Griffin, Mr Gulaptis, Mr Henskens, Mr Humphries, Mr Johnsen, Mr Kean, Dr Lee, Ms Leong, Mr Maguire, Mr Marshall, Mr Notley-Smith, Mr O’Dea, Mr Parker, Mrs Pavey, Ms Petinos, Mr Piper, Mr Provest, Mr Rowell, Mr Sidoti, Ms T.F. Smith, Mr Speakman, Mr Taylor, Mr Toole, Mr Tudehope, Ms Upton, Mr Ward, Mr Williams, Mrs Williams and Ms Wilson.

Tellers: Mr Bromhead and Mr Patterson.

NOES 26

Ms Aitchison, Mr Atalla, Mr Bali, Mr Barr, Ms Car, Ms Catley, Mr Crakanthorp, Mr Daley, Mr Dib, Ms Doyle, Ms Finn, Mr Foley, Mr Harris, Ms Harrison, Ms Hornery, Mr Kamper, Mr Lynch, Dr McDermott, Mr Mehan, Mr Minns, Mr Park, Ms Tesch, Mr Warren and Mr Zangari.

Tellers: Mr Scully and Ms Watson. In the Chair: Mr Fraser.

Pairs: Ms Berejiklian—Mr Chanthivong; Mr Grant—Ms Cotsis; Mr Hazzard—Ms Haylen; Mr Perrottet—Mr Hoenig; Mr Roberts—Mr Lalich and Mr Stokes—Ms Mihailuk.

Question passed.

14 FARM DEBT MEDIATION AMENDMENT BILL

The order of the day was read.

Mr Paul Toole moved, That this bill be now read a second time.

Debate ensued.

Dr moved, That this debate be now adjourned.

Question put and passed.

Ordered, That the resumption of the debate stand an order of the day for tomorrow.

15 MATTER OF PUBLIC IMPORTANCE—NATIONAL ROAD SAFETY WEEK

The Deputy Speaker previously informed the House of receipt from Mr Greg Aplin of a notice of a matter of public importance, namely:

1689 VOTES AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW SOUTH WALES LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 2 May 2018

National Road Safety Week.

Discussion ensued and concluded.

16 MESSAGE FROM THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

The Temporary Speaker (Mr ) reported a message from the Legislative Council dated 2 May 2018, returning the Road Transport Legislation Amendment (Road Safety) Bill, without amendment.

17 PRIVATE MEMBERS’ STATEMENTS

18 ADJOURNMENT

The House adjourned, pursuant to standing and sessional orders, at 7.11 pm, until tomorrow, at 10.00 am.

Attendance: All members present except Mr Anoulack Chanthivong, Ms , Mrs , Ms , Mr and Mr .

HELEN MINNICAN SHELLEY HANCOCK Clerk of the Legislative Assembly Speaker ______

Authorised by the Parliament of New South Wales